Elisa Eastwood Pulido

Elisa Eastwood Pulido is a religious historian. She received her PhD in Religious Studies from Claremont Graduate University in 2015 and taught World Religions at BYU, Salt Lake Center from 2016–2019. Her first book, The Spiritual Evolution of Margarito Bautista: Mexican Mormon Evangelist, Polygamist Dissident, and Utopian Founder, 1878-1961, was published by Oxford University Press in 2020. She has published articles and given lectures and podcasts on various aspects of Mormonism in Mexico in the early twentieth century.

 

Share

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, Third Convention

THIRD CONVENTION TIMELINE

1876:  The first Mormon missionaries journeyed to Mexico.

1879:  Plotino Rhodakanaty, the father of Mexican anarchy, briefly joined the Latter-day Saints in Mexico.

1885:  The first polygamist Mormon Colony (Colonia Díaz) was founded in Northern Mexico.

1878 (June 10):  Margarito Bautista was born in the town of Atlautla, in the state of Mexico, Mexico.

1901:  Margarito Bautista converted to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

1902 (March 27):  Bautista married Teresa Mendez.

1903:  Bautista moved to the Mormon Colonies in Chihuahua, Mexico.

1910:  Two months before the outbreak of the Mexican Revolution, Bautista and his family relocated to Mesa, Arizona.

1913:  Bautista relocated to Salt Lake City, Utah.

1917:  The Mexican Constitution of 1917 was ratified, with anticlerical measures to insure Mexican independence in religious matters.

1922:  Bautista was made the president of the newly formed Spanish-speaking LDS congregation in Salt Lake City.

1922-1924:  Bautista returned as a missionary to Mexico.

1924: Bautista returned to Salt Lake City and was involved in a fracas over indigenous leadership in the fledgling Spanish-speaking congregation there.

1926-1929:  The Cristero War, a peasant uprising that protested the anticlericalism of the Mexican government, broke out in Mexico.

1932 (January 3):  The First Convention was held in Mexico City.

1934 (February 11):  The native Mormon leadership held a Second Convention and requested aid from church headquarters in Salt Lake City.

1935:  Margarito Bautista repatriated to Mexico to publish his first book and he began organizing for a third convention

1936 (April 21):  Harold Pratt, then Mexican Mission President, cautioned members against purchasing Bautista’s recently published book; The Third Convention met in Mexico City.

1937 (May 6-May 8):  Leaders of the Third Convention were excommunicated from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints; conventionists withdrew from the mainstream Church, calling their new organization The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Third Convention.

1937:  Margarito Bautista was expelled from the Third Convention for his promotion of polygamy.

1937-1946:  The Third Convention grew through convert baptisms and the construction of chapels.

1942:  Arwell L. Pierce was made president of the mainstream Mexican Mission. He worked toward reunification with the Third Conventionists.

1946:  After ten years apart, the Third Convention reunified with the mainstream Church; George A. Smith, LDS president and prophet, visited Mexico to attend the reunification service.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

As its name suggests, The Third Convention followed two other Conventions held in the early 1930s by indigenous Latter-Day Saints in the Mexican Mission. The first two Mexican conventions were held to discuss solutions for the pressing needs of local units of the LDS church in Mexico, such as chapel building, the collection of tithes, certificates of baptism, and the care of widows and orphans (Gomez, 2024). Minutes of the first two conventions suggest no friction between Mexican converts and the LDS church (Gomez 2024). Nevertheless, the church’s response to the Third Convention, held in Tecalco on April 21,1936, resulted in the separation of one-third of the approximately 2,400 Latter-Day Saints in Mexico from the mainstream church. This separation lasted ten years. At the heart of the Third Convention’s quarrel with the mainstream Church in Salt Lake City, lay the desire of conventionists to see an indigenous president appointed to lead the Mexican Mission.

The desire for ecclesiastical self-governance on the part of indigenous Mexicans was not peculiar to Latter-day Saints.  Following the Mexican Revolution (1910-1917), Mexican cultural nationalists demanded indigenous leadership in government, industry, and churches. Additionally, beginning in the 1920s, anticlerical laws forbidding the functioning of foreign clergy in Mexico were enforced. These two factors empowered Mexican converts to petition for native leadership of the LDS Mission in Mexico.

Though several indigenous Latter-day Saints participated in the formation of the Third Convention, the founder of the Third Convention is generally held to have been Margarito Bautista. [Image at right] Margarito was born on June 10, 1878, in Atlautla, a small town on the slopes of the volcano Popocatépetl, located approximately forty-five miles southeast of Mexico City. His father, Jose de la Luz (Luz) Bautista was the elected mayor of Atlauta. Luz won the loyalty of local farmers in 1901, when he helped them legally defend their communal farmlands from the machinations of a local hacendado, who sought to annex ejidal (communal) lands into the Hacienda de Guadalupe Guadalupe (Bautista 1936, de Olarte 2013). This was not an unusual occurrence during the administration of Mexican President Porfirio Díaz, who in his efforts to industrialize Mexico confiscated many ejidos and awarded them to wealthy landowners. Without these lands, Mexican peasants had little choice but to work for wealthy hacendados (owners of haciendas), and, as a result, often fell into debt peonage.

Bautista’s mother, Candelaria, was Nahua and spoke only Nahuatl. Her dying request was that Margarito see to the ordination of the gente (people). While Luz protected the land, Candelaria’s request reflected her longing for her son to help undo four hundred years (1519-1917) of lost ecclesiastical leadership for indigenous Mexicans.

After the conquest of Mexico, colonizers forced conversion upon Mexicans and then subjected them to a xenophobic religious patrimony. This situation prompted Mexicans to seek spiritual autonomy on many fronts: through indigenous movements such as rebellions and revolutions led by indigenous spiritual leaders (both Catholic and pagan); through supernatural means such as miracles; and through lay-led religious communities and combinative folk practices.

The members of the Third Convention who petitioned for indigenous leadership in the Mexican Mormon Mission came from the most radical nationalists among Mexican members of the church. Many of them resided in towns on the slopes of Popocatepetl in the southeast region of the state of Mexico, including Ozumba, Amecameca, Zoyatzingo, Tepetlixpa, and Atlautla (Bautista’s birthplace) (de Olarte 2013). Small farmers in this area had been taught agrarian socialism and the principles of resistance in the mid to late 1860s by Plotino Rhodakanaty, the intellectual father of Mexican anarchy.

Rhodakanaty was a Greek philologist, who immigrated to Mexico in 1861 hoping to establish a communalist colony and to promote labor resistance, local political governance, and socialism among Mexicans. In 1865, he established a school in Chalco, a small farming community on the Central Plateau. There he taught basic academic skills, alongside principles of rhetoric, and organizational skills for resistance to campesinos (peasants) already disposed to support the communal ownership of property and land reform. As a result, it was Rhodakanaty who inculcated the activism of peasants on the Central Plateau with a philosophical core, one which demanded the return of ejidal farmlands and opposed centralized federal government in favor of local rule (Hart 1987).

Interestingly, Rhodakanaty joined The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints for a brief period in 1879, hoping that hierarchs in Utah would fund his own communalist experiment. Mormons had, after all, successfully built over 700 colonies in the American wilderness. Rhodakanaty’s insistence on local control over his proposed colony, however, set him at variance with the LDS Church and precipitated his departure from the church. Long after Rhodakanaty left Mexico, his ideology continued to fuel peasant uprisings on Mexico’s Central Plateau, including those led by Emiliano Zapata.

Alternative opportunities for indigenous religious leadership finally appeared in Mexico in the 1870s. From 1871 to 1874, Quakers, Northern Baptists, Congregationalists, Northern and Southern Presbyterians, and Northern and Southern Methodists all established missions in Mexico (Baldwin 1990). Methodist missionaries who arrived in Central Mexico followed ancient trade routes from Mexico City to farming villages on the central Plateau. For Mexico’s Indigenous populations, one of the attractions of foreign missionary movements was the availability of an education, followed by the possibility of ordination and a job as a minister. Latter-day Saints also began proselytizing in Mexico about this time (1875). They followed the same trade routes up to farming communities built on the slopes of the twin volcanos Popocatepetl and Iztaccihuatl.

Margarito first gravitated toward the teachings of Methodists congregation-building near Atlautla. Though the Methodists invited him to enter the ministry, he had already begun to converse with Latter-day Saint missionaries. He quickly became captivated by the Book of Mormon (1841), [Image at right] which reimagined the native peoples of the Americas as lost Israelites. Luz Bautista opposed his son’s interest in Mormonism, as Latter-day Saints, while offering ordination to a lay ministry, offered no education and had no positions for paid clergy, opportunities which Luz believed would help his son secure a stable financial future.

Margarito ultimately joined the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in 1901 after a faith healing performed by then Mexican Mission president Ammon Tenney. Immediately following his baptism, Margarito began proselytizing other Mexicans into the LDS fold. In 1903, he moved 1,000 miles to the Mormon Colonies in Mexico’s northern wilderness, where he learned more about the LDS gospel from Latter-day Saints who had come to Mexico from Utah to practice polygamy. In 1910, he moved to Mesa, Arizona two months before the outbreak of the Mexican Revolution (1910-1917). By 1914, Bautista decided to move his family further north to Salt Lake City, where employers paid Mexican laborers higher wages.

Everywhere he went, Bautista proselytized Mexicans expatriates and helped to found Spanish-speaking congregations for the Latter-day Saint Church. In Utah, Margarito learned English, proselytized, and benefitted from ecclesiastical leadership opportunities. While he spoke publicly on Mexican politics and promoted support for Mexican rebels, his family members and friends fought in Mexico. Luz Bautista was a courier and spy for rebel forces, and at one point faced a federalist firing squad, but was saved by the tears of his townspeople (de Olarte 2013). Nevertheless, it is estimated that between 1,000,000 and 3,000,000 casualties occurred during the war.  At the height of the violence (1915), life expectancy in Mexico sank to between fifteen and twenty years of age.

In 1922, Margarito was named Branch President of The Local Mexican Mission in Salt Lake City, a small congregation of Spanish-speaking Latter-day Saint converts, most of whom were Mexican expatriates working in the United States. Margarito’s tenure as the president of The Local Mexican Mission in Salt Lake City, however, was short-lived. He returned to Mexico as a missionary in 1922, where he garnered some fame among indigenous Latter-day Saints as an eloquent speaker. They also admired his acquaintance with prophets and apostles in Salt Lake City, his bilingualism, his expertise in portions of the LDS cannon not yet translated into Spanish, and his familiarity with the esoteric rites of LDS temples.

At the conclusion of his mission in 1924, he returned to Salt Lake City to find that he had been replaced as the president of The Local Mexican Mission by Francisco Solano, a Spanish convert. Rivalries formed in the congregation and a power struggle ensued, which coincided with Bautista’s return. It is likely that the appointment of a European leader in the Mexican branch of the Church rankled in the minds of many congregants. To put an end to divisions, the Church hierarchy removed all Spanish-surnamed leadership from this congregation for a period of forty years. Margarito’s name disappeared permanently from the minutes of the branch from 1924 onward.

With no pulpit to expound from, Bautista found a new platform for his personal melding of the indigenous history of Mexico and The Book of Mormon (1841 [1830]) in his authorship of a 564-page tome entitled The Spiritual Evolution of Mexico: Her True Ancestors, and Her Origen: The Destiny of America and Europe (1935). In this book, Bautista argued that Mexicans were transplanted Israelites, who had suffered under Spanish rule to atone for their practice of human sacrifice. He blended Book of Mormon narratives with commonly used history textbooks, which would have been familiar to anyone who had attended secondary school in Mexico. He further asserted that a just God would one day also mete out retribution to Mexico’s unrepentant oppressors (i.e. European colonizers and their descendants) for centuries of slavery, injustice, abuse, and the theft of aboriginal lands. Though Mexicans had lost the prerogative of rule centuries before, the Mexican Revolution had now prepared them to rise on the world stage. According to Bautista, the Book of Mormon (1841) outlined a simple, yet prophetic program for the development of Mexico: obey God and prosper.

Bautista’s tome also argued that, beyond Mexico, world peace largely depended on whether Gentiles (Europeans and Euro-Americans) were willing to recompense the indigenous inhabitants of all the nations they had colonized and give up their quest for world dominance. He insisted they “must voluntarily RETURN what they have stolen,” though he made no suggestion for the practical application of this formula for peace. He quoted the Book of Mormon (1841) in asserting that unrepentant colonizers would lose spiritual knowledge if they were to continue to be prideful: to continue their lying, deceiving, hypocrisy, murders, priest crafts, whoredoms, and secret abominations. Though God used colonizers to punish unbelieving natives, God would in due time punish unrepentant colonizers with sore destruction and return sovereignty of the land to its original inhabitants. All of this was to occur before the Second Coming. Ultimately, indigenous peoples would build the New Jerusalem on the North American continent and help usher in Christ’s millennial reign.

In 1935, Bautista repatriated to Mexico, hoping to find a publisher for his book. The goal was to proselytize Mexicans in print and to convince them not only of their future roles as world leaders, but also of their destiny to build the Holy City. Bautista travelled to many Latter-day Saint congregations in Central Mexico to read chapters of his book at local fireside meetings in the homes of friends and acquaintances. His readings were enthusiastically attended by indigenous Latter-day Saints, who, like Bautista, had great post-revolutionary hopes for the future of Mexico and Mexicans.

As he travelled throughout Central Mexico, Bautista visited with and garnered support from indigenous converts who also held nationalistic aspirations. Their collaborative goal was to gather indigenous Latter-day Saints at an assembly known as the Third Convention and to collectively petition the presidency of the Church in Salt Lake City to replace the Anglo president of the Mexican mission with a native Mexican. The previously mentioned first and second conventions in the Mexican mission had occurred on January 3, 1932, and February 11, 1934, while Bautista was living in Salt Lake City.  Minutes of these conventions reveal concerns over the collection of tithes, the construction of chapels and the care of widows and orphans. The Third convention, however, was openly critical of Anglo leadership, and petitioned for change, going so far as to suggest a suitable candidate for the mission presidency. Though this development shocked both the mission leadership and the white hierarchy in Salt Lake City, it was not an unusual demand in other denominations; in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century, Mexican Catholics, Protestants, and Pentecostals in the U.S./Mexico borderlands all resisted the oversight of Euro-American leaders within the missions that had converted them (Baldwin 1990; Espinosa 2008).

Many of the Mexican Mormons who supported the Third Convention had fought in the Mexican Revolution under the banner of Emiliano Zapata. During the Revolution, their religious differences were respected and they developed leadership skills. Like other Mexican cultural nationalists of their era, they believed that Mexicans could and should lead their own government, industries, and missions. The idea of ecclesiastical self-governance for Mexicans was further supported by the Mexican Constitution of 1917, which barred foreign clerics from operating in Mexico (Article 130).  Though designed to curtail the power of the Catholic Church in Mexico, Article 130 applied to religious leaders from any foreign-based denomination. Article 9 also granted Mexican citizens the right to submit petitions to organizations to which they belonged.

Margarito published his tome in 1936, approximately six weeks prior to the first meeting of the Third Convention. On March 11, 1936, he sent copies of his book to Mexican Mission President, Harold W. Pratt. Pratt asserted that the text promoted the establishment of a national Church in Mexico and he wrote to Salt Lake City recommending that the Church not endorse the book. Pratt also distributed a circular to congregations within the mission, advising members that La evolución did not have the endorsement of the Church and was therefore not official literature (Tullis 1997). This circular had disastrous consequences for book sales among Mexican Mormons, a situation which not only affected Bautista but all those who had donated or lent funds for its publication. Many have speculated that Margarito’s anger over Pratt’s response to his book led to the formation of the Third Convention. However, Bautista’s 1935-1936 diaries evidence that he had already begun planning this convention with other indigenous Latter-day Saints shortly after his 1935 arrival in Mexico.

On April 21, 1936, approximately 120 Mexican Mormons gathered in Tecalco for the first meeting of the Third Convention. The meeting was attended by Mexican members living on Mexico’s Central Plateau, as well as by leaders of several congregations, including Narciso Sandoval, branch president in San Gabriel; Agricol Lozano, branch president in San Marcos; Felipe Barragán, branch president in Tecalco; Faustino Amaro, branch president of Tepecoculco; Demitrio de la Rosa, branch president in Amecameca; and Pilar Páez, first counselor to the Branch President in Mexico City. These branch presidents brought members of their own congregations with them. Also in attendance was Ábel Páez, Bautista’s nephew and a counselor in the district presidency, which operated directly under the auspices of the Mission president, while overseeing the activities of the branch presidents.

While the main goal of the movement was to secure the leadership of an indigenous mission president in Mexico, secondary goals included the building of chapels and schools, publishing Church literature in Spanish, and the creation of opportunities for Mexican youth to act as missionaries for the Church. Conventionists also believed that a native mission president would be more understanding of the needs of Mexicans and more dedicated to the proselytizing of Mexicans. There was also a concern over a lack of respect for the autonomy of Mexican members when given assignments, and heavy-handed censure when LDS Mexicans took initiative to improve the life of the community, such as publishing a newsletter without the permission of the mission president.

Bautista also read letters to the attendees from the other two members of the District Presidency: President Isaías Juarez and Bernabé Parra, a counselor. Juarez’s letter stated that though the cause was just, The Conventionists’ method was without the backing of the district presidency and therefore could have “fatal” consequences for the Church. Bautista scorned this notion, stating that “procedure was a secondary thing” and they “were not criticizing nor censoring anyone” nor were they violating the law.

During the meeting, Members of the Third Convention unanimously voted that they needed “to have a Mission President distinctly of Mexican race.” Two candidates were nominated for the position: Ábel Páez and Margarito Bautista. Bautista declined the nomination and made a statement in support of Páez, whose nomination was seconded. Páez was unanimously voted a candidate for the position of Mexican mission president, and his name was submitted to Church authorities in Sat Lake City.

After the meeting in Tecalco, Margarito painstakingly edited the proceedings of the inaugural meeting. The minutes of the meeting were signed by eighty-two attendees. On behalf of the Directive Board of the Third Convention, the minutes and a letter to the First Presidency of the Church listing the grievances of the Conventionists was sent to church headquarters in Salt Lake City.  This letter inferred that Euro-American Mormons had appropriated the historical heritage of indigenous Americans, namely the Book of Mormon (1841), while ungratefully orphaning the descendants of the authors of the Church’s primary scriptural work. They further stated that they languished under the paternalism of the Euro-American Church simply because they were Mexicans and that this paternalism was, overtly stated, racial prejudice. Bautista included a personal letter to Church President Heber J. Grant denying accusations that he had repatriated to Mexico specifically to organize the third convention. This missive was followed by an exchange of terse letters between the First Presidency of the Church and the Conventionists.

