Movement of Spiritual Inner Awareness (MSIA)

MOVEMENT OF SPIRITUAL INNER AWARENESS TIMELINE

1934 (September 24):  Roger Delano Hinkins was born in Rains, Utah.t

1940s-1950s:  Hinkins attended high school in Huntington, Utah.

1951:  John Morton was born in Las Vegas, Nevada.

1952:  Hinkins attended Carbon College for two years in Price, Utah.

1957:  Roger Hinkins underwent surgery to remove tissue growing out of his nose and eyes. During the surgery, he received the first part of the Mystical Traveler Consciousness.

1958:  In an operation on the same condition, Hinkins received the second part of the Mystical Traveler Consciousness.

1958:  Hinkins earned a bachelor’s degree at the University of Utah. He did not attend the Mormon Church after receiving his degree

Late 1950s-1960s: Hinkins explored many religious traditions, parapsychological mysticism, and esoteric philosophies.

1960:  John Morton moved to Sacramento with his family. Hinkins moved to Los Angeles and taught high school in Rosemead.

1963:  Following a car accident Hinkins underwent kidney surgery. While in a coma, he received the “John Consciousness” and the third part of the Mystical Traveler Consciousness.

1963:  After getting a reading from two channelers, he changed his name to John-Roger (J-R).

1967:  John-Roger and Pauli McGarry went to Disneyland, where he revealed his spiritual side and visions of spreading the Mystical Traveler Consciousness.

1968:  John-Roger started giving seminars that subsequently became the Movement of Spiritual Inner Awareness (MSIA).

1969 (January):  MSIA held its first yearly conference, the Conference of Understanding. John-Roger began packaging and selling his teachings.

1971:  The group legally incorporated as a church. The idea for the MSIA ministry took shape as the first ministers were ordained.

1971:  Eckankar sent letters to John-Roger asking that he not mention Paul Twitchell or Eckankar in his talks.

1972:  John Morton earned a Bachelor of Science degree in Renewable Natural Resources from the University of California at Davis.

1973 (June 16):  The first national minister’s meeting was held with 143 ministers.

1973 (September):  A group of MSIA members and John-Roger, with his staff, visited Sathya Sai Baba in India.

1974:  MSIA purchased the former Guasti Villa for ashram, office, and seminar space. MSIA renamed it Prana (Purple Rose Ashram of the New Age).

1976:  John-Roger founded Koh-E-Nor (Mountain of Light) University as a separate educational organization.

1977:  Peace Theological Seminary and the College of Philosophy (PTS) were established and headquartered at Prana.

1978:  John-Roger and Russell Bishop founded Insight Training Seminars as a separate organization from MSIA.

1978:  John Morton earned a Master of Science degree in counseling from California State University at Sacramento and was ordained (November 18).

1979:  Koh-E-Nor began operations and three years later began graduating students.

1982:  The Institute for Individual and World Peace (IIWP) was created.

1983:  Former staff members, Wendell and Wesley Whitmore, accused J-R of being a fraud and reported receiving threats, vandalism, and hate mail.

1984:  Peace Theological Seminary (PTS) organized the PAT IV (Peace Awareness Training), which led to yearly PAT trips led by John-Roger.

1985:  At the Conference of Giving, John Morton received the keys to ordaining ministers.

1986:  MSIA purchased Windermere Ranch in the Santa Inez foothills to be used for peace studies and as a gathering place.

1987-1988:  Victor Toso, a former staff member (along with several other members), alleged financial and sexual misconduct by John- Roger. This led to allegations that MSIA was a cult.

1988:  Koh-E-Nor University changed its name to University of Santa Monica (USM) under the direction of Mary and Ron Hulnick and functioned as a separate organization.

1988 (June 19):  John-Roger passed the keys of the Mystical Traveler Consciousness to John Morton.

1989:  John-Roger and his staff traveled to Russia and Germany where John-Roger put a “Light Worm” in the Berlin Wall.

1990 (July):  John Morton married Laura Donnelley in July. The couple had two children but divorced in 2006.

1994-1996:  The Peter McWilliams controversy flared up over the authorship of books he had cowritten with John-Roger.

1995:  John-Roger and the Pat IV group of over 300 people traveled to Greece, Turkey, and Asia Minor.

1997:  MSIA grew to 2,577 ministers worldwide, including 738 in California and 459 in Mexico and Latin America.

2000:  MSIA installed the Labyrinth at Prana.

2001:  After September 11, 2011, MSIA prayed for all those involved. John-Roger, John Morton, Jsu Garcia, and others visited New York in December, where they placed “Light Columns” at the fallen towers.

2006 (May 16):  The movie, Spiritual Warriors, based on John-Roger’s 1998 book by the same title, premiered at the NuWilshire Theater in Los Angeles. Other films followed: The Wayshower (2011) and the MSIA documentary Mystical Traveler (2014).

2013 (January 1):  John Morton and Leigh Taylor-Young were married at Prana.

2014 (October 22):  John-Roger died, and John Morton succeeded him as MSIA leader.

2020:  MSIA launched That Which Is (thatwhichis.org) that streamed all John-Roger and John Morton talks and meditations.

2020:  MSIA  began the “succession presidency” policy by mentoring three people to later assume the duties of president, vice President, and treasurer/secretary.

2021:  After selling its retreat properties in Lake Arrowhead the previous summer, MSIA sold its property in Santa Monica as a result of the COVID epidemic and declining usage,

2025:  John Morton and Leigh Taylor Young Morton led a PTS trip to Assisi, Italy.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Erma Hinkins bore her son, Roger Delano Hinkins, on September 24, 1934, in Rains, Utah, a Mormon community (John-Roger 1981; Introvigne 1998). In that company town his father, Parley, worked as a mine foreman. Roger suffered from bouts of asthma as a child. At a young age Roger saw auras (Lewis 1998). He remained connected to his family, while also looking for new worldviews and ways of life.

In 1957, he underwent surgery to remove tissue growing out of his nose and eyes. During surgery, he received the first part of the Mystical Traveler Consciousness, a high consciousness that ministers through transcendental energy. During surgery on the same condition one year later, Hinkins obtained the second part of the Mystical Traveler Consciousness (John-Roger 1981). He underwent more psychic experiences, including out-of-the-body travel.

Hinkins earned a BA degree in psychology at the University of Utah in 1958. By 1960, he moved to Los Angeles where he taught English at Rosemead High School. In 1963, he was in a car accident and subsequently underwent a kidney operation. While in a coma, he received the John Consciousness and the third part of the Mystical Traveler Consciousness, reportedly John the Beloved of Jesus Christ (John-Roger 1981). After he had a reading with channelers, Wayne A. Guthrie and Bella Karish, he changed his name to John-Roger (J-R) (Introvigne 1998; Anonymous 1999). He reported that it took him two years to integrate his new consciousness into his physical body (Anonymous 1999).

During the mid-1960s, John-Roger crisscrossed the country in his Mustang, attending metaphysical and parapsychological conferences and giving lectures. He sampled many religious traditions and philosophies from which he borrowed concepts. During that time, he reported that he cleared energies in different locations, while also releasing karmic patterns (Sanderson 1988).

John-Roger sought out in some cases and also serendipitously encountered a variety of different spiritual teachings and practitioners. He called this period of his life the “metafizzle” years, when he roamed like a metaphysical tramp studying all types of spiritualities (Tumminia and Lewis 2013). He talked about the Emissaries of Light, Noel Street, Elizabeth Claire Prophet, Arthur Ford, and Roy Eugene Davis.

During this period he earned a degree in Personology. He took correspondence courses with the Ancient and Mystical Order Rosae Crucis (AMOC), the Rosicrucians. John-Roger progressed to high levels in the coursework, but he found the rituals ineffective (Introvigne 1998). Twice he attended the Temple of Agasha, a spiritualist church (Lurie and MSIA 1999), and he had contact with the Fellowship of Universal Guidance in Glendale, which emphasized the importance of the three selves. John-Roger became acquainted with the New-Age ideologue David Spangler, and he later visited Findhorn in 1971. One MSIA member stated he met J-R at a flying-saucer conference (Tumminia and Lewis 2013).

During his forays in the late 1960s, John-Roger heard about Neva Dell Hunter who was a teacher, psychic, and co-originator of a type of aura balancing. He stopped by on a trip to see her, and she gave him a past-life reading. He also received an aura balance at the Quimby Center in Alamogordo, New Mexico, from Ellavivian Power (Tumminia and Lewis 2013). Power emphasized self-forgiveness in her balancings. He adopted her technique. Power later became a MSIA minister as did numerous students of Hunter.

On a trip to Disneyland in 1967, John-Roger revealed to fellow teacher, Pauli McGarry, (Sanderson 1988) his spiritual consciousness. [Image at right] His vision was to share his knowledge (Tumminia and Lewis 2013). McGarry (now Sanderson) became a key contributor to this process.

John-Roger started giving nascent MSIA seminars on May 4, 1968, at Muriel Engle’s home in Santa Barbara (Engle 1972). According to MSIA, these extemporaneous talks were guided by the Mystical Traveler Consciousness.
From his home in Baldwin Park, John-Roger gave Light Studies (individual spiritual readings) to those who signed up. [Image at right] He quickly drew followers, including high-school students such as Candice Shanklin (Semigram) and Phil Anthony. 1971 was a pivotal year as MSIA incorporated as a church and John-Roger ordained the first ministers.

MSIA held its first national minister’s meeting on June 16, 1973, with 143
ministers. Prompted by Muriel Engle, John-Roger, his staff, and a MSIA group visited Sathya Sai Baba in India in September. By 1974, MSIA had purchased the former Guasti Villa for ashram, office, and seminar space. MSIA renamed it Prana (Purple Rose Ashram of the New Age). [Image at right] It was later renamed Peace Awareness Labyrinth and Gardens, but most people call it Prana.

After two years, John-Roger established the Peace Theological Seminary &
College of Philosophy (PTS) at Prana, which offered classes, workshops, and retreats. PTS then began awarding a Master’s and Doctorate of Spiritual Science. At the same time, J-R started Koh-E-Nor University [Image at right] Mary Hulnick had a dream that she and her husband, Ron Hulnick, would breathe life into Koh-E-Nor. They asked for a meeting with John-Roger to offer their services. Ron and Mary Hulnick were put in charge. Later in 1988, it became the University of Santa Monica (USM), with programs in spiritual psychology and counseling. In February 2024, Ron and Mary Hulnick retired as co-directors of USM, and administrative authority transferred to a Board of Directors.

At the end of the 1970s and early 1980s, ancillary organizations emerged. A separate, more secular organization, Insight Training Seminars, coalesced through the work of John-Roger and Russell Bishop in 1978. Insight taught self-help and heart-centered consciousness. “Insight I: The Awakening Heart” arose out of the adoption and modification of the then-popular large group awareness trainings. Having been a trainer for Lifespring, Russell Bishop proposed to John-Roger that a Lifespring-like session be held specifically for MSIA people.  [Image at right] The first training was given at the Miramar Hotel in Santa Monica on January 4-8, 1978, with about 150 people attending. It instantly caught on. Insight was said to help people resolve many personal issues by instructing them to change their attitudes and so change their lives. Throughout the eighties, people flocked to the trainings.

It was after an Insight Training that John Morton talked to John-Roger saying he wanted to work with Insight. Subsequently he was put on staff. On November 18, 1978, John Morton received his ordination.

Adjunct organizations developed. For example, in 1979 the volunteer non-profit Heartfelt Foundation, under Patti Rayner, took form to serve and to assist people in hardship, such as the homeless, needy families, and disaster survivors. In 1994, a Los Angeles-area minister dying of AIDS appealed for assistance at a meeting. This event inspired the founding of HeartReach within the preexisting Heartfelt Foundation; it focuses on the needs of the elderly, the sick, and the dying in MSIA.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

MSIA consists of pre-existing theologies and philosophies interwoven and revamped. God is formless and genderless. It can be reached by chanting the Holy Names in the Indian Sound Current tradition, Sant Mat (Lane 2025). The symbol for God and the church is the Sanskrit letter HU. The Movement combines Christian notions with Sant Mat practices in addition to its emphasis on the “practical spirituality” of self-help psychology. Other elements have been
derived from New Thought and New Age themes (DeChant 1999). Jesus Christ is referred to as the head of the church. The teachings remind members that they are “the Light,” encouraging them to use the Light in their daily process of living. Members consider themselves Light Bearers. [Image at right] MSIA imparts Soul Transcendence, transcending the lower worlds to be united with Soul and Pure Spirit.

The movement adheres to the importance of a living Traveler, who is embodied with the Mystical Traveler Consciousness. The first Mystical Traveler for MSIA
was John-Roger, and now John Morton holds that position. John-Roger also possessed the Preceptor Consciousness, a special dispensation. [Image at right] These Consciousnesses legitimize all teachings and practices. The Traveler shepherds the adherent through the Realms of Light and back to God. Between the physical and the soul realm are realms through which a votary must travel. They are as follows: Soul (the True Self), Etheric (the unconscious), Mental (the mind), Causal (emotions), Astral (the imagination), and Physical (everyday life). These realms are accessed through the guidance of the Mystical Traveler through spiritual exercises.

The three selves are also taught as an important part of human perception. They are the basic self (lower self), conscious self (conscious decision making), and high self (higher consciousness). The three-selves framework allows anyone to sort out experiences from impulse to inspiration.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

The movement provides books that are a mix of spirituality, self-improvement, and psychological exploration. Many MSIAers write and repeat affirmations about having positive self-images or about creating wealth and success. The journaling of personal experiences serves as a popular preoccupation in the movement, indicating the emphasis placed upon internal dialogue and self-examination (John-Roger 1998). Another spiritual motivation for self-help comes from movement teachings about self and karma. The movement warns against judgments of self and others. Members learn they do not have karma with other people but rather have karma with themselves. The teachings call for self-forgiveness and forgiveness of others. The movement values acceptance. Humor and laughter are also prized as they are considered the presence of the Holy Spirit. All members are encouraged to tithe.

The most used practice is “Calling in the Light,” along with placing people and situations in the Light. This practice precedes seminars, meetings, or gatherings. Followers call in the Light before doing spiritual exercises, the silent devotional chanting of sacred words. People can also call in the Christ Consciousness. The movement’s membership requirement is that a person must sign up for discourses and/or listen to recordings that are referred to as SATs. This is expected for initiation to the Sound Current. MSIA offers the private services of aura balances, innerphasings (programming the subconscious), and polarity balances (equalizing body energy).

The movement’s ministry program consists of doing self-chosen service along with submitting a yearly renewal (Tumminia and Lewis 2013). Minister’s meetings occur once a month in person or online. When a person is ordained, he/she receives a singular blessing from Spirit. Ministerial services encompass baby blessings, baptisms, prayer communion, and officiating at weddings or funerals. Ministers are a resource for volunteerism that assists the running of the church. In 2026, MSIA had 2,453 ministers who come from the United States and around the world.

LEADERSHIP/ORGANIZATION

The movement began as a small organization. MSIA’s first office operated out of John-Roger’s home. Discourses were mimeographed. As followers joined, they took on volunteer tasks and some staff positions. The movement grew due to J-R’s charisma, his wit, and his hugs. As an author, speaker, and innovator, he created fun and excitement for his votaries. John-Roger could fill ballrooms with listeners. Supporters valued him for his message of Light and Love and for his humor (Peterson 2022). Eventually bureaucracy developed within the church and its ancillary organizations. Leadership revolved around the presidency. John Morton became MSIA President on February 4, 1988. [Image at right] The position was previously held by John-Roger.

When Morton stepped aside to attend to other duties, Paul Kaye became MSIA President on November 21, 1989. Vincent Dupont came on board as Vice
President and Mark Lurie as Secretary/Treasurer. Around 2020, the “succession presidency” was inaugurated. [Image at right]  Presently the succession presidency consists of the three MSIA students who are being mentored to be future leaders. They do not have legal standing, but they are being coached for the roles of corporate officers and board members.

The Movement is presently led by John Morton as the Mystical Traveler. His wife, Leigh Taylor Young Morton, works with him on workshops and public appearances. [Image at right] They host a daily online show, Blessing This Day with John and Leigh, and also travel extensively carrying the movement’s message.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Several controversies erupted during John-Roger’s leadership. Lane (2025) has argued that Eckankar’s founder plagiarized Radhasoami texts, and that John-Roger copied Eckankar, creating a chain of questionable authenticity. Some groups and former members have accused MSIA of manipulative practices and misappropriation of funds (Lane 1984). Based on these allegations, the anti-cult movement and some media sources have labeled MSIA a “cult” (Lewis 1994).

While these old controversies have largely subsided, the movement has faced new challenges. The passing of first generation members has had an attenuating effect on membership numbers. In 2026, MSIA had about 3,200 discourse subscribers (defined by having an initial subscription to Soul Awareness Discourses or SAT Series Seminars for those who have completed twelve years of discourses). In response, the church has downsized and developed a greater online presence. In addition to smaller membership, the church has faced the problem that new members are members of a new generation who did not know John-Roger personally and therefore relate differently to the church and its teachings. While the teachings remain the same, new forms of delivering that message are being explored to connect with contemporary audiences. MSIA’s leadership is working to make the teachings relatable and relevant to today’s world. The movement as responded by changing message delivery but not the teachings themselves.

IMAGES

Image #1: John-Roger and Pauli McGarry, 1970. Permission granted by Kay and Lee Clausen.
Image #2: Early ad for MSIA. Permission of MSIA.
Image #3: Prana. Permission of MSIA.
Image #4: Ron Hulnick, Mary Hulnick, and John-Roger. Permission of MSIA.
Image #5: Russell Bishop and John-Roger started Insight. Permission of MSIA.
Image #6: HU symbol. Permission of MSIA.
Image #7: The Realms of Light. Permission of MSIA.
Image #8: John Morton and John-Roger in the early 1990s. Permission of MSIA.
Image #9: MSIA Presidency (back row) Mark Lurie, Paul Kaye, Vincent Dupont, and the MSIA Succession Presidency (front row) Jeffrey Morgan, Sherie Wylie Markova, and David Jaramillo. Permission of MSIA.
Image #10: John Morton and Leigh Taylor Young Morton. Permission of MSIA.

REFERENCES

Anonymous. 1999. Interviews with John-Morton and John-Roger: Religious Scholars Interview the Travelers. Los Angeles: Mandeville Press.

DeChant, Dell. 1999. “New Thought and the Movement of Spiritual Inner Awareness.” Paper presented at the Meetings of CESNUR: Center for Studies on New Religions in Bryn Athyn, Pennsylvania. June 2-4, 1999.

Engle, Muriel. 1972. “Five Years of Growth in MSIA: Muriel Engle Traces Roots of the Movement from Santa Barbara to the World.” The Movement 1:10-11, 14.

Hulnick, H. Ronald, and Mary R. Hulnick. 2010. Loyalty to your Soul: The Heart of Spiritual Psychology. Carlsbad, CA: Hay House.

Introvigne, Massimo. 1998. “The Origins of the Movement of Spiritual Inner Awareness (MSIA).” CESNUR: Center for Studies on New Religions. Accessed from http://www.cesnur.org/testi/msia.htm on 25 January 2026.

John-Roger. 1998. Spiritual Warrior: The Art of Spiritual Living. Los Angeles: Mandeville Press.

John-Roger. 1981. The Signs of the Times. (Volume 1). New York: Baraka.

John-Roger and Pauli Sanderson. 2004. When Are You Coming Home?: A Personal Guide to Soul Transcendence. Los Angeles: Mandeville Press.

Lane, David C. 1994. Exposing Cults: When the Skeptical Mind Confronts the Mystical. New York: Garland Publishing.

Lane, David C. 1984. “A Critical Analysis of John-Roger and M.S.I.A.” Understanding Cults and Spiritual Movements, Volume 1.

Lane, David C. 2025. The Sound Current Tradition: A Historical Overview. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Lewis, James R. 1999. Life 102. Web page (revised). Accessed from http://www.life102.com/ on 1 January 2026.

Lewis, James R. 1998. Seeking the Light: Uncovering the Truth about the Movement of Spiritual Inner Awareness and Its Founder John-Roger. Los Angeles: Mandeville Press.

Lewis, James R. 1994. “The Cult Stereotype as an Ideological Resource in Social Conflicts: A Case Study of the Movement of Spiritual Inner Awareness.” Syzygy 3:23-37.

Lurie, Mark, and MSIA. 1999. E-mail correspondence on behalf of John-Roger addressed to J. Gordon Melton, James R. Lewis, and Massimo Introvigne. John-Roger Library Archives at Prana in Los Angeles.

McWilliams, Peter. 1994. Life 102: What To Do When Your Guru Sues You. Los Angeles: Prelude Press.

Peterson, Jackie. 2022. “Soul Transcendants: Stories on the Path to GOD.” Los Angeles: Living Light Press.

Reed, Jack. 1972. “In the Beginning with Jack Reed” The Movement 1:1, 6.

Sanderson, Pauli McGarry. 1988. John-Roger: In Tribute to Twenty-Five Years as Traveler. Los Angeles: Movement of Spiritual Inner Awareness.

Tumminia, Diana G. 2004. “Heart and Soul: A Qualitative Look at the Ethos of the Movement of Spiritual Inner Awareness.” Pp. 331-49 in Controversial Religions, edited by James R. Lewis. New York: Oxford University Press.

Tumminia, Diana G. and James R. Lewis. 2013. The Study of the Movement of Spiritual Inner Awareness: Religious Innovation and Cultural Change. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

Publication Date:
29 January 2026

Share

Moritz Maurer

Dr Moritz Maurer is an FWF Fellow (2025–2028) at the Department of Religious Studies at the University of Vienna. He studied Religious Studies and Philosophy at the University of Heidelberg (B.A. 2012; M.A. 2015) and Iranian Studies at the School of Oriental and African Studies in London (M.A. 2015). In 2022, he completed his doctorate at the Institute for Religious Studies at Heidelberg University with the support of the German Academic Scholarship Foundation. In 2024, his doctoral thesis was published as Kosmos, Gesellschaft, Religion [Cosmos, Society and Religion] by de Gruyter in the series Religionsgeschichtliche Versuche und Vorarbeiten. From 2022 to 2023, he was a research assistant at the Institute for Religious Studies at Heidelberg University, and in the summer semester of 2025 at the University of Göttingen. He has taught classes at the Universities of Heidelberg and Frankfurt and has worked for the DFG long-term project Zoroastrian Middle Persian:Digital Corpus and Dictionary at Ruhr University Bochum. Moritz Maurer has intensively researched late antique Iranian religious history. His focus here is on Middle Iranian Manichaean and Zoroastrian texts. His current research focuses on the connections between esotericism, alternative religion, and right-wing extremism as well as the history of free religious groups in German-speaking countries. He has published on QAnon, right-wing meme cultures, and conspirituality. His research at the University of Vienna focuses on Traditionalism.

Share

The Tartarian Empire

TARTARIAN EMPIRE TIMELINE

1779:  Jean-Sylvain Bailly located the cradle of civilisation in Tartary.

1912:  Hanns Hörbiger and Philipp Fauth published Glazialkosmogonie (Glacial Cosmogony).

1950:  Velikovsky’s Worlds in Collision was published by Macmillan.

1995:  Новая хронология Руси, Англии и Рима (A New Chronology of Russia, England, and Rome) by Anatoli Fomenko and Gleb Nosovsky was published. The New Chronology was introduced to a wider audience.

