Axelle Brodiez-Dolino

Axelle Brodiez-Dolino is a senior researcher at the CNRS (National Center for Scientific Research, France). Her work focuses on the history of poverty and precariousness, solidarity associations, and humanitarian action from the 19th to the 21st century. She has authored numerous articles and has published six monographs: ATD Quart Monde, une histoire transationale. La lutte contre la pauvreté, d’un bidonville à l’ONU (ATD Quart Monde: A Transnational History. The Fight Against Poverty, from a Shantytown to the United Nations) (2025, Paris: PUF); Notre part de solidarité (Our Share of Solidarity) (2022, Paris: Belopolie); Des sans-logis aux sans-domicile. Le Foyer Notre-Dame des Sans-Abri à Lyon depuis 1950 (From the Homeless to the Shelterless: The Foyer Notre-Dame des Sans-Abri in Lyon Since 1950) (2020, Saint-Etienne: Publications de l’Université de Saint-Etienne); Combattre la pauvreté. Vulnérabilités sociales et sanitaires de 1880 à nos jours (Fighting Poverty: Social and Health Vulnerabilities from 1880 to the Present) (2013, Paris: CNRS Editions); Emmaüs and Abbé Pierre (2009, Paris: Presses de Sciences Po), also available in an English Version: Emmaüs and the Abbé Pierre. An Alternative Model of Enterprise, Charity and Society (2013, Paris : Presses de SciencesPo) ; and Le Secours Populaire français, du communism à l’humanitaire (The French Popular Relief, 1945–2000: From Communism to Humanitarianism) (2006, Paris: Presses de Sciences Po).
She is editor-in-chief of the historical journal Le Mouvement social.
Since 2017, she is also a member of the National Council for Policies Against Poverty and Social Exclusion, a French body reporting to the Prime Minister.
Professional website: https://histoire-sociale.cnrs.fr/axelle-brodiez-dolino/

 

 

 

Share

Twin Flames Universe

TWINS FLAMES UNIVERSE TIMELINE

2012:  Jeff and Shaleia met online.

2014 (June):  Jeff and Shaleia met in person and recorded their first video together in Sedona, Arizona.

2014:  Jeff and Shaleia moved to Hilo, Hawaii.

2015:  Jeff and Shaleia moved to Michigan.

2016:  Jeff and Shaleia were married in Holland, Michigan.

2017:  Twin Flames Universe was founded.

2019:  Church of Union was founded.

2023:  Jeff and Shaleia’s daughter Grace was born.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Twin Flames Universe is an online spiritual group founded by Jeff and Shaleia Divine. Their given names are Jeff Ayan and Megan Plante, and they met via Facebook. Jeff was born in Michigan, baptized Greek Orthodox and then converted to Roman Catholicism at age seven (Church of Union 2023). His own explanation for leaving Christianity was because of its position on gay marriage; he believed everyone should have right to marry who they choose. He went on to study business at Western Michigan University graduating and moving to Hawaii in 2010 where he was a lifestyle blogger who built a “shack” on someone else’s land to rent out through Airbnb (Berman 2023). It was at college that Jeff discovered new age spirituality. By his own account, he was part of a Hare Krishna community in Hawaii (Church of Union 2023). At the time he also called himself Ender Ayanethos, a reference to sci-fi novel Ender’s Game by Orson Scott Card, and had a website called Ender’s Adventures about living in Hawaii.

Originally from Canada, Shaleia was a spiritual seeker living in Sedona, Arizona in 2012-2014 (White 2023). She had a spiritual teacher called Altonah Lampe, practiced psychic readings and reiki, as well as amateur photography and also worked in a Thai restaurant. She moved to Hawaii to live with Jeff, and from there the couple then moved to Michigan (Church of Union 2023). They called themselves Jeff and Shaleia Divine from 2014. They began a blog called Awakened Intimacy, then began making YouTube videos together, mostly focusing on how they found each other as twin flames and offering advice on how others could do the same. They founded Twin Flames Universe, a privately held company, in 2017. The activity of Twin Flames Universe centers on Facebook groups and YouTube Channels. Jeff and Shaleia went on to found the Church of Union in 2019, a registered church, also known as Unionism.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Twin Flames Universe fits in the wider current of new age spirituality. There is a central idea of each individual pursuing their own distinct and unique spiritual path or journey. Following a spiritual path leads toward spiritual enlightenment, sometimes talked about in terms of ascension. They also use the core concept from new age spirituality of energy. Energy constitutes everything in the universe in new age spirituality, and it is characterized by frequency and vibration (Crockford 2021). Higher frequencies and vibrations have positive moral valence. The purpose of the spiritual path is to raise the vibration and frequency to reunify with the oneness of the universe. This way of thinking is both pa ntheistic, in that the universe is divinity and encompasses all things, and monistic, because all things are part of the universe, they are of one substance often referred to as oneness. In Twin Flames Universe (TFU), the understanding of divinity is often phrased as God, which has aspects of the pantheistic universe in the wider new age and also Christian notions of a transcendent divinity. Individual people also have souls, sometimes called the higher self, that transcend the physical body that exists on earth in a specific lifetime.

TFU takes the concept of a spiritual path and orients it specifically around finding and forming a romantic relationship among twin flames. On the TFU website, they claim that the term “harmonious twin flames union” was coined by Jeff and Shaleia. It further defines a twin flame union as: “A spiritual state wherein both Twin Flames are awakened to their Twin Flame connection and have mutually agreed to be exclusively committed to each other” (Twin Flames Universe 2024). A further post by a member of TFU defines a twin flame union as perfect, composed of two bodies that were made as one person with an intense spiritual connection that cannot be lost (Lee 2024). On the Church of Union website they define a twin flame as “a complementary person who shares the same “soul blueprint” with another person who is designed as a perfect romantic partner and compatible match” (Church of Union 2023).

Twin flames are two soul mates who are spiritually connected because they were created as one by God. They share the soul essence, or the same vibration. Twin flames therefore reflect or mirror each other. A permanent harmonious union is only possible with true twin flames, not fake ones. The route to finding a twin flame is through self-love as the two parts are one and the same, so loving the self brings the other half. What TFU claims to offer is advice and support on how to practice self-love and deal with personal trauma, allowing followers to identify their twin flame, build a good relationship with them, and then work towards spiritual enlightenment together. Jeff and Shaleia’s authority in the group is based in part on their claim that they are twin flames, so they can identify other people’s twin flames.

Each twin flame unit has two parts, identified as divine feminine and divine masculine. Here “masculine” and “feminine” refer to energies rather than bodies. Twin flame couples are therefore heteronormative in their composition, and this gender essentialism is couched in spiritual terms: “we believe each person is created as either 100% masculine or 100% feminine with an Eternal Divine Complement of the opposite sexual polarity” (Church of Union 2023). However, in terms of the composition of the group, the leaders estimate that there is a gender imbalance with 80% female and 20% male in TFU (TwinFlames Jeff and Shaleia 2017). This reflects a gender imbalance in new age spirituality more broadly, which is widely described as being female dominated (Crowley 2011).

Jeff and Shaleia have provided their definition of “Twin Flame” on their YouTube channel (2017). The concept of twin flames is not specific to TFU and is used among the wider new age milieu. The phrase was coined by English novelist Marie Correlli in A Romance of Two Worlds in 1886 (Hines 2020). It resembles the twin rays concept from Guy and Edna Ballard, who founded the I AM Movement and adopted Theosophical Society’s notion of ascended masters, spiritual gurus who can be channeled. Twin flames as a concept was popularized by Elizabeth Clare Prophet who founded and led the Church Universal Triumphant, who wrote a book Soul Mates and Twin Flames in 1999. Prophet’s work had Hindu, Buddhist, evangelical Protestant influences and described the concept as two people with a divine connection who achieve enlightenment together. Their relationship was a manifestation of their alignment with God, and they help each other continue their work towards enlightenment. The connection is permanent, and the two cannot be separated from each other. Elizabeth Clare Prophet’s daughter Erin Prophet, who is a professor of religion at the University of Florida, attributes influence to the work of Emmanuel Swedenborg, who claimed it was possible to have sex in heaven with your spiritual other half (Miller 2023). It was also common among nineteenth century American Spiritualists. Prophet also identifies the influence of Plato’s Symposium, in which the character of Aristophanes, who is drunk, discusses one person cut in half to form two separate physical beings that always long for each other.

The concept is part of new age spirituality more generally, where similar notions of a soul pod and soul mates are used to describe spiritually connected beings who are incarnated in separate physical bodies, yet remain permanently connected through a spiritual connection over numerous lifetimes. The idea also connects to the concepts of reincarnation and life purpose. In new age reincarnation, souls have been born repeatedly in different physical and spiritual planes of existence, often with a mission or purpose they have chosen prior to incarnation. This is the life purpose, a concept that Jeff and Shaleia use. They have stated that their life purpose as a couple is to “bring people back to God” (Church of Union 2023).

Other concepts from new age spirituality such as chakras, channeling, and alignment are used in TFU. They espouse the common new age understanding that external reality is a reflection of your inner world. This means that thoughts and belief shape your experience of life because that experience is within you. Everything you are experiencing is within you, it is not external or caused by anyone else. The conclusion drawn from this is that each person can control their own reality, they create it through their thoughts, words, and actions. First you believe things are real and then you make them real. If someone does well financially and in their relationships, this means they are spiritually enlightened and in alignment with God. Conversely sickness and romantic failure are also a personal responsibility, a sign they have not done the spiritual work. Struggling financially or in relationships is taken as a sign that a member is “not aligned” with God or with the teachings of the group. Negative feelings are expected to result.

Jeff and Shaleia founded the Church of Union in 2019, a registered church. They call its doctrines the Teachings of Union, and use the epithet Unionism. Their teachings are a set of principles which amount to spiritual laws that are a “science” that has quantifiable, empirical, and meaningful results (Church of Union 2023). These laws govern “base reality” which they also refer to as Truth. They describe their system of beliefs as logical, scientific, experiential, and holistic. By following their teachings they promise a personal connection to God that will build heaven on earth, or “the optimal reality,” characterized by love, oneness, and unity. On the other side of this optimal reality is illusion and fear.

In the Church of Unity, Jeff refers to himself as “Father Christ,” Shaleia as “Mother Christ,” their daughter Grace as “Princess of All Creation,” the three together form “the Master Christ: Eternal Ruler of all Creation by God’s Living Hand” (Hines 2020). Jeff has also called himself the Second Coming. He has stated that the purpose of Unionism is to unify all religions under one umbrella. The Church website quotes a Course in Miracles, indicating an influence from the channeled material that makes up that book (Church of Union 2023). The blog on the Church website has posts that indicate crossovers with conspiracism, such as a post listing signs that you are a “slave” in the “Luciferian system” including that you believe everything the media says and a picture of the red pill and blue pill from the film The Matrix (Divine 2023). Believing that the “mainstream media” is entirely illusory and that to “wake up” you should “take the red pill” like the main character in The Matrix are common tropes in new age conspiracism (Robertson 2016).

RITUALS/PRACTICES

Twin Flames Universe teaches techniques purported to lead to spiritual development and fulfillment. The main practice is twin flame ascension coaching which seeks to heal twin flame separation. The result claimed is that they get people together in ongoing relationships, evidenced on the group’s website which presents success stories of twin flame couples, accompanied by photos of the couples and testimonials of how they are living their dreams and have perfect relationships.

Another main practice for TFU is the mirror exercise, which is described as a tool for self-transformation. Twin flames are said to mirror each other because they share the same spiritual essence so they reflect back each other’s joy or upset. If one is happy, so is the other, and vice versa. This concept of mirroring applies beyond twin flames, as they claim that anyone can mirror anyone else, but only a twin flame is a perfect mirror. Mirroring here means reflecting each other’s emotional and psychological states. For example, twin flames are said to mirror each other’s insecurities, but once committed to healing they will reflect this back. In this way, finding a twin flame is also advocated as a path to emotional and psychological wellbeing.

The mirror exercise takes this concept of reflecting the emotional and psychological states of others and uses it to provide a framework for resolving emotional distress. The mirror exercise helps to identify what in external reality is upsetting (Bassow and Manolo 2023). Then it provides steps for understanding that external reality as reflecting an inner state. It encourages personal responsibility for the upset feeling, recognizing that it is a call for love from within. The fourth step aims to heal the upsetting pattern permanently. The aim of the exercise to love the upset as part of yourself, so you feel better. The specific steps of the Mirror Exercise are as follows:

STEP 1: Identify the upset in a concise sentence. Who are you upset with? What are you upset about? And why? For example: “I’m upset with my Twin Flame because I feel rejected by him/her because he/she is ignoring me.”

STEP 2: Invert all the pronouns to point to yourself. We do this because what you experience externally, is simply a reflection of an inner state. For example: “I’m upset with myself because I feel I am rejecting myself and I am ignoring myself.”

STEP 3: Ask yourself whether this is true. The answer is: yes. It will always be true, because you can only experience a pattern that is within you. Example answer: “Yes, it’s true. I don’t acknowledge my feelings and ignore and reject my own boundaries. I don’t feel like I am good enough to be loved so I ignore my needs and don’t nurture myself.”

STEP 4: Once you have identified this place within you, ask what does he/she need to feel fully loved right now? Give yourself space to receive the answer from within. Once you know it, give yourself the love that this part of you is asking for. Remain with this part of you until you feel it received everything he/she needed (Bassow and Manolo 2023).

While the mirror exercise is described as leading to joy, what may occur more immediately is called upheaval or purging. Upheaval is “the process by which everything that is out of alignment with love is removed from your consciousness” (Twin Flames Universe 2024). The TFU website offers a support guide for upheaval, with suggestions of actions to take while experiencing upheaval, such as meditating, playing video games, or speaking with your ascension coach. There is a caveat that the mirror exercise is for healing yourself and not controlling external circumstances or your twin flame or others. It is meant to help you create whatever you desire in your reality through taking responsibility for anything that happens to you. The concept of upheaval seems to implicitly acknowledge that blaming yourself for everything that you are upset about may cause further upset, however, it offers the joy follows afterwards.

Much of TFU practice aims at this level of self-help derived healing, especially on an emotional or psychological level. Emotional healing has spiritual effects though. If instead of using the mirror exercise, you project issues on to each other for healing, you will not attract your twin flame. You must heal in yourself otherwise you will drive your twin flame away. Self-help for emotional wellbeing therefore leads to the romantic relationship that will then enable spiritual progress. This form of self-help takes the form common in new age spirituality that the self is the root of all problems. In TFU, they claim that those who feel abandoned by their parents need to stop abandoning yourself. They further claim that physical diseases have spiritual roots. At points, Jeff and Shaleia have claimed to be able to cure cancer and other medical conditions with spiritual therapy (Berman 2020).

Another practice that TFU employs is channeling, where noncorporeal, spiritual entities are voiced by a human medium called a channel (Brown 1997). Through channeling, spiritual insight and information is attributed to non-human sources. Jeff and Shaleia talk about using a channeling state in their YouTube videos. Jeff states that his ability to channel began after he met Shaleia in Sedona (Church of Union 2023). They use channeling to identify twin flames, who are usually people already active in the group. Another practice referred to is manifestation, which is a practice that aims to create whatever is desired, usually something material and beneficial, in reality (Crockford 2022). In TFU, they instruct members to manifest their perfect partner by being themselves. This, again, points to the importance of self-help and self-love to attracting a romantic partner in this framework. However, negative effects can be manifested by those who are seen as not in alignment with God. Shaleia states that her mother “manifested cancer” and died when she was fifteen (TwinFlames Jeff and Shaleia 2017). The way to get positive effects from manifestation is to surrender to God, this means that your twin flame will manifest in your life. Meditation, a standard practice in new age spirituality, is also recommended by TFU, as noted above as a way to ease upheaval. They also list guided meditations as available to purchase from their website.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Twin Flames Universe is organized as a multi-level marketing enterprise, with a coaching platform, website, and YouTube channels. The primary site has 26,400 subscribers (TwinFlamesUniverse website 2024).  In addition, there is a Facebook group with 312,000 members (Facebook website 2025), an Instagram account with 134,000 followers (Instagram website 2025), and a Pinterest page with 15,600 followers (Pinterest website 2025), Jeff and Shaleia have recorded many videos together, available on YouTube, explaining TFU teachings and practices. The coaching platform is called the Twin Flames Ascension School; through taking its courses members can become certified ascension coaches. Ascension coaches run discussion groups on Google Hangouts, sell TFU products, make sales calls, and recruit new students (Berman 2020, 2023). Classes and e-courses are available to purchase online for subscriptions. There have been some in person workshops, notably in Toronto and Sedona, which were then filmed and they sell access to the videos on the website. Access to one class is priced at $333, with $4,444 for access to the 300 classes that are part of the Twin Flames Ascension School (Twin Flames Universe 2024). Other products include a book and a set of audio recordings of guided meditations (Twin Flames Universe 2023). Introductory products, such as the twin flame test, are free. Like many MLMs, TFU products start free or lower priced and then members are encouraged to level up and invest more. Becoming a coach can cost up to $20,000. Coaches received a ten percent commission when they sold a pass for all classes, but had to pay a monthly coach licensing fee and have to buy the new products and courses to stay in good standing (Berman 2020, 2023). Products are promoted as enabling a path to personal and spiritual fulfillment through accessing the teachings of TFU.

The Church of Union has its headquarters in Suttons Bay, Michigan, in what is also Jeff and Shaleia’s private residence. They run the business from their house, and the Church is entirely online. The website is unionism.org. On the website, they state that “we believe our gurus were sent by God from Heaven to bring us the teachings of Union and partner with us in creating Heaven on Earth. Their authority comes from the results of their work which completely transforms the lives of all those who sincerely engage with it” (Church of Union 2023). The gurus are Jeff and Shaleia Divine; they are the leaders of the Church of Union and also the private enterprise, Twin Flames Universe. It is unclear what the balance of power is in the relationship, as two documentaries diverged on their characterization. The Netflix documentary, Escaping Twin Flames, shows Jeff as more dominant, and equates him to a cult leader. Media reports follow this characterization, for example stating that Jeff is the “unquestioned leader” of TFU (Romano 2023). The Amazon Prime documentary, Desperately Seeking Soulmate, depicts Shaleia as an equal partner in leadership.

The Church of Union is run by an Executive Council, all of whom are also certified ascension coaches in TFU. The executive ministers of operations are also the CEOs of other subsidiary businesses, such as Divine Dish. The Sunday services of the Church of Union are streamed online featuring various different ministers of the church (although not Jeff and Shaleia recently), and links to their social impact work, which involves discussions filmed and put online about Black Lives Matter and LGBTQ+.

The Church of Union seems to incorporate a variety of prosperity consciousness, a variant of evangelical Protestant prosperity gospel (Mikaelsson 2001). The donation page of Church of Union states that

having a healthy financial relationship with the Church of Union puts you in a position for God to use you as His financial instrument, and so He is even more compelled to prosper you financially. It also generates strong positive karma for you, not just financially, but spiritually too. The Law of Reciprocity states that whatever you give must return to you, often multiplied. Giving to the Church of Union is investing in an eternal spiritual foundation that you can return to day after day, year after year, lifetime after lifetime. Just because you can’t take your money and assets with you doesn’t mean you can’t invest into something that you can (Church of Union 2023).

Other businesses run by TFU include Mind Alignment Process that claims to treat PTSD and trauma (Mind Alignment Process website 2022). The therapy is supposed to target the most upsetting memories, resetting the mind like a computer developer debugging a computer, in twelve weeks. They claim to reduce flashbacks for all participants. They also run a food delivery service called Divine Dish, divinedish.org, claiming it is a diet to help support alignment with God or “food for God-consciousness.” The meals advertised on the website seem to mostly consist of eggs, meat, and pasta. It costs $129 per month.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Twin Flames Union has faced criticism from former members, psychologists, and the media that it is a cult. First in articles in Vice and Vanity Fair (Hines 2020; Berman 2020), and then in two documentaries, one shown on Amazon Prime and another on Netflix (Peck 2023; Zernovich 2023). It was also the subject of a Wondery podcast series that came out before the documentaries. The level of control of members has been critiqued. Members have moved, often long distances and to different countries, to get married and stay with their twin flame, encouraged by Jeff and Shaleia. Jeff and Shaleia set themselves up as the arbiters of who is each others’ twin flames, according to former members, and they charge money to help members find their twin flame. There have also been accusations of labor exploitation of members (Berman 2020). Some former members have been left bankrupt through high fees paid to TFU to participate as coaches (Berman 2023). There have been claims that members have been separated from family, and discouraged from seeking professional mental health care (Michallon 2023).