Conventionists had hoped to remain in the mainstream Church while initiating a change in church policy though petition. Like many Mexican members, Bautista held the opinion that Mexico’s Constitution gave Conventionists the right to air their ecclesiastical grievances in assemblies. In fact, the Mexican Constitution of 1917 stated in Article Nine: “No assembly or meeting which has as its object the petitioning of any authority or the presentation of a protest against any act shall be deemed unlawful; nor may it be dissolved . . .” As far as the Conventionists were concerned, assembling to petition “any authority” included religious authorities.

As this meeting was held without the authorization of the Mexican Mission Presidency, it was seen as an act of rebellion by the mainstream church. In November of 1936, J. Rueben Clark, a member of the First Presidency of the LDS Church and a former U.S. Ambassador to Mexico, sent a letter in response to all congregations in Mexico, declaring that petitioning the Church, as had the Conventionists, was completely out of order. Mission Presidents were the representatives of the President of the Church; they were not representatives of the members.

While the demand for an indigenous mission president was shocking to the LDS hierarchy, it was not an unusual desire on the part of indigenous Mexicans who had converted to foreign missionary movements. For example, when Protestant missionaries from the U.S. fled Mexico during the Revolution, Mexican ministers admirably demonstrated their leadership skills, shepherding congregations through the conflict.

In February of 1937, Antoine R. Ivins and George F. Richards, both apostles sent by LDS headquarters, arrived in Mexico. Ivins and Richards at first agreed to speak to the Conventionists, although under the Mexican Constitution, foreign clerics were not allowed to address bodies of Mexicans. However, a rumor began to circulate that Conventionist leaders planned to have them both arrested at that meeting.  As a result, both men quickly returned to the U.S.  Ivins’ and Richards’ report displeased the First Presidency, who made the decision to excommunicate leaders of the Third Convention. Harold Pratt, the current Mexican Mission President, distributed the remarks Richards had planned to give, which told Mexican Latter-day Saints to fall in line with the advice of the authorities of the centralized church, or risk excommunication.

in early May of 1937, eleven months after the meeting of the Third Convention, the church began excommunicating all leaders of the Convention movement for rebellion, insubordination and apostacy. After the excommunication of their leaders, those who supported the goals of the Convention were forced to choose between the mainstream Church and the Convention itself. Nearly a third of the membership of the Church in Mexico (800 persons), decided to break from the Salt Lake-lead church, forming a new entity called The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Third Convention, with Abel Páez as their leader. After the divide, relations between the two sides became acrimonious, one side viewing the Conventionists as heretics and Conventionists viewing those who remained with the mainstream church as turning their backs on the need for native leadership. Páez continued as the leader of the Conventionists for the next nine years, during which the Conventionists added 400 new members through proselytization and births. They organized fifteen congregations, built six chapels where they held their own religious services, and trained a small group of young missionaries (Tullis 1997).

Harold Pratt was replaced by A. Lorenzo Anderson as president of the LDS Mexican Mission in 1938. However, acrimony between the Conventionists and non-Conventionists did not begin to subside until May of 1942 when Arwell L. Pierce was assigned to be the president of the mainstream LDS mission in Mexico. Pierce recognized that the Latter-day Saints could bring back more members to the mainstream church than they could baptize. He established a policy of friendliness and cooperation between the two groups. He instructed all missionaries to focus their efforts on healing the schism and preventing further rifts by offering service and showing respect. He sold Conventionists hymnals and Books of Mormon, attended both mainstream and Conventionists’ services, and instructed the missionaries he oversaw to do the same. He invited Conventionists to his home and shared news from Salt Lake with them.

Pierce also pointed out the advantages reunification would prove to members of the Convention as the mainstream church was sure to build temples in Mexico in the future. Temple building would require funds conventionists did not have, and membership in the mainstream church was necessary to participate in Mormonism’s most sacred rites, those performed only in temples. Such rituals were already being performed in Spanish in an LDS temple in Mesa, Arizona.

In 1943, Apostle David O. McKay traveled from Utah to tour Mormon congregations in Mexico. While he visited mainstream meetings and members, he also visited the home of Othon Espinosa, a leader of the Third Convention to give a health blessing to an ill family member. At the conclusion of World War II in 1945, returning American soldiers swelled the missionary ranks in Mexico. That same year, George Albert Smith became the world-wide President of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. It fell to Smith to unite the church in regions of the world that had fought against each other as enemies during the war. His emphasis was on love and forgiveness; this same attitude characterized the approach he took with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Third Convention in Mexico (Tullis 1997-1998).

By 1945, cracks in Conventionists’ loyalty to Abel Páez began to appear as Abel’s health began to deteriorate. Staunch leaders such as Apolonio B. Arzate, the Convention’s printer, and Othon Espinosa tired of the Convention’s infighting. Pierce pressed this advantage, using Arzate for mainstream mission printing jobs. Pierce also offered Convention leaders rides in his automobile and argued that what Mexico needed was not a Mexican Mission President, as mission presidents oversaw the planted congregations. Those congregations were turned over to the leadership of a stake (diocese) president as they became strong enough to stand on their own. Mexicans, he argued, needed a stake president as the Hawaiians already had. Pierce had priesthood manuals translated into Spanish, organized new mission districts under local control, and set up leadership training seminars so that Mexicans congregations could become independent of the control of a mission president. Pierce worked hard to address the original complaints of the Conventionists and to simultaneously soften the view of the mainstream hierarchy in Salt Lake City (Tullis 1997).

In contemplating possible reunification, Conventionist leaders wondered how they could return to the mainstream fold while maintaining their dignidad. Pierce reframed the split with the mainstream church as steps taken toward Mexican church leadership in Mexico. He argued that Salt Lake was paying attention. He also managed to bring about an ecclesiastical review of the excommunications of the leadership of the Third Convention. As a result, the First Presidency of the Church changed the status of the leaders to disfellowshipped. Thus, they did not need re-baptism to rejoin the mainstream church. Only new members proselytized into the Convention during its ten-year existence were required to have their baptisms ratified by a new baptismal ceremony. Most of these baptisms were performed by Pierce himself.

Reunification services were held in two locations: On Sunday, April 26, 1936, the first reunification meeting took place in a meeting house in Tecalco. The following week approximately 1,200 Conventionists (all most all the Conventionists) reunited with the LDS Church at a second reunification meeting in Mexico City, seat of the Mexican Mission headquarters.  George Albert Smith’s attendance at the meetings, made him the first Mormon prophet ever to visit Mexico. Though many expected a message of reproof, he spoke of harmony and kindness and invited Ábel Páez, leader of the Conventionists to address the crowd. Páez spoke of the progress both groups would make together. There were a few disgruntled members, but the majority were pleased to put differences aside and to reunited with former acquaintances.

Post Reunification, Pierce addressed the need for indigenous leadership in Mexico by appointing a Comité de Consejo y Bienestar (a Counsel and Welfare Committee), which included former Conventionists Abel Páez and Apolonio Arzate alongside non-Conventionists Isaías Juárez, Guadalupe Zárraga, and Bernabé Parra. It was not until 1968, however, that Agricol Lozano, a former Conventionist, was appointed the first Mexican Stake President in Mexico. This appointment heralded the exponential growth of Mormonism in Mexico.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Though the mainstream church in Mexico and the Conventionists differed on the immediate role native Mexicans should take in the leadership of the mission, the two groups were still very similar in doctrine and in practice. Conventionists and mainstream Mexican Latter-day Saints both shared the same Articles of Faith. This meant both sides rejected the three-in-one doctrine of the trinity, the doctrine of original sin, and infant baptism. Conversely, they both believed in the physical embodiment of God and the restoration of the priesthood through Joseph Smith. Conventionists also revered the same scriptural canon they had as members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (the Bible, the Book of Mormon (1841), and the revelations of Joseph Smith).

Mexican Latter-day Saints, whether mainstream members of the LDS Church or Conventionists, cherished Book of Mormon narratives, which they felt described the journey of their ancestors to the Americas in 600BC, three years prior to the Babylonian conquest of Jerusalem (597BC). In the Americas, the Israelite ancestors of the Mexicans created great civilizations and weathered great destructions. In the meridian of time, they were visited by the resurrected Jesus and thereafter established a utopian society that endured for 200 years.

The Book of Mormon (1841) ends with mass destructions and a prophecy of colonization by cruel oppressors. Both Conventionists and mainstream Latter-day Saints in Mexico believed that Mexico would be redeemed and Mexicans would play important roles before the Second Coming of Christ. Conventionists, however, believed that indigenous Mexicans needed to prepare for higher levels of leadership by developing hands-on skills in the present.

In the 1930s, the same decade that saw the rise of The Third Convention in Mexico, the British Israel movement had become popular in the United States. This movement promoted the idea that the Lost Tribes of Israel came to England. This notion convinced many Latter-day Saints in the U.S. that though the Book of Mormon (1841) describes European colonizers as “Gentiles,” descendants of British colonialists descended from their own branch of “Lost Israelites.” Therefore, the need to convert indigenous peoples to help build the New Jerusalem was less pressing, or, as J. Ruben Clark argued, God had other “Israelites” to choose from. While Conventionists and mainstream Mexicans differed over when Mexicans should develop leadership skills. J. Ruben Clark and like-minded Latter-day Saints in the U.S. differed with Conventionists and many mainstream members in Mexico over who would be leaders in the days leading up to the millennium.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

Conventionists retained the same rituals and practices as the mainstream congregations, They read the same scriptural canon, even teaching members English so that they could read mainstream Church manuals and sacred documents, such as the revelations of Joseph Smith, that had not been translated into English. Conventionists sang the same hymns, uttered the same sacramental prayers, and structured their worship services in the same manner as the mainstream church. Though the resources of the LDS Church in Salt Lake City were not available to them, Third Conventionists nevertheless donated the land and labor required to build six chapels from 1936 to 1946 where they held weekly worship services. They continued to bless infants, to baptize new members by immersion, to and confirm new members by the laying on of hands.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

After the excommunication of five of the Convention’s leaders, the Convention separated themselves from the mainstream Church. Consequently, The Third Convention was made up of families and congregations who made joint decisions to either support or not support the Third Convention. Their support for the Convention was largely a manifestation of their support for their local, excommunicated branch presidents. Abel Páez continued as their leader, despite his excommunication as did other leaders of Conventionists’ congregations. As they had before the schism, they ordained men to offices in the priesthood and organized priesthood quorum’s, women’s auxiliaries, and programs for youth and children. They also taught proselytizing skills to young adults and had a vigorous missionary program, growing their membership numbers from 800 to 1200 in a period of ten years (Tullis 1997).

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Though Third Conventionists struggled without the resources of the mainstream Church, most of the hardship they experienced resulted from internal conflict between leaders of the Convention. While Margarito Bautista figured prominently in the formation of the Third Convention, his influence was short-lived. A few months after the Third Convention’s formal break with the mainstream Church, it was discovered that he was surreptitiously enlistimg polygamist wives, some of whom were daughters of Convention leaders. Conventionists were not interested in adopting discontinued Mormon marital practices that had never been used by indigenous Latter-day Saints In Central Mexico. When the first Mormon polygamists came to colonize in northern Mexico, (1885), Mexican President Porfirio Díaz agreed to allow them entry if they would not introduce polygamy to native Mexicans. As a result, polygamy in Mexico was confined to Anglo colonies in the northern desert. Outrage over Bautista’s covert introduction of the ideals of polygamy to young females resulted in his expulsion from the Convention.

After his departure, Bautista, as an independent missionary, continued to preach his personal amalgamation of the Book of Mormon (1841) and Mexican History, along with polygamy, and communalism. He attempted to proselytize Conventionists to his new movement but had little success. Another leader of the Convention, Branch President Daniel Mejía, broke with the group to found his own polygamist colony in the farming town of Cuautla de Morelos. He brought several members of his congregation with him. This community lasted until his colonists rebelled against him to rejoin the mainstream Church in 1945.

Toward the end of the ten-year existence of the Convention, other leaders, such as physician and printer Apolonio Arzate and Othon Espinosa, began to drift away from the Convention toward the leadership of Pierce. Abel Páez’s failing health was certainly a factor, but the resources Pierce had to offer, as well as changing attitudes on the part of the LDS hierarchy certainly played a role in shifting loyalties.

IMAGES
Image #1: Bautista Margarito. Credit: Public Domain.
Image #2: Front page of The Book of Mormon, 1841 edition. Credit: Public Domain.

REFERENCES

Baldwin, Deborah J. 1990. Protestants and the Mexican Revolution: Missionaries, Ministers and Social Change. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.

Bautista, Margarito. Diaries, 1935-1937. Enriqueta and Fernando Gomez Collection, Honnold Library, Claremont Graduate University.

Bautista, Margarito. 1935 [printed 1936]. La evolución de México; sus verdaderos progenitores y su origen; el destino de América y Europa. Distrito Federal: Arzate Brothers.

Comite Directivo. 1936. Informe General de la Tercera Convención de los Miembros de la Iglasia de Jesu-Cristo de los Santos de los Ultimos Días Celebrada en Tecalco, México, el 21 de abril de 1936 y que fué enviado a la Primera Presidencia para su resolución.

Espinosa, Gastón. 2008. “Brown Moses: Francisco Olazabel and Mexican American Pentecostal Healing in the Borderlands. Pp. 263-95 in Mexican American Religions: Spirituality, Activism, and Culture, edited by Gastón Espinosa and Mario T. García. Durham: Duke University Press.

Gomez, Fernando R. 2024. A Documentary History of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in Mexico, 1875-1946. Waltham, MA: By Common Consent Press.

Hart, John Mason. 1987. Anarchism and the Mexican Working Class, 1860-1931. Austin: University of Texas Press.

Mexico. 1917. English translation of the new Mexican Constitution: effective from May 5th, 1917. Accessed from https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=ien.35556003545423&seq=5 on 23 September 2026.

Mexican Mission Record of Members, circa 1920-1940. 8:1147, 1169. Church History Library, Salt Lake City, Utah. Call number LR 5506 7.

Pulido, Elisa Eastwood. 2021. “Margarito Bautista, Mexican Politics and The Third Convention.” Mormon Studies Review January:48-56.

Pulido, Elisa Eastwood. 2020. The Spiritual Evolution of Margarito Bautista: Mexican Mormon Evangelizer, Polygamist Dissident, and Utopian Founder, 1878-1961. New York: Oxford University Press.

Pulido, Elisa Eastwood. 2015. “Solving Schism in Nepantla: The Third Convention Returns to the LDS Fold.” Pp. 89-110 in Just South of Zion, edited by Jason H. Dormady and Jared M. Tamez. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press.

Pulido, Elisa Eastwood. n.d. “Mormonism in Mexico.” The Mormonism in Migration Project. Claremont Graduate University. Accessed from https://research.cgu.edu/mormonism-migration-project/study-resources/mormonism-in-mexico/#_ednref36 on 21 September 2026.

The Book of Mormon. 1841. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. First European edition.

Spencer de Olarte, Moroni Hernandez. 2013. “Ya llegaron los de Tierra Fria…”: Los colores del Zapatismo en la Región de lo Volcanes, Estado de México.”  M.A. thesis, Universidad Autónoma Metropolitan.

Tullis, F. Lamond. 1997-1998. “A Shepherd to Mexico’s Saints: Arwell L. Pierce and the Third Convention.” BYU Studies 37:1. Accessed from https://byustudies.byu.edu/article/a-shepherd-to-mexicos-saints-arwell-l-pierce-and-the-third-convention on 21 September 2026.

Tullis, F. Lamond. 1997. Mormonism in Mexico: The Dynamics of Faith and Culture. Second Edition. Provo: Museo de Historia del Mormonismo en México.

Publication Date:
18 October 2026

Share

US Satanism Scare

 

SATANISM SCARE TIMELINE

1966 (April) – Church of Satan was founded by Anton Szandor LaVey and began to gain media attention

1972: Mike Warnke publishes ‘The Satan Seller’ in which he claims to have previously been a ‘Satanic high priest’ in the mid 1960s, before turning to Christ (a backstory that was eventually debunked in a 1992 exposé). He positions himself as an expert during the livestock mutilation panic, and in the late 80s on the Geraldo TV special.

1973 – Early reports of lifestock mutilations began, sparking conspiracy theories

1974 (January) – Nixon signs the Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act (CAPTA) into law, prompting investigations into determining the extent of the problem of child abuse in the US.

1974 – Ted Patrick founds the Citizens Freedom Foundation (CFF)

1975 – Investigative and media reports began to speculate whether lifestock mutilations were being carried out by Satanic cults

1978 – The Jonestown Massacre occurs, prompting a new wave of cult fear in the US

1979 – Rev Jerry Falwell establishes the Moral Majority

1980 – Lawrence Pazder and his patient Michelle Smith publish the co-authored ‘Michelle Remembers’, which documented Smith’s alleged childhood experiences as a victim of ‘Satanic Ritual Abuse’ (SRA). Pazder claimed that these memories had previously been supressed, but that he had been able to uncover them.

1983 – Patricia Pulling creates Bothered About Dungeons and Dragons (BADD), and began publishing information alleging that D&D encouraged devil worship and suicide.

1983 – Judy Johnson, a parent of a child at McMartin preschool, reports to the police that her son had been sexually abused by preschool employee Ray Buckey. Buckey is arrested.

1984 – News of a mass child abuse scandal at McMartin is reported, alleging up to 360 victims. Ray Buckey, along with 6 others, are indicted on 115 counts of child sexual abuse. Among the many allegations were claims that the children were ritualistically abused and made to watch animals be slaughtered.

1985 – The CFF officially changes its name to the Cult Awareness Network (CAN)

1985 – Mike Warnke publishes ‘Schemes of Satan’, building on the D&D panic. In this book he fabricated claims relating to Dallas Egbert’s suicide.

1986 – Charges are dropped against 5 of the 7 McMartin defendants

1987/88 (est) – Jacquie Balodis starts ‘Overcomers Victorious’, a support group for self-proclaimed SRA survivors. She later features on Geraldo’s TV special (see below).

1988 – Geraldo Rivera broadcasts his TV special ‘Devil Worship: Exposing Satan’s Underground’ in which he claimed a hidden interconnected network of Satanic cults were sacrificing children across the US, and recruiting young people through materials such as D&D and heavy metal music.

1989: Judith Spencer publishes ‘Suffer the child’ – an account of “Jenny” and her recovered memories of being abused by a satanic cult, many of which were almost identical to Michelle’s.