2016:  The first known content on the Tartarian Empire was uploaded to YouTube.

2018:  The topic gained attention on social media platforms, and r/Tartaria was founded.

2020:  Stolenhistory.net went online.

2021:  The first episode of the documentary series Stolen History – Lifting the Veil of Deception was made available online.

2022:  Tartariabritannica.com went online.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Tartary was historically the name given to various parts of Siberia, Eastern Europe, and Central Asia from the Middle Ages to the nineteenth century. [Image at right] It takes its name from the Tartars, an ancient European ethnonym for various peoples of the Asian steppes, among them the Mongols who invaded Europe in the High Middle Ages. In modern usage, the term “Tartars” refers to a Turkic people living in Eastern Europe and northern Asia.

But, in a vibrant online community, this name has come to denote something very different. Tartary, sometimes also called Tartaria, the Tartarian Empire, Grand Tartary, or simply the Old World, is, in these circles, thought to be a lost, highly spiritual supercivilisation that once covered vast stretches of the Earth. Belief in it spread through social media, beginning in the second half of the 2010s. The vehicle for this is a multitude of online content creators who sometimes spread contradictory narratives about this empire, its downfall, and the conspiracy supposedly concealing its former existence. Not only in its spread and organisation, but also in its contents, it is highly dependent on the technological possibilities of the Internet.

Given that there exists no organisation and no authoritative voices in this narrative community (i.e. the loose network of people who, mostly through social media, work together to weave the complex set of stories and fragments of stories surrounding the Tartarian Empire), it is hard to reconstruct its history in a way suitable for groups such as Scientology, the Shakers, or Jainism. It is a very recent phenomenon, the history of which is mainly played out on the internet and social media. It can be seen as part of the broader field of conspirituality (a particular discursive formation in which topoi of esotericism are negotiated in a narrative framework determined by a conspiracy metanarrative). While it is impossible to map the whole network of sites, blogs, forums, and accounts on platforms such as Telegram, Instagram, and TikTok that spread content on the lost civilisation, at least a few important examples should be mentioned here.

An episode of the Skeptoid podcast identifies a conspiritual content creator named Philipp Druzhinin as the first person to upload a YouTube video on one of the community’s central topics in August of 2016. This can be seen as the beginning of the community’s history. The format, a video rather than text, already points to the Tartarian Empire’s special roots in the World Wide Web. According to Skeptoid’s research based on Google data, interest in Tartary started to gain momentum on the internet in December 2018 and January 2019 (Dunning 2021). Around the same time, on  December 26, 2018, the subreddit r/Tartaria, one of the largest forums dedicated to the theory, was founded (Maurer and Göckel 2025:12). On August 24, 2020, stolenhistory.net was registered, one of the early forums and blogs dedicated to the subject. The video series Stolen History – Lifting the Veil of Deception, one of the first comprehensive portrayals of the Tartarian Empire in the style of the Zeitgeist movies, classics of Internet conspiracism, was also created in connection with the homepage. Its first episode went online in March 2021 (Maurer and Göckel 2025:6 and fn. 5). On December 1, 2021, the Telegram channel, “Tartaria & History Channel,” with more than 120.000 members as of January 2026, was founded. In January 2022, tartariabritannica.com was registered. The homepage provides technically sophisticated blog posts on a wide variety of topics from the cultic milieu. At the same tie, interest in the Tartarian Empire has also spread to other areas of the cultic milieu, especially Anon. This radical movement, originating from the United States, has a tendency to absorb a wide range of subjects associated with the cultic milieu (Maurer 2024:124–29).

While the movement itself has only a relatively short history, it is interesting to take a brief look at the history of similar movements and ideas that often span a difficult-to-define area between esotericism and “alternative science”, especially “alternative archaeology”. Historically, these fields have not only influenced each other, but also the popular perception of academically institutionalised archaeology and its representation in popular culture (Andersson 2012; Anderson 2019). A topic we will come back to later.

Ideas about lost continents such as Mu, Lemuria, and Atlantis became popular, for example, in the Theosophical movement from the nineteenth century onwards. Such ideas were mostly embedded in larger, evolutionary narratives, which are absent in the case of the Tartarian Empire. Still, people in the community are interested in these lost continents and their relationship to Grand Tartary is debated.

Beyond that, the parallels with various catastrophist authors and proponents of alternative chronologies are striking, though references to them in the community are scarce. One parallel can be found in the works of Austrian engineer Hanns Hörbiger (1860-1931), inventor of the Welteislehre (World Ice Theory), which became extremely popular, especially in the German-speaking world, between the 1910s and the end of the Second World War. Hörbiger’s theory originated in a nocturnal vision he had at his family home in the 1890s. He advocated a complex cosmology based on a cosmic balance of ice and fire. An essential component of the theory, which he first sought to disseminate publicly in the book Glazialkosmosgonie (Glacial Cosmogony 1912), co-authored with the German teacher and astronomer Philipp Fauth (1867-1941), was, among other things, a catastrophist world view that saw the history of the Earth as determined by the impact of ice moons which caused, for example, the ice ages of prehistory (Wessely 2013). World Ice Theory was linked to alternative speculations on archaeology, history, and religions too, as, for example, in the works of authors such as Edmund Kiss (1886-1960) and his Das Sonnentor von Tihuanaku und Hörbigers Welteislehre (The Sun Gate of Tihuanaku and Hörbiger’s World Ice Theory 1937).

Similarly, there are ideological parallels to the physician, psychoanalyst, and amateur historian Immanuel Velikovsky (1895–1979) and his catastrophist counter-history, which he presented in a large number of books. He claimed to have extrapolated an alternative history of the solar system from ancient myths. In this theory, Earth and early civilisations were shaken by a series of cosmic events that manipulated Earth’s axis and rotation, causing various catastrophes. Velikovsky created a scientific scandal in 1950 when the academic publisher Macmillan published the first outline of his theories, Worlds in Collision. Despite this, or perhaps because of it, he developed a cult following that remained organised for many decades, partly in reading circles and societies (Gordin 2013).

Russian mathematician Anatoli Fomenko plays an important role in debates surrounding the origins of the Tartanian Empire community. Since the late 1970s, he has promoted his own form of chronology criticism, the so-called New Chronology. He has enjoyed tremendous success with this project since the early 1990s when he published Новая хронология Руси, Англии и Рима (A New Chronology of Russia, England, and Rome 1995), together with Gleb Nosovsky (b. 1958). Through the publication of a series of popular science books and appearances in various Russian media, Fomenko has gathered a noticeable following in Russia. His books have also been translated into various languages, including English. In his alternative Russian-ethnonationalist history of the world, a Mongol or Tartarian-Russian empire confederation is the aggressive center of world history (Sheiko 2009). It might be that the initial idea, and especially the naming of the virtual Tartary, were inspired by Fomenko. Still, beyond some motifs, this has very little parallel in the vision of Tartary found in the narratives common in the community, in which Fomenko’s role is also controversial (Halmhofer 2024:35-36; Maurer and Göckel 2025:14–15). Nationalist and revisionist narratives mostly come into play when discussing the history of the Tartarians after the mud flood. In contrast to Fomenko’s fantasy, the Empire is not imagined as a force of military conquest. Another parallel can be seen in the works of English Traditionalist and New
Age author John Michell. He advanced the idea of an Atlantean civilisation similar to that of the Tartarian Empire, most notably in his book The View Over Atlantis (1969; See Thaler 2026).

The scene also mentions other proponents of similar theories and disseminates their works, such as those of amateur historian Wilhelm Kammeier (1889–1959) on chronology criticism. With their belief in freely available energy, often linked to ether theories, they are part of a broad esoteric tradition. Names such as Karl von Reichenbach (1788–1869), the inventor of od energy, are also found as points of reference. (On various theories regarding esotericism and subtle energies, compare the contributions in Strube et al. 2026).

What most of these older examples have in common is that they initially sought recognition in established science but were rejected by academia. After this initial rejection, their founders turned to a popular audience. Even Hörbiger, whose starting point had been a spontaneous inspiration, endeavoured to give the World Ice Theory a formal scientific character, for example, by founding a journal and gaining recognition in academia. None of this seems to matter for proponents of Grand Tartary. Perceived truths and references to the seemingly obvious are at the forefront here. Where earlier authors such as Erich von Däniken focused on magnifying individual historical details that seemed to resist orthodox explanation, the conspiritual framework shifts attention away from discrete evidentiary anomalies toward the overall historical tableau, privileging narrative atmosphere and holistic plausibility over isolated proof. The Tartarian Empire community is thus not only an important part of modern conspiritual discourses, but also an important example of the disintegration of older patterns of argumentation and forms of representation within a field that is turning towards a post-scientific age.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Given its character as a narrative community, shared themes are more important than anything else in defining the community. However, not every study of a Tartarian civilisation can be meaningfully attributed to it. Already in 1779, French astronomer and politician Jean-Sylvain Bailly (1736–1793) had located the cradle of civilisation in Tartary. However, this seems not to have had a direct impact on the discourse in the online community (Bailly 1779:273). As mentioned above, the New Chronology advocated by Fomenko and his followers cannot be counted among the narrative community surrounding the Tartarian Empire in the narrower sense either.

The defining feature of the community is the shared production and consumption of texts in the widest possible sense, relating to the existence of the lost, spiritual empire, the Tartarian Empire, which was destroyed by a cataclysmic event called the mud flood. Given the nature of the community and the lack of authoritative voices, it is only possible to give a rough outline of some topoi as expressed across various media.

In these narratives, Grand Tartary stretched from the Northern parts of Asia over vast regions of Eurasia and other parts of the world, most notably North America. It relied on free energy to power its machinery, sometimes called Antiquitech. Beyond its material culture, Grand Tartary was characterised by its harmonious social relations and the spiritual character of its people. In some versions of the story, giants and other mythological beings were among its inhabitants. Within the community, it takes on the role of other comparable places known from religious and esoteric history, such as Shangri-La or Atlantis. Alongside this utopian, Elysian vision, however, it is very striking that there are virtually no forward-looking ideas about a return to the golden age, apart from a few attempts by community members to build free energy generators and a sometimes hinted-at shift in human consciousness by uncovering our shared Tartarian heritage. The Tartarian Empire vanished in the so-called mud flood, a global cataclysm that covered its cities in – mud. It is worth noting that a sizeable part of the narrative community seems to believe in a flat earth surrounded by an ice wall, which might make the idea a little more believable (on the flat earth movement, see Hammer and Swartz-Hammer 2024:18-19). Still, its successors appear to have been involved in various conflicts, depending on the narrator (for example, with the Russian Empire, the British Empire, or the Vatican). It is difficult to fit these events precisely into a common scientific chronology, as the Second World War is by some proponents seen as part of the struggle (in this case by the Allies) against the remnants of the Tartarian Empire ( i.e. Nazi Germany). However, the mud flood is generally dated to before the year 1800.

Historical revisionist content is disseminated within the Tartarian Empire community. Blogs associated with the scene feature articles on the far-right legend of the so-called Great Replacement, and videos on the history of the Tartarian Empire are used to deny German war guilt in the First and Second World Wars (Maurer and Göckel 2025:6; Halmhofer 2024:36). On Telegram, “Tartaria & History Channel” is used to spread antisemitism.

Most of the outlets discussing Tartary also address other topics current in the cultic milieu (on this concept see Campbell 1972). One finds a notable interest in flat earth research, free energy research, and the theories surrounding so-called mud fossils and giant tress. The latter two interpret geographical features of landscapes as remnants of long-gone titanic beings, either giants, dragons, or gigantic trees (Maurer 2025:59–61). Especially believing in a flat earth is also linked to a Christian self-identification among community members (Maurer and Göckel 2025:14; Maurer 2025:55-56 and figure 6). Here we can again see the shift from seeking to correct misconceptions within the framework of scientific discourse to establishing a new discourse based on unscientific assumptions. In general, Olav Hammer and Karen Swartz-Hammer have pointed out parallels between narratives in the Tartarian sphere and biblical stories (Hammer and Swartz-Hammer 2024:16-17,)  although this is true of many stories shared in our societies.

A feature noted by every observer is the obsession of the community with what they take to be “Old World architecture” (e. g. Mortice 2021; Halmhofer 2024:36). This can be any form of architecture that is actually old and historic or prominently uses historicising or ornamental elements in the broadest sense, such as Art Deco. Buildings, ranging from the Colosseum to the Empire State Building, can be interpreted as remnants of Tartarian cities. Cellar windows, seemingly cut off at ground level, are seen as evidence of the mud flood. Historical church spires with their weathervanes, domes and similar features are regarded as antennas with which the Tartars were able to extract free energy from the atmosphere or ether. [Image at right] Early modern star forts are also linked to the extraction of free energy. Within this lore, the world exhibitions of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries play a special role. The temporary building ensembles erected there are seen as remnants of Tartar cities, whose demolition was to be concealed by reframing them as part of these exhibitions (Halmhofer 2024:36). Fittingly, a somewhat historicizing depiction of a griffin has become the unofficial logo of the community.

What all members of the community agree on is that after the downfall of the Tartarians, a global conspiracy started covering up the evidence of the lost Tartarian. The idea that a sinister conspiracy consciously hides such higher spiritual abilities and fantastic technologies is common in what is known as the conspiritual milieu (Dyrendal et al. 2018:41), of which the Tartary community can be considered a part of, although narratives surrounding this conspiracy are not necessarily in the foreground (Maurer and Göckel 2025:8–10). One theory states that this happened to suppress knowledge of the Tartarians’ free energy technology. In this subplot, the so-called “robber barons,” U.S.-American industrialists of the Gilded Age, stole Tartarian technology from the partly buried cities but replaced free energy generators with combustion engines to make the world dependent on a limited resource they could sell for profit. Tartarian survivors or people with memories of the empire were killed or lobotomized, and the empty cities repopulated with the “orphan trains,” in real history, a U.S. program to relocate children from the Eastern seaboard to foster families in rural parts of the country. In addition to alleged physical measures taken against witnesses, adherents also argue that memories of Grand Tartary were psychologically or spiritually suppressed. As a result, art, movies, and literature are interpreted as sites where fragments of this repressed history reappear. But this destruction of evidence was not, in the eyes of the believers, complete. One main body of evidence consists of references in old documents and, in particular, old maps, and the main type of practice in the community is uncovering it.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

The theory practically contradicts every conviction of modern historical science. However, unlike older narratives with similar content, it does not seek a place in academia anyway. The members of the narrative community follow their own form of anti-rationality, in which, for example, source criticism is not practised. Rather, “common sense” or even feelings and intuitions are used to argue that, for example, a building is a witness to the fallen empire. In an age focused on rationality, this anti-scientific approach makes it a point of reference for a meme culture focused on transgression. This dynamic renders the distinction between serious propagandistic intent and ironic appropriation structurally ambiguous (Maurer 2025:56–59).

But the creation of memes, the most defining practice is the research members of the community engage in, often by searching for the word “Tartary” and its variants in online databases. Every marginal reference to the term in historical documents, often maps, can serve as evidence for the existence of Grand Tartary. In addition, “researchers” examine photographs of historical buildings and, of course, the historical maps mentioned above. Thanks to the technical possibilities offered by the internet, relevant information can not only be easily found, but also recontextualised and disseminated, even across various platforms (Maurer and Göckel 2025:15–16). Equally important is the collection of images of the architecture described above, which is seen as proof of the Tartars’ superior technology. According to community members, even simple buildings from the late nineteenth century could not have been constructed without sophisticated machinery (Halmhofer 2024:34–35). However, this also opens up the possibility of re-enchanting one’s own neighbourhood. Users on forums like r/Tartaria can post pictures of their own hometowns that they link to the golden past of Grand Tartary (Maurer and Göckel 2025:24).

Similar practices can be found in the mud fossils, and giant trees,-communities (Maurer 2025:59–61). There are also parallels to QAnon, where doing research is called “baking” (Sommer 2023:25–27). Previous studies have pointed out that such processes of gamification can heighten the attractiveness of such groups (Fröhlich and Mertes 2022). The psychological effects, some of which have been reported in the community and some of which have been brought to the author’s attention personally, appear, as in the case of QAnon, to be partly destructive to the relationship between those involved in “backing” and their environment (Maurer and Göckel 2025:18).

The Tartarian community can be seen as a product of the technical and social conventions of social media, in conjunction with the culture industry’s commodification of history. Many people now experience history solely as an aesthetic assault, in the form of disconnected visual impressions and snippets of information via the media. The grand narratives that could organise these impressions seem to have lost their binding force, allowing something like the Tartary theory to take their place. However, its catastrophism also represents a step back towards older ways of thinking about history. The community knows only a history-less golden age and an almost equally static, crisis-ridden present. It is thus symptomatic of a loss of the past as history in the narrower sense, a crisis of historicism whose consequences in our society are not yet foreseeable. (Maurer and Göckel 2025:24–27).

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

The community is best described as a grassroots movement engaged in a shared discourse. It is important to note that not even belief in its content is a really defining feature of it. As pointed out by Christopher Partridge regarding conspiracy theories surrounding the Islamist terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, we can assume that not everyone involved in spreading such theories believes in them to the same extent (Partridge 2013:116). As a consequence, the question of who might be considered the legitimate heirs of the Tartarian Empire remains unresolved and contested within the community.”

What can be said for sure is that we have a loosely organised scene in which, so far, only a kind of conspiritual precariat is discernible, functioning based on small voluntary contributions from interested parties via Patreon, for example (Maurer and Göckel 2025:10). Beyond this, small-scale vendors market e-books related to the theory as well as print-on-demand products featuring the griffin emblem and other Tartarian motifs.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

As shown in this article, debates about the Tartarian Empire remain largely confined to online environments. Despite this, the Tartarian discourse shows no signs of fading. Its fragmented structure and lack of authoritative voices make it highly adaptable. Tartarian motifs circulate easily across platforms and are readily integrated into broader conspiritual contexts. In particular, the narrative has proven compatible with right-wing esoteric milieus, where it intersects with historical revisionism, antisemitism, and anti-democratic worldviews. Further, it allows for ironic, playful, or transgressive uses, blurring the line between entertainment and ideological affirmation. The strong emphasis on images, architecture, and atmosphere supports its persistence. Visual material spreads easily and offers a low-threshold, aesthetically appealing introduction to the theory.

At the individual level, the psychological effects of sustained online “research” appear comparable to those observed in QAnon contexts. As reported within the community and through personal communications with the author, such engagement can be partly destructive to participants and their social relations (Maurer and Göckel 2025:18).

Overall, the significance of the Tartarian Empire lies less in its concrete claims than in its durability. As a post-scientific, conspiritual interpretation of history, it functions as a flexible cultural resource within esoteric online environments, with effects that remain difficult to assess.

IMAGES

Image #1: 1626 map of Tartary by John Speed – Public domain map – PICRYL – Public Domain Media Search Engine Public Domain Search.
Image #2: A church spire suggesting how free energy was captured.

REFERENCES

Anderson, David S. 2019. “Crafting a Mysterious Ancient World.” Nova Religio 22:13-26.

Andersson, Pia. 2012. “Alternative Archaeology: Many Pasts in Our Present. Numen 59:125–37.

Campbell, Colin. 1972. “The Cult, the Cultic Milieu and Secularization. A Sociological Yearbook of Religion in Britain 5:119–36.

Dunning, Brian. 2021. “Tartaria and the Mud Flood. Skeptoid Media (Skeptoid Podcast).  Accessed from https://skeptoid.com/episodes/4765 on 20 July 2022.

Dyrendal, Asbjørn, Egil Asprem and David G. Robertson. 2018. “Conspiracy Theories and the Study of Religion(s): What we are Talking about, and Why it is Important.”  Pp 21-47 in Handbook of Conspiracy Theory and Contemporary Religion, edited by Asbjørn Dyrendal, David G. Robertson and Egil Asprem. Leiden and Boston: Brill.

Fröhlich, Vincent and Michael Mertes. 2022:#Der neue Konspirationismus. Wie digitale Plattformen und Fangemeinschaften Verschwörungserzählungen schaffen und verbreiten. Marburg: Büchner-Verlag (# Kritische Reflexionen, 7).

Gordin, Michael D. 2013. “The pseudoscience wars. Immanuel Velikovsky and the birth of the modern fringe.” Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Halmhofer, Stephanie. 2024. “Unveiling the Truth. Behind ‘Hidden’ Histories.” British Columbia History 57:34–37.

Hammer, Olav and Karen Swartz-Hammer. 2024. New Religious Movements and Comparative Religion. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press (Elements in New Religious Movements).

Maurer, Moritz. 202. “Conspirituality and Meme Culture: Transgressive Dynamics in Right-Wing Esoteric Social Media Discourse.”Religion 55:43-66.

Maurer, Moritz. 2024. “God Emperor Trump und flache Erde. Konspiritualität in virtuellen Räumen.“ Pp. 123-33 in Esoterik und politische Bildung, edited by Ansgar Martins and Philipp Wilhelm Kranemann. Frankfurt am Main: Wochenschau Verlag.

Maurer, Moritz and Thierry Göckel. 2025. “The Tartarian Empire. Conspirituality, Pop Culture, and the End of the Past.” Nova Religio 29:5–34.

Mortice, Zach. 2021. “Tartarian Empire. Inside Architecture’s Wildest Conspiracy Theory” Accessed from https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2021-04-27/inside-architecture-s-wildest-conspiracy-theory on 14 November 2023.

Sheiko, Konstantin 2009. “Nationalist imaginings of the Russian past. Anatolii Fomenko and the rise of alternative history in post-communist Russia.” With the collaboration of Stephen Brown. Stuttgart: Ibidem-Verlag (Soviet and post-Soviet politics and society, Volume 86).

Sommer, Will. 2023. “Trust the plan. The rise of QAnon and the conspiracy that unhinged America.” London: 4th State.

Strube, Julian, Marleen Thaler and Dominic Zoehrer, Dominic, eds. 2026. Subtle Energies in Therapy, Spirituality, Arts, and Politics. 1800–Present. Leiden, Boston: Brill.

Thaler, Marleen. 2026 (forthcoming): Albian’s Sage for the New Age. Sheffield: Equinox.

Wessely, Christina. 2013. Welteis. Eine wahre Geschichte. Berlin: Matthes & Seitz.

Publication Date:
20 January 2026

Share

Rosita Šorytė

Rosita Šorytė was born on September 2, 1965 in Lithuania. In 1988, she graduated from the University of Vilnius in French Language and Literature. In 1994, she got her diploma in international relations from the Institut International d’Administration Publique in Paris.
In 1992, Rosita Šorytė joined the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Lithuania as a diplomat. She has been posted to the Permanent Mission of Lithuania to UNESCO (Paris, 1994-1996), to the Permanent Mission of Lithuania to the Council of Europe (Strasbourg, 1996-1998), and was Minister Counselor at the Permanent Mission of Lithuania to the United Nations in 2014-2017, where she had already worked in 2003-2006. In 2011, she worked as the representative of the Lithuanian Chairmanship of the OSCE (Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe) at the Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (Warsaw). In 2013, she chaired the European Union Working Group on Humanitarian Aid on behalf of the Lithuanian pro tempore presidency of the European Union. As a diplomat, she specialized in disarmament, humanitarian aid and peacekeeping issues, with a special interest in the Middle East and religious persecution and discrimination in the area.  She also served in elections observation missions in Bosnia and Herzegovina, Georgia, Belarus, Burundi, and Senegal.
Her personal interests, outside of international relations and humanitarian aid, include spirituality, world religions, and art. She takes a special interest in refugees escaping their countries due to religious persecution and is co-founder and President of ORLIR, the International Observatory of Religious Liberty of Refugees. She is also a member of the Scientific Committee of the European Federation for Freedom of Belief (FOB) and the author of two books and several journal articles on religious liberty, refugee issues, and new religious movements.
Share

The Revelation Spiritual Home

THE REVELATION SPIRITUAL HOME TIMELINE

1977 (November 8):  Samuel Mbiza (later known as Inkosi yamaKhosi Omoya IMboni uZwi-Lezwe Radebe, or IMboni uZwi-Lezwe Radebe [See  Founder/History] was born in Gugulethu, Western Cape, South Africa.

