Richard Wolff

Richard Wolff is the author of Fight Sports and the Church: Boxing and Martial Arts Ministries in America (North Carolina: McFarland Press, 2021). He is Professor and Chair of Communication and Visual Arts at Valparaiso University in Indiana, and previously served as Professor of Speech, Media Studies and Religious Studies at Dowling College on Long Island, New York. He holds a Ph.D. in Mass Communication from Ohio University, an S.T.M. in Church History from the Lutheran Theological Seminary at Philadelphia, and an M.A. in Theology and Communication from the Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago. He is a boxer, and advises and trains the boxing club at Valparaiso University.

Share

Fight Sports Ministries

FIGHT SPORTS MINISTRIES TIMELINE

1869:  The New York branch of the Young Men’s Christian Association (YMCA) opened as the first “Y” location planned primarily for fitness activities, including boxing.

1912:  Rev. Frederick Wedge, known as “The Fighting Parson,” published his semi-autobiographical novel The Fighting Parson of Barbary Coast.

1930:  The Catholic Youth Organization (CYO), with its renowned annual boxing tournaments, began in Chicago.

1986:  Jack Butler published a novel in the Southern literature tradition titled Jujitsu for Christ.

1994:  The Christian Karate Association’s schools, with various locations, opened.

2003:  The Rock Ministry of Calvary Chapel in Kensington, Pennsylvania, with its inner-city boxing program, started.

2005:  Mark Galli, former editor of the flagship evangelical magazine Christianity Today, published an opinion piece in that periodical which argued that boxing, as a sport of tightly controlled and expertly restrained violence, is ennobling and redeeming, noting that Biblical violence itself is often related to redemptive acts.

2005:  Victory Boxing Club in Omaha, Nebraska, founded by a former gang member to keep youth out of trouble, opened.

2008:  Trinity Martial Arts Club of Praise Lutheran Church in Fort Wayne, Indiana, with its balance of self-defense and Bible training, was founded.

2009:  A website called “fightpastor.com,” a blog devoted to discussing mixed martial arts, was created by a minister as a Christian outreach to the mixed martial arts (MMA) community.

2010:  The New York Times ran a front-page story (“Flock is Now a Fight Team”) about evangelical Christian mixed martial arts ministries and their leaders.

2010:  The Catholic Charities Teen Center at St. Peter’s Church in Dorchester, Massachusetts began its boxing program.

2012:  Boxing for Christ, a San Jacinto, California non-profit boxing program aimed at providing youth a positive alternative to bad influences, was founded.

2012:  Concord Karate Club of Concordia Lutheran Church in Fort Wayne, Indiana began.

2014:  Fight Church, a documentary about pastors who practice mixed martial arts and lead MMA ministries in their congregations, was released. The documentary significantly elevated public awareness of fight sports ministries and their related issues.

2014:  Christian Today published an article about a pastor’s MMA-based “fight ministry” as an effort to counter a “feminized” church.

2014:  The New York Times published an opinion piece and video documentary produced by the directors of Fight Church, addressing the phenomenon of church-based martial arts ministries and, among other things, their effort to combat a “feminized” church.

2014:  The Christian Boxing Academy in Jersey City, New Jersey was founded by a police lieutenant and former amateur boxer.

2016:  SonRise Church opened its Church Street Boxing program in Salem, Oregon. The gym-like facility included space to train, alongside space to worship.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

The phenomenon of fight sports ministries began as parts of large-scale national or city-wide organizations, and has over time become mainly the work of individual, local ministries.

Early on, the Young Men’s Christian Association (YMCA, or “Y”) established programs offering physical activity for its participants, to complement its multipronged mission to help those in need, evangelize, and provide opportunities for character building. The New York branch of the Y, opened in 1869, was the first location planned primarily for fitness activities with a well-appointed facility, including boxing equipment (Baker 2007:46-51). Dedicated to ministering to the whole person, the Y’s “four-fold program” sought to develop its participants spiritually, mentally, socially, and physically (Weier 2016:166). Over time, the YMCA deemphasized its evangelical focus in favor of providing more general community services. Still, its programs have included those in boxing, with more and more nowadays including training in martial arts. Similarly, the Chicago chapter of the Catholic Youth Organization (CYO) began its world-famous boxing tournament for similar reasons as the Y’s, but also to raise the profile of the Catholic church. Under the direction of Bishop Bernard J. Sheil, the CYO developed its renowned boxing program, hosting thousands of young boxers and spectators at its annual CYO boxing tournaments. Intended to promote ideals of Christian character through athletic achievement, and thus to combat inner city juvenile delinquency, the CYO also raised the national profile of the Catholic church, helped assimilate immigrants, and fostered integration (Neary 2016). The boxing program was a significant success, lasting through Sheil’s retirement in 1954. Programs such as those of the YMCA and CYO were successful in their use of boxing and martial arts to help achieve religious, social and institutional goals.

In more recent decades, fight sports ministry programs have been the province of local efforts, be these of individual churches, dioceses, community centers, or local civic-minded leaders. In fact, one estimate places the number of mixed martial arts ministries in U.S. evangelical churches alone at more than 700 (Watson and Bolt 2015). Such programs vary in terms of their athletic and religious practices; but all make effective use of popular athletic activities, such as martial arts and boxing programs, to reach those in need, bring followers to a religious organization, and/or reach out to those already in a church to strengthen their engagement. What is most remarkable is the variety of backgrounds of the founders of fight sports ministry organizations.

We find among fight sports ministry founders concerned parents, such as Sonia Ramos of Boxing for Christ in San Jacinto, who started her ministry after moving from a city where a similar boxing program helped keep her own children out of trouble. Finding no such club in her new city, she created one, and Ramos’s own children box in the program. A USA Boxing (the official national organization for amateur boxing) certified club, Ramos says it was her calling to start Boxing for Christ as a program to teach youth “self-defense, discipline and self- esteem.” Having reached more than 700 boxers, with thirty-five to forty participating daily, the program is somewhat rare in its being headed by a woman.

Other founders are ex-gang members and drug enforcement agents. Exemplifying the former is a past gang member who served time in a federal prison for drug-related offenses, Rev. Servando Perales, and who began Victory Boxing Club in Omaha, Nebraska. [Image at right] The program was first held in his garage and later in a warehouse, after receiving support from local law officers and members of the community. Upon being released from prison, Perales became a minister and, remembering the positive outlet boxing provided him as a youth, felt called to begin a boxing ministry and community center. A faith-based program, Rev. Perales emphasizes Christian values for the youth who participate, offering weekly Bible studies and praying with those who need it.

As for police officers who helped found boxing ministries, an example is retired Drug Enforcement Agency agent and former heavyweight boxing champ Paul Doyle. He and a priest, Father Richard Conway, began a boxing program at The Catholic Charities Teen Center at St. Peter’s Church in Dorchester, Massachusetts, later run by the Colonel Marr Boys & Girls Club under some of the same leadership. Providing an opportunity to counsel youth and help them develop discipline to avoid trouble, this particular outreach did not emphasize religious activity, such as prayer and Bible study. Another example is Cristino Felix, a Lieutenant in the Jersey City Police Department and former amateur boxer, who founded The Christian Boxing Academy in Jersey City, New Jersey. Providing a safe outlet for youth who might otherwise get in trouble on the streets, the after-school boxing program was based upon Christian values, and emphasized character development. While The Christian Boxing Academy was open to youth of all faiths, Felix would nonetheless share inspiring scriptural passages with participants, as well as pray with them. The program ended in 2019 when Felix moved to Texas, where he hopes to begin a similar program.

Still other founders are ministers, such as Pastor Brandon Beals of Canyon Creek Church in Washington; Pastor J. Brown of two Lutheran churches in Fort Wayne, Indiana; and Pastor Mark Morrow of SonRise Church in Salem, Oregon. Pastor Beals, nicknamed the “Fight Pastor,” of Canyon Creek Church in Washington (now Venture Church) began a website called “fightpastor.com,” a blog devoted to discussing mixed martial arts. Beals said on the site that his mission was to be “an ambassador for Christ to the MMA community and to be an ambassador for MMA to the Christian culture.” Canyon Creek would host MMA fight parties, where men would watch televised matches at the church (Schneiderman 2021).

Pastor Brown began Trinity Martial Arts Club of Praise Lutheran Church in Fort Wayne, Indiana complementing physical training with spiritual and personal growth. Teaching self-defense and preparing youth and adults for competitions and tournaments, the program included Bible study, prayer, devotions and scripture memorization. Brown also founded and led Concord Karate Club of Concordia Lutheran Church in Fort Wayne. A similar program to the other, it combined training in faith and karate for self-control and discipline. Brown envisioned the two ministries as outreach to those whom the church might not otherwise reach.

A final example is Pastor Mark Morrow, who led SonRise Church and opened the Church Street Boxing program in Salem, Oregon. The facility had space on one side devoted to boxing, with a ring, heavy bags and other training equipment; and on the other side, a worship space, with a lectern and room for musicians. Set within a church conceived as a ministry for all, including those with addictions or who were gang members or homeless, the boxing program included participants of all ages, but mostly teen-agersd to young adults. The ministry was multifaceted in its appeals: while Morrow offered worship on Sunday mornings, some of the boxers participated, while others did not; and not all of the worshipers boxed.

One pastor-founded fight sports ministry that included various locations (including Post Falls, Coeur d’ Alene; Moscow, Idaho; and Byram, Mississippi) was The Christian Karate Association’s schools, begun by Rev. Steve Wilson, an associate pastor in Idaho. With locations around the world, the CKA approach has combined training in Christian discipleship with that of martial arts, balancing spiritual and physical mentorship. Its program has emphasized character development based upon a dozen principles taught year round, derived from Christian teachings and those of martial arts.

Finally, founders of fight sports ministries include concerned former amateur and professional fighters themselves, such as Cristino Felix (discussed above) and Golden Gloves’ Buddy Osborne of Calvary Chapel’s The Rock Ministry in Kensington, Pennsylvania. The Rock Ministry’s goal is to reach youth before they get into trouble on the streets, and to stop existing juvenile offenders from returning to trouble. Originally geared to boys and young men, the ministry now extends to girls and young women as well. Co-founder Osborne, a Golden Gloves champion who worked with juvenile offenders, works with pastors to provide participants with a place to train, do homework, and engage weekly Bible studies. The program is free and USA Boxing certified. (Wolff 202l: passim, for all outlined ministries, unless otherwise cited.)

The religious affiliations of the founders of fight sports ministries range from Catholic to mainline and evangelical protestant. Their forms include karate, mixed martial arts, jiu-jitsu and boxing. And their aims range from character development and social outreach, to evangelism, and providing masculine programs to what some perceive as a feminized church. Beyond such variety, what these fight sports ministry founders and leaders have in common is their fondness for boxing and martial arts, and an interest in using fight sports to attract participants to church and other religious programs.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Individual fight sports ministry programs may trace their theological lineage back to the muscular Christianity or social gospel movements.

Begun in England in the mid-nineteenth century and reaching the United States not long thereafter, the muscular Christianity faction believes the church has become too feminized and, both to reclaim a masculine identity for the church and appeal to more “traditional” men, its adherents accentuate models of church identity and practice that reinforce a masculine character for the church and its programs, particularly via sport and athletics. Among its philosophical proponents are Thomas Hughes, who wrote 1887’s The Manliness of Christ, a treatise about Jesus’ masculinity, and Tom Brown’s Schooldays (1857), a novel which explicitly advocates for young Christian men to learn boxing (Wolff 2021:78-81). Similarly, evangelist Billy Sunday, who once proclaimed that “Jesus was the greatest scrapper that ever lived,” explicitly distanced himself from “effeminate, sissified, three-carat Christianity” in favor of “the manliest” men who have the guts to follow Jesus (Prothero 2003:94). This approach to Christian ecclesiology and discipleship, highlighting masculine qualities of the church and encouraging masculine forms of character building in sports and other programs, motivates some fight sport ministries. Examples of these are chronicled in Daniel Junge and Bryan Storkel’s documentary Fight Church (2014), which includes interviews with church leaders and others involved in debates about the ethics of fight sports, and a perceived need to appeal to men by creating a masculine identity for the church. Similar debates and motivations are chronicled in ministries discussed in a front-page New York Times article on fight sports ministries (“Flock is Now a Fight Team in Some Ministries”) and in a Christian Today article on Paul Burress, an associate pastor at Rochester’s Victory Church (“Pastor’s ‘fight ministry’ incorporates mixed martial arts; sees it as a counter to ‘feminised’ church”). The use of fight sports ministries to appeal to men and promote a masculine appeal for the church has thus received considerable media attention.