Another issue exacerbating the accusations of coercive control has been Jeff’s personal behavior. YouTube and Facebook videos show him mocking, undermining, and belittling members, as well as telling Shaleia not to speak and claiming that he forced himself on her (Romano 2023). Jeff and Shaleia also enjoy conspicuous wealth and a luxury lifestyle, which they depict in videos and claim is a sign of their spiritual advancement. The mirror exercise has been criticized as reflecting problems back on the self, leading to members blaming themselves for their problems, and experiencing a continual state of emotional upheaval and turbulence (Romano 2023). Psychology professor Janja Lalich has called TFU a cult in interviews (Berman 2020; Peck 2023). Former members have also been explicit about labelling it a cult (Romano 2023). TFU have said they are not a cult in statements in response to documentaries and media reports (Berman 2020; Romano 2023; Facebook post statement). Jeff and Shaleia sued seven former members and a parent of a member in June 2020, and the case was dismissed for lack of proper jurisdiction in March 2021 (Berman 2023). Jeff has also made statements, later claimed to be insincere, in videos and to a reporter that he is a cult leader (Hines 2020).

TFU members have also been involved in stalking accusations. Some members say they were encouraged by Jeff and Shaleia to do whatever it takes to be with their twin flame (Miller 2023). They believed that being with their twin flame was more important than anything else, which resulted in restraining orders being issued against multiple members. One former member claimed they were told that the restraining order does not exist by Jeff and Shaleia, and to keep pursuing their purported twin flame (Romano 2023; Hine 2020). Other members claim they were forced to stay with abusive or criminal partners who had been identified as their twin flames by Jeff and Shaleia (Romano 2023; Berman 2023). TFU members have been arrested, subject to involuntary psychiatric treatment, and one died by suicide (Berman 2020).

Another area of controversy has been claims of coerced gender transitioning of members. In TFU, everyone is their spiritually feminine or spirituality masculine, and this “divine” assigned gender identity may differ from their physical bodies. Some former members claim that Jeff and Shaleia confirmed their gender identity for them, claiming it came from God (Romano 2023; Berman 2023). These members alleged that Jeff and Shaleia pressured people to change their gender identity, including taking hormone therapy or getting surgery, so that they will form male-female couples as twin flames (Hine 2020; Miller 2023). In the documentaries, former members alleged that Jeff and Shaleia addressed the gender imbalance in the group by pressuring cis-women to live as trans-men in order to assign them female twin flames. This practice has been called a form of conversion therapy that is transphobic as it shows people coming out as transgender as a result of social pressure rather than their own volition (McFarland 2023).

TFU was investigated by police in Michigan in 2020, and they found it was a legitimate business (Miller 2023). They had received a complaint from a family member of someone who was involved with the group. The Michigan Attorney General’s office reported it had an open investigation into TFU in 2025 (Haines 2025).

REFERENCES

Bassow, Deborah, and Briana Manolo. 2023. “The Mirror Exercise – Healing Twin Flame Blocks Easily.” Twin Flames Universe, October. Accessed from https://twinflamesuniverse.com/the-mirror-exercise-healing-twin-flame-blocks-easily/ on 5 April 2025.

Berman, Sarah. 2020. “This YouTube School Promised True Love. Students Say They Got Exploited Instead.” Vice, February 5. Accessed from https://www.vice.com/en/article/this-youtube-school-promised-true-love-students-say-they-got-exploited-instead/ on 5 April 2025.

Berman, Sarah. 2023. “How ‘Twin Flames Universe’ YouTubers Monetized Heartbreak and Trauma.” Vice, November 9. Accessed from https://www.vice.com/en/article/twin-flames-universe-youtubers-monetized-heartbreak-and-trauma-netflix-amazon-prime/ on 5 April 2025.

Brown, Michael F. 1999. The Channelling Zone: American Spirituality in an Anxious Age. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Church of Union. 2023. “Donate.” Accessed from https://unionism.org/donate/ on 5 April 2025.

Church of Union.2023. “Our Gurus.” Accessed from https://unionism.org/ourgurus/ on 5 April 2025.

Church of Union. 2023. “Social Impact.” Accessed from https://unionism.org/socialimpact/ on 5 April 2025.

Church of Union. 2023. “Unionism.” 2023. Accessed from https://unionism.org/ on 5 April 2025.

Crockford, Susannah. 2022. “How to Manifest Abundance: Money and the Rematerialization of Exchange in Sedona, Arizona, USA.” Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 28:920-37.

Crockford, Susannah. 2021. Ripples of the Universe: Spirituality in Sedona, Arizona. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Crowley, Karlyn. 2011. Feminism’s New Age: Gender, Appropriation, and the Afterlife of Essentialism. Albany: SUNY Press.

Divine, Jeff. 2023. “10 Signs You’re A Slave In The Luciferian System.” Church of Union. Accessed from https://unionism.org/10-signs-youre-a-slave-in-the-luciferian-system/ on 5 April 2025.

Divine, Jeff and Shaleia. 2018. Twin Flames: Finding Your Ultimate Lover. Twin Flames Universe.

Ender’s Adventures. 2012. Accessed from https://web.archive.org/web/20120412220559/http://www.endersadventures.com/ on 5 April 2025.

Haines, Avery. 2025. “We’re Not a Cult: Inside Twin Flames Universe” (Television). Canada: CTV Television Network, March 23, Accessed from  https://www.ctvnews.ca/video/2025/03/23/were-not-a-cult-inside-twin-flames-universe-w5/ on 5 April 2025.

Hines, Alice. 2020. ““Everywhere I Went, They Went With Me, Because They Were on My Phone”: Inside the Always Online, All-Consuming World of Twin Flames Universe.” Vanity Fair, December 3. Accessed from https://www.vanityfair.com/style/2020/12/inside-the-all-consuming-world-of-twin-flames-universe on 5 April 2025.

Lee, Angelika. 2024. “What is a Twin Flame? – Beyond the Myths and into Union.” Twin Flames Universe. Accessed from https://twinflamesuniverse.com/what-is-a-twin-flame/ on 5 April 2025.

McFarland, Melanie. 2023. “What ‘Escaping Twin Flames’ teaches us about the anti-trans nature of a supposedly loving cult” Salon, November 11. Accessed from https://www.salon.com/2023/11/11/twin-flames-universe-anti-transgender-panic/ on 5 April 2025.

Michallon, Clémence. 2023. “She joined Twin Flames Universe looking for love. Her family says she ‘disappeared’ from their lives.The Independent, November 8. Accessed from https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/escaping-twin-flames-universe-netflix-b2443828.html on 5 April 2025.

Mikaelsson, Lisbeth. 2001. “Homo Accumulans and the Spiritualization of Money.” Pp.94-110 in New Age Religion and Globalization, edited by Mikael Rothstein. Copenhagen: Aarhus University Press.

Miller, Matthew. “Hit Netflix doc ‘Escaping Twin Flames’ is rooted in Michigan. What’s it all about?” 2023. M Live, November 20.

Mind Alignment Process website. 2022. Accessed from https://mindalignmentprocess.org/ on 5 April 2025.

Peck, Cecilia. 2023. Escaping Twin Flames. Netflix, Accessed from https://www.netflix.com/gb/title/81615919 on 5 April 2025.

Prophet, Elizabeth Clare. 2017. Soul Mates and Twin Flames. Summit University Press.

Robertson, David G. 2016. UFOs, Conspiracy Theories and the New Age: Millennial Conspiracism. London: Bloomsbury.

Romano, Aja. 2023. “Explaining “Twin Flames,” the subject of Netflix’s disturbing new documentary.” Vox, November 14. Accessed from https://www.vox.com/culture/23959800/escaping-twin-flames-netflix-jeff-ayan-twin-flames-universe-cult-soulmates on 5 April 2025.

TwinFlames Jeff and Shaleia. 2025. “You Don’t Know What Twin Flames Are.” YouTube. Accessed from https://youtu.be/9vVNW0Gh94o on 5 April 2025.

TwinFlames Jeff and Shaleia. 2017. “The Divine Masculine Twin Flame: What’s Really Going On?” YouTube, August 9. Accessed from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6XrKdA6O0Js on 5 April 2025.

“Twin Flames Universe.” Wikipedia, March 24, 2025, Accessed from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twin_Flames_Universe on 5 April 2025.

Twin Flames Universe Facebook website. 2025. Accessed from https://www.facebook.com/Twinflamesuniverse/ on 5 April 2025.

Twin Flames Universe Instagram website. 2025. Accessed from https://www.instagram.com/twinflamesuniverse/ on 5 April 2025.

Twin Flames Universe Pinterest website. 2025. Accessed from https://www.pinterest.com/twinflamesuniverse/ on 5 April 2025.

Twin Flames Universe. 2024. “Products.” Accessed from https://twinflamesuniverse.com/products/ on 5 April 2025

Twin Flames Universe. 2024. “Twin Flame Ascension School.” Accessed from https://twinflamesuniverse.com/twinflameascensionschool/ on 5 April 2025.

Twin Flames Universe. 2024. “Twin Flame Unions.” https://twinflamesuniverse.com/twin-flame-unions/ on 5 April 2025.

Twin Flames Universe. 2024. “Upheaval Support Guide.” Accessed from https://twinflamesuniverse.com/upheaval-support-guide/ on 5 April 2025.

Twin Flames Universe website. 2024. Accessed from https://twinflamesuniverse.com/ on 5 April 2025.

Vognar, Chris. 2023. “The Twin Flames Dating ‘Cult’ Targeting the Lonely (and Ryan Gosling).” Rolling Stone, October 6. Accessed from https://www.rollingstone.com/tv-movies/tv-movie-reviews/twin-flames-universe-dating-cult-jeff-ayan-shaleia-ayan-ryan-gosling-stalking-1234841863/ on 5 April 2025

White, Meredith G. 2023. “Netflix’s shocking documentary ‘Escaping Twin Flames’ has an Arizona connection.” Arizona Republic, November 15. Accessed from https://eu.azcentral.com/story/entertainment/television/2023/11/15/netflix-escaping-twin-flames-sedona-connection/71580327007/ on 5 April 2025.

“Twin Flames.” 2022. Wondery (podcast). Accessed from https://wondery.com/shows/twin-flames/ on 5 April 2025.

Publication Date:
13 April 2025

 

 

Share

Matthew Casey-Pariseault

Matthew Casey-Pariseault is a faculty member in the School of Historical, Philosophical & Religious Studies at Arizona State University. His research explores religion as a catalyst for social and political change in modern Latin America. Matthew’s writing has appeared in academic publications as well as public-facing outlets such as Salon, Religion News Service, and NPR’s Latino USA.

 

Share

Israelites of the New Universal Covenant

ISRAELITES OF THE NEW UNIVERSAL COVENANT  TIMELINE

1918:  Ezequiel Ataucusi Gamonal was born in Huarhua, Arequipa, Peru.

1930-1936:  Ataucusi had his first supernatural experiences.

1940-1943:  Ataucusi served in the Peruvian armed forces, rising to the level of Seargent, Second Class.

1953:  Ataucusi converted to Seventh-day Adventism in a town near the Andean city of Tarma.

1956:  Ataucusi experienced his foundational revelation.

1968:  Ataucusi formally founded the Evangelical Association of the Israelite Mission of the New Universal Covenant, commonly referred to as the Israelitas.

1980:  Members of a Maoist guerrilla group, Sendero Luminoso, burned ballot boxes in the small Andean town of Chuschi, leading to armed insurrection against the Peruvian government that lasted over a decade.

1989:  Ataucusi founded the Frente Popular Agrícola Popular FIA del Perú (FREPAP) as a political party representing the Israelitas fiscally leftist and socially conservative socio-religious agenda.

1990:  Ataucusi ran unsuccessfully for the presidency of Peru, earning 69,832 votes (1.04% of the total first round ballots). He subsequently ran and lost in 1995 and 2000.

2000 (June 21):  Ezequiel Ataucusi Gamonal died in Lima of renal failure at age seventy-one. His youngest son, Jonás, took leadership of the congregation. Israelitas was estimated to have  had between 150,000 and 200,000 members.

2020:  Fifteen FREPAP representatives were elected to the Peruvian Congress.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

The story of the Israelitas begins with the life of Ezequiel Ataucusi Gamonal, a Quechua-speaking Andean man of humble origins. Over the second half of the twentieth century, Ataucusi founded and led one of Peru’s largest non-Catholic religious groups. The Israelitas’ blend of biblical and Indigenous influences, along with a liberatory political message, has attracted many converts and made a significant impact on Peruvian society.

From a historical perspective, the early life of this charismatic leader is opaque. Having been born and raised in a marginal, rural community during a period in which the Peruvian state had little presence in the provinces, we lack documentary evidence for many major life events, including his birth. Most of the information we have on the first forty years of Ezequiel Ataucusi’s life has come from interviews given by the man himself and those close to him.

Ataucusi was born in 1918 into a peasant family that held both Catholic and Indigenous Andean traditions. He was the first of five children and was raised by his single mother and grandparents. He has recalled being a loner and was said to have suffered bullying as a child. At a young age, he began to criticize the Catholic practices of his family, especially the reverence of the saints. During his teenage years, Ataucusi had his first supernatural experiences, which included receiving teachings about the saints from an old man and being rescued from drowning by a giant fish.

Ataucusi was trilingual, with Quechua and Spanish as his dominant languages. He learned Aymara during his years of military service in the early 1940s. His fluency in Quechua and Aymara, Peru’s two largest indigenous languages, helped make his later missionary work particularly successful among people of Andean origin. After leaving the military, Ataucusi held a variety of occupations, including carpenter and shoemaker, spending much of his time in the central Andean and high jungle regions east of Lima. During this period, he married his first wife, Dionisia Ospina, with whom he had seven children.

Around 1953, Ataucusi met a Seventh-day Adventist man who introduced him to the Christian Scriptures and the beliefs of the Adventist church. While the Catholic Church had maintained a presence in most rural Peruvian villages since the sixteenth century, the early twentieth century saw waves of Protestant evangelists from the United States and the U.K. bringing biblical literature and religious pamphlets to remote communities. The Adventists were one of the most prominent of these early Protestant churches in Peru. Ataucusi’s initial Bible study was accompanied by prophetic visions, during which he traveled through the cosmos and encountered God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit directly.

Ataucusi converted to Seventh-day Adventism but was soon asked to leave the congregation for making predictions that went beyond the faith’s orthodox beliefs. Nearly one hundred other Adventists followed him out of the church, joining him as he began to pursue his own visions (Ossio 2014:119). Shortly thereafter, Ataucusi received a divine commission to carry out his spiritual work, accompanied by an updated version of the Ten Commandments. In this pivotal vision, the central founding spiritual event of the Israelitas, Ataucusi was raised to the “third heaven,” which appeared in the form of a classroom. The Ten Commandments were written on a blackboard, and the Holy Trinity instructed him to write them down and then return to Earth to preach them to the world. This experience became known as the “new covenant.”

Ataucusi recalled facing violence and even imprisonment in these early years of preaching in towns throughout the Andes. In Lima, he met with other dissident Adventists and began to formally develop the system of beliefs and practices that the group began to call the Asociación Evangélica de la Misión Israelita del Nuevo Pacto Universal (Aeminpu),  the Evangelical Association of the Israelite Mission of the New Universal Covenant.

In 1962, Ataucusi traveled to the central Amazon region, where he acquired land to establish the first Israelita community in the high jungle near the towns of Oxapampa and La Merced. Over the following decade, this region became home to six additional Israelita settlements. Traveling mainly on foot, Ataucusi visited remote population centers, gaining followers and establishing permanent communities by colonizing parts of the jungle. In Ataucusi’s evolving system of teachings, the Amazon was positioned as a sort of sacred waiting room for the coming apocalypse.

In 1968, Ataucusi formally founded the Evangelical Association of the Israelite Mission of the New Universal Covenant. This same year, General Juan Velasco Alvarado led a leftist military coup and began a series of dramatic political projects that included a major land reform aimed to return monopolized agricultural land to indigenous Peruvians. Ataucusi’s jungle communes fit well within Velasco’s reforms and the government facilitated the Israelitas’ land acquisitions in the Amazon (Ráez Suárez 2022:89).

After founding the first jungle communities, Ataucusi settled in a migrant shantytown of Lima called El Agustino. There, the leader was in intimate contact with Pentecostalism. Ataucusi and his followers in Lima began attending a small, loosely organized Pentecostal church. According to Leoncio, one of Ezequiel Ataucusi’s sons, “All of the church congregation was won for the Israelitas and he [Ataucusi] converted the church into his first Biblical Training Center” (Ossio 2014:96). During this period, Ataucusi’s first wife died and he married his second wife with whom he had three children, including Ezequiel Jonás (b. 1972), who would go on to take leadership of the congregation after his father’s death. Followers revered Ataucusi, treating him as a living representation of God. But he was also approachable. He regularly visited the jungle colonies, where he would stay in a designated Royal House, attended by a select group of important women.

The congregated, as members call themselves, have generally come from poor, rural backgrounds. Many have been part of Peru’s massive migratory class that moved to cities like Lima and Cusco during the late twentieth century. Most have little more than primary school education and generally live on the margins of Peru’s dominant westernized national culture (Ossio 2000:197).

The 1980s were a period of rapid growth and institutionalization. Ataucusi began a formalization process that would help launch the Israelitas into the national political sphere by the end of the decade. A secular side of the organization’s hierarchy was established with Jeremías Ortiz Arcos serving as president The president, Jeramías Ortiz Arcos, was a pragmatic administrator and his approach complemented the charismatic, intuitive leadership of Ataucusi. Under this dual leadership structure, the congregation built a massive compound called la Casa Real in the foothills east of Lima that served as a sort of headquarters for the organization. Along with the main residence for Ataucusi and his family, the extensive project housed a school, a bakery, workshops a print shop, and conference center. Their own magazine, Lucero de la Mańana, published its first issue in 1985. Soon there were communities of believers not only throughout Peru but in Bolivia, Chile, Ecuador, and later Colombia as well (Meneses Lucumí 2021).

The 1980s were also marked by a violent civil war between the Maoist guerrillas of Shining Path (Sendero Luminoso) and the government, leaving nearly 70,000 (mostly poor and Indigenous) people dead. Anthropologist Juan Ossio has argued that Ataucusi’s teaching served as a peaceful alternative to the violence of Sendero Luminoso, which recruited from the same disenfranchised, poor, and Indigenous population as the Israelitas (Ossio 2014).

In 1989, Ataucusi and other leaders formally established a political party called the Peruvian Popular Agricultural Front (Frente Popular Agrícola Popular FIA del Perú, FREPAP) to participate in the 1990 elections. [Image at right] with Ataucusi as the presidential candidate and several candidates to Congress. The party considers itself to be “theocratic,” “nationalist,” “revolutionary,” and “agro-ecological” (Estatuto 2023:1). Ataucusi earned just over one percent of the vote in the first round ballot and none of FREPAP’s congressional or senate candidates were elected. However, during the 1990s, FREPAP did send five candidates to Congress (Ráez Suárez 2022:94).

At the time of Ataucusi’s death, ,just following his third and final bid for the presidency, Aeminpu had grown to around 200,000 members. After the prophet’s death, his twenty-seven-year-old son, Ezequiel Jonás Ataucusi Molina, became the maximum leader of the congregation.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

The Israelites of the New Universal Covenant are a messianic and revivalist tradition that creatively blends Indigenous Peruvian influences and Christian scripture. They consider themselves to be the one, true Christian church and draw heavily on the Old Testament for their doctrines. Ezequiel Ataucusi’s visions, teachings, and biblical interpretations form the basis of the movement’s doctrines. Because Ataucusi left behind little in the way of formal, written teachings, Israelita theology is quite diverse and malleable.

The Israelitas are Sabbatarians who draw from Seventh-day Adventism as inspiration for their observation of weekly Saturday rituals. Members believe that Emperor Constantine of the Western Roman Empire broke the original covenant with God when he changed the day of worship from Saturday to Sunday, which they argue began a period of decay in the church (Ossio 2000:196).

Ataucusi is positioned as the second coming of Jesus Christ who will guide believers into the fourth and final age of human history. While the end of the world is believed to be imminent, people can be saved from the apocalypse by joining the Israelitas and following God’s law according to Ataucusi’s interpretation. Ataucusi was a prolific teacher, but did not leave much writing behind. His teachings are most clearly laid out in extended interviews and in recordings and videos. Ataucusi regularly performed public sessions where he read selections ranging widely from throughout the Old and New Testaments to illustrate the group’s theological tenets. He regularly blended scriptural analysis with his own life experiences.

The Ten Commandments, the version that Ataucusi received in his spiritual vision during the 1950s, are the central, “royal law” of the congregation. Ataucusi’s version of the Ten Commandments does not vary much from the accepted Adventist list or that of most other Abrahamic traditions. The main difference is the condensing of several generally separated commandments (for example, the Israelita list combines the commandment to not have other gods with the order to not worship idols), and the inclusion of the New Testament (Matthew 22:37-40, ESV) formula to establish the first two commandments as 1) Love your God with all your heart. and 2) Love your neighbor as you love yourself.

