THIRD CONVENTION TIMELINE
1876: The first Mormon missionaries journeyed to Mexico.
1879: Plotino Rhodakanaty, the father of Mexican anarchy, briefly joined the Latter-day Saints in Mexico.
1885: The first polygamist Mormon Colony (Colonia Díaz) was founded in Northern Mexico.
1878 (June 10): Margarito Bautista was born in the town of Atlautla, in the state of Mexico, Mexico.
1901: Margarito Bautista converted to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
1902 (March 27): Bautista married Teresa Mendez.
1903: Bautista moved to the Mormon Colonies in Chihuahua, Mexico.
1910: Two months before the outbreak of the Mexican Revolution, Bautista and his family relocated to Mesa, Arizona.
1913: Bautista relocated to Salt Lake City, Utah.
1917: The Mexican Constitution of 1917 was ratified, with anticlerical measures to insure Mexican independence in religious matters.
1922: Bautista was made the president of the newly formed Spanish-speaking LDS congregation in Salt Lake City.
1922-1924: Bautista returned as a missionary to Mexico.
1924: Bautista returned to Salt Lake City and was involved in a fracas over indigenous leadership in the fledgling Spanish-speaking congregation there.
1926-1929: The Cristero War, a peasant uprising that protested the anticlericalism of the Mexican government, broke out in Mexico.
1932 (January 3): The First Convention was held in Mexico City.
1934 (February 11): The native Mormon leadership held a Second Convention and requested aid from church headquarters in Salt Lake City.
1935: Margarito Bautista repatriated to Mexico to publish his first book and he began organizing for a third convention
1936 (April 21): Harold Pratt, then Mexican Mission President, cautioned members against purchasing Bautista’s recently published book; The Third Convention met in Mexico City.
1937 (May 6-May 8): Leaders of the Third Convention were excommunicated from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints; conventionists withdrew from the mainstream Church, calling their new organization The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Third Convention.
1937: Margarito Bautista was expelled from the Third Convention for his promotion of polygamy.
1937-1946: The Third Convention grew through convert baptisms and the construction of chapels.
1942: Arwell L. Pierce was made president of the mainstream Mexican Mission. He worked toward reunification with the Third Conventionists.
1946: After ten years apart, the Third Convention reunified with the mainstream Church; George A. Smith, LDS president and prophet, visited Mexico to attend the reunification service.
FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY
As its name suggests, The Third Convention followed two other Conventions held in the early 1930s by indigenous Latter-Day Saints in the Mexican Mission. The first two Mexican conventions were held to discuss solutions for the pressing needs of local units of the LDS church in Mexico, such as chapel building, the collection of tithes, certificates of baptism, and the care of widows and orphans (Gomez, 2024). Minutes of the first two conventions suggest no friction between Mexican converts and the LDS church (Gomez 2024). Nevertheless, the church’s response to the Third Convention, held in Tecalco on April 21,1936, resulted in the separation of one-third of the approximately 2,400 Latter-Day Saints in Mexico from the mainstream church. This separation lasted ten years. At the heart of the Third Convention’s quarrel with the mainstream Church in Salt Lake City, lay the desire of conventionists to see an indigenous president appointed to lead the Mexican Mission.
The desire for ecclesiastical self-governance on the part of indigenous Mexicans was not peculiar to Latter-day Saints. Following the Mexican Revolution (1910-1917), Mexican cultural nationalists demanded indigenous leadership in government, industry, and churches. Additionally, beginning in the 1920s, anticlerical laws forbidding the functioning of foreign clergy in Mexico were enforced. These two factors empowered Mexican converts to petition for native leadership of the LDS Mission in Mexico.
Though several indigenous Latter-day Saints participated in the formation of the Third Convention, the founder of the Third Convention is generally held to have been Margarito Bautista. [Image at right] Margarito was born on June 10, 1878, in Atlautla, a small town on the slopes of the volcano Popocatépetl, located approximately forty-five miles southeast of Mexico City. His father, Jose de la Luz (Luz) Bautista was the elected mayor of Atlauta. Luz won the loyalty of local farmers in 1901, when he helped them legally defend their communal farmlands from the machinations of a local hacendado, who sought to annex ejidal (communal) lands into the Hacienda de Guadalupe Guadalupe (Bautista 1936, de Olarte 2013). This was not an unusual occurrence during the administration of Mexican President Porfirio Díaz, who in his efforts to industrialize Mexico confiscated many ejidos and awarded them to wealthy landowners. Without these lands, Mexican peasants had little choice but to work for wealthy hacendados (owners of haciendas), and, as a result, often fell into debt peonage.