1989 – Lawrence Pazder and Michelle Smith (now Michelle Pazder as they had married in 1986) appear together on The Oprah Winfrey Show to promote Michelle Remembers

1990 – Peggy Buckey is acquitted on all counts, charges are dismissed (following two hung verdicts favouring acquittal) against Ray Buckey

1993 – Teenagers Damien Echols, Jesse Miskelley Jr, and Jason Baldwin are arrested and charged with the murder of three children. Police suspicions of Echols being a Satanist prompted them initially questioning him.

1994 – Misskelley is sentenced to 40 years, Baldwin to life, and Echols to death.

2007: DNA evidence found at the crime scene is found not to match Echols, Misskelley or Baldwin

2011: The West Memphis 3 (Echols, Misskelley, and Baldwin) are released using an Alford plea

 

The foundations of the Satanism scare

Note early foundations and various existing concerns and panics it built on:

Church of Satan?

Mutilations

Missing children panic

Homophobia / concerns around women in workforce

ACM

Note here on the different social roles that then banded together to make the panic more plausible & span religious and secular.

The allegations of the panic

Satanic ‘brainwashing’

Discuss BADDD and heavy metal concerns. Fears of corrupted youth being indoctrinated into Satanism.

Satanic Ritual Abuse

Discuss Pazder and McMartin. Note McMartin was far from the only case.

((End note on these not being mutually exclusive. Tabloid media branded these together – such as infamous Geraldo TV special. Note that SRA cases generally died down after McMartin, but effects went on into the 1990s – note WM3 case and San Antonio 4. Both cases exonerated far later. However, still not the end. Last noted exoneration was documented in 2023 (check!). Impact of the 80s panic still ongoing, while we may already be witnessing a new revival.))

 

 

 

 

Share

United Kingdom Satanism Scare

UK SATANISM SCARE TIMELINE

1973:  Doreen Irvine published her autobiography From Witchcraft to Christ in which she claimed to have previously been the “Queen of Black Witches” before joining the Baptist Church.

1987:  Investigations began in Nottingham regarding allegations of abuse occurring within a large multi-generational family in the area. Social workers posited that it was indicative of satanic ritual abuse.

1988: Over twenty children were removed from the Nottingham family.

1988:  British newspapers began to widely report claims that children across the UK were being abused and murdered in occult rituals.

1988:  Ten adults in the Nottingham case were found guilty of sexual and physical abuse and incest.

1989:  A television special titled “The Family – Suffer the Little Children” was aaired on Central Independent Television covering the Nottingham case. It included various details of unverified occult rituals.

1990:  Joint Evaluation Team (JET) investigation into the Nottingham case conclude that the crimes showed no evidence of satanic activity. The results of the investigation were initially suppressed from public reporting.

1990:  Audrey Harper (with Harry Pugh) published Dance with the Devil, the first satanic ritual abuse survivor book to be published in the UK.

1990 (March):  Jim Harding, the director of The National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children (NSPCC), stated at a press conference that social workers across the UK were uncovering a new form of abuse,  satanic ritual abuse (SRA).

1990 (March-June):  Fifteen children in Rochdale were forcefully taken from their homes by social services; the agency alleged a widespread SRA conspiracy.

1990 (September):  Investigative journalist Rosie Waterhouse published an exposé of the Rochdale case in a Sunday edition of The Independent titled “The Making of a Satanic Myth” in which she criticised the social workers handling of the case and pointed to the lack of evidence.

1990 (October):  Iain Walker, John Quinn, and Peter Day co-authored a Sunday article for The Mail  titled “The Attack on Innocence”which also raised doubts on the validity of SRA accusations, citing Rosie Waterhouse.

1991:  Police investigations into the Rochdale case determined that there were no grounds for a criminal prosecution; instead the case was taken to family court. It is was determined unequivocally that the case offered  no evidence for a widespread SRA conspiracy. The children were returned to their homes and the case was closed.

1991 (February):  Nine children in Orkney were removed from their families by social services and police based on allegations of sexual abuse, including ritualistic themes.

1991 (March):  The Orkney case children were flown to mainland Scotland and examined for signs of abuse; no evidence was found. The children themselves also denied any abuse had occurred.

1991 (April):  The Orkney case was dismissed and the children were returned to their families.

1992:  Following the Orkney events, The Clyde Report was published criticising Orkney police and social workers for their handling of the case and their fixation on SRA testimonies.

1992:  Social anthropologist Jean La Fontaine was commissioned by the Department of Health to investigate all eighty-four alleged cases of SRA across the UK dating from 1987.

1994:  Jean La Fontaine published her groundbreaking Department of Health report. She formally concluded, and was supported by the Health Secretary Virginia Bottomley, that SRA was a myth with no evidence to support it.

1997:  The JET report findings were leaked online.

2000:  It was discovered that two psychotherapists at the Tavistock clinic in London (Dr. Valerie Sinason and Dr. Rob Hale)  had accepted a £22,000 government grant to “produce evidence” of SRA from their patients

REFERENCES

Mulhern, Sherrill (October 1, 1994). “Satanism, Ritual Abuse, and Multiple Personality Disorder: A Sociohistorical Perspective”. International Journal of Clinical and Experimental Hypnosis. 42 (4): 265–288

Oake, Bethan. 2026. “Save Our Children from Satanists”: Women, Motherhood, and Satanic Moral Panic.” Pp. 51-63 in  ed. Satanism and Feminism in Popular Culture: Not Today Satan, edited by Miranda Corcoran. Milton Park: Routledge. https://wrldrels.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/Save-Our-Children-from-Satanists_-Women-Motherhood-and-Satanic-Moral-Panic_26_08_23_16_17_55.pdf.

Oake, Bethan. 2025. The Satanic Cult Conspiracy: How online conspiracy theory discourses construct moral panic. PhD Dissertation, University of Leeds. Accessed from https://wrldrels.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/The-Satanic-Cult-Conspiracy.pdf on 15 April 2026.

INVESTIGATORY REPORTS

Inquiry into the Removal of Children from Orkney in February 1991 – GOV.UK

La Fontaine, Jean S. 1994. The extent and nature of organised and ritual abuse: research findings. Department of Health. London: H.M.S.O. Accessed from https://archive.org/details/extentnatureofor0000lafoon 15 August 2026. 

Nottinghamshire County Council. 1997. Revised Joint Enquiry Report. http://www.users.globalnet.co.uk/~dlheb/jetrepor2.htm.

 

Share

San Francisco Zen Center

SAN FRANCISCO ZEN CENTER (SFZC) TIMELINE

1904 (May 18):  Shunryu Suzuki was born in Kanagawa, Japan.

1934:  Sokoji Temple, a Soto Zen temple, was founded by Hosen Isobe in San Francisco.

1936:  Richard Dudley Baker was born in Biddeford, Maine.

1951:  Baker received a M.A. in Japanese History from the University of California at Berkeley.

1959 (May 9):  Shunryu Suzuki arrived from Japan to San Francisco to serve as head priest of Sokoji Temple. The temple had entirely Japanese membership.

1959-1961:  Suzuki soon began attracting non-Japanese followers, and Westerners quickly became the majority of members.

1961:  Westerners began meeting separately.

1962:  SFZC was founded by Shunryu Suzuki and his Western students, making it the first Japanese Sōtō Zen center outside of Asia.

1962:  Baker married his first wife, Virginia “Ginny” Curtis Brackett.

1967:  The Tassajara Zen Mountain Center was purchased by SFZC.

1967:  Suzuki announced that he wished Richard Baker to succeed him as SFZC abbot.

1969:  Suzuki was asked to resign as priest at Sokoji by the temple’s board of directors because he was spending more time with his Western students than the Japanese-American congregation.

1969:  The SFZC Center was purchased with the financial assistance from American students.

1970:  Richard Baker was ordained as a priest.

1970:  Suzuki’s teachings were compiled in Zen Mind, Beginner’s Mind

1971:  Suzuki died of cancer at age sixty-seven and was succeeded as abbot by Richard Baker.

1972:  Green Gulch Farm was acquired by SFZC.

1979:  The Greens restaurant opened.

1983:  Rob Anderson received dharma transmission from Richard Baker.

1983:  It became publicly known that Baker had been intimately involved with SFZC donor Paul Hawken’s wife.

1983 (December 21):  Baker resigned from his post as abbot.

1983:  Baker and his wife separated and subsequently divorced.

1984:  Baker established the Dharma Sangha in Santa Fe, New Mexico.

1984-1985:  Dainin  Katagiri stepped in to lead the SFZC community until 1985.

1985-1995:  Tenshin Reb Anderson assumed the position of Abbot of the Zen Center.

1995:  Zoketsu Norman Fischer was installed as Abbot.

1996:  Zenkai Blanche Hartman was appointed as co-Abbot with him (becoming the first female Abbot in SFZC history).

1996:  Baker founded Dharma Sanga in Santa Fe, New Mexico.

1999:  Baker married his second wife, Princess Marie Louise of Baden.

2000:  Jiko Linda Cutts was appointed Abbess, having received Dharma transmission from Tenshin Reb Anderson in 1996.

2003:  Paul Haller, who had received transmission from Sojun Mel Weitsman in 1993, was installed as co-abbot with her.

2005:  Christina Lenherr received dharma transmission from Rob Anderson.

2007:  Steve Stucky replaced Linda Cutts and Paul Haller as abbot.

2013:  Steve Stucky died.

2014:  Ed Sattizahn, co-founder of Vimala Sangha in Mill Valley, became abbot.

2024 (September):  Richard Baker officially resigned from his position as abbot of the two Dharma Sangha centers at age eighty-eight.

2025 (May 22):  Baker suffered a stroke and was offered residential recovery accommodations at SFZC.

2025:  Beginner’s Mind Temple, which was established in 1969 in San Francisco, was renovated and became the urban center for meditation and community events.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Zen Buddhism is a branch of Mahayana Buddhism that originated in China during the Tang Dynasty and then  spread from China to Vietnam, Korea, and Japan. It is the largest of the three traditional sects of Zen in Japanese Buddhism. In North America, the Zen lineages derived from the Japanese Sōtō school are the most numerous. One of the most prominent of these is the San Francisco Zen Center. Shunryu Suzuki Roshi, a Japanese Zen priest belonging to the Sōtō lineage, came to San Francisco in 1959 with his wife, and established what became the largest Sōtō organization in the West.

Shunryu Suzuki was the son of Sogaku Suzuki, a priest of a Zen temple in Tsuchisawa, Japan. [Image at right] At the age of eleven Shunryu began studying under his first master, Gyokujun So-on. He was ordained a novice monk at thirteen and became assistant director of his father’s temple when he was twenty-nine (Chadwick 2000). Suzuki moved to America in 1959 and was embraced by members of one of the few Soto Zen temples in the U.S., Sokoji. The San Francisco temple, which had only Japanese members, had been struggling with leadership issues (Wenger 2002).

The 1960s witnessed the emergence of a wide range of social movements (Freeman 1983). Some of these were political, like the governmentally sponsored Peace Corps, Students for a Democratic Society, Black Power groups, feminist rights groups); others represented both Christian and Buddhist traditions. The membership base for many of these movements was upper-middle-class, white, young adults who, starting in the 1950s, began to manifest dissatisfaction with the bureaucratic organization of the public sphere, absence of a meaningful religiosity or spirituality, and materialism of prevailing culture generally. One important component of dissatisfaction for some of these young adults as the spiritual emptiness of available conventional religious group options (Bivins 2007:64; Freeman 1983).

Suzuki soon began attracting American students, largely from the hippie, artist, politically progressive population in San Francisco. However, Suzuki did not simply import the established Japanese Zen tradition, he sought to reform it (Lachs 1999:8).  He and his followers created an Americanized, individualized version of the tradition, one that focused on meditation as a means of changing subjective consciousness (Bivins 2007).

As his following grew, Suzuki began attracting media attention (Chadwick 2000). In 1961, Richard Baker, who was twenty-five years old at the time, was one of the new students Suzuki attracted. In that year the Western students began meeting separately, with Suzuki paying the temple for use of its space. Suzuki’s decision to create a separate meeting for Westerners was not acceptable to the temple. In 1962, therefore, Suzuki and his students established the San Francisco Zen Temple.

Suzuki was asked to resign as priest at Sokoji in 1969. That same year the SFZC building was purchased with the financial assistance from American students. Suzuki’s leadership continued on until 1971, when he died at age sixty-seven. Suzuki gave Richard Baker dharma transition before his death, making him Suzuki’s sole western heir. He assumed the position as abbot at SFZC. Prior to his becoming a member of SFZC, Baker was educated at both Harvard and the University of California at Berkeley where he earned an M.A. in Japanese history and worked in various jobs prior to participating in SFZC (Richard Baker website n.d.).

Under Baker’s leadership SFZC developed an impressive network of organizations between 1971 and 1983. [Image at right] SFZC experienced a major crisis in 1983 (which came to be known as “The Apocalypse) when Baker was charged with sexual violations and removed from his leadership position. [See, Issues/Challenges] SFZC leadership was regularized following Baker’s tenure. He was replaced by another of Suzuki’s followers, Daimin Katagiri. Rob Anderson to whom Baker had given dharma transmission succeeded Katagiri. The Board later decided to appoint a co-abbot.

DOCTRINES/RITUALS

At the center of SFZC doctrines are the Sixteen Bodhisattva Precepts that include the Three Refuges, the Three Pure Precepts, and the Ten Grave Precepts (SFZC website 2026):

Three Refuges

I take refuge in Buddha
before all beings,
immersing body and mind
deeply in the Way,
awakening true mind.

I take refuge in Dharma
before all beings,
entering deeply the merciful ocean
of Buddha’s Way.

I take refuge in Sangha
before all beings,
bringing harmony to everyone,
free from hindrance.

Three Pure Precepts

I vow to refrain from all evil.
I vow to make every effort to live in enlightenment.
I vow to live and be lived for the benefit of all beings.

Ten Grave Precepts

I vow not to kill.
I vow not to take what is not given.
I vow not to misuse sexuality.
I vow to refrain from false speech.
I vow to refrain from intoxicants.
I vow not to slander.
I vow not to praise self at the expense of others.
I vow not to be avaricious.
I vow not to harbor ill will.
I vow not to disparage the Three Treasures.

In Suzuki’s understanding of Zen, its primary aim is the experience of satori (enlightenment), which he characterized as encompassing “irrationality, intuitive insight, authoritativeness, affirmation, exhilaration, and momentariness” (Crist6bal Serran-Pagan y Fuentes). This is achieved at SFZC through it primary ritual, meditation (zazen). As Bivins has noted this represents an Americanization of the Japanese Zen Soto tradition (Bivins 2007:73):

Baker orchestrated an Americanized version of Zen the notion that there exists an essential unity to all of reality that is free from material particulars. Meditation was thus supposed to generate a type of awareness that is free from ostensive reference, from self-interest, and from attachment to particulars. This understanding of Zen practice omits a number of the tradition’s constitutive features (such as ritual devotion and doctrinal formulation) because of its overriding conviction that Zen aims at experiential release the exclusive focus on meditation was, in many ways, an absorption in the individual, the devolvement of practice onto a single practitioner. The distinctly American language of possessive individualism was retained.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

SFZC has three centers of ritual activity. City Center in San Francisco is the main practice center. There are daily meditative services along with instructional classes and workshops and dharma talks. Green Gulch Farm in northern California includes a temple that hosts Zen studies, conferences, and retreats for practitioners at all levels but also produces organic products for the other centers. The Tassajara center in the Big Sur region, which functions as a monastery, offers public Zen learning experiences during the summer months.

One of the central rituals at SFZC is the Full Moon Ceremony at which practitioners renew their vows monthly. In addition to the Three Refuges, the Three Pure Precepts, and the Ten Grave Precepts, the vows include Repentence and Homage (SFZC 2026):

Repentence

All my ancient twisted karma
From beginningless greed, hate and delusion
Born through body, speech and mind
I now fully avow

Homages

Homage to the Seven Buddhas before Buddha
Homage to Shakyamuni Buddha
Homage to Maitreya Buddha
Homage to Manjusri Bodhisattva
Homage to Samantabhadra Bodhisattva
Homage to Avalokitesvava Bodhisattva
Homage to the Succession of Ancestors

In addition, Suzuki created Dharma Talks that took place either before or after zazen. On the weekends, as well there have been regular Dharma talks, with additional talks on special occasions. In the early 2020s, SFZC began offering live streamed zazen. Externally, SFZC maintains an extensive community outreach program, with food pantries and women’s shelters.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

The orientation at SFZC departs significantly from traditional Zen in both leadership and organization structure. With respect to leadership, the Zen traditions understands a roshi to be a living example of the ideal of Zen. As Lachs has observed, drawing on Baker’s comments in Zen Mind, Beginners Mind (1999:3):

A roshi is a person who has actualized that perfect freedom which is the potentiality for all human beings. He exists freely in the fullness of his whole being. The flow of his consciousness is not the fixed repetitive patterns of our usual self-centered consciousness, but rather arises spontaneously and naturally from the actual circumstances of the present. The results of this in terms of the quality of his life are extraordinary-buoyancy, vigor, straightforwardness, simplicity, humility, security, joyousness, uncanny perspicacity and unfathomable compassion. His whole being testifies to what it means to live in the reality of the present. Without anything said or done, just the impact of meeting a personality so developed can be enough to change another’s whole way of life. But in the end it is not the extraordinariness of the teacher that perplexes, intrigues, and deepens the student, it is the teacher’s utter ordinariness.

This interpretation was particularly attractive to potential countercultural recruits. It is important to note, however, that traditional Zen was historically closely connected to ruling elites and “Dharma transmission was as much about institutional prosperity, prestige, authority, continuity and acceptance and control by imperial authorities as it was about notions of enlightenment and spiritual perfection (Lachs 2002). In fact, Dharma transmission is commonly a father-son transmission ritual culminating in the son’s inheritance of the family temple. SFZC was not imported whole cloth from Japan, and it was introduced into an entirely different cultural context. Suzuki’s innovation was one of the reasons for its success and one of the reasons the movement faced the challenges it did.

Beginning in 1970, SFZC began growing rapidly and built a network of affiliated organizations. These included Green Gulch Farm and Tassajara Zen Mountain Center (Image at right). Shunryu Suzuki had a vision of creating an organic farm where families could live a Buddhist life while working together on the farm’s agricultural pursuits. The 115 acre Green Gulch Farm was acquired by SFZC in 1972. The farm was gradually transformed into a monastery and retreat center for residents and guests, offering environmental education along with the organic farm, flower gardens, a teahouse and a plant nursery. The farm also supplied produce to its Greens Restaurant in San Francisco, along with other local restaurants and food suppliers.