Israelita theology is a living, innovative tradition that interacts creatively with biblical texts. It is common for believers to pull seemingly at random from different parts of the Bible to provide evidence for their beliefs. Many Israelitas have been non-literate or read and write at very basic levels, so orality and free-form interpretation have been key to the development of their theology. They have created a unique biblical linguistics to bring new meaning to key terms and concepts. Jerusalem, for example is broken down this way: Jeru=Peru, salem=people (Ossio 2014:116). Numerology and image interpretation are also key features of Israelita scriptural interpretation. All of these interpretations locate Ataucusi and Peru in a privileged position as the culmination of Christian tradition and history.

Indigenous influences are prominent throughout the congregation’s teachings as well. They believe that the Incas were people of God. Believers often promote the three moral laws of the Inca empire, which in the Quechua language are “ama sua, ama llulla, ama quella” (do not steal, do not lie, do not be lazy). A variety of biblical citations are used to situate Peru as the location of the second coming of Jesus. For example, in Ezequiel 16:4 a reference to the umbilical cord is interpreted as meaning the city of Cusco, which is often referred to as the ombligo (belly button) of Tahuantinsuyo, the Inca Empire (Scott 1990: 43). Some followers believe that the tablets of the Ten Commandments are hidden somewhere at Machu Pichu (Ossio 2014:159). And during community rituals, the rainbow colored Tahuantinsuyo flag (representing the Inca empire) flies alongside the sky blue and white flag of the congregation.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

Ritual practice serves as the most important unifying force in this religious community. While Israelita beliefs are fairly malleable, the congregation’s ritual practices are quite strictly codified and monitored. The majority of their practices are Old Testament-inspired, including their clothing, economic practices, and their rituals. The ritual calendar is outlined in detail in a manual that Israelita priests compiled after Ezequiel Ataucusi’s death. While Israelita guides for ritual consist almost entirely of paraphrased selections from the Hebrew Scriptures, there is innovation and particularity in the congregation’s ritual world. One of these innovative components is the centrality of the Peruvian Amazon in Israelita practice. Since the early 1960s, the organization’s Fronteras Vivas (living frontiers) program has sent tens of thousands of members to live in agricultural communes in the Peruvian Amazon in preparation for the cataclysmic end to the current cycle of human history.

For outside observers, the defining feature of the Israelita congregation is their dress. [Image at right] Members attempt to replicate the dress of ancient Hebrews, especially on Saturdays. They wear tunics and sashes, with women in head coverings and men keeping their hair and beards long. Men wear ritual dress on the Sabbath only, while women wear tunics and veils daily. The colors of their clothing are revealed to them in dreams and correspond to a list of twenty-three spiritual characteristics (Ossio 2014:207).

At the core of Israelita practice is the offering of burnt sacrifices. These rituals are held at each Israelita churche and jungle commune. These offerings, called holocausts by members, follow strict rules of preparation rooted in a variety of biblical passages. The four animals used in the rituals are cows, goats, lambs, pigeons, which are killed and then burned on raised altars at the center of an open ceremonial space. Priests are specially trained to prepare and administer the burnt offerings. Beyond holy days and Saturday services, there are many other occasions for offerings, ranging from touching a dead body to women’s menstruation (AEMINPU 2014:46-48).

For most members, especially those who do not live in Israelita communities, Saturday services offer the most regular point of contact with their peers. These all-day events begin with the burnt offerings in the morning and include multiple priest-led Bible study sessions (Ossio 2014:234). The services are divided by sex, with women and men sitting separately (AEMINPU 2014:70-74). Music and dance are also features of the worship services, with electric guitar and keyboard as the most common instruments (Ossio 2014:253). In some cases, members will enter into trances and even speak in tongues, likely an example of the early congregation’s interactions with Pentecostalism in Lima.

The annual Israelita calendar is oriented around six major holidays. Their year starts in April, which is when Ataucusi calculated the birth of Jesus to have occurred. The week-long Easter celebration is a major attraction, with as many as 5,000 members attending the events held at the Cieneguilla headquarters.

Marriage and death are the two main life-cycle rituals. All members are expected to marry (ideally within the congregation) and to have children that they will raise in the community. Both premarital and extramarital sex are strictly forbidden. Members tend to marry young and have many children. Women are meant to be subordinate to their husbands (Ossio 2014:222). Israelita funerals frame death as a celebration, because the deceased member is believed to be saved from damnation. This celebratory, less emotional approach contradicts most Andean traditions, where deep and expressive mourning are the norm. Children born into the community receive baptism around eight years old, but many members join as adult converts.

Children born into the community receive baptism around eight years old, but many members join as adult converts. After an adult candidate attends services and events for an extended period, they are invited join the community through baptism. These are collective, celebratory events, centered on the application of water to the new member’s head. Members are expected to avoid drugs and alcohol. They pay a modest tithe to the community and those who live in the colonies renounce most personal property. The Israelitas stand firmly against adultery, theft, lying and corruption. Members can receive visions and direct experiences with God. One member named Sofía experienced an extended interaction with God in 1981 during which she spoke in foreign languages (Valderrama Escalante 2005:127).

The Peruvian Amazon holds a central place in Israelita practice. Ataucusi taught that members should move to these utopian communities in preparation for the next stage of human history, which would be the final of four stages before the apocalypse. In 2008, as many 15,000 people lived in communal, agricultural colonies located throughout Peru’s Amazon region (Ossio 2014:267). The congregation owns these properties. The colonies are divided into the old Andean social division of ayllus, with groups of families organized into shared labor units, often based on their region of origin. Each family manages an equal amount of land and resources. The communes collectively produce agricultural goods for local and regional markets. When the end of the third stage in human history comes, all Israelitas will move to these communes.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

The Israelita congregation is an extremely hierarchical organization, with the prophetic leader, first Ezequiel Ataucusi and now his son, Jonás, at the top of three distinct branches of authority: spiritual leadership, administrative governance, and the political party (FREPAP). Each of these branches plays a crucial role in the functioning of the community.

The spiritual hierarchy consists of multiple levels of priests and ministers modeled after the Hebrew scriptures (AEMINPU 2014). At the highest level is the International General Priest, followed by National Priests, Departmental Priests, Baptism Priests, and the Levite Priests. While there are two levels of female priests, these roles are quite limited; they are not permitted to prepare or administer animal sacrifice, for example. The majority of the priesthood is composed of married men with children. Priestly duties include overseeing religious ceremonies and running Biblical Training Centers, which provide instruction to lay members. Spiritual authority extends into the Amazonian communities, where male elders form the councils that make religious and administrative decisions. While members have some input in local and church-wide matters, leadership remains highly centralized. For example, all adult members are eligible to vote in national assemblies, but the ultimate decision-making power remains with the prophet.

Since the 1980s, a separate group of leaders has taken responsibility (always under the guidance of Ataucusi) for the congregations logistical, financial, and legal matters. The president makes most major organizational decisions, supported by an inner circle of trusted advisors. Proximity to the prophet is a key determinant of influence and status within the community.

Beyond its religious structure, the movement is also active in electoral politics through the Frente Popular Agrícola FIA del Perú (FREPAP). Though deeply rooted in the Israelita community, FREPAP has consistently drawn votes, and even candidates, from beyond its religious base. Its platform combines primarily leftist economic policies, such as protections for agricultural laborers and the redistribution of wealth to the poorest citizens, with culturally conservative positions on issues like sexuality, marriage, and education. FREPAP has seen electoral success over the years, especially in regional governments where Israelita communes are located, with thirty-three members having been elected as mayors or town councilors (Ráez Suárez 2023:98). In the 2020 elections, the party surprised many observers by securing fifteen seats in Congress (Casey-Pariseault 2020).

ISSUES/CHALLENGES.

Over the years, the Israelitas have faced a variety of challenges, many of which have stemmed from their position as a religious minority. Like other non-Catholic groups in Peru, they have often encountered hostility and, at times, violence at the hands of their fellow Peruvians. Over the years, accusations against the group have been numerous, ranging from economic misconduct to sexual abuse and drug trafficking. Both internal and external sources have raised these allegations, leading to a variety of legal actions. By the 1990s, the Israelitas employed a permanent legal advisor, who became a key member of Ezequiel Ataucusi’s inner circle.

Despite the broader growth of Protestantism in Peru, which now represents approximately twenty-two percent of the population, the Israelitas remain on the fringe of national religious life, even among the Evangelical community (Instituto de Estudios Peruanos 2024). Their isolation has contributed to widespread suspicion, if not outright hostility, from the broader Peruvian society. The national press has played a significant role in shaping negative perceptions of the group. As early as April 11, 1958, the newspaper Última Hora labeled Ataucusi a fraud, accusing him of deceiving poor families into purchasing overpriced land in the high jungle province of Chanchamayo. The headline read, “Smart Aleck Prophet Even Sells Mountains in the Jungle” (de la Torre 2008:98). Beyond negative media portrayals, Israelita members have also faced direct persecution. One convert recalled that after joining the movement in 1975, his Andean community accused him and fellow Israelitas of practicing dangerous magic and threatened to burn them alive (Valderrama Escalante 2005:122).

As a minority religious tradition in a preeminently Catholic society and they have developed a deep-seated anti-Catholicism in response. Among other things, they believe the Catholic Church invented the saints to trick people out of their money and that the Pope submitted himself to the power of the devil (Ossio 2000:198).

Throughout his life, Ezequiel Ataucusi was the subject of numerous legal accusations and was jailed multiple times. Charges against him included murder, sexual abuse of minors, and enslavement, though he was ultimately acquitted in each case (Ossio 2014:99-104; Brehaut 2023a; Loli S. 2015). Because of these accusations, many critics of the community view it as a “cult” with Ezequiel and later Jonás functioning as the corrupting leader figure.

The Israelita settlements in the Amazon have also attracted controversy. Environmental groups have accused the communities of engaging in destructive deforestation practices. Additionally, the Brazilian Federal Police claim to have evidence that some Israelitas are involved in coca cultivation for the international cocaine trade (Brehaut 2023b). However, members of the Monte Santo community insist that those implicated in the drug trade are not legitimate members of the congregation.

Following Ataucusi’s death, a succession dispute briefly shook the movement. When Ataucusi’s lawyer announced that Jonás, the prophet’s youngest son, had been chosen to lead the congregation, several of Jonás’ brothers contested his claim, arguing that they were the rightful heirs (Salazar Vega 2020). Despite this internal conflict, no major schism has taken place, though some dissident factions exist. Compared to his father, Jonás has proven to be a more reclusive and less charismatic leader. His public appearances, often circulated on YouTube, typically show him reading closely from prepared scripts. However, the religious organization seems to have remained stable in membership, and its political wing, FREPAP, has gained influence in recent years.

The Israelita religious community remains strong today, though it is unclear what future growth might look like. One might expect to come across a few members of the congregation in a working-class neighborhood in Lima or in cities and towns throughout the country. Though years of bad press and mistrust have made many Israelitas reluctant to open up to strangers. You would more likely find the blue fish (“pescadito”) symbol of the organization’s political party emblazoned on a whitewashed wall. This young tradition is sure to continue evolving over the coming generations. With many changes in Peruvian society and within the community, the Israelitas seem poised to strike a new balance between the public-facing political presence of FREPAP and the tightly woven ritual world of the faith community.

IMAGES

Image #1: FREPAP Logo. Credit: Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:FREPAP-Logo-removebg-preview.svg.
Image #2: Israelita David Chauca Quispe (right) wearing traditional ritual clothing at a parade in Lima July 29, 2018. Credit: Attribution 2.0. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:David_Chauca_Quispe.jpg.

REFERENCES

AEMINPU, “Manual del sacerdote.” 2014. Accessed from https://issuu.com/traperosdeemaus/docs/manual_del_sacerdote_aeminpu on 4 April 2025.

Brehaut, Ivan. 2023a. “Religión y deforestación en Perú: Los Israelitas del Nuevo Pacto (primera parte).” La Mula, December 1. Accessed from https://ibrehaut.lamula.pe/2023/01/12/religion-y-deforestacion-en-peru-los-israelitas-del-nuevo-pacto/ibrehaut/ on 4 April 2025.

Brehaut, Ivan. 2023b. “Religión y deforestación en Perú: Los Israelitas del Nuevo Pacto (segunda parte).” La Mula, December 1. Accessed from https://ibrehaut.lamula.pe/2023/01/12/religion-y-deforestacion-en-peru-los-israelitas-del-nuevo-pacto-segunda-parte/ibrehaut/ on 4 April 2025.

Casey-Pariseault, Matthew. 2020. “Fringe religious party gains power in crisis-stricken Peru.” The Conversation,  February 18. Accessed from https://theconversation.com/fringe-religious-party-gains-power-in-crisis-stricken-peru-130679 on 4 April 2022.

Curatola, Marco. 1992. “Mesías andinos: pestes, apocalipsis y el regreso de Cristo en el Perú privilegiado.” Historia y cultura 21:305-23.

de la Torre, Arturo. 2008. “La utopía viva. Asentamientos israelitas en el oriente Peruano.” Pp 97-122 in Políticas divinas: Religión, diversidad y política en el Perú contemporáneo, edited by Fernando Armas Asín, et. al.  Lima: Pontificia Universidad Catolica del Peru.

de la Torre, Arturo. 2013. “El zapatero mesiánico. Hagiografía de Ezequiel Ataucusi.” Pp. 241-68 in Los rostros de la tierra encantada: religión, evangelización y sincretismo. Homenaje a Manuel Marzal, S.J., edited by José Sánchez Paredes and Marco Curatola. Lima: Pontificia Universidad Catolica del Peru – IFEA.

“Estatuto del Frente Popular Agrícola FIA del Perú – FREPAP.” 2023. Jurado Nacional de Elecciones, March 29. Accessed from https://sroppublico.jne.gob.pe/Reporte/ReporteConsulta.ashx on 4 April 2025.

Espinoza-Benavides, Enrique. 2005. “2002: Los israelitas de ahora.” Allpanchis 65:139-43.

FREPAP, “Con el agro al poder, Frente Popular Agrícola Fía del Perú.” No date. chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/https://aeminpuperu.org/descargas/frepap.pdf

Granados, Manuel. 1998. “Los israelitas.” Socialismo y Participación 41:95-105.

Graziano, Frank.1999. The Millennial New World. New York: Oxford University Press.

Instituto de Estudios Peruanos. 2024. “Informe de opinión de marzo 2024.”

Meneses Lucumí Lucía Eufemia. 2021. “Los Israelitas del Nuevo Pacto Universal en la prensa colombiana.” Revista Colombiana de Sociología 45:417-37.

Loli S., Pamela. 2015. “Ezequiel Ataucusi: a 15 años de la muerte del candidato del ‘Pescadito’.” El Comercio June 19. Accessed from https://elcomercio.pe/blog/huellasdigitales/2015/06/ezequiel-ataucusi-a-20-anos-de-la-muerte-del-candidato-del-pescadito/?ref=ecr on 4 April 2025..

Oak, Len. Prophetic Charisma: 1997. The Psychology of Revolutionary Religious Personalities. Syracuse: Syracuse University Press.

Ossio, Juan.2014. El Tahuantinsuyo Bíblico: Ezequiel Ataucusi Gamonal y el mesianismo de los Israelitas del Nuevo Pacto Universal. Biblioteca Nacional del Perú, Fondo Editorial.

Ossio, Juan. 2000. “Israelites of the New Covenant.” In Encyclopedia of Millenialism and Millennial Movements (VF), edited by Richard Landes. New York: Routledge.

Ráez Suárez, Carlos Ernesto. “El Frepap y la cultura política de los Israelitas del Nuevo Pacto Universal.” Discursos del sur, revista de teoría crítica en ciencias sociales 1, no. 9 (2022): 87-116.

Salazar Vega, Elizabeth. 2020. “Disputas en el Frepap: facciones pelean por bienes y túnicas patentadas.” Ojo Público, February 26.

Scott, Kenneth. 1990. Los israelitas del Nuevo Pacto Universal: Una historia. Ediciones Pusel.

Valderrama Escalante, Gonzalo. 2005. “La segunda reencarnación del verbo de Dios en la tierra de los Incas: una historia sobre el fin del tiempo: mesianismo andino.” Allpanchis 65:109-38.

Publication Date:
7 April 2025

Share

Tolstoyan Communities

TOLSTOYAN COMMUNITIES TIMELINE

1828:  Leo Tolstoy was born.

1860s–1870s:  A peaceful offshoot of Russian populism, a communitarian movement, arose in the Russian Empire.

1880s:  Leo Tolstoy wrote Confession, What do I believe?,  What Then Must We Do?, and The Kingdom of God is Within You. Their uncensored distribution prompted the appearance of followers of Tolstoy, tolstovtsy (Tolstoyans).

1884:  The populist writer Gleb Uspensky in his article “By the Labor of One’s Own Hands” articulated the ideas of the Siberian peasant Timofei Bondarev on the moral necessity of physical labor for all.

1884 (November):  Tolstoy and his followers established the publishing house “Posrednik” (The Mediator).

1886:  In the south of Russia in the small settlement of Uch-Dere near Sochi, Tolstoyan Nikolai Ozmidov founded the first Tolstoyan community, which disbanded within a year.

1886:  Near Gelendzhik the commune “Krinitsa” was established. It exists for approximately forty years and became the largest and most economically successful communitarian settlement with Tolstoyan participation.

1888:  Leo Tolstoy published Timofei Bondarev’s essay Industry and Idleness, or the Triumph of the Land-Tiller.

1888 (Winter):  An informal Tolstoyan “conference of the like-minded” took place at which the decision  was made to create a network of interconnected agricultural communes.

1891–1893:  Tolstoyans took part in famine relief for peasants, organized by Leo Tolstoy. As a result, many began to think that the movement should shift from a purely escapist stance to a more active public position.

1895:  The burning of weapons by pacifist-minded Doukhobors and the Cossacks’ violence against them spurred Tolstoyans to active defense of freedom of conscience and provoked an even greater rise in pacifist sentiments in the Tolstoyan milieu.

1898:  Tolstoyan emigrés founded the publishing house “Svobodnoe slovo” (The Free Word) with centers in England and Switzerland.

1909 (February 28):  The Moscow Vegetarian Society (MVS [in Russian, MVO]) opened and became a stronghold and information center for the movement.

1910:  Leo Tolstoy died.

1911:  In Voronezh province, Ivan Benevsky created the Rzhev Production Artel, which became the largest communitarian settlement of Tolstoyans in the pre-revolutionary period.

1917 (June):  After the February Revolution, which established civil liberties, the first legal association of Tolstoyans was created, the Moscow Society of True Freedom in Memory of Leo Tolstoy (STF or MSTF [in Russian, OIS]), followed by numerous local branches. 

1918 (October):  Tolstoyans created the United Council of Religious Communities and Groups (UCRCG [in Russian, OSROG]), an interfaith body that became a coordinating center for religious communists and pacifists.

1920–1921:  Tolstoyans Pavel Biriukov and Ivan Tregubov developed and proposed to the Bolsheviks a plan for Soviet authorities’ economic and political cooperation with sectarian communists that would ensure autonomy and freedom of conscience for communities of peaceful religious communists in Soviet Russia.

1921:  Members of Tolstoyan agricultural communities took part in famine relief in the Volga region, independent from the state. 

1921 (March):  Tolstoyans held the First All-Russian Conference of Sectarian Agricultural and Production Communes, Communities, and Artels, which adopted resolutions sharply critical of Bolshevik policies.

1921 (October 5):  The People’s Commissariat of Agriculture of the Soviet Republic issued an appeal “To sectarians and Old Believers living in Russia and abroad,” inviting religious communists to occupy the land taken from landowners, to establish religious communes that modeled economically efficient communist agriculture.

1921 (December 31):  On the former landowner’s estate Shestakovka near Moscow the Tolstoyan commune “Life and Labor” was established.

1923:  The Leo Tolstoy agricultural commune near the New Jerusalem station in the Moscow suburbs was founded.

1924:  Tolstoyan peaceful anti-militarists attended a reception with General Secretary of the Central Committee of the Russian Social-Democratic Party (Bolsheviks), Joseph Stalin, with a petition for noninterference in their lives. 

1928 (September 9–16):  The USSR celebrated the centennial of Tolstoy’s birth on a grand scale. Hundreds of Tolstoyans gathered from all over the country at the unofficial celebration of the anniversary on the premises of the MVS (MVO; the Moscow Vegetarian Society). The Tolstoyans’ speeches at this celebration, vehemently opposed the Soviet authorities, resulting in repression.

1929 (February):  The MVS [MVO] was closed upon the demand of the authorities. 

1929–1931:  The forcible conversion of religious communes into collective farms [kolkhozy] began; Tolstoyans protested against collectivization.