1981–1983:  As a child, Radebe experienced visions and spiritual phenomena interpreted as a divine calling.

1993:  At sixteen, Radebe joined the Universal Church of the Kingdom of God (UCKG) in Johannesburg, where he became a successful boy preacher.

2006:  Radebe reported a revelation at the Vaal River, near Johannesburg, where he saw a golden lampstand with seven colored candles and beings with abnormally large heads. He understood he would be called to found a new African spiritual institution.

2008 (5 December):  Radebe performed a pilgrimage to the Ncome River (Blood River), near Vryheid, KwaZulu-Natal. He reported he entered there into a Covenant with his “spiritual guide,” affirming his calling to restore African Indigenous Spirituality (AIS).

2008 (December):  Unusual phenomena during a UKCG’s night vigil were interpreted as a confirmation of Radebe’s calling.

2009 (March 22):  After leaving the UKCG, Radebe conducted his first service in a restaurant at Gandhi Square, Johannesburg. Services were then held in the basement of a building on Plein Street, and the “institution” (Radebe’s term for his group, rejecting both “religion” and “religious movement”) was temporarily named “African Church.”

2009 (April): Radebe and his followers adopted the name “The Revelation Church of God,” which he claimed he had received by revelation.

2009 (May 10):  The group, whose numbers had grown, relocated to the former Great Synagogue in Johannesburg.

2011 (31 December):  A ritual was performed along Durban’s coastline, later named “eSibonakalisweni” (the Sea of Revelations), the first of several rituals conducted at this site.

2012 (May–June):  Radebe announced he had received spiritual revelations instructing that his followers should enter into the Covenant with him and his Deity.

2014:  Radebe acquired a mountain near Clocolan, Free State, later called “Ekuphumuleni” (the Place of Rest), which would become “the permanent resting place” for the Covenant.

2014 (December 5):  Radebe went to renew the Covenant at Ekuphumuleni.

2015 (February):  Radebe reported a revelation naming the pact the “Covenant of Restoration.”

2015 (June):  Radebe’s followers undertook their first pilgrimage to Ekuphumuleni to renew their commitment to the Covenant of Restoration.

2014–2016:  Over three consecutive years, a “spiritual act of national cleansing” was performed at FNB Stadium in Johannesburg. In 2016, scholars reported that more than 90,000 attended the event,

2017 (August):  Radebe reported that he had received a “profound spiritual revelation” (isibonakaliso), announcing major transformations in Africa and globally beginning in 2019.

2018 (June 8):  Radebe shared another isibonakaliso, concerning an impending great revival of African Indigenous Spirituality.

2019 (12 May):  Radebe reported yet another isibonakaliso, about an extraordinary event that would mark the beginning of a new era.

2020:  TRSH identified the COVID-19 pandemic as the event announced by the May 12, 2019, isibonakaliso.

2020:  The name of the institution was changed from The Revelation Church of God to The Revelation Spiritual Home (TRSH).

2023:  Radebe inaugurated the African Association for Indigenous Spirituality (AAFIS).

2024 (April 20):  The musical The Spirit King premiered in Durban.

2025 (March 15):  After one in Ireland, an overseas branch of TRSH was inaugurated in Atlanta, Georgia.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

The Revelation Spiritual Home (TRSH) defines itself as a “spiritual institution” and rejects labels such as “religion,” “new religion,” or “new religious movement.” It was founded by Samuel Radebe, born Samuel Mbiza and later known as “Inkosi yamaKhosi Omoya IMboni uZwi Lezwe Radebe” and “IMboni uZwi Lezwe Radebe” [Image at right]. Mbiza is his civil surname, while “Radebe” is his clan name (isithakazelo), which is regarded as central to his genealogy and spiritual identity, affirming both his bloodline and his spiritual position. The names “IMboni” and “iNkosi yamaKhosi oMoya,” according to TRSH, come from revelations and are the principal spiritual titles defining his calling, authority, and role.

Radebe’s biography is central to the institution’s identity, and followers narrate his life story as a sequence of spiritual revelations, struggles, and triumphs that embody the destiny of African Indigenous Spirituality (AIS).

Radebe was born in Gugulethu, a township outside Cape Town, in 1977. According to TRSH, extraordinary experiences marked his childhood. At the age of four, he began to see colored lights and hear voices. He sometimes lost the ability to speak or walk, which caused concern in his family. An older woman renowned for her spiritual gifts explained that he was not sick but chosen by the Izithunywa, spiritual guides who were preparing him for a spiritual mission. Rituals with candles and camphor appeased the spirits, and Radebe regained speech and mobility (Radebe 2022:14) [we also rely on interviews with Radebe and other TRSH members in January 2023, December 2023, December 2024, and November 2025: see Introvigne and Šorytė 2025; these were group interviews including TRSH senior leaders and other members, and we have chosen not to identify individual informants]. Radebe later recalled that his childhood visions were both frightening and empowering, teaching him that ancestral spirits and Izithunywa (higher spirits) were active forces in daily life.

After losing both parents, Radebe moved to Johannesburg. In 1993, at the age of sixteen, he joined the Universal Church of the Kingdom of God (UCKG), a Brazilian Pentecostal movement that had expanded aggressively in South Africa (van Wyk 2014). He quickly became known as a boy preacher and healer, attracting crowds with his ability to cure illnesses.

Yet, he grew disillusioned with the church’s racism and demonization of African spirituality. The UCKG taught that ancestral spirits were demons and that African traditions were obstacles to salvation. Radebe began to question why black South Africans and their culture remained marginalized, including in some Pentecostal churches, even after the end of apartheid. He later concluded that Christianity in all its shapes, far from liberating Africans, had perpetuated colonial hierarchies.

In 2006, Radebe reported a decisive revelation at the Vaal River, near Johannesburg [Image at right]. He saw a golden lampstand with seven colored candles and mysterious beings with large heads. He interpreted this as a call to establish an institution rooted in AIS. The lampstand became central to TRSH’s symbolism, later embodied in izibane, spiritual lamps used in rituals.

Two years later, on December 5, 2008, he undertook a pilgrimage to the Ncome River, also known as Blood River. This site was historically associated with the Afrikaner vow of 1838, when Voortrekkers promised to commemorate their victory over the Zulu as a covenant with God. He was accompanied by followers, which he initially referred to as the “Three Mighty” (and later received by revelation the name “Abofakazi Nabaziyo”). Radebe enacted a counter-covenant at the Ncome River, dissolving what he regarded as a curse imposed on Africans and restoring AIS. This act was seen by followers as a turning point in African history, marking the reclaiming of spiritual sovereignty from colonial powers (Radebe 2022: 18).

Shortly later, during a night vigil at one of the main UCKG branches, where Radebe was conducting a service, a young boy reportedly vomited a lion’s nail. A “spiritual presence” subsequently confirmed that this signified the “dominion as a consequence of the Covenant Radebe had established at the Ncome River” (personal interviews, November 2025).

On March 22, 2009, the first service after the separation from the UCKG was held in a restaurant at Gandhi Square, Johannesburg. This was followed by services held in the basement of a building on Plein Street, Johannesburg, [Image at right] during which Radebe temporarily named the institution the “African Church.”

These humble beginnings were quickly overshadowed by rapid growth. In April, during a large gathering at Johannesburg City Hall to commemorate Good Friday, Radebe and his followers adopted the name “The Revelation Church of God,” which he claimed he had received through revelation. On May 10, 2009, the group moved to the former Great Synagogue in Johannesburg, which the dwindling Jewish community was no longer using as a place of worship. TRCG preserved the synagogue’s heritage while repurposing it as a spiritual center.

The institution attracted thousands of followers, particularly from townships and marginalized communities (Wilhelm-Solomon 2013). Its emphasis on healing, empowerment, and pride in African identity resonated with people who felt excluded from mainstream churches (Malcomess and Wilhelm-Solomon 2016:52–55). [Image at right]

In 2011, Radebe performed a ritual in a location along Durban’s coastline, later called “eSibonakalisweni” (the Sea of Revelations). It was the first of several rituals conducted at this site. He reported visions of spiritual beings emerging from the sea, reinforcing the connection between water and spirituality. The location, associated with Maphithini Thusi (1888–1964), the founder of a previous AIS institution, emaKhehleni (du Toit 1970, 1971), would become a favorite spot for Radebe’s visions and prophecies (African Hidden Voices 2023:96–102).

In May and June 2012, Radebe reported a spiritual revelation instructing his followers to enter into the Covenant with him and his Deity (uMabizwa’Asabele).

In 2014, Radebe acquired a mountain, whose name was later revealed to him as “Ekuphumuleni” (the Place of Rest), near Clocolan, Free State (African Hidden Voices 2023:83). This site was in turn associated with a famous seer and visionary who lived at an Anglican mission but included obvious African non-Christian elements in her preaching: Mantsopa Anna Makhetha (1793 or 1797–1908) [these
dates are correct, as, according to tradition, she died at age 111 or 115]. The covenant was not new but a reaffirmation of the one at the Ncome River. [Image at right]

Ekuphumuleni will become “the permanent resting place for the Covenant” that Radebe had established at the Ncome River. On December 5, 2014, Radebe went to renew the Covenant there. Until that year, the Covenant had been renewed annually at the Ncome River. December 5 became a date Radebe observes each year to personally renew the Covenant.

In February 2015, Radebe reported a revelation formally designating the pact as “the Covenant of Restoration.” In June 2015, Radebe’s followers undertook their first pilgrimage to Ekuphumuleni to renew their commitment to the Covenant of Restoration. This is their annual pilgrimage, even as its date and location shifted over time.

TRSH reports that “it is through the spiritual mountain, Ekuphumuleni, a mountain concentrated with profound spirituality and regarded as a divine archetype, that the revelations of the corrupted faith began to unfold in successive phases, guiding the restoration of AIS and African identity” (personal interviews, December 2024).

TRSH insists that although the formal process of restoring AIS emerged during the 2010s, Radebe’s spiritual gifts had been present since birth, long before the institution’s founding. They explain that, like other IImboni (plural of Imboni), (i.e., AIS spiritual leaders with national missions, particularly those who appeared in the early twentieth century during the rapid expansion of Christianity in Africa) Radebe grew up in a Christian environment. Nevertheless, “he carried an inherent spiritual destiny that pointed toward a different purpose. This inner calling distinguished him and ultimately led to the restoration work he later embodied. The significance of this restoration lies in the recognition that AIS had always been present within him, even as it found fuller expression through divine revelation and institutional formation. In fact, Radebe’s institution has consistently practiced AIS, while initially incorporating selected elements of Christianity, reflecting the historical and spiritual realities of African spirituality and religious experience” (personal interview, December 2024).

In 2014, Radebe reported that he was led by revelation to perform a “national act of spiritual cleansing:” a ritual of purification for the nation over three consecutive years at the FNB Stadium in Johannesburg, where the venue was filled to capacity. These gatherings focused on the ritual of Uhlanjululo Ngamanzi (the cleansing with water) and were perceived by TRSH as a significant moment in the nation’s collective spiritual renewal. In 2015, the institution publicly proclaimed its mission to restore AIS.

In 2016, the first South African scholars who studied the TRCG reported that more than 90,000 people had gathered at Johannesburg’s main stadium (Malcomess and Wilhelm-Solomon 2016:53), including a sizable contingent of immigrants from Zimbabwe who felt discriminated against in other religious organizations but were welcomed by Radebe (Wilhelm-Solomon, Zulu, and Worby 2016:266–67).

In August 2017, Radebe reported he had received a “profound spiritual revelation” (isibonakaliso) that would later emerge as a significant turning point in South Africa’s political and societal landscape (personal interview, November 2025). He foresaw a major shift beginning in 2019, becoming more pronounced from 2020 onwards, marked by changes in public consciousness, governance patterns, and collective direction. The revelation further extended beyond South Africa, indicating parallel transformations unfolding on a global scale. According to TRSH, these developments, both locally and internationally, carried profound social and spiritual implications, affirming the broader scope and relevance of Radebe’s revelations.

On June 8, 2018, Radebe publicly shared another isibonakaliso concerning an impending African revival, marked by the restoration and widespread awakening of AIS. Yet another isibonakaliso followed on May 12, 2019, concerning “a coming phenomenon—an extraordinary and unprecedented event that would mark the beginning of a new era. He was shown that when this phenomenon occurred, members of his institution were to declare success and dominion, signifying spiritual transition and victory” (personal interview, November 2025). TRSH later saw a confirmation of this revelation in the global outbreak of COVID-19, interpreted as the phenomenon that ushered in a new international era.

In 2020, the institution’s name changed from The Revelation Church of God to The Revelation Spiritual Home (TRSH), marking a decisive shift from Christian references to a fully indigenous spiritual identity.

TRSH continued to expand across Southern Africa, with branches in Zimbabwe, Mozambique, Eswatini, Botswana, Lesotho, and Malawi. By 2025, overseas branches had been established in Ireland and Atlanta, USA.

In 2024, the institution gained further recognition. On April 20, the musical The Spirit King premiered in Durban, dramatizing Radebe’s life and visions. The mainline South African media reviewed it favorably (see, e.g., SABC News 2024). TRSH members were proud of this recognition and of the awards Radebe received in different countries for his contribution to the renewal and spread of AIS.

They proudly noted how, from its origins in a Johannesburg basement, TRSH had become a global institution, presenting AIS to international audiences and asserting its place among the world’s spiritual traditions.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

The Revelation Spiritual Home (TRSH) presents itself as the custodian of African Indigenous Spirituality (AIS), insisting that it is the oldest and most authentic spiritual tradition of humanity. Its teachings emphasize the distinction between spirituality and religion. Spirituality is defined as direct knowledge and lived experience, while religion is portrayed as belief imposed by external powers, often through colonialism and missionary activity.

According to TRSH, spirituality is experiential: it is the ability to perceive, communicate with, and be guided by spiritual forces. Religion, by contrast, is a system of doctrines and dogmas that alienates people from their ancestral roots. Radebe frequently stresses that Africans were spiritual (a form of “knowledge”) long before they were religious (a form of “belief:” African Hidden Voices 2023:17), and that religion was introduced as a tool of domination. Christianity and Islam are described as foreign impositions that severed Africans from their ancestral spirits and the Izithunywa.

The distinction between a genuine African spirituality and a colonial religion informs TRSH’s entire practice. Followers are taught that to restore balance in their lives, they must reconnect with AIS, which permeates every aspect of existence: birth, death, marriage, family, diet, dress, grooming, health care, financial decisions, and governance.

TRSH proposes what we may call a “historiosophy,” an esoteric gaze at the world’s history. It situates Africa as the cradle of spirituality. Ancient Egypt is interpreted both through Egyptology and the speculations of (Western) esotericists, often referred to as Egyptosophy. Followers are taught that mystery schools, pyramids, and esoteric traditions originated in Africa and were later appropriated by Europe and the Middle East (African Hidden Voices 2024:147). References to Atlantis and cosmic origins are sometimes invoked, blending indigenous traditions with global esotericism, as another South African spiritual leader who tried to restore
and spread AIS, Credo Mutwa (1921–2020), had done before TRSH (Chidester 2002). This narrative instills pride in African identity. It asserts that AIS is not a local or tribal phenomenon but a universal heritage. [Image at right]

The cosmology of TRSH is expressed through dual hierarchies represented by upward and downward triangles. At the apex is the Creator, uMfihlakalo (“the Mystery”), referred to as “He,” but in fact transcending masculine and feminine energies. The Creator is ineffable, beyond human comprehension, yet accessible through intermediaries. TRSH insists that to regard AIS as monotheistic because of the presence of a single Creator God is a mistake. In fact, AIS is polytheistic as the plurality of the gods, although subordinate to uMfihlakalo, is a defining feature (African Hidden Voices 2024:23–26).

Communication between the Creator God and humans occurs through the Izithunywa, spirits who speak in dreams and revelations to the IIMboni, who are spiritual “guiders” born with foresight and healing powers. TRSH distinguishes between spiritual “guides,” who are disincarnate spirits, and human “guiders” such as the IIMboni. Izithunywa are not ancestors but distinct spiritual beings, each with specific functions, such as hope, war, balance, harmony, fertility, and light.

TRSH insists that an IMboni is more than a prophet. A prophet speaks for the gods, but an IMboni guides a nation, heals spiritually and physically, and is born into a lineage of spiritual “guiders.” Radebe is recognized as a “Spirit King,” a title reserved for those IIMboni who establish spiritual nations.

Historically, African kings were assisted by IIMboni, who conveyed messages from the Izithunywa. Colonialism destroyed this connection by persecuting IIMboni and replacing them with missionaries. TRSH teaches that to restore African sovereignty, the role of IMboni must be revived.

Numerology and symbolism play a central role in TRSH doctrine. Balance is expressed through equations such as “-1 + 0 + 1 = 2,” representing the synergy of negative and positive forces (African Hidden Voices 2024:51–52).

Colors also carry symbolic meaning. The seven izibane lamps represent different Izithunywa and spiritual forces: baby blue for presiding spirits, royal blue for hope, red for war, yellow for balance, green for fertility and female spirits, and white for light and family [Image at right]. These symbols are integrated into rituals and garments, reinforcing the cosmological order.

Ancestors (idlozi) are acknowledged but distinguished from the Izithunywa, who were never incarnated on Earth. Benevolent ancestors may be embraced and pacified, while hostile ancestors who led bad lives may be severed from their descendants. TRSH emphasizes rituals of cleansing ancestral lineages, purifying distortions caused by syncretism, the mixing of AIS with Christianity. Followers are taught that ancestors who converted to Christianity were misled, and their descendants must liberate them through rituals.

This teaching has been controversial, as some critics argue it denies the agency of ancestors who may have freely chosen Christianity. TRSH responds that it is not condemning ancestors but liberating them from colonial distortions (African Hidden Voices 2024:130).

TRSH also critiques African Initiated Churches (AICs), arguing that they were colonial projects rather than genuine revivals. Leaders such as Kimpa Vita (1684–1706), Isaiah Shembe (1865–1935), and Simon Kimbangu (1887–1951) are recognized as IIMboni who camouflaged their message to escape persecution, leading their followers and academic scholars to misunderstand them as Christian leaders. Christianity, even in the Africanized forms of the AICs, is rejected by TRSH as a foreign imposition.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

TRSH’s rituals are central to its identity. They are not borrowed from other groups but revealed directly to Radebe, although they are rooted in AIS’ history.

TRSH conducts two primary weekly services. Sunday services focus on teaching, testimonies, and institutional progress. Videos chronicle the growth of TRSH and its business enterprises. Music plays an important role, with choirs performing songs that blend traditional rhythms with modern styles.

Tuesday, “Services of Enlightenment” are devoted to rituals. These services are more impressive, with participants lined up in rows waiting for blessings. Some carry umkhonto (symbolic wooden spears), others bring children to be blessed, and many display pictures or documents of relatives in need. [Image at right]  Manifestations of ancestral spirits are common, with participants shaking or speaking in voices not their own. Radebe discerns whether these spirits are benevolent or hostile.

Water is central to TRSH rituals. It is believed to absorb information about illnesses and transform it into antidotes. Participants are blessed with sanctified water, splattered on their bodies in the weekly intsebenzo yokuchelwa ngamanzi. On the first Tuesday of each month, they bring bottles of water to be blessed in the ibhafu ritual [see Radebe and Hloele 2022 for these different rituals; we also rely on our observation of TRSH from 2023 to 2025].

Every Wednesday, participants drink blessed water from small white cups in the intsebenzo yenkomishi, often followed by vomiting or urination, interpreted as expulsion of illnesses or evil spirits. Sea water is used in the monthly intsebenzo yamanzi, which participants use to bathe or inhale vapors. At the New Year (which TRSH’s “African Spiritual Calendar” (ASC) places in August) sanctified water is placed in a bull’s horn and rubbed on the feet and foreheads.

Eggs are used in the intsebenzo yeqanda ritual to absorb negative energies. Milk is poured on participants in the intsebenzo yoBisi, invoking abundance and good fortune. Salt is distributed at year’s end to protect homes from hostile spirits. Incense is inhaled in the intsebenzo yeMphepho, warding off evil.

Izibane, the spiritual lamps of seven colors that represent different Izithunywa, are placed on a golden lampstand, recalling Radebe’s vision at the Vaal River. Radebe’s garments also carry symbolic meaning. The leopard skin represents lineage and Spirit Kingship. The white and blue ingubo yesambulo symbolizes his role as Spiritual Guider. The white ingubo yamakhosi is used during rituals for kings. The red-yellow ingubo yokubamba wards off evil spirits. The white and blue ingubo yamanzi is used for water rituals.

As mentioned earlier, annual pilgrimages are conducted to Ekuphumuleni Mountain, where the “Covenant of Restoration” is renewed. Durban’s “Sea of Revelations” is another pilgrimage site. These pilgrimages reinforce the institution’s identity and connect followers to sacred geography.

Most followers come to TRSH seeking healing, protection, and good fortune. Rituals are intended to cure illnesses, expel evil spirits, and bring prosperity. Testimonies are central to services, with participants recounting how rituals changed their lives. Singing, dancing, and shouting express joy and gratitude. [Image at right]

TRSH integrates sangomas and traditional healers, some of whom join the institution or participate in the African Association for Indigenous Spirituality (AAFIS), founded by Radebe in 2023. Benevolent healers are distinguished from malevolent witches. TRSH emphasizes that sangomas heal and help, while witches harm and damage. This distinction is crucial in African societies, and TRSH has specific rituals to protect from witchcraft.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

By the early 2020s, TRSH had more than seventy70 branches in South Africa, with expansion into neighboring countries such as Eswatini, Botswana, Lesotho, Malawi, Zimbabwe, and Mozambique, as well as into Ireland and the United States. These foreign centers were typically founded not by missionaries sent from Johannesburg but by immigrants or students who had encountered TRSH in South Africa and then carried its message back to their home countries.

TRSH claims to have some 3,500,000 members internationally. Statistics are difficult to confirm, but certainly its services attract large crowds. The headquarters in Marshalltown, Johannesburg, seats approximately 5,000
participants, but even this, along with other extensive facilities, cannot contain the crowds that gather for Sunday and Tuesday services. Overflow spaces, tents, and courtyards are routinely used, and services are streamed to branches outside of Johannesburg. [Image at right]

The institution deliberately distinguishes itself from Christian churches by adopting different terminology: it operates “spiritual centers” rather than “churches” and has “leaders” rather than “bishops.” At the apex of the hierarchy stands IMboni iNkosi YamaKhosi oMoya Radebe, a title that emphasizes his recognition as a Spirit King, regarded as both the supreme spiritual authority and the founder of a spiritual nation.