Bautista’s mother, Candelaria, was Nahua and spoke only Nahuatl. Her dying request was that Margarito see to the ordination of the gente (people). While Luz protected the land, Candelaria’s request reflected her longing for her son to help undo four hundred years (1519-1917) of lost ecclesiastical leadership for indigenous Mexicans.
After the conquest of Mexico, colonizers forced conversion upon Mexicans and then subjected them to a xenophobic religious patrimony. This situation prompted Mexicans to seek spiritual autonomy on many fronts: through indigenous movements such as rebellions and revolutions led by indigenous spiritual leaders (both Catholic and pagan); through supernatural means such as miracles; and through lay-led religious communities and combinative folk practices.
The members of the Third Convention who petitioned for indigenous leadership in the Mexican Mormon Mission came from the most radical nationalists among Mexican members of the church. Many of them resided in towns on the slopes of Popocatepetl in the southeast region of the state of Mexico, including Ozumba, Amecameca, Zoyatzingo, Tepetlixpa, and Atlautla (Bautista’s birthplace) (de Olarte 2013). Small farmers in this area had been taught agrarian socialism and the principles of resistance in the mid to late 1860s by Plotino Rhodakanaty, the intellectual father of Mexican anarchy.
Rhodakanaty was a Greek philologist, who immigrated to Mexico in 1861 hoping to establish a communalist colony and to promote labor resistance, local political governance, and socialism among Mexicans. In 1865, he established a school in Chalco, a small farming community on the Central Plateau. There he taught basic academic skills, alongside principles of rhetoric, and organizational skills for resistance to campesinos (peasants) already disposed to support the communal ownership of property and land reform. As a result, it was Rhodakanaty who inculcated the activism of peasants on the Central Plateau with a philosophical core, one which demanded the return of ejidal farmlands and opposed centralized federal government in favor of local rule (Hart 1987).
Interestingly, Rhodakanaty joined The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints for a brief period in 1879, hoping that hierarchs in Utah would fund his own communalist experiment. Mormons had, after all, successfully built over 700 colonies in the American wilderness. Rhodakanaty’s insistence on local control over his proposed colony, however, set him at variance with the LDS Church and precipitated his departure from the church. Long after Rhodakanaty left Mexico, his ideology continued to fuel peasant uprisings on Mexico’s Central Plateau, including those led by Emiliano Zapata.
Alternative opportunities for indigenous religious leadership finally appeared in Mexico in the 1870s. From 1871 to 1874, Quakers, Northern Baptists, Congregationalists, Northern and Southern Presbyterians, and Northern and Southern Methodists all established missions in Mexico (Baldwin 1990). Methodist missionaries who arrived in Central Mexico followed ancient trade routes from Mexico City to farming villages on the central Plateau. For Mexico’s Indigenous populations, one of the attractions of foreign missionary movements was the availability of an education, followed by the possibility of ordination and a job as a minister. Latter-day Saints also began proselytizing in Mexico about this time (1875). They followed the same trade routes up to farming communities built on the slopes of the twin volcanos Popocatepetl and Iztaccihuatl.

Margarito first gravitated toward the teachings of Methodists congregation-building near Atlautla. Though the Methodists invited him to enter the ministry, he had already begun to converse with Latter-day Saint missionaries. He quickly became captivated by the Book of Mormon (1841), [Image at right] which reimagined the native peoples of the Americas as lost Israelites. Luz Bautista opposed his son’s interest in Mormonism, as Latter-day Saints, while offering ordination to a lay ministry, offered no education and had no positions for paid clergy, opportunities which Luz believed would help his son secure a stable financial future.
Margarito ultimately joined the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in 1901 after a faith healing performed by then Mexican Mission president Ammon Tenney. Immediately following his baptism, Margarito began proselytizing other Mexicans into the LDS fold. In 1903, he moved 1,000 miles to the Mormon Colonies in Mexico’s northern wilderness, where he learned more about the LDS gospel from Latter-day Saints who had come to Mexico from Utah to practice polygamy. In 1910, he moved to Mesa, Arizona two months before the outbreak of the Mexican Revolution (1910-1917). By 1914, Bautista decided to move his family further north to Salt Lake City, where employers paid Mexican laborers higher wages.