1929–1931:  Tolstoyan and sectarian communes relocated to Siberia to avoid conversion into collective farms. In the Novokuznetsk region, the Peaceful Plowman artel, the Universal Brotherhood community, and the Life and Labor commune appeared.

1936–1940:  Mass arrests and trials of members of Tolstoyan communes took place. Sixty-five Tolstoyans were arrested and convicted; twenty-four of them perished in the camps.

1937–1938:  The last Tolstoyan commune, “Life and Labor,” was liquidated. 

1941–1945:  More than 100 Tolstoyans were convicted for refusing to go to war with weapons in their hands; many of them were shot.

1949:  Tolstoyans from the Life and Labor commune who survived the repressions and the war built the village of Talzhino near Novokuznetsk.

1951:  A group of Tolstoyans were arrested in the case of the “illegal Tolstoyan center;” they were accused of creating a terrorist organization that was preparing an attempt on the life of Joseph Stalin; several of those arrested were shot.

1976–1977:  The process of rehabilitating the Tolstoyans began.

1978 (September):  Soviet hippies attended Tolstoy’s anniversary at Tolstoy’s estate, Yasnaya Polyana.

1983:  In London, writer and emigré Mark Popovsky published Russian Peasants Tell Their Story, a book about the Tolstoyan communes.

1988 (September):  In the Soviet “thick” journal Novyi mir, the first permitted publication in the Soviet era of Boris Mazurin’s memoirs concerning the Tolstoyan commune “Life and Labor” appeared.

1989:  Arseny Roginsky published Memoirs of Peasant Tolstoyans, with a print run of 75,000 copies.

1988–1991:  Hippy-Tolstoyan Georgy Meitin published the samizdat [self-published] periodical Yasnaya Polyana in Riga, Latvia.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Tolstoyan communes appeared in the Russian Empire in the last quarter of the nineteenth century and were destroyed during the years of Stalin’s terror. They also existed in other countries: the Tolstoyan communities in Bulgaria, England, and the United States were especially well known.

The appearance of the first Tolstoyan communities marked the beginning of a new stage of development in the Russian communitarian movement. Ideologically, the Russian communitarian movement originated in the 1830s and 1840s, and it became a peaceful offshoot of Russian populism in the 1860s and 1870s. While some populists went to the people seeking to rouse the peasants to revolution, representatives of nonviolent populism pursued cultural aims: they sought to create model agricultural communes in the countryside, consisting of members of the intelligentsia or of the intelligentsia and peasants together, first, to live in accordance with their conscience, and second, to render various kinds of assistance to the peasantry (medical, educational, legal, and agronomic). This entailed the “simplification” (oproschenie) of one’s way of life, having to take the position of a person living by his or her own physical labor. Contemporaries called these settlements of members of the intelligentsia “cultured (intelligentnye) agricultural” communes or colonies.

The first Tolstoyan communities appeared in the mid-1880s; they were composed primarily of educated individuals and representatives of the privileged social estates (sosloviia). These communities broke up very quickly, because of ignorance of how to work and internal squabbles. Nikolai Ozmidov founded the first of these communities in August 1886 in the small town of Uch-Dere near Sochi. The number of permanent members of the first Tolstoyan community/commune did not exceed ten people. The settlement did not last as a community/commune even a year.

In the winter of 1888, an informal Tolstoyan “conference of the like-minded” took place at which it was decided to create a network of agricultural communities/communes with the goal of “union with the people” and “hastening the realization of the Kingdom of God on earth.” After the conference, at least seven Tolstoyan settlements in the countryside and several Tolstoyan circles on estates belonging to Tolstoyans arose. The Tolstoyan settlements were in constant communication with each other.

The years from 1891 to 1893 were a time of “intelligentsia”  community members’ participation in famine relief. Tolstoyans from various communities gathered in Ryazan province to help with distributing among the needy population the donations sent to Tolstoy from all corners of the country. One of the main topics of conversation among Tolstoyans working “on the famine” was the future fate of the Tolstoyan agricultural communities.

The geography of the placement of Tolstoyan agricultural communities gravitated toward locations with a mild climate favorable for agriculture, as well as to places of traditional settlement for sectarianism. In search of remote areas free from police harassment and other forms of state control, Tolstoyans gradually moved their settlements from the central provinces to the south, to the Black Sea coast of the Caucasus, and to the Transcaucasus. (The issue of emigration to America was also repeatedly discussed.) These areas were a traditional place of exile for religious dissidents, with whom these intellectuals easily found a common language and with whom they felt a spiritual kinship.

In 1886, the Krinitsa (that meant spring of water) agricultural community/commune was established on the Black Sea coast of the Caucasus near Gelendzhik. Its founders were representatives of two early branches of Russian communitarianism. One of these branches was the radical circle that gathered around the doctor Osip Kogan and his friends, Princess Natalya Drutskaya-Sokolinskaya and Vladimir Eropkin. The second branch was initially formed by students of chemistry professor Alexander Engelhardt who, in the mid-1870s and early 1880s at his Batishchev estate in Smolensk province, conducted a social experiment on the “education” (training in agricultural work) of “intellectual tillers of the land.” From the 1890s to the 1920s, many Tolstoyans lived in and around Krinitsa. Despite internal conflicts, a lack of resources for the development of communal economy, and problems in relations with the authorities, Krinitsa exerted significant influence on the cultural life of the local population from the 1890s to the early 1920s.

In the last quarter of the nineteenth century the social base of the Tolstoyan movement consisted of members of the privileged strata of the population; among them were many aristocrats and individual representatives of the bourgeoisie. There were instances in which Tolstoyan landowners transferred their land to the peasants for free or for a nominal fee. Over time the Tolstoyan movement was democratized through both the “simplification” of its “elite” elements and the influx of a large number of peasants and workers into the movement. Women constituted approximately a third of the movement’s members, but they were not always voluntary and independent participants; often they were the wives of Tolstoyans. Tolstoyan communities, even in the Soviet period, were small: according to historian Tatiana Petukhova (2008), they can be classified as small and medium-sized collectives, whose membership ranged from five to one hundred people. Thus, they were much smaller than both religious communes of sectarians and collectives set up in the countryside by the Bolsheviks, which numbered hundreds of members.

The “intelligentsia” colonies constructed their various communitarian ideologies on their conscious opposition to revolutionary values, on striving to “repay [their] debt” to the people, [and] in a polemic with philistine “bureaucratic” ideals. Their members also rejected the values of “civilization” and, wanting to escape its “pernicious” influence, organized communities in desolate, remote locations. Tolstoyans’ life in close contact with the peasants, their work to help the hungry and sectarians persecuted for their faith, and their frequent communication with each other and with Leo Tolstoy did not pass without a trace in Tolstoyans’ self-consciousness: many of them came to think that the escapism of the communal/community movement should be replaced by a more active public stance.

One impetus to choose social activism was Tolstoyans’ participation in the defense of the Doukhobors who, after moving to a position of absolute pacifism with the act of burning their weapons, in 1895 suffered severe persecution by the authorities, as well as Tolstoyans’ participation in the international act to resettle the Doukhobors in Canada. From this point on, Tolstoyans would proclaim as their goals the active struggle for freedom of conscience and the building of a nonviolent society.

Tolstoyan communities, as a rule, existed from one to three agricultural seasons, after which they disbanded. There were many reasons for this. First, there were ideological disagreements among the participants. Second, there were financial and material problems, which entailed economic difficulties and physical hardships. Third, the insistence on the obligation of personal physical labor and the principled rejection of wage labor resulted in community/commune members suffering from a lack of free time to devote to intellectual pursuits and discussions on important topics. Police harassment of the movement’s participants was also a frequent cause of communes’ dissolution.

The practical failures of life in Tolstoyan communes and theoretical disagreements led to Tolstoyans’ preference in the decade from 1895 to 1905 for creating neighboring settlements and farms (khutors) but not communes with joint property and labor. The gradual return of Tolstoyans to the practice of establishing collective settlements would occur after the first Russian revolution, amid a wave of rising anarcho-socialist sentiments in their circles and the gradual democratization of the Russian communitarian movement.

The lack of political rights and freedoms in the Russian empire meant that Tolstoyans could not have their own legal press organs and organizations. During this period, the dissemination of Tolstoyan communitarian ideas was carried out through personal correspondence and samizdat, as well as with the help of censored books and pamphlets from the publishing house “Posrednik” (Mediator) founded by Leo Tolstoy and his friends in 1884. In 1898, Tolstoyan emigrés established the “Svobodnoe Slovo” (Free Word) publishing house with centers in England and Switzerland. Free Word’s books and periodicals served to spread Tolstoy’s ideas and especially the idea of a peaceful revolution. From the time of the first Russian revolution, Tolstoyans interpreted the movement to create communities in the context of this idea.

At the end of the nineteenth century and in the early twentieth century, under the influence of Tolstoy’s ideas, communities emerged in other countries, and Russian Tolstoyans established communication with them. Ties between Tolstoyan communities in Russia and Bulgaria were especially close.

On February 28 (16 March) 1909, the Moscow Vegetarian Society (MVS [in Russian, MVO]) was opened, which for a long time served as an informal organizational and information center for Tolstoyans. The society proclaimed as its main purpose the establishment of love and peace between all living beings; its motto was the words “One soul in all.” Within the MVS the “Information Bureau on the Organization of Agricultural Communities, Communes, and Artels” was created. The MVS periodical The Vegetarian Review published materials about communes and addresses for correspondence with those interested in the communal issue; meetings and discussions on the topic of communes took place in its dining rooms; and the bookstore at the MVS also facilitated the dissemination of the communal idea.

In early 1911, on the Rzhev estate in the Bogucharsky district of Voronezh province, which belonged to the mother of Tolstoy’s friend Vladimir Chertkov, the Rzhev Production Artel was created under the leadership of Ivan Benevsky. This artel became the largest communitarian settlement of Tolstoyans in the pre-revolutionary period. The artel united about one hundred Tolstoyans, most of whom were workers and peasants. In addition to Tolstoyans, Baptists, followers of Alexander Dobrolyubov and Vladimir Solovyov, and even Orthodox [believers] were members of the artel.

After the February Revolution of 1917, basic political freedoms were proclaimed in Russia, and the existence of legal Tolstoyan organizations and periodicals became possible. In June 1917, the Society of True Freedom in memory of Leo Tolstoy (STF or MSTF [in Russian, OIS]) was founded in Moscow. Its name came from one of Tolstoy’s articles, which quoted the Gospel saying, “And you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free” (John 8:32 ESV). According to the group’s charter, its goal was to strive for the radical transformation of modern society, which is based on state violence, into a peaceful, stateless community by means of the moral improvement of the people. Similar societies modeled on the Moscow STF began to arise throughout Russia. Among other activities, these societies engaged in the promotion of physical labor and the creation of agricultural communities. In the Soviet era, the Moscow Vegetarian Society also continued its activities. A program of lectures and numerous circles functioned under its auspices. The topics raised in the lectures included the creation of agricultural settlements, Christian socialism, the “natural life,” the land theory of Henry George, and the like.

The problems of the movement to the land in forming communes were widely covered in the Tolstoyan press. The periodicals Unity (“a journal dedicated to the renewal of life in the light of reason and love”), The Voice of Tolstoy, The Voice of Tolstoy and Unity, True Freedom, Brotherhood, The Open Word, The Word of Truth, The Way to the Light, The Seeker of Truth, and The Renewal of Life had sections that featured the facts “of awakening and moving to true life.” The periodicals of the vegetarians and Esperantists also dealt with issues of communal living, and an attempt was made to publish a transnational organ on community themes, World Unity: The Organ of Human Unity in All Forms of Thought and Action (1913–1914, published in three languages: Russian, English, and Esperanto).

After the Bolsheviks came to power, the members of Tolstoyan agricultural communities saw themselves as full-fledged participants in the revolution, not the “violent,” “materialist” revolution the Bolsheviks effected, however, but a nonviolent, religious movement within the revolution. They hoped to influence the Bolsheviks toward a softening of their policies. In this regard, Tolstoyans Pavel Biryukov and Ivan Tregubov proposed a plan to the Bolsheviks in 1920 and 1921 for the economic and political cooperation of the Soviet regime with sectarian communists, who had been called upon to provide an example of the new, communist life to the patriarchal Russian peasantry. They hoped that should this project be realized, peaceful religious communists would be able to preserve their autonomy and quietly engage in economic activities.

The People’s Commissariat of Agriculture met with the Tolstoyans and on October 5, 1921 issued the appeal “To sectarians and Old Believers living in Russia and abroad,” which called upon religious communists to engage actively in economic cooperation with the Soviet regime, occupying lands taken from landowners and creating religious communes on them.

During the implementation of this project, Tolstoyan Ivan Tregubov, who had become a staff member of the People’s Commissariat of Agriculture, defended the interests of Tolstoyans and sectarians before the Soviet government. Religious communes, including Tolstoyan communes, were most often created in this period on former landowners’ estates with the active assistance of the authorities.  For example, the Tolstoyan commune “Life and Labor” was founded on the former landowner estate of Shestakovka on December 31, 1921 not far from Moscow, and the New Jerusalem community was established in 1923 in the Moscow region, also on former landowners’ land.

In addition to economic activities, Tolstoyan communes engaged in cultural and educational work, educating children in the spirit of nonviolence, and they also were collective participants in the transnational pacifist movement, particularly the War Resisters International and the International Fellowship of Reconciliation.

In the years 1921–1923, Tolstoyans participated in famine relief in the Volga region: they not only cooperated with the Soviet government’s Central Commission for Famine Relief (Pomgol) but also established the autonomous L. N. Tolstoy Committee for Famine Relief and the Committee for Public Assistance to Starving Children, which collected donations for the hungry from Tolstoyans and sectarians in Soviet Russia and abroad.

The economic successes of religious communes during the period of the New Economic Policy and the growth of their religious and cultural influence resulted by 1924 in the “sectarian project” facing imminent closure and Tolstoyans beginning to experience harassment for their antimilitarism. In 1924, at a reception with General Secretary of the Russian Social-Democratic Party (Bolsheviks), Joseph Stalin, Tolstoyan pacifists requested the legalization of their social organizations and non-interference in their lives. Participants in the meeting reported that Stalin seemed to receive them well and said: “In military affairs you are not our helpers but in peaceful construction we know you as honest and hard-working people.”

Under the Bolsheviks, Tolstoyans actively engaged in defending those who refused military service. In 1918, they created the United Council of Religious Communities and Groups (UCRCG [in Russian, OSROG]), an interfaith body that filled the role of expert witnesses in the courts for conscientious objector cases, helping to free the objectors from punishment. In addition to defending freedom of conscience, the UCRCG set itself the goal of facilitating the “rapprochement of various free-religious movements on the basis of spiritual interests.” The council’s membership included representatives of the Evangelical Christians, Baptists, Mennonites, Seventh-Day Adventists, and members of the Moscow people’s temperance group, in addition to Tolstoyans.

In March 1921, the UCRCG convened the First All-Russian Conference of Sectarian Agricultural and Producers’ Communes, Communities, and Artels, which adopted resolutions sharply critical of Bolshevik policies. The UCRCG aspired to become the central representative body for religious communists throughout Soviet Russia, who were perceived as an alternative to the Bolsheviks, embodying a peaceful, religious Russia.

Beginning in 1922, the authorities began to restrict Tolstoyans’ activities, Societies of True Freedom throughout the country were forced to close, repression against individual Tolstoyans began, and conflicts between Tolstoyans and local authorities became more frequent. During these years the publication of Tolstoyan periodicals was banned. Instead of legal periodicals, illegal samizdat bulletins from Tolstoyans were sent to subscribers under the auspices of the Moscow Vegetarian Society (MVS) until the mid-1930s. These bulletins published articles by Tolstoy, addresses for correspondence between like-minded individuals, and articles on topics related to the movement to create communes around the world.

The confrontation with the authorities reached its peak in the late 1920s. In September 1928, the USSR celebrated the centennial of Tolstoy’s birth on a grand scale. At the official celebrations, Tolstoy was praised as a writer but ridiculed as a religious thinker. In contrast, Tolstoyans held an unofficial celebration in the building of the Moscow Vegetarian Society, where they gave speeches in which they openly criticized the violent and antireligious policies of the Bolsheviks. Soon after this anniversary, a new wave of arrests of Tolstoyans began, and in February 1929 the MVS was closed.

As the collectivization of agriculture got underway, the state began the forcible transformation of Tolstoyan and other religious communes into collective farms (kolkhozy). Krinitsa was liquidated, and many other religious communes ceased to exist at that time. Tolstoyans protested vigorously against collectivization through letters to the authorities, passive protest in their communes, and articles and letters they published in their underground samizdat.

Seeking to avoid conversion into collective farms, Tolstoyan and sectarian communes began to relocate from central Russia to western Siberia, with the government’s permission in the years 1929–1930. One of the key centers of religious communitarian settlements arose near Novokuznetsk in the Altai, where the Peaceful Plowman artel, the Universal Brotherhood commune, and the Life and Labor commune were established. These communes achieved impressive economic results despite constant harassment by the authorities and repressive tax policies. In the 1930s, the Life and Labor commune was the largest of the surviving Tolstoyan communes. Until its destruction in 1938, the commune was an oasis of social, economic, and cultural practices that were an alternative to the Bolsheviks’ communism.

During the Great Terror, sixty-five Tolstoyan-communitarians were arrested and convicted; twenty-four of them perished in the camps. Tolstoyan communes were liquidated and their property was transferred to collective farms. More than one hundred Tolstoyans who had refused to take up arms in military service during the war (1941–1945) were convicted; many of them were shot.

In 1949, Tolstoyans from the Life and Labor commune who had survived the repressions and the war built the Talzhino settlement not far from Novokuznetsk and organized a collective farm within it. Descendants of Tolstoyans still live in Talzhino. In 1951, a group of Tolstoyans was arrested in the fabricated case of an “illegal Tolstoyan center.” According to the investigation, some of the founders of this “center” had been exposed in 1937, and now others were arrested who had established a terrorist organization that was preparing an attempt on Stalin’s life. Two of those arrested in this case were sentenced to death, and one, Vasily Shershenev, received twenty-five years in the camps (he was released in an amnesty after five years and died very soon thereafter).

Surviving Tolstoyans preserved the Tolstoyan movement’s archives and wrote memoirs, but they did not engage in public social activity. In 1963, the Tolstoyan Dmitry Morgachev appealed to the Procurator General for the rehabilitation of the Tolstoyans and was refused; the rehabilitation process for Tolstoyans began only around 1976-1977 (they started slow and unwillingly).

Official propaganda did everything to ensure that the history of the Tolstoyan communitarian and pacifist movement would be forgotten. The vast Tolstoyan archives were closed to researchers; Tolstoy was studied only in courses on Russian literature, not in those on history and philosophy. All academic interpretations of Tolstoyanism were subordinated to Lenin’s conception of Tolstoy as a “mirror of the Russian Revolution,” a great artist and a “ridiculous” thinker. Lenin called Tolstoyans “hysterical milksops,” bourgeois and philistines, “stuffed with a moral theory about not opposing evil with violence,” “a miserable little group of people,” “who wanted to turn into dogma precisely the weakest aspect of Tolstoy’s teaching.

Nevertheless, some members of Soviet society managed to discover Tolstoy’s ideas and the history of the Tolstoyan movement on their own. Soviet dissidents and hippies did this almost simultaneously. In the mid-1970s, the writer and dissident Mark Popovsky came upon some old Tolstoyans by chance and became acquainted with their archives, on the basis of which he wrote and published in exile in 1983 the book Russian Peasants Tell Their Story, dedicated to the Tolstoyan communes. Several other dissident historians, among whom were the future founders of the Memorial society Arseny Roginsky and Dmitry Zubarev, published the memoirs of Tolstoyans in the underground historical collection Memory. Thanks to them, in 1988 during perestroika the memoirs of Boris Mazurin about the Life and Labor commune appeared in the Soviet “thick” journal Novyi mir (New World), the first permitted publication of the memoirs in the Soviet period; and one year later, the book Memoirs of Peasant Tolstoyans was published with a large print run. Dissidents interpreted the history of the Tolstoyan movement as a history of popular resistance to totalitarianism.

In September 1978, on the anniversary of Tolstoy’s birth, several dozen Soviet hippies organized a pilgrimage to Tolstoy’s estate Yasnaya Polyana in Tula oblast; among them there were those who considered themselves Tolstoyans. One of them, Georgy Meitin, would publish a Tolstoyan samizdat journal, Yasnana Polyana, in Riga from 1988 to 1991, on the pages of which he would revive anew the forgotten themes of the Tolstoyan communitarian and pacifist movement.