Suzuki had also expressed interest in establishing a retreat center. The membership organized a fundraiser that accumulated the $150,000 to purchase Tassajara Zen Mountain Center (TZMC) in 1966. The countercultural cultural influence was on full display as ”the event was sponsored by the heir to the Xerox Corporation, and music was provided by Janis Joplin and the Jefferson Airplane” (Bivins 2017:71). The center opened the following year. Richard Baker served as head monk during the first year of operation. Zen leaders from Japan subsequently visited Tassajara to offer teachings to American students. It was the first Zen Buddhist monastery built in the U.S; it also was the first in the world to admit women. TZMC offered retreats, seminars, and workshops. Tassajara became the primary location for ninety-day practice periods (ango) and for the ordination of priests and lay practitioners. In order to attain formal admission, participants have been required to undergo tangaryo, which involves sitting for a period of five days or longer in the zendo.

There were other organizational initiatives as well. In 1976, Tassajara Bakery was established in San Francisco in 1976 to take advantage of the baking operation at Tassajara Zen Mountain Center, but it ultimately was sold in 1992. Greens Restaurant opened in 1979 with a vegetarian cuisine, bread from Tassajara Bakery and produce from Green Gulch Farm. Through the 1980s, prior to its closure, it became one of the most popular dining venues in San Francisco.

SFZC also  inaugurated the Zen Hospice Project, a volunteer hospice program that operated out of a local guest house with five residential beds. There was also a twenty-five bed ward within Laguna Honda Hospital in 1987. It is the largest Buddhist hospice center in the U.S.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Three major moments defined early SFZC history. The first was the arrival of Suzuki with his revisionist version of Zen Buddhism that led to the group’s attractiveness to a swarth of American spiritual seekers and the formation of SFZC. The second was the dharma transmission to Richard Baker who put his mark on the movement largely through entrepreneurial organizational development but also created a major organizational crisis. The third was the movement’s response to the crisis, its re-envisioning of itself, its reassertion of commitment to Suzuki’s vision, and the resolution of its relationship with Richard Baker.

SFZC’s early years were quite successful. Suzuki’s vision and Baker’s entrepreneurial talent created growth, high visibility and generally favorable public response. It appeared that SFZC was on a sustained upward trajectory. Then there was a moment of crisis. Following Suzuki’s death, Richard Baker assumed a high level of control over the movement (Bivins 2007; Lachs 2019; Ryan 2002). As a result, his relationships with students and SFZC became more strained due to his personal absence as he pursued organizational goals, an imperious manner that discouraged questioning of his decisions and authority as head of SFZC organizations and SFZC abbot, and his personal adventurism. There were a number of reasons why Baker was not challenged: loyalty to Suzuki, belief in the unique qualities of Zen practice at SFZC, and personal relationships and careers in the community. This lack of community control was a factor in allowing Baker’s personal adventurism.

One aspect of the 1960s counterculture that pervaded San Francisco and SFZC was open sexuality. Normative guidelines for sexual relationships that were consensual were ambiguous. It subsequently came to light that Baker, who was married, had a number of sexual relationships with SFZC students. The defining event, which came to be known within ZFZC as “The Apocalypse,” took place in 1983 at a Peace Conference at Tassajara, chaired by Baker (Downing 2002; Bivins 2007). Over several days the shoes of Anna Hawken, wife of influential member and major SFZC donor Paul Hawken, were left in a publicly visible place outside the door to Baker’s cabin.  Once Paul Hawken was made aware of these events, he immediately informed the SFC Board. When Baker disputed the details of the relationship and Hawken threatened legal action for clergy malpractice, the Board returned Hawken’s stock donations to SFZC and demanded that Baker step down. On December 21, 1983, Baker resigned his position as abbot (Schneider 1994). He and his wife separated and subsequently divorced. Numerous students left SFZC in the wake of The Apocalypse.

In the wake of The Apocalypse SFZC revised its ethical guidelines. For example, there is explicit language on sexual relationships: “it is considered a misuse of authority, responsibility and sexuality for a Zen Center to engage in sexual behavior with his or her student.” The guidelines go further by explicitly prohibiting sexual relationships between teachers and students for the first six months of the relationship and for the same period if a student leaves SDZC (Bivins 2007:69,73; SFZC 1996).

For his part, Baker resumed his teaching activities in 1984. He relocated to Santa Fe, New Mexico where he founded a new community, Dharma Sangha. Subsequently, the educational nonprofit foundation Lindisfarne Association donated their campus in Crestone, Colorado, to Baker’s Dharma Sangha. Baker took up residence there and expanded the campus, which originally consisted of the passive solar Lindisfarne Fellows House, a so-called Founder’s House, and the dome-shaped Lindisfarne Chapel. He built a traditional Japanese Zendo with seating for several dozen practitioners, a guesthouse, and additional structures. Some of these projects were funded by Laurance Rockefeller, who had previously made significant donations to SFZC.

While developing Crestone Mountain Zen Center, Baker simultaneously established connections to Europe in the mid-1980s. In 1983, he was first invited to speak at two conferences in Austria and Switzerland. Afterwards, he was invited to return for further conferences and asked to offer seminars. In the late 1980s, some European Zen students who wanted to practice more frequently with Baker began attending at Crestone. In the mid-1990s, Baker began offering annual practice periods at Crestone. In 1999, Baker married Princess Marie Louise of Baden whose family’s historical home in the German Forest region was near a Zen center administered by Baker.

In 2024, at the age of eighty-eight, Baker resigned as abbot of the two Dharma Sangha centers. A year later he suffered a stroke. The abbot at SFZC offered residential facilities in his suite during Baker’s recuperation (Zimmerman 2025).

IMAGES

Image #1: Shunryu Suzuki. Credit: Public Domain.
Image #2: Richard Baker. Credit: Public Domain.
Image #3: Tassajara Zendo at Hot Springs. Credit Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.0 Generic license. Photographer: Bradley Allen.  

REFERENCES

Anderson, Reb. 2001. Being Upright: Zen Meditation and the Bodhisattva. Toronto: Rodmell Press.

Bivins, Jason. 2007. “Beautiful Women Dig Graves”: Richard Baker-roshi, Imported Buddhism, and the Transmission of Ethics at the San Francisco Zen Center.” Religion and American Culture: A Journal of Interpretation 17:57–93.

Chadwick, David. 2000. Crooked Cucumber: The Life and Teaching of Shunryu Suzuki. New York: Crown Publishing Group.

Downing, Michael. 2002. Shoes Outside the Door: Desire, Devotion, and Excess at San Francisco Zen Center. Washington, DC: Counterpoint.

Freeman, Jo, ed. 1983. Social Movements of the Sixties and Seventies. London: Longman.

Lachs, Stuart. 2019. “Tibetan Buddhism Enters the 21st Century: Trouble in Shangri-la.” Tibetan Buddhism in the West, July 12. Accessed from https://info-buddhism.com/index.html on 20 September 2026.

Lachs, Stuart. 2002. “Richard Baker and the Myth of the Zen Roshi.” thezensite, October 22. Accessed from http://www.thezensite.com/ZenEssays/CriticalZen/Richard_Baker_and_the_Myth.htm on 21 September 2026.

Lachs, Stuart. 1999. “Means of Authorization: Establishing Hierarchy in Ch’an/Zen Buddhism in America.” Revised paper from presentation at the 1999 (Boston) Meeting of the American Academy of Religion.

Richard Baker website. n.d. “Insights into Baker Roshi’s Life & Work.” Accessed from https://www.bakerroshi.com/about on 19 March 2026.

Ryan, Philip. 2002. “Sex, Shoes, and California Zen.” Killing the Buddha, May 2. Accessed from
https://killingthebuddha.com/mag/exegesis/sex-shoes-and-california-zen/ on 21 September 2026.

SFZC website. 2026. “Full Moon Bodhisattva Ceremony.” Accessed from https://www.sfzc.org/files/chants-full-moon on 10 September 2026.

SFZC website. 2026. “The Sixteen Bodhisattva Precepts.” Accessed from https://www.sfzc.org/offerings/establishing-practice/sixteen-bodhisattva-precepts on 10 September 2026.

SFZC website. 1996. Ethical Principles and Grievance Procedures. Accessed from www.sfzc.org on 21 September 2026.

Schneider, Sugata. 1994. “The Long Learning Curve: An Interview With Richard Baker Roshi.” Tricycle: The Buddhist Review. Accessed from https://tricycle.org/magazine/richard-baker-roshi/ on 21 September 2026.

Serran-Pagan y Fuentes, Cristobal. “Deep Ecumenism in the Mystical Thought of D. T. Suzuki and Thomas Merton.” Thomas Merton Center. Accessed from https://merton.org/ITMS/Seasonal/31/31-3Serran-Pagan.pdf.;

Suzuki,  Shunryu. 2020 [1970]. Zen Mind, Beginners Mind. Boulder, CO: Shambhala Publishing.

Wenger, Michael. 2002. Wind bell: Teachings from the San Francisco Zen Center 1968-2001. Berkeley: North Atlantic Books.

Zimmerman, David. 2025. “An Update on Zentatsu Richard Baker from Abbot David Zimmerman.” Sangha News Journal, May 22. Accessed from https://blogs.sfzc.org/blog/2025/05/22/an-update-on-zentatsu-richard-baker-from-abbot-david-zimmerman/ on 23 March 2026.

Publication Date:
21 September 2026

 

Share

Children of God

CHILDREN OF GOD TIMELINE

1827 (April 27):  Mary Ann Girling was baptised in the Anglican church of Little Glemham, a hamlet in Suffolk, England.

1858 (Christmas):  Girling experienced her first vision of Christ.

1863 (May 2):  Girling married George Stanton Girling.

1864 (December):  Girling experienced a range of mystical phenomena, including visions and stigmata on her hands, feet, and side.

1869:  Girling prophesied the Second Coming of Christ. She abandoned her family and became an independent, itinerant preacher.

1870:  Eliza Folkard became the first convert to Girling’s teaching.

1870-1871:  Girling and several followers moved to London.

1871 (December):  Julia Wood joined the group and became its main financial supporter.

1872 (January 2):  The Children of God moved from London to New Forest Lodge in Hampshire, named by Girling as the place of the Second Coming.

1872:  Several converts visited Mount Lebanon and introduced ideas from the American Shakers into the Children of God.

1874 (December 15):  The Children of God were evicted from New Forest Lodge, and Girling was arrested.

1875 (February 11):  The Children of God were moved from a barn to a field, then to Tiptoe Farm, in the village of Hordle.

1883:  Girling published The Close of the Dispensation in which she claimed to be the female incarnation of Christ.

1886 (September 18):  Girling died of cancer in Tiptoe Farm.

1886 (September 22): Girling was buried in the churchyard of Hordle; the Children of God disbanded.

1889:  William Oxley published Modern Messiahs and Wonder Workers, containing first-hand accounts of the Children of God.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

The Children of God were a small, short-lived millenarian group in England in the second half of the nineteenth century. Their founder was Mary Ann Girling, née Clouting. Girling was born in April 1827 into a strictly religious and relatively poor farming family as the eldest of twelve children. Although she was baptised in the Anglican church of Little Glemham, in Suffolk, her family maintained close ties to the Wesleyan Methodist Church. Her father may have been a Methodist lay preacher, and her younger brother Mark eventually preached on the Wesleyan circuit. Girling did not receive much formal education but had by adulthood required considerable knowledge of the Bible. Around Christmas 1858, she first saw Christ. He revealed himself three more times in the following years.

On May 2, 1863, she married George Stanton Girling, with whom she already had two children, in the Anglican church of Lowestoft. They moved close to Ipswich Docks. Both worked different jobs. Girling was, at various times, a domestic servant, a dressmaker and a milliner. The family was beset by misfortune. Girling repeatedly claimed to have lost eight children either through miscarriage, stillbirth or infant death. This gave her “very hard thoughts of God” (Oxley 1889) but also drove her to the local Methodist chapel, where she became a class leader and began to preach, first in a Wesleyan chapel at Stratford St Andrew. Although by the mid-nineteenth century it was unusual, women on occasion did preach on Methodist circuits. As class leader, Girling led Methodist prayer meetings during which she exhibited a confident style of public speaking and proselytising. By autumn 1863, she was expelled because of the radical nature of her teachings, although no sources exist about the contents. Afterwards, Girling nevertheless continued to preach in cottages and in open air, following a rudimentary rural preaching circuit through Suffolk. Followers lived in their own homes and earned their livings in their usual ways, meeting regularly for Bible classes and worship in each other’s homes.

In late December 1864, Girling fell ill and began to experience a series of mystical phenomena: the gift of prophecy, speaking in tongues, bearing the stigmata in her hands, feet and side. Christ appeared to her a final time, and agreeing to his mandate “to go forth and declare the immediate Coming of the Lord” she was, eventually, healed. “Grace came upon me,” she explained to reporters of The Times a decade later, on December 26, 1874: it was a “sweet revelation, filling her with a holy joy beyond all expression.” She subsequently left her husband and children to preach.

The chronology is uncertain, but by the late 1860s Girling was an itinerant prophet, preaching on street corners and in the cottages of followers such as the farmhouse of the Bentham family in Little Glemham, which Girling used as a licensed chapel every three weeks, hosting prayer groups of up to a hundred people. [Image at right] She was barred from the Methodist chapels, in part because of her fire-and-brimstone style of preaching, and in part, as Janet Rose shows, because she increasingly alluded to her own, personal divinity. Aside from private prayer meetings, Girling sometimes also spoke to large audiences about her mission. Those public appearances were increasingly haunted by controversy and hostility, sometimes escalating into violence.

In 1870, Eliza Folkard, a twenty-five-year-old woman living in the hamlet of Parham, on Girling’s preaching circuit, became the first of Girling’s followers to go through a dramatic conversion experience. Folkard was a choir member in the local Wesleyan congregation. Considerable detail about this experience exists in the writing of an eyewitness, the spiritualist chronicler William Oxley. During a prayer meeting with Girling, she was reported to suddenly fall back and lay in an unconscious or trance state for two hours. Then she rose and began to dance wildly, saying she had received the message and its accompanying gift of the Holy Spirit. She declared that “Mrs Girling was the chosen messenger to herald the Saviour’s appearing” (Oxley 1889). After the meeting, she left her parents and began to follow Girling on the circuit as her first disciple. Folkard’s conversion marked a change in Girling’s religious career, from preacher to sectarian leader. Other converts followed, primarily from Methodist circles and from within the Church of England, sometimes from other dissenting congregations. Peter Jerrome writes how, for instance the Loxwood Dependants in London saw their prayer rooms empty, their “tiny community subjected by the sheer power of Mrs Girling’s preaching.

Folkard’s conversion in 1870 could be considered the beginning of the Children of God as an autonomous religious group. Girling left her husband and children to pursue her spiritual goals, and Folkard went with her. By the autumn of 1871, Girling was known to her converts as “Mother.” Folkard’s conversion marked a change in Girling’s ministry. “Mother” emerged as charismatic leader of a movement and a mission, and as her following grew the organisational structure was adjusted so that, by 1873, the Children of God were living in a celibate community, working and worshipping together, having abandoned notions of private property and family structures. The introduction of celibacy, in particular, caused some conflict between married couples and significantly slowed the conversion rate.

Girling’s lectures were advertised in pamphlets and handbills across Suffolk, indicating both an ambition to increase audiences and a certain public fascination with the fledgling group. Increasingly, her lectures and sermons became subject to harassment and attacks even as they continued to inspire conversions. Cottage meetings were disrupted, often violently so. In Woodbridge, in 1872, a public event ended in rioting. By then, Girling had moved to London, together with a small group of disciples from Suffolk, likely in reaction to opposition and controversy (and perhaps also because her brother Charles lived in Chelsea then). It is unclear whether once in the capital Girling first joined with the Bible Christians before being banned from the pulpit after proclaiming her own immortality, or whether he Children of God immediately began to hold Bible class meetings in the houses of followers in Battersea in 1870. Either way, before long Girling made a rudimentary makeshift chapel in Chelsea, under a railway bridge on Walworth Road, South London. Some accounts mention a group of twelve congregates, a “small band” of followers closest to Girling who acquired gifts of prophecy themselves. There Girling became known as an eccentric woman preacher from Suffolk, whose sermons caused followers to dance, kiss, and go into trances. Those spectacular events in turn drew curious onlookers. Girling’s preaching style received significant attention from journalists and audiences. According to the London journalist and Anglican clergyman Charles Maurice Davies, she “prayed volubly, and used her long arms freely in gesticulation, actually screaming at one point;” she had “a sort of animal appearance” (Davies 1873). Many accounts indeed focused on Girling’s appearance, always dressed in black, with gaunt expressions, wildly waving a Bible around; she was described as assertive, even aggressive, and argumentative.

Hostility followed the congregation to London, however, in the form of heckling, property damage, violent assault, and court cases. Prayer services were barricaded against gangs who smashed windows and attacked followers. On January 2, 1872, Julia Wood, a recent convert hailing from a wealthy family in Staffordshire, bought New Forest Lodge in Lymington, Hampshire. Wood’s influence extended to the organisational and doctrinal aspects of the community, particularly introducing elements from the American Shakers. There is some evidence that some of Girling’s disciples were in contact with the Shakers, in the hope of establishing a more direct connection. Wood convinced the Children to live communally and provided the accommodation to do so. Once established in the New Forest, the Children of God, by then numbering around 150 people (111 of whom women and children) with varying social backgrounds, grew into a tight-knit enclave commune. Under Wood’s patronage, the community restructured. Female Children of God, for example, began to wear trouser costumes during the week and white dresses for Sunday worship.

The community failed to pay the interest on the mortgage of the Lodge and, on December 15, 1874, were evicted from New Forest Lodge. The eviction involved a heated altercation between the Sheriff’s officers and the Children of God. Girling was briefly arrested but released soon after while the Children of God huddled, for days, in open air by the side of the road. The harshness of the eviction drew nationwide attention, also from the press, and led to public sympathy as well as support. The Children of God could stay in a barn on the Lymington property of local dignitary, the Hon. Auberon W. E. M. Herbert. This arrangement, too, proved untenable, and they once again stayed on the roadside for five weeks before renting a cluster of small farm buildings in Hordle, called Tiptoe Farm.