Everywhere he went, Bautista proselytized Mexicans expatriates and helped to found Spanish-speaking congregations for the Latter-day Saint Church. In Utah, Margarito learned English, proselytized, and benefitted from ecclesiastical leadership opportunities. While he spoke publicly on Mexican politics and promoted support for Mexican rebels, his family members and friends fought in Mexico. Luz Bautista was a courier and spy for rebel forces, and at one point faced a federalist firing squad, but was saved by the tears of his townspeople (de Olarte 2013). Nevertheless, it is estimated that between 1,000,000 and 3,000,000 casualties occurred during the war. At the height of the violence (1915), life expectancy in Mexico sank to between fifteen and twenty years of age.
In 1922, Margarito was named Branch President of The Local Mexican Mission in Salt Lake City, a small congregation of Spanish-speaking Latter-day Saint converts, most of whom were Mexican expatriates working in the United States. Margarito’s tenure as the president of The Local Mexican Mission in Salt Lake City, however, was short-lived. He returned to Mexico as a missionary in 1922, where he garnered some fame among indigenous Latter-day Saints as an eloquent speaker. They also admired his acquaintance with prophets and apostles in Salt Lake City, his bilingualism, his expertise in portions of the LDS cannon not yet translated into Spanish, and his familiarity with the esoteric rites of LDS temples.
At the conclusion of his mission in 1924, he returned to Salt Lake City to find that he had been replaced as the president of The Local Mexican Mission by Francisco Solano, a Spanish convert. Rivalries formed in the congregation and a power struggle ensued, which coincided with Bautista’s return. It is likely that the appointment of a European leader in the Mexican branch of the Church rankled in the minds of many congregants. To put an end to divisions, the Church hierarchy removed all Spanish-surnamed leadership from this congregation for a period of forty years. Margarito’s name disappeared permanently from the minutes of the branch from 1924 onward.
With no pulpit to expound from, Bautista found a new platform for his personal melding of the indigenous history of Mexico and The Book of Mormon (1841 [1830]) in his authorship of a 564-page tome entitled The Spiritual Evolution of Mexico: Her True Ancestors, and Her Origen: The Destiny of America and Europe (1935). In this book, Bautista argued that Mexicans were transplanted Israelites, who had suffered under Spanish rule to atone for their practice of human sacrifice. He blended Book of Mormon narratives with commonly used history textbooks, which would have been familiar to anyone who had attended secondary school in Mexico. He further asserted that a just God would one day also mete out retribution to Mexico’s unrepentant oppressors (i.e. European colonizers and their descendants) for centuries of slavery, injustice, abuse, and the theft of aboriginal lands. Though Mexicans had lost the prerogative of rule centuries before, the Mexican Revolution had now prepared them to rise on the world stage. According to Bautista, the Book of Mormon (1841) outlined a simple, yet prophetic program for the development of Mexico: obey God and prosper.
Bautista’s tome also argued that, beyond Mexico, world peace largely depended on whether Gentiles (Europeans and Euro-Americans) were willing to recompense the indigenous inhabitants of all the nations they had colonized and give up their quest for world dominance. He insisted they “must voluntarily RETURN what they have stolen,” though he made no suggestion for the practical application of this formula for peace. He quoted the Book of Mormon (1841) in asserting that unrepentant colonizers would lose spiritual knowledge if they were to continue to be prideful: to continue their lying, deceiving, hypocrisy, murders, priest crafts, whoredoms, and secret abominations. Though God used colonizers to punish unbelieving natives, God would in due time punish unrepentant colonizers with sore destruction and return sovereignty of the land to its original inhabitants. All of this was to occur before the Second Coming. Ultimately, indigenous peoples would build the New Jerusalem on the North American continent and help usher in Christ’s millennial reign.
In 1935, Bautista repatriated to Mexico, hoping to find a publisher for his book. The goal was to proselytize Mexicans in print and to convince them not only of their future roles as world leaders, but also of their destiny to build the Holy City. Bautista travelled to many Latter-day Saint congregations in Central Mexico to read chapters of his book at local fireside meetings in the homes of friends and acquaintances. His readings were enthusiastically attended by indigenous Latter-day Saints, who, like Bautista, had great post-revolutionary hopes for the future of Mexico and Mexicans.