Also influencing some fight sports ministry programs is the social gospel movement. It aimed to create a more just society by addressing social challenges affecting individuals via creating ethical pronouncements, policy advocacy and institutional programs designed to minister to the whole person’s needs, not just the spiritual. Arising in the late nineteenth century and peaking in the early twentieth, the legacy of the movement’s concerns still influence many churches and organizations today in their focus on institutional responses to societal ills and those adversely affected by social conditions (Evans 2017:2-4, 227). These concerns and goals find expression in some fight sports ministries’ attempts to help youth, particularly those in urban centers, avoid the influences of drugs, gangs and crime, and avert undesired involvement with law enforcement and correctional institutions by not only providing positive, supportive programs, but also ones that involve physical activity and play, thereby appealing to the “whole” individual’s needs, not just the spiritual (Wolff 2021:30-31). Ministries such as The Rock Ministry of Calvary Chapel in Kensington, Pennsylvania; Victory Boxing Club in Omaha, Nebraska; Boxing for Christ in San Jacinto, California; and the Church Street Boxing program of SonRise Church in Salem, Oregon, fit this bill.

Finally, fight sports ministry programs are founded on the expectation that they offer opportunities for fellowship and evangelism. To strengthen ties between congregants or believers, and attract newcomers to a church or independent faith-based sports ministry, are among the goals of martial arts and boxing programs. These efforts are not without challenge, as among the issues that arise in such ministries is the extent to which competition among Christians and the pursuit of victory among those who should otherwise work together as fellow disciples may compromise Christian ideals. Other ethical concerns include fight sports’ placing the body, a gift from God, at risk of being damaged in more aggressive forms of fight sports practice. Arguably, providing appropriate approaches are taken, such challenges may be adequately addressed and, as we will see, met for those with ethical and theological concerns about fight sports ministries’ practices (Wolff 2021:164-165).

RITUALS/PRACTICES

While all fight sports ministries involve training techniques, drills, and exercises, they vary in the degree to which religious practice is involved. Some only claim a religious affiliation by name, while others offer group prayer, Bible study, and even worship services. For example, the Catholic Charities Teen Center and Boys and Girls Club of Dorchester did not emphasize religious practice aside from counselling, while the Victory Boxing Club of Omaha, Rock Ministry of Calvary Chapel in Kensington and others regularly offer prayer and Bible study. Some, such as Trinity Martial Arts Club of Praise Lutheran Church and the Christian Karate Association, have added even more religious practice, such as offering devotions, expecting scripture memorization and providing other types of Christian education. SonRise Church of Salem, Oregon even held worship services in the same facility in which it engaged fight sports training (Wolff 2021:passim).

In addition, it is noteworthy that religious iconography finds expression in many fight sports ministry logos. For instance, a cross figures prominently in the Boxing for Christ and Christian Boxing Academy logos, both of which depict boxing gloves hanging from a cross. [Image at right]

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

That the founders of individual fight sport ministries almost always remain their ongoing leaders says something about the nature of this religious movement: that it is a labor of love for many, arising from their own interests and vision; that the continued success of the ministry often relies upon the dedication of the founder/leader; and that changes in the life circumstance of the leader may impact a fight sports ministry. So, for example, when Boxing for Christ’s founder and leader Sonia Ramos moved to a new city and discovered the need for a fight sports ministry, she established one. And as we’ve seen, when a ministry is part of a larger organization that transforms, such as with the boxing program that became part of the Boys and Girls Club of Dorchester, its continuation often relies upon the program originators to help it continue. When a founder/leader moves, as with Cristino Felix of New Jersey’s Christian Boxing Academy, a ministry may end, even as the possibility of opening a new fight sports ministry in the new location emerges. Some ministries are part of a broader organization, such as the Christian Karate Academy, which includes several individual programs under its charter; but even here, the founder, Rev. Steve Wilson, remains the driving force behind the association. In the end, the existence, character, success and fate of such ministries relies heavily on their founders/leaders (Wolff 2021:111-146).

While many boxing ministry programs are members of USA Boxing, the non-profit national boxing organization overseeing Olympic-style amateur boxing, there is currently no overarching organization, national or local, that advocates for and serves the collective needs of individual fight sport ministries.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Given the way many see the Christian church’s character (as an institution that rightly promotes love, care for others, and contemplation of the spiritual) fight sports’ association with aggression, competition, and in some practices potential the harm of the body leads some to question fight sports ministries as appropriate endeavors for churches and believers. This tension is reflected in treatments of boxing and Christianity in general, and fight sports ministries in particular, in popular culture. Hence in literature, Thomas Hughes’ writings (discussed above) address this matter in favor of celebrating a depiction of Christian masculinity that is prepared to fight to meet a challenge or slight. Charles Dickens paints a similar portrait of a good-natured but at-the-ready Christian pugilist in his depiction of Rev. Septimus Chrisparkle of The Mystery of Edwin Drood (1870), writing of him that a “soft-hearted benevolence beamed from his boxing gloves.” Harvard-educated American boxer-turned-minister Rev. Frederick Wedge, known as “The Fighting Parson,” addressed this balance in his semi-autobiographical novel The Fighting Parson of Barbary Coast (1912) in which the protagonist, after killing a man in a ring, is advised by a cleric to consider turning to ministry, saying “I knew that your work in the ring would help you see many things in the right way. Life is a battle. Even the struggle for culture and religion is a warfare.” Thus in true muscular Christian fashion, the hero’s character, forged as a boxer, is deemed an asset to his pursuit of ministry. The Fighting Parson uses his boxer’s grit to address social problems, protect the innocent, and help the needy. Finally, Jack Butler’s Jujitsu for Christ (1986), a work of Southern literature set in Mississippi’s era of desegregation with all its racial tension, features a young, simple-minded-but-sincere martial artist who opens a studio in which he not only teaches people how to fight, but also “flips” them for Christ. An occasional preacher, the protagonist responds to an inquiry about what topic he speaks on at churches by saying “Self-defense and Jesus, mostly” (Wolff 2021:57-63).

Fictional television and film have also addressed the issue of how to involve fight sports in Christian life and ministry. In TV, the long-running Korean War set series M*A*S*H’s (1972-1983) soft-spoken Jesuit priest, Father Mulcahy, was a regular advocate for peace, but also a boxer who became a coach for the Catholic Youth Organization. Similarly, based on the true story of Father Edward J. Flanagan, the movie Boys Town (1938) finds its featured cleric skilled in boxing, and encouraging boys in his charge to not only learn the sport, but also use the ring to solve conflicts. In The Bells of St. Mary’s (1945), Ingred Bergman plays a nun who, while wearing her habit, teaches a bullied boy how to box to defend himself if necessary, while also suggesting that it is best not to fight, if you can. Her conversations with a priest (played by Bing Crosby) explicitly respond to muscular Christianity’s tenets and concerns about a “feminized church”; she replies to the Father’s insistence that boys must learn to fight with her counterpoint that the superior way is to think matters through. The tension between encouraging self-defense and peaceful restraint is depicted in her attempt to train her young protégé to avoid fighting if possible, yet approving response when he defends himself against a bully. The nun beams with delight when the boy follows his act of self-defense with the peacemaking gesture of offering to buy his would-be assailant an ice cream cone. Focusing on fight sports’ emphasis on character building, Kid Monk Baroni (1952) finds a priest using a parish boxing program to teach gang members to better channel their anger, leading one talented boxer (who also enjoys singing in the church choir) to pursue a boxing career, only to lose a big fight in which he nevertheless raises money for a parish recreation center. He learns that winning isn’t everything… and sacrifice can be a form of penance. A spin-off TV series to Walker, Texas Ranger (1993-2001), Sons of Thunder (1999) finds a “preacher’s kid” and former army combat instructor opening a martial arts studio that teaches Biblical principles, and serves as a base for his own crime fighting business; with it, he helps those in need, only resorting to physical violence when necessary. He refuses to use a gun as too-lethal of a weapon, favoring the sole use of his martial arts skills. Finally, the film The Boxer (1997) depicts a former Irish Republican Army operative and pugilist opening up a boxing gym for youth, where he teaches both Catholic and protestant young men during “the Troubles” in Northern Ireland, and fights those using terrorist violence to further divisive goals. He is thus both a strong and peace-loving Christian fighter and fight sports ministry leader (Wolff 2021:63-74). In most of these fictional works of film, TV and literature, the apparent tension between being a Christian involved in fight sports is highlighted and ultimately resolved as each peace-loving apostle only fights when necessary.

As for non-fictional representations of fight sports and the church, both the documentary film Fight Church and the New York Times articles on the phenomenon (discussed above) demonstrate a national media tendency to focus on more sensational and controversial aspects of Christians involved in fight sports. So too does an opinion piece and short video documentary created by the directors of Fight Church that also appeared in the New York Times, titled “Pastor with a punch” (September 8, 2014). It begins with the question “Can you love your neighbor as yourself and at the same time knee him in the face as hard as you can?” and considers the issue of churches’ use of martial arts as a means to combat a feminized church. Amidst talk of the success of his ministry and opportunities it provides for fellowship and evangelism, the pastor at the piece’s center states that Christians need not necessarily be “sissies” and that Christ’s original disciples were “rough necks.” Similar issues are taken up by the news website The Conversation (“Mixed Martial Arts: Where feet, fists and faith collide,” and January 5, 2015) in an article that reflects on evangelistic and ethics matters at the heart of combining fight sports and Christianity; the article focuses on fight sports as a “masculine” spiritual pursuit, observing that MMA is a “manly expression of devotion.” Notably, more local coverage of workaday fight sports ministries, such as many of those outlined above, tend to focus less on controversy and more on the positive social outreach provided by such ministries (Wolff 2021:142-46).

Some theological issues reflected in contemplating the relation of fight sports to Christianity are bound up in broader treatments of the place of competitive sport in the life of Christians and the church. On this matter, Joseph L. Price (2001:15-38) developed a five category taxonomy of how engagement in sport by religions may be considered, finding this relationship to range from sport (1) being in conflict with, (2) commingling with, (3) conscripting, (4) co-opting, or (5) supplementing religion (Price 2001). Each of Price’s categories reflects particular ethical and theological concerns, as they consider various factors at play in the encounter between the two. Many fight sports ministries find themselves in the second category of commingling, which involves uses of sports for mission work or evangelical outreach. And yet, there are those that see the relation of fight sports with the church to fall into other categories, particularly that of being in conflict. Indeed, it is the apparent conflict of fight sports with church values that leads some to question its practice within church programs, and the media occasionally to sensationalize the meeting of the two. In fact, included among the abounding ethical and theological reflections on the relationship of fight sports to the church are well-grounded defenses of the practice of fight sports by the faithful, including in the context of the church. Regardless of the position taken, debates about such practice regularly invoke several theological issues that fight sports ministries face.

One issue concerns the treatment of the body. Christianity posits that humankind is created as imago dei, in the image of God, and is due respect in all its grandeur, seeing the body as a gift. Relatedly, this body is considered a temple, the dwelling place of God’s spirit, and thereby due reverence. Depending on the approach to fight sports as these are practiced, this sets up various ethical considerations. Inasmuch as physical activity may help maintain the body, training the body to work at its optimal capacity is caring for God’s gift. Indeed, training in forms that might help defend that body if attacked, be that one’s own or another’s, may also find theological support for the practice of fight sports, particularly if one pursues such defense only when needed. Where the theology of the body creates more challenges for fight sports is when harm is done to oneself or another. As Mark Galli, former editor of Christianity Today, wrote in an opinion piece in that publication, while it is true that the practice of many sports, including boxing, indulges in a celebration of violence both for participants and the audience, that which is practiced with masterful self-control and clear constraints (using gloves, timed rounds, recovery rules, and a referee’s presence and intervention) makes it not only acceptable but also ennobling and redemptive (in what others have called ritualized violence); indeed, further challenging the theological discussion, Galli observes that acts of Biblical redemption are often achieved through violence (Galli 2005). To be sure, amateur boxing and martial arts tournaments tend to be practiced with restraints and the well-being of participants in mind. Of greater concern is when such practice rises to the extremes of fight sports practice, such as in more competitive and professional matches, where theological and ethical concerns regarding honoring the body as imago dei and God’s temple most fully manifest.