The eviction from New Forest Lodge posed a fundamental problem as a failure of prophecy: its location was identified by Girling as the site of the Second Coming, after all. It marked a public turn of Girling and the Children of God. She began to appear more regularly in the press, either to explain the movement’s circumstances and beliefs, or to defend their spiritual and social position. Select reporters were allowed tours of the encampment in Hordle. Local entrepreneurs began to arrange tourist trips to the community, including the Children of God, usually referred to as “New Forest Shakers,” in lists of local sights to see. In 1883, Girling published The Close of the Dispensation, the Last Message to the Church and the World, a four-page tract in which she publicly declared herself the (female) Messiah, “the second appearing of Jesus, the Christ of God, the Bride, the Lamb’s Wife, the God-mother and Saviour, life from heaven.” She signed it “Jesus First and Last (Mary Ann Girling)” (Girling 1883).

After a period of declining health and decreasing public appearances, during which Alice Read looked after her, Girling died of womb cancer on September 18, 1886. The funeral on September 22 drew curious crowds. About twenty Children of God attended her grave in Hordle churchyard in expectance of their “Mother’s” resurrection. The group disbanded soon after, although evidence suggests some Children occasionally convened in the months following the funeral. Eliza Folkard returned to her parental home and became a dressmaker. A few of the Girlingite households clustered near Tiptoe Farm, and some appear to have taken in former disciples as lodgers. In 1912, Lawrence Housman interviewed an unnamed follower who still lived in the meeting house and “spoke of the ‘Mother’ as if she were yet alive.” Interviewed in 1927, two former disciples told the author T. A. Wylie that they still grieved “for the break up of their community life” (Wylie 1927).

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

The doctrinal roots of the community’s theology were in Methodism, but even in the earliest days Girling’s theology deviated from mainstream Christianity in fundamental ways. Extant sources do not shed light on the details of Girling’s eschatology. Moreover, Girlingite doctrine was not set in stone from the beginning; it shifted in message and emphasis several times. It was shaped by the constantly changing circumstances in which the Children of God found themselves, increasingly centring Girling’s own divinity.

At its core, however, Girlingite doctrine centred on the idea that the Apocalypse was imminent, and that Girling served as God’s main messenger. After Girling’s mystical experiences, culminating in her stigmatisation in 1864, she expounded the conviction that God had personally revealed to her the path of salvation and that she was tasked with leading humankind to redemption: “He revealed to me all passages from Genesis to Revelation relating to the redemption of the body, and He gave me the key to read them.” All knowledge was said to come directly from God. Following those experiences, Girling’s biblical exegesis determined the imminent course of events, leading up to the Second Coming of Christ.

Newspapers suggest that, while still preaching on the Methodist circuit, Girling declared that Judgment Day was near. She anticipated the events described in I Thessalonians 4:16-17: “(16) For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trump of God: and the dead in Christ shall rise first: (17) Then we which are alive and remain shall be caught up together with them in the clouds, to meet the Lord in the air: and so shall we ever with the Lord.” This central idea, that these scriptural events were imminent, shaped all other beliefs. Those chosen to be saved through Girling’s prophesying would take up their rightful place as saints by Christ’s side in Heaven, as in Revelation 20:4-6. Those who rejected Girling’s message would soon be judged by Christ.

Her mission of proselytization was, therefore, felt to be urgent. The Children of God believed that they were living through biblical prophecies. The community’s eschatology can be best described as pre-millennial. Believers held the idea that the Second Coming of Christ will mark the start of His thousand-year reign, for which the Children must prepare. Having chosen to follow the path to salvation, the Children of God were to become God’s chosen people, with Girling as their prophet. During a riot in Exeter in 1876, one disciple shouted at the crowd: “Touch not the Lord’s anointed!”

This salvation, necessary to qualify as an elected saint in the Millennium, required a spiritual death and rebirth into immortality. Girling’s own mystical experiences likely served as a template. During her early visions, in 1864, Christ had said to her: “Daughter, thy sins are forgiven thee. I have called to declare my immediate coming, and it is now the close of this dispensation; a new era is opening on the world.” The purification of sin was, also in her own case, accompanied by a spiritual death that resulted in rebirth and immortality. Girling proclaimed that faithful followers, having gone through this transformative experience, were immune to death. This belief was shared in many statements of followers throughout the existence of the congregation. In 1871, for example, one follower wrote to another that “Life to me is earnest… I know that I am going to live for ever and am conscious that every thought and every action is moulding my character for eternity.” One disciple stated to a reporter of the Salisbury and Winchester Journal on April 24 ,1886, months before Girling’s death: “If I did not feel sure I was going to live forever… I would leave the camp tomorrow.” By then, however, several disciples had died.

As the Children of God became a commune in Hampshire, doctrinal modifications were introduced that resembled those of the American Shakers. Julia Wood steered Girling’s theology towards a more explicit acknowledgment of the existence of a female Christ, and towards attempts to accommodate a female deity within Holy Trinity. This set the stage for Girling’s own divinity, which was formally revealed in the published tract The Final Dispensation (1883). In this tract, Girling aimed to reconcile the male Christ of Scripture with her own femininity. Upon their move out of London, Girling identified New Forest Lodge in Hampshire as the location of Christ’s Second Coming and Judgment Day; the community’s eviction from the lodge in December 1874 therefore caused a crisis of faith that remained largely unresolved but might also have led to the increasing emphasis on Girling’s own divinity in later years.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

The central belief in Judgment Day and Christ’s Second Coming steered the practices of the Children of God. Girling preached that it was the responsibility of proselytes to prepare themselves for the arrival of the Messiah and their own sanctification. Guided by Girling, disciples established direct communication lines with God. Followers claimed that the Holy Spirit was working amongst them and through them, and that this could be observed as they spoke in tongues, danced ecstatically, went into trance states and prophesied.

Doing so, the Children of God regularly transgressed the boundaries of Victorian social conventions, engaging in religious practices that were considered unacceptable by outsiders, particularly riotous dancing with limbs flailing, and kissing one another without inhibition, and crying out loudly when in religious ecstasy. Prayer meetings were loud and unrestrained. Worship was exuberant and similar to that of contemporaneous Evangelical movements: people danced, sang, fell to the floor in rapture in a shared religious experience that was both intensely physical and spiritual.

Central to this religious experience in the community was conversion. It enhanced Girling’s charisma as spiritual leader around which followers orbited, and each conversion validated her religious mandate. Following Eliza Folkard’s dramatic conversion, proselytes underwent equally spectacular conversions during which they fell to the ground while disciples went into ecstasy, prophesies, spoke in tongues and danced. Converts exhibited a loss of bodily control. Frequently during these communal and public conversion moments, disciples undressed. Conversion was described as a visible manifestation of the Spirit, and also as a spiritual death, and a cleansing of sins. If the sins of the individual were particularly numerous and damaging, this “death” could take on spectacular forms. During a prayer meeting in 1873, a man fell to the floor and did not get up for more than an hour, grimacing and suffering in front of a shocked audience. “Some die very hard, in great agony,” one follower explained to the press (Popplewell 1993). While in trance, converts claimed to speak under the influence of the Holy Spirit. Afterwards, they entered a “state of grace” akin to spiritual rebirth.

Folkard also introduced music and dance into Girling’s services, features that came to define worship in the community. The dancing characterised the group and gave them names under which they were more popularly known: the “Walworth Jumpers” and, later, the “New Forest Shakers.” Services included music such as, in Charles Maurice Davies’ description, “a queer, jumpy, John-Brown-Glory-Hallelujah kind of hymn” as well as Folkard’s singing performances, which were generally very well received (Davies 1873). Without the charismatic conversions, trances and ecstatic dancing, the Children of God would probably not have generated such public interest, nor such intense opposition.

It was commonly expected that converts gave up their way of life to join the Children; after conversion only a strict ascetic life was said to retain the state of purity. Rumours of sensational, ecstatic conversions drew crowds: in the lecture halls of Suffolk, in the makeshift chapel in Walworth, and later in the New Forest. The practices on display during Girling’s sermons appeared radical to outsiders but were, in the eyes of the Children, founded in Scripture, validated by prophecy, and encouraged through direct communications with the Holy Spirit in ways that they likened to God’s interactions with Christ’s apostles at Pentecost. Conversion was, in short, essential in establishing a sense of religious community. Janet Rose has written extensively about the importance of prophecy for the Children of God, a gift that was extended through conversion and spiritual rebirth, mostly to young female members.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Girling’s spiritual authority over the Children of God was derived from her gift of prophecy; and it was absolute. Initially, Girling’s ministry reflected her Methodist background. In Suffolk she was first a class leader, then, operating increasingly independently, also public preacher. As the central aim of the Children of God became apocalyptic, namely to prepare for Judgment Day, societal structures, including gendered hierarchies, were dissolved through a rejection of mainstream society and culture, in favour of a hierarchy of faith. To this end, community members were expected to abandon their old lives and follow Girling. The Children of God were celibate and repudiated marriage. Childcare was shared by all community members.

Social profiles of the Children of God varied. Some came from poor backgrounds. Henry Osborne, for instance, a “brother” who had joined Girling early on in Suffolk and became Girling’s right hand, was described by William Oxley as a “rough, uncouth and illiterate farm labourer” (Oxley 1889). Others left behind successful businesses, relative wealth and careers to join the community; some Children had been tailors, blacksmiths, postmasters, dressmakers and shoemakers, tenant farmers, and gentlemanly types who occasionally acted as spokespersons for the congregation in court or before the press. Some male Girlingites were imprisoned as they were seen to abandon their familial responsibilities; others, like Osborne, brought their wife and children with them. Others donated money and property to the Girlingite cause. Most followers had a religious background.

By the time the community moved to the New Forest, Girling was in all spiritual and practical ways the leader of the Children of God; she was the “Mother” and disciples were her “children.” Followers addressed each other as “brother” and “sister.” But the community was not egalitarian; it had a simple, non-bureaucratic but rigid hierarchical structure. Behavioural rules in the community were biblically sanctioned according to Girling’s study of the Bible; only adherence to these stringent rules would prepare followers for salvation. They included celibacy, daily worship, the renunciation of all worldly goods and relationships, and a commitment to a “life of Christian love.”

Girling’s status, especially in the later years, was that of “God-mother.” She was assisted by several prophets in what Janet Rose has called a “female leadership structure” (Rose 2007). Prophets were mostly young women such as Eliza Folkard, whose early endorsement of Girling ensured her of a place as Girling’s closest confidante, leading outsiders to believe she was Girling’s daughter. By 1870, Folkard preached in private prayer meetings, although Girling remained the only person to read from the Bible in public. Girling’s patron, the wealthy philanthropist Julia Wood, had provided disciples from poor backgrounds with a home since 1870. Wood’s financial support also meant considerable spiritual influence within the community. Primarily through Wood’s interventions, Girlingite women began to wear trouser suits, for instance.

The shared belief in the imminent Apocalypse rendered social structures and material responsibilities irrelevant. Financial management of the community was left to Girling or discarded as unimportant as the Children were expected to focus solely on their preparations for the Millennium. The farmer Benham from Little Glemham donated farm buildings and large sums of money, which he lost as the Children of God experienced severe financial difficulties in Hampshire. The loss seemingly did not bother Benham. When asked by a reporter he stated: “I shall get it back a hundred-fold when the time is accomplished.” The detached attitudes of the Children of God to money and matter also led to the eviction in December 1874, however.

After Girling’s death on September 18, 1886, the formal structure of the community frayed, although individual members maintained social contact.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

The spectacular content and style of Girling’s preaching was received with hostility from the beginning, leading to her expulsion from the Methodist chapel circuit. Her public lectures regularly descended into disorder and violence. In 1872, for instance, the Woodbridge Reporter described how a sermon in the local Lecture Hall was disrupted: “Outsiders rushed in, insiders rushed out, jostling with each other… With some difficulty, the door was shut and locked,” but people in the crowd shouted through Girling’s reading from the Book of Revelation, shouting “Go home to your husband!” and “Are you going to mesmerise us?” The organisers ended the event when a stone shattered a back window. Girling was, by then, considered a disturbance of social order, and this type of controversy followed her and the Children of God, first to London and later to the New Forest.

Religious challenges came not from mainstream denominations. The Anglican vicar of Lymington, for instance, told Girling in 1875 how he considered her preaching harmless. Opposition did come from other “fringe religious” practitioners, who contested Girling’s authority as messenger of God and saw her as a rival in a crowded spiritual marketplace. Preaching tours were dogged by a stage mesmerist named Miller, who organised public demonstrations in which he claimed to imitate the ecstatic worship of the Children of God, getting people to dance, as The Times reported on December 29, 1874, “precisely as the Shakers and… fall into stupors.”In Hampshire, an ex-Swedenborgian clergyman named Clissold repeatedly and publicly exposed Girling’s appeal by also calling her a mesmerist. Clissold allied himself with a stage magician in the hopes of unmasking Girling. On stage and in the press, but also from the pulpit and occasionally in the courtroom, the Children of God defended themselves, as Girling herself did writing in the Hampshire Chronicle of February 6, 1875: “The Lord Jesus has called me to the work I am doing, and He has borne witness of it, and will continue to do so till He comes in the clouds of glory to prove what I have asserted to thousands. I am not afraid of men’s frowns; neither do I court their smiles; but labour night and day in prayer to God for the salvation of precious souls, knowing that the time of the redemption of the body has come in, and saints shall stand ready to meet the Lord.”

The Children of God were regularly and publicly accused of immorality because of the exuberant behaviour during services but also because of their appearance. Julia Wood introduced loose-fitting tunics and trouser suits for the female Children, which were considered by visitors to the community as outrageous. The death of several followers in the years following the eviction from New Forest Lodge caused doubt about the fate of the community.

Another difficulty followed from the group’s belief in an imminent Second Coming. The Children of God prioritised the spiritual above the material to the extent that they neglected financial and other practical obligations, consequentially suffering deprivation, near-starvation, exposure to the elements, mockery and, in some extreme cases, death. The community did not plan for the future, because they were convinced that future would never come. “We never know what we shall do on the morrow,” one “brother” told the Weekly Hampshire Independent on December 19, 1874, days before the community ended up living by the side of the road, “we only live from one moment to another.” Physical hardship and material deprivation haunted the movement from the early 1870s but worsened considerably once they lived communally in Hampshire. Spending weeks by the side of the road, in wind and snow in the winter of 1874-1875, allegedly resulted in the death of one infant.

Finally, the identification of the movement with Girling’s person had as a consequence that her death also meant the death of the movement’s religious purpose. The Children of God as a pre-millennial congregation thus ceased to exist.

IMAGE

Image #1. Mary Ann Girling. Credit: Public domain.

REFERENCES

Andress, W. T. 1937. “True History of ‘Mother’ Girling, the Mystery Woman of the New Forest Shakers.” Hampshire Record Office, 26M79/P23.

Davies, Charles Maurice. 1873. Unorthodox London; or, Phases of Religious Life in the Metropolis. London: Tinsley Brothers.

Heimann, Mary. 2004. “Girling, Mary Ann.” Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Houseman, Lawrence. 1949. “The Watchers.” The Listener.

Jerrome, Peter. 1998. John Sirgood’s Way: the Story of the Loxwood Dependants. Petworth: Window Press.

Oxley, William. 1889. Modern Messiahs and Wonder Workers. London: Trübner.

Popplewell, Lawrence. 1993. Moving the Shakers. Bournemouth: Melledgen Press.

Rose, Janet K. 2007. “‘The Woman Who Claimed to be Christ’: the Millennial Belief of Mary Ann Girling and her Disciples, 1860-1886.” PhD dissertation, University of Oxford.

Smeyers, Kristof. 2024. Supernatural Bodies: Stigmata in Modern Britain and Ireland. Manchester: Manchester University Press.

Smeyers, Kristof. 2019. “A Christ in Curls: the Contested Charisma of Mary Ann Girling (1827-1886).” Women’s History Review 29:18-36.

Smeyers, Kristof. 2017. “When Immortals Die: Excavating the Emotional Impact of the Death of Prophets in Nineteenth-Century England.” Pakistan Journal of Historical Studies 2:1-32.

Wylie, T. A. 1927. “The New Forest ‘Shakers’.” Milford-on-Sea Record Society 4:36.

 Publication Date:
9 September 2026

 

Share

Kristof Smeyers

Kristof Smeyers is a senior research fellow at KU Leuven, Belgium. His research focuses on the histories of religion, science and magic since 1750. He has written books on stigmata and exorcism in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, and co-edited multiple scholarly volumes on the history of incorruptibility, miracles, and animal magnetism. He is co-founder of the research networks Enchantment in the History of Capitalism and Fabula Velata.

Share

Bothered About Dungeons and Dragons

BOTHERED ABOUT DUNGEONS AND DRAGONS TIMELINE

1948 (June 30):  Patricia A. Pulling was born Patricia Ann Showker.

1965:  Irving Lee (Bink) Pulling II was born.

1973:  Tactical Studies Rules (TSR, Inc.) the original publisher of Dungeons & Dragons was established.

1982 (June 9):  Pulling’s son, Irving, committed suicide.

1983:  Pulling created Bothered About Dungeons and Dragons (BADD) with Thomas Radecki, who was Director of the National Coalition on Television Violence (NCTV).

1983:  Following a series of failed lawsuits, Pulling began began publishing information asserting that  Dungeons and Dragons (D&D) encouraged devil worship and suicide.

1984:  Pulling became a director of the National Coalition on Television Violence.

1985:  Pulling appeared on the television program Sixty Minutes.

1989 (August):  Pulling co-authored The Devil’s Web: Who Is Stalking Your Children For Satan?

1989:  Michael A. Stackpole published Game Hysteria and the Truth, which challenged the accuracy of assertions made in The Devil’s Web.

1990:  Pulling resigned from BADD.

1991:  The Game Manufacturers Association published a report citing he American Association of Suicidology, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control, and Health and Welfare Canada that indicated no relationship between role playing video games and suicide.

1997 (September 18): Patricia Pulling died.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Role playing video games (RPGs) achieved considerable popularity in the U.S. and other western nations beginning in the mid-1970s (Fine 1983; Laycock 2015). The genre typically involves story and character development, controlled by the participants, in the context of some type of combat or quest, such as world exploration or world saving. Each player creates a character who  has a name and physical  and personality characteristics distinct from the player that the player adopts for the game. As Barton notes (2007):

 The characters operate in a virtual world controlled by a referee/narrator figure called the GM or games master, depending on which variant of game is being played. (Variants include Dungeon Master, referee, narrator, storyteller, etc.). The GM creates a virtual world and the players make decisions, based on their character’s interaction with that world and moderated by a combination of statistics, probability and characterisation.