As he travelled throughout Central Mexico, Bautista visited with and garnered support from indigenous converts who also held nationalistic aspirations. Their collaborative goal was to gather indigenous Latter-day Saints at an assembly known as the Third Convention and to collectively petition the presidency of the Church in Salt Lake City to replace the Anglo president of the Mexican mission with a native Mexican. The previously mentioned first and second conventions in the Mexican mission had occurred on January 3, 1932, and February 11, 1934, while Bautista was living in Salt Lake City. Minutes of these conventions reveal concerns over the collection of tithes, the construction of chapels and the care of widows and orphans. The Third convention, however, was openly critical of Anglo leadership, and petitioned for change, going so far as to suggest a suitable candidate for the mission presidency. Though this development shocked both the mission leadership and the white hierarchy in Salt Lake City, it was not an unusual demand in other denominations; in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century, Mexican Catholics, Protestants, and Pentecostals in the U.S./Mexico borderlands all resisted the oversight of Euro-American leaders within the missions that had converted them (Baldwin 1990; Espinosa 2008).
Many of the Mexican Mormons who supported the Third Convention had fought in the Mexican Revolution under the banner of Emiliano Zapata. During the Revolution, their religious differences were respected and they developed leadership skills. Like other Mexican cultural nationalists of their era, they believed that Mexicans could and should lead their own government, industries, and missions. The idea of ecclesiastical self-governance for Mexicans was further supported by the Mexican Constitution of 1917, which barred foreign clerics from operating in Mexico (Article 130). Though designed to curtail the power of the Catholic Church in Mexico, Article 130 applied to religious leaders from any foreign-based denomination. Article 9 also granted Mexican citizens the right to submit petitions to organizations to which they belonged.
Margarito published his tome in 1936, approximately six weeks prior to the first meeting of the Third Convention. On March 11, 1936, he sent copies of his book to Mexican Mission President, Harold W. Pratt. Pratt asserted that the text promoted the establishment of a national Church in Mexico and he wrote to Salt Lake City recommending that the Church not endorse the book. Pratt also distributed a circular to congregations within the mission, advising members that La evolución did not have the endorsement of the Church and was therefore not official literature (Tullis 1997). This circular had disastrous consequences for book sales among Mexican Mormons, a situation which not only affected Bautista but all those who had donated or lent funds for its publication. Many have speculated that Margarito’s anger over Pratt’s response to his book led to the formation of the Third Convention. However, Bautista’s 1935-1936 diaries evidence that he had already begun planning this convention with other indigenous Latter-day Saints shortly after his 1935 arrival in Mexico.
On April 21, 1936, approximately 120 Mexican Mormons gathered in Tecalco for the first meeting of the Third Convention. The meeting was attended by Mexican members living on Mexico’s Central Plateau, as well as by leaders of several congregations, including Narciso Sandoval, branch president in San Gabriel; Agricol Lozano, branch president in San Marcos; Felipe Barragán, branch president in Tecalco; Faustino Amaro, branch president of Tepecoculco; Demitrio de la Rosa, branch president in Amecameca; and Pilar Páez, first counselor to the Branch President in Mexico City. These branch presidents brought members of their own congregations with them. Also in attendance was Ábel Páez, Bautista’s nephew and a counselor in the district presidency, which operated directly under the auspices of the Mission president, while overseeing the activities of the branch presidents.
While the main goal of the movement was to secure the leadership of an indigenous mission president in Mexico, secondary goals included the building of chapels and schools, publishing Church literature in Spanish, and the creation of opportunities for Mexican youth to act as missionaries for the Church. Conventionists also believed that a native mission president would be more understanding of the needs of Mexicans and more dedicated to the proselytizing of Mexicans. There was also a concern over a lack of respect for the autonomy of Mexican members when given assignments, and heavy-handed censure when LDS Mexicans took initiative to improve the life of the community, such as publishing a newsletter without the permission of the mission president.
Bautista also read letters to the attendees from the other two members of the District Presidency: President Isaías Juarez and Bernabé Parra, a counselor. Juarez’s letter stated that though the cause was just, The Conventionists’ method was without the backing of the district presidency and therefore could have “fatal” consequences for the Church. Bautista scorned this notion, stating that “procedure was a secondary thing” and they “were not criticizing nor censoring anyone” nor were they violating the law.