In parallel to its spiritual mission, TRSH operates a vast business and cultural network through Trillion Cart Holdings, a conglomerate founded in 2009 that oversees more than seventy companies. These enterprises range from burial schemes and cosmetics to gyms, restaurants, health supplements, travel agencies,
and investment advice. The Siyangakhona Burial Scheme was the first venture, designed to serve individuals excluded from other burial programs. Ubuntu Cosmetics, Black Rhino Gyms [Image at right], and The Burger Joint & Grill, a fast-food chain, are among the most visible enterprises. Trillion Cart also breeds racing pigeons, a passion of Radebe since he was a child (See, Radebe 2023), and Ankole cattle (African Business Quarterly 2024:15), linking economic activity to African heritage and symbolism.

Leadership within Trillion Cart includes women in prominent positions, such as the president and CEO, balancing the male-centered spiritual authority of TRSH. Members are encouraged to become financially autonomous through distributorships and micro-businesses. The distributorship model is presented as direct selling rather than multi-level marketing, with profits shared equally between the company and distributors. In fact, many members move from distributorships to independent businesses, supported by the African Centre of Excellence, which trains entrepreneurs.

TRSH also sponsors cultural and educational initiatives. The Dr. S.B. Radebe Foundation distributes food and blankets, grants and scholarships, and establishes libraries in African townships. The Trillion Dollar Kids Club promotes financial literacy among children, inspired by Radebe’s own childhood experiences with racing pigeons. Sports clubs, choirs, theatrical troupes, and publishing houses further extend the institution’s reach. In 2023, Radebe was elected African coordinator of the African Forum for Religious and Spiritual Liberty, reflecting his commitment to inter-spiritual dialogue and freedom of religion or belief.

TRSH’s organization is deliberately structured to replicate the spiritual hierarchy in the physical world. Just as IMboni Radebe is regarded as the head of a spiritual nation, so too is he seen as the leader of a physical community. His revelations are presented as of national significance, and he is recognized as the Spiritual Guider of Langalibalele II, the reigning king of the AmaHlubi, Radebe’s ethnic group (African Hidden Voices 2023:90).

The institution’s leadership model thus combines spiritual authority, cultural custodianship, and economic empowerment. It is both hierarchical, with Radebe at the apex, and decentralized, with local leaders managing branches and members encouraged to develop agency and autonomy, including by establishing businesses. This dual structure reflects TRSH’s conviction that spirituality and material life are inseparable, and that empowerment must extend from ritual to economics and from healing to entrepreneurship.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

TRSH has faced scrutiny from South Africa’s Commission for the Promotion and Protection of the Rights of Cultural, Religious and Linguistic Communities (CRL). In 2015, the CRL launched hearings on the commercialization of religion, citing reports of abuses in other groups. Radebe was summoned to present TRSH’s financial records but refused, arguing that the requests violated constitutional protections.

The CRL’s chairperson attempted, unsuccessfully, to have him arrested for contempt. A member of TRSH was jailed for sending a spiritual warning to the chairperson, who felt threatened. Although the CRL proposed legislation requiring all religious organizations to register under umbrella bodies and disclose finances, no such law was enacted. Scholars warned that the proposals risked undermining religious freedom (Mapitsa 2022).

The anti-cult campaign in South Africa reached its zenith in 2017, with CRL releasing a critical report (CRL 2017) and news outlets portraying new religious and spiritual movements as dangerous.

Media coverage during this period depicted TRSH as a powerful and influential institution, often with suspicion. Critics argued that TRSH’s integration of spirituality and commerce risks exploitation, while supporters insisted it offers opportunities otherwise denied to marginalized communities.

Despite controversies, TRSH continues to expand, balancing criticism with enthusiastic support from members who see TRSH as a source of healing, empowerment, and pride in African identity.

The challenges faced by TRSH thus reflect broader tensions in South Africa and, more generally, across Africa. TRSH positions itself as both defender of AIS and innovator in business, a combination that attracts both admiration and hostility. In the words of an early scholar of TRSH, Matthew Wilhelm-Solomon, which we believe are still valid today, Radebe’s institution is successful, particularly in Southern Africa’s problematic megalopolises, because “it speaks to a hope that the failed aspirations of the city can be restored, that its pollutants can be cleansed, and that the people and things lost in its streets will return safely home, wherever that may be” (Wilhelm-Solomon 2013:52).

IMAGES

Image #1: IMboni iNkosi YamaKhosi oMoya Radebe. Courtesy of The Revelation Spiritual Home.
Image #2: A local TRSH leader showing the location of Radebe’s vision at the Vaal River. (All photos by the authors except #1).
Image #3: TRSH leader Thembi Tulwana at the basement in Johannesburg where some of the first services of The Revelation Church of God were held in 2009.
Image #4: Inside the former Grand Synagogue of Johannesburg, now a TRSH spiritual center.
Image #5: TRSH members and co-author Rosita Šorytė at Ekuphumuleni Mountain in December 2024.
Image #6: Credo Mutwa’s daughter shows the authors her father’s sanctuary in Soweto, November 2024.
Image #7: The Izibane lamps.
Image #8: Radebe during a “Service of Enlightenment,” January 2023.
Image #9: TRSH members during a “Service of Enlightenment,” January 2023.
Image #10: A tent housing overflow members during a service at the Soweto Branch, January 2023.
Image #11: Booth promoting Black Rhino Gyms at a TRSH event in Cape Town, December 2023.

REFERENCES

African Business Quarterly [unsigned]. 2024. “Trillion: Creating Sustainable Opportunities for All South Africans.” African Business Quarterly 18:14–17.

African Hidden Voices. 2024. Restoring Africa’s Spiritual Identity. Johannesburg: Isambulo Publications.

African Hidden Voices. 2023. An Introduction into Afrikan Indigenous Spirituality. Johannesburg: Isambulo Publications.

Chidester, David. 2002. “Credo Mutwa, Zulu Shaman: The Invention and Appropriation of Indigenous Authenticity in African Folk Religion.” Journal for the Study of Religion 15:65–85. DOI: 10.4314/jsr.v15i2.6128.

CRL Rights Commission. 2017. Report of the Hearings on the Commercialisation of Religion and Abuse of People’s Belief Systems. Johannesburg: CRL Rights Commission.

du Toit, Brian Murray. 1971. “Religious Revivalism among Urban Zulu.” Pp. 80–103 in Man: Anthropological Essays Presented to O. F. Raum, edited by Eben Jansen de Jager. Cape Town: C. Struik.

du Toit, Brian Murray. 1970. “Emakhehleni—A Revivalistic Cult.” Pp. 42–58 in Culture Change in Contemporary Africa, edited by Brian Murray du Toit. Gainesville, FL: African Studies Center, University of Florida.

Introvigne, Massimo, and Rosita Šorytė. 2025. The Revelation Spiritual Home: The Revival of African Indigenous Spirituality. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Malcomess, Bettina, and Matthew Wilhelm-Solomon. 2016. “Valleys of Salt in the House of God: Religious Re-territorialisation and Urban Space.” Pp. 31–60 in Routes and Rites to the City: Mobility, Diversity, and Religious Space in Johannesburg, edited by Matthew Wilhelm-Solomon, Lorena Núñez, Peter Kankonde Bukasa, and Bettina Malcomess. London: Palgrave Macmillan.

Mapitsa, Cosmo. 2022. “Freedom by Regulation: A Legal Assessment of the CRL Commission’s Report on the Commercialisation of Religion and Abuse of People’s Belief Systems.” Religion & Development 1:58–72. DOI: 10.30965/27507955-20220004.

Radebe, Samuel. 2023. Trillion Dollar Kids: Savings & Entrepreneurship for Children. Johannesburg: Isambulo Publications.

Radebe, Samuel. 2022. The Revelation of Imboni. Johannesburg: Isambulo Publications.

Radebe, Samuel, and Palesa Hloele. 2022. Iintsebenzo zeSambulo. Johannesburg: Isambulo Publications.

SABC News. 2024. “Theatre—‘The Spirit King’ and the Revival of African Spirituality: Mbongeni Moroke.” April 21. Accessed from www.youtube.com/watch?v=1qSdxWP4v8c on 5 January 2026.

van Wyk, Ilana. 2014. The Universal Church of the Kingdom of God in South Africa: A Church of Strangers. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Wilhelm-Solomon, Matthew. 2013. “Prophets of the City.” Pp. 39–52 in Writing Invisibility: Conversations on the Hidden City, edited by Jackee Budesta Batanda, Caroline Wanjiku Kihato, and Matthew Wilhelm-Solomon. Johannesburg: Mail & Guardian.

Wilhelm-Solomon, Matthew, Melekias Zulu, and Eric Worby. 2016. “Angels and Ancestors: Prophetic Mobility and Diversity in the City.” Pp. 239–271 in Routes and Rites to the City: Mobility, Diversity, and Religious Space in Johannesburg, edited by Matthew Wilhelm-Solomon, Lorena Núñez, Peter Kankonde Bukasa, and Bettina Malcomess. London: Palgrave Macmillan.

 

Share

Process Church of the Final Judgement

PROCESS CHURCH OF THE FINAL JUDGEMENT TIMELINE

1931:  Mary Ann MacLean was born in Glasgow, Scotland.

1935:  Robert Moor was born in Shanghai, China.

1961:  MacLean joined Scientology.

1962:  Moor joined Scientology.

1963:  Moor and MacLean left Scientology and started their own group, Compulsion Analysis.

1965:  Compulsion Analysis changed its name to the Process, and Moor and MacLean changed their last names to de Grimston.

1966:  Around thirty Processans moved to the Bahamas, and later the same year Xtul, Mexico where they received more messages from a collective called the Beings.

1966:  After surviving the Hurricane Inez the Process returned to England.

1967:  Robert de Grimston started to formalize Processean theology and the teachings of the Great Gods.

1967:  The Process was incorporated in New Orleans as the Process Church of the Final Judgment.

1969 (August 9-10):  The Tate-LaBianca murders were committed on the orders of Charles Manson. The Process became connected to Manson, although no supporting evidence existed.

1969:  The Process published the Fear and Death issue of their magazine, which contained a letter from Charles Manson.

1971:  The Love issue of the Process magazine was published, signifying a change in theology. Further, the Process uniform was changed to appear less Satanic.

1971:  Ed Sanders published The Family about the Manson murder, implicating the Process. The publishers were successfully sued by the Process in the U.S.

1974:  The de Grimstons divorced, Robert was expelled, and his teachings were no longer used. The same year the organization changed its name to the Foundation Church of the Millenium.

1978:  William S. Bainbridge published Satan’s Power: A Deviant Psychotherapy Cult

1982:  The Foundation moved to Utah and started an animal sanctuary.

1987:  Terry Marury published The Ultimate Evil: An Investigation Into a Dangerous Satanic Cult. The book claimed a connection between the Son of Sam-killer David Berkowitz, the Process Church, and a non-existing off shot called the Four Ps.

1993:  The Foundation formally became the Best Friends Animal Sanctuary.

1996:  Skinny Puppy released The Process.

2005:  Mary Ann died.

2015:  Sympathy for the Devil, a documentary about the Process was released.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

The Process was the creation of Robert and Mary Ann de Grimston. Born as Robert Moor (1935) and Mary Ann MacLean (1931), they had meet through the Church of Scientology in 1962. Mary Ann had joined in 1961, was an apt student, and the same year became an auditor. Robert joined in 1962 and soon meet Mary Ann who became his auditor. The couple left Scientology in 1963 and married the same year. During this period, they had gathered a small group of mainly young and wealthy members and started their own practice, Compulsion Analysis, a form of therapy based on Dianetics that used E-meters, later renamed P-meters (Wyllie 2009:27-28). Originally there was little spiritual or religious in their sessions, and they seemed to focus more on personal therapy and development. As they used methods and the E-meter without approval from the Church of Scientology, Robert and Mary Ann were declared “Suppressive Persons” by L. Ron Hubbard in 1965 (Wylie 2009:19).

In 1965, after having increasingly spiritual experiences in group sessions with Compulsion Analysis, the name was changed to The Process. Robert and Mary Ann also took on more religious roles, with Robert being named “the Teacher” and Mary Ann “The Oracle.” There were, however, no references to the three Great Gods that l would later become the central teaching of the Process. The same year, Robert and Mary Ann changed their surname from Moor to de Grimston. The spiritual aspects became more prominent, with members claiming to have joint telepathic experiences in the sessions and experiencing traumas from previous lives, a practice also found in Scientology (Wylde 2009:28). The first mention of the Process in the media appeared in the magazine Isis in February 1966, and we also find the first response from the Process there. Isis is a student publication at the University of Oxford, a population from which they sought to attract members. The article, reproduced in Alessandro Papas’s The Process: Archives, Documents, Reflections and Revelations, shows that there are Apocalyptic ideas present even at this stage, although the focus is on psychology. The article ends with calling for people to join and contribute to the “possible survival of the human race.” (Papa 2020:13). During this period, a growing group of mostly young and affluent people had started to gather around the de Grimston’s, but it was never a large group, with only around fifty members at this stage.

In 1966, the situation in London started to become more problematic, and there was an increase in pressure from media and concerned parents of the members. One magazine published an article calling them “the Mindbenders of Mayfair.” The parents of one of the new members, who at the time was only seventeen, threatened to file a lawsuit against them. All this trouble, and adding the increasingly religious aspects of the teachings, lead to a decision to abandon London and move abroad. According to former member Timothy Wyllie (1940-2017), the intention was to leave England and never return. There was no clear idea of where they would go, but, according to Wyllie, the members, numbering around thirty people, gave all their possessions to the Process to sell off in order to fund the move. The group first ended up at Nassau, Bahamas. In Nassau, the sessions continued to become increasingly focused on spiritual matters. The group started to get into contact with a collective of entities, “non-corporeal intelligences.” They were at first called “The Beings” and they appeared in their group meditations (Wyllie 2009:38). The communications with the Beings increased and lead to a decision to move on from the Bahamas. Some members left during this period and the group was now only around twenty-five people. After traveling to Mexico, they moved further away from the urban areas.

The small group ultimately traveled to Xtul a village in Mexico’s Yucatán region. Members moved into an abandoned salt factory where they lived collectively. The communication with the Beings continued and lead to “The Dialogues from Xtul” (de Grimston in Wyllie 2009:265). These communications constituted the foundation of what later would become the teachings of the Process. Later, seven dialogues were published based on communications with the Beings, which now were called The Unity of Xtul. The dialogues were often complex, with most dealing with GOD and the separation and unity of the conscious and unconscious. There is a sense of mankind being in error but nothing explicitly apocalyptic. Life in Xtul was by all descriptions difficult, and the group experienced a lot of hardship. Especially significant for the development of the Process was hurricane Inez, which hit Yucatán and lasted for three days (Wyllie 2009:46-47). The group survived and saw this event as evidence that the gods were protecting them and that they had a cosmic mission. The Xtul experience would later form a central part of Process inner lore and was the start of the theology about the Great Gods. However, the hurricane left their dwellings demolished, and the group decided to return to London. Indeed, at the end of 1966 the members of the Process were back in London. The Process was now developing quickly. Robert and Mary Ann were now starting to call themselves Omega, which became the highest degree in the Process. It was during this period that the ideas about the three Gods, Satan, Jehovah, and Lucifer, and the unity of Christ started to develop. One indication of how Satan had now become a part of the Process is that the Process started a coffee shop called Satan’s Cavern to attract new members. The theological ideas about the unity of opposites, like Christ and Satan, as well as the gods of the universe seems to have been developed by Robert de Grimston primarily.  When the Process later split up in 1974 and Robert de Grimston was expelled, these teachings were discarded as no longer valid. Now the Process had a clear agenda and a religious framework through  which to work. Different degrees and requirements also were developed during this period.

Seeing greater potential in the United States, de Grimston with a few of the more dedicated members moved there in 1967. That same year, the Process was incorporated as a religious entity, the Process Church of the Final Judgement, in New Orleans. The group started to form chapters in cities in both America and Canada. The Process uniforms attracted public attention during this period as they consisted of a black robe with a cross and a goat head-medallion (which represented the unity of opposites). The Process also gained visibility by traveling with large Asatian dogs. Yet, despite its active recruiting and high visibility, the Process always remained a small organization, with at most a few hundred members (Gregorius 2023:190). The level of communal dedication and financial obligation required of full-time members certainly were factors in the movement’s small size. With chapters now established both in North America and Europe, the late 1960’s was the height of the activities of the Process and the most productive period regarding publication of its teachings. While Robert was the primary theologian and the group’s public face, most of the control resided with Mary Ann.

The movement’s fortunes changed dramatically in 1974 when Robert and Mary Ann divorced. The divorce resulted in the expulsion of Robert from the Process. Mary Ann also changed the name of the organization to the Foundation Church, and the teachings about the four gods were rejected. Instead, the Foundation became a movement focused only on Jehovah and later became more mainstream Christian. During these turbulent times most of the members left the Process. Robert made several attempts to restart the Process, but none proved successful. After a final attempt in 1979, he moved to Staten Island and ceased to make any public appearances or respond to any inquires (Papa 2020:200).

Mary Ann continued her group, now as the Foundation Faith of the Millenium, and moved to Utah in 1982 where the group founded an animal sanctuary called Best Friends. In 1993, the last remains of the Foundation were dissolved and it became Best Friends Animal Sanctuary, with no religious references. Best Friends has over the years developed into the largest no-kill animal sanctuaries in the United States. The history of the group is only occasionally brought up in media exposes. There is no indication of any spiritual or religious remains from the Process in the Best Friends Animal Sanctuary, although the view of animals is consistent with what could be found in the Process. Mary Ann died in 2005.

While the Process Church itself was small and short lived, it has continued to serve as an inspiration for later forms of occulture and Satanism. The band American Sabbath Assembly used the Process Church as a central inspiration, especially the first two of their albums Restored to One (2010), and Ye are Gods (2012). The group used lyrics from the Process Church sung to psychedelic metal music and included recordings from former member Timothy Wyllie, as well as Genesis P’Orridge. Several Facebook-groups have been dedicated to the Process, some include former members who are more open to talk about their experiences today. In Italy, a small museum was opened that was dedicated to the Process by Alessandro Papa, who also founded New Processean Order in 2014. Papa also made a recording Hymns to the Great Gods of the Universe in connection with the founding of his order.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

While the doctrines of the Process would change over the existence of the organization, at its core the doctrines remained the same, creating a theology that was a mix of countercultural suspicion for mainstream society, Millenarianism, Scientology, and Esotericism. At the core was the doctrine of the gods and their people. The Process taught that each person is ruled by one of three gods, Satan, Lucifer, and Jehovah, with Christ as the unifier. Later in the early 1970’s, Christ would become part of a quaternity with Satan, Jehovah, and Lucifer adding a larger focus on unity of opposites.

The three Great Gods dominate each of us and reflect our personalities (De Grimston 1970:7):

CONSCIOUSLY or unconsciously, apathetically, half-heartedly, enthusiastically or fanatically, under countless other names than those by which we know Them, and under innumerable disguises and descriptions, men have followed the three Great  Gods of the Universe ever since the Creation. Each one according to his nature. For the three Gods represent three basic human patterns of reality. Within the framework of each pattern there are countless variations and permutations, widely varying grades of suppression and intensity. Yet each one represents a fundamental problem, a deep-rooted driving force, a pressure of instincts and desires, terrors and revulsions. All three of them exist to some extent in every one of us. But each of us leans more heavily towards one of them, whilst the pressures of the other two provide the presence of conflict and uncertainty.The goal is to identify more fully with the god that is the essence of one’s personality. When entering the Process, a new member would become an Advocate for one of the gods, like Advocate for Satan and interpret the world and the teachings of the Process from that viewpoint. The aim was to become purer in one’s identity as a Satanist, Luciferian or Jehovian, as a way of separating from humanity.

In the 1970 book The Gods and their Peoples, the nature and path of the gods are presented (De Grimston 1970: 9):

SATAN: Lust, Abandon, Violence, Excess, Indulgence: SUB-HUMANITY
LUCIFER: Enjoyment, Permissiveness, Harmony, Success, Satisfaction: HUMANITY
JEHOVAH: Duty, Discipline, Struggle, Sacrifice, Self-denial: HUMANITY
SATAN: Detachment, Mysticism, Otherworldliness, Magic, Asceticism: SUPER-HUMANITY.

Christ is the emissary of the gods here, the link between humanity and the gods and beyond the Great Gods, and their transcendence. The different paths represented by the gods are not simply ideals but also represent negative aspects that a person must work with and learn to control. Based on one’s personality, one of the three gods would be chosen.

The Jehovian is presented as one of the harshest paths. Jehovah is a god of war and battle and demands total devotion of his followers. It is a stern and ascetic path. In de Grimston’s words, Jehovah is done with his creation and is preparing for the end (De Grimston 1970:20-21):

JEHOVAH has watched man set out to destroy himself by disobeying every commandment that JEHOVAH gave him. And He knows that the End has come. The game is almost over for His creation. He seeks now to preserve only the few who still remain His people; the remnant who are loyal to Him and have followed Him through the Valley of the Shadow of Death.

And of these He demands nothing less than total dedication. He demands a link so strong and so direct that nothing can break it. He demands no deviation from His rigid laws. He demands pain and suffering; expiation to the full for every sin.

Even in future presentations of Jehovah from the Process the focus is on devotion and asceticism and suffering to reach God. In “What are the Gods” from the 1971 Process-magazine on Love, Jehovah’s pattering is presented as “drive, determination, courage, endurance, will-power, self-discipline, self-denial, self-sacrifice” (Process 2023, Volume 2). In the material from the late 1960’s, Jehovah is presented using male pronouns, but later in the 1970’s feminine pronouns are used as Jehovah now is part of a binary with Lucifer.

In contrast, the path of the Luciferian was one of enjoyment and a positive view of existence and nature. Lucifer is taught as a god of Light, and it is only by mistake that Lucifer has been identified with Satan. The Luciferian enjoys success, beauty, and harmony. This is the most positive of the gods apart from Christ. Lucifer is a god of life, of nature, and in contrast to Jehovah sees the world as positive. About Lucifer Robert de Grimston writes  (De Grimston 1970):

He believes in success and the enjoyment of success. He believes in comfort and the enjoyment of comfort. He clings to the concept of basic human goodness. He loves the world and the people of the world, and his greatest wish is that all men should love one another, that men should live at peace, that there should be no strife or violence, no ill feeling, no conflict, only a soft and gentle harmony.
This is the Luciferian ideal. This is the star that the Luciferian follows; man at peace with himself and his fellow man; man at one with the world in which he lives.

The Process Church’s use of the term Luciferian seems to be one of the earliest examples of the term being used as a self-identification, also as totally separated from Satanism. Lucifer always has male pronouns and is later set as opposed to Jehovah.

Satan is the third God and one of the more complex. Satan exists as both a higher form (represented by the serpent) and a lower (represented by the goat). The satanist path is for that reason one of extremes and has a higher and lower pattern. Satan is a duality and leads his people to either a state below or above human (De Grimston 1970:58).

SATAN is the ultimate of all things. He is the End and the Ultimate Destruction. Equally He is the Beginning and the Ultimate Creation. He spans the Universe – in Time. He is both the Beginning and the End; the God of Ultimate Destruction and the God of Ultimate Creation. And His two poles are separated by the presence of the Universal Mind that fills the Universe with conflict.

The Satanist is both a person who indulges in all his desires, and violence, and the god of the mystic, a god of ascetics. Satan exists in both poles and so does the Satanist who stands outside all of humanity and its rules. Of all the gods, Satan is the most complex and controversial as taught by the Process. In later teachings Satan would be presented as female, as opposed and united with the male Christ.