Even so, in any sport, Christian theologians and ethicists acknowledge that one does not honor oneself or an opponent by not engaging in competition to the best of one’s ability. Here is where theologies of play come to bear on the practice of fight sports, particularly as a ministry. Theologians and ethicists of religion and sport, particularly from a Christian perspective, note that believers should ideally be about mutual support of each other, and reflect critically upon competition that pits believers against each other in a way that leads to victors and losers (Linville 2003; Hoffman 2010; Schafer 2015; Wolff 2021:90-110). Discussions of such matters critique engagements in sports competition that make winning and victory over another idolatrous, and praise those that emphasize Christian fellowship. Yet again, not to do one’s best and challenge both another and oneself is not honorable. Guidelines for the best practice of fight sports by Christians come from theologies of play, which suggest that participants should deemphasize the need for victory and dominance over another in favor of perceiving sport as a time for enjoyment, growth, friendship and fellowship. In short, theologies of play suggest the focus should ideally be more on delight in created good and mutual support, rather than outcome, dominance and conquest. So practiced, many suggest, fight sports ministries may properly be enjoyed without running afoul of theological and ethical concerns. Particularly given all the good they do (providing camaraderie, fitness, outreach to youth, and opportunities to learn and practice the Christian faith) those fight sports ministries that mindfully respond to such challenges may provide a meaningful though perhaps unconventional way to participate in fight sports in the context of the church (Wolff:160-62).

IMAGES

Image #1: Rev. Servando Perales (center, to the left of the ring post) leads a Bible study for young boxers at his Victory Boxing Club in Omaha, Nebraska. (Used by permission of Perales).
Image #2: The logo of Cristino Felix’s Christian Boxing Academy, including boxing gloves and the cross. (Used by permission of Felix).

REFERENCES

Baker, William J. 2007. Playing with God: Religion and Modern Sport. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Butler, Jack. 1986. Jujitsu for Christ. Atlanta: August House.

Evans, Christopher H. 2017. The Social Gospel in American Religion. New York: New York University Press.

Galli, Mark. 2005. “Punches, Smashes, and Bombs: Boxing Gives Us a Window into the Violence Inherent in All Sports.” Christianity Today, November 1.

Hoffman, Shirl James. 2010. Christianity and the Culture of Sports. Waco, TX: Baylor University Press.

Junge, Daniel and Bryan Storkel. 2014. “Pastor with a Punch.” New York Times, September 8.

Linville, Greg. 2003. “Ethics Competition in Church Setting.” Pp. 187-210 in Recreation and Sports Ministry: Impacting Postmodern Culture, edited by John Garner. Nashville, TN:  Broadman & Holman.

Marie, Brownie. 2014. “Pastor’s ‘Fight Ministry’ Incorporates Mixed Martial Arts; Sees it as Counter to ‘Feminised’ Church.” Christian Today, September 12.

Neary, Timothy B. 2016. Crossing Parish Boundaries: Race, Sports, and Catholic Youth in Chicago, 1914-1954. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Price, Joseph L. 2001. “From Sabbath Proscriptions to Super Sunday Celebrations: Sports and Religion in America.” Pp. 49-60 in From Season to Season: Sports as American Religion, edited by Joseph L. Price. Macon, GA: Mercer University Press.

Prothero, Stephen. 2003. American Jesus: How the Son of God Became a National Icon. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

Schneiderman, R.M. 2021. “Flock is Now a Fight Team.” The New York Times, February 1.

Shafer, Michael. 2015. Well Played: A Christian Theology of Sport and the Ethics of Doping. Eugene, OR: Pickwick Publications.

Watson, Nick and Bolt, Brian. 2015. “Mixed Martial Arts and Christianity: ‘Where Feet, Fist and Faith Collide’.” The Conversation, January 5.

Wedge, Frederick R. 1912. The Fighting Parson of Barbary Coast. Washington, D.C.: Frederick R. Wedge.

Weier, Jonathan.  2016. “The Building of Boys for War: The Militarization of Boys’ Work in the Canadian and American YMCAs.” In Children’s Literature and the Culture of the First World War, edited by Lissa Paul, Rosemary Ross Johnston, and Emma Short. New York: Routledge.

Wolff, Richard. 2021. Fight Sports and the Church: Boxing and Martial Arts Ministries in America. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.

Publication Date:
21 July 2025

 

Share

Kingdom of Jesus Christ

KINGDOM OF JESUS CHRIST TIMELINE

1950 (April 25):  Apollo Carreon Quiboloy was born in Davao City, Mindanao.

1964:  Quiboloy reported his first spiritual experiences.

1972:  Quiboloy graduated from the United Pentecostal Bible Institute.

1985:  Quiboloy left the United Pentecostal Church to found the group that would become the Kingdom of Jesus Christ (KOJC).

1991:  Quiboloy formed a gospel television program, The Hour of Truth, that broadcasted to various cities in the Philippines.

1995:  Quiboloy began preaching internationally.

1995:  Quiboloy established the Children’s Joy Foundation, Inc. as a charitable organization.

2000:  Quiboloy founded José María College, which he named after his parents.

2003:  KOJC was licensed by the government for television broadcasting across the Philippines.

2003 (September 13):  QuIboloy claimed to have been ushered into Sonship.

2006:  KOJC announced the formation of the Sonshine Media Network International (SMNI), which became the movements primary communication platform

2014 (June):  Quiboloy founded Sonshine Sports Management in Davao City.

2018 (June 17):  KOJC announced that Almighty Father had taken the name of His Appointed Son, Pastor Apollo C. Quiboloy, as His new Name.

2019 (August 31):  Philippine President Rodrigo Duerte signed legislation renewing SMNI’s broadcasting license for another twenty-five years.

2021 (November 11):  Prosecutors in the Central District of California U.S. Attorney’s Office indicted Quiboloy and several KOJC officials for conspiracy to conduct human and sex trafficking, money laundering, immigration fraud, and other charges.

2021:  The Philippine government responded to Quiboloy’s indictment with a statement that Quiloboy was a “private individual” and should defend himself in court.

2021:  Quiboloy warned his opponents that the COVID-19 epidemic would worsen if harassment and prosecution of him continued.

2022:  Ferdinand Marcos, Jr. became President of the Philippines; Sara Duerte was elected Vice President.

2022 (February 5):  The U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation released a wanted poster for Quiboloy.

2022 (December 10):  The U.S. Department of Treasure and Department of State imposed sanctions on Quiboloy for gross human rights abuses and corruption.

2023 (December):  A shutdown of KOJC’s broadcasting operations was ordered.

2024 (February 21):  Quiboloy released an audio recording stating that the Marcos family was plotting his assassination and announcing that he was going into hiding.

2024 (March 19):  The Senate of the Philippines issued an arrest warrant for Quiboloy. This was followed by a bounty offer from the Department of Interior and Local Government for information on his whereabouts on July 8.

2024 (July):  Philippine Vice President Sara Duerte resigned her positions as Secretary of Education and director of an anti-insurgence agency but retained here position as Vice President.

2024 (September 8):  Quiboloy was arrested and taken into custody by Philippine authorities.

2024 (October):  Quiboloy registered as a candidate for the Philippine Senate while being held in custody. His election bid was subsequently unsuccessful.

2024 (October):  Duerte registered his candidacy to run for mayor of the southern city of Davao. His election bid was subsequently unsuccessful.

2025 (January 18):  Quiboloy was hospitalized for pneumonia while in police custody.

2025 (March 12):   Duterte was surrendered to the custody of the International Criminal Court in The Hague.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Beginning around the 1980s, the 7,000 island archipelago nation of the Philippines witnessed the emergence of a number of influential indigenous religious movements growing out of Christianity. [Image at right] These included Iglesia ni Cristo, the Kingdom of Jesus Christ, Every Nation,and El Shaddai (Cornelio 2020; Philippine Statistics Authority 2023; Alba-Jones 2024). This profile focuses on the Kingdom of Jesus Christ, founded by Appollo Quiboloy.

Apollo Carreon Quiboloy was born in Davao City on April  25, 1950 to Kapampangan immigrant parents José Quiboloy y Turla and María Carreón y Sambat. He was the youngest of nine children (Gavilan 2024). Quiboloy’s father had been a member of the Christian and Missionary Alliance (which emerged in the U.S. out of the Holiness Movement in the late nineteenth century and emphasizes church planting and formation of foreign missions). Along with his four sons, José Quiboloy became influential in the United Pentecostal Church of the Philippines, an affiliate of the United Pentecostal Church International. During the 1970s, Apollo’s connection with United Pentecostal fluctuated as he became leader of its youth organization, was subsequently expelled for heretical teachings, and then reintegrated through his pastorship of the affiliated Agadao church. Finally, in 1985, again under fire, he left United Pentecostal along with fifteen followers to form the church that became the Kingdom of Jesus Christ (King 2016; Quiboloy 2018).

The early years in the movement’s development were difficult. As one early member recalls (Arevlo 2020):

We had no cars, no comfortable rooms to stay in. We left our life of comfort as young professionals and chose to follow in his footsteps,” she shares. “In those times of intense persecutions, hunger, and sacrifices, if you are not committed to your calling, you’d really choose to leave the ministry. As we slept on the bleachers of the Amoranto Stadium, Pastor Apollo would speak of great things, how one day, we would have our grand cathedral. How one day, he would bring all of us to different countries all over the world.

These initial challenges notwithstanding, the movement expanded very quickly under Quiboloy’s leadership. A strong, visible organizational base was created in the Philippines, and Quiboloy’s charismatic standing expanded correspondingly. In the 1990s, KOJC went international, and by 2018, Quiboloy was regularly traveling to the United States to monitor the church’s operations that he had established in California, Nevada and Hawaii. The initial signs of trouble for the movement emerged around 2020, and by 2024 the movement and its founder faced intense legal pressure [See, Issues/Challenges].

DOCTRINES/RITUALS

There are several key elements in KOJC doctrine. One is Oneness Pentecostalism, which rejects the concept of the Trinity. Rather, Oneness groups believe that God exists in two modes, as the Father in Heaven and as Jesus on earth, but He is only one entity. A second is prosperity gospel, the doctrine that God intends physical wellbeing and financial success for the faithful, and so professions of faith and thrust along with financial commitments to the church lead to both physical and material wellbeing (Medina and Cornelio 2021). A third is “serpent seed” doctrine. This doctrine asserts that the serpent mated with Eve in the Garden of Eden and produced Cain as their offspring; the result has been that an evil Cain lineage and righteous Adam lineage have been in conflict through human history.

Quiboloy draws on serpent seed to assert that all of humankind is now compromised by the “disobedient spirit of sin” and must repent (Quiboloy 2019):

Absolute and genuine repentance requires a surrender of the old spirit of rebellion and disobedience, that serpent seed of Satan, that was planted in the heart of mankind when Adam and Eve disobeyed God. It entails a dethroning of that old spirit and the enthroning a new one – the spirit of obedience to the Father’s Will.

But all of these plans were aborted when Satan deceived first Eve, and then Adam, in the Garden of Eden. The infant seed of righteousness and obedience that was in them was dislodged and ejected. And what replaced it in man’s heart was the serpent seed, that disobedient spirit of sin that is in now in every man, woman, and child born of the fallen race of Adam. In other words, in all of humankind.

Absolute and genuine repentance requires a surrender of the old spirit of rebellion and disobedience, that serpent seed of Satan, that was planted in the heart of mankind when Adam and Eve disobeyed God. It entails a dethroning of that old spirit and the enthroning a new one – the spirit of obedience to the Father’s Will.

In addition, Quiboloy has claimed that he is “the Appointed Son of God” as well as being “the Owner of the Universe. His website states (Quiboloy 2019):

Apollo C. Quiboloy was the first man to be called by the Father to the true and genuine repentance. He was the first man to have endured all the fiery trials of persecution and hardship and to have overcome them all without breaking his covenant with the Father. He was the first man to finally eject the serpent seed, breaking the chain of sin by his absolute obedience to the Father’s will…
It is for this reason that the Father anointed him and made him His Appointed Son in these last days. And by following in the life and example of Pastor Quiboloy, millions of sons and daughters are in the process of becoming appointed sons and daughters of God, like him…
Anybody who listens to him, believes and repents, will enter in the Kingdom of God on Earth today, and after judgment, unto eternity.

Since Quiboloy has pronounced himself the “Appointed Son of God,” those who follow him will enter in the Kingdom of God on Earth today, and after judgment, unto eternity” (Quiboloy 2019).

Quiboloy has expanded his charismatic status claims even further. In 2018, the movement announced that the Almighty Father had taken Quibiloy’s name as His name (Kingdom of Jesus Christ 2018). In addition, he stipulated that he possessed the final authorization (clearance) for salvation without which petitioners would not be granted redemption.

Quiboloy has also extended his charismatic claims through retroactive hagiography to create a seamless religious calling (Quiboloy 2018). For example, he recounts that when he was being born his mother saw God seated on a cloud and he said to her “That is my son.” In !964, he had a dream in which the world was in flames and utter chaos, which he subsequently interpreted as the Second Coming of Christ. He asserts that when he was attending a Billy Graham event in the 1970s that God whispered to him “I will use you.” Ten years later he launched KOJC upon recalling that statement when he experienced criticism from the Pentecostal Church of the Philippines.