One indication of the subcultural quality of D&D is that thirty-five percent of men and twenty percent of women create characters that are alternate gender and more than half choose nonhuman characters (Waldron 2005). RPGs have become a major industry with a plethora of game varieties and hundreds of millions of participants (Barton 2007). I has been estimated that by 2004 20,000,000 gamers have played D&D (“The Great 1980s…” 2014)

Dungeons & Dragons, which is is widely considered the first tabletop role-playing game (TTRPG), was initially created in 1974 by two entrepreneurs, Gary Gygax and Dave Arneson, essentially establishing the genre. D&D evolved from a pencil-and-paper game to mainframe computers and then personal computers.

Irving Pulling encountered D&D as a student in Patrick Henry High School  in Virginia and sometimes played the game on high school computers as a member of the Dungeons and Dragons Club. At the time there were an estimated 3,000,000-4,000,000 game players in the U.S. (Isikoff 1983). He was included in the school’s Talented and Gifted program but was regarded by classmates as experiencing personal problems unrelated to D&D (Deutschmann 2021).

When he committed suicide by a self-inflicted gunshot wound in June 1982, his mother attributed the event to his involvement with D&D, claiming that the game had placed a curse on Irving’s game character immediately prior to his death. She the filed an unsuccessful wrongful death suit against the high school principal. She also filed an unsuccessful suit against TSR, Inc., D&D‘s publishers (Deutschmann 2021). While there were a few other cases of suicide by “troubled teens” who had engaged in D&D play, the Pulling case was the most influential since it lead to the formation of BADD (Allison 2014). The case received national media coverage (Isikoff 1983; Stackpole 1989; “The Great 1980s…” 2014).

When Pullings legal suit strategy failed as cases were dismissed, by 1983 she was self-publishing and distributing information supporting her allegations, most notably Dungeons and Dragons – Witchcraft Suicide Violence (Dempsey, Dempsey and Pulling n.d.). [Image at right] She launched a personal crusade that was quite successful in gaining publicity and influence through the end of the 1980s. [See, Organization/Leadership] The movement then encountered significant headwinds. Two reports on which Michael Stackpole was an author, Game Hysteria and the Truth (1989) and The Pulling Report (1991) seriously discredited Pulling’s allegations, and particularly the thoroughgoing examination of cases attempting to link D&D with suicide. The second report incorporated disconfirmation findings by the American Association of Suicidology, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control, and Health and Welfare Canada (Wiseman and Stackpole 1991). By the time the second report was published, Pulling had already resigned from BADD in 1990. The movement languished thereafter and Pulling died in 1997, effectively ending the organizational crusade she started.

DOCTRINES/RITUALS

Pulling has laid out the guiding vision for B&D clearly (Waldron 2005):

A fantasy role-playing game which uses demonology, witchcraft, voodoo, murder, rape, blasphemy, suicide, assassination, insanity, sex perversion, homosexuality, prostitution, satanic type rituals, gambling, barbarism, cannibalism, sadism, desecration, demon summoning, necromantics, divination and other teachings.  There have been a number of deaths nationwide where games like Dungeons and Dragons were either the decisive factor in adolescent suicide and murder, or played a major factor in the violent behaviour of such tragedies.  Since role-playing is typically used for behaviour modification, it has become apparent nationwide (with the increased homicide and suicide rates in adolescents) that there is a great need to investigate every aspect of a youngster’s environment, [sic] including their method of entertainment, in reaching a responsible conclusion for their violent actions.

Those reported to be vulnerable to being drawn into B&D include a broad swarth of adolescents with characteristics that include over- and under-achievers, loners, intelligent, creative, rebellious, and abused. They may be reached both through friendship networks,  and public events, occult books and films, heavy metal bands, satanic groups, and, of course, role playing games (Waldron 2005). [Image at right] The game playing ritual is dangerous because it may induce personality changes such that players lose a sense of the boundary between fantasy and reality. In that event players may engage in immoral or even criminal acts as the transfer game permissible actions into the everyday world.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

As the primary source of BADD activity, Pulling developed a range of initiatives designed to increase the visibility and influence of the organization. These included petitions to Congress and federal agencies (Federal Trade Commision, Consumer Products Safety Council), appearances on popular television programs (Geraldo, Sally Jesse Raphael, Sixty Minutes), lobbying heads of a range of institutions (church, family, media, law enforcement), launching a lecture series to educate the public about her findings, and serving as an expert witness in criminal cases. She obtained a private investigator’s licence to bolster her credentials with law enforcement agencies.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

The anti-D&D coalition consisted of  a loosely coupled network of interests. Conservative Christian groups claimed that summoning and interacting with was anti-biblical and dangerous. One of the dangers was that assuming the identity of fictional entities created the potential for actual demon possession. For the therapy community, D&D was alleged to induce personality deterioration that threatened players’ ability to discriminate between fantasy and reality. In the most extreme cases this might lead to self harm and even suicide, as Pulling alleged occurred in her son’s case. For law enforcement there was the potential for immoral and illegal conduct as actions permissible in fantasy games were transposed into real life situations, including violence and homicide.

While the radical and unsupported D&D claims unravelled within a few years, it was instrumental in building the larger Satanism Scare coalition as it laid the groundwork for a range of other purported satanic activities that continued long after BADD had disappeared (Little 2025; Geier 2025). Similar fears were transferred to heavy metal bands like Black Sabbath, Mötley Crüe, and Judas Priest for including subliminal messages in their albums and backmasking. In 1983, the first in at least 100 ritual daycare abuse cases surfaced in California when staff at a preschool in Manhattan Beach run by Virginia McMartin were accused of ritual abuse of the young children. in 1985, serial killer Richard Ramirez displayed a pentagram on his hand and shouted “Hail Satan” at his trial. In 1990, two American families unsuccessfully sued the British heavy metal band Judas Priest and CBS Records for inducing their sons to commit suicide five years earlier.

Over time the alarm over D&D subsided, even as the larger satanism scare expanded. The humber of role playing games of all types rapidly expanded and the new wave of music groups mainstreamed. Ironically perhaps, established Christian denominations began promoting role playing games, even D&D. One observer (Tallon 2019) stated that

D&D is the most popular tabletop role-playing game in the world, and seems to have a special magic to summon friends together. For adults with busy lives (or teenagers with gaming consoles), this is no small feat. The culture moment seems to need D&D, or something like it.

In commenting on D&D, a Methodist minister went further (Patterson 2026):

“I would argue that the most Christian thing in the world is to come together to create something beautiful and something meaningful,” Woodroof said. “I think that building those bonds and reaching out to the community, establishing that there is hope in the world, and you can make a story that even if it starts from a dark place, ends in a place that is beautiful and poignant and full of hope — a happy ending. I think that is the most Christian thing in the world.

In addition, Christianized alternatives to D&D, such as Dragon Raid and Deliverance, by incorporating biblical text into the game language.

IMAGES

Image #1: Cover of Dungeons and Dragons – Witchcraft Suicide Violence. Public Domain.
Image #2: Dungeons and Dragons game in progress.  Credit: GNU Free Documentation License through the Free Software Foundation.

REFERENCES

Allison, Peter. 2014. “The great 1980s Dungeons & Dragons panic.” BBC, April 11. Accessed from https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-26328105 on 15 August 2026.

Barton, Matt. 2007. “The History of Computer Role-Playing Games Part 1: The Early Years (1980 – 1983).” Gamasutra. UBM Tech.

Dempsey, Mary, Pat Dempsey, Pat A. Pulling. n.d. Dungeons and Dragons – Witchcraft Suicide Violence. BADD.

Deutschmann, Jennifer. 2021. “The Tragic Death Of Irving Lee Pulling.” Grunge, June 15. Accessed from  https://www.grunge.com/438682/the-tragic-death-of-irving-lee-pulling/ on 15 August 2026.

Farge, Paul. 2006. “Destroy All Monsters.” The Believer Magazine. Accessed from http://www.believermag.com/issues/200609/?read=article_lafarge on 15 August 2026.

Fine, Gary. 1983. Shared Fantasy Role Playing Games as Social Worlds. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Geier, Thom. 2025. “When Dungeons & Dragons Cast Its Spell on 1980s America” History, December 11. Accessed from

Isikoff, Michael. 1983. “Parents Sue School Principal: Game Cited in Youth’s Suicide.” Washington Post, August 13. Accessed from  https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1983/08/13/parents-sue-school-principal/bc9209f6-3070-430d-a38d6d4cca8be63/ on 15 August 2026.

Laycock, Joseph. 2015. Dangerous Games: What the Moral Panic over Role-Playing Games Says about Play, Religion, and Imagined Worlds. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Little, Becky. 2025. “What Sparked the Satanic Panic of the 1980s?” History, November 13.  Accessed from https://www.history.com/articles/what-was-satanic-panic-1980s on August 15 2026.

Patterson, Jim. 2026. “Embracing role-playing games at church.” UM News, July 31. Accessed from https://www.umnews.org/en/news/embracing-role-playing-games-at-church on 15 August, 2026.

Pulling, Patricia. 1989. The Devil’s Web.  Los Angeles: Huntingdon House.

Pulling, Patricia.  1988. “Interviewing Techniques for Adolescents.”  BADD Inc., September.

Pulling, Patricia and Kathy Cawthon. 1989. The Devil’s Web: Who Is Stalking Your Children For Satan? Vital Issues Press.

Stackpole, Michael. 1990. The Pulling Report. Accessed from https://web.archive.org/web/20130129132040/http://www.rpgstudies.net/stackpole/pulling_report.html on 15 August 2026.

Stackpole, Michael. 1989.  Game Hysteria and the Truth. Accessed from https://thedevilyouknow.org/game-hysteria-and-the-truth/ on 15 August 2026.

Tallon, Phil. 2019. “A Christian Defense of Dungeons & Dragons.”  Lovethynerd, November 22. Accessed from  http://A Christian Defense of Dungeons & Dragons Phil Tallon Nov 22, 2019 https://lovethynerd.com/the-christian-response-to-dnd/ on 15 August 2026.

“The great 1980s Dungeons & Dragons panic.” BBC, April 11. Accessed from https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-26328105 on 15 August 2026.

Wiseman, Loren and Michael Stackpole 1991. QUESTIONS & ANSWERS ABOUT ROLE-PLAYING GAMES. Swanton, Ohio: Game Manufacturers Association.

Publication Date:
22 August 2026

Share

Science of Identity Foundation

SCIENCE OF IDENTITY FOUNDATION TIMELINE

1948:  Chris Butler was born in New Orleans.

1966:  Indian renunciate A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami founded the International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON).

1968:  Butler, as “Sai Young,” opened the Haiku Meditation Center.

1969 (January 1):  Butler first met members of ISKCON at a music festival in Hawai‘i.

1970:  Butler disbanded his spiritual community, surrendered to Bhaktivedanta, and joined ISKCON.

1972:  Bhaktivedanta initiated Butler into the renounced order of life (saṃnyāsa).

1973:  Butler left ISKCON, instigating the “Big Split.”

1976:  The political party Independents for Godly Government fielded candidates in a Hawaiian general election.

1977 (November 14):  Bhaktivedanta passed away in Vrindavan, India.

1977:  Butler established the Holy Names Foundation (later renamed the Science of Identity Foundation) and began initiating disciples.

1980s:  Butler (co)authored several books, recorded four albums, and produced the TV program Chris Butler Speaks, which aired internationally.

1994:  With others, Butler established the World Vaiṣṇava Association

1999:  The Australian political party EarthSave fielded candidates in a New South Wales state election.

1998 (January 4):  Butler filed what would ultimately be unsuccessful defamation lawsuits against four media companies.

2026 (June 21):  Jon Swaine of The Washington Post published an exposé suggesting that Butler had long been micromanaging the politics of U.S. government official Tulsi Gabbard

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

In 1948, Chris Butler, the individual who would come to establish the Science of Identity Foundation (SIF), was born in New Orleans. Shortly after, his parents moved him to Molokaʻi, Hawaiʻi, where he was raised Quaker (Wright 1977). During high school, Butler became interested in meditation and, after graduation, enrolled in various philosophy and religion courses at the University of Hawaiʻi. In 1968, however, he abruptly abandoned his postsecondary education and moved to the island of Maui, where he began practicing yoga in earnest and experimenting with things like fasting and psychedelics. After having allegedly attained what he now refers to as nirvikalpa-samādhi or “the impersonal Brahman feature of the Supreme Soul” (SIF 2026b), Butler founded the Haiku Meditation Center, a religious hermitage (āśrama) for instructing fellow youths in aṣṭāṅga and kuṇḍalinī yoga. To these students, he was known as Sai Young. Their community quickly grew and came to inhabit three locations: a Quonset hut on the North Shore of Oʻahu; a house in ʻĀlewa Heights, Honolulu; and a three-acre farm on Maui (Wharton 1970).

On January 1, 1969, at a music festival at Diamond Head (Lēʻahi) on the island of Oʻahu, Butler came into contact for the first time with members of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON), a Gauḍīya Vaiṣṇava organization that Indian renunciate A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami (1896–1977) had established in New York roughly two and a half years prior. The Swami’s disciples introduced Butler to their guru’s teachings as well as to the Hare Krishna mantra, both of which he then incorporated into his programs at the Haiku Meditation Center. It was not long before Butler fully embraced the devotional (bhakti) yoga espoused by ISKCON’s founder and renamed his Haiku Meditation group the Krishna Yoga Community.

Throughout 1969 and 1970, tensions between adherents of ISKCON and those of the Krishna Yoga Community steadily increased. The former accused Butler of being an illegitimate spiritual leader lacking the pedigree provided by an established lineage of gurus, such as theirs: the Brahmā-madhva-gauḍīya-sampradāya. They also rebuked him and his disciples for retaining common counterculture dress and hairstyles. The dispute reached its climax in the winter of 1970 when ISKCON’s Govinda dāsī went together with two other female devotees to confront Butler at the Church of the Crossroads in Honolulu, where he was hosting a public gathering of between seventy and one hundred people. There, the three women distributed a letter written by Bhaktivedanta articulating ISKCON’s condemnation of the Krishna Yoga Community. Govinda dāsī also read it to attendees through a microphone (Vanisource 1972). Within two days, Butler made the decision to join ISKCON. He shaved his head, an act he claims “meant surrender to [Bhaktivedanta] and the disciplic succession,” (1971:33) and encouraged his followers to do the same. All property belonging to the Krishna Yoga Community was gifted to ISKCON before the end of the year. By the spring of 1971, Butler was formally initiated as Bhaktivedanta’s disciple and received the Sanskrit spiritual name Siddha-svarūpānanda. In May of 1972, he entered the renounced order of life (saṃnyāsa).

For well over a year, Butler served ISKCON in a series of countries (Australia, New Zealand, the Philippines, etc.) without significant issue. By December 1972, however, tensions had formed between him and other ISKCON leaders, and in late 1973, together with many sympathizers, Butler left ISKCON, decimating centers in Auckland and Brisbane. The disaffiliated claimed to take issue with the rigid authoritarianism of temple life as well as devotees’ aggressive and deceptive book-distribution tactics. The latter criticism was one that Butler harbored to an extent even prior to joining the organization (Wolf 1970) and one that many individuals both within and outside of ISKCON would increasingly come to share in the years to come (Rochford 2004). Despite his apparently unreconcilable differences with ISKCON, Butler continued to view Bhaktivedanta as his guru and maintain an amiable relationship with him, in part through regular monetary presents (Vanisource 1974; Vanisource 1975b). For his part, the Swami consistently sought to heal the division between his disciples (or “Big Split” [dāsa 1999: 282] as it was being called) but to no avail (Vanisource 1973; Vanisource 1976; GBC 1976).

After Bhaktivedanta passed away on November 14, 1977, Butler adopted the title “jagad-guru,” “guru of the world,” and began formally initiating his own disciples. He added the Sanskrit honorific “paramahaṃsa” to the end of his name, as well, a term that literally means “supreme swan.” Before the end of the year, Butler had also established his own religious organization: the Holy Name Foundation (Scott 1977), which he quickly came to call, instead, the Science of Identity Foundation, a designation reflective of both the organization’s alleged mission to help individuals realize their true nature as well as its tendency (shared with ISKCON) to view science as an epistemology, worldview, and establishment to be “replaced,” rather than “guided” or “absorbed” (Zeller 2010). In 1994, with other spiritual leaders, Butler assisted in founding of the World Vaiṣṇava Association.

Through persistent, and often cunning, evangelical efforts spanning roughly half a century, Butler has amassed a global following.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

The basics of the worldview promulgated by SIF can be readily found in the literature and other media (co)produced by its founder. Since establishing the organization, Butler has authored several booklets as well as two full-length books: Who Are You? Discovering Your Real Identity (1984) and Reincarnation Explained (1987 [1983]). He has also published (with Zhang Huilan) Xifang shehui bing: xidu, zisha he lihun (Social Ills of the West: Drugs, Suicide, and Divorce [1983]), Yujia: qigong yu mingxiang (Yoga: Qigong and Meditation [1986]), and Huilan Yujia (Huilan Yoga [2012]). In addition, he has produced the television series Chris Butler Speaks (also called Jagad Guru Speaks), which began airing in the early 1980s and was broadcast in the United States, New Zealand, and the Philippines. Finally, between 1982 and 1985, he released four records with his Hawaiian rock band, Morning Sun, for whom he performed vocals. Through these diverse media, Butler relays the core teachings introduced to him by Bhaktivedanta Swami in what appears to be efforts to make them yet more accessible, culturally relevant, and/or palatable to audiences in the West (or China, as is the case with the coauthored material). The teachings of Bhaktivedanta are in turn principally rooted in the main religious texts that the Swami translated, commented upon, and taught to be authoritative: Bhagavad-gītā, Bhāgavata-purāṇa, Caitanya-caritāmṛta, and Bhakti-rasāmṛta-sindu.

As might be expected given its name, SIF functions to spread a worldview centered on the question of identity. “Uncovering our true identity,” declares Butler (1987:143), “this is the actual goal in life.” Who are we? What is our constitution? What is our ontological position in the universe? Our purpose? That we get the answers to these questions right is crucial, for by getting them wrong (that is, by misidentifying) we endlessly produce all manner of “bitter fruits” (Butler 1984:303): depression, anxiety, drug abuse, suicide, crime, war, racism, environmental degradation, and so on.