In the 1990s and the first decade of the twenty-first century Tolstoyans and anarchists made several attempts to establish settlements on the land on the basis of Tolstoyan ideas, but these attempts did not have any social or cultural significance.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Leо Tolstoy (1828-1910) is a world-famous Russian writer and religious thinker.  In the late 1870s, when Tolstoy was at the peak of his literary career, he underwent an existential crisis that changed his life completely. Tolstoy rejected institutional Christianity for the sake of the “Law of Love.”  He revised world religious traditions and found that the fullest version of the “Law of Love” is given in the Christ’s commandments. However, it is also imprinted in the human heart, comprehended by the founders of religions and by the eminent philosophers, such as Confucius, Lao Tzu, Buddha, Socrates, and others. In this spirit, Tolstoy wrote numerous essays and tracts, such as: What I Believe (1883-1884); What is Religion, and What is the Essence of It? (1884); The Kingdom of God Is within You (1890-1893); Do Not Kill (1900); Christian Teaching (1897); What Then Must We Do? (1886); A Law of Violence and A Law of Love (1908); I Cannot Be Silent (1908).

Tolstoy’s ideas were directed against the autocracy, the police, and the “official” Orthodox Church. His rejection of social injustice, the division of labor, the monetary economy, private property, and the parasitism of professional and aristocratic classes led him to abandon the idea of technological progress and embrace anti-capitalist and anti-modernization views. Instead, he advocated Christian anarchism, non-violence, and communitarianism.

Tolstoy lived on his estate Yasnaia Poliana and closely communicated with the peasants, tried to work physically himself, creating the ideology of the “bread labor,” the moral duty for everyone to earn one’s own food. Tolstoy considered that the genuine Christian teaching had been spread among people by the sectarians and freethinkers and since then had existed in self-sustained, beyond-Church forms. Tolstoy was eager to overcome the individuality, regarding it as an evil and illusion, and replace it by the “people’s truth” of common life, which he had found among Russian peasants. Tolstoy believed that both he and other people could find a way to a true faith and a true life by watching common people and learning the gospel commandments.

Although Tolstoy never called for the creation of communes, he pointed to the ideal of the back-to-the-land movement, manual labour, cooperation, private property refusal. Tolstoy’s communitarian ideas allowed for both escapist and radical revolutionary interpretations.

In most cases, communities considered “Tolstoyan” were not strictly Tolstoyan; they brought together adherents of a wide variety of communitarian ideologies. People confessing various religions and sympathizing with vastly different philosophical systems and political theories could get along in one community. In addition, many members periodically changed their views and even their religious identity.

In the 1860s and 1870s, participants in communitarian settlements in Russia were enamored with the ideas of Western utopian socialists and the “positive religion” of Auguste Comte; they went to the United States to join American communitarian settlements and developed their own teachings. With the appearance of Tolstoy’s works, many participants in these early experiments found in Tolstoyanism the most accurate language for expressing their ideal and joined Tolstoyan communities. Such works of Tolstoy as Confession, What Do I Believe?, What Then Must We Do?, and The Kingdom of God is Within You were especially popular.

The first Tolstoyan communities lacked a unified ideology; instead, a shared spirit, not a collection of ideas, united their members. This outlook resulted from social and cultural aspects of the process of modernization, which the Russian Empire was experiencing at that time. The communitarian aspirations of the first Tolstoyans were the product not so much of the need for social reform, as much as they were individual quests for the meaning of life, a striving to overcome alienation and a crisis of identity. A communal way of life met these people’s needs, in “face to face” interaction with “significant others,” for a “second birth” and for finding the meaning of life in the circle of a new, spiritual family. Tolstoyans’ search for an “ideology” as a “system of ideas that gives a convincing picture of the world” was already occurring within the communities. As Benjamin Zablocki, who studied American communes, suggests (1978:109), it makes sense to evaluate these communities not from the perspective of their success in the economic or political spheres, but from the perspective of their success as institutions of identity. With time the significance of the ideological and even political element in the Tolstoyans’ communal experiments grew, reaching its peak in the 1920s and 1930s, when adherents began to perceive their peaceful communist project as an alternative to the violent communism of the Bolsheviks.

The concept of a “Tolstoyan” does not correspond to any particular collection of ideas drawn from Tolstoy. It is possible rather to speak of a more or less general worldview, a shared ethic of the participants in Tolstoyan communes, as well as of the popularity among them of various kinds of “teachings” and ideas, the enthusiasm for which came in waves, one after another. Of chief importance for Tolstoyans were self-definition through the concept of freedom (they preferred to call themselves “free Christians” or even “persons of a free religious worldview”), the idea of conscience as the voice of God, which should be above any “external” authorities, the rejection of violence against a human being’s spirit and body, and faith in the universal brotherhood of people.

Tolstoyans’ conceptions of God varied. Most Tolstoyans adhered to various rational interpretations of Christianity; there were also mystics inclined toward Eastern religions and Orthodoxy, pantheists, atheists, and agnostics; many called love, truth, or goodness God. In the early twentieth century, theosophy and anthroposophy became widespread in Tolstoyan communities; and in the 1920s, spiritual monists (followers of Petr P. Nikolaev) appeared in them. One might also encounter in Tolstoyan communities individual representatives of Russian sectarianism and independent God-seekers from the people and the intelligentsia (Syutaevtsy, Dobrolyubovtsy, teetotalers temperance activists, Evangelical Christians and Baptists, Malevantsy, and the like).

With respect to worldview, among the first Tolstoyans one finds a whole range of anti-modernization ideas that brought them closer to both Russian Slavophilism and European conservative Romanticism. Almost all Tolstoyans had a negative attitude toward capitalism and urbanization, opposed the division of labor, and aspired to a rural life in the bosom of nature, physical labor, and the “natural” upbringing of children. In the most radical cases Tolstoyans came to a complete repudiation of “civilization.”

An interesting blend of individualism and collectivism was characteristic of Tolstoyans. They combined the principle of “faith in oneself,” an individual quest for God, with the idea of inner moral self-improvement in a close circle of like-minded individuals, pursuing ethically lofty and socially significant goals. They regarded communes as local experiments, designed to change the existing order gently and gradually, to promote the establishment of new social, economic, and cultural ways of changing society. This, the most general set of social ideas on which Tolstoyan communities were built, may be called communitarianism, in the sense in which Arthur Bestor defined this movement (1978:3-4).

This understanding of a social mission developed largely in a polemic with revolutionary populism: the ideas of equality and social justice were dear to Tolstoyans, but they disliked violent methods of social change, and one can consider the communitarian movement they founded a peaceful strand of Russian populism. There were frequent cases of transition into the Tolstoyan movement from the revolutionary one due to disillusionment with violent methods of struggle.

The Tolstoyans’ ideal of a future society was an association of free, self-governing communities based on the ideals of agricultural labor and nonviolence. In the early twentieth century, thanks to close communication with like-minded individuals abroad, Tolstoyans increasingly began to define themselves as a religious-anarchist or religious-communist movement, and with time a pacifist identity came to the fore: Tolstoyan communitarianism became radical pacifism. During the First World War and the revolutionary years, many Tolstoyans already understood their movement as a peaceful revolutionary movement, regarding a worldwide revolution of brotherhood as the ultimate goal of their movement.

Ideas about a “special Russian path,” the unique spiritual and social qualities of the Russian people, and the Russian people’s tendency to collectivism were not uncommon among first-generation Tolstoyans, but over time the movement became increasingly cosmopolitan, and by the 1920s such ideas had almost completely lost their influence.

The perception of agricultural colonies as environments conducive to the development of a person’s higher individual and social attributes was widespread among the members of Tolstoyan communes. They were convinced that leaving the cities, living in the bosom of nature, and having close contact with the peasants were necessary for a person’s moral purification. Such sentiments could be justified by the ideas of Tolstoy, Rousseau, Henry Thoreau and other American transcendentalists, Edward Carpenter, and the like. The idea of common, joint labor was more popular than the idea of collective property, but still only a few Tolstoyans were advocates of private property and farming: they preferred the image of a spiritual community to its socioeconomic, material interpretations.

Tolstoyans also sought support in Russian folk-religious traditions. Especially popular among the participants in the Tolstoyan communes were the ideas of the peasant-communist Vasily Syutaev and the people’s thinker and apologist for physical labor Timofey Bondarev. In 1884, the populist writer Gleb Uspensky in his article “By the Labor of One’s Own Hands” outlined the ideas of this Siberian peasant on the moral obligation of agricultural labor for all. They made a strong impression on the youth of the populist movement and on Leo Tolstoy. Bondarev’s essay Industry and Idleness, or the Triumph of the Land-Tiller was published by Tolstoy in 1888 (Sibirskii 2010); Tolstoy himself wrote an introduction criticizing the division of labor and calling on educated people to “sit on the ground.”

As for economic theories, many Tolstoyans, taking their cue from Tolstoy, were adherents of the single-tax theory of Henry George, who proposed the abolition of all direct and indirect taxes and the move to a single tax levied on the value of land, regardless of the labor invested in it. Tolstoyans sent government agencies notes with a proposal to apply Henry George’s theory; the last such attempt was made by Sergei Bulygin, a Tolstoyan from the Life and Labor community, under Stalin in the 1930s.

The Tolstoyan movement was closely linked with the ethical wing of the Russian vegetarian movement. At a time when Tolstoyans could not have their own legal organizations and periodicals, their activities were carried out through vegetarian societies and their journals, which published materials on contemporary communitarian settlements in Russia and abroad, theoretical articles and practical recommendations on physical labor, the natural life, the creation of communities, and the like. In the 1920s, Tolstoyan communes often opened inexpensive vegetarian canteens in cities.

Considering themselves participants in a revolutionary project for the peaceful, nonviolent transformation of society, the members of Tolstoyan communities were fascinated by theories of nonviolence and civil disobedience (such as the theories of Petr Chelčický, Hryhoriy Skovoroda, Adin Ballou, Henry Thoreau, Gandhi, Romain Rolland, the idea of a general peaceful strike, and others) and thought of communes as practical experiments in the realization of life outside the existing violent structures, as seedbeds of a free, nonviolent, and natural life.

The Tolstoyan movement was also intertwined with the Esperantist movement: Tolstoyans studied Esperanto and used it in correspondence with like-minded people around the world. The publications of the Esperantists printed articles by Tolstoyans, and attempts were made to organize joint projects of Tolstoyans and Esperantists for uniting people and all living things in a single worldwide brotherhood.

Tolstoyans attached great importance to the education of children; they considered pedagogical work the most important dimension of creating new ways of life. They published literature for children, the pedagogical periodical Free Upbrining, worked with street children, and established orphanages, farm schools, and children’s colonies. It was assumed that graduates of Tolstoyan children’s institutions would acquire a certain worldview and the psychological inclination to agricultural labor and collective ways of life. The guiding principles of a Tolstoyan school were physical labor training, nonviolence, the demilitarization of consciousness, equality and mutual assistance, sobriety and vegetarianism, and school self-government.

Tolstoyan communities often had devotees of the most exotic philosophical theories: the communities were ready to accept anyone whose views did not contradict the principles of nonviolence, physical labor, and freedom of conscience. For example, “aoists,” who considered themselves “extarchists,” that is, “extragovernmentalists,” lived in the Life and Labor commune. Unlike the Tolstoyans, who aspired to the “natural,” they considered everything “natural” to be wild chaos and were convinced that in the sphere of human life it was necessary to invent something new all the time, to make everything reasonable and practical. They tried to reform language, devised their own language, “Ao,” and spoke it among themselves, came up with new names for themselves, dreamed of creating artificial suns and going on interplanetary flights, making human beings immortal, and developing a new, rational diet. They considered Tolstoy a great innovator in the field of morality.

Also, “nudists” sometimes appeared in Tolstoyan communities; they went about completely naked and even worked in this way, believing that this was a natural practice that brought them closer to nature. Although they wore trunks to the common table, they were tolerated with difficulty and excluded from the community because of the women’s displeasure.

Tolstoyans’ religious and communist aspirations are best captured in the names of their communities: Universal Brotherhood, Brotherly Life, Brotherly Labor, Banner of Brotherly Labor, Life and Labor, Unity, Goodwill, Free Life, the Free Life commune, Free Labor, the Equality commune, Kingdom of Light, the Leo Tolstoy Agricultural Artel, the Timofey Bondarev Working Agricultural Community, the Leo Tolstoy community of Free Christians, the At the Dawn of the New Life commune, the Free Conscience agricultural community of Free Christians, Good Gift, the Peaceful Plowman artel, Peace with All  Living Things, the True Way of Life Universal Religious Community, the Friends of True Freedom community, the Society for the Renewal of Life in Memory of Leo Tolstoy, and the Laboring and Living Together agricultural community.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

Tolstoyan “life according to conscience” and “simplification” involved physical labor (living “by the labor of one’s own hands”), which meant training in self-sufficiency, agriculture, manual labor skills, and various DIY practices. Tolstoyans learned to plow the land and to mow, to grow grain, to tend the garden and kitchen garden, and to make their own clothes and shoes. The use of wage labor was ethically unacceptable to Tolstoyans, and practical failures to comply with this principle often caused disillusionment with communal agricultural ideals and the collapse of Tolstoyan communes.

Due to the widespread dissemination of vegetarianism in Tolstoyan communities, gardening, vegetable gardening, and beekeeping were preferred, and non-traditional methods of farming were also used. The most radical Tolstoyans extended the idea of universal brotherhood even to animals as well; hence, some Tolstoyan communities experimented with farming without the use of animals. Evgeny Popov even created a method of “manual farming” or “grain gardening,” the purpose of which was to provide oneself and one’s family with the necessary amount of plant-based food with one’s own hands, without draft animals, on a small plot of land. There were also communities that refused to send old animals no longer fit for agricultural work to slaughter; they had to keep retired animals.

In the biographies of Tolstoyans, there are numerous cases of “refusals”: refusals of social status, property, careers (military, bureaucratic, or academic), higher education, military service, church marriages, urban living, oaths to the sovereign, participation in elections, passports, and even given names. In the daily social and economic life of Tolstoyan communities, refusal to cooperate with the state was also widespread and was even enshrined at the level of the communities’ charters: there were refusals to officially register communes and land ownership, to pay all or specific taxes, to perform labor obligations, to participate in the state education system, and to obey certain laws that contradicted “conscience.”  Such a position caused constant clashes with the authorities in every era and entailed severe repression in the Soviet period.

Although Tolstoy’s “Kreutzer Sonata,” written in 1890, and in general his criticism of the institution of the family, greatly impressed many Tolstoyans, few in Tolstoyan communities professed the principle of celibacy. Interest in the topic of celibacy in some of the first Tolstoyan communes can rather be explained by their religious and ascetic aspirations, as well as the perception of the community as a spiritual family in which everyone was “brother” and “sister” to each other. The statement of Benjamin Zablocki (1978:114) was also true of the Tolstoyan communes; he believed that the participants in the communitarian movement were dissatisfied with the traditional form of the family and tried to find new forms of family life. Adoption or collective upbringing of orphans, more equal relations between men and women and between parents and children, giving children unconventional, “ideological” names, addressing parents by name instead of calling them “mama” and “papa,” giving children great independence from an early age were typical Tolstoyan practices but were exotic in terms of the “larger society” in both the Russian Empire and Soviet Russia.

Specific communication practices characterized Tolstoyans. They built their movement on the network principle. The networks’ anchor points were the Tolstoyan communes, the homes of individual Tolstoyans, legal and illegal organizations and circles, vegetarian canteens, publishing houses, periodicals’ editorial offices, and book warehouse reading rooms. Important texts and useful information were disseminated through these networks, and legal and material assistance was provided. Close ties and active correspondence were established with members of Tolstoyan communities abroad, which gave them the opportunity to perceive themselves as participants in transnational movements: Christian-anarchist, pacifist, vegetarian, Esperantist.

Communication, especially conversations, discussions, and debates, played a large role in the life of Tolstoyan communities. Many guests from both the outside world and from other colonies visited the communities to exchange ideas. In some communities, the tradition arose in which guests who live in the community for more than three days are required/obliged to join in the common work. During Tolstoy’s lifetime, Tolstoyans often made “pilgrimages” to Yasnaya Polyana or to his Moscow home to talk with him about life; they also visited other Tolstoyan and sectarian communities.

Early communitarian settlements, including Tolstoyan examples, often practiced a ritual similar to the “criticisms” of the American perfectionists. These involved discussing the actions, character, and disposition of each individual member at regularly held meetings that were mandatory for all community members. Over time, such meetings were almost entirely replaced by cultural and educational discussions and musical and theatrical entertainments.

Successful Tolstoyan communes had a significant effect on the surrounding population. At the same time, the Tolstoyans never engaged in direct propaganda of their views. Like the new social movements that appeared later, they preferred the “politics of example” and strove to create “model” farms, the high cultural and economic level of which should itself prompt interest and imitation among the local population.

Tolstoyans rarely produced ideological texts, but the expression of their ideas and emotions through amateur poetic creativity was widespread among them. Many members of agricultural communities wrote amateur verses and songs in which they described their lives and ideals. These works showed varying degrees of talent: some were purely the products of an urge to write, but sometimes one encountered examples of poetic creativity whose authors can be considered truly original folk poets.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Tolstoyans considered themselves free Christians and religious anarchists; they disliked inequality, any social hierarchy, and rigid bureaucratic structures. Tolstoyan communities often refused to obtain official registration and sometimes lacked written charters. And while before the revolution of 1917 self-government among the Tolstoyans was more often informal, in Soviet times almost all communes sooner or later had to formalize their procedures of self-rule in written charters. Initially, these were charters based on Tolstoy’s principles of nonviolence and autonomy from the state.

As a rule, the highest governing body in the Tolstoyans’ communes and artels was the general assembly. Decisions concerning all major economic and organizational issues lay within its competence. The general assembly could elect a council as an executive body in the commune, headed by the chairman of the commune, and it also appointed an auditing commission. The issues of the admission of new members and exclusion from the community were also decided collectively. Communities sought to act fairly toward departing community members, allowing them to take not only their personal property but also, if available, part of the community’s property corresponding to the departing members’ contribution to the common economy. The voluntary principle governed the assignment of work in Tolstoyan communes: as a rule, people inclined to a particular kind of work were assigned to that work.

Already in the early 1920s, the Soviet government insistently recommended that Tolstoyans change to the standard Soviet charter for an agricultural commune, and at the end of the decade, the state began the forcible transition of Tolstoyan communes to the standard charter. The Soviet authorities also insisted that the Tolstoyans accept into their collectives all those who wished to join them or whom the authorities would send, even if these people did not share Tolstoyan values. At the turn of the 1920s and 1930s, as collectivization began, the typical practice was the closure of Tolstoyan communes by expelling the Tolstoyans from them and transferring the property to a neighboring collective farm. This pressure forced Tolstoyan communities from all over the country, with the help of the government, to move to Siberia in an organized manner, where for some time the hope remained that Tolstoyan communes would be able to continue their autonomous existence without coming into conflict with the state.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

The internal problems of Tolstoyan communities differed little from similar problems in other communitarian settlements. As a rule, the causes of their troubles and disillusionment with community life were ideological disagreements between the participants and the financial difficulties and material hardships that led to the collapse of the enterprise, as well as conflicts between the interests of community members with families and those who were single. Involuntary violation of principles (for example, recourse to hired labor or external sources of funding) also often led to disillusionment with community life. In large communes that managed to survive for a considerable length of time, generational differences between “fathers” and “children” could be the source of internal problems. Perhaps one can consider the distinctive characteristics of Tolstoyan communes most often to be not their excessive rigidity and authoritarianism, but rather the inordinate leniency of their internal administration. This leniency was based on the ideals of a free-religious worldview, which caused organizational confusion, economic problems, and subsequent disintegration.

With respect to the departure of Tolstoyans from the Tolstoyan movement to other groups, the largest exodus at the beginning of the twentieth century was observed to the Orthodox Church, with subsequent criticism of Tolstoyanism. In the Soviet era, Tolstoyans also left for theosophical, anthroposophical, and mystical-anarchist communities, which, as a rule, did not maintain a communal economy and were merely secret spiritual societies. There were no cases of mass emigration of the members of Tolstoyan communities.

External factors, especially harassment by the authorities, often led to the collapse of a community. Tolstoyans were considered politically unreliable throughout the history of their movement, in both the Russian Empire and Soviet Russia. In the late nineteenth century, the authorities did not distinguish between Tolstoyans and revolutionaries, believing that Tolstoyans also posed a threat to social stability and suspecting that revolutionaries could be hiding in Tolstoyan communes. Before 1917, surveillance by the political police and administrative and criminal prosecutions were prompted by the Tolstoyans’ involvement in the distribution of Tolstoy’s works (which were banned by the censors), their close contact with sectarians (who exerted a “harmful influence” on them), their protection of sectarians from persecution, and their efforts to publicize cases of the violation of freedom of conscience.