This combination of doctrinal elements created an extremely powerful narrative base for the movement and for Quiboloy personally. These elements include the emergence of KOJC represents a final chapter in the biblical Garden of Eden saga, the acceptance by followers of their obligation to acknowledge their state of sinfulness and to seek redemption through Quiboloy, Quiboloy’s status as the Appointed Son of God as the sole source of this divinely ordained project, and the nationalistic implications of the Philippines being the launch point for divine restoration (Cornelio 2017:170; Ragragio 2023).

Ritualistic observances in KOJC include bible sessions and prayer services for members daily. Sunday services, Global Worship, are held in the Cathedral. In addition, there is a Sunday online service, Sounds of Worship. The church also hosts continuously available livestreaming services.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

The full title of KOJC is Kingdom of Jesus Christ: the Name Above Every Name. Congregational units are called Kingdom Light Congregations, and church members often refer to the church as Kingdom Nation.

Quiboloy has been undisputedly the central figure in KOJC both symbolically and instrumentally. [Image at right] He has regularly pronounced himself to be God’s Appointed Son and employs that status to direct the activities of movement members and movement organizations. He has created a network of movement organizations, centered in the new Jerusalem, that has achieved international reach and impact.

The KOJC organizational fifty-seven acre hub is located in Davao City. There are two major movement centers. Covenant Mountain Paradise Garden of Eden Restored, which is its prayer compound, and claims to be the “Healing Center of the World.” It also serves as Quiboloy’s official residence (Cornelio  175). The Cathedral is the center for religious rituals. The other major component is what is planned as the King Dome. Begun in 2012, this impressive structure is to accommodate a choir of 6,000, a 250-instrument orchestra, and a 50,000 audience capacity. Construction completion has been planned for 2025 (Cornelio 179-80).

The movement consists of a set of interrelated organizations that were developed beginning in the early 1990s. National and international online television programming was one of the major sources of KOJC reach and influence. In 1991, Quiboloy formed a gospel television program, The Hour of Truth, that broadcasted to various cities in the Philippines. This was followed by a 24-hour cable network, “The Q Channel,” in 2000, with an expansion to international coverage in 2003. Further developments led to Sonshine Media Network International (SMNI) in 2006, which became the movement’s primary communication platform until 2023.

Other organizational components of KOJC developed beginning in the 1990s included José María College, which Quiboloy named after his parents and offers over thirty academic programs, in 2000; the charitable organization, Children’s Joy Foundation, Inc. in 2005; and Sonshine Sports Management in 2014. The organizational complex in Davao City also included commercial establishments, including a McDonald’s franchise.

The membership size of KOJC has been a matter of some debate, with estimates ranging from several thousand to several million (Beech 2024; Ager 2024; Philippine Statistics Authority 2023). Proponents, opponents, official agencies and investigative media all have vested interests in different membership estimates. Two things are clear. One is that the media following is vastly higher than the active membership. The second is that it is not membership size but the capacity of the movement to build political alliances and to project itself as a powerful religious movement in an emerging nation seeking to become a major international presence that is most significant about KOJC.

Quiboloy became involved in political activity beginning in the early 2000s. He supported a series of presidential campaigns in 2001 (Gloria Arroyo), 2010 (Gilbert Teodoro), 2016 (Rodrigo Duterte). The Duterte election victory in 2016 was the most significant for KOJC as Quiboloy encouraged KOJC members to vote for Duterte, who was Mayor of Davao City at the time, and loaned him a private jet and helicopter during the campaign. Quiboloy went on to become Duerte’s “spiritual advisor.” [Image at right] Duerte was noted for its pursuit of a stronger relationship with China and for an aggressive and deadly campaign against illegal drugs that produced thousands of casualties and was very controversial politically.

Amid a tumultuous period in Philippine politics, the 2022 presidential election was won by a “unity ticket” composed of representatives of two of the Philippine’s most prominent and powerful families. Ferdinand (Bongbong) Romualdez Marcos Jr. (son of former president Ferdinand Marcos) won the presidency with Sara Duerte (daughter of Rodrigo Duerte) as his Vice President. (Duerte was constitutionally prohibited from seeking a second term) Quiboloy endorsed both Marcos and Duerte. However, the political partnership lasted only two years as Vice President Sara Duerte resigned her positions as Secretary of Education and director of an anti-insurgence agency in 2024; she retained here position as Vice President. While Sara Duerte continued verbal support for Quiboloy and even appeared with him in public, Quiboloy was now facing increasing political opposition and pending criminal chargers [See, Issues/Challenges].

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Quiloboy experienced opposition throughout his religious career. He was rejected by the Pentecostal Church in which his career began. His broader rejection of institutionalized religion and lofty charisma claims alienated the powerful Catholic Church. In addition to the theological divide, the Catholic Church was adamantly opposed to his “War on Drugs” campaign that resulted in over 7,000 extra-judicial executions that the church pronounced as human rights violations. This opposition notwithstanding, Quiboloy developed a dynamic, rapidly growing church during the 1990s and early 2000s as one of the high profile indigenous Philippine religious movements growing out of Christianity. He sought to cement his power base through political alliances beginning in the early 2000s, an initiative that reached its zenith with the election of Rodriguez Duerte to a six-year term as President in 2016.

Troubling signs of Quiboloy’s impending legal problems first surfaced when complaints for rape, child abuse and human trafficking were filed against Quiboloy and five other church members. These charges were dropped by the Davao City Prosecutor’s Office in 2020, reportedly for lack of evidence. However, legal issues resurfaced from another source. Quiboloy had established affiliate organizations in a number of nations, including the U.S. After obtaining information from an informant, U.S prosecutors  followed up the earlier 2020 charges, which did not include Quboloy, asserting that Quiboloy and associates had been running a sex-trafficking operation involving underage women (Hosenball and Brunnstrom 2021).

The superseding indictment is specific and detailed and traces the alleged behaviors back to at least 2002 (United States Attorney’s Office 2021):

The superseding indictment charges Quiboloy, Dandan and Salinas with participating in a conspiracy to engage in sex trafficking by force, fraud and coercion, as well as the sex trafficking of children. These three defendants allegedly recruited females ranging from approximately 12 to 25 years of age to work as personal assistants, or “pastorals,” for Quiboloy. The indictment states that the victims prepared Quiboloy’s meals, cleaned his residences, gave him massages and were required to have sex with Quiboloy in what the pastorals called “night duty.” The indictment specifically mentions five female victims, three of whom were minors when the alleged sex trafficking began.

The United States and the Republic of the Philippines signed a mutual extradition treaty in 1994. The immediate impact on Quiboloy was limited, however, as officials in the Philippines reported that there was no immediate extradition request for Quiboloy from the U.S. (Casilao 2021).

This indictment was accompanied by a series of additional U.S. actions. In February 2022, the Federal Bureau of Investigation released a wanted poster for Quiboloy; in December 2022, the U.S. Departments of Treasury and State imposed sanctions on Quiboloy’s U.S. based organizational finances, properties, activities, and interests. Comparable actions were also being taken in the Philippines. In March 2024, the Senate issued an arrest warrant for Quiboloy; In July the Department of the Interior and Local Government offered a bounty for information for information leading to his arrest.

Throughout governmental pursuit of Quiboloy, he had not only protested his innocence through his attorneys but also lashed out against his pursuers. He threatened divine intervention against his enemies during the COVID-19 pandemic (Garcia 2021):

The Delta virus variant of COVID-19 is only an introduction. If you keep on hurting, persecuting, and harming the Appointed Son and the Kingdom, you will see much worse than the Omicron variant,” his post said.
He said the pandemic will only stop if he is freed from his charges.
“You want this to stop? Stop persecuting, prosecuting, maligning and falsely accusing the appointed son,” Quiboloy said.

Quiboloy later alleged that President Marcos and his wife were conspiring with U.S. authorities to have him assassinated (Garner 2024). Ultimately, Quiboloy barricaded himself in the KOJC center surrounded by a large contingent of police. [Image at right] After a weeks long standoff, Quiboloy was taken into police custody on September 8, 2024.

The future for Quiboloy and KOJC remains opaque. The shift in governmental control after the 2022 Philippine presidential election from the Duerte family to the Franco family, soon followed by the resignation of Sara Duerte as Vice President; the corresponding decline in Duerte’s influence as his legal problems mounted (Duerte was ultimately taken into custody by the International Criminal Court in The Hague on charges of crimes against humanity in 2025), the series of charges against Quiboloy and KOJC in both the U.S. and the Philippines, with the possibility of extradition to the U.S.; and the arrest and confinement of Quiboloy while legal proceedings moved forward all left him legally endangered and powerless. The subsequent attempts by both Duerte and Quiboloy to regain political power, Duerte by running for Senate and Quiboloy by running for Mayor of Davao City, both failed. In Quiboloy’s case, there may be larger implications. He had elevated his status in KOJC to such an exalted level and he and the group became virtually synonymous. One possible long-term outcome therefore may be that his fate will become the movement’s fate.

IMAGES

Image #1: The Philippine archipelago. Public Domain.
Image #2: Quiboloy FBI wanted picture. Federal Bureau of Investigation. Public domain.
Image #3:  Appollo Quilobroy with Rodrigo Duerte. Joey Dalumpines for the Presidential Communications Operations Office. Public domain.
Image #4:  Philippine National Police in KOJC compound to serve warrant of arrest against Pastor Apollo Quiboloy. Photo by Robinson Niñal J. Public domain.

REFERENCES

ABC.net. 2024. “Apollo Quiboloy of the Kingdom of Jesus Christ church registers for Philippine senate elections from behind bars.” Accessed from https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-10-08/apollo-quiboloy-registers-for-philippine-senate-elections/104447262 on 10 July 2025.

Ager, Maila. 2024. ”Quiboloy claims KJC has 7M followers, but PNP says it’s less than 8,000.” Inquirer.net, October 23. Accessed from https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1996128/quiboloy-claims-kjc-has-7m-followers-but-pnp-says-its-less-than-8000 on 25 June 2025.

Alba-Jones, Beng. 2024. “Arrested Filipino Pastor Apollo Quiboloy Claims He’s the Messiah: Why millions of Filipinos are drawn to his movement and other heretical sects.” Christianity Today, September 17. Accessed from https://www.christianitytoday.com/2024/09/apollo-quiboloy-kingdom-jesus-christ-philippines-heretical/ on 7 July 2025.

Arevalo, Regina. 2020. “Inside the walls of Pastor Quiboloy’s mysterious, powerful sect Kingdom of Jesus Christ.” Manila Bulletin, November 19. Accessed from https://mb.com.ph/2020/11/19/inside-the-walls-of-pastor-quiboloys-mysterious-powerful-sect-kingdom-of-jesus-christ/ on 20 June 2025.

Beech, Hannah. 2024. “Fugitive Televangelist Wanted by F.B.I. Is Caught in the Philippines.” New York Times, September 8. Accessed from https://www.nytimes.com/2024/09/08/world/asia/philippines-pastor-kingdom-trafficking.html on 25 June 2025.

Casilao, Joahna. 2021. “No request yet to extradite Quiboloy to US — Guevarra.” GMA News, November 19. Accessed from https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/topstories/nation/811589/no-request-yet-to-extradite-quiboloy-to-us-guevarra/story/ on 9 July 2025.

Castro, Nestor T. 2019. “The Interface between Religion and Politics in the Philippines Based on Data from Recent Philippine Elections.” International Journal of Interreligious and Intercultural Studies 2:100-07.

Cornelio, Jayeel. 2020. “Claiming the Nation: Theological Nationalism in the Philippines.” In What Does Theology Do, Actually? Observing Theology and the Transcultural, edited by Natthew Robinson and Inja Inderst. Leipzig: Evangelische Verlagsanstalt.

Cornelio, Jayeel. 2017. “Religious worlding: Christianity and the new production of space in the Philippines.” Pp. 169-98 in New religiosities, modern capitalism, and moral complexities in Southeast Asia, edited by Juliette Köning and Gwenaël Njoto-Feillard. Singapore: Palgrave Macmillan.

Delizo, Michael. 2025. “Quiboloy Suffers Pneumonia, Now Confined at Private Hospital.” ABS-CBN News, January 21. Accessed from https://www.abs-cbn.com/news/nation/2025/1/21/quiboloy-suffers-pneumonia-now-confined-at-a-private-hospital-bjmp-1354 on 25 June 2025.

Garcia, MA. Angelica. 2021. “Apollo Quiboloy says Omicron variant due to allegations against him.” GMA News, November 29. Accessed from https://www.gmanetwork.com/news/topstories/nation/812591/apollo-quiboloy-says-omicron-variant-due-to-allegations-against-him/story/ on 7 July 2025.

Gavilan, Jodesz. 2024. “FAST FACTS: Who is Pastor Apollo Quiboloy, the ‘Appointed Son of God’?” Rappler.com, March 14. Accessed from https://www.rappler.com/newsbreak/iq/196156-fast-facts-pastor-apollo-quiboloy-kingdom-jesus-christ/ on 25 June 2025.