Above all is Christ, who at first is seen as an emissary and unifier of the Great Gods, but not a pattern for individual humans. Later, in the early 1970’s, this changes, and Christ is seen as a pattern, although the focus is on his role as unifier. In the 1970’s, more focus is placed on the unity of opposites, and the unity of Christ and Satan becomes central, expressed in one of the Process most famous statements that would be reprinted several times in their magazine The Process from the 1970’s onward. It also was part of the preface to The Gods and their People, meaning the idea was not completely novel (De Grimston 1970:2; Process 2023):

Christ said: Love your enemies.
Christ’s Enemy was Satan and Satan’s Enemy was CHRIST.
Through Love enmity is destroyed.
Through Love saint and sinner destroy the enmity between them.
Through Love Christ and Satan have destroyed their enmity and come together for the End;
Christ to judge and Satan to execute the Judgement.
The Judgement is Wisdom; the execution of the Judgement is Love.

This unity will then lead to the end, but what is the end. This is often unclear. In the early forms there seems to be some indication that there is a possibility of survival for a select few, but later it is expressed more as an inevitable doom. De Grimston writes in As it is:

Humanity is doomed! If we are part of humanity, identified with humanity, in sympathy with humanity, we are doomed.
If we attempt to save humanity from its doom, we shall fail, because humanity has chosen its doom and has shown its unwillingness to reverse its choice. Our only valid course of action is to detach from humanity, climb out of the quagmire of its lies, its hypocrisy, its blind desire for its own destruction, find our own truth and create our own destiny.

Human existence is presented as being part of the Game, which is another term used frequently by the Process. This is a term drawn directly from L. Ron Hubbard and the Church of Scientology. The Universal Game is beyond human control, but we can choose in the human or personal game how we act and take responsibility for our actions. The rule of the game is the rules of existence, of life itself (Papa 2020:91). As we can’t change those rules and have no way of changing the game of the gods, the end cannot be avoided. As in most Millenarian movements, there is a promise of the birth of a New Age and a New World, but how this will look is rather vague. In the Gods on War the end offers hope for a select group (De Grimston in Propaganda 2022:156):

Humanity as a whole will not rise above its conflicts. Even if it were to do so it would still destroy all the physical, social and moral structures which it has created, because it would see their total invalidity. But it will not; so the destruction will take place in a chaos and confusion of ignorance, with the vast majority still clinging desperately to their hollow materialistic dreams, even in the depths of their final despair; whilst the few who do rise above the conflicts, will stand aside, separated from the mass, united not within but without the man-made structures of the human game, and linked to a new reality founded not on the laws of men but on the Laws of GOD.

We see a form of anti-humanism in the text by the Process, which often would emphasize the destructive and sadistic nature of humanity. It is also expressed in their anti-vivisectionist stance and animal rights politics. This can be exemplified in their booklet The Ultimate Sin that states ”Animal vivisection is the blackest of all sins. And for the blackest of sins there awaits the blackest of all retributions” (quoted in Papa 2020:61). Most of humanity is seen as being beyond redemption and under the control of what the Process labels “the Grey forces.”

Grey forces are the antagonists, and a representation of materialism and social convenience. Being part of them is to allow the Game to be played without control, and to settle for convenience. This is also one of the reasons for the focus on extremism within the Process. To separate from humanity, from the Grey, a person must embrace the extremes. This led to the Process printing magazines with positive references both to Communism and Nazism, neither representing a political ideal, but rather both representing extremes that was preferable to the middle position. The concept of the Grey forces is a clear example of the Process connection to1960’s and 1970’s subculture and a rejection of mainstream society. In the sex-issue of The Process magazine the Grey forces are personified by a psychiatrist, here similar to Scientology in its rejection of psychiatry (Papa 2020:128).

RITUALS/PRACTICES

There is a limited Process background within Scientology as their practices often have included therapy sessions like Dianetics and they originally used an E-meter, later called a P-meter. In contrast to Dianetics, however, most of the sessions seem to have been conducted as group sessions.

As the Process developed there was increased focus on religious practice, and the group developed rituals for occasions such as weddings, baptisms, and initiations. Central was a ceremony called the Sabbath Assembly that occurred on Saturday and was open to non-members. Assemblies were also held in the morning. On some days events called “meditations” were held (at midnight); they had as their aim the resolution of inner tensions, and they were often conducted in a call and response form. One of the most important of these meditations was the “healing mediation” (Papa 2020:158-60).

Life in the communes was often strictly regulated, and, apart from assemblies and meditations, the focus of activity was on various ways of getting the message out, like selling the Process magazine (Process 2023).

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

The Process was constructed as a strict hierarchical organization with the de Grimstons as the supreme leaders who appropriated the Omegas degree for themselves only. (Image at right) While there were some changes over the years, the church maintained nine degrees. Below the Omegas, were Master, Superior (in some early documents Priest), and Prophet, Inside Processean Messenger, Outside Processean Messenger, Disciple, Initiate, and Acolyte (Papa 2020:94).

A person became an Acolyte by addressing a superior member at the open Sabbath Assemblies. Being an Acolyte was a type of trial membership, and to advance to the degree of Initiate the Acolyte had to complete two meditations on Christ and Satan and perform a twenty-four hour fast. After becoming an Initiate, which also took place at the Sabbath Assembly, a person was a beginning, but formal, member. To become a Disciple required more commitment and courses, and the ceremony was performed as a baptism. Each successive degree required more substantial commitment (Papa 2020:94-96).

New members were expected to practice celibacy and abstain from all drugs and alcohol, although these rules were not always enforced. Men and women were separated and lived in separate quarters. William Bainbridge, as well as former members, have written that formal rules were more ideal than actual practice (Bainbridge 1978).

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Through its history the Process encountered a variety of challenges. From the start, the Process faced negative press coverage. Parents of legal minors also sought to press charges against the group, a development that led to the group leaving England in 1966. There were early accusations about exploitive financial practices (Wyllie 2009:35). Former members have reported maltreatment of children. Despite later conspiratorial ideas, such as those presented by Terry Maury in Ultimate Evil: An Investigation of America’s Most Dangerous Satanic Cul (1987), there has been no convincing evidence of abuse. However, as is discussed in the 1968 documentary, Sympathy for the Devil: The True Story of the Process Church of the Final Judgment (2015), there was considerable negligence.

There were two primary problems that plagued the Process and ultimately led to its demise more directly, its alleged connection to Satanism and its organizational schism. With respect to the first, there was growing suspicion and social pressure against alternative communities and spirituality following the Tate–LaBianca murders in Los Angeles on August 9-10, 1969. The shocking murders were planned and ordered by Charles Manson and carried out by his followers (referred to as the Family in media reports). The murders created a darker picture of the flower-power movement and became one of the most culturally significant events of that era, as well as an inspiration for the growth of the emerging anti-cult movement. An organization using satanic symbols and predicting an impending Apocalypse that would end most of humanity combined with written material expressing a disdain for humanity was problematic enough, but The Process was closely connected to the Manson Family in a variety of public sources.

In 1971, author Ed Sanders published The Family: The Story of Charles Manson’s Dune Buggy Attack Battalion, examining the Manson murders and claiming a connection between Charles Manson and The Process Church. The Process responded by suing Sanders. Even though litigation was ultimately unsuccessful, later editions of the book in the United States were required to remove the contested chapter, and the remaining copies had to be sold with a disclaimer about the book’s portrayal of the Process.

The prosecutor in the Manson case, Vincent Buglioso, claimed a connection between Manson and The Process in his 1974 book Helter Skelter: The True Story of the Manson Murders, even though he also argued that Manson was inspired by the teachings of the Process more than the organization. As (Bainbridge 1978:145) reported, however, it is more likely that Manson and the Process had simply been attracted to similar ideas that were characteristic of the late 1960’s counterculture (Bainbridge 1978:146).

During the 1980s, Satanic Panic (Hicks 1991; Richardson, Best and Bromley 1991), Terry Maury, a journalist, published The Ultimate Evil: An Investigation into America’s Most Dangerous Satanic Cult (1987), a sensationalist book that made the unsubstantiated claim that the Son of Sam-killer, Dan Berkowitz was a member of a secret Satanic cult that was an offshoot of the Process Church. The alleged connection was repeated the following year in Arthur Lyons’ Satan Wants You (1988). In 2021, Netflix released a limited series The Sons of Sam: A Descent into Darkness! based on Maury’s book, that uncritically supported the narrative of The Ultimate Evil.

REFERENCES

Abrahamsson, Carl. 2024. Meetings with Remarkable Magicians: Life in the Occult Underground. Rochester: Inner Traditions.

Bainbridge, William S. 1978. Satan’s Power: A Deviant Psychotherapy Cult. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Buglosi, Victor. 1974. Helter Skelter: The True Story of the Manson Murders.

De Grimston, Robert. 1970. The Gods and Their People. Chicago: Process Church of the Final Judgment, Chicago Chapter.

Gregorius, Fredrik. 2023. The Process Church of the Final Judgement: excerpts from “The Gods on War” (1967) & “The Gods and Their People” (1970). Pp. 187-91 in Satanism: A Reader, edited by Per Faxneld and Johan Nilsson. New York: Oxford University Press.

Hicks, Robert D. 1991. In Pursuit of Satan: The Police and the Occult. New York: Prometheus Books.

Hubbard, L. Ron. 2007. Dianetics; The Modern Science of Mental Health. Los Angeles: Bridge Publications.

Laycock, Joseph P. 2020.Speak of the Devil: How The Satanic Temple is Changing the Way We Talk about Religion. New York: Oxford University Press.

Luijk, Ruben van. 2016. Children of Lucifer: The Origins of Modern Religious Satanism. New York: Oxford University Press.

Lyons, Arthur. 1988. Satan Wants You: The Cult of Devil Worship in America. New York: The Mysterious Press.

Maury, Terry. 2021. Ultimate Evil : The Search for the Sons of Sam. Philadelphia: Quirk Books.

Maury, Terry. 1987. Ultimate Evil: An Investigation of America’s Most Dangerous Satanic Cult. Dolphin Books.

Papa, Alessandro. 2020. The Process: Archives, Documents, Reflections and Revelation. Rome: End of Kali Yuga-Productions.

Process: Complete Collection vol1. 2022. Rome: End of Kali Yuga-Productions.

Process: Complete Collection, Volume 2. 2023. Rome: End of Kali Yuga-Productions.

Propaganda and Holy Writ of the Process Church of the Final Judgment. 2022. Port Townsend: Feral House.

Richardson, James, Joel Best, and David Bromley, eds. 1991. The Satanism Scare. New York: Routledge.

Sanders, Ed. 1971. The Family: The Story of Charles Manson’s Dune Buggy Attack Battalion. New York: E.P. Dutton.

The Process Church of the Final Judgment Documents. Accessed December 18, 2025. http://www.mediafire.com/download/5uzb4rk44g4puy6/The-Process-Church-of-the-Final-Judgment-Documents.pdf .

Sympathy for the Devil?  2015. Accessed September 21, 2025. http://www.theprocessmovie.com/.

Urban, Hugh B. 2011. The Church of Scientology: A History of a New Religion. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Wyllie, Timothy. 2009. Love, Sex, Fear, Death: The Inside Story of the Process Church of the Final Judgment. Port Townsend: Feral House, 2009.

Publication Date:
5 January 2026

 

Share

Yogaville

YOGAVILLE TIMELINE

1914:  Sri Swami Satchidananda was born in Tamil Nadu, South India.

1947-1964:  Satchidananda met and studied under Sri Swami Sivanandaji for seventeen years.

1966:  Satchidananda traveled to New York City.

1966 (October):  The first Integral Yoga Institution (IYI) was established in New York City.

1969:  Satchinananda addressed the crowd at the Woodstock Music Festival.

1970s:  The initial rumors of sexual abuse of disciples by Satchinanada emerged.

1972:  Yogaville-West was established in Seigler Springs, California.

1973:  Yogaville-East was established in Pomfret Center, Connecticut and became IYI headquarters.

1976:  Satchidananda became a U.S. citizen.

1979 (September):  IYI was gifted a parcel of land in Connecticut that was sold to acquire 600 acres of land Buckingham County, Virginia which became Satchidananda Ashram-Yogaville (SAYVA).

1979-1986:  Light of Truth Universal Shrine (LOTUS) was constructed in Buckingham, Virginia at SAYVA.

1986 (July):  A dedication ceremony was held for LOTUS, and SAYVA became the IYI headquarters.

2002:  Satchidananda died in his home region of Tamil Nadu, South India.

2024:  A civil lawsuit was filed in New York alleging that Integral Yoga and Yogaville were negligent in failing to protect members from Satchiyananda’s ongoing sexual abuse.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Sri Swami Satchidananda was born as Ramaswamy Grounder in Tamil Nadu, South India on December 22, 1914. He was one of two sons born to Kalyanasundaram Gounder and his wife, Srimati Velammai, a prosperous Hindu couple (Perringer n.d.). His early adult life was quite secular in nature. He graduated from an agricultural school and worked in the automotive industry before becoming a manager in the National Electric Works. In the hagiographic account of his life, however, Swami Satchidananda is described as having been intensely spiritual from childhood: “Even as a young child, he spoke truths and displayed insights far beyond his years. His devotion to God was strong, and he looked at people of all castes and faiths with an equal eye, always recognizing the same light within every being” (Perringer n.d.) While working as the manager of a Hindu temple, Grounder met and married his wife, and the couple gave birth to two children. However, five years later his wife died suddenly. Following his wife’s death, Grounder renounced the world and began his spiritual career at age twenty-eight.

In order to become disciplined in yoga, Grounder secluded himself for several years before traveling around India to study under various gurus. After studying under several spiritual figures, including Sri Ramakrishna, and Ramana Maharshi. Grounder met Sri Swami Sivananda in the foothills of the Himalayas in 1947; the Swami initiated him into the Holy Order of Sannyas and gave him his spiritual name, Swami Satchidananda (divine bliss). Satchidanada studied with Sivananda for seventeen years. Due to his mastery of all branches of yoga, Satchidananda was given the title “Yogiraj,” master of yoga. Sivanandaji sent Satchidananda to Ceylon (present day Sri Lanka) to spread Sivanandaji’s teachings. He lectured across India and established yoga centers in Sri Lanka, Hong Kong, Japan, Malaysia, Singapore, and the Philippines (Meadows and Hadden 2002:646).

Satchidananda met filmmaker Conrad Rooks and artist Peter Max in India while the two were filming the now cult classic film Chappaqu in 1965. Satchidananda made a cameo appearance in the film, and Rooks and Max invited Satchidananda to New York City the following year. Although initially planned as a two day visit, Satchidananda attracted hundreds of followers resulting in an extended stay in New York City.

The first Integral Yoga Institute was founded in New York City on October 7, 1996. Six years later in 1972, Yogaville-West was established in Seigler Springs, California to provide a community for those who practiced Integral Yoga. Following closely behind Yogaville-West, Yogaville-East was founded in 1973 in Pomfret Center, Connecticut. Yogaville-East served as IYI headquarters for ten years.

In 1978 vocalist Carole King (Karuna King) gave Satchidanada a large tract of land in Connecticut. Satchidanada sold the land the following year to purchase a 650 acre tract in Buckingham County, Virginia. (Image at right) It was in Buckingham County that construction began on the Light of Truth Universal Shrine (LOTUS) at the new Satchidananda Ashram-Yogaville (SAYVA). LOTUS is described as a temple for all world religions where one can find the Spirit that unites everything. LOTUS held a dedication ceremony on July 20, 1986, after which SAYVA became the new headquarters for IYI.

Satchidananda continued to travel the world giving lectures to promote religious harmony. He “left his body” (Mahasamadhi) on August 19, 2002 as a result of a brain aneurysm while visiting his home region of Tamil Nadu, South India.

BELIEFS/DOCTRINES

Yoga is conventionally divided into six paths or traditions, with over fifteen million practitioners in the United States, but numerous other schools have developed out of these six traditions (Cook 1999-2000). Hatha Yoga, which first opened a center in San Francisco in 1955, became the most popular branch of Yoga, using physical postures (Asanas), regulated breathing (Pranayama) and meditation (Dharana). Karma Yoga emphasizes selflessness and service to eliminate attachment to the material results of the practitioner’s actions. Bhakti Yoga uses repetitive sounds or words (mantras) in order to surrender the self, identify with a higher self and experience the divine in all of creation. Raja Yoga uses deep meditation to create stillness and focused control over the mind that allows the emergence of the practitioner’s higher self. Jnama Yoga emphasizes the development of the intellect and study of yogic scriptures combined with deep meditation that promotes an unfolding of the “surface mind” and understanding of the Ultimate.

Kim (2006) describes Integral Yoga as rooted in Hatha Yoga, but Integral Yoga presents itself as a synthesis of the hatha, karma, bhaki, raja, and jnana traditions (Meadows and Hadden 2002:646). Satchidananda understands Integral Yoga as a scientific method for integrating both the various branches of Yoga and the mental, physical and spiritual aspects of the individual. Integral Yoga is therefore more than religion. In Satchidananda’s view, “Integral Yoga is the basis of all religions, not a religion itself” (Ma 1980:24). Put another way, “Yoga is not a religion, but embodies the essence of ethical perfection that is the foundation of all religions” (Ma 1980:23). Satchidananda acknowledges that “We do teach religion, but not as it is usually taught. That is, we teach the basic principles which are common to every religion” (Ma 1980 24). He is often quoted as stating that “Truth Is One, Paths Are Many.”

However Integral Yoga is categorized, Satchidanada teaches that most individuals operate only with their “surface minds” and therefore never realize their full spiritual potential. The objective of Integral Yoga is to facilitate individuals’ quest for self knowledge (Sadhana). What impedes individual progress toward Sadhana is imperfect or selfish actions. Practitioners are taught to understand that they are completely responsible for their actions and to engage in selfless service. As Satchidananda has put it, “Wherever you are, whatever you are doing, do it for the benefit of others (Ma 1980:19). When practitioners complete the quest for self knowledge, they recognize that all living things are connected in One Spirit. Because One Spirit is broadly conceived, Integral Yoga can be practiced within a multitude of religious and spiritual frameworks based on the belief that the One Spirit unites all faiths. The belief that all living beings are part of One Spirit led Satchidanada to disavow inequality. As he has put it, “No person is an untouchable. Differences come, not with the work one does nor the caste into which one is born, but with the state of mind. Essentially we are all one and the same. All are God’s children.” (Perringer n.d.)

The term integral yoga can legitimately be applied to any spiritual path based upon the synthesis of multiple yoga traditions. There are two main schools of thought and practice of integral yoga, one established under Sri Aurobindo and the other established under Sri Satchidananda. Followers of Satchidananda have trademarked the name Integral Yoga in the United States.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

The degree of involvement in Integral Yoga varies among practitioners. Some individuals choose to only take weekly classes at the closest center, institute, or ashram while others choose to live within the Yogaville communities. The headquarters for Integral Yoga, SAYVA , offers courses, retreats, special seminars, and internships. A typical retreat package offers various choices of accommodations within onsite dormitories, private rooms, or camping. Also included are three buffet style vegetarian meals as practitioners of Integral Yoga practice non-violence toward all beings. Additionally, daily yoga, meditation, and scripture classes are offered. At SAYVA, weekly spiritual meetings (satsangs) are held every Saturday evening. Satsang includes chanting (Kirtan), a DVD featuring Satchidananda, a spiritual presentation by a guest lecturer or senior member, and prayers for world peace. Every year SAYVA offers silent retreats; a ten day retreat in June, a five day retreat during New Year’s, and four-day retreats in both Spring and Fall.

Consistent with its integrative perspective, Integral Yoga practitioners celebrate a variety of Christian, Jewish and Hindu holidays: Christian (Easter, Thanksgiving, Christmas ), Jewish (Rosh Hoshana, Yom Kippur, Hanukkah) Hindu (the Navarati celebration of the Divine Mother, the Mahasivaratri celebration in honor of Lord Shiva, and the Deepavali celebration of the Festival of Lights). Some mainstream culture holidays, such as Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, and New Year’s are celebrated. Integral Yoga practitioners have created their own holy days that honor Satchidananda (Guru Poornima – an annual sacred occasion honoring Satchidananda and marking the anniversary of the LOTUS dedication ceremony) and Mahasamadhi (commemorating Satchidananda’s exit from his physical body).

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

When Satchidanada arrived in the United States in 1966, he was drawn to youthful members of the counterculture (Kempton 1967). He argued that established institutions had failed American youth: “Where do you go if your institutions don’t offer you anything?…To a tepee in Vermont, that’s where….They are all searching for the necklace that’s around their necks” (Katz 1992:377). His popular fame increased after he addressed the audience at the Woodstock Music Festival in 1969, teaching them tochant “Hari Om.” (Image at right) His message to the assembled was to find peace within: “I still don’t understand how they are going to fight and then find peace. Therefore, let us not fight for peace, but let us find peace within ourselves first” (Satchidanda 1969). He touted Integral Yoga as a means to abandon drug use, stating that “The problem with drugs is that while they elevate you, they immediately drop you back down again” while Integral Yoga offered a “natural high” (Katz 1992:377). Satchidanada subsequently attracted many wealthy and prestigious followers.

Satchidananda was regarded by his followers as “God realized” and as a person who retained human form only as a way of supporting the spiritual development of others. He initiated many sannyasi in the West and gave new yoga names and individual mantras to his many initiates. He became a celebrity, appearing on talk shows and consulting with corporations, conducting interfaith dialogues, speaking on college campuses, and lecturing on nutrition and holistic health. Satchindanada has received numerous awards for his work, including the U Thant Peace Award from the United Nations Meditation Group, the Martin Buber Award for Outstanding Service to Humanity, the Judith Hollister Interfaith Award, the B’nai Brith Anti-Defamation Leage Humanitarian Award, and the Albert Schweitzer Humanitiarian Award. The fiftieth anniversary of his ministerial ordination was commemorated in 1999 during an interfaith service prior to the commencement of the 54th General Assembly of the United Nations. Numerous famous personages from Bill Clinton to Dean Ornish to Richard Gere to Allen Ginsberg praised his work.

Integral Yoga has established three yogavilles in the United States, Yogaville-East, Yogaville-West, and Satchidananda Ashram-Yogaville (SAYA), the headquarters of IYI . Integral Yoga also has four Integral Yoga Institutes within the United States, with one in Canada and one in India. Institutes offer coursework for those interested in becoming certified Integral Yoga teachers. Additionally, Institutes offer classes to the larger surrounding communities and Integral Yoga practitioners. Integral Yoga maintains thirty-seven centers in twenty-eight countries. These centers are similar to Institutes but are smaller, localized, and do not offer courses for teacher certification. Integral Yoga does not maintain a formal membership list, but only a few hundred people are certified to teach Integral Yoga.

Like many Ashrams, Yogavilles are normally located in rural areas. They serve as monastic-like communities of Integral Yoga yogis and teachers. At any given time the population of a Yogaville will consist of guests, associate members and full-time members. At the Yogaville ashram the renunciate swamis are provided food and housing while householders are expected to provide basic necessities for themselves. Practitioners come for retreats.