Constant surveillance and harassment affected the psychological state of the participants in the Tolstoyan movement, some of whom were brought to nervous and mental disorders or concluded that it was impossible to establish communities in such conditions in Russia. The decree on religious toleration of 1904 and the introduction of basic constitutional freedoms in the years 1905–1906 significantly improved the situation, although these changes did not completely free the Tolstoyans from persecution. The religious toleration proclaimed by the law was upheld in practice only with difficulty.

The persecution of the Tolstoyans during the First World War and the Civil War was brought on by their pacifist position: they signed a series of anti-war appeals and intensified their defense of conscientious objectors, the number of which increased dramatically at that time. In Soviet times, the persecution resumed due to the presence among the Tolstoyans of their own alternative project of building communism in a peaceful, non-violent way. In the early years of Soviet rule, many sectarians supported the Tolstoyan plan for a “peaceful revolution” as a spiritual revolution, which was occurring at the same time as the Bolsheviks’ violent, materialist revolution.

This project became a real challenge for the Bolsheviks, who responded with several waves of repression. The first wave occurred in the years 1921–1924, at which time all legal Tolstoyan organizations and publishing houses were closed, and pressure on sectarians friendly to Tolstoyans began. As a result of the extensive campaign against the Tolstoyans in the late 1920s, their last legal organization, the Moscow Vegetarian Society [MVO], was closed, and many active figures in the “free–religious” movement were repressed. In the 1930s, Tolstoyan communes remained the last centers of the radical pacifist movement, the destruction of which was completed during the years of the Great Terror.

In the late Soviet Union, Tolstoy’s religious and philosophical teachings were unofficially banned. Only a few groups referred to themselves as “Tolstoyans”: elderly survivors of repression and World War II, individual intellectual dissidents (including religious ones), and members of youth subcultures such as hippies and anarchists, numbering in the dozens but not even in the hundreds. Most of them valued Tolstoyan ideas of reformed Christianity and nonviolence. His communitarian ideas were less popular: in the late 1980s and 1990s. Only a few attempts were made to establish agricultural settlements based on Tolstoyan principles, but all failed. Participants in ecovillages of the 2000s also showed interest in Tolstoy’s ideas. In 2024, the last Tolstoyan in Russia, Boris Zolotov, passed away; since the 1990s, he had attempted to live a communal life “on the land.”

Various types of alternative movements, especially pacifist-anarchists and communitarians, outside Russia, tended to use the ideas of Leo Tolstoy. The first Tolstoyan colony was founded in 1896 at Purleigh, Essex, by a Tolstoyan anarchist Kenworthy and Aylmer Maude, the translator of Tolstoy. The number of colonies rose to over sixty, a quarter of whom lived on land owned by the colony, whilst the remainder resided nearby. In accord with the concept of the “bread labor” that Tolstoy had taken over from peasant Timofei Bondaref, each colonist had to earn their livelihood by their labor. The colony sustained itself for about three years and then collapsed, but the Tolstoyan communitarian movement in England did not disappear until the First World War.

Tolstoyan communes also emerged in Holland, Bulgaria, U.S., Korea, Japan, and Chile. Despite the fact that most of them existed for a very short time, their history is not a story of disappointment in utopia, but a history of a laboratory for creating alternative values, foremost of which was freedom and non-violence.

The two world wars became a serious test for the followers of nonviolence in the spirit of Tolstoy. In the post-war period, interest in Tolstoy’s religious and philosophical works was limited mainly to small pacifist groups that could still be found in the West, especially in England and America.

In the late 1960s and 1970s, communes that were ideologically or symbolically connected to Tolstoyanism became widespread in the United States, particularly within the youth counterculture. The most vivid example is Tolstoy Farm in Eastern Washington, which was established in 1963. These communities combined the Tolstoyan principle of living “on the land” with values of nonviolence, ecological ideas, anarchism, psychedelia, and elements of the New Age, movement. Thereafter, the movement almost entirely faded away.

REFERENCES**
**
Unless otherwise specified, the profile contents are drawn from
Petukhova, Tatiiana. 2008.  Kommuny i arteli tolstovtsev v Sovetskoi Rossii (1917-1929 gg.). Ul’ianovsk.

 Bestor, Arthur. 1978. Backwoods Utopias: The Sectarian Origin and Owenite Phase of Communitarian Socialism in America, 1663-1829. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.

Sibirskii krest’ianin. 2010. Timofei Bondarev i graf Lev Tolstoi: Bibliogragficheskii ukazatel’. Abakan, 2010.

Zablocki, Benjamin D. 1987. “Communes, Encounter groups and the Search for Community.” Pp. 97-142 in Search for Community: Encounter Groups and Social Change, edited by Kurt W. Back. New York: Routledge

SUPPLEMENTARY RESOURCES

Agarin, Efim. 2019. Trudami ruk svoikh. Tolstovskie zemledel’cheskie kolonii v dorevol’utsionnoi Rossii. Moscow: Common Place.

Alston, Charlotte. 2014. Tolstoy and His Disciples: The History of a Radical International Movement. London: I.B. Tauris & Co.

De Lange, Dennis. 2016. “Die Revolution bist Du!” Der Tolstojanismus als soziale Bewegung in den Niederlanden. Heidelberg: Verlag Graswurzelrevolution.

Etkind, Aleksandr. 1998. Khlyst. (Sekty, literatura i revolutsiia). Moscow: NLO.

Fairfield, Richard. 2010. Tolstoy Farm.” Pp. 62-65 in The Modern Utopian. Alternatives Communities of the ‘60s and 70’s, edited by Richard Fairfield. Process Media.

Gordeeva, Irina. 2003. “Zabytye L’udi”: Istoriia rossiiskogo kommunitarnogo dvizheniai. Moscow: AIRO-XX.

Marks, Steven G. 2003. How Russia Shaped the Modern World: From Art to Anti-Semitism, Ballet to Bolshevism. Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press.

Popovskii, Mark. 1983. Russkie Muzhiki Rasskazyva’ut: Posledovateli L.N. Tolstogo v Sovetskom So’uze, 1918 – 1977. London: Overseas Publications Interchange (OPI).

Rigby, Andrew. 1974. Alternative realities: A study of communes a. their members. London; Boston: Routledge & Kegan Paul.

Roginskii, Arsenii, ed. Vospominaniia krest’an-tolstovtsev, 1910-1930-е gg. Moscow: Kniga,  1989.

Parker, Martin, Fournier, Valerie, and Reedy, Patrick. 2007. “Tolstoy Leo.” Pp., 285-287 in The Dictionary of Alternatives. Utopianism and Organization. London; New York: Zed Books.

Publication Date:
15 March 2025

Share

Irina Gordeeva

Irina Gordeeva graduated from the Institute for History and Archives of the Russian State University for the Humanities (Moscow, Russia). She is the author of the book “Zabytye Ludi: Istoriia rossiiskogo kommunitarnogo dvizheniai” (The Forgotten People: A history of the Russian communitarian movement) (Moscow: AIRO-XX, 2000, 2nd edition -2017). Now she is a research associate at the Leibniz Centre for Contemporary History (ZZF Potsdam, Germany). Her academic interests and publications embrace the Tolstoyan movement, Russian communitarianism and utopianism, the history of conscientious objection, alternative social movements, pacifist and independent peace movement, antimilitarism, and nonviolence in the Russian Empire, USSR and post-Soviet states. E-mails: gordeeva@zzf-potsdam.de , pacifismhistory@gmail.com

Share

Organic Christ Generation

ORGANIC CHRIST GENERATION TIMELINE

1956:  Ivo Sasek was born in Zürich, Switzerland.

1977:  Sasek converted to Christianity.

1982:  Sasek left the Newlife Bible school and began working in drug rehabilitation.

1984:  Sasek founded a drug rehabilitation center in Walzenhausen, Switzerland, which later evolved into a religious community.

1994:  Sasek experienced a mental breakdown, leading to a reinterpretation of his theology and the establishment of the Bemessungsdienst.

1999:  The Organic Christ-Generation (OCG) was officially announced.

2001: The OCG gained national attention for its advocacy of corporal punishment in child education.

2006:  Ivo Sasek directed the controversial film Helden sterben anders! sparking media debate in Switzerland.

2008:  The OCG founded political and media organizations, including the Anti-Genocide Party (AGP) and the Anti-Censorship Coalition (AZK), and adopted reincarnation as part of its theology.

2012:  The media organizations S&G and Kla.TV were established.

2019:  The alternative encyclopedia Vetopedia was created.

2020:  The OCG transitioned to online events, ceasing large-scale in-person meetings.

2022:  Three of Ivo Sasek’s sons left the OCG, publicly criticizing their father and the organization.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Both critics and Ivo Sasek himself use his biography as a foundation to discuss the history of the OCG. Born in Zurich, Ivo Sasek was raised in an atheist family and initially had no interest in religion. During his youth, he played in a band, experimented with drugs, and was popular with women. He trained as a car mechanic, and it was a co-worker who inspired him to embrace Christianity. Consequently, in 1977, at the age of twenty-one, Ivo Sasek converted to Christianity and soon left his job as a car salesman to attend the Newlife Bible School (I. Sasek 2020 [2002]; Lamprecht 2003; Schmid 1998).

Newlife was an evangelical community that gained traction in the late 1970s in Zurich. It had a significant impact on young people like Ivo Sasek and actively ministered to the many drug addicts in Zurich at the time (Schmid 1998). With Newlife, Ivo Sasek participated in mission trips abroad, was baptized, and received education at their Bible school in Walzenhausen in the canton of Appenzell Ausserrhoden. His time at the Bible school ended abruptly in 1982 when he, inspired by audio cassettes from the U.S., began to adopt a charismatic-Pentecostal theology. Practices such as speaking in tongues, laying on of hands, and healing were not accepted by the explicitly anti-charismatic Newlife movement. After refusing to renounce these ideas, Sasek was expelled from the school. He then joined a former Newlife leader and worked in the Christian drug rehabilitation center he had founded (I. Sasek 2020 [2002]; Lamprecht 2003).

A few years later, the center was closed down. Ivo Sasek, along with his wife Anni, took care of the clients by establishing their own rehabilitation center named Obadja. They purchased a house in Walzenhausen, the same town where he had attended Bible school. Over the years, the focus of rehabilitation shifted from solely addressing drug addiction to addressing a variety of problems. Ivo Sasek also began writing books and recording his sermons on cassettes, gradually fostering a community around him (I. Sasek 2020 [2002]; Lamprecht 2003).

In 1994, according to Sasek’s own account, he experienced a mental breakdown, prompting him to reconsider the structure of his organization (I. Sasek 2020 [2002]). By this time, the concept of the Organism (See, Doctrines/Beliefs) had become significant. Sasek attributed the community’s struggles to the malevolent behavior of certain members. Consequently, he introduced the “Bemessungsdienst,” a practice designed to assess individuals who are willing to join the OCG (See, Rituals/Practices).

This practice became the central belief within the community, which adopted the name Organic Christ-Generation (OCG) in 1999. The community steadily grew, and aside from cult-watching organizations highlighting the authoritarian structures centered around Ivo Sasek as their leader, and some other nearby evangelical communities, they remained relatively unknown (Schmid 2010).

This changed in 2001 when the national newspaper Tagesanzeiger discussed Ivo Sasek’s teachings on corporal punishment of children. This was particularly striking as the OCG’s focus had shifted from drug addicts to family support. The article highlighted sermons by Ivo Sasek and books allegedly written by the three oldest of the eleven Sasek children, which explicitly advocated for corporal punishment (Stamm 2001). Other news outlets picked up the story (Von Tobel 2001), and although Sasek attempted to defend himself against these accusations over the following years, he gained notoriety in public discourse (I. Sasek 2010).

Nevertheless, the community continued to grow and began producing other media, including films and musicals, in addition to books and sermon cassettes. Touring through Switzerland, Germany, and Austria, the family presented their theology and organization. In 2006, Ivo Sasek produced an almost three-hour-long historical hero movie about the mythologically charged figure Arnold von Winkelried, who is said to have lived in the fourteenth century. This film, Helden sterben anders, was shown at the prestigious Solothurn Film Festival and subsequently gained significant media attention. The film reviews were devastating, describing the production as amateurish, bad, and boring, while also highlighting Ivo Sasek’s background as the leader of a “cult-like” organization, a “fanatic,” and the missionary intent of the film’s storyline. Many cinemas opted against screening the contentious production (Walther 2007; Rütti-Saner 2007; Zinsli 2007).

In 2008, the Anti-Genocide Party (AGP) was founded by members of the OCG, with Anni Sasek serving as vice president. Initially called the Anti-Genocide Movement, this political party warned about the dangers of RFID chips being implanted in humans for surveillance and control (Fagetti 2008; Cavelty 2008; AGB n.d.). The AGP actively participated in a political referendum against the introduction of new passports in Switzerland, which contained biometric data stored on an RFID chip (I. Sasek 2008 [2004]). This endeavor ultimately failed as voters narrowly approved the introduction of these new passport (SwissVotes 2009).

The AGP was the first of several conspiracy theory organizations established by Sasek in the following years, shifting the focus from religious missions to alternative news coverage. The next significant project was the Anti-Censorship Coalition (Anti-Zensur-Koalition, AZK), also founded in 2008. The AZK aimed to provide a platform for open expression and free speech, attracting a variety of speakers, many of whom were considered conspiracy theorists and right-wing populists. The media backlash was swift, with critics labeling the AZK’s activities as “obscure” and its conferences as gatherings for “uncanny patriots.” (Stamm 2009; Stutz 2014)

The year 2008 not only marked the beginning of a newfound interest in mass media production, often appearing without any reference to the OCG, but also signified a significant shift in the OCG’s theology. Reincarnation was introduced as a paradigm shift in their beliefs (See, Doctrines/Beliefs). Observers have noted that this led to a significant loss of membership, as parts of the conservative Christian base did not accept this change (Plock 2009; Relinfo N.D.).

In 2012, Sasek expanded his media presence by founding Voice & Countervoice (Stimme und Gegenstimme, S&G) and Kla.TV. S&G features alternative news with conspiratorial content in a short, printed newspaper format, while Kla.TV presents alternative media content in a late-night news style. Although the AGP eventually disappeared, the other organizations continued their production. Kla.TV is considered a particularly important media platform for spreading German-speaking conspiracy theory content (Pöhlmann 2021, 2023), while the AZK repeatedly made headlines. Featuring controversial conspiracy theorists like Daniele Ganser (AZK 2014) and David Icke (AZK 2024), the AZK’s most significant controversy arose in 2012 when one of the speakers publicly denied the Holocaust (Stamm 2013).

Nevertheless, the media production proved to be impactful, with a steadily growing viewership. In 2019, the network of platforms was further expanded. The OCG founded the alternative encyclopedia Vetopedia to counter the perceived disinformation on other online encyclopedias (Vetopedia N.D.; Relinfo 2019)

In 2020, due to the global pandemic, the OCG moved their large-scale meetings online. Even before the pandemic, finding venues willing to host these events had proven challenging due to the controversies surrounding Sasek and the OCG (I. Sasek 2019). After the COVID-19 measures were loosened, the OCG did not return to large-scale in-person meetings. Events like the AZK conferences are now live-streamed from the headquarters in Walzenhausen, where the Sasek family still resides (AZK 2022).

In 2022, a two-part documentary by Swiss national television reported on three of the Sasek sons leaving the OCG. The eldest, Simon Sasek, and his brother Joschua, confirmed accusations of corporal punishment, right-wing extremist views, and strict monitoring of children. Their departure, along with other former members’ criticisms, challenged Sasek’s image of a perfect family man (Falk 2022). This situation was addressed in Sasek’s internal communications (I. Sasek 2022a). The story gained further attention when a high-ranking Kla.TV staff member also left, providing insights into the production processes of the platform (Galgani 2024).

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

The OCG bases its belief system on the Bible, adhering to an evangelical-literalist view that considers the Bible infallible. However, Sasek criticized existing translations and introduced his own, the Interlineare Vollanalyse (I-VO), which offers different interpretations of certain passages, sometimes drawing criticism from other Christian communities (I. Sasek 2008).

In addition to biblical scripture, the OCG believes in Continuationism, the idea that spiritual gifts are present in the contemporary world and can be received by the faithful. Sasek and his followers often speak of God’s “Wirkungen” (workings), which are signals from God that must be understood. Sasek emphasizes the importance of interpreting these “Wirkungen” correctly, as anything contrary to the Bible’s teachings is seen as against God’s will. For instance, Sasek frequently criticizes homosexuality and Christian communities that support the LGBT community, citing biblical references. He views Christian values as being under attack, interpreting this as evidence of satan’s machinations. He translates the concept of the Anti-Christ as meaning “instead of Christ,” which diverts attention from God’s true intentions (I. Sasek 2008 [2004]).

In this context, the concept of the Organism is essential to the OCG. Sasek frequently cites Ephesians 1:22-23, where Jesus is characterized as the head of a body formed by his faithful (I. Sasek 2007 [1994]). He extends this metaphor, suggesting that the Body of Christ should function like a human organism (I. Sasek 2022b). The Body can achieve maturity only by moving as a united whole under the leadership of apostles, prophets, shepherds, and teachers appointed by God. Sasek sees himself as an apostle in this leadership role but emphasizes that the community is central to the Organism (I. Sasek 1999). Each member must contribute to the Body of Christ, requiring radical and total surrender to Christ’s headship (I. Sasek 2013 [1996]).

Although Sasek had long emphasized the significance of the body of Christ, a personal experience in 1994 prompted a shift in his perspective. In his autobiography, he recounts that intense work pressures, spiritual uncertainties, and a demanding ministry led to a severe breakdown. Traditional remedies were ineffective, compelling him to seek divine intervention. At his lowest point, God revealed leadership errors, particularly in failing to confront sin. Embracing this revelation, he committed to a ministry of judgment and correction. According to Sasek, despite initial setbacks, including a decrease in membership, this shift revitalized their community and led to the flourishing of their ministry. For Sasek, this marked the birth of the “Bemessung” (I. Sasek 2020 [2002]).

The term “Bemessung” can be translated as measurement or assessment and describes an essential practice within the OCG. These assessments are conducted to evaluate an individual’s capacity to be part of the Organism. The aim is to reflect deeply on one’s life and identify areas for improvement. In group sessions, individuals are assessed to support each other in their personal development. Through this practice, members are taught to set aside their egoistic motives and contribute to the collective Organism (OCG N.D.-a).

Since 2008, Ivo Sasek has incorporated a form of reincarnation belief into his teachings, suggesting that achieving sinlessness may require multiple incarnations. He claims that reincarnation was a fundamental belief in early Christianity, distorted by the churches in their malevolent quest for power (I. Sasek 2009). Sasek emphasizes personal responsibility and views reincarnation as a means to motivate relentless activity and self-improvement among his followers. Combined with the concept of the Organism, this leads to a focus on improving the current world. Sasek believes it is necessary to combat everything that opposes God’s will, which in his view most of the modern world does. Unsurprisingly, this theology informs the creation of many of the media channels (Lamprecht 2023).

Over the years, especially following the successful launch of various media organizations, Sasek increasingly preached universal reconciliation. He reduced God to an “ontic force” permeating the cosmos and favoring certain developments at times. On the one hand, he points to different religions teaching similar concepts, viewing the Bible as one way to learn about this truth, while other religious texts also contain the truth. On the other hand, this interpretation leads to the idea of divinity for all, as God is equated with positive energy within everyone (I. Sasek 2022c). When the Organism learns to live in accordance with this inner power, the New World can emerge. According to Ivo Sasek’s teachings, the New World is not brought about by divine intervention but must be actively created by the OCG members and their associated “righteous ones” through their own efforts (Lamprecht 2023).

As an addition to his theological teachings, the OCG believes in an ongoing global conspiracy. Sasek frequently refers to the image of the octopus, which appears in the Protocols of the Elders of Zion and is prevalent in anti-Semitic conspiracy narratives, to describe a global takeover by a small, malevolent group. He claims this octopus seeks world domination but denies targeting any specific nation or race, attempting to deflect accusations of anti-Semitism. Sasek argues that true Jews would not commit such crimes, blaming Satanists disguised as Jews instead. He suggests that accusations of anti-Semitism against him are tactics used by the octopus (I. Sasek 2023).

Sasek describes the octopus as a global network of high-level Freemason Satanists who have infiltrated key societal sectors such as the economy, justice, politics, science, medicine, media, and religion. He portrays himself and other activists as victims of defamation by mainstream media and cult-watching organizations, who (as weapons of these evil conspirators) label him a dangerous cult leader, religious fanatic, and anti-Semite (I. Sasek 2023).

The theology taught within the OCG has undergone several significant shifts over the years. Although Sasek still references the Bible, the shift towards understanding God as an ontic force has diminished the importance of traditional Christian teachings, which Sasek often dismisses. The incorporation of reincarnation theology and the emphasis on this-worldly change, combined with the belief in an ongoing satanic conspiracy, have led to a focus on activism rather than spiritual practice.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

The Christian origins of the OCG still hold importance with certain rituals such as baptism and weddings still taking place. Especially weddings involving Sasek children are visible and often broadcasted to all the OCG members (Familie Sasek 2024).