During the meeting, Members of the Third Convention unanimously voted that they needed “to have a Mission President distinctly of Mexican race.” Two candidates were nominated for the position: Ábel Páez and Margarito Bautista. Bautista declined the nomination and made a statement in support of Páez, whose nomination was seconded. Páez was unanimously voted a candidate for the position of Mexican mission president, and his name was submitted to Church authorities in Sat Lake City.
After the meeting in Tecalco, Margarito painstakingly edited the proceedings of the inaugural meeting. The minutes of the meeting were signed by eighty-two attendees. On behalf of the Directive Board of the Third Convention, the minutes and a letter to the First Presidency of the Church listing the grievances of the Conventionists was sent to church headquarters in Salt Lake City. This letter inferred that Euro-American Mormons had appropriated the historical heritage of indigenous Americans, namely the Book of Mormon (1841), while ungratefully orphaning the descendants of the authors of the Church’s primary scriptural work. They further stated that they languished under the paternalism of the Euro-American Church simply because they were Mexicans and that this paternalism was, overtly stated, racial prejudice. Bautista included a personal letter to Church President Heber J. Grant denying accusations that he had repatriated to Mexico specifically to organize the third convention. This missive was followed by an exchange of terse letters between the First Presidency of the Church and the Conventionists.
Conventionists had hoped to remain in the mainstream Church while initiating a change in church policy though petition. Like many Mexican members, Bautista held the opinion that Mexico’s Constitution gave Conventionists the right to air their ecclesiastical grievances in assemblies. In fact, the Mexican Constitution of 1917 stated in Article Nine: “No assembly or meeting which has as its object the petitioning of any authority or the presentation of a protest against any act shall be deemed unlawful; nor may it be dissolved . . .” As far as the Conventionists were concerned, assembling to petition “any authority” included religious authorities.
As this meeting was held without the authorization of the Mexican Mission Presidency, it was seen as an act of rebellion by the mainstream church. In November of 1936, J. Rueben Clark, a member of the First Presidency of the LDS Church and a former U.S. Ambassador to Mexico, sent a letter in response to all congregations in Mexico, declaring that petitioning the Church, as had the Conventionists, was completely out of order. Mission Presidents were the representatives of the President of the Church; they were not representatives of the members.
While the demand for an indigenous mission president was shocking to the LDS hierarchy, it was not an unusual desire on the part of indigenous Mexicans who had converted to foreign missionary movements. For example, when Protestant missionaries from the U.S. fled Mexico during the Revolution, Mexican ministers admirably demonstrated their leadership skills, shepherding congregations through the conflict.
In February of 1937, Antoine R. Ivins and George F. Richards, both apostles sent by LDS headquarters, arrived in Mexico. Ivins and Richards at first agreed to speak to the Conventionists, although under the Mexican Constitution, foreign clerics were not allowed to address bodies of Mexicans. However, a rumor began to circulate that Conventionist leaders planned to have them both arrested at that meeting. As a result, both men quickly returned to the U.S. Ivins’ and Richards’ report displeased the First Presidency, who made the decision to excommunicate leaders of the Third Convention. Harold Pratt, the current Mexican Mission President, distributed the remarks Richards had planned to give, which told Mexican Latter-day Saints to fall in line with the advice of the authorities of the centralized church, or risk excommunication.
in early May of 1937, eleven months after the meeting of the Third Convention, the church began excommunicating all leaders of the Convention movement for rebellion, insubordination and apostacy. After the excommunication of their leaders, those who supported the goals of the Convention were forced to choose between the mainstream Church and the Convention itself. Nearly a third of the membership of the Church in Mexico (800 persons), decided to break from the Salt Lake-lead church, forming a new entity called The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Third Convention, with Abel Páez as their leader. After the divide, relations between the two sides became acrimonious, one side viewing the Conventionists as heretics and Conventionists viewing those who remained with the mainstream church as turning their backs on the need for native leadership. Páez continued as the leader of the Conventionists for the next nine years, during which the Conventionists added 400 new members through proselytization and births. They organized fifteen congregations, built six chapels where they held their own religious services, and trained a small group of young missionaries (Tullis 1997).