Gomez, Jim. 2024. “Philippine Vice President Sara Duterte resigning from posts in Marcos’ Cabinet as alliance flounders.” Associated Press, June 19. Accessed from https://apnews.com/article/philippines-vice-president-duterte-marcos-73a4ae12f2d0af475790bc2229d1c5c6 on 25 June 2025.

Hosenball, Mark and David Brunnstrom. 2021.  Reuters, November 19. “U.S. announces sex-trafficking charges against Duterte’s spiritual adviser.” Accessed from https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/us-announces-sex-trafficking-charges-against-duterte-ally-2021-11-18/ on 25 June 2025.

International Criminal Court. 2025. “Situation in the Philippines: Rodrigo Roa Duterte in ICC custody.” Press Release, March 12. Accessed from https://www.icc-cpi.int/news/situation-philippines-rodrigo-roa-duterte-icc-custody on 9 July 2025.

King, Johnny Loye (2016). Spirit and Schism: A History of Oneness Pentecostalism in the Philippines (PhD thesis). University of Birmingham.

Kingdom of Jesus Christ The Name Above Every Name. 2018. “THE NEW NAME OF THE ALMIGHTY FATHER.” Accessed from https://kingdomofjesuschrist.org/the-new-name-of-the-almighty-father/ on 9 July 2025.

Medina, Erron and Jayeel Cornelio. 2021. “The Prosperity Ethic: Neoliberal Christianity and the Rise of the New Prosperity Gospel the Philippines.” Pneuma 43:72–93.

Quiboloy, Pastor Appollo C. 2019. “The Birth of the Kingdom Nation. Accessed from https://www.apolloquiboloy.com/who-is-pastor-apollo-quiboloy/ on 25 June 2025.

Quiboloy, Pastor Appolo. 2018. “Apollo Quiboloy’s Life and Calling.” Accessed from https://web.archive.org/web/20180726233842/https:/www.apolloquiboloy.com/life-calling-apollo-quiboloy/#the_exodus_from_religious_bondage on 21 June 2025.

Ragragio, Jefferson Lyndon D. 2023. “Media populism and the metanarrative of God in the Philippines.” Communication, Culture and Critique 16:49–56.

Philippine Statistics Authority. 2023. “Religious Affiliation in the Philippines (2020 Census of Population and Housing).” Accessed from https://psa.gov.ph/content/religious-affiliation-philippines-2020-census-population-and-housing on 25 June 2025.

Rodger, Daniel. 2010. “A Summary of Pastor Apollo Quiboloy and The Kingdom of Jesus Christ.” Christian Apologetics and Research Ministry, May 12. Accessed from https://carm.org/kingdom-of-jesus-christ/a-summary-of-pastor-apollo-quiboloy-and-the-kingdom-of-jesus-christ/

Tan, Alyssa Nicole O. 2022. “Palace: Duterte’s spiritual adviser can defend himself.” BusinessWorld, April 4. Accessed from https://www.bworldonline.com/the-nation/2022/04/04/440152/palace-dutertes-spiritual-adviser-can-defend-himself/ on 25 June 2025.

Publication Date:
14 July 2025

Share

The Danforth Report

Danforth-Final-Report.

Danforth-Report-Exhibits-to-the-Final-Report.

Danforth-Report-Preface.pdf.

Danforth-Report-Press-Release.

Danforth-Report-Transmittal-Letter-to-Deputy-Attorney-General.

Appendix A: History-and-Beliefs-of-Branch-Davidians.

Appendix B: Summary-of-Expert-Findings.

Appendix C: Chronological-Table-of-Events.

Appendix D: Wetherington-Report-on-Fire.

Appendix E: Wickstrom-Report-on-Fire.

Appendix F: Havens-Report-on-Tear-Gas-and-Flammability.

Appendix G: Mills-Report-on-Title-III-FLIR-Tape-and-FBI-Video-Analysis-Audio.

Appendix H: Klasen-and-Madsen-FLIR-Systems-and-Video.

Appendix I: Vector-Data-Systems-FLIR-Analysis.

Appendix J: Graham-Forensic-Pathology-Examination.

Appendix K: Lucier-Report-on-Toxicity-Hazards-of-Methylene-Chloride.

Appendix L: Heinrich-Report-on-Possible-Lethal-Effects-of-CS-Tear-Gas-on-Branch-Davidians.

Appendix M: George and Kaltenbroon Report on Ballistics is not available.

Appendix N: Murray-and-Green-Report-on-Micro-Chemical-Explosive-Residue-and-Blast-Damage.

Comments on the Danforth Report’s conclusions (Catherine Wessinger)

Appendix B: Summary of Expert Findings (on this webpage) summarizes each of the reports in the appendices to the Danforth Final Report, including the missing Appendix M on ballistics.
Appendix M: Expert Report of Mr. William George and Mr. John Kaltenbroon, St. Louis County Police Crime Laboratory
The following comments on the summary of Appendix M in “Summary of Expert Findings.”

The experts were asked to make a ballistics report on very narrowly defined topics. The topics are so narrowly defined, there can be nothing incriminating to the FBI in their report, such as whether or not agents behind the building shot automatic weapons toward the Branch Davidians on April 19, 1993, as concluded by a number of FLIR experts but disputed by the government.

The experts were asked to review ballistics “associated with the events that occurred at the Branch Davidian complex on April 19, 1993.” There is nothing in this ballistics report about the shootout between ATF agents and Branch Davidians on February 28, 1993.

The experts were asked to address the question: “Whether twelve (12) .308 caliber spent shell casings collected from FBI sniper position Sierra One were fired from an FBI weapon.”

Their answer: “The twelve .308 caliber spent shell casings retrieved from FBI sniper position Sierra One were not fired from an FBI weapon.”

Comment: This implies that the spent shell casings were fired by ATF snipers on February 28, 1993, during the shootout between Branch Davidians and ATF agents. Sierra One is probably the house across Double EE Ranch Road that became known as the “undercover house,” referring to an ATF surveillance operation based at the house. (This house was subsequently demolished and removed.)

********

The experts were asked to address the question: “Whether twenty-four (24) .223 caliber spent shell casings collected from FBI sniper position Sierra One were fired from an FBI weapon.”

Their answer: “The twenty-four .223 caliber spent shell casings retrieved from FBI position Sierra One were not fired from an FBI weapon.”

Comment: This implies that these rounds were fired by ATF snipers on February 28, 1993.

********
The experts were asked to answer the question: “Whether fuel cans and lanterns recovered from the Branch Davidian complex possess any man-made puncture holes.”Their answer: “Three fuel cans and one lantern recovered from the Branch Davidian complex contain tool made puncture holes. Eleven additional fuel cans recovered from the Branch Davidian complex contain holes that are consistent with tool made punctures or damage caused by exploding ammunition.”

Comment: The Branch Davidians were using kerosene in lanterns during the siege, because electricity had been turned off by FBI agents.
FBI agents allege that fuel known to be in the building was used by Branch Davidians to start the fire on April 19, 1993. There is  no way to know if these fuel cans were punctured to pour fuel into lanterns or to pour fuel for the purpose of starting the fire.

*******
The experts were asked to address the following: “Determine whether agents of the United States used an explosive device to breach the concrete bunker on April 19, 1993.”Their answer: Government agents did not use a shaped charge or other high explosive device to breach the concrete bunker at the Branch Davidian complex on April 19, 1993.

Comment: A hole in the top of the concrete room, which was a former vault with an open doorway, was visible after the fire. This former vault/concrete structure is where the mothers and young children were sheltering from the CS gas. They had been gassed directly by a Combat Engineering Vehicle spraying in CS gas by 11:50 am; the first fire was visible by 12:07 pm. This hole in the ceiling of the concrete room has been the subject of conspiracy theories alleging that agents placed a shape charge on top of that concrete structure and detonated it, with the explosion making that hole in the room’s ceiling and causing concrete debris to fall on the mothers and children. This is unlikely, because there were Branch Davidians on the second floor directly over the concrete structure and they died by gunshots and fire; they were in a location where they could not escape the fire.

Attorney David Hardy, author of This Is Not an Assault, told historian of religions Catherine Wessinger that he has concluded that the hole in the ceiling of the concrete room was made by the sudden desiccation (removal of moisture) of the concrete by the fire and the massive explosion that occurred close to the central tower with the concrete room at its base.

********
The experts were asked to address the following: “Determine whether agents of the United States used an explosive device to detonate the exploded propane tank recovered from the Branch Davidian complex fire debris.”Their answer: “Government agents did not use an explosive device to detonate the exploded propane tank found amongst the fire debris of the Branch Davidian complex.”

Comment: FBI photos show that before the fire there was a large propane tank located outside the building behind the central tower.  A person knowledgeable about propane tanks told historian of religions Catherine Wessinger that a propane tank is constructed to release gas slowly when the tank is exposed to high heat (such as a fire). The propane gas being emitted from this propane tank is probably the source of the large explosion that occurred in the midst of the fire. Photos taken after the fire show that the propane tank was not demolished in the explosion, but it had been blown to a different location on the property.

Share

Washitaw de Dugdahmoundyah

WASHITAW DE DUGDAHMOUNDYAH TIMELINE

1975-1976:  Verdiacee Goston served as the inaugural mayor of Richwood, Louisiana, a predominantly black township incorporated in 1974 outside Monroe, Louisiana.

1980-1984:  Goston served a second term as mayor of Richwood.

1993:  Empress Goston’s Return of the Ancient Ones, the scriptural text and research guide for the Washitaw movement, was published

1993:  During the United Nations’ International Year of the World’s Indigenous Peoples, a Washitaw delegation attended a UN meeting and were registered under the number 215, which was henceforth cited by Washitaw as evidence of UN recognition of their indigeneity.

1996:  A Washitaw delegation again attended a United Nations event, this time in Geneva. Empress Goston led the group, and during the fourteenth session of the UN Working Group on Indigenous Populations the phrase “oldest indigenous peoples on earth” was included in the Washitaw name and thus printed on the program for the event. This fact was also cited by Washitaw as evidence of UN recognition of their claims.

1996:  Empress Goston signed “a treaty of Peace and Recognition” with one of the Republic of Texas groups.

1997:  Empress Goston met with “the Royal Family” of the Kingdom of Hawaii, establishing diplomatic relations (and “family ties”) to this community, which was understood by Goston to be, like the Washitaw, descendants of the inhabitants of ancient Mu.

2000:  There as an FBI raid of Goston’s home, which also served as Washitaw headquarters.

2014:  Empress Goston died.

2015:  At the annual summer gathering of Washitaw in Louisiana, Goston’s granddaughter Wendy Farica Washitaw was crowned Empress.

2016:  A group identified as the Washitaw de Dugdahmoundyah Empire of Mu’urs claimed property in the New Orleans neighborhood of Bywater by moving into a house and posting signs around the property citing international law.

2016:  In the wake of a murder committed by a man, Gavin Long, with a form of Washitaw identification in his wallet, the Washitaw movement came under national press scrutiny. In response, Goston’s son and de facto leader of the Empire Washitaw group, Fredrix Joe Washington, gave an interview to the Los Angeles Times, and R.A. Umar Shabazz Bey, who worked closely with Goston and was one of the Washitaw representatives to travel to the United Nations, took a journalist from The Guardian through a tour of the Washitaw museum he has maintained in his home.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Members of the Washitaw de Dugdahmoundyah movement claim to be the descendants of the original settlers of the New World. They point to prehistoric mounds across the U.S. and, sometimes, other parts of America, as evidence of legal claims to territory, with particular focus on the northern half of the current state of Louisiana. The Washitaw call this land“Washitaw Proper” and identify it as the heart of their ancient empire and the site of what many Washitaw hope will be sovereign land, at least on the model of Native American reservations.

The movement was started in the 1990s by a Louisiana politician Verdiacee “Tiara” Washitaw-Turner Goston El-Bey (1927-2014). Before she became a religious leader, Goston helped incorporate the town of Richwood, outside Monroe, Louisiana, and served as the mayor of Richwood from 1975-1976 and 1980-1984. She framed her political work as a struggle against white supremacy and patriarchy. According to her accounts, this political activism led her to engage in research on history, uncovering what she claimed to be lies used to maintain systems of oppressive power. She devoted herself to this work, visiting archives and historical societies, collecting maps, reading firsthand accounts of Louisiana history. Through this archival work, Goston came to believe that the Louisiana Purchase was “an illegal sale” (Goston 1993:139) and that most of that land of Louisiana belonged, by law, to the heirs of one Henry Turner “Louisiana is known for one of the worst U.S.A. cover-ups in history!” she wrote in the book she later published detailing her historical, legal, and religious vision, Return of the Ancient Ones (Goston 1993:395). Goston claimed descent from Turner, and, through that family, claimed title to 68,883 acres of land that she called “Washitaw Proper.”