The essential ritual within the OCG is the above mentioned “Bemessungen.” This practice serves as rite of passage to enter the OCG and as way to assess individual and collective questions. Ivo Sasek’s concept of “Bemessungen” involves a continuous process of evaluating and reflecting upon one’s beliefs and actions, as well as holding others accountable. This practice is rooted in scriptural references and aims to ensure that the faith community remains true to its spiritual commitments (OCG n.d.-a).

The process typically involves group discussions where members share their thoughts and concerns. These sessions focus on identifying actions that either uplift or pull down the community, guided by the belief that Christ resides within each individual. By regularly assessing the collective actions and their alignment with spiritual principles, the community strives to maintain its integrity and fulfil its God-given task (I. Sasek 2014).

Former OCG members provide a different perspective on “Bemessungen.” They describe it as a process aimed at achieving personal subordination to the collective, often at the expense of personal freedom. One former member describes the ritual as a group confession where participants’ sincerity is judged, often leading to repeated rounds of confession if deemed insufficient. This process is criticized as manipulative and traumatic (Der Dunkle Parabelritter 2022).

During the introductory “Bemessung,” conflicts are analysed with reference to Sasek’s sermons, and a scapegoat is often identified and criticized until they conform. This portrayal suggests that “Bemessungen” enforce conformity and control within the OCG, often at significant personal cost to its members. Critics argue that “Bemessungen” serve as mechanisms for enforcing conformity and control, while official explanations present them as constructive ways to address issues. This divergence in views contributes to the contentious nature of the topic (S. Sasek 2020).

Apart from the “Bemessungen,” the most significant activity for OCG members is their engagement in activism. Numerous alternative media platforms are created and maintained by OCG members who volunteer their time and effort. This includes writing articles, producing video content, and performing various essential but less glamorous tasks necessary to sustain the extensive media network (OCG N.D.-b). This intensive involvement fosters high levels of interaction among members and aligns with the theology of this-worldliness, providing a ritual that meets its demands.

Another important practice is participating in community-wide events, primarily centered around Ivo Sasek’s sermons. These include the “Freundestreffen” (friends meeting), where potential new recruits are invited, and the internal “Gesamttreffen” (general meetings), where Sasek announces significant theological shifts. Additionally, the AZK conferences feature a variety of speakers. While these events were held in large venues until 2020, they are now livestreamed globally. Local OCG groups come together to watch these streams and discuss the presentations afterwards.

As is the case for doctrines/beliefs, groups vary in the existence and importance of formal rituals, and this section should such information. In some groups, such as communal groups and monastic groups, daily life itself may be highly ritualized. For formal groups, such as interfaith groups or museums, the primary organizational practices in furtherance of the collective mission would be placed in this section.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

The undisputed leader of the OCG is Ivo Sasek, who identifies as an Apostle called by God. Building on the previously mentioned concept of the “Organism,” Sasek positions himself as the head to whom the body (his followers) must obey (I. Sasek 1999). Surrounding him is a relatively small team of full-time members based in Walzenhausen. Notably, several of Sasek’s children hold key positions within the organization, with Lois Sasek leading Kla.TV and Elias Sasek serving as the head of IT, both playing highly visible roles (Familie Sasek N.D.). Hierarchically below the central team in Walzenhausen regional groups are responsible for media production and spiritual activities, each led by individuals overseeing these respective subdivisions.

The OCG lacks a clearly defined membership structure, which has led to speculation regarding its size. Estimates suggest the organization has between 2,000 and 3,000 members worldwide, with the largest concentration in German-speaking countries. However, members are also present in Eastern Europe and across the globe (Lamprecht 2023).

While the number of committed and actively engaged members within the OCG is estimated to be around 2,500 worldwide, its media presence suggests a significantly broader reach. Videos produced by the organization regularly garner hundreds of thousands of views. Organized as a decentralized network, the number of individuals partially involved in OCG activities is likely much larger than its core membership.

Financially, the OCG and its affiliated organizations rely on donations. Ivo Sasek frequently emphasizes that he does not solicit money from members. Despite this, members contribute financially in addition to their voluntary work. A hack by the online activist group Anonymous exposed some of the organization’s financial records, revealing individual donations ranging up to 1,500 Swiss francs (Wietlisbach 2020).

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

The OCG has repeatedly caused controversy in German, Austrian and Swiss public discourse. In addition to the discussions in the media focusing on the corporal punishment of children, the strict controlling of members and the dissemination of conspiracy theories, Ivo Sasek also had legal problems. He was taken into custody and accused of beating his children in 2001, but he was cleared of these charges (I. Sasek 2020 [2002]). Following the holocaust denial by Sylvia Stolz at one of his conferences, he once more had to defend himself in court, but he was again found not guilty of any wrongdoing (Stutz 2018). The legal situation in Switzerland is important to point out here, as the corporal punishment of children remains legal if it is not extensive, something hard to prove according to Sasek’s critics. Also, Stolz was held legally responsible for her holocaust denialism in Germany, in Switzerland; however, it is legally difficult to draw any consequences from this (Relinfo 2019).

Ivo Sasek and other members of the OCG frequently address the repercussions they face due to the negative public perception of their community. Children of members report being bullied at school, while the organization encounters difficulties in renting event spaces and procuring services. Some members have even been denied bank loans for home purchases (I. Sasek 2019). The controversy surrounding the OCG’s media platforms has intensified in recent years, as evidenced by the hacker collective Anonymous Germany targeting the OCG as a central hub of disinformation. The collective hacked Kla.TV and other platforms, gaining control for several days and leaking internal data to journalists (Anonymous 2020).

Most OCG members are integrated into mainstream society, sending their children to public schools, serving in the military, and holding conventional jobs. However, they often avoid publicly disclosing their involvement with the OCG. While membership is not entirely concealed (and members are encouraged to discuss their participation with others who might be persuaded to join), the controversy frequently leads to uncomfortable situations in public settings.

The public debate surrounding the OCG has been further fueled by high-profile departures and public criticism from former members. Notably, two of Ivo Sasek’s sons voiced their criticisms in a documentary aired on Swiss national television. Additionally, a high-ranking Kla.TV producer left the community and publicly detailed some of the internal mechanisms of the organization (Falk 2022; Hehli 2023).

External observers have noted an increasing radicalization within the OCG, raising concerns that the group may be developing parallel structures aimed at undermining contemporary society. The existence of an extensive network of alternative media platforms lends credence to these fears (Müller 2023). However, Ivo Sasek has repeatedly stated that he does not seek to incite any form of revolution. Instead, he claims that the OCG’s activism focuses on encouraging individuals within the system (such as police officers, judges, and politicians) to enact change from within, rather than seeking to overthrow existing structures (I. Sasek 2018). Still, authorities in Bavaria and across Germany continue to monitor the OCG’s activities closely (Amsler 2022).

REFERENCES

Amsler, Felicitas. 2022. “Der Staatsschutz ermittelt.” Süddeutsche Zeitung, January 27.

Anonymous. 2020. “Einleitung: Operation Tinfoil – Klagemauer TV (kla.tv), Ivo Sasek und die CG (Organische Christus Generation).” Accessed from  on 25 February 2025.

Anti Genozid Bewegung (AGB). No Date. “Anti Genozid Bewegung.” Accessed from https://www.agb-antigenozidbewegung.de on 25 February 2025.

Anti-Zensur-Koalition (AZK). 2014. “Verdeckte Kriegsführung – Ein Blick hinter die Kulissen der Machtpolitik – Dr. phil. Daniele Ganser.” Accessed from https://anti-zensur.info/azk10/verdecktekriegsfuehrung on 25 February 2025.

Anti-Zensur-Koalition (AZK). 2022. “18. AZK – Trailer.” Accessed from https://anti-zensur.info/azk18/ on 25 February 2025.

Anti-Zensur-Koalition (AZK). 2024. “Aufdeckung der Welt-Tyrannei und ihrer Kriegsstrategien – David Icke.” Accessed from https://anti-zensur.info/azk-20/tyrannei-kriegslist on 25 February 2025.

Cavelty, Gieri. 2008. “Wenn die «Anti-Genozid- Partei» Politik macht.” Tagesanzeiger, November 1.

Der Dunkle Parabelritter. 2022. “Die Zerstörung von Ivo Sasek und der widerlichsten Sekte Europas.” Accessed from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nESQtruDk38 on 25 February 2025.

Fagetti, Andreas. 2008. “Die Warner von der Anti Genozid Partei.” St. Galler Tagblatt 28.08.2008.

Falk, Eveline. 2022. “Radikale Christen – Mein Ausstieg aus der OCG.” Schweizer Radio und Fernsehen (SRF), April 13.

Familie Sasek. 2024. “Hochzeit Jeremias & Ruth Elpida Forell-Sasek.” Accessed from https://www.familie-sasek.ch/hochzeit-jeremias-ruth/ on 25 February 2025.

Familie Sasek. No Date. “Die Familie.” Accessed from https://www.familie-sasek.ch/die-familie/ on 25 February 2025.

Galgani, Gianluca. 2024. “Aussteigerin aus Sasek-Sekte erzählt vom Leben in Fake-News-Welt.” Schweizer Radio und Fernsehen (SRF), October 4.

Hehli, Simon. 2023. “Miriam Christ flüchtete aus dem Käfig der Sasek-Sekte. Doch um richtig frei zu sein, muss sie ihre Eltern vor Gericht besiegen.” Neue Zürcher Zeitung (NZZ), November 23.

Lamprecht, Harald. 2023. “Was ist Sasekismus?” In Organische Christus-Generation, Kla.TV und Anti-Zensur-Koalition. Die Verschwörungswelten des Sasekismus (EZW-Texte 276), edited by Matthias Pöhlmann, 7-8. Berlin: EZW-Texte.

Lamprecht, Harald. 2003. “Organische Christusgeneration. Ivo Sasek und seine   Bewegung.”Materialdienst der Evangelischen Zentralstelle für Weltanschauungen 66:132-43.

Müller, Claudia. 2023. “Der Sasek’sche Christus-Organismus und sein Gerichtsdienst im Endkampf. Kla.TV-Innenansichten.” Pp. 69-99 in Organische Christus-Generation, Kla.TV und Anti-Zensur-Koalition. Die Verschwörungswelten des Sasekismus (EZW-Texte 276), edited by Matthias Pöhlmann. Berlin: EZW-Texte.

Organische-Christus-Generation (OCG). n.d-a. “Bemessung.” Accessed from on 25 February 2025.

Organische-Christus-Generation (OCG). n.d.-b. “Schwarm-Power-Praxistag“ in Sachsen. Accessed from https://www.ocg.life/schwarmpowerpraxistag/ on 25 February 2025.

Plock, Wilfried. 2009. Ivo Sasek und seine Organische Christus-Generation. Hünfeld: Christlicher Mediendienst Hünfeld GmbH.

Pöhlmann, Matthias. 2023. “Informationskrieg gegen bösartige Eliten. Die crossmediale Verschwörungswelt des Sasekismus.” Pp. 41-67 in Organische Christus-Generation, Kla.TV und Anti-Zensur-Koalition. Die Verschwörungswelten des Sasekismus (EZW-Texte 276), edited by Matthias Pöhlmann. Berlin: EZW-Texte.

Pöhlmann, Matthias. 2021. Rechte Esoterik. Wenn sich alternatives Denken und Extremismus gefährlich vermischen. Freiburg im Breisgau: Herder.

Relinfo. 2019. “Vetopedia – das neueste Projekt der Familie Sasek (OCG).” Accessed from https://www.relinfo.ch/2019/02/12/vetopedia-das-neueste-projekt-der-familie-sasek-ocg/ on 25 February 2025.

Relinfo. n.d. “Organische Christus-Generation OCG.” Accessed from https://www.relinfo.ch/lexikon/christentum/aeltere-und-evangelikale-freikirche/neuere-fundamentalistische-sondergruppen/organische-christus-generation-ocg/ on 25 February 2025.

Rütti-Saner, Fränzi 2007. “Saseks Helden in Solothurn.” St. Galler Tagblatt, January 25.

Sasek, Ivo. 2023. “Staatsfeind Nr. 1 – Krake im Staatsgewand.” Accessed from https://anti-zensur.info/azk19/staatsfeind on 25 February 2025.

Sasek, Ivo. 2022a. “Der Verlust meiner Söhne.” Panorama-Nachrichten Sptember 2022 (3).

Sasek, Ivo. 2022b. Sieg der Herrlichkeit. Die Überwindung des Bösen. Walzenhausen: Elaion Verlag.

Sasek, Ivo. 2022c. “GEMEINSAME MÜNDIGKEIT – Internationales Freundestreffen 2022” Accessed from https://www.kla.tv/22737 on 25 February 2025.

Sasek, Ivo. 2020 [2002]. Herr der Wandlungen (Teil I – III). Walzenhausen: Elaion Verlag.

Sasek, Ivo. 2019. Dokument einer Verschwörung. Walzenhausen: Elaion Verlag.

Sasek, Ivo. 2018. “16. AZK: Warum es eine AZK braucht!” Accessed from https://anti-zensur.info/azk16/vorwort-ivosasek on 25 February 2025.

Sasek, Ivo. 2014. “Spielfilm: Männer stiehlt man nicht.” Accessed from https://www.elaion-verlag.ch/dvd-maenner/ on 25 February 2025.

Sasek, Ivo. 2013 [1996]. Die Königsherrschaft. Walzenhausen: Elaion Verlag.

Sasek, Ivo. 2010. “«Mit Prügel nichts am Hut».” Landbote, August 19.

Sasek, Ivo. 2008. Der Epheserbrief. Interlineare Vollanalyse. Walzenhausen: Elaion Verlag.

Sasek, Ivo. 2008 [2004]. Anstatt- oder Christus. Walzenhausen: Elaion Verlag.

Sasek, Ivo. 2008. “Predigt: Paradigmenwechsel  “’Reinkarnation’“.” Gemeinde-Lehrdienst, December 25.

Sasek, Ivo. 1999. “Wandel im Geist.” Gemeinde-Lehrdienst, June 5.

Sasek, Ivo. 2007 [1994]. Krieg in Gerechtigkeit. Walzenhausen: Elaion Verlag.

Sasek, Simon. 2020. “Opferrituale der OCG – Simon Sasek 2.0.” Accessed from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ziSWOY0n0YI on 25 February 2025.

Schmid, Georg Otto. 2010. “Neues von der OCG.” Informationsblatt. Herausgegeben von der Evangelischen Informationsstelle: Kirchen – Sekten – Religionen 47:5-9.

Schmid, Georg Otto. 1998. “Obadja.” Informationsblatt. Herausgegeben von der Evangelischen Informationsstelle: Kirchen – Sekten – Religionen 35:7-12.

Stamm, Hugo. 2013. “Der grosse Auftritt der Holocaust-Leugnerin.” Tagesanzeiger, January16.

Stamm, Hugo. 2009. “Das Klassentreffen der unheimlichen Patrioten.” Der Bund, October 31.

Stamm, Hugo. 2001. ““Blutige Striemen schützen vor der Hölle”.” Tagesanzeiger, June 22.

Stutz, Hans. 2018. “Freispruch für Ivo Sasek.” Tacheles, August 24.

Stutz, Hans. 2014. “Im Netz des Predigers.” Die Wochenzeitung (WOZ), October 23.

SwissVotes. 2009. “Einführung des biometrischen Passes.” Accessed from https://swissvotes.ch/vote/542.00 on 25 February 2025.

Vetopedia. No Date. “Vetopedia – Die freie Enzyklopädie der Gegenstimmen.” Accessed from https://v1.vetopedia.org/index.php?title=Vetopedia_-_Die_freie_Enzyklopädie_der_Gegenstimmen on 25 February 2025.

Von Tobel, Urs. 2001. “Prügelstrafe im Namen des Herrn.” Beobachter, September 14.

Walther, Christian. 2007. “Winkelried, der christliche Held. Ein blutrünstiges Schlachtenepos an den Filmtagen.” Schweizer Radio und Fernsehen (SRF), January 24.

Wietlisbach, Oliver. 2020. “Schweizer Sektenführer Sasek von Anonymous brutal vorgeführt.” Watsonm September 24.

Zinsli, Hans Jürg. 2007. “Sektenalarm in Solothurn?” Berner Zeitung, January 26.

Publication Date:
4 March 2025

Share

Loïc Bawidamann

Loïc Bawidamann is a PhD candidate in the Department of Religious Studies at the University of Zürich, Switzerland. His research focuses on religion and conspiracy theories in contemporary Switzerland. He is also a co-editor of the Zeitschrift für junge Religionswissenschaft.

Share

Sovereign Citizens

SOVEREIGN CITIZEN MOVEMENT TIMELINE

1971:  William Gale’s Posse Comitatus began practicing and spreading versions of sovereign citizen teaching in the early 1970s. This followed more dispersed and less publicized practices of tax protest and pro se vernacular legal activism by various citizens but marks a significant moment in the rise of this diverse movement.

1980s:  The recession and the Farm Crisis made sovereign citizen teachings appealing to many Americans suffering economically.

1995:  The Oklahoma City bombing, carried out by Timothy McVeigh and Terry Nichols. Nichols was invested in a sovereign citizen worldview, viewing the U.S. government as corrupt and renouncing, via vernacular legal practices, his citizenship and the authority of the U.S. government over him.

1996:  The Montana Freemen movement, a sovereign citizen group founded and led by LeRoy Schweitzer, declared a foreclosed farm to be “Justus Township” and assumed jurisdiction for themselves to post bounties for their local (largely law enforcement or governmental employee) enemies. The Freemen also engaged in widespread bank fraud.

2007:  The Tea Party movement began, offering a popular political forum for sovereign citizens to exchange ideas as well as an emphasis on returning to a lost original American mode of individual freedom. Sovereign citizens, such as the Natural Living Man (aka Ernie Wayne TerTelgte) adopted a practice popularized by Tea Party activists of dressing in colonial-era outfits. The Natural Living Man’s tri-corner hat became an important part of his public self-presentation as sovereign in courtroom encounters and in recordings thereof that his supporters distributed.

2014:  Rancher Cliven Bundy and his supporters engaged in a standoff with federal officials. Bundy refused to recognize the legitimacy of Bureau of Land Management’s jurisdiction, representing, instead, an authentic understanding of the United States as planned and underwritten by God.

2015:  One of many home seizures to make the news took place in which individuals affiliated with a sovereign citizen interpretation of the diverse, citizenship-focused Moorish Science Temple of America movement claimed a mansion in North Carolina. They cited elaborate legal interpretations for their rights to the property.

2016:  Two of Cliven Bundy’s sons continued his struggle against what they interpreted as unlawful federal seizure of lands by occupying the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge in Oregon for forty days.

2016:  A group calling itself the Washitah Nation that is linked to the broader Washitaw de Dugdahmoundyah religious movement, briefly occupied a house in New Orleans. The group defending its claim to the property to police via citation of treaties and legal interpretations.

2021:  A convoy of vehicles driven by members of a group called Rise of the Moors was stopped by police on a highway in Massachusetts. Police later described the event as a “standoff,” but while the Moors carried guns, they were also armed with photocopies of treaties and legal decisions that they insisted explained their status as foreign nationals travelling, according to law, peacefully through U.S. territory.

2021:  Romana Didulo, declaring herself “Queen of Canada,” who blended the epistemological drama of Q-Anon with sovereign citizen practice, was detained by police after posting on-line that doctors who administer the Covid-19 vaccine to children should be killed.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

The sovereign citizen movement involves interpretations of the law that clash with widely accepted interpretations within the legal institution. While “sovereign citizen” is a term describing a diverse range of theories and practices related to politics and law, the movement has a coherent core of insisting on the possibility of sovereignty (understood as self-determination, freedom) of the individual. While increasingly a global movement, sovereign citizen logic emerged first in the USA and is rooted in core tensions of the American political experiment. Specifically, tensions between the promise of individual liberty and the restrictions imposed by the authority of the government and its institutions, founding narratives describing a teleology of government’s inevitable decline into tyranny and the responsibility of citizens to resist, and tensions around elitism versus universal access in relation particularly to the language and protocol of legal practice serve as engines for sovereign citizen creativity.