Harold Pratt was replaced by A. Lorenzo Anderson as president of the LDS Mexican Mission in 1938. However, acrimony between the Conventionists and non-Conventionists did not begin to subside until May of 1942 when Arwell L. Pierce was assigned to be the president of the mainstream LDS mission in Mexico. Pierce recognized that the Latter-day Saints could bring back more members to the mainstream church than they could baptize. He established a policy of friendliness and cooperation between the two groups. He instructed all missionaries to focus their efforts on healing the schism and preventing further rifts by offering service and showing respect. He sold Conventionists hymnals and Books of Mormon, attended both mainstream and Conventionists’ services, and instructed the missionaries he oversaw to do the same. He invited Conventionists to his home and shared news from Salt Lake with them.
Pierce also pointed out the advantages reunification would prove to members of the Convention as the mainstream church was sure to build temples in Mexico in the future. Temple building would require funds conventionists did not have, and membership in the mainstream church was necessary to participate in Mormonism’s most sacred rites, those performed only in temples. Such rituals were already being performed in Spanish in an LDS temple in Mesa, Arizona.
In 1943, Apostle David O. McKay traveled from Utah to tour Mormon congregations in Mexico. While he visited mainstream meetings and members, he also visited the home of Othon Espinosa, a leader of the Third Convention to give a health blessing to an ill family member. At the conclusion of World War II in 1945, returning American soldiers swelled the missionary ranks in Mexico. That same year, George Albert Smith became the world-wide President of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. It fell to Smith to unite the church in regions of the world that had fought against each other as enemies during the war. His emphasis was on love and forgiveness; this same attitude characterized the approach he took with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Third Convention in Mexico (Tullis 1997-1998).
By 1945, cracks in Conventionists’ loyalty to Abel Páez began to appear as Abel’s health began to deteriorate. Staunch leaders such as Apolonio B. Arzate, the Convention’s printer, and Othon Espinosa tired of the Convention’s infighting. Pierce pressed this advantage, using Arzate for mainstream mission printing jobs. Pierce also offered Convention leaders rides in his automobile and argued that what Mexico needed was not a Mexican Mission President, as mission presidents oversaw the planted congregations. Those congregations were turned over to the leadership of a stake (diocese) president as they became strong enough to stand on their own. Mexicans, he argued, needed a stake president as the Hawaiians already had. Pierce had priesthood manuals translated into Spanish, organized new mission districts under local control, and set up leadership training seminars so that Mexicans congregations could become independent of the control of a mission president. Pierce worked hard to address the original complaints of the Conventionists and to simultaneously soften the view of the mainstream hierarchy in Salt Lake City (Tullis 1997).
In contemplating possible reunification, Conventionist leaders wondered how they could return to the mainstream fold while maintaining their dignidad. Pierce reframed the split with the mainstream church as steps taken toward Mexican church leadership in Mexico. He argued that Salt Lake was paying attention. He also managed to bring about an ecclesiastical review of the excommunications of the leadership of the Third Convention. As a result, the First Presidency of the Church changed the status of the leaders to disfellowshipped. Thus, they did not need re-baptism to rejoin the mainstream church. Only new members proselytized into the Convention during its ten-year existence were required to have their baptisms ratified by a new baptismal ceremony. Most of these baptisms were performed by Pierce himself.
Reunification services were held in two locations: On Sunday, April 26, 1936, the first reunification meeting took place in a meeting house in Tecalco. The following week approximately 1,200 Conventionists (all most all the Conventionists) reunited with the LDS Church at a second reunification meeting in Mexico City, seat of the Mexican Mission headquarters. George Albert Smith’s attendance at the meetings, made him the first Mormon prophet ever to visit Mexico. Though many expected a message of reproof, he spoke of harmony and kindness and invited Ábel Páez, leader of the Conventionists to address the crowd. Páez spoke of the progress both groups would make together. There were a few disgruntled members, but the majority were pleased to put differences aside and to reunited with former acquaintances.
Post Reunification, Pierce addressed the need for indigenous leadership in Mexico by appointing a Comité de Consejo y Bienestar (a Counsel and Welfare Committee), which included former Conventionists Abel Páez and Apolonio Arzate alongside non-Conventionists Isaías Juárez, Guadalupe Zárraga, and Bernabé Parra. It was not until 1968, however, that Agricol Lozano, a former Conventionist, was appointed the first Mexican Stake President in Mexico. This appointment heralded the exponential growth of Mormonism in Mexico.