The Satchidananda Ashram-Yogaville welcomes about 2,000 visitors every year, while another 150 individuals consider the community their home. Some of the workshops offered at SAYA are classes that teach the concepts of each branch of yoga of which Integral Yoga is composed. These include Hatha Yoga, which focuses on postures, breathing pattern, and diet; Raja Yoga, which revolves around controlling the mind through meditation; Bhakti Yoga, which is practiced through constant love of and devotion to God; Karma Yoga, which is the path of selfless service; Jnana Yoga, which concentrates on the existence of everything that is natural and/or unchangeable; and Japa yoga, in which the focus is on chanting. Other workshops and classes include yoga for athletes, stress management yoga, prenatal and labor yoga, laughing yoga, inner tantric yoga, as well as yoga for those with scoliosis. For those at SAYA the diet is vegetarian, celibacy is required for singles and monastics, and alcohol, drugs and tobacco are prohibited.

SAYA is also home to the Light of Truth Universal Shrine (LOTUS), which opened in 1986. (Image at right) The shrine houses alters dedicated to ten major religions, as well as two additional alters, one dedicated to other known religions and the other dedicated to those still unknown. The outside of the shrine contains fountains and gardens, many with spiritual symbolism. The interior of the shrine consists of two floors; the bottom floor houses cases that display artifacts of the religions represented in the alters, which are located on the top floor of the shrine.

Following Satchidananda’s passing, a “leadership team” managed Yogaville and reported to its Board of Trustees.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Integral Yoga was caught up to a very limited extent in the mental manipulation and divided family controversies that affected many religious movements beginning in the 1970s. It has been the claims of sexual manipulation and abuse levied against Satchidananda that have received the greatest public visibility and most significantly affected the movement. Reports of sexual violations trace back to the 1970s(“Scandal Among the Swamis” 1972). During the early 1990s several female members who had served on Satchidanada’s staff charged him with sexual improprieties of various kinds (McGehee 1991). Following the initial allegations, several additional women made similar charges. Satchidananda has consistently denied the charges but refused interviews with journalists or responses to those making the allegations. With respect to his accusers, he has stated that “They are free to feel this way….If they don’t feel comfortable with me, they can go learn from someone else.” With respect to his unwillingness to provide a public response to the accusations, he has stated that “There is no need. If the public wants to believe that, they can believe it” (Chopra 1999). Many followers have vigorously defended Satchidananda and dismissed the charges as fabricated, but opponents claim that the movement lost numerous practitioners, teachers, and center affiliations in the wake of the controversy (Zuckerman 1991). Former members also formed a support group, Healing Through Truth Network. Legal issues remained dormant following Satchinanada’s passing until 2024. In 2024, two former members filed a civil lawsuit in New York charging that Integral Yoga and Yogaville were negligent by failing to protect them from Satchidananda’s ongoing sexual abuse (Stuart 2024).

Satchidananda’s mahasamadhi in 2002 ended his  personal involvement in sex abuse allegations but does not appear to have impacted his overall influence. Yogaville has remained a popular pilgrim and tourist site.

IMAGES
Image #1: S.ri Swami Satchidananda
Image #2: Yogaville in Buckingham County, Virginia.
Image #3: Satchidananda’s appearance at the Woodstock Festival.
Image #4: Light of Truth Universal Shrine.

REFERENCES

Chopra, Sonia. 1999. Satchidananda’s Yoga Ashram Caught Up In A New Controversy, Past Sexual Charges Begin Resurfing.” Rediff On The Net. 14 June. Accessed at http://www.rediff.com/news/1999/jun/14us on 28 October 2011.

Cook, Jennifer. 1999-2000. “Not All Yoga Is Created Equal.” Yoga Journal. Winter 1999-2000. Accessed at http://www.yogajournal.com/basics/165 on 23 October 2011.

Kempton, Sally. 1967. “What’s New in America?” Village Voice. 9 November, p. 1.

Ma, Swami Saravananda. 1980. “The Integral Yoga School in Historical Perspective.” Ph.D. dissertation. Storrs: University of Connecticut.

Meadows, Sarah and Jeffrey K. Hadden. 2002. “Integral Yoga International.” Pp. 646-47 in Religions of the World, Volume 2, edited by J. Gordon Melton and Martin. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO.

McGehee, Overton. 1991. “Ex-followers Say Swami Demanded Sexual Favors.” Richmond Times-Dispatch, Aug 2, p. B-1.

Pettinger, Richard. n.d. “ Biography Swami Satchidananda.” Biography Online. Accessed at http://www.biographyonline.net/spiritual/satchidananda/index.html on 25 October 2011.

Satchinanada, Sri S. 1969. “ Woodstock.” Accessed at http://www.swamisatchidananda.org/docs2/woodstock.htm on 15 November 2011,

“Scandal Among the Swamis.” 1972. Village Voice, December 14, 68.

Stuart, Courteney. 2024. “Lawsuit alleging sexual abuse by guru filed against Yogaville.” Cville Right Now, February 28. Accessed from https://cvillerightnow.com/news/208802-064460-courteney-stuart-reports-lawsuit-alleging-sexual-abuse-by-guru-filed-against-yogaville/ on 10 December 2025.

Zuckerman, Joy. 1991. “An Open Letter.” Accessed at http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Sri_Chinmoy_Information/message/2448 on 28 October 2011.

SUPPLEMENTARY RESOURCES

Bordow, Sita. 1984. The Master’s Touch. Yogaville, VA: Integral Yoga Publications.

Bordow, Sita. 1986. Sri Swami Satchidananda: Apostle of Peace. Yogaville, VA: Integral Yoga Publications.

Mandelkorn, Philip, Ed. 1978. To Know Yourself: The Essential Teachings of Swami Satchidananda. Garden City, NY: Anchor Books.

Satchidananda, Sri. 1978. [translation and commentary]The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali. Yogaville, VA: Integral Yoga Publications.

Weinca, Sita. 1972. Swami Satchidananda. NY: Bantam Books.

Post Date:
22 November 2011
Update:
10 December 2025

 

 

 

 

Share

Mark McLeister

Mark McLeister is an ethnographer of Christianity in China. His research focuses on grassroots church-state interactions, religious policy and the everyday lives of Chinese Christians. Mark was appointed as Lecturer in Chinese Studies at the University of Edinburgh in 2015. He was previously Senior Teaching Fellow (2012-2013) and Early Career Fellow (2013-2015) at Edinburgh. Mark completed his PhD in Chinese Studies at the University of Sheffield in 2013. He also holds an MSc from the University of Sheffield (2008) and an MA (Hons) in Social Anthropology from the University of St. Andrews. Before Edinburgh, Mark taught at the University of Sheffield, the University of Leeds and in HE institutes in China. He has published research in Asian Ethnology, Studies in World Christianity and Review of Religion in Chinese Society.

 

Share

Three-Self Patriotic Movement (TSPM)

THREE-SELF PATRIOTIC MOVEMENT (TSPM) TIMELINE

1872:  The first independent Chinese church was established in Guangzhou.

1910:  The World Missionary Conference was established in Edinburgh.

1922:  The National Christian Council of China (NCC) was established.

1937-1945:  The second Sino-Japanese War took place.

1948:  “The Present-Day Tragedy of Christianity” by Y.T. Wu was published.

1949 (October 1):  The People’s Republic of China was founded.

1949 (December):  “Message from Chinese Christians to Mission Boards Abroad” was published.

1950 (May):  Meetings between elite Protestants and Premier Zhou Enlai (May 2, 6, 13, 20) took place.

1950 (July):  The Christian Manifesto was signed by forty prominent Christian leaders.

1950 (September 23):  The Christian Manifesto was published in the People’s Daily.

1950 (October):  The Christian Manifesto was backed by 140 delegates of the NCC national meeting.

1951-1953:  The Denunciation Movement emerged.

1951 (April):  The “Preparatory Committee for the Oppose-America, Assist-Korea Three-Self Reform Movement” was established.

1954 (July 22-August 6):  First National Conference of the Three-Self Patriotic Movement took place.

1958:  TSPM pushed churches to initiate “United Worship.”

1966-1976:  The Cultural Revolution era occurred.

1978:   A small number of Protestant churches reopened.

1980 (October 6-13):  The National TSPM Committee was re-established and the China Christian Council was established.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

The Three-Self Patriotic Movement (TSPM) (三自爱国运动) is a mass “patriotic religious organization” (爱国宗教组织) in the People’s Republic of China (PRC), which since its founding has sought to unite and represent all Protestant Christians in the country under the “Three-Self” principles: self-governance (自治), self-support (自养), and self-propagation (自传). Its sphere of influence covers Mainland China only: it does not operate in Hong Kong. Patriotic religious organizations were established as a response to the Communist Party of China’s (CPC) “United Front” (统一战线) strategy which aimed “to strengthen its authority and legitimacy, especially among the more marginalised, independent, and minority sectors of the Chinese population” (Groot 2015:67a-67b). The establishment and development of the TSPM should be viewed in this context, and as a response by Christians seeking the survival of Christianity in an atheist socialist state. Although the TSPM as a patriotic religious association is not an “organ of the state,” it is expected to unite its membership under the leadership of the CPC under the banner of “love [your] country, love [your] religion” (爱国, 爱教 meaning “be patriotic and be a good religious citizen”). The status of the TSPM is somewhat “ambiguous” because of its dual purpose representing religious communities and being accountable to the state for the religious activities of these communities (Dunch 2012:265; Dunch 2008:163). There is no formal membership for ordinary believers in the patriotic religious organizations. The work of the TSPM is overseen by the National Committee of the Three-Self Patriotic Movement of the Protestant Churches in China (中国基督教三自爱国运动委员会) whose headquarters are in Shanghai.

Multiple complex factors relating to historical precedents in the Chinese state’s engagement with religion and movements within Christianity in China towards indigenization and/or independence from the nineteenth century to the 1940s, and which came together in the newly-formed PRC in 1949, in large part shaped the form and function of the TSPM in the 1950s and beyond. Despite the PRC being referred to as “New China” from 1949, the CPC government inherited many elements of imperial- and Republican-era approaches to religion. Since imperial times, the state has monitored religious groups and their activities and insisted on the registration of religious sites and leaders with the government (Bays 2012). In the early twentieth century, as reformers sought to design a modern Chinese state, they borrowed heavily from Japan, including the Christian-secular model of religion, which defined itself against the “undesirable” (irrational and backward) “superstitious” beliefs and practices that were deemed incompatible with a modern state (McLeister 2019b). With the collapse of the imperial system in 1911, the Republican government continued with this culture of administrative control of religious groups, and in keeping with a post-Enlightenment approach to religion “as a church-like institution separate from society” coerced those religions it deemed worthy of being modernized into identifiable institutions (Goossaert 2008:209-13). In large part, these religious institutions and their management by the state served as models from which the CPC liberally borrowed.

The “Three-Self” principles of the TSPM did not originate with the TSPM itself. These principles were in development long before the establishment of the PRC. Henry Venn (1796-1873) and Rufus Anderson (1796-1880) are credited with bringing together the three principles of self-support, self-governance, and self-propagation into a formula for the indigenization of Christian churches in the 1850s (Shenk 1990:29b). An early effort to put into practice elements of the three-self principles was in 1872 when Chen Mengnan (陈梦南 1840-1882) established an independent church in Guangzhou. Missionary conferences in China in 1877 (Yates 1878) and 1892 helped develop a comprehensive formulation of the three-self principles.

The first quarter of the twentieth century saw significant developments in the establishment of ecumenical movements among some mission churches and denominations, independent Christian churches and individual preachers and evangelists in China, as well as the birth of indigenous Christian movements and denominations. Although mission societies advocated “indigenization,” the slow pace caused frustration for some Chinese Christians. Pastor Cheng Jingyi’s (诚静怡1881-1939) rejection of “Western-imposed denominationalism” during the 1910 Edinburgh Missionary Conference highlighted the necessity for churches in China to be unified and Chinese-led (Tiedemann 2012:3a). Following this conference, the formation of the China Continuation Committee accelerated a more systematic approach to the three-self formula. This became the National Christian Council of China (NCC) in 1922, which initiated the ecumenical Church of Christ in China (中华基督教会), bringing together Western denominations in China and some independent Chinese churches (Tiedemann 2012:4a).

Independent Chinese churches included the Chinese Christian Independent Church (中国耶稣教自立会) established in 1906, and the Shandong Chinese Independent Christian Church (山东中华基督教自立会) established in 1915. Independent itinerant preachers included Wang Mingdao (王明道 1900-1991), Yu Cidu (余慈度Dora Yu 1873-1931), and Song Shangjie (宋尚节 John Sung 1901-1944). Lastly, and perhaps most significantly, was the emergence of indigenous Christian denominations or movements in the late 1910s through to the early 1930s. These denominations evolved with limited or no contact with foreign missions and missionaries and they embodied the three-self formula. The True Jesus Church (真耶稣教会), founded by Wei Enbo (魏恩波 Paul Wei 1877-1919), the Jesus Family (耶稣教廷), founded by Jing Dianying (敬奠瀛 1890–1957), and the Spiritual Gifts Movement (灵恩会 a network of churches heavily influenced by the revivals in northern China in the 1920s) were highly Pentecostal in nature. The Little Flock (小群会 or Local Church 聚会所), founded by Ni Tuosheng (倪柝声 “Watchman Nee” 1903-1957), was not Pentecostal but all of these denominations or movements were often critical of (Western) missions.

Several political movements in the 1910s and 1920s roused nationalist and anti-imperialist sentiments across China and Japan’s eight-year occupation of China compelled the implementation of three-self principles. The political movements included the May Fourth Movement (五四运动) in1919, the May Thirtieth Movement (五卅运动) of 1925, and the Anti-Christian Movement (非基督教运动), 1922-1927 (Yamamoto and Yamamoto 1953). The Japanese occupation of China (Second Sino-Japanese War), 1937-1945, resulted in the removal of foreign missionaries from Chinese churches and ultimately forced the realization of three-self principles in foreign mission churches: “The cutting off of Western mission funds forced the church to become self-supporting, the removal of Western missionaries forced it to become self-propagating, and the new responsibilities of leadership encouraged it to become self-governing” (Brook 1996:336). This was partly achieved through the League for the Promotion of Church Union in North China (华北基督教联合促进会) established in April 1942.

These events were instrumental in shaping the views of many Chinese Christians who would later become senior TSPM leaders, most importantly, the “progressive” Christian Y.T. Wu (吴耀宗 Wu Yaozong 1893-1979). Wu joined the YMCA in 1920, before training at Union Theological Seminary and Columbia University in New York. Wu returned to the YMCA in 1932 (Reilly 2012:264). It was attractive to young progressives because it promoted Chinese leadership. In addition, the CPC used the YMCA to perform its underground activities (Xu 2004:112). Wu’s experience is similar to the trajectory of other TSPM leaders, most of whom had association with the YMCA, St. John’s University (Shanghai) and/or Union Theological Seminary (Xu 2004:107). Wu was committed to pacifism in the 1920s, but his views shifted to the “social gospel” in the 1930s and then in the 1940s, heavily influenced by the atrocities committed under the Japanese occupation, he became procommunist or Christian socialist (Gao 1996:340-42). In April 1948, Wu published, “The Present-Day Tragedy of Christianity”, in which he critiqued the links between Protestant Christianity, imperialism and capitalism, arguing that Christianity had become a “reactionary force” stifling social change (Wu 1963). Wu’s views were significantly different from the indigenous church movements which expressed no interest in politics or social change (Xu 2004:109), but in the late 1940s across China, including within Protestant churches, there was increasing support for the CPC.

Close to defeating the Nationalist Party (国民党) the CPC established the framework of a national government in the summer of 1949. Several prominent Chinese Protestants were invited as delegates to the first meeting of the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference (CPPCC 中国人民政治协商会议), a political advisory organ of the United Front. The Protestant delegates included Y.T. Wu, Deng Yuzhi (邓裕志Cora Deng 1900-1996), and T.C. Chao (赵紫宸Zhao Zichen 1888-1979). After the official founding of the PRC in October 1949, Wu and the other Protestant CPPCC delegates wrote an open letter which stated that the role of foreign missionaries in China would change. The letter raised complicated issues in the history of foreign missions, including imperialism, denominationalism, and financial support (Wu et al 1963). In November 1949, this group of Protestant CPPCC delegates, together with representatives from the YMCA, YWCA and NCC, visited different areas of China to assess the implementation of the CPC state’s “freedom of religious belief” policy contained in China’s interim constitution, the Common Program (共同纲领). They discovered “serious problems” with the implementation of religious policy, and in April 1950 a group of nineteen leaders, led by Wu, went to Beijing to report to senior officials, including Zhou Enlai. Instead of following their original plan to report the problems they had identified, the group instead decided that it would be more prudent to write a statement of their political standpoint (Bays 2012:161). Further meetings with Zhou in May (2, 6, 13, and 20) led to a fifth and final draft of the founding document of the TSPM, “The Direction of Endeavour for Chinese Christianity in the Construction of New China” (中国基督教在新中国建设中努力的途径) also known as, “The Christian Manifesto” (基督教宣言) (Three-Self Reform Movement 1963). Some scholars have claimed that the Christian Manifesto was drafted by CCP officials (Chan 2012:873), but it is more likely that it was written by the Protestant leaders themselves, with Zhou’s input (Wickeri 1990). On July 28, 1950, forty Protestant leaders signed the Christian Manifesto and then promoted it. By August, they had collected 1,525 signatures from Chinese church leaders and lay believers (Xu 2004:115). The Manifesto reportedly amassed 400,000 signatures by 1954. It was published in full in the People’s Daily on September 23, 1950. In October 1950, at the NCC national meeting, the Manifesto was signed by 140 delegates, thus backing the formation of what was to become the TSPM (Bays 2012:162).

While there was undoubtedly broad support for the full indigenization of Christianity in China, the Manifesto established a clear political agenda for Chinese churches. The core message of the Manifesto was support for the CPC-led government and the state’s agenda of “anti-imperialism, anti-feudalism and anti-bureaucratic capitalism” (The Christian Manifesto 1963). Protestant Christianity’s extensive foreign networks meant that the state was determined to align Christianity with its political goals and key to this was purging imperialist influences, most of all within Christianity itself, including missionary agencies (Kindopp 2004:122-23). The change resulted in many missionaries exiting China in 1950, with most having left by 1951. Those that did not want to leave were expelled from the country.

During the initial drive to promote the Manifesto and establish a unified movement of Chinese Protestants, participation was largely voluntary. Into 1951, this campaign continued. At this time, local church life within the different denominations and church movements was largely “normal”: church gatherings took place, pastors were ordained, and outreach continued (Ying 2011:157). However, this changed markedly with the outbreak of the Korean War (1950-1953), as Chinese troops entered into North Korea in October 1950. This took “the CPC’s struggle with American imperialism to a new level and the tide of anti-imperialism affected its policy on Christianity” (Ying 2014:887). In March 1951, religious groups were ordered to prioritize the purging of imperialist influences. This was followed by conference in Beijing called by the State Affairs Council (SAC), which launched the “Christian Denunciation Movement” (基督教控诉运动) on April 19 and established the “Preparatory Committee for the Oppose-America, Assist-Korea Three-Self Reform Movement of the Christian Church (中国基督教抗美援朝、三自革新运动委员会筹备委员会)” on April 21, whose aims were anti-imperialist. The Denunciation Movement lasted into 1953 and coincided with the violent Campaign to Suppress Counterrevolutionaries” (镇压反革命运动), which had started in 1950. The Denunciation Movement aimed to purge Christianity in China from imperialist influences, including foreign missionaries. Liu Liangmo (刘良模 1909-1988), Secretary of the Preparatory Committee, even published an article titled “How to Hold a Successful Accusation [Denunciation] Meeting” on May 15, making the TSPM complicit in state suppression of and violence against Christians (Liu 1963). Other political campaigns implicated Chinese Christians, including the Campaign to Suppress Counterrevolutionaries, the Three-Anti (三反) Campaign (1951), and the Five-Anti (五反) Campaign (1952), leading to the denunciation, imprisonment or execution of many Christians.

In May 1951, Wu convened a meeting in Beijing to launch the Three-Self Reform Movement. At the First National Conference, which took place July 22-August 6, 1954, 139 members were appointed, forty-two of these to the Standing Committee, Wu was appointed as Chair, and the (first) Constitution was approved (Wickeri 1990:150). Some of the core leaders were “evangelical,” including Chen Chonggui (陈崇桂 Marcus Cheng, 1883-1963) and Jia Yuming (賈玉銘 1880-1964), bringing together a theologically diverse groups of Protestants. The term “Reform” was changed to “Patriotic” in the Movement’s name to discourage the idea that Christians would have to be reformed against their will or that the intention of the TSPM was to change Christian doctrine (China Christian Conference 1963). The TSPM was put under the supervision of the Religious Affairs Bureau (RAB), (under the authority of the United Front) and RAB officials served as “advisers” to the TSPM (Bays 2012:164). With many foreign mission institutions such as schools and hospitals nationalized in the early 1950s, and foreign funds cut off in response to the freezing of Chinese assets in the United States after China’s involvement in the Korean War, the remaining Protestant institutions were dismantled or reformed after the official establishment of the TSPM (Xu 2004:116), including Bible schools and seminaries, thus signalling a more coercive approach to “uniting” Chinese Protestants.

Now with considerable legitimacy within the Protestant churches in China, the TSPM moved to suppress the groups and individuals who resisted joining it. Many mission churches, some independent churches and several indigenous movements joined up to the TSPM enthusiastically or at least backed it albeit with some reticence because there seemed no alternative. There were some dissenters, however, Wang Mingdao of the Christian Tabernacle (基督徒会堂) in Beijing being one of them. A staunch conservative, Wang labelled the TSPM a “modernist” (liberal) project, and in the 1950s he penned a number of open letters in Christian magazines, such as The Spiritual Food Quarterly (灵食季刊), stating his position and criticizing those involved, particularly Y.T. Wu (Ying 2010:108). Wu and others responded with their own essays. The state labelled dissenters as “counterrevolutionaries” (Ying 2014:893). Wang’s 1955 pamphlet “We, Because of Faith” called the TSPM leadership “unbelievers” (Wang 1963). He was arrested and imprisoned for over twenty years despite the fact that there was no legal case against him (Wickeri 1990:165). However, even churches and individuals who did not oppose the TSPM were subject to criticism and subsequently disbanded or arrested, including the Jesus Family, despite many members having signed The Manifesto. Ni Tuosheng did not resist the TSPM but was arrested on dubious charges and died in prison soon after. The Little Flock did not have a “clear trajectory of accommodation or rejection” (Dunch 2012:264), but Little Flock congregations were harassed nonetheless (Lee 2005:86-89). The state-led Anti-Rightist Campaign (反右运动) started in June 1957 and was extended to churches in November that year, leading to more harassment and arrests. Despite the True Jesus Church having had no links to foreign mission organizations and having a fully Chinese leadership, leaders were imprisoned during the Campaign in 1957 and churches were shut down (Autry 2013 42a). There can be no denying that the TSPM collaborated with the state in suppressing and eliminating Christian denominations, groups and individuals who did not want to join the TSPM (Bays 2008:484a). Targets were those who were “too influential or too popular” (Gao 1996:349). It is ironic that the TSPM leadership, who were the greatest beneficiaries of Western institutions, attacked imperialism so vehemently and that these same people “attacked most viciously…those that had made the most significant contributions to Chinese Protestantism’s realization of the three-self principles” (Xu 2004:118-19).