The sovereign citizen movement holds that true law is natural law, often glossed as deriving its “authority from nothing less than Nature and the Holy Spirit” (Riezinger and Belcher 2014:105). In contrast to such authentic, divine law (usually identified as that referenced by the Founders of the U.S. and at the core of the intended American political experiment), sovereign citizens say that they live in a society unjustly ruled by a corrupt government (a U.S. that has abandoned its exceptional ideals and commitments). As a result, sovereign citizens engage in a variety of practices, ranging from refusal to comply with tax laws or to carry state-issued identification to the use of alternative forms of identification like their own license plates. [Image at right] In pro se appearances in court and in encounters with law enforcement, sovereign citizens often make reference to alternative interpretations of legal precedent, claiming exception to laws. As will be described below, some sovereign citizens object to such basic conventions as being identified with a name, citing elaborate counter-histories and legal theories. Some sovereign citizens attempt to secede from the state altogether, and, indeed, sovereign citizen claims can lead to violent conflicts with state authorities.

The religiosity of sovereign citizens comes first in their appeal to a true Law identified as natural law, God’s law. Many sovereign citizens also express a sacralized narrative of the United States, with the Founders functioning as God’s agent, establishing the promise of a divine republic. For some sovereign citizens, sovereign citizen logic and action is paired with an existing religious framework, such as the diverse, citizenship-focused Moorish Science Temple of America, or the  Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, with its popular sacralization of the U.S. as a central part of God’s plan. In such instances, divine support for or intervention in the actions of sovereign citizens can be identified by sovereigns themselves, as when supporters of Mormon rancher Cliven Bundy identified miraculous occurrences around the 2014 standoff between Bundy’s group and federal officials (Cox 2014). [Image at right]

While the logic of the sovereign citizen movement is rooted in foundational American texts and in a sacralized reading of the founding of the U.S. as an exceptional experiment in individual freedom, sovereign citizen thought and practice as recognizable today came to popularity in the 1970s through the teachings of William Gale and his Posse Comitatus movement. The recession in the early 1980s, along with the Farm Crisis of the same decade, made some sovereign citizen logic widely appealing, particularly the offer of relief from taxes, disavowal the power of the government to foreclose on and seize property, and emphasis on individual autonomy and self-determination in the face of government oversight and intervention. The Montana Freemen movement was composed of rural farmers who usurped for themselves the authority of local government and law enforcement, engaging in both a series of financial crimes (largely involving fraudulent checks) and harassment (both via the filing of liens and the offering of cash bounties for the arrest of their local opponents, law enforcement and government employees who the Freemen spoke openly about executing by hanging as a punishment for “treason” against true law. These early examples stand out largely because of the criminal justice spectacle they produced: both groups were armed, engaged in violently racist rhetoric (if not outright violent acts, as in the case of the Posse Comitatus) and were responded to by law enforcement with investigations and arrests.

Yet while spectacular criminal cases tend to highlight the existence of sovereign citizen thinking (as in the case of the Oklahoma City bombing of 1995) or in newsworthy instances of audacious squatting via citation of “lawful” claims to property (as when sovereign citizens adherents claim houses as their own, as happened notably in North Carolina in 2015 and New Orleans in 2016), most sovereign citizens engage in their practice as individuals and on much smaller scale, under the radar of mass media coverage and often with a limited degree of success. When, for instance, a police officer is presented with sovereign citizen paperwork and legal rhetoric at a traffic stop, then decides to let the sovereign off with a warning, such instances are read as evidence validating sovereign citizen claims. Videos of such “victories” are often publicized online, which is where sovereign ideas and practices are spread to sympathetic audiences, acquiring converts to this worldview.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

One widely shared belief among sovereign citizens is that the individual sovereignty enshrined in the founding of the United States has been lost, along with the original intent and design of the United States government. The United States of America has been replaced by the United States of America corporation (sometimes rendered in all capital letters to flag its status as a legal fiction). As part of this narrative emerges a theory of two Constitutions, an original Constitution and a corrupted Constitution invoked and used by the government. As David Robinson, a popular sovereign citizen thinker and author puts it, this shift in Constitutions was part and parcel of a replacement of a “service oriented form of government with a profit oriented form of government—without our knowledge of consent” as citizens. (Robinson 2009:52).

Sovereign citizens disagree on when this crisis (wherein authentic government is replaced with fraudulent government) happened. Some cite the Organic Act of 1871. Some cite Reconstruction (with widely shared concerns that the Fourteenth Amendment creates a false class of citizen (federal citizen as opposed to state citizen, for instance, or strawman as opposed to flesh and blood person). Some point to 1933 and the abolishment of the gold standard, often as part of a narrative of citizens becoming slaves to international bankers, often a euphemism for a global Jewish conspiracy. In all of these cases, however, the sovereign citizen worldview emphasizes an eschatology of decline and expresses nostalgia for the ideals of the founders, who, with the Declaration of Independence (in the words of Robinson) “established that the people are sovereign under God’s Natural Law” (2009:23). As sovereign citizen thinker Johnny Liberty puts it, “Our natural-born, unalienable sovereign rights as human beings are being taken away, the U.S. constitution is becoming a historical relic of the past and the protection of our precious freedoms now within the domain of false patriots and fake leaders” (Liberty 2022:217). The divinely aligned government of the Founders has been abandoned for reasons for greed. Allegiance to and alignment with true Law has been replaced with institutionally enforced understandings of the “legal.” This is an essential distinction for the sovereign citizen worldview. As Robinson says, “Anything the government does is generally ‘legal’ but it may not always be ‘lawful.’” (2009:76)

Since sovereign citizen ideology is one that emphasizes self-determination, anyone is free to adapt basic sovereign citizen claims to their own desires. Thus, some thinkers argue that sheriffs are the only legitimate form of law enforcement and some weaponize liens and tax forms against sheriffs as illegitimate authorities; some sovereign citizens hold that U.S. current isn’t real money while others insist that every individual social security number is a guarantee of a massive financial trust. For some sovereign citizens, that lawyers are referred to as “esquire” means they are claiming British titles of nobility and thus operate under the logic of exclusively British law; others hold that all citizens are, in fact, royalty (kings and queens) held down by brainwashing into an exploitative political reality. The gold fringe on the U.S. flag in courtrooms indicates, according to some sovereign citizens, the jurisdiction of maritime law, though to others it is a mark of the jurisdiction of a foreign power, and to yet others the fringe indicates a state of war and the suspension of law that results therefrom. Such diversity holds true, too, when it comes to aspects such as racist ideology and specific conspiracy theories: some sovereign citizens imagine a Jewish or Catholic conspiracy controlling the corrupt U.S. government while others are avowedly anti-racist, even arguing that race itself is a controlling fiction imposed to shatter the potential unity of “We the People.”

This diversity leads to confusion only when the movement is reductively described on the basis of some of its adherents. William Gale espoused Christian Identity, the white supremacist form of Christian theology that identifies Jews as literal descendants of Satan and thus inhuman; contemporary sovereign citizen author and speaker Johnny Liberty, however, embraces an egalitarian outlook, identifying racial divisions as a weapon of governmental oppression and supporting such seemingly diverse causes as the release of the Montana Freeman “political prisoners” and the release of American Indian Movement activist Leonard Peltier, the dignity of transgender individuals and the need to shut down the U.S.-run detention center at Guantanamo Bay (Liberty 2022:179, 173). Liberty quotes Malcolm X alongside Donald Trump as part of his construction of a genealogy of American sovereignty, a struggle of citizens against the corruption of a legal system that has abandoned divine law. Sovereign citizen ideology seeks to wake citizens up to their true freedom, to offer them a “red pill” in the imagery from the film The Matrix, often cited in sovereign citizen literature.

As part of this desire to escape the misinformation foisted on citizens by the corrupt government, sovereign citizens believe that hidden meanings can be discerned within language and symbols, particularly legal discourse and courtroom protocol. Thus, the fringe on the flag of the identification of a lawyer as esquire has significance, revealing the falseness of the legal claims advanced by the court. The urgency of such epistemological work, the work of figuring out what is real law, is coupled with an insistence that every citizen is able “to practice law, or to exercise your Rights” (Kilam 2024:np) The elitism of institutional legal education is rejected in favor of a responsibility of all citizens to do their own research and learn the truth about law and legal practice. Such truth can include the idea that one’s written name can only refer to a legal fiction, as argued by a man sometimes known as Ernie Wayne Tertegtle, but self-identified as the Natural Living Man. This argument, that the act of naming is a technique of state power, an attempt to label the aforesaid named individual and, thus, control him, leads to confusion in the courtroom but serves as an opportunity for performance of one’s distinct individuality, one’s true identity as a “living man, whose mark is that of life. It is called a signature, and the nature of that sigil is the living person. It is never in capital letters.” (“Tertelgte hearing” 2013).

Other sovereign citizens express this anxiety about the ineluctable nature of the self in other ways. Some sovereign citizens put trademark signs next to their names or change their names, often to something unpronounceable. [Image at right] Another common practice is to write “all rights reserved” across state-issued documents. As one sovereign citizen thinker explains is, “The only way a state Citizen may rid his Personam of the corporate status is to refute its very existence with a reservation of Rights.” (Dixon 2004:30) Writing “all rights reserved” functions as a formula to resist state capture and insist upon the uniqueness (and liberty) of the individual. The Living Nature Man, for his part, signs documents, when he does so, in red ink and with a thumbprint, reference to and image of organic markers of distinction. Such practice is also common among sovereign citizens, insisting upon their status as living person rather than legal fiction.

As a sovereign citizen cannot be named, so too they cannot be represented in court. The Natural Living Man explains this by reference to vernacular etymology, the word represent means re-presented, emphasizing a distance from the immediacy of his living self. “I have to speak for myself,” he attempts to explain in one hearing, a recording of which has been posted online, “No one else is capable of doing it.” Such etymological work seeks to reveal nefarious, semi-hidden meanings in language. The Living Natural Man characterizes his own (distinctive) way of speaking as “natural living man’s English” in contrast to the “Latin” lurking always behind the official discourse of the legal system, which he dismisses as “legalese,” language meant to ensnare less skilled thinkers into surrendering their rights. (“Raw footage” 2013)

Connected to the belief in hidden significance is the belief that there are equally concealed traps everywhere: in documents issued by the state, in the language commonly used to greet and interact with government officials, in something as simple as answering to a name. Sovereign citizens recognize that we live in a world characterized by unfreedom; they identify such traps as means by which the vast majority of citizens have, unwillingly and unconsciously, surrendered their natural sovereignty. Thus, everyday language becomes a battlefield, a site of struggle against state control.

Even the name “sovereign citizen” is contested within the movement, largely because it has become a criminalizing term, a category by which journalists, watchdog groups, and law enforcement can neatly label attempts at vernacular legal interpretation and practice. As sovereign citizen practices are intended to escape control by powerful institutions or hegemonic discourses, the name “sovereign citizen” is often rejected by those such labeled. In one well-publicized (both by outside media and by the sovereign group itself, which live-streamed the event) confrontation with law enforcement, a group called Rise of the Moors, armed with automatic rifles and wearing military-style uniforms, presented police with photocopies of legal decisions to support their argument that they were foreign nationals travelling peacefully through United States territory. Notably, this group also insisted, both to police and in their own media releases following the arrest of some of their members, that they were “not sovereign citizens.” While some sovereigns insist upon the term, as an accurate description of their status, others, like the Rise of the Moors, are wary that the term merely connotes criminal activity and leads to dismissal of legal arguments advanced by sovereign citizens as fraudulent and unworthy of serious consideration.

Two final beliefs are a faith in the possibility of near-absolute freedom and a similarly utopian belief that the legal system of the government, however corrupt and fallen from true law, possesses, nonetheless, some potential receptibility for the truth. This individual freedom has been stripped away by the corrupt system and so exercise of freedom is itself a form of rebellion. Likewise, protest in courts is seen as an appeal to authorities that, however corrupt and in the service of oppression, recognize the vocabulary and give lip service to the ideals of “law.” These beliefs underlie sovereign citizen legal practice, such that a sovereign citizen can interrupt a judge, who threatens to hold him in contempt of court, and shout back with sovereign fury: “You are in contempt of law!” (Court Cam 2023)

RITUALS/PRACTICES

The central ritual practices of the sovereign citizen movement are practices of law, performances of vernacular interpretations of law in conflicts with recognized state authorities. This can happen in encounters with law enforcement officers or via correspondence with IRS officials, but such practices also happen in court. It is important to understand the courts as contested spaces for sovereign citizens. They are, after all, part of a corrupt institution (but also as sacred spaces) places set aside for discussion of and under the name of law. Courts are, then, a privileged place to testify to the supposed truth of sovereign citizen claims. While court practices vary widely, one sovereign citizen handbook (titled, succinctly and seductively, Freedom from Government) offers a template for how to proceed, as sovereign, in the courtroom:

Before you get into the questions with the judge, you need to have first declared that you are there for the matter (your response to their calling THE name), rebutted all presumptions (declared the mistake), and declared no proper notice (no contract, no meeting of the minds), and then declared your honorable intentions to help settle the matter.

THEN question, question, question, non-rebuttable statement, question, question, non-rebuttable statement, question, question, non-rebuttable statement, question, question, question, question, question till the other side drops into dishonor or the judge decides you are never going to crack and create controversy or go into dishonor. It is at this point that you will see the true reality and the court will likely zero the account whilst making up some plausible reason to dismiss the case without spooking the public gallery (Goodbaudy 2013:30).

Such courtroom practice is often dismissed as mere harassment, though scholars should give close readings to individual encounters. Likewise dismissed as mere harassment is what is often labeled “paper terrorism,” the filing of liens and the weaponization of tax forms or the imposition of unilateral contracts. For instance, a sovereign citizen might insist that a targeted official has entered into a contract with the sovereign citizen and providing them with paperwork that contains “fee schedules” due to the sovereign. Such practices serve to harass targeted individuals but also emphasize the willingness of sovereign citizens to exercise what they understand to be their expertise with legal instruments. Central to the sovereign citizen movement is a faith that the courts and the legal system can be reclaimed and thus reformed by those who understand and practice true law. Sovereign citizen legal practice is thus practical in the short term (attempting to, say, get out of a traffic violation charge or, via filing of liens, harass and discourage an opponent) but eschatological in the long term (devoted to restoring God’s vision for the United States, uniting the legal system with divine and natural law).

Another practice to be considered is the occupation of property through recourse to legal interpretations. This can be done on a spectacular scale, as when two of rancher Cliven Bundy’s sons occupied the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge in Oregon with an arsenal of weapons, or in ways intended to escape the notice of authorities, like home seizures by Moorish sovereign citizen groups or the claiming of a New Orleans home by a Washitaw-related group in 2016.

A final practice widely shared within the sovereign citizen movement is the production of media, ranging from libraries of often self-published handbooks explaining sovereign citizen theory and practice to the publication, online, of video recordings of such practice. The Natural Living Man, for instance, far from existing off-grid, is devoted to posting his own encounters with the legal system and to sitting for interviews with sympathetic sovereign citizen journalists. He is very much an activist, and while he struggles for recognition of his own rights under universal law (the ability to hunt and fish or travel in a motor vehicle without a license, for instance), he also seeks to teach others about their own rights and how to, likewise, fight for them in court. In an interview, the Living Man explains that the reason he posts clips of his legal actions on social media is so that “the corruption of the courts [can] be revealed.” His desire is to “peacefully effect radical change” both through his own legal practices and by spreading his worldview to others who will join him in this struggle (White 2023).

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

While occasionally leaders arise of specific communities (like the Montana Freemen) and popular thinkers and authors (or “gurus” as they are sometimes termed by outsiders) exert influence over wide audiences, the sovereign citizen movement is, by definition, leaderless. Indeed, central to sovereign citizen logic is an emphasis on individual responsibility to research and learn, an epistemological sovereignty that responds to the perception of elite control of language and protocol in courtrooms, for instance, with an assurance that every citizen can become a legal expert and speak the truth of the law. While sovereign citizens share broad patterns of worldview (emphasizing true law’s guarantee of individual sovereignty, and practice), including the range of legal performances compiled in the sections above, such through is constantly being revised and innovated upon by individual thinkers. Many of these are publishing their own work through various means, notably self-published books and digital publications, the latter including recordings of confrontations with law enforcement or court officials.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

That sovereign citizens testify to true law (God’s law, natural law) in situations controlled by other legal regimes presents the major challenge for the movement. The existing legal order (the institutions devoted to interpreting and enforcing laws, from police to judges to the IRS) exists in contrast to the utopian worldview of sovereign citizen legal imaginings. For those sovereign citizens set on some form of secession from the state in order to achieve their freedom (whether on the local level, like the Montana Freeman’s “Justus Township” as a separate political order, or merely in protest of the federal, as when Cliven Bundy insisted on the “sovereign state of Nevada”), such claims, obviously, put sovereign citizens in conflict with layers of political and legal authority with armed force at their disposal. Yet while watchdog groups like the Southern Poverty Law Center tend to frame the threat of this movement in terms of isolated acts of violence perpetrated by those who hold sovereign citizen beliefs, the more immediate risk is probably to sovereign citizens themselves, who are misled by those who use sovereign theories as part of financial scams and are encouraged by collective thinking to behave in encounters with law enforcement and courts in ways that will only lead to greater risk of punishment. The driving desire of the sovereign citizen movement represents a core ideal (and tension) within US politics and society. The promise of self-determination, the ability to be “free,” coupled with the idea of “law” as that which is equivalent with truth and justice, universally applicable, are the beliefs at the root of this movement. Such ideals, alongside the crushing reality of economic hardship under an exploitative financial system and recognition of the deep history of injustice supported by the institutionalized legal system, lead to real discontent with a government seen as abandoning its higher calling. As long as God’s natural law (synonymous with justice and the good) is seen as neglected by the legal system, sovereign citizens will surely continue their struggle.

This broad moral vision, that the legal should align with true law, has led to the spread of sovereign citizen practices across the globe, as has the power that can be claimed by individuals who mobilize such teaching for their own benefit, either to exert authority and derive financial benefit from others (as in the case, recently, of the self-described “Queen of Canada”). The other great appeal to sovereign citizen logic and practices, however, is the possibility of exception from restrictive government policies, whether taxes or, more recently, vaccine and mask mandates related to the Covid-19 pandemic.

One handbook for use in the United Kingdom summarizes a basic stance uniting the diverse global spread of sovereign citizen thought and practice: “I DO NOT CONSENT to be governed, ruled, forced or policed.” (lioness 2011:24) This desire for individual freedom is the driving force behind all sovereign citizen thought and practice.

IMAGES

Image #1: Illustrative Sovereign Citizen designed license plate.
Credit: Wiki Commons, Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0.
Image #2: Cliven Bundy. Credit: Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.0 Generic license. Photo by Gage Skidmore.
Image #3: Billboard disclaiming legal names. Credit: Wiki Commons, Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

REFERENCES

“Court Cam: Sovereign Citizen Wears ‘No Trespassing’ Sign, Fights Court Officers.” 2023. A&E, January 22. Accessed from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dNUXicpSPZQ on 1 March 2025.

Cox, Shawna. 2014. Last Rancher Standing: The Cliven Bundy Saga, a Close-up View. Legends Library.

Dixon, William. 2004. Sovereign Covenant: ‘Without Prejudice” UCC 1-207, Self-published.

Goodbaudy, Trent. 2013. Freedom from Government: Acting with Honor and as King. Self-published.

“Jim White With Ernie wayne ter telgte, talking on corporations, exposing evil & deception with Truth.” 2023. The Sheep of the Good Shepard 26, January 25. Accessed from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z0g9u2RtmEg on 1 March 2025.

Kilam, Don. 2024. From Citizen to Sovereign: Understanding Political Status. Private Institute Academy Publishing.

Liberty, Johnny. 2022. Sovereign’s Handbook. Volume 1: Sovereignty & Power. Liberty International Foundation.

lioness, the. 2011. So, they say you’ve broken the law…: Challenging Legal Authority. Self-published.

“Raw footage of Ernie Wayne Tertelgte in Three Forks Justice Court,” 2013, KBZK Bozeman Montana News, November 1. Accessed from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_LwR0c-CE5g on 1 March 2025.

Riezinger, Anna Maria and James Clinton Belcher. 2014, You Know Something is Wrong When… ‘An American Affidavit of Probable Cause.’ Self-published.

Robinson, David E., 2009, Reclaim Your Sovereignty: Take Back Your Christian Name. Maine Patriot.

“Tertelgte hearing raw footage, Nov. 22, 2013,” KBZK Bozeman Montana News, November 22. Accessed from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RbVWY_dQQoc on 1 March 2025.

Publication Date:
2 March 2025

Share

Spencer Dew

Spencer Dew is Associate Teaching Professor in the departments of Comparative Studies and African American and African Studies at the Ohio State University. His most recent book is The Aliites: Race and Law in the Religions of Noble Drew Ali (University of Chicago Press, 2019). He is short revi

Spencer Dew is Associate Teaching Professor in the departments of Comparative Studies and African American and African Studies at the Ohio State University. His most recent book is The Aliites: Race and Law in the Religions of Noble Drew Ali (University of Chicago Press, 2019). He is short review editor for Religious Studies Review.

 

Share