DOCTRINES/BELIEFS
Though the mainstream church in Mexico and the Conventionists differed on the immediate role native Mexicans should take in the leadership of the mission, the two groups were still very similar in doctrine and in practice. Conventionists and mainstream Mexican Latter-day Saints both shared the same Articles of Faith. This meant both sides rejected the three-in-one doctrine of the trinity, the doctrine of original sin, and infant baptism. Conversely, they both believed in the physical embodiment of God and the restoration of the priesthood through Joseph Smith. Conventionists also revered the same scriptural canon they had as members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (the Bible, the Book of Mormon (1841), and the revelations of Joseph Smith).
Mexican Latter-day Saints, whether mainstream members of the LDS Church or Conventionists, cherished Book of Mormon narratives, which they felt described the journey of their ancestors to the Americas in 600BC, three years prior to the Babylonian conquest of Jerusalem (597BC). In the Americas, the Israelite ancestors of the Mexicans created great civilizations and weathered great destructions. In the meridian of time, they were visited by the resurrected Jesus and thereafter established a utopian society that endured for 200 years.
The Book of Mormon (1841) ends with mass destructions and a prophecy of colonization by cruel oppressors. Both Conventionists and mainstream Latter-day Saints in Mexico believed that Mexico would be redeemed and Mexicans would play important roles before the Second Coming of Christ. Conventionists, however, believed that indigenous Mexicans needed to prepare for higher levels of leadership by developing hands-on skills in the present.
In the 1930s, the same decade that saw the rise of The Third Convention in Mexico, the British Israel movement had become popular in the United States. This movement promoted the idea that the Lost Tribes of Israel came to England. This notion convinced many Latter-day Saints in the U.S. that though the Book of Mormon (1841) describes European colonizers as “Gentiles,” descendants of British colonialists descended from their own branch of “Lost Israelites.” Therefore, the need to convert indigenous peoples to help build the New Jerusalem was less pressing, or, as J. Ruben Clark argued, God had other “Israelites” to choose from. While Conventionists and mainstream Mexicans differed over when Mexicans should develop leadership skills. J. Ruben Clark and like-minded Latter-day Saints in the U.S. differed with Conventionists and many mainstream members in Mexico over who would be leaders in the days leading up to the millennium.
RITUALS/PRACTICES
Conventionists retained the same rituals and practices as the mainstream congregations, They read the same scriptural canon, even teaching members English so that they could read mainstream Church manuals and sacred documents, such as the revelations of Joseph Smith, that had not been translated into English. Conventionists sang the same hymns, uttered the same sacramental prayers, and structured their worship services in the same manner as the mainstream church. Though the resources of the LDS Church in Salt Lake City were not available to them, Third Conventionists nevertheless donated the land and labor required to build six chapels from 1936 to 1946 where they held weekly worship services. They continued to bless infants, to baptize new members by immersion, to and confirm new members by the laying on of hands.
ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP
After the excommunication of five of the Convention’s leaders, the Convention separated themselves from the mainstream Church. Consequently, The Third Convention was made up of families and congregations who made joint decisions to either support or not support the Third Convention. Their support for the Convention was largely a manifestation of their support for their local, excommunicated branch presidents. Abel Páez continued as their leader, despite his excommunication as did other leaders of Conventionists’ congregations. As they had before the schism, they ordained men to offices in the priesthood and organized priesthood quorum’s, women’s auxiliaries, and programs for youth and children. They also taught proselytizing skills to young adults and had a vigorous missionary program, growing their membership numbers from 800 to 1200 in a period of ten years (Tullis 1997).
ISSUES/CHALLENGES
Though Third Conventionists struggled without the resources of the mainstream Church, most of the hardship they experienced resulted from internal conflict between leaders of the Convention. While Margarito Bautista figured prominently in the formation of the Third Convention, his influence was short-lived. A few months after the Third Convention’s formal break with the mainstream Church, it was discovered that he was surreptitiously enlistimg polygamist wives, some of whom were daughters of Convention leaders. Conventionists were not interested in adopting discontinued Mormon marital practices that had never been used by indigenous Latter-day Saints In Central Mexico. When the first Mormon polygamists came to colonize in northern Mexico, (1885), Mexican President Porfirio Díaz agreed to allow them entry if they would not introduce polygamy to native Mexicans. As a result, polygamy in Mexico was confined to Anglo colonies in the northern desert. Outrage over Bautista’s covert introduction of the ideals of polygamy to young females resulted in his expulsion from the Convention.