She also described the Turner family bloodline as “the imperial bloodline” of the Washitaw, meaning that she was the latest in a series of Empresses. Tracing her family back to ancient Mu, she had a series of visions in which ancestral figures appeared to help her in her quest to understand the past and uncover the truth buried among the lies. In her book, she claimed the role of Empress of the Ancient Ones, descendant of those who dug the mounds (the meaning of the work “Dug-dah-mound-yah”).

Influenced both by Noble Drew Ali’s Moorish Science Temple of America and a wider, popular, “do your own research” ethos of contemporary U.S. American religion, the Washitaw movement proposed an alternative history for African Americans, one characterized by imperial grandeur and promising a return to sovereignty and self-governance over land in the current U.S. The Empress often dismissed the reality of African slavery, arguing that narratives of the transatlantic slave trade were, at least, highly exaggerated, as there are no slave ships on display in museums.

In Goston’s narrative, the Ancient Ones came to what is now America from Mu, having been warned by a prophetic Empress of that continent’s destruction. The command to build mounds was a divine command, as echoed in the Hebrew Bible (Exodus 20:23-26), which Goston cites as a directive “to build altars of earth for worship…” (Shabazz Bey 1996:19). These earthworks thus became the foci for religious practice among Goston’s followers.

Her alternative history (one strand of diverse claims to indigeneity among African American new religious movements) insisted on not only Washitaw having, in the past, achieved the heights of arts and sciences, but also that contemporary Washitaw had legal rights to inheritance as a result of this history. The earthworks themselves were legal evidence for Washitaw claims to the land. Moreover, Goston insisted that Noble Drew Ali was also in the bloodline of the Turner family, the royal line of Washitaw, and his work served to prepare the way for her own revelations of truth about identity, history, divinely-ordained religious practice, and destiny.

To pursue this destiny, Goston and her followers sought legal recognition of their indigenous status and claims to land, first in 1993, during the United Nations’ International Year of the World’s Indigenous Peoples, where a Washitaw delegation attended meeting of the Working Group on Indigenous Peoples. At this meeting the Washitaw delegation was assigned, in the program, the number 215, and this number continues to be cited as proof of UN recognition of the Washitaw as indigenous.

Again in 1996, the Washitaw sent a delegation to a United Nations event, this time in Geneva. At a meeting of UN Working Group on Indigenous Populations, R.A. Umar Shabazz Bey gave a brief speech on the needs of the Washitaw for international support. In the program for this event the Washitaw delegation included the phrase “oldest indigenous peoples on earth” as part of their name, a fact now likewise cited as evidence of international legal recognition of their claims about history (Bey 1996:41).

While seeking recognition from international legal bodies, Empress Goston also sought alliances with other groups she saw as pursuing similar struggles for sovereignty within the United States, including the Kingdom of Hawaii and one of the Republic of Texas organizations. It was these alliances that seem to have put the Washitaw movement on the FBI’s radar. In Hawaii, in particular, the FBI kept track of Washitaw activities. In 2000, Goston’s home was raided, an event that led to the arrest of a lieutenant on financial crime charges but also shaped the movement. “The Raid” has become shorthand for a moment of tension between Washitaw and the federal government. In this raid, the federal government seized a variety of documents, including driver’s licenses and passports and certificates of live birth, all of which had been for sale, along with other documentation proving Washitaw identity.

“The Raid” caused so much stress for the Empress that, in its wake, her health precipitously declined. Her son Fredrix Joe Washington placed her in an assisted living facility in California. He kept her out of contact with the Washitaw community, speaking on her behalf and emphasizing the need to obey the law of the United States and remain on good terms of law enforcement agencies in relation to all Washitaw activities. Under his leadership, the movement (or at least the core organization, called Empire Washitaw) rejected the practice of selling any documentation of membership. Instead, the movement’s public-facing efforts since “the Raid” have involved outreach to the federal government (writing letters to elected representatives, speaking directly to potential FBI agents surveilling their public conference calls) in an attempt to correct the reputation of the Washitaw and have their legal claims (to ownership of the land, to indigenous status) heard by those in power in the U.S.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Washitaws identify as Moors or as Muurs (linked to the lost continent of Mu, from which their ancestors fled before it was destroyed). This identity brings with it legal consequences: the land of the Washitaw, marked with mounds by the Ancient Ones, belongs by right to the descendants of these Muurs. The Washitaw believe themselves to be indigenous people with rights both enshrined in historical legal decisions (like the “Turner Heirs” decision) and in divinely-ordained natural law. As Shabazz Bey writes, summarizing core Washitaw beliefs:

The Washitaw Muurs have always been here. The Great Spirit created us in this land (Muu), granting us divine rights and protections. In spirt of a ‘history’ that says the original inhabitants were decimated by the dis-eases imported from Europe, we are still here. In spirt of America’s legalized institution of genocide against the native peoples and the American Helocaust of chattel slavery imposed on blacks, the Ancient Ones have persevered (Bey1996:36).

Washitaw insistence on the rights that follow from the Washitaw truth claims motivates a range of practices, from legal activism to meditation at mound sites. The language of indigeneity is key to these beliefs in part because of its political and legal legibility. It was as an indigenous that Goston hoped to receive a hearing and eventual recognition of Washitaw claims from the United Nations. Her son Fredrix Joe Washington, whose focus has been recognition from the U.S. government, has said, “when you say indigenous people of the United States, that’s what gets recognized” (Empire Washitaw 2015, September 20).

Many Washitaw hold to the belief that, with recognition, Washitaw will be granted some degree of sovereign control over some amount of their ancestral territory, possibly following the model of the Native American reservation system. This would allow them to exist as a semi-autonomous nation within the nation of the United States, under their own flag and with their own educational system as well as their own political and legal institutions.

The deity worshipped by the Washitaw is referred to by many names, including God as well as the Great Spirit (in a nod to panindigeneity) and Allah (following Moorish Science convention). While Goston’s book is the central scriptural text, Washitaw follow her example of citing the Bible. They also cite an assortment of other African American new religious texts, weaving together strands of Kemeticism and broader Black Indigeneity with Moorish Science and the distinctly Washitaw narrative of history.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

For the Washitaw, prehistoric mound sites across the United States are seen as sacred, focal points for pilgrimage and religious practices including meditation and prayer. Goston describes learning some of these practices from an older relative who, when she was young, “made [a] circuit every month up to the Mound to pray.” (Goston 1993:viii) While he did not remember the full religion of the Washitaw, his practices were nonetheless a trace, like his name, Grant, which he was given in remembrance of the Spanish Land Grant that gave Washitaw Proper to the Turner family. Goston writes in her book that “Our religion, the sacred MOUNDS and the SACRED LAND” are synonymous. (Goston 1993:419-20) The ancient mounds were themselves designed, in part, to mark legal ownership of the land. Now they serve as reminders of this as sites for religious experience.

Washitaw are “constantly visiting these mounds,” and, while there, experiencing the “spiritual side to things.” (Empire Washitaw, September 3, 2017). Miraculous occurrences and feelings of connection between generations (from the Ancient Ones through to future generations) are subject of much discussion among Washitaw. Some Washitaw speculate about the alignment of mound sites with “ley lines” and metaphysical energies associated with them (S. Bey 2010:36) As one Washitaw testifies, “the spiritual essence of the mounds… will change you” (Tunica El Bey 2018) Another religious practice at mound sites is evangelical work correcting the historical displays and narratives in on-site mound museums (See, Dew 2023).

Washitaw make pilgrimage, too, to “Washitaw Proper,” a part of Louisiana that includes Ouachita Parish, through which the Washitaw River runs.  Annual “family reunions,” with appearances by Mardi Gras Indians and featuring lectures on history, as well as time to gather and mingle, have been important staples of the main group, led first by Goston and then by her son, Dauphin Joe.

The most important Washitaw holiday is “Our Juneteenth,” which, borrowing its name from the celebration of the date that news of emancipation reached the last enslaved people in the U.S. South, celebrates, for the Washitaw, the “Turner Heirs” decision. It is worth noting that the “decision” Washitaw celebrate here is a District Court decision from 1848 (which was appealed to and later heard by the US Supreme Court in 1850). The decision celebrated by the Washitaw, then, is not actually a Supreme Court decision, and the documents related to the Turner case (and proving, according to Goston, that the Turner family legally owns the land) are documents from the earlier case and documents submitted to the Supreme Court in preparation for that later case (See, Dew 2015).

Return of the Ancient Ones, the Washitaw scripture (which is read aloud in public gatherings, studied in groups and individually) is, foremost, a revisionist history. [Image at right] “Did Mr. Columbus discover America? No he didn’t,” Goston writes in that text. “Are white people great explorers? No, they are great exploiters” (Goston 1993:155). Goston’s text teaches her followers to pull “the lying cover… off the past and present,” revealing the “documented truth” present in slightly hidden form within a given source (Goston 1993:190, 34, 35).

As she describes her role in that book, “I am not a writer. I am a reader and I am tired of reading white lies” (Goston 1993:85). In contrast to the dominant lies of popularly accepted history, Goston offers “ancient truth” drawing on a range of studies (Goston 1993:101). “Return of the Ancient Ones contains authentic copies of the treaties, maps, conventions, Supreme Court cases and others legal documents that will silence the staunchest skeptics” (S. Bey 1996:39). As such, Goston’s scriptural text offers a model for how Washitaw should conduct their research and study. Such study and research is synonymous with Washitaw identity and understood as the central practice of Washitaw life. Washitaw who publish their own texts, like R.A. Umar Shabazz Bey, make clear that “[t]he most important reason for writing this book is to spark a new wave of research,” a process that all Washitaw must engage in both on their own and collectively (Shabazz Bey 2010:87). On the various weekly conference calls of the Empire Washitaw group, participants read Goston’s book and discuss their wider studies of history, indigeneity, and the law.

Finally, following Goston’s insistence, in her book, that Washitaw must struggle to protect “our land, our properties, our rights, and our religion,”  [Image at right] Washitaw engage in a range of activist practices, including, writing letters to elected representatives and circulating petitions. (Goston 1993:419). While some Washitaw or Washitaw groups engage in more aggressive, “sovereign citizen,” legal filings (insisting upon their rights as indigenous peoples) most Washitaw seek recognition from the federal government or, following Goston’s example, the United Nations. The Empire Washitaw held a weekly conference call just to discuss this work, offering interested Washitaw templates to use and sample language for a national letter-writing campaign to call attention to Washitaw claims.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

By the time that Goston died in 2014, her son Fredrix Joe Washington had already assumed de facto control of the largest Washitaw group, Empire Washitaw. Though his daughter was crowned Empress in 2015 at the annual Washitaw homecoming event in Louisiana, she has remained less interested in the future of the movement than “Brother Joe” or “the Dauphin” (sometimes also called “Emperor Joe,” a title he officially rejects). Washington’s focus has been “getting the land back” through legal means, banning any sale of Washitaw identity documents or paperwork, insisting that such material is a form of fraud. Moreover, in the wake of the 2000 FBI raid, Washington’s group has come to attribute to the FBI the role not of enemy but of listeners. The possibility of FBI surveillance, particularly over the Washitaw’s various weekly public conference calls, is understood to be a possibility also for government attention to Washitaw claims and thus government recognition of Washitaw indigeneity and rights. The FBI listeners are thus welcomed, vocally, on such calls, greeted as “lovers of truth” and directly addressed in the hopes that individual agents can be convinced of the correctness of Washitaw claims and help work to convince the wider U.S. government to intervene in Washitaw affairs.

For Washington, recourse to the FBI also serves as an attempt to shore up his own authority in the face of contestation from his fellow Washitaw. Repeatedly, on the weekly Empire Washitaw conference call (to which Washitaw believed that the FBI was listening), Washington has argued that, as one of his supporters once insisted, “The Emperor has the FBI on his side” (Empire Washitaw, January 4, 2014).  Washington reassures Empire Washitaw members that federal authorities are “very proud of the ways you have conducted yourselves” when everyone is polite and compliant; when there is tension within the community, he reminds them that the FBI is listening in, using the power of federal law enforcement as an implicit threat to maintain discipline and control (Empire Washitaw 2015, October 25).