First, we must understand that we do, in fact, exist. We have selves. Butler repeatedly decries the Buddhist notion of anātman (non-self) as severely misguided, as well as the related aim of Buddhist life: nirvāṇa. Yet, while we undoubtedly exist, we are neither the “gross physical body” of flesh and blood, which Butler likens to “a garment” worn or “a vehicle” driven (1984:19), nor are we the “subtle material body,” which consists of our false ego (i.e., bodily identification), intelligence, and mind. Both bodies, gross and subtle, are in constant flux, transforming within each life and from one life to the next as we are reborn again and again according to our desires. Our true nature, though, is unchanging; we are indestructible “spirit soul,” a jīva, which is at once conscious and part and parcel of Krishna, the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

While jīvas are one with Krishna in substance, the distinct identity of each spirit-soul is meant to remain intact. Butler and his spiritual predecessors vehemently reject the theologies of nondualist Hindu schools, such as Advaita Vedānta, whose adherents seek to realize undifferentiated union with Nirguṇa Brahman (the attribute-less absolute). Rather than attempting to see oneself as God, a person should, instead, adopt the view that she or he exists in a position relative to Krishna that is dependent, dominated, and feminine (a position that exists solely for his pleasure). Surrendering to this reality, one embraces one’s natural place in the universe and takes to a life of loving service to God, especially indirectly through service to one’s guru (viewed as Krishna’s ineffable representative on Earth, “a living extension of the Kingdom of God,” [Butler 1987:98] and essential mediator between oneself and the divine). Such service may take the form of whatever work one does, which is to say that Butler and his disciples profess a kind of “inner-worldly asceticism” (Weber 1964 [1922]:166) that encourages individuals to live out their faiths through a variety of vocations. As Butler puts it, one should use all of one’s “talents . . . abilities . . . [and] position in the service of God” (SIF 2026a). Moreover, adherents of SIF aim to embrace (even revel in) all manner of suffering which may result through such service, thus developing an answer to the various torments and toils of life through what sociologist Peter L. Berger (1967) calls a “masochistic” theodicy.

Once Krishna becomes the center of one’s life and serving him one’s sole aim, an individual returns to Godhead and attains the spiritual world. Such occurs because the singular desire to serve Krishna replaces the material desires which had hitherto perpetuated the cycle of births and deaths within which the jīva was trapped. While it is sometimes implied that the goal of spiritual practice is to be attained in the hereafter and realized far above the material plane (i.e., framed as a “transporting teleography” [Tweed 2008]), SIF literature also indicates that one may unite with Krishna and dwell in the spiritual world not only after death but right here, right now, in this lifetime (a “transforming teleography” [Tweed 2008]). “The loving servant of God . . . is not really where he appears to be,” says Butler (1987:98). “Although [such a devotee] may appear to exist in the material world, he is really with God, in the Kingdom of God” (1987:239).

RITUALS/PRACTICES

In addition to regularly reading and hearing the words of their guru, Butler’s disciples are encouraged to engage Vaiṣṇava scriptures and practice (like members of ISKCON) four regulatory principles: (1) no meat, fish, or eggs; (2) no sex for purposes other than procreation with one’s spouse; (3) no gaming; and (4) no intoxicants. Moreover, they are called to meditate. Some meditations taught by Butler are designed to offer a quick lesson on the nature of one’s identity. For instance, in Who Are You? (1984), Butler recommends three forms of meditation that can help practitioners appreciate that they are “not the mind” (1984:58) and are separate from and witness to “the stream of thoughts, feelings, perceptions, and so on that flow through [it]” (1984:56). The first form is called “watching your dreams” (1984:56) and involves mindfully falling asleep so as to promote lucid dreaming. The second form, “silent witness” (1984:57), has one disengage from mental processes in favor of watching them as one “might watch the cars of a train pass . . . at a railroad crossing” (1984:57), and the third, “controlling the mind” (1984:58), has the practitioner stare for a time at an image, then close their eyes with the aim of maintaining within their mind for as long as possible a perfect duplicate. According to Butler, “the fact that you can try to redirect or control your mind, combined with the fact that it is so difficult to succeed in the endeavor . . . shows that you are not the mind or stream of mindstuff” (1984:58).

By far, though, the type of meditation most highly regarded and commonly taken up within SIF is mantra meditation. The practice involves either privately chanting (japa) or communally singing (kīrtana) mantras, especially combinations of the many names and epithets of Krishna, such as Gopāla and Mohana. While certainly embraced, the Hare Krishna mantra is not emphasized within SIF to nearly the same degree that it is within ISKCON (the organization that made it (in)famous), no doubt, in part, as a differentiation tactic. Butler (1982) calls mantra meditation “an integral part of the science of identity” (1982:8) and extolls its revelatory power, which derives from the ontological status of God’s names as “not separate from God Himself” (1982:22). The mantras thus act as “transcendentally purifying agent[s]” (Butler 1987:222) and remove the “dirt and dust” (1987:221) covering our “natural love for the Lord” (1987:221).

For precisely the same reason, foodstuffs prepared for and offered to an embodied image (mūrti) of Krishna are held to be equivalently potent. Once he has taken his fill, devotees eat and drink the leftovers or “prasāda” (literally, “grace”), which they hold to be, like Krishna’s names, non-different from him. (Even more desirable, though, is to consume the remnants of prasāda left by one’s guru after he has eaten). While deity worship and the consumption and distribution of prasāda are practiced within SIF, they are not emphasized as potent soteriological tools in its public-facing media. On SIF’s official website one thus finds mantra recitation, not prasāda, being called “spiritual food” (2026c). Such reticence stands in stark contrast to ISKCON’s evangelical corpus (which frequently celebrates being able to “eat [one’s] way back to Godhead” [King 2012:444]) and is certainly connected to Butler’s recognition that potential recruits from Christian cultures can “have a very difficult time” (Vanisource 1975a) accepting the worship of God’s embodied forms on an altar. Similarly, SIF refrains from highlighting the practice of guru-pūjā, which involves disciples making devotional offerings to Butler’s photo.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

One does not join SIF by becoming a registered member of the organization. Rather, one is either born into or brought progressively deeper into its culture. The gatekeepers of this culture are senior devotees who assess the sincerity and aptitude of its potential recipients. Eventually, if deemed suitable, one may become a disciple of SIF’s founder and, perhaps, even enter his inner circle of trusted pupils so as to serve him directly. The roster of such intimates is fluid, subject to change as individuals fall in and out of favor with Butler.

New devotees are discovered primarily through yoga and meditation centers, which are overseen by longtime Butler disciples, such as Allan Tibby (Acharya das), Johnny Baldwin Midgett (Balakhilya das), and Zhang Huilan (Vaishnava dasi). Often significantly downplaying their connections to SIF, these centers exist in several countries and operate under brands like Yoga Meditation Canada, Australian School of Meditation and Yoga, Meditation New Zealand, Huilan Yoga, and Wai Lana Yoga. In the Philippines, SIF is also behind Madana Mohana Colleges, Inc., which offers primary and secondary school education, and SIFCare (SIF Community Assistance for Responsible Existence), which carries out charitable initiatives, such as providing meals to malnourished children and free acupuncture to those in need. Additionally, SIF is connected to various podcast (e.g., The Breaking Trail, Yoga Wisdom, etc.) and music ventures (e.g., Mantra at the Disco, Billie Sky, etc.).

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

SIF has been accused of issuing rhetoric that is misogynistic, Islamo-, trans-, and homophobic (Han 2022; Hurley 2022). Former disciples of Butler also allege instances of sexual and psychological abuse within the SIF community, which are intimately linked to its culture and ignored by its leadership (Swaine 2026, Leonard 2024, Lalita 2017).

A sustained public concern also exists over Butler’s long-harbored political ambitions (Butler 1976) and the possible influence he has (or would have) over his disciples’ decision making in office. Such concern began in the mid-1970s when several SIF devotees formed the Independents for Godly Government in Hawai‘i and emerged again in the late 1990s when the political party EarthSave was established in Australia. However, to come under greatest scrutiny have been Butler’s relationships with Hawai‘i state senator Mike Gabbard and his daughter Tulsi Gabbard, the latter having held a number of government offices, including director of national intelligence (2025–2026). In 2026, Jon Swaine of The Washington Post published an exposé based on hundreds of memos leaked by former Butler-disciple Rebecca Saltzburg, raising strong suspicions that SIF’s founder has been micromanaging Tulsi’s politics for decades.

In 1978, Butler launched unsuccessful lawsuits against four media companies (two newspapers: Honolulu Star-Bulletin and The Honolulu Advertiser, and two television stations: KGMB and KITV). He argued that, by using the term “Hare Krishnas” in their reporting (and thus failing to distinguish between his community and ISKCON’s), the defendants had caused his organization defamatory damages (The Honolulu Advertiser 1978).

SIF has continued to experience controversy as businesses linked to SIF have been sued for religious discrimination (Cole 2000) and prosecuted for racketeering in several countries (Forrest et al. 2025).

REFERENCES

Berger, Peter L. 1967. The Sacred Canopy: Elements of a Sociological Theory of Religion. Garden City: Doubleday & Company, Inc.

Butler, Chris (Jagad Guru Siddhaswarupananda Paramahamsa). 1987 [1983]. Reincarnation Explained. 2nd ed. Honolulu: The Science of Identity Foundation.

Butler, Chris (Jagad Guru Siddhaswarupananda Paramahamsa). 1984. Who Are You? Discovering Your Real Identity. Honolulu: The Identity Institute.

Butler, Chris (Jagad Guru Siddhaswarupananda Paramahamsa). 1982. Mantra Meditation and Self-Realization. Honolulu: The Science of Identity Foundation.

Butler, Chris (Jagad Guru Siddhaswarupananda Paramahamsa). 1976. “What’s Wrong with Our Politicians? A Point-by-Point Analysis of the Problem and a Positive Program for Change. Back to Godhead 11:19, 22.

Butler, Chris (Jagad Guru Siddhaswarupananda Paramahamsa). 1971. “I Offer My Respectful Obeisances to His Divine Grace  A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda . . .” Back to Godhead 44:28–33.

Butler, Chris (Bo Zhongyan) and Zhang Huilan. 2012. Huilan Yujia (Huilan Yoga), 3 vols. Nanjing: Jiangsu kexue jishu chubanshe.

Butler, Chris (Bo Zhongyan) and Zhang Huilan. 1986. Yujia: qigong yu mingxiang (Yoga: Qigong and Meditation). Beijing: Renmin tiyu chubanshe.

Butler, Chris (Bo Zhongyan) and Zhang Huilan. 1983. Xifang shehui bing: xidu, zisha he lihun (Social Ills of the West: Drugs, Suicide, and Divorce). Beijing: Sanlian shudian.

Cole, William. 2000. “Fired Workers File Religion Lawsuit.” The Honolulu Advertiser, December 17.

dāsa, Kūrma. 1999. The Great Transcendental Adventure: Pastimes of His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda in Australia and New Zealand. Charlottesville: Bookwrights Press.

Forrest, Brett, Caitlin Ostroff, and Rebecca Feng. 2025. “As a Rising Political Star, Gabbard Paid to Mask Her Sect’s Ties to Alleged Scheme.” The Wallstreet Journal, January 28. Accessed from https://www.wsj.com/politics/policy/tulsi-gabbard-science-of-identity-qi-group-ed51c890 on 22 July 2026.  

Governing Body Commission (GBC), ISKCON. “GBC Resolutions, March 1976.” Accessed from https://gbc.iskcon.org/1976/ on 25 July 2026.

Han Yoonji. 2022. “Tulsi Gabbard’s Ties to the Science of Identity Foundation, a Controversial Religious Sect That Some Call an Abusive ‘Cult.’” Business Insider, October 18. Accessed from https://www.businessinsider.com/tulsi-gabbard-science-of-identity-controversial-religious-sect-2022-10 on 28 July 2026.

Hurley, Bevan. 2022. “Tulsi Gabbard’s Ties to Secretive Cult May Explain Her Perplexing Political Journey.” The Independent, October 16. Accessed from https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/tulsi-gabbard-cult-putin-democrat-science-of-identity-b2556594.html on 19 July 2026.

King, Anna S. 2012. “Krishna’s Prasadam: “Eating Our Way Back to Godhead.” Material Religion: The Journal of Objects, Art, and Belief 8:440–65.

Lalita. 2017. “An Insiders Perspective on Tulsi Gabbard and Her Guru.” Medium, September 24. Accessed from https://medium.com/@lalitamann/an-insiders-perspective-on-tulsi-gabbard-and-her-guru-e2650f0d09 on 21 July 2026.

Leonard, Jasper. 2024. “Chris Butler and The Science of Identity Foundation Cult.” Medium, November 28. Accessed from https://medium.com/@jasperoftheriver/chris-butler-and-the-science-of-identity-foundation-cult-45958d4e90c1 on 19 July 2026.

Rochford, E. Burke. 2004. “Airports, Conflict, and Change in the Hare Krishna Movement.” Pp. 273–90 In The Hare Krishna Movement: The Postcharismatic Fate of a Religious Transplant, edited by Edwin F. Bryant and Maria L. Ekstrand. New York: Columbia University Press.

Science of Identity Foundation. 2026a. “Find Happiness in Service to God.” YouTube video. Accessed from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wn2jf63eZfA on 24 July 2026.

Science of Identity Foundation. 2026b. “Jagad Guru Siddhaswarupananda Paramahamsa.” Accessed from https://sif.yoga/about/jagad-guru on 20 July 2026.

Science of Identity Foundation. 2026c. “Meditation.” Accessed from https://sif.yoga/meditation on 23  July 2026.

Scott, Nadine W. 1977. “Siddha Decries Recent Tales of Krishnas’ ‘Lawbreaking.’” Honolulu Star-Bulletin, December 17.

Swaine, Jon. 2026. “Tulsi Gabbard, Her Guru, and the Mysterious Messages That Helped Shape Her Political Career.” The Washington Post, June 21. Accessed from https://www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/2026/06/21/tulsi-gabbard-her-guru-mysterious-messages-that-helped-shape-her-political-career/ on 22 July 2026.

The Honolulu Advertiser. 1978. “Teacher of Krishna Yoga Sues Media for $6 Million.” The Honolulu Advertiser, January 5.

Tweed, Thomas A. 2008. Crossing and Dwelling: A Theory of Religion. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Vanisource. 1976. “Morning Walk – Mayapur.” Accessed from https://vanisource.org/wiki/760308_-_Morning_Walk_-_Mayapur on 22 July 2026.

Vanisource. 1975a. “Conversation A – Honolulu.” Accessed from https://vanisource.org/wiki/750615_-_Conversation_A_-_Honolulu on 26 July 2026.

Vanisource. 1975b. “Letter to Bhurijana written from Vrndavana.” Accessed from https://vanisource.org/wiki/750911_-_Letter_to_Bhurijana_written_from_Vrndavana on 26 July 2026.

Vanisource. 1974. “Letter to Sudama Vipra written from Los Angeles.” Accessed from https://vanisource.org/w/index.php?title=740716_-_Letter_to_Sudama_Vipra_written_from_Los_Angeles on 26 July 2026.

Vanisource. 1972. “Conversation on BG 6.11-14.” Honolulu, Hawai‘i. Accessed from https://vanisource.org/wiki/720513_-_Conversation_on_BG_6.11-14-_Honolulu on 31 July 2026.

Weber, Max. 1964 [1922]. The Sociology of Religion. Boston: Beacon Press.

Wharton, Nadine. 1970. “They Have a Tangible Purpose.” Honolulu Star-Bulletin, July 4.

Wolf, Janice. 1970. “Absolute Power Over Devotees: One Man Rules Haiku Krishnaites.” The Honolulu Advertiser, July 28.

Wright, Walter. 1977. “Chris Butler, Maverick—with 1,000 Followers.” The Honolulu Advertiser, August 22.

Zeller, Benjamin E. 2010. Prophets and Protons: New Religious Movements and Science in Late Twentieth-Century America. New York: New York University Press.

Publication Date:
9 August 2026

Share

Social Scares & Panics

THE SATANISM SCARE

INTERNATIONAL EVENT TIMELINE
Event Timeline for the United States, United Kingdom, Australia [Forthcoming]

WRSP PROFILES
The Satanism Scare (United States) [Forthcoming]
The Satanism Scare (United Kingdom) [Forthcoming]

RELATED PROFILES
Church of Satan
Bothered about Dungeons and Dragons

ACADEMIC PUBLICATIONS

Bader, Christopher. (2003). “Supernatural Support Groups: Who are the UFO Abductees and Ritual Abuse Survivors?” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 42(4): 669-678.

Bottoms, Bette L.; Davis, Suzanne L. (June 1, 1997). “The Creation of Satanic Ritual Abuse”. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology. 16 (2): 112–132.

Bottoms, Bette L., Shaver, Phillip R., and Goodman, Gail S. 1996. “An Analysis of Ritualistic and Religion-Related Child Abuse Allegations”. Law and Human Behavior 20(1):1- 34.

Bromley, David G. and Susan Ainsley. 1995. “Satanism and Satanic Churches: The Contemporary Incarnations.” Pp. 401-409 in America’s Alternative Religions, edited by Timothy Miller. Albany: State University of New York Press.

Bromley, David G. 1991. “Satanism: The New Cult Scare.” Pp. 49-74 in The Satanism Scare, edited by James T. Richardson, Joel Best, and David G. Bromley. Hawthorne, NY: Aldine De Gruyter. 

Bromley, David G. 1991. “The Satanic Cult Scare.” Culture and Society 28 (May 1991): 55-66.

Clifton, Chas.  “The Three Faces of Satanism: A Close Look at the Satan Scare.” Gnosis 12  (Summer 1989):  9-18.

Cleary, Sarah (July 1, 2022). “Better the Devil you Know: The Myth of Harm and the Satanic Panic”. Gothic Studies. 24 (2): 167–184

Cohen, Stanley.  Folk Devils and Moral Panics.  Oxford: MacGibbon and Kee, 1972.

Crouch, Ben M., and Kelly R. Damphousse. 1992. “Newspapers and the Anti-satanism Movement: A Content Analysis”. Sociological Spectrum 12:1-20.

De Young, Mary (1994). “One Face of the Devil: The Satanic Ritual Abuse Moral Crusade and the Law”. Behavioral Sciences and the Law. 12 (4): 389–407.

Downing, Shirley; Charlier (January 17–23, 1988). “Justice Aborted: A 1980s Witch-Hunt”. The Commercial Appeal

Dyrendal, Asbjorn. 1998. “Media Constructions of ‘Satanism’ in Norway, 1988-1997” Foaf- Tale News 43:2-5.

Frankfurter, David (2006). Evil incarnate: rumors of demonic conspiracy and ritual abuse in history. Princeton, N.J: Princeton University Press.

Frankfurter, David (2003). “The Satanic Ritual Abuse Panic as Religious-Studies Data”. Numen. 50: 108–117.