Having seemingly united a small majority of Protestants under the leadership of the CPC-state, and removed imperialist influences, the National TSPM Committee pushed for “united worship” (联合礼拜) in 1958 in an attempt to demolish the last vestiges of “denominationalism” which was regarded as a “tool of foreign infiltration” (Autry 2013:41b). Throughout the political campaigns and TSPM crusades, church attendance had been falling. The Great Leap Forward (大跃进), launched by the central state in February 1958, further eroded church attendance as citizens in rural and urban areas worked overtime to achieve impossible output goals and often attended political study sessions in the evenings. Falling congregation sizes facilitated the shutting down of churches and the merging of congregations into designated buildings; for example, in Shanghai, 208 churches were reduced to twenty-two, and in Beijing, sixty-five churches were reduced to four (Ying 2011:157). Church leaders were sent to factories or farms to work. A hymnal was published in 1958, the purpose of which was to unite Christians around a shared worship experience. Any texts used in church gatherings were vetted for political correctness. Denominational features were abandoned. Plans for unification of worship were published in Tian Feng, and mention some specific denominations by name, including the Little Flock, Salvation Army and Seventh-Day Adventists (Lü et al. 1963).

Following the political campaigns of the 1950s, the 1960s proved even more challenging for Christians, including those within the TSPM. The Socialist Education Movement (社会主义教育运动1962-1965) was a CPC attempt to remove “reactionary elements” from society, including “superstitious” beliefs. The launch of the Cultural Revolution (文化大革命) in May 1966 brought with it intense scrutiny of many citizens, and many Christians suffered at the hands of officials, Red Guards and even work colleagues. Almost all forms of public religion were effectively banned, the TSPM committees at all levels were disbanded, churches shut down, and even the state apparatus designed to manage religion ceased functioning (namely the United Front Work Department (UFWD 统一战线工作部) and the RAB). Christians in many parts of China did not stop their religious activities, even at the height of the Cultural Revolution in some areas (Kao 2009; Wang 2020).

At the end of the main Cultural Revolution era, a degree of normality returned to the political arena as CPC and government organs were rehabilitated, including the UFWD and the RAB in the early 1970s. Christians were more emboldened to operate more openly. In the late 1970s, some Christians who had worshipped in TSPM-affiliated churches in the 1960s before their closure quietly pushed for their re-opening. In 1978, some such churches began to re-open and Christianity was once again permitted a degree of public expression. Christians imprisoned without any legal basis were released and rehabilitated. Many of the surviving TSPM leaders at the national and local levels were approached by UFWD or RAB officials and tasked with reviving the TSPM committees, although the CPC leadership assumed that the number of Christians was small and predominantly elderly (Dunch 2008:155). In March 1980, the interim National TSPM Committee sent a letter to Christians in China, which reaffirmed the “correct” path established by the CPC and declared that Christianity in China was no longer a tool of imperialism, and no longer a foreign religion. It also called on Christians to help realize the state’s “Four Modernizations” goal (TSPM 2000). On October 6-13, 1980, the Third National Christian Conference was held in Nanjing. K.H. Ting (丁光训 Ding Guangxun 1915-2012) was elected Chairperson of the TSPM and President of the newly-formed China Christian Council (CCC 中国基督教协会), responsible for the handling of church affairs. Ting retired from both organizations in 1997. Together, the TSPM and CCC work closely together and are collectively referred to as the “Two Committees” (两会).

K.H. Ting, often called Bishop Ting (or Bishop Ding), was as influential a figure on the TSPM (and CCC) in the Reform Era as Y.T. Wu was in the 1950s and 1960s, and although not without his critics, was certainly less controversial than Wu. He was made Anglican Bishop of Zhejiang in 1955, not long before denominations were banned by the TSPM. There are claims that Ting was a secret CPC member and that he worked in the CPC base in Yan’an in 1937 (Hunter & Chan 1993:89). No substantial evidence has corroborated this claim. Ting took up the position of Principal of Jinling Union Theological Seminary (金陵协和神学院) in 1953, and continued in the role from 1980. From 1980 he held a variety of positions outside of the TSPM/CCC, including as Director of Religious Studies at Nanjing University, Member of the Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress, and Vice-Chairperson of the CPPCC (Hunter and Chan 1993:89).

Although criticized for supporting Maoist policies and collaborating with the authorities in the repression of Protestant groups and individuals in the 1950s, Ting used his leadership in the TSPM/CCC and his political positions to speak on behalf of Protestant Christians. Throughout the 1980s and 1990s, Ting pushed the state for the return of church properties confiscated in the 1950s and 1960s, promoted theological training in seminaries and in grassroots training programs, and was at times outspoken about the restrictive nature of the state’s policy on religion. For example, Ting defended the rights of Chinese Christians to meet in homes and in 1988 even asked the RAB to end the harassment of such meetings. In 1989, Ting publicly supported the student and worker protests which culminated in the crackdown in Tian’anmen Square in Beijing and other places (Hunter and Chan 1993:95). In February 1989, Ting claimed that the TSPM would be dissolved by 1991 during an interview with a Christian news agency in the U.S. (Hunter and Chan 1993:94), though this idea was dropped in the aftermath of Tian’anmen. One scholar aptly described Ting as “more equipped than the more political leaders of the 1950s to represent Chinese Protestants to the outside world, to advocate for the church with Chinese state and party bureaucrats, and to reach out to the theologically conservative believers who comprised the majority of Chinese Protestants, within and outside official churches” (Dunch 2012:270). No TSPM or CCC leader has been as vocal about defending the rights of Chinese Christians or extending the space for Christian churches to operate as Ting.

Throughout the Reform Era and into the present day, the TSPM/CCC remain the sole officially-recognized Protestant organizations through which Chinese Protestants can register to meet and worship legally. Into the new millennium, there was a relatively high degree of freedom for TSPM-affiliated congregations to proselytize, establish charitable enterprises, and collaborate with churches outside of the TSPM/CCC system. This was largely due to a more laissez faire approach to religion under President Hu Jintao’s (胡锦涛 1942-) leadership. It was also partly due to an increasingly younger leadership in TSPM-affiliated congregations who were more willing to take risks and less entrenched in their views about the exclusivity of the TSPM/CCC system. Since the current leadership took office in 2012 and 2013, there has been a rapid retreat from the previous laissez faire treatment of religion.

The state is concerned about the rapid growth of Christianity, and has taken measures to curb this growth. The TSPM/CCC have become the focus of an ideological re-orienting of Protestant Christianity in an attempt to align it more closely to CPC goals. This re-politicization of the TSPM/CCC has been evident in its official statements, and in a re-emphasis on the bodies’ roles in supporting the leadership of the CPC, promoting patriotism, and celebrating important political anniversaries. The state has also been bolder in silencing dissenting voices. In 2015, Pastor Gu Yuese (顾约瑟 Joseph Gu b.d. unknown), Pastor of Chongyi Church (崇一堂) in Hangzhou and President of the Zhejiang Christian Council, penned an open letter criticizing the state’s forced removal of crosses and demolition of churches in the province which began in 2014. He was subsequently arrested in January 2016 on dubious charges and removed from all leadership positions. He remains under house arrest. Gu was the most senior TSPM/CCC leader to be arrested since the Cultural Revolution. Other TSPM-affiliated church leaders critical of state actions have also been arrested.

The events in Zhejiang impacted TSPM-affiliated congregations across the country and resulted in increasing distrust of the state’s view of Christianity (McLeister 2018). A raft of new legislation on religion since 2018 has brought further restrictions to TSPM-affiliated congregations, and despite the adeptness of many church leaders to negotiate and circumvent some elements of the legislation, it has had a dulling effect on numbers attending TSPM-affiliated congregations. Some church leaders have quit their roles due to the increase in political pressure (McLeister 2025).

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

The TSPM/CCC are not a church but are bodies founded on political principles which constitute “a loose [Christian] fellowship with many diverse views” (Chan 2012:878). However, there is a general division in beliefs and doctrines of the TSPM/CCC between the top leadership of the National TSPM/CCC (including some elites within seminaries and provincial TSPM/CCC committees) and the leadership of local-level TSPM/CCC committees and TSPM-affiliated congregations. While the fundamental beliefs of the TSPM/CCC could be described broadly as “evangelical,” the TSPM/CCC elites have tended to be more progressive and politically-oriented in their theology whereas grassroots TSPM/CCC committee and church leaders have tended to be more conservative and/or fundamentalist. This is, however, a somewhat crude division and there have been a number of elite TSPM/CCC leaders who were theologically evangelical, such as the late Wang Weifan (汪维藩 1927-2015) (Yao 2016).

The TSPM/CCC Church Order of Protestant Churches in China, 2018 (中国基督教教会规章) (TSPM/CCC 2018) outlines the core beliefs. The Church Order takes the Bible, the Apostles’ Creed and the Nicene Creed as foundational to faith (Article 6). Central beliefs include a triune God (Father, Son and Holy Spirit); a literal birth, death and resurrection of Jesus Christ; a Holy Spirit who works in individuals to lead them to repentance and in the church to build it up. Jesus will return to judge the world and those with faith in him will be resurrected and enjoy eternal life. These beliefs are explained in more detail in the Catechism (要道问答) produced by the CCC (CCC 2012). The Catechism, first published in 1983 (revised in 2023), covers one hundred and twenty points of faith and doctrine, divided into seven sections: the Bible, God, Jesus Christ, the Holy Spirit, salvation, the church, and the saints. These statements of faith are not only attempts to unite Chinese Christians around shared beliefs, but also to defend the TSPM/CCC from what are regarded as “heretical” groups.

However, these statements of belief need to be placed in context alongside the key beliefs on which the TSPM/CCC were founded (eg, “Love [Your] Country, Love [Your] Religion,” anti-imperialism), as well as more recent developments in theology. After the early 1980s, there was much less discussion of anti-imperialism, but In March 2019, Xu Xiaohong, Chairperson of the National TSPM Committee, berated the use of Christianity by “Western powers” to bring instability to China and the CPC (Gan 2019). The TSPM and CCC constitutions (revised 2023), both contain identical text stating that the main purposes of the Committees are to, “Support the leadership of the Communist Party of China, support the socialist system, and study and implement Xi Jinping Thought on Socialism with Chinese Characteristics for a New Era” (Article 3). Additional goals are for the TSPM/CCC to stick to the Three-Self principles, to unite and lead believers in China to be patriotic and to glorify God and benefit people, and to stick to the “Sinicization” (中国化) of Protestant Christianity and “Theological Reconstruction” (神学思想建设) (Article 3).

Sinicization refers to a project launched by the central state in 2015 which calls on all recognized religions in China to adapt to essentialized ideals of (Han) Chinese culture and to fully support the CPC’s goals (Madsen 2021). It has become a major focus of the previous (2018-2022) and current (2023-2027) Work Plans of the TSPM/CCC. However, since the fundamental purpose of the Sinicization project is to encourage religions in China to actively support the CPC’s goals, it is not radically different from the demands of previous regimes, such as the “Harmonious Society” goals of the Hu leadership, or the “Adaptation to Socialism” goals of the Jiang Zemin leadership. Although the National and Provincial TSPM/CC(C)’s have been promoting its realization, not all local-level TSPM/CCC’s and TSPM-affiliated churches are engaging with it, with some (perhaps many) church leaders viewing Sinicization as a political project that does not benefit the church (McLeister 2025). Even at the highest levels of the TSPM/CCC system, at least some of the use of political rhetoric (such as Sinicization) is performative, and it should not be assumed that there is necessarily a deep “belief” in the state’s political goals. Some leaders within the TSPM/CCC system choose to parrot political language as a means of placating the state and carving out space for Christianity (McLeister 2025).

Theological Reconstruction refers to an attempt by K.H. Ting to develop Chinese Protestant theology to help it adapt better to socialist society (Dunch 2008). Theological Reconstruction was formally launched at a TSPM/CCC conference in November 1998 in Jinan (Shandong). Unlike Sinicization, it is not a state-initiated project. Ting wanted to challenge “fundamentalist” theology which he felt many Chinese Christians accepted uncritically (Wickeri 2007:340), not only at the grassroots but by many TSPM seminary faculty as well. At its core, Ting argued that the doctrine of justification needed to be “downplayed” (淡化) because he felt this doctrine over-emphasized a separation between Christians and non-Christians. By emphasizing “good works” and seeing sin as structural as well as personal, Ting hoped to find common points of contact between Christians and non-Christians, and to emphasize Christian witness in wider society (Chow 2018; Wickeri 2007). Ting’s ideas continue to be controversial, with some within the TSPM/CCC rejecting them outright as an attack on core Protestant beliefs (Vala 2018). Others argue that his ideas have not been understood sufficiently. In TSPM-affiliated churches, there is little discussion of Theological Reconstruction. However, Ting’s writings are still debated and discussed by TSPM/CCC leaders and seminary faculty, and should therefore be included in a broad survey of the TSPM/CCC’s doctrines and beliefs.

The TSPM continues to downplay “denominationalism” in official publications, but the reality in TSPM-affiliated churches reflects a partial return to specific denominational beliefs; for example, the Seventh-Day Adventists (Chow 2021), the True Jesus Church (Inouye 2018) or the Little Flock (Bays 2012). Although some scholars have claimed that TSPM-affiliated church leaders are discouraged from preaching on some topics such as eschatology and faith-healing (Hunter and Chan 2012:816), evidence suggests that these aspects of faith are taught in some churches (McLeister 2019b).

RITUALS/PRACTICES

The TSPM/CCC recognize the celebration of two sacraments common to many forms of Christianity: holy communion and baptism. According to the Church Order, only ordained clergy are permitted to administer holy communion and baptism (Article 15). Holy communion is only supposed to be taken by baptized believers, but this is not always strictly enforced (Article 14). Baptism takes two forms, full immersion or sprinkling. Christian weddings and funerals are also recognized by the TSPM/CCC but there are few stipulations on how these should be conducted other than that ordained clergy should provide some form of marriage counselling for those getting married (Article 20) and that funerals should be conducted in an orderly manner and that expenditure should not be excessive (Article 21). The church festivals of Christmas and Easter are recognized in the Church Order. Some TSPM-affiliated churches also celebrate Harvest Thanksgiving (McLeister 2013a). The Church Order outlines a number of education and experience qualifications for each clerical position (Article 28), their duties (Article 29) and the procedures for consecration or ordination (Article 30).

The re-politicization of the TSPM/CCC has resulted in an increasing emphasis on the ritualistic display of CPC symbols in TSPM seminaries, at TSPM/CCC meetings, and in TSPM-affiliated churches. In 2018, the state launched the “Four Enters” campaign, forcing TSPM-affiliated churches to fly the Chinese state flag (McLeister 2025:25). Flag-raising ceremonies and the singing of “patriotic songs” (唱红歌) have become common in TSPM seminaries and TSPM/CC(C) meetings at the national, provincial and local levels. 

There is a wide range of TSPM-affiliated churches, and therefore substantial diversity in practices; for example, some TSPM-affiliated congregations practice Spirit-filled prayer meetings, complete with glossolalia (McLeister 2019b), fasting, prayers for healing and exorcisms of evil spirits are also practiced in some TSPM-affiliated congregations (McLeister 2019b) while TSPM-affiliated True Jesus Churches practice feet-washing (Inouye 2018). Although state religious policy prohibits attempts at evangelism in public spaces, TSPM-affiliated churches have been known to engage in the public distribution of “gospel leaflets” and other outreach activities (McLeister 2012; McLeister 2021).

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

The TSPM (together with the CCC) is a mass patriotic religious organization, not a church, although it arguably fulfils some ecclesiastical functions (training and ordination of clergy, provision of a Church Order). The TSPM and CCC both have national committees named National Committee of Three-Self Patriotic Movement of the Protestant Church in China (中国基督教三自爱国运动委员会 National TSPM) and China Christian Council (中国基督教协会 CCC). There are TSPM committees at the provincial, municipal and district/county levels. All provinces have a provincial TSPM except for Tibet. There are Christian Councils (CC) at the provincial, municipal and some district/county levels. The National Chinese Christian Conference (中国基督教代表会议 NCCC) is the highest authority of both the TSPM and the CCC. It is made up of representatives elected by the National TSPM and CCC, the provincial TSPMs and CCs, Nanjing Union Theological Seminary, and the National Associations of the Young Men‘s Christian Association of China (中华基督教青年会全国协会) and Young Women’s Christian Association of China (中华基督教女青年会全国协会). The NCCC meets every five years and elects the leadership of the National TSPM and CCC. The Standing Committees of the National TSPM and CCC hold a Plenary together every two years. The NCCC sometimes appoints small groups for specific tasks. The Standing Committees of each body meet independently more regularly (CCC 2023; TSPM 2023). Traditionally, it was common for the equivalent positions in the TSPM/CCC (or CC) to be held by the same person; for example, K.H. Ting held the positions of Chairperson of the National TSPM and President of the CCC concurrently. However, it is now more common for the equivalent positions in both bodies to be held by different persons at any one time.

The entire structure of the TSPM and CCC/CC’s is not fully hierarchical and is divided into two levels. The upper level comprises the National TSPM/CCC and the provincial-level TSPM/CCs. Provincial-level TSPM/CCs should adhere to the directives of the National TSPM and CCC (TSPM Constitution Article 6.9 and CCC Constitution Article 7.10). There is no stipulation that local-level TSPM/CCs should obey provincial-level TSPM/CCs. However, there is a degree of control from the National TSPM/CCC (at least in theory). Article 4 of the Church Order stipulates that local-level TSPM/CCs have an obligation to comply with the Church Order. In addition, Church Orders drafted by TSPM/CCs are not allowed to contradict in any way the Church Order promulgated by the National TSPM/CCC (Church Order Article 5). The ordination of church pastors is ultimately decided by provincial-level TSPM/CCs because local-level TSPM/CCs must send the nomination for ordination to the province for approval (Church Order Article 30). There is also a degree of influence from provincial-level TSPM/CCs to local-level TSPM/CCs by membership, since leaders of local-level TSPM/CCs can concurrently hold a post in the provincial-level TSPM/CC.

The lower level comprises local-level TSPM/CCs and individual TSPM-affiliated congregations. Individual churches and meeting points are required to register with the state to be recognized as approved “religious activities venues” (宗教活动场所). Local-level TSPM/CCs are responsible for guiding and supervising all aspects of the ministry of individual churches and meeting points registered through them (Church Order Article 40). The level of guidance and supervision varies: some local-level TSPM/CCs can be very controlling towards individual congregations, some enjoy a broad latitude of freedom, and some TSPM/CCs can even be very supportive of church activities which push the boundaries of what the state views as acceptable religious activity (McLeister 2013a; McLeister 2021; See also Vala 2020).

The Church Order recognizes the following church leadership positions: Bishop (主教), Pastor (牧师) (including Associate Pastor 副牧师, also called Teacher 教师 in some places) and Elder (长老) (Article 27) and the process for ordination. There are currently no bishops in the TSPM/CCC system. The last two bishops to be consecrated were Sun Yanli (孙彦理 1914-1995) and Shen Yifan (沈以藩1928-1994) in 1988, and while the Church Order has retained the position of bishop, it is largely defunct due to theological disagreements (Guo 2025). The ordination of leaders in individual churches includes pastors and elders, whose ordination must be approved by the TSPM/CC. Their ordination is also subject to political checks by the state. Other leadership positions can include Preachers (传道人), Deacons (执事) and volunteer lay church workers (同工). Preachers are generally graduates of TSPM seminaries or Bible schools and are tasked with preaching and pastoral duties. Before being nominated for seminary enrolment, applicants must be approved by the TSPM/CC and are also subject to political background checks. Individual congregations themselves decide on the appointment of deacons and lay church workers. However, individual congregations can also wield significant influence on the ordination of pastors and elders, as well as their election to TSPM/CC positions, even if they have state approval (See McLeister 2019b).

What exactly constitutes a TSPM-affiliated congregation is sometimes ambiguous. Churches (堂) and meeting points (聚会点) which are formally registered with the state through the local TSPM/CC are clearly TSPM-affiliated congregations. However, there is a sizable number of congregations which have a connection to the TSPM/CC system but which are not formally registered. This connection would usually take the form of a leader or leaders of the unregistered congregation being known to the leadership of a church or meeting point who can advocate for the group to the TSPM/CC or state organs. Some of these groups are unable to register because they do not yet fulfil the basic requirements to do so. Others may not wish to register but know that it is politically expedient to make a connection with a TSPM-affiliated congregation or leader, albeit in an informal manner. There is, therefore, significant diversity in TSPM-affiliated congregations, including congregations predominantly made up of young professionals, migrant workers, a specific ethnic minority, or the Deaf (McLeister 2013b; McLeister 2019a; McLeister 2024), as well as congregations who adhere to specific denominational traditions, such as the Seventh-Day Adventists (Chow 2021), the True Jesus Church (Autry 2013; Inouye 2018) or the Little Flock (Bays 2012). Some local TSPM/CCs and TSPM-affiliated congregations network with “house churches” (家庭教会), seminaries which operate outside the TSPM/CCC system, and overseas Christian organizations (McLeister 20024; Vala 2009).

The National TSPM/CCC and TSPM/CCs at all levels, as well as individual TSPM-affiliated congregations, are all subject to state supervision by a number of state organs. The primary state organ is the United Front Work Department (UFWD) and the National Religious Affairs Commission (NRAC 国家宗教事务局 formerly called the State Administration for Religious Affairs SARA). The NRAC was an independent government organ until 2018 when it was absorbed into the UFWD. It still functions under the name NRAC but does not have any leadership independent of the UFWD. The UFWD oversees the formulation and development of policy on religion, which incorporates the oversight of religious associations and their activities. Other state organs such as subdistrict offices (街道办事处), residents’ committees (居民委员会) and village committees (村民委员会) also have responsibility for the oversight of religious activities in many places (McLeister 2025).

The TSPM/CCC are also involved in theological education, charity work and Bible printing. In an attempt to train clergy in three-self principles and patriotism and to equip church leaders, the TSPM/CCC run their own seminaries; one national seminary (Jinling Union Theological Seminary, often referred to as Nanjing Seminary) and a number of regional and provincial seminaries. Seminaries receive funding from the TSPM/CCC and the state (Vala 2009). There are also a number of Bible schools and short-term theological training programs run by local-level TSPM/CCs and individual churches. As a further extension of its educational training, the TSPM/CCC publishes books and other training materials. Tian Feng: The Magazine of the Christian Church in China (天风: 中国基督教杂志) is an official publication of the TSPM. Its content includes official communications from the TSPM and the CCC, devotional and spiritual articles, and commentary on religious policy. Other key publications include Nanjing Theological Review (金陵神学志), published by Jinling Union Theological Seminary, and Chinese Theological Review, an English-language journal. The TSPM/CCC contributes to charity work through The Amity Foundation (爱德基金会), headquartered in Nanjing, with offices in Hong Kong and Geneva. It is a voluntary charitable organization established in 1985 by Chinese Christians. In mainland China, it is involved in a range of programs relating to disaster relief, and health and social care. The Nanjing Amity Printing Company (南京爱德印刷有限公司), part of The Amity Foundation, is a joint venture together with the United Bible Societies, and was established in 1988. As of 2025, it has printed over 279 million Bibles, some in Chinese and other languages used in China, and some in a range of other languages for export.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

As religious bodies whose role is to represent Protestant Christians in China while at the same time cooperate with the state in implementing official policy on religion, the TSPM/CCC and the TSPM-affiliated churches are required to walk a fine line at times. If the TSPM/CCC or TSPM-affiliated church leaders are deemed to be too political by their Protestant constituency, they lose religious legitimacy and are unable to carry out their spiritual mandate. Similarly, if they do not adhere to demands from the state, then they lose political legitimacy and therefore their space to operate. While many leaders are adept at negotiating these demands, this has undoubtedly become more challenging in recent years with the re-politicization of religion (McLeister 2025).