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

The Washitaw, like the Moorish Science Temple of America to which it is geneologicaly connected, has splintered into multiple organizations, with most of these small groups pursuing their own practices. Likewise, there are individuals who sometimes affiliate with Washitaw groups or identify as Washitaw but who pursue their own idiosyncratic approaches to movement history and practice. After “the Raid,” in particular, the main group, Empire Washitaw, lost some members first due to debates about interpretation of tax law (and whether Washitaw claims to sovereignty rendered Washitaw exempt from such law) and later due to concerns about Joe Washington’s leadership of the group (including his controlling of access to the Empress). Like the MSTA, so-called “sovereign citizen” legal tactics linked to Washitaw offshoots tend to make the news, further bolstering popular associations of this movement with vernacular legal tactics like squatting in houses and citing treaties as evidence of right to do so. This happened in 2016 with a small group of Washitaw in New Orleans. The group claimed a house as “Washitah Mu’ur” property,” citing “international treaties” and posting signs around the property warning that any violation of their rights to occupancy would be a “Federal Offense” (McClendon 2016).

A masculinist self-help guru, Gavin Long, who used the name Cosmo Ausar Setepenra, killed three Baton Rouge police officers and was found with a form of Washitaw identification in his wallet. This led to a resurgence of press coverage linking Washitaw identity to “sovereign citizen” ideology and practice. Though several high-profile articles featured Washitaw representatives offering their own opinions on this controversy (Fredrix Joe Washington in the Los Angeles Times and R.A. Umar Shabbaz Bey in The Guardian), the Long killings continue to cast a shadow over the reputation of the movement (Kaleem and Jarvie 2016 and Teague 2016; See also, Dew 2016).

Finally, there is the fact that Goston’s vision was, in many ways, focused on local, northern Louisiana concerns. The claims are to specific land, engagement with specific mound sites, like the now UNESCO-recognized World Heritage Site of Poverty Point, which Washitaw sometimes call “Old Mecca,” “Our Mecca,” or “Prosperity Point.” This local focus may ultimately limit the attraction of any religious movement linked directly to Return of the Ancient Ones, and leadership issues seem set to reduce the Empire Washitaw group to a mere handful of people.

The future of Washitaw thought will likely be in its influence on a diverse range of movements, Moorish- and Black Indigenous-adjacent, fueling a religious imagination in relation to prehistoric mounds, an alternative history for African Americans, and a promise of legal recompense (“reparations,” as Goston phrased it) and federal and international recognition of some degree of sovereignty and self-determination over territory.

IMAGES

Image #1:  Washitaw Nation flag. Accessed from https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?search=Verdiacee+Goston&title=Special:MediaSearch&type=image. Credit: Creative Commons Attribution 2.5.
Image #2: Cover of Return of the Ancient Ones.
Image #3: Public presence of Washitaw Nation. Accessed from https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?search=Verdiacee+Goston&title=Special:MediaSearch&type=image. Credit: Creative Commons Attribution 2.0. 

REFERENCES

Dew, Spencer. 2023. “Les tumuli sacrés des Washitaw de Dugdahmoundyah.” Hypothèses. Accessed from https://relrace.hypotheses.org/6392?fbclid=IwY2xjawKmzIpleHRuA2FlbQIxMQBicmlkETFLckk3enFwa2doNWVRakM4AR4sY5zevLGgljfCTJq_IIs-qlpPSDS0yEnPAJMhDWETXLSerlOTrxFiInNdlg_aem_jMCFnNHDB-iDjPHenSB-wg on 3 June 2025.

Dew, Spencer. 2019. The Aliites: Race and Law in the Religions of Noble Drew Ali. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Dew, Spencer. 2016. “‘I’m the One’: Masculinity in the Philosophy of the Baton Rouge Shooter.” Accessed from https://divinity.uchicago.edu/sightings/articles/im-one-masculinity-philosophy-baton-rouge-shooter on 3 June 2025.

Dew, Spencer. 2015. “Washitaw de Dugdahmoundyah: Counterfactual Religious Readings of the Law.” Nova Religio19:65-82.

Empire Washitaw. 2014. Sunday Night Conference Call, January 4.

Empire Washitaw. 2015. Sunday Night Conference Call, September 20.

Empire Washitaw. 2015. Sunday Night Conference Call, October 25.

Empire Washitaw. 2017. Sunday Night Conference Call, September 3.

Goston El-Bey, Verdiacee “Tiara” Washitaw-Turner. 1993. Return of the Ancient Ones: The True History Uncovered of the Washitaw De Dugdahmoundyah Empire / The Washitaw Files. Washitaw Publishing Company.

Kaleem, Jaweed and Jenny Jarvie. 2016. “Black nationalist group Washitaw Nation distances itself from the Baton Rouge shooter, who had pledged allegiance to it.” Accessed from https://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-washitaw-nation-baton-rouge-snap-story.html on 3 June 2025.

McClendon, Robert. 2016. “Black nationalist ‘Washitah Nation’ claims Bywater house, changes locks while home is for sale.” Accessed from http://www.nola.com/crime/index.ssf/2016/02/black_nationalist_washitah_nat.html on 3 June 2025.

Bey, R.A. Umar. 2010. Pyramids in America: A Traveler’s Guide. Baton Rouge: Indigenous Concepts LLC.

Shabazz Bey, R.A. Umar. 1996. We are the Washitaw: The Indigenous Black Inhabitants of North America. Washitaw Proper: Washitaw International Human Rights Network.

Teague, Matthew. 2016. “The Washitaw sovereign citizens: where the Baton Rouge gunman found a home.” Accessed from https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/jul/25/sovereign-citizens-washitaw-baton-rouge-gunman on 3 June 2025.

Tunica El Bey, Mikael Wesley Lawrence. 2018. “Washitaw De Dugdahmoundyah Empire.” Accessed from https://www.youtube.com/shorts/R2yD_WZQk8Y on 3 June 2025.

Publication Date:
4 June 2025

 

Share

Eugenia Rainey

Eugenia Rainey is a cultural anthropologist who studies Lucumí, race, and biomedicine. Her research interests span African Diaspora religions, lived religion, spiritual ontologies, racial formation theory, decolonial theory, and medical anthropology. Her current monograph project Pray for Me: Afro-Cuban Religion in Biomedical Space examines how Lucumí devotees in south Florida manage chronic and acute illness by navigating religious ritual and doctor visits. She earned her PhD in cultural anthropology at Tulane University and an MFA in Writing at the University of Nebraska, Omaha. She was a Mellon Postdoctoral Fellow at Dartmouth College, and the Postdoctoral Fellow, Africa and African Diasporic Religions at the Center for the Study of World Religions, Harvard Divinity School. In the fall of 2025, she will be joining the faculty at William & Mary in the Department of Religious Studies and American Studies.

Share

Santeria

SANTERIA TIMELINE

1789-1840:  The Oyo empire began to collapse upon the death of Alafin Abiodun. Over the coming decades many Yoruba people were transported to the Americas through the transatlantic slave trade as forces to the north and along the coastline closed in on the empire.

1902-1958:  After two wars of independence during the nineteenth century, the island became free of Spanish colonial rule with the help of the United States. The Republic of Cuba was established, but the U.S. remained a neo-colonial power on the island.

Late 19tth– Early 20th centuries:  Lucumí leaders reformed religious ritual and religious roles into its current religious structure.

1946/1950:  Poncho Mora, the first babalawo from Cuba to come the live in the U.S arrived in New York City.

1959:  The Cuban Revolution took place, ending the Republic of Cuba and ousting the influence of the United States. Many Cubans left the island and emigrated to the United States. The practice of Santería increased.

1980:  Feeling frustrated with economic insecurity, Cubans protested at the Peruvian embassy, requesting asylum. Fidel Castro announced that he was opening the port of Mariel for protesters to leave. He also announced that he was clearing the jails and mental institutions. Cubans from South Florida got boats and rushed to the port of Mariel to collect family members. They were required to fill their boats with all those deemed undesirable by the Castro administration. This event is known as the Mariel Boatlift.

1987:  The City of Hialeah passed an ordinance targeting the practice of animal sacrifice. The Church of the Lukumí Babalu Aye sued the city council, and the lawsuit worked its way up to the United States Supreme Court.

1993:  The Supreme Court ruled that Lukumí was a religion with the right to perform animal sacrifice in Church of the Lukumí Babalu Aye v. The City of Hialeah, Florida.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

With the advent of European colonialism in the Americas and the establishment of the Transatlantic Slave Trade (TAST) many religions indigenous to the African continent arrived in the Americas. Among them is the religion popularly known as “Santería.” It is the Cuban incarnation of the worship of the orisha, divinities indigenous to Yorubaland, spanning present day Nigeria, Benin, and Togo. Other common terms for the religion are Lucumí/Lukumí, La Regla de Ocha, or simply Ocha. There are a variety of orisha traditions throughout the Caribbean and Latin America, the information that follows relates to the Cuban and Cuban diasporic tradition. Ifá is an adjacent and overlapping tradition in Cuba.

In the first half of the nineteenth century, there was a spike in Yoruba presence on the island of Cuba due to the fall of the Oyo Empire in Yorubaland. This ethnically Yoruba population and the religion would come to be referred to as “Lucumí” on the island of Cuba. As a Spanish colony, everyone on the island, including people enslaved, had to be baptized Catholic. In Spanish colonial Cuba, enslaved people were able to gain their freedom and that of friends and family through manumission. The class of people known as the gens de couleur libres ([free] people of color) were influential in Cuban culture and central to maintaining the practice of African Diaspora religious traditions on the island. By the mid-nineteenth century, when Yoruba presence on the island was at its height, roughly one-third of the island’s African descent population were free people of color (Clark 2007:20).

In the urban areas of Cuba free people of color had many options for work and social life. In places such as Havana, Matanzas, or Santiago de Cuba, there was a great deal of social intermixing between enslaved people and free people of color. One of the avenues to build a social network was through cabildos organized by the Catholic Church. This system was designed to indoctrinate people into the teachings of Catholicism and served as mutual aid societies helping members with healthcare and funeral services, and in the case of Cuba, pooling funds to manumit others (Brandon 1993:70). This system also provided people with cultural continuity among their countrymen. It was an autonomous space where culture, including religions like Lucumí, could flourish. Both men and women were able to socialize and support one another in this space (Brandon 1993:71).

Lucumí religion changed from indigenous Yoruba religion in order to fit the sociocultural context of Cuba and later the United States. The current system was likely codified in the early twentieth century by a few different people of Yoruba descent. In the transition from colonial Cuba to the Republic of Cuba (1902-1959), many of the colonial cabildos were disbanded and religious devotion transferred to more informal spaces, the casas de Ocha/casas de santo (houses of the Orisha/saints). There are eleven founders of Lucumí that date to this period of reform:  Efunche (Ña Rosalia, aka María Trujillo), Ainá (Ñá Margarita Armenteros), Igoró (Ñá Caridad Argudín), Apoto (Ña Belén González), Ma Monserrate (González), Francisca Entensa (“Palmira”), José Pata de Palo (Urquiola), Los Ibeyi (the “Twins,” Perfector and Gumersindo), Tía Julia Abonse, Obadimelli (Octavio Samar Rodríguez) and Monserrate Asiñabí. Seven of the eleven founders were women (Brown 2003:99; Clark 2007:23).

In 1946 or 1950, Francisco “Pancho” Mora arrived in New York city, becoming the first practicing Babalawo (priest of Ifa) in the U.S. on record. While his arrival was important, he was without a quorum of other babalawos to initiate any new babalawos in the U.S. That would not happen until 1969 or 1970 (Brown 2003:92). In 1958, Merecedes Noble was initiated into the religion in the U.S., a U.S. citizen of Cuban origin. One year later, in 1959, the first African American, Walter King, was initiated into Lucumí in Matanzas Cuba with Christopher Oliana. King would later become Osejiman Adefunmi I and establish the Oyotunji Village in South Carolina. In 1969, the first African American woman was initiated in Queens, Margie Baynes Quiniones. Author Judith Gleason was the first Anglo-American woman initiated in the religion, by Assunta Seranno, a priestess from Puerto Rico (Clark 2007:26).

Both the 1959 Cuban Revolution and the 1980 Mariel Boatlift were seismic events in establishing Lucumí in the U.S. In the initial years after 1959 many Cubans, largely white and with means, fled to the U.S, settling in Miami, New York, and New Jersey. A religion that had been associated with people of African descent and the lower-class white population in the island, gained wide-spread appeal in a new country as it became a way to connect to Cuban cultural heritage. In 1980, in reaction to protest over economic conditions in Cuba, Fidel Castro opened the port of Mariel allowing anyone who wanted to leave the country free to do so. Roughly 125,000 people left the island, arriving in south Florida over a period of six months. These Cuban immigrants were diverse both economically and racially. In the years that followed there was a large increase in Lucumí practice. Today there are orisha devotees and communities throughout the U.S.