Frankfurter, David. (2001). “Ritual as Accusation and Atrocity: Satanic Ritual Abuse, Gnostic Libertinism, and Primal Murders”. History of Religions. 40 (4): 352–380.

Goleman, Daniel (October 31, 1994). “Proof Lacking for Ritual Abuse by Satanists”. The New York Times. Archived from the original on 2018-05-21

Goode, Erich, and Nachman Ben-Yehuda. 1994. Moral Panics: The Social Construction of Deviance. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.

Goodwin, Megan. 2020. Abusing Religion: Literary Persecution, Sex Scandals, and American Minority Religions. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press. https://wrldrels.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/Abusing_Religion_Literary_Persecution_Sex_Scandals.pdf.

Guilliatt, Richard. 1996. Talk of the Devil: Repressed Memory and the Ritual Abuse Witch-Hunt. Melbourne, Australia: The Text Publishing Co. [Australia]

Gunn, Joshua. 2005. “Prime-time Satanism: rumor-panic and the work of iconic topoi.” Visual Communication 4:93–120. Accessed from https://wrldrels.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/Prime-Time-Satanism.pdf on 15 August 2026.

Hicks, Robert. 1991. In Pursuit of Satan: Police and the Occult.  Buffalo, NY: Buffalo, NY: Prometheus.

Hicks, Robert. 1989.  Satanic Cults: A Sceptical View of the Law Enforcement Approach.  Criminal Justice Analyst.  11th Annual Crime Prevention Seminar, Virginia, June 13.

Hill, Sally and Jean Goodwin. 1989. “Satanism: Similarities between Patient Accounts and Pre-Inquisition Historical Sources”. Dissociation 2(1):39-43.

Hood, Lynley. 2001. A City Possessed: The Christchurch Civic Creche Case. Longacre Press.

Jenkins, Philip, and Daniel Maier-Katkin. 1992. “Satanism: Myth and Reality in a Contemporary Moral Panic”. Crime, Law and Social Change 17:53-75. https://wrldrels.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/Satanism-Myth-and-Reality.pdf.

Jonker, F; Jonker-Bakker P (1991). “Experiences with ritualist child sexual abuse: a case study from the Netherlands”. Child Abuse and Neglect. 15 (3): 191–96. doi:10.1016/0145-2134(91)90064-K. PMID 2043971. Retrieved 2007-10-20.

Kent, Stephen (1993). “Deviant Scripturalism and Ritual Satanic Abuse Part One: Possible Judeo-Christian Influences”. Religion. 23 (3): 229–241.

Lippert, R. 1990. “The Social Construction of Satanism as a Social Problem in Canada”. Canadian Journal of Sociology. 15(4):417-439. [Canada]

Sarah Marshall (November 3, 2025). “Episode 3: Moral (Panic) Entrepreneurship”. The Devil You Know with Sarah Marshall. CBC Listen.

Mulhern, Sherrill (October 1, 1994). “Satanism, Ritual Abuse, and Multiple Personality Disorder: A Sociohistorical Perspective”. International Journal of Clinical and Experimental Hypnosis. 42 (4): 265–288

Nathan, Debbie. 2003. “Inside the Satan Scare Industry–The Devil Made them do it–While nation’s cops chase demons taxpayers get burned.” The Roc 8 (1992). http://www.theroc.org/roc-mag/textarch/roc-08/roc08-06.htm. Accessed October 2003.

Nathan, Debbie, and Snedeker, Michael. 1995. Satan’s Silence: Ritual Abuse and the Making of a Modern American Witch Hunt. New York: Basic Books.

Nathan, Debbie and Michael Snedeker. 2001. Satan’s silence: Ritual abuse and the making of a modern American witch hunt. iUniverse

Oake, Bethan. 2026. “Save Our Children from Satanists”: Women, Motherhood, and Satanic Moral Panic.” Pp. 51-63 in  ed. Satanism and Feminism in Popular Culture: Not Today Satan, edited by Miranda Corcoran. Milton Park: Routledge. https://wrldrels.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/Save-Our-Children-from-Satanists_-Women-Motherhood-and-Satanic-Moral-Panic_26_08_23_16_17_55.pdf.

Oake, Bethan. 2025. The Satanic Cult Conspiracy: How online conspiracy theory discourses construct moral panic. PhD Dissertation, University of Leeds. Accessed from https://wrldrels.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/The-Satanic-Cult-Conspiracy.pdf on 15 April 2026.

Pfohl, Stephen S. 1977. “The ‘Discovery’ of Child Abuse”. Social Problems 24:310-323.

Richardson, James T. 1997. “The Social Construction of Satanism: Understanding an Inter- national Social Problem” Australian Journal of Social Issues 32(1):61-85.

Smith, Michelle, and Lawrence Pazder. 1980. Michelle Remembers. New York: Congdon & Latte. (Paperback edition by Pocket Books, New York: Simon and Schuster, 1981).

Stevens, Phillips. 1991. “The Demonology of Satanism: An Anthropological View”. In: James Richardson; Joel Best, and David Bromley (eds.). The Satanism Scare. New York: Aldine de Gruyter, 21-40.

Victor, Jeffrey S. 1989. “A Rumor-Panic about a Dangerous Satanic Cult in Western New York”. New York Folklore 15(1-2):23-49. . 1990. “Satanic Cult Rumors as Contemporary Legends”. Western Folklore 49(1):51-81. . 1991.

“The Dynamics of Rumor-Panics about Satanic Cults”. In: James Richardson; Joel Best and David Bromley (eds.). The Satanism Scare. New York: Aldine de Gruyter, 221-236. . 1992.

“The Search for Scapegoat Deviants”. The Humanist 52(5):10-13. . 1993a. Satanic Panic: The Creation of a Contemporary Legend. Chicago:Open Court. . 1993b.

“The Sociology of Contemporary Legends: A Review of the Use of the Con- cept by Sociologists”. Contemporary Legend 4:63-84. _ . 1994.

“Fundamentalist Religion and the Moral Crusade Against Satanism: The Social Construction of Deviance”. Deviant Behavior 15:169-198. . 1995.

“Satanic Panic Update: The Dangers of Moral Panics”. Skeptic 3(3): 44-5 1.

. 1996. “How Should Stories of Satanic Cults Be Understood? Harvard Mental Health Letter 12(6):8.

Victor, Jeffrey. 1998. “Moral Panics and the Social Construction of Deviant Behavior: A Theory and Application to the Case of Ritual Child Abuse.” Sociological Perspectives 41:541-65. https://wrldrels.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/Victor-MoralPanicsSocial-1998.pdf.

Victor, Jeffrey (1998). “Construction of Satanic Ritual Abuse and the Creation of False Memories”. In DeRivera J; Sarbin T (eds.). Believed-In-Imaginings: The Narrative Construction of Reality. Washington, D.C.: American Psychological Association. p. 203

Jeffrey S. Victor (1993). “Sexual Attitudes in the Contemporary Legend About Satanic Cults”. IPT Journal. Archived from the original on 2025-10-06.

David Waldron. 2005. “Role-Playing Games and the Christian Right: Community Formation in Response to a Moral Panic.” Journal of Religion and Popular Culture.

Zirpolo, Kyle and Debbie Nathan. 2005. “I’m Sorry; A long-delayed apology from one of the accusers in the notorious McMartin Pre-School molestation case.” Los Angeles Times Magazine, October 30. https://wrldrels.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/I-Lied.pdf.

EX-MEMBER LITERATURE**
** This list is taken from Ex-Member Accounts from New Religious Movements: A Compilation, 2000-Pesent authored by 
J. Gordon Melton (Institute for Studies of Religion, Baylor University) and W. Michael Ashcraft (Truman State University). It has been published in The Journal of CESNUR | 5/6 (2021) 70—103 79.

Authors’ note: The memoirs of life in a Satanic cult exist as a special case in cult memoirs. While some relatively small Satanic churches exist, the controversy overthe accounts of Satanic ritual abuse in the 1980s and 1990s called into question the existence of a national Satanic movement. There were over 12,000 accusations nationwide of widespread cultic sexual abuses involving Satanicritual, but investigating police were not able to substantiate any allegations of organized cult abuse.]

Barker, Kerth. 2019 [2014]. Angelic Defenders and Demonic Abusers: Memoirs of a Satanic Ritual Abuse Survivor. N.p.: Kerth Barker Books.

Bennett, Beth M. 2020. Return to Innocence: My Journey to Claim Wholeness from Ancestral Ritual Abuse. N.p.: Tom Bird Retreats, Inc.

Canton, Sarah. 2019. The Land of Dark Forgetting: My Story of Healing from Satanic Ritual Abuse. N.p.: the Author.

Conners, August, and April May. 2020. To God Be the Glory: Healing from Satanic Ritual Abuse. Pittsburgh, PA: Dorrance Publishing Co.

Daymore, Rosie. 2001 Blessed: Reclaiming My Life from the Hidden Horror of Ritual Abuse. Life Path Publishing House.

Johnson-Davis, Anne A. Hell. 2008. Minus One—My Story of Deliverance from Satanic Ritual Abuse and My Journey to Freedom. Tooele, UT: Transcript Bulletin Publishing.

“Katie.” 2013. Satanic Ritual Abuse Exposed: Recovery of a Christian Survivor. Beaverton, OR: Revelation Gateway Publications.

Koppes, Samuel. 2019. A Sinful Mind: A Memoir of Surviving Satanic Ritualistic Child Abuse. N.p.: Katsilean Publishing.

Meister, Lisa. 2016. Only God Rescued Me: My Journey from Satanic Ritual Abuse. Indianapolis, IN: There Is a Line Publishing.

Reynolds, Nathan. 2018. Snatched from the Flames: One Man’s Journey to Uncover the Family Secrets Buried in His Blood-Stained Past. N.p.: Snatched from the flames Publishing.

Schaeffer, C.J. 2020. My Life in Pieces: Shattered by Satanic Ritual Abuse, Splintered by Dissociative Identity Disorder, Redeemed and Restored. N.p.: the Author.

Shortridge, Eric T. 2019. Landon’s Cry: A True Story of Satanic Ritual Abuse. N.p.: the Author.

Shurter, David. Rabbit Hole: 2012. A Satanic Ritual Abuse Survivor’s Story. Council Bluff, IA: Consider It Creative LLC.

The Trailer Park Angel. 2019. This is a True Story. N.p.: the Author.

INVESTIGATORY REPORTS

Goodman, Gail,  Jianjian Qin, Bette Bottoms, and Phillip Shaver. 1995. Characteristics and Sources of Allegations of Ritualistic Child Abuse. Final Report to the National Center on Child Abuse and Neglect. Grant No. 90CA1405. https://wrldrels.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/Characteristics-and-Sources-of-Allegationll-of-Ritualistic-Cb.ild-Abuse.pdf [United States]

La Fontaine, Jean S. 1994. The extent and nature of organised and ritual abuse: research findings. Department of Health. London: H.M.S.O. Accessed from https://archive.org/details/extentnatureofor0000lafoon 15 August 2026. [England]

Lanning, Kenneth V. 1992. Investigator’s Guide to Allegations of Ritual Child Abuse. Behavioral Science Unit, National Center for the Analysis of Violent Crime, Federal Bureau of Investigation, FBI Academy, January. [United States]

Lanning, Kenneth V. 1989. Satanic, Occult, Ritualistic Crime: A Law Enforcement Perspective. https://wrldrels.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/SATANIC-OCCULT-RITUALISTIC-CRIME.pdf. [United States]

Ministry of Justice. 1994. Report of the Working Group Ritual Abuse. https://wrldrels.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Mapping-the-Impact-of-Religious-Harm.pdf. [The Netherlands]
Ministerie van Justitie. 1994. RAPPORT VAN DE WERKGROEP RITUEEL MISBRUIK. https://wrldrels.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/Rapport-van-de-werkgroep-ritueel-misbruik-1994.pdf. [The Netherlands]

Missouri Legislative Library. 201 The Satanic Panic in the Missouri General Assembly. https://www.senate.mo.gov/LegislativeLibrary/Panic.html.

Nottinghamshire County Council. 1997. Revised Joint Enquiry Report. http://www.users.globalnet.co.uk/~dlheb/jetrepor2.htm. [England]

 

Australia

Guillatt, R. (1996). Talk of the Devil: Repressed Memory & the Ritual Abuse Witch-Hunt. Melbourne: The Text Publishing Company. 

    England

    THE CULT SCARE

    ACADEMIC PUBLICATIONS

    Bromley, David G., and James T. Richardson, eds. 1983. The Brainwashing/Deprogramming Controversy: Sociological, Psychological, Legal and Historical Perspectives. Studies in Religion and Society. New York: Edwin Mellen Press.

    Bromley, David G., and J. Gordon Melton. 2012. Reconceptualizing Types of Religious Organization: Dominant, Sectarian, Alternative, and Emergent Tradition Groups. Nova Religio: The Journal of Alternative and Emergent Religions 15: 4–28.

    Bromley, David G. and Anson D. Shupe. 1981. Strange Gods: The Great American Cult Scare. Boston: Beacon Press.

    Bromley, David G., Anson Shupe, and Joseph Ventimiglia. 1979. “Atrocity Tales, the Unification Church,
    and the Social Construction of Evil.” Journal of Communication  29:42-53. Accessed from https://wrldrels.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/Atrocity-Tales.pdf on 25 August 2025.

    Duron, Jacquelynn F., Laura Johnson, Gretchen L. Hoge, and Judy L. Postmus. 2021. Observing coercive control beyond intimate partner violence: Examining the perceptions of professionals about common tactics used in victimization. Psychology of Violence 11: 144–54.

    Hassan, Steven. 2015. Combating Cult Mind Control, 25th anniversary ed. Newton: Freedom of Mind Press.

    Hassan, Steven. 2020. The BITE Model of Authoritarian Control: Undue Influence, Thought Reform, Brainwashing, Mind
    Control, Trafficking and the Law. Ph.D. thesis, Fielding Graduate University, Santa Barbara, CA, USA. Available online:
    https://www.proquest.com/docview/2476570146/ (accessed on 22 July 2026).

    Hassan, Steven Alan, and Mansi J. Shah. 2019. The anatomy of undue influence used by terrorist cults and traffickers to induce
    helplessness and trauma, so creating false identities. Ethics, Medicine and Public Health 8: 97–107.

    Hoesly, Dusty. 2026. Brainwashing, Race, and the Unification Church: Orientalism and Yellow Peril Rhetoric from the Cold War to the
    Cult Wars. Nova Religio 29: 43–68.

    Introvigne, Massimo. 2022. Brainwashing: Reality or Myth? Cambridge Elements: New Religious Movements. Cambridge: Cambridge
    University Press.
    Introvigne, Massimo. 2026a. Brainwashing Returns Through Trafficking Laws: A New Threat to Religious Freedom. Bitter Winter,
    June 27. Available online: https://bitterwinter.org/brainwashing-returns-through-trafficking-laws-a-new-threat-to-religiousfreedom/
    (accessed on 22 July 2026).
    Introvigne, Massimo. 2026b. Global Anti-Cultism and the Return of “Brainwashing” Theories. Bitter Winter, July 6. Available online:
    https://bitterwinter.org/global-anti-cultism-and-the-return-of-brainwashing-theories/ (accessed on 22 July 2026).
    Introvigne, Massimo. 2026c. The Truth, Please, About Steven Hassan. 1. The “BITE Model” as Pseudoscience. Bitter Winter, March 5.
    Available online: https://bitterwinter.org/the-truth-please-about-steven-hassan-1-the-bite-model-as-pseudoscience/ (accessed
    on 22 July 2026).

    New York State Legislature. 2025. Senate. 2025. S4079. Establishes the Crime of Coercive Control.

    Parker, Jacques. 2021. ‘Psychologically Kidnapped!’: ‘Secular’ Deprogrammings, the Category of Cult, and Fear of Social Change.
    International Journal for the Study of New Religions 12: 185–209. [CrossRef]
    Parker, Jacques. 2025. Anti-Cultism in Japan: American Influences and Differences in Opposition to Cults. Alternative Spirituality and
    Religion Review 16: 121–43. [CrossRef]

     

    Prophet, Erin. 2016. Charisma and Authority in New Religious Movements. In The Oxford Handbook of New Religious Movements. Edited
    by James R. Lewis and Inga B. Tøllefsen. Oxford: Oxford University Press, vol. 2.

    Richardson, James T. 2021. The Myth of the Omnipotent Leader: The Social Construction of a Misleading Account of Leadership in
    New Religious Movements. Nova Religio 24: 11–25.

    Santo, Alysia. 2025. How ‘Coercive Control’ Is Expanding Domestic Abuse Laws in Several States. The Marshall Project, June 28.
    Available online: https://www.themarshallproject.org/2025/06/28/women-south-carolina-domestic-violence-coercive-control
    (accessed on 23 July 2026).

    Sessions, Erin Martine, and Bernard Doherty. 2021. Cults,’ Coercion, and Control: Rhetoric, Reality, and the Return of ‘Brainwashing’?
    Implicit Religion 24: 161–94.
    Shupe, Anson, and Susan E. Darnell. 2006. Agents of Discord: Deprogramming, Pseudo-Science, and the American Anticult Movement.
    London and New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers.
    Shupe, Anson D. 1995. In the Name of All That’s Holy: A Theory of Clergy Malfeasance. Westport and London: Praeger.
    Shupe, Anson D., ed. 1998. Wolves Within the Fold: Religious Leadership and Abuses of Power. New Brunswick and London: Rutgers
    University Press.
    Shupe, Anson D. 2000. Bad Pastors: Clergy Misconduct in Modern America. New York and London: New York University Press.
    Shupe, Anson D. 2007. Spoils of the Kingdom: ClergyMisconduct and Religious Community. Urbana and Chicago: University of Illinois Press.

    Singer v. American Psychological Association. 1993. No. 92 CIV. 6082 (S.D.N.Y. 1993).

    Stuart, Melissa. 2025. Redefining Domestic Abuse: Coercive Control. Family Law Quarterly 59: 113–37.

    United States v. Cherwitz. 2026. No. 1:23-cr-00216 (E.D.N.Y. March 30, 2026). [CrossRef]
    United States v. Fishman. 1990. 743 F. Supp. 713 (N.D. Cal. 1990).
    United States v. Kozminski. 1988. 487 U.S. 931 (1988).

    Washington State Legislature House. 2021. HB 1449, Creating the Crime of Coercive Control.

    QANON

    1. Lavin, Talia (September 20, 2020). “QAnon, Blood Libel, and the Satanic Panic”. The New Republic. Retrieved 2020-10-24.

     

     

     

    Share