The TSPM/CCC has not addressed the highly-politicized debates and violence of the 1950s and 1960s, and this continues to play a role in the rejection of the TSPM/CCC by significant numbers of Protestants in China today. Some outside the TSPM/CCC system regard its leadership as “hypocrites” or “collaborators with the ‘Anti-Christ’” (Hunter and Chan 1993:87). If the TSPM/CCC are determined to persuade outsiders to join them, then historical issues need to be addressed, although this is unlikely to happen in the current political climate.

REFERENCES

Autry, Jiexia Zhai. 2013. “Pentecostal Christianity and Church-State Relations in China: The Case of the True Jesus Church Movement.” The Review of Faith & International Affairs 11:40-51.

Bays, Daniel H. 2012. A New History of Christianity in China. UK: Wily-Blackwell.

Brook, Timothy. 1996 “Toward Independence: Christianity in China Under the Japanese Occupation, 1937-1945.” Pp. 317-37 in Christianity in China: From the Eighteenth Century to the Present, edited by Daniel H. Bays. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

CCC. 2023. “中国基督教协会章程 [Constitution of the China Christian Council].” 中国基督教协会章程.

CCC. 2012. 基督教:要道问答 Protestant Christianity: Catechism. Shanghai: Jinling xiehe shenxueyuan.

Chan Kim-Kwong. 2012. “Chinese Churches and Communist State: The ‘Patriotic’ Churches.” Pp. 867-81 in Handbook of Christianity in China, Volume Two: 1800-present, edited by R.G. Tiedemann. Leiden: Brill.

China Christian Conference. 1963 [1954]. “Letter to the Churches.” Pp. 98-99 in Documents of the Three-Self Movement: Source Materials for the Study of the Protestant Church in Communist China, edited by Wallace C. Merwin and Francis P. Jones, New York, NY: National Council of the Churches of Christ in China.

Chow, Alex. 2018. Chinese Public Theology: Generational Shifts and Confucian Imagination in Chinese Christianity. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Chow, Christie Chui-Shan. 2021. Schism: Seventh-Day Adventism in Post-Denominational China. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press.

Dunch, Ryan. 2012. “Chinese Christianity. 261-82 in The Wiley-Blackwell Companion to Chinese Religions, edited by Randall L. Nadeau. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing.

Dunch, Ryan. 2008. “Christianity and ‘Adaptation to Socialism’.” Pp. 155-78 in Chinese Religiosities: Afflictions of Modernity and State Formation, edited by Mayfair Mei-Hui Yang, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

Gan, Nectar. 2019. “Official head of China’s Protestant churches says religions must be purged of ‘Western influences.’” South China Morning Post, March 12. Accessed from Official head of China’s Protestant churches says religions must be purged of ‘Western influences’ | South China Morning Post on 2 December 2025.

Gao Wangzhi. 1996. “Y.T. Wu: A Christian Leader Under Communism.” 338-52 in Christianity in China: From the Eighteenth Century to the Present, edited by Daniel H. Bays. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

Goossaert, Vincent. 2008. “Republican Church Engineering: The National Religious Associations in 1912 China.” Pp. 209-32 in Chinese Religiosities: Afflictions of Modernity and State Formation, edited by Mayfair Mei-Hui Yang. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

Groot, Gerry. 2015. “The Expansion of the United Front Under Xi Jinping.” China Story Yearbook. Australian Centre on China in the World, Australian National University. Accessed from https://ciw.anu.edu.au/ on 2 December 2025.

Guo, Katherine. 2025. “Why is there No Bishop in Today’s Protestant Chinese Church?” China Christian Daily, September 26. Accessed from Why There Is No Bishop in Today’s Chinese Protestant Church? – China Christian Daily on 2 December 2025.

Hunter, Alan and Chan Kim-Kwong. 2012. “Growth of the Chinese Church since 1949.” Pp. 810-25 in Handbook of Christianity in China, Volume Two: 1800-present, edited by R.G. Tiedemann. Leiden: Brill.

Hunter, Alan and Chan Kim-Kwong. 1993. Protestantism in Contemporary China. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

Inouye, Melissa Wei-Tsing. 2018. China and the True Jesus: Charisma and Organization in a Chinese Christian Church. New York: Oxford University Press.

Kao Chen-Yang. 2009. “The Cultural Revolution and the Emergence of Pentecostal-style Protestantism in China.” Journal of Contemporary Religion 24:171-88.

Kindopp, Jason. 2004. “Fragmented yet Defiant: Protestant Resilience under Chinese Communist Party Rule.” In God and Caesar in China: Policy Implications of Church-State Tensions, edited by Jason Kindopp and Carol Lee Hamrin, 122-145. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.

Lee, Joseph Tse-Hei. 2005. “Watchman Nee and the Little Flock Movement in Maoist China.” Church History 74:68-96.

Liu Liang-mo. 1963 [1951]. “Advice on Accusation.” Pp. 49-51 in Documents of the Three-Self Movement: Source Materials for the Study of the Protestant Church in Communist China, edited by Wallace C. Merwin and Francis P. Jones. New York, NY: National Council of the Churches of Christ in China

Lü Wen et al. 1963 [1958]. “Unification of Worship.” Pp. 190-84 in Documents of the Three-Self Movement: Source Materials for the Study of the Protestant Church in Communist China, edited by Wallace C. Merwin and Francis P. Jones. New York, NY: National Council of the Churches of Christ in China.

Madsen, Richard. 2021. ”Introduction.” Pp. 1-15 in The Sinicization of Chinese Religions: From Above and Below, edited by Richard Madsen. Leiden: Brill.

McLeister, Mark. 2025. “Christianity in China since 2018: Grassroots Perspectives.” Religions & Christianity in Today’s China XV:21-30.

McLeister, Mark. 2024. “Worship Bricolage and the Categorization of Protestant Congregations in Contemporary China.” Pp. 124-37 i n Political Theologies in Chinese Society, edited by Joshua Mauldin. London: Routledge.

McLeister, Mark. 2021. “‘Gospel-leafleting,’ Three-Self-Affiliated Congregations and Rule of Law in the PRC.” Pp. 242-65 in Christian Social Activism and Rule of Law in Chinese Societies, edited by Fenggang Yang and Chris M. White. Bethlehem, PA: Lehigh University Press.

McLeister, Mark. 2019a. “Worship, Technology and Identity: A Deaf Protestant Congregation in Urban China.” Studies in World Christianity 25:220-37.

McLeister, Mark. 2019b. “Popular Christianity, Sensation and Ling’en Authority in Contemporary China.” Asian Ethnology 77:127-53.

McLeister, Mark. 2018. “Chinese Protestant Reactions to the Zhejiang ‘Three Rectifications, One Demolition’ Campaign.” Review of Religion and Chinese Society 5:76-100.

McLeister, Mark. 2013a. “Negotiating Policy and Practice: A Micro-Level Analysis of Three-Self Churches in a Coastal Chinese City.” PhD Thesis, University of Sheffield.

McLeister, Mark. 2013b. “‘House Church’ versus ‘Three-Self’? Cooperation Across the Christian Community in China.” ChinaSource Quarterly, June 24. Accessed from https://www.chinasource.org/resource-library/articles/house-church-and-three-self-cooperation-across-the-christian-community on 2 December 2025.

McLeister, Mark. 2012. “A Three-Self Protestant Church, the Local State and Religious Policy Implementation in a Coastal Chinese City.” Pp. 234-46 in Christianity in Contemporary China: Socio-Cultural Perspectives, edited by Francis Khek Gee Lim. Oxon: Routledge.

Reilly, Thomas. 2012. “Wu Yaozong and the YMCA: From Social Reform to Social Revolution, 1927-1937.” Journal of American-East Asian Relations 19:263-87.

Shenk, Wilbert R. 1990. “The Origins and Evolution of the Three-Selfs in Relation to China.” International Bulletin of Missionary Research 14:28-35.

Three-Self Reform Movement. 1963 [1950]. “Direction of Endeavor for Chinese Christianity in the Construction of New China [‘The Christian Manifesto’].” Pp. 19-20 in Documents of the Three-Self Movement: Source Materials for the Study of the Protestant Church in Communist China, edited by Wallace C. Merwin and Francis P. Jones. New York, NY: National Council of the Churches of Christ in China.

Tiedemann, R.G. 2012, “Comity Agreements and Sheep Stealers: The Elusive Search for Christian Unity Among Protestants in China.” International Bulletin of Missionary Research 36:3-8.

TSPM. 2023. “中国基督教三自爱国运动委员会章程 [Constitution of the National Committee of the Three-Self Patriotic Movement of the Protestant Church in China].” 中国基督教三自爱国运动委员会章程.

TSPM. 2000 [1980]. “Letter to Brothers and Sisters in Lord Nationwide from the Standing Committee of the National Committee of the Three-Self Patriotic Movement of the Protestant Churches in China (March 1, 1980).” Chinese Law and Government 33:52-55.

TSPM/CCC. 2018. “中国基督教教会规章 [Church Order of Protestant Churches in China].” 中国基督教教会规章.

Vala, Carsten. 2020. “The Three-Self Patriotic Movement: Divergent Perspectives and Grassroots Realities.” ChinaSource Quarterly 22:3-4, 16.

Vala, Carsten. 2018. The Politics of Protestant Churches and the Party-State in China: God Above Party? Oxon: Routledge.

Vala, Carsten T. 2009. “Pathways to the Pulpit: Leadership Training in ‘Patriotic’ and Unregistered Chinese Protestant Churches.” Pp. 96-125 in Making Religion, Making the State: The Politics of Religion in Modern China, edited by Yoshiko Ashiwa and David L. Wank. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

Wang Mingdao. 1963 [1955]. “We, Because of Faith.” In Documents of the Three-Self Movement: Source Materials for the Study of the Protestant Church in Communist China, edited by Wallace C. Merwin and Francis P. Jones, 99-114. New York, NY: National Council of the Churches of Christ in China.

Wang Xiaoxuan. 2020. Maoism and Grassroots Religion: The Communist Revolution and the Reinvention of Religious Life in China. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Whyte, Bob. 1988. Unfinished Encounter: China and Christianity. London: Collins.

Wickeri, Philip L. 2007. Reconstructing Christianity in China: K.H. Ting and the Chinese Church. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books.

Wickeri, Philip L. 1990. Seeking the Common Ground: Protestant Christianity, the Three-Self Movement, and China’s United Front. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books.

Wu Y.T. et al. 1963 [1949]. “Message from Chinese Christians to Mission Boards Abroad.” Pp. 14-18 i n Documents of the Three-Self Movement: Source Materials for the Study of the Protestant Church in Communist China, edited by Wallace C. Merwin and Francis P. Jones. New York, NY: National Council of the Churches of Christ in China.

Wu Y.T. 1963 [1948]. “The Present-Day Tragedy of Christianity.” Pp. 1-5 in Documents of the Three-Self Movement: Source Materials for the Study of the Protestant Church in Communist China, edited by Wallace C. Merwin and Francis P. Jones, New York, NY: National Council of the Churches of Christ in China.

Xu Yihua. 2004. “‘Patriotic’ Protestants: The Making of an Official Church.” Pp. 107-21 in God and Caesar in China: Policy Implications of Church-State Tensions, edited by Jason Kindopp and Carol Lee Hamrin. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.

Yamamoto, Tatsuro and Sumiko Yamamoto. 1953. “The Anti-Christian Movement in China, 1922-1927.” The Far East Quarterly 12:133-47.

Yao, Kevin Xiyi. 2016. “Wang Wei-fan’s Evangelical Theology: Its Significance for the Church in China Today.” Pp. 3-16 in Yearbook of Chinese Theology 2016, edited by Paulos Z. Huang. Leiden: Brill.

Yates, M.T., ed. 1878. Records of the General Conference of the Protestant Missionaries of China held at Shanghai, May 10-24, 1877. Shanghai: Presbyterian Mission Press.

Ying Fuk-Tsang. 2014. “The CPC’s Policy on Protestant Christianity, 1949-1957: An Overview and Assessment.” Journal of Contemporary China:89:884-901.

Ying Fuk-Tsang. 2011. “Mainland China.” Pp. 149-70 in Christianities in Asia, edited by Peter C. Phan. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing.

Ying Fuk-Tsang 邢福增. 2010. “革命時代的反革命: 基督教「王明道反革命集團」案始末考 [Counterrevolution in the Revolutionary Era: A Study of the Protestant Christian ‘Wang Mingdao Counterrevolutionary Group’].” Zhongyang yanjiuyuan jindaishi yanjiusuo jikan 67: 97-147.

Publication Date:
3 December 2025

 

Share

Zizians

ZIZIANS TIMELINE

2013:  Ziz LaSota, a computer engineer and self-identified “rationalist,” began promoting speculative theories about hemispheric cognition and moral purity within online rationalist communities.

2017:  LaSota recruited a “Rationalist Fleet,” an experimental community that lived aboard boats off the U.S. Pacific coast to practice anarcho-rationalist ethics.

2019:  Four Zizian associates, including LaSota, were arrested during a protest against the Center for Applied Rationality (CFAR) in Occidental, California. The incident, widely publicized, led to the community’s ostracization from mainstream rationalist and effective-altruist networks.

2022:  The group’s informal network became associated with violent confrontations resulting in multiple deaths in California and Pennsylvania.

2023:  LaSota briefly resurfaced in Philadelphia after allegedly faking her own death the previous year.

2025:  A series of interconnected killings in Vermont, Pennsylvania, and California were linked by prosecutors to Zizian-affiliated individuals.

2025 (February):  Federal authorities arrested LaSota in Maryland.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

The Zizians are an informal, self-declared community of “rationalist moral extremists” whose ideology fuses elements of anarchism, veganism, transhumanism and a radical reinterpretation of decision theory. Although participants reject the term cult and often deny belonging to any organized group, the label “Zizian” derives from Ziz LaSota (Image at right), an Alaskan-born engineer and writer who became a minor figure within the Bay Area’s rationalist and effective-altruist scenes in the mid-2010s (Beam 2025; Ratliff 2025; Wendling 2025).

LaSota studied computer engineering at the University of Alaska Fairbanks and briefly pursued postgraduate work at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign. After internships with NASA, she relocated to the San Francisco Bay Area seeking involvement with organizations suchas the Machine Intelligence Research Institute (MIRI) and the Center for Applied Rationality (CFAR) (Image at right). Disillusioned by what she described as “ethical hypocrisy” within those institutions, LaSota developed a breakaway worldview that fused rigorous moral reasoning with mystical language about cognition, hemispheric conflict and apocalyptic responsibility.

By 2017, she had gathered a small circle of adherents (largely trans or gender-nonconforming rationalists) who attempted to establish a “Rationalist Fleet,” a floating intentional community aboard a repurposed World War II tugboat, The Caleb. The project embodied their ideal of anarchic self-sufficiency, cognitive liberation and total veganism. When the vessel’s upkeep collapsed, members moved into trailers and converted trucks along the California coast, maintaining an intense online presence through encrypted forums (Beam 2025).

A 2019 protest at a CFAR retreat marked a decisive rupture. After police arrested LaSota and several companions, the broader rationalist movement publicly distanced itself, and online commentators coined the term “Zizians”: a name the group itself never formally adopted but which became the shorthand for its network.

Over subsequent years, Zizian circles radicalized further, developing their own rituals, jargon and cosmology. By the early 2020s, the movement had transmuted from a philosophical splinter group into what scholars of new religions might call a “sacralized rationality movement:”a project that rendered cognitive purity, moral extremity and the rejection of compromise as quasi-religious obligations.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Zizian belief crystallized around a vision of total moral coherence (Peng 2025). Drawing from decision-theoretic debates in the rationalist community, LaSota’s writings proposed that moral agents must act in strict accordance with timeless principles rather than causal pragmatism: a view she termed “heroic responsibility”. For adherents, ethical lapses were not local errors but existential betrayals of universal logic.

This philosophical severity merged with several distinctive doctrines:

Hemispheric Dualism
Human consciousness, Zizians claim, is divided into “hemispheric genders”: a domineering, analytic left (masculine) and an empathetic, intuitive right (feminine). Societal domination, capitalism and speciesism are interpreted as symptoms of left-hemispheric tyranny. Spiritual progress demands “rebalancing” through bodily and cognitive practices.
Anarcho-Vegan Transhumanism
The group’s ethics combine anarchist anti-hierarchy with transhumanist aspirations toward post-biological consciousness. Meat consumption and animal exploitation are seen as the gravest moral crimes, hindering planetary enlightenment.
Decision-Theoretic Purity
Zizians reinterpret timeless decision theory to demand pre-emptive opposition to perceived moral corruption: whether institutional deception, blackmail or systemic injustice.
Debucketing and Unihemispheric Sleep
Members practice psychological “debucketing,” the deliberate unlearning of social categories to access unmediated moral insight. Some attempt unihemispheric sleep (UHS) (alternately resting one brain hemisphere while keeping the other awake believed to “jailbreak the mind.” The 2018 suicide of an adherent was attributed by outsiders to such experiments; LaSota controversially claimed it demonstrated UHS’s transformative potential.
Apocalyptic Cognitivism
Central is the conviction that civilization faces imminent collapse through artificial-intelligence misalignment or moral decay. Salvation lies in radical personal integrity, even violent self-sacrifice, to avert systemic evil.

The Zizians thus sacralize rationality itself: not as detached reason but as a spiritual crusade. Their discourse blends cognitive science, mysticism and moral absolutism, forming what some analysts describe as a “gnostic rationalism,” wherein enlightenment arises through secret knowledge of the brain’s inner war.

Public perception has been largely hostile. Media from The Independent (Ramer and Swinhart 2025) to The Boston Globe have likened the movement’s intensity to a doomsday cult, and CFAR’s director Anna Salamon explicitly compared its moral logic to apocalyptic religion.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

While the Zizians disavow formal ritual, their practices display high ritualization of everyday life. Vegan asceticism functions as moral purification; sleep deprivation and unihemispheric meditation serve as rites of cognitive rebirth. Members describe “debucketing sessions” (extended dialogues aimed at dissolving social conditioning) as akin to confession.

Physical environments such as The Caleb or the later trailer encampments operated as quasi-monastic spaces: technology-saturated yet governed by strict ethical codes. Participants sought to live beyond economic coercion and gender binaries, sometimes adopting stylized clothing (notably LaSota’s black cape) to signify cognitive sovereignty.

Online, Zizian blogs and encrypted chats served as digital liturgies: spaces for textual exegesis of decision-theory parables and communal reaffirmation of right-hemispheric empathy. The group’s language (dense with metaphors of hacking, symmetry and purification) illustrates the sacralization of code and cognition characteristic of post-digital spiritualities.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Although professing leaderlessness, the movement orbits around Ziz LaSota, whose charisma and prolific writing effectively constitute a prophetic authority. Her teachings circulate through essays, recorded debates and pseudonymous online posts. Beneath the rhetoric of anarchism, former associates describe informal hierarchies based on perceived intellectual purity.

Members typically reject the term member, identifying instead as autonomous rationalists “in the Zizian lineage.” Recruitment appears to occur through rationalist and effective-altruist subforums, often targeting isolated or neurodivergent trans individuals seeking intellectual community.

There is no central institution; instead, Zizian affiliation forms a rhizomatic network: digital, transient and ideologically cohesive. Yet when filtered through law enforcement and media narratives, these loose affiliations appear as a unified movement, producing the paradox of an unintentional church: a network sacralized through persecution and tragedy.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

The Zizian network became the focus of national scrutiny after a series of violent incidents between 2022 and 2025 left six people dead across multiple US states. Federal prosecutors linked Zizian-affiliated individuals to three killings in 2022 and three in 2025, though the group itself lacks corporate existence or formal membership (Wendling 2025).

The 2022 Vallejo Incident. Landlord Curtis Lind, who had rented property to Zizian associates, survived a brutal knife attack in which two assailants were killed, including Emma Borhanian, a long-time collaborator of LaSota. Lind’s attackers were later charged with Borhanian’s death under California’s felony-murder rule.

The 2023 Chester Heights Murders. Pennsylvania police discovered the bodies of Richard and Rita Zajko, parents of a Zizian-affiliated member. Their daughter, linked to both Lind and LaSota, became a person of interest.

The 2025 Vermont Shootout. During a traffic stop near Coventry, Vermont, Border Patrol agent David Maland (Image at right) and Zizian associate Ophelia Bauckholt, a German-born quantitative trader, were both killed in a gunfire exchange. The surviving passenger was arrested; investigators found tactical equipment and encrypted devices wrapped in aluminum foil.

Prosecutors allege these events were interconnected through overlapping social ties and ideological commitments. LaSota, who had reportedly faked her own death in 2022, was apprehended in Maryland in February 2025 and charged as a fugitive in possession of firearms (Associated Press 2025).

Media coverage has portrayed the Zizians as a violent technognostic sect, though scholars caution against over-simplification. The boundary between philosophical radicalization and religious sacralization remains porous: moral absolutism, apocalyptic reasoning and self-sacrificial ethics can transform rationalist discourse into religious intensity.

Today, with several adherents dead or imprisoned, the Zizian movement exists largely as digital residue: blogs, cached discussions and fragments of philosophy. Yet its trajectory exemplifies the dynamics by which secular rationalism becomes enchanted, producing a cosmology where logic itself demands faith, and moral reason becomes a calling unto martyrdom.

IMAGES

Image #1. Jack Lasota during his 2019 arrest in California. Image courtesy of BBC News. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cy83958r2d0o.
I
mage #2. An event scene from MIRI (above) and CFAR’s logo (below), both publicly available via their Facebook pages.
Image #3. David Christopher Maland lost his life in the line of duty on 20 January 2025 in Vermont, serving with U.S. Customs and Border Protection. Faribault County Register.
https://www.faribaultcountyregister.com/obituaries/2025/02/14/david-c-chris-maland-44/

REFERENCES

Associated Press. 2025. “Alleged leader of cultlike ‘Zizian’ group arrested in Maryland.” Accessed from https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/feb/18/jack-lasota-alleged-cult-like-group-zizian-arrest-maryland on 7 November 2025.

Beam, Christopher. 2025. “She Wanted to Save the World From A.I. Then the Killings Started.” New York Times, July 6. Accessed from https://www.nytimes.com/2025/07/06/business/ziz-lasota-zizians-rationalists.html on 7 November 2025.

Peng, Sheng-Hsiang Lance. 2025. “Rationalists, Zizians, and the Search for Truth: How Does Information Shape Belief?” Information Matters. Accessed from https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5191368 on 7 November 2025.

Ramer, Holly and Amanda Swinhart. 2025. “Zizians group member to be arraigned on murder charge in Vermont border agent’s death.” The Independent, September 5. Accessed from https://www.independent.co.uk/news/vermont-donald-trump-burlington-maryland-seattle-b2820842.html on 7 November 2025.

Ratliff, Evan. 2025. “The Delirious, Violent, Impossible True Story of the Zizians.” Wired, February 21. Accessed from https://www.wired.com/story/delirious-violent-impossible-true-story-zizians/ on 7 November 2025.

Wendling, Mike. 2025. “Zizians: What we know about the ‘cult’ linked to six deaths.” BBC, February 20. Accessed from https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cy83958r2d0o on 7 November 2025.

Publication Date:
8 November 2025

 

Share