After his departure, Bautista, as an independent missionary, continued to preach his personal amalgamation of the Book of Mormon (1841) and Mexican History, along with polygamy, and communalism. He attempted to proselytize Conventionists to his new movement but had little success. Another leader of the Convention, Branch President Daniel Mejía, broke with the group to found his own polygamist colony in the farming town of Cuautla de Morelos. He brought several members of his congregation with him. This community lasted until his colonists rebelled against him to rejoin the mainstream Church in 1945.
Toward the end of the ten-year existence of the Convention, other leaders, such as physician and printer Apolonio Arzate and Othon Espinosa, began to drift away from the Convention toward the leadership of Pierce. Abel Páez’s failing health was certainly a factor, but the resources Pierce had to offer, as well as changing attitudes on the part of the LDS hierarchy certainly played a role in shifting loyalties.
IMAGES
Image #1: Bautista Margarito. Credit: Public Domain.
Image #2: Front page of The Book of Mormon, 1841 edition. Credit: Public Domain.
REFERENCES
Baldwin, Deborah J. 1990. Protestants and the Mexican Revolution: Missionaries, Ministers and Social Change. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
Bautista, Margarito. Diaries, 1935-1937. Enriqueta and Fernando Gomez Collection, Honnold Library, Claremont Graduate University.
Bautista, Margarito. 1935 [printed 1936]. La evolución de México; sus verdaderos progenitores y su origen; el destino de América y Europa. Distrito Federal: Arzate Brothers.
Comite Directivo. 1936. Informe General de la Tercera Convención de los Miembros de la Iglasia de Jesu-Cristo de los Santos de los Ultimos Días Celebrada en Tecalco, México, el 21 de abril de 1936 y que fué enviado a la Primera Presidencia para su resolución.
Espinosa, Gastón. 2008. “Brown Moses: Francisco Olazabel and Mexican American Pentecostal Healing in the Borderlands. Pp. 263-95 in Mexican American Religions: Spirituality, Activism, and Culture, edited by Gastón Espinosa and Mario T. García. Durham: Duke University Press.
Gomez, Fernando R. 2024. A Documentary History of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in Mexico, 1875-1946. Waltham, MA: By Common Consent Press.
Hart, John Mason. 1987. Anarchism and the Mexican Working Class, 1860-1931. Austin: University of Texas Press.
Mexico. 1917. English translation of the new Mexican Constitution: effective from May 5th, 1917. Accessed from https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=ien.35556003545423&seq=5 on 23 September 2026.
Mexican Mission Record of Members, circa 1920-1940. 8:1147, 1169. Church History Library, Salt Lake City, Utah. Call number LR 5506 7.
Pulido, Elisa Eastwood. 2021. “Margarito Bautista, Mexican Politics and The Third Convention.” Mormon Studies Review January:48-56.
Pulido, Elisa Eastwood. 2020. The Spiritual Evolution of Margarito Bautista: Mexican Mormon Evangelizer, Polygamist Dissident, and Utopian Founder, 1878-1961. New York: Oxford University Press.
Pulido, Elisa Eastwood. 2015. “Solving Schism in Nepantla: The Third Convention Returns to the LDS Fold.” Pp. 89-110 in Just South of Zion, edited by Jason H. Dormady and Jared M. Tamez. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press.
Pulido, Elisa Eastwood. n.d. “Mormonism in Mexico.” The Mormonism in Migration Project. Claremont Graduate University. Accessed from https://research.cgu.edu/mormonism-migration-project/study-resources/mormonism-in-mexico/#_ednref36 on 21 September 2026.
The Book of Mormon. 1841. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. First European edition.
Spencer de Olarte, Moroni Hernandez. 2013. “Ya llegaron los de Tierra Fria…”: Los colores del Zapatismo en la Región de lo Volcanes, Estado de México.” M.A. thesis, Universidad Autónoma Metropolitan.
Tullis, F. Lamond. 1997-1998. “A Shepherd to Mexico’s Saints: Arwell L. Pierce and the Third Convention.” BYU Studies 37:1. Accessed from https://byustudies.byu.edu/article/a-shepherd-to-mexicos-saints-arwell-l-pierce-and-the-third-convention on 21 September 2026.
Tullis, F. Lamond. 1997. Mormonism in Mexico: The Dynamics of Faith and Culture. Second Edition. Provo: Museo de Historia del Mormonismo en México.
Publication Date:
18 October 2026