By far the largest concentration of Lucumí is along the eastern seaboard with the Miami area a hub of religious practice. In 1987 in the wake of the Mariel Boatlift, the Hialeah city council targeted the practice of Lucumí by banning animal sacrifice, a critical part of religious ritual, in the city limits. The city council allowed any other killing of animals. The religious organization, the Church of the Lukumí Babalu Aye, sued the city. By 1993, the lawsuit had worked its way up to the US Supreme Court which sided with the Church of the Lukumí Babalu Aye.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Lucumí has been described as a syncretic religion, a blending of African religion and Catholicism. The topic of religious syncretism is debated. Many scholars argue that Catholicism only accounts for superficial elements of religious practice, easily discarded because they do not impact ritual (Bascom 1950; Murphy 2008; Palmie 1995, 2013). People who practice Lucumí are often multi-religious. Lucumí is not dogmatic. It is also not exclusive. It does not require devotees to reject other religions to claim membership or a religious identity. The religion is practice based, meaning religious identity is based on the practice of the religion as opposed to claims about religious doctrine. Many devotees practice Lucumí alongside other religions such as Catholicism, Spiritism, and Palo Mayombe (another Afro-Cuban religion) most commonly. While many in the community are multi-religious and at times religious spheres intersect, people approach each religion separately.

Religious practice is based on Lucumí cosmology. According to this cosmology the fundamental source of creation is Olodumare. From Olodumare flows ashé/ache/axé, the foundational energy that moves throughout the universe giving life to all things, including orisha. Olodumare exists in heaven with the araorun, “spirits of heaven.” Olodumare provides each person with an orí and a destiny in life. Ori is sometimes referred to as the “inner head” and often described in relation to “integrity” or a person’s spiritual quality. There is no direct translation or comparable concept in English.

The orisha (also referred to as santos) are the focus of religious practice. All Lucumí devotees have a tutelary orisha that is the focus of devotion, but not to the exclusion of other orisha. Each orisha represents a domain of the material world such as elements of nature (oceans, rivers, thunder, lightning, mountains, disease, and so on)  or elements of humanity (technology, healing, hunting, and so on). Not all of the orisha in West Africa were transferred to the Americas during the TAST, and not all places of orisha worship in the Americas have the same set of orisha that they propitiate in the same ways. There is no exact number of orisha, but the saying goes that there are 401, the one referencing either the fact that that new orisha are coming into being or simply that orisha are a mystery.

In Cuba, Catholic systems were added to the worship of the orisha. These additions served multiple functions: to mitigate the overt hostility of the Church and to position devotees to become more acquainted with the Catholic system. Saints were depicted in certain colors and with an emblem, those that parallelled that of a given orisha were understood as having a connection or affinity with that orisha. In general, colors and emblems were more important than gender: the masculine-warrior-storm-king orisha Shango, tutelary deity of Oyo, is affiliated with the female Catholic Santa Barabara depicted in red and white with a bolt of lightning and tower. The ashé that flows forth from Olodumare is understood to flow throughout all things in the universe, and so it is only in keeping that this ashé would also flow through Catholic saints, Muslem amulets, Hindu deities, Chinese deified ancestors, Taíno zemi/cemis, and so on.

In Cuba and its diaspora, seventeen orisha are ritually propitiated (Clark 2007). All but one of them (Olokun) is associated with a Catholic saint. Each has a domain, ritual instrument, and color with which they are associated. What follows is a general description of each. Elegba is often referred to as the divine trickster of the crossroads. Ogun is the orisha of iron, the forge, and by extension, all things relating to technology and hard work. Ochosi is the orisha of the hunt, and associated with the reserve, patience, and foresight that is required to be successful in this endeavor.

Obatala is often referred to as “king of the gods” while Shango is referred to as “the god of kings.” [Image at right] In some versions of creation (for any myth there are multiple versions), Obatala creates the earth and humanity. Obatala literally means “lord/owner of the white cloth” and is associated with serenity, mountains, wisdom, and forgiveness. Shango, the tutelary deity of Oyo, is the orisha of kingship, the drum and dance, associated with hyper masculinity, justice, and earthly power as well as fire and thunder. Aganju is the orisha of the volcano and rivers of lava. In some mythology he is referred to as the father of Shango. Orunmila is the orisha of divination who is said to be the witness to creation. Orunmila owns the Ifa system of divination, the divining board, and has his own separate priesthood, the Babalawos.

The four major goddesses of the pantheon are Yemaja, Ochun, Oya, and Obba. Yemaja is the great mother goddess associated with the sea and all of its riches. Ochun is the goddess of sweetness and honey associated with rivers and fresh water. Ochun is the orisha who makes life meaningful for human beings. Oya is associated with the walls of the cemetery, lightning, and the whirlwind. A warrior goddess, she commands and accompanies the dead and runs the marketplace. In Cuba, Obba is associated with domesticity as well as the riches of the household and scholarly endeavors.

Osayin, Erinle, and Babaluaye are all associated with healing. Osayin is the orisha of plants which are central to Lucumí practice. [Image at right] According to William Bascom the foundation of Lucumí is “the stones, the blood, and the herbs” (1950:65). Osayin is disfigured with one enormous ear that is deaf and one tiny ear that hears all, one arm, one leg, and one eye. Erinle, a fisherman, is the orisha of medicine; some refer to him as the divine doctor. Babaluaye is the orisha of disease, especially smallpox and other communicable diseases that cause epidemics. While he spreads these diseases, he can also cure them and is looked upon to prevent their spread. People very often refer to him as San Lazurus and he is widely popular in Cuba, despite his association with disease, or because of it.

Olokun, Ibeji, and Orishaoko all have a primordial quality to them. Olokun is the orisha of the depths of the ocean, while Yemaja is associated with the surface. Some identify Olokun as male, others as female, and still others as nonbinary. The Ibeji are the divine twins. Orishaoko is the orisha of agriculture and the fertility of the soil. He is also the orisha that all human beings have a debt to, a debt that is paid upon burial.

In addition to the worship of the orisha, the spirits of the deceased, referred to as egun, are also a central part of Lucumí. It is understood that deceased family members are still concerned with the well-being of relatives and the moral order of society. Historically, among the Yoruba, spirits were understood to reincarnate within families after a period of rest. All devotees have a group of egun, both blood and religious, whom they honor. A devotee cannot connect with orisha, if they have not connected with egun first.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

Lucumí is a community-based initiatory religion rooted in practice. [Image at right] The orisha are accessed through divination, ritual, possession, and initiation. The priesthood in Lucumí is regulated, witnessed, and documented within the community. While there are multiple Lucumí communities around the globe and even more Lucumí casa templos (home temples) which practice variations in worship, these variations orbit around a widely acknowledged center rooted in the history described above. At the heart of Lucumí is the casa templo of the olosha/olorisha (owners of orisha) also called a santero/a. A priest/ess who has been through the kariocha initiation.

The casa templo is the center of religious activity in Lucumí and constitutes a religious family. Within the religious family the person who heads the family is the iyalosha/iyalorisha (mother of the orisha) or babalosha/babalorisha (father of the orisha) often referred to colloquially as the madrina/padrino or godmother/godfather of the members of the house. The inner circle is generally made up of godchildren who have been initiated, oloshas, the longest (“elders” in ritual, as opposed to age) and/or have received many different initiations or orisha. The outer circle is generally made up of aleyos, individuals who have been consecrated within the house with necklaces, warriors, or other ritual, but not gone through the formal kariocha. Beyond that, people who may visit the house for readings or rituals intermittently are referred to as iworo (visitors).

What follows is the common order of initiations people go through in a casa templo. Generally, the first step a person takes is to receive their elekees, sacred necklaces to the four pillar orisha, Obatala, Yemoja, Shango, Ochun (white, blue, red, yellow) and to Elegua (the number of elekees varies by house). This is a purification ritual. Often the next ritual people go through is receiving warriors: Elegua, Ogun, Ochossi and Osun. In some houses a person who has received their warriors is referred to as an aborisha (orisha worshipper) since they now have orisha to worship at home. Some people receive warriors from a babalawo rather than a godparent. After this, if it is called for in divination, a person may receive adimu orisha like Olokun, or Ibeji, (warriors are arguably a type of adimu orisha). Warriors and Olokun may be received from an olorisha or a babalawo. For many it is only after these initial steps that they proceed with initiation, referred to as kariocha (Yoruba for “to place the Orisha in or on the head”), asiento (Spanish for “seat or contract”), or simply crowning (Clark 2007:127). The kariocha ritual creates a set of orisha for the devotee and “seats” the individual’s tutelary orisha on the head through a series of rituals performed by anywhere from ten to twenty ordained olorishas directed by an oriate responsible for the integrity of the ritual. The second, or “middle-day,” the initiate is presented to the public in an open ceremony, and the animals sacrificed the day before are consumed. On the third day a lifetime Dilogún divination, referred to as an itan, is performed by an oriate. In full, the kariocha involves the devotee being cloistered in a small ritual area of the godparent’s casa templo for seven days, followed by a year of wearing all white and seclusion from public life. After the kariocha initiation a person may be called to receive pinaldo, a confirmation ritual. This ritual sanctifies the person to sacrifice four-legged animals, also their orisha are reconsecrated, fed, and speak in itan a second time. If a person has lost their original godparent or been severed from that house for some reason, this ritual can help establish ties to a new casa templo. In order to participate in any ritual, a person must have gone through the ritual themselves.

Lucumí rituals are conducted through the guidance of divination. There are three types of divination employed in Lucumí: Obí, Dilogún, and Ifa. Obí divination is the most common form of divination. It is used most often to ask egun or orisha simple yes/no questions. Some well-experienced and trained priest/esses attain more complex and nuanced messages from obí divination. It is done in Cuba and its diaspora with four pieces of coconut.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

Diloggún divination is performed by an iyalorisha/babalorisha with a set of sixteen consecrated cowry shells. [Image at right] It is a complex process involving multiple throws to complete a sign/odu/odun. Anyone with access to a santero/a can receive a Diloggún divination to ask a question or inquire about a problem. Within the community, consulting the Diloggún is done regularly, not only for problems but to “check-in” on your connection with your orisha. Diloggún divination includes a “remedy” for the issues that arise in the divination. Remedies may involve offerings, behavioral modifications, or further ritual, depending on what the diviner can negotiate with the oracle. A devotee is likely to receive divination from their godparent or another trusted diviner within their spiritual family.

Ifá divination is performed only by babalawos, divination priests initiated to Orunmila, the orisha of divination, who owns the diving board. Ifá divination is performed either with kola nuts or the opele chain. These are used to reveal an odu which is connected to a series of Patakí (myths). The Babalawo identifies the Patakí which contains the advice the client needs to address the issue they are having and performs the ritual remedy called for in the divination to alleviate the consultee’s problems.

The messages of both Diloggún and Ifá are revealed through odu. Ifá is considered the most complex system and able to handle the most difficult problems. Ifá is only read by babalawos initiated to Orunmila (gendered male, heterosexuals who have never experienced spirit possession), and to become a proficient babalawo takes years of apprenticeship to elders who have gained wisdom and skill through work and devotion to Ifá. Diloggún divination can only be performed by olorishas. While not all olorisha perform Diloggún, it is not restricted by gender/sexuality/possession experience, but to those who have gone through the considerable study required to learn to system. The gender/sexuality segregation in divination is the source of some tension within the community.

Rituals performed to alleviate issues that arise in the course of divination are far too numerous to account for here. A ritual may be as simple as speaking to an orisha, or lighting a candle, or as complicated as performing an animal sacrifice, preparing a series of sacred foods, taking a series of sacred baths, having an ornate party, or committing yourself to orisha devotion through kariocha initiation. The purpose of ritual is to restore balance to the person by realigning them with an orisha or egun that they’ve gotten out of alignment with. A misalignment which has resulted in whatever issue brought them to the oracle in the first place (Brandon 1991; Nodal and Ramos 2005).

Possession rituals called toques or tambors or bembes are public rituals in Lucumí. Possession is an important element of Lucumí. The state of possession is cultivated through ritual and managed by a priest/ess in order to protect the person experiencing it. In spirit possession the orisha in question will provide people in attendance individual advice, ritual prescriptions and spiritual cleansing as well as enjoy the hospitality of the host and community. Formal possession rituals involve sacred bata drums which have been consecrated to the orisha Aña. These drums are played by sacred drummers and accompanied by a singer, the akpwón, all of whom must be initiated to Aña. The drumming and singing are the method by which an orisha is called to mount one of their initiates. If a lay person in attendance shows signs of possession, the elders of the community generally remove them from the area to prevent the possession out of concern for the effect it might have on an inexperienced person. Not all devotees experience possession, but those that do provide a great serve to the community as through them others are allowed close communication with the orisha

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Lucumí is not institutionalized and does not have a system of centralized leadership. The casa templo is the center of religious activity and constitutes a religious family. Within the religious family the person who heads the family is the iyalosha/iyalorisha (mother of the orisha) or babalosha/babalorisha (father of the orisha) often referred to colloquially as the madrina/padrino or godmother/godfather of the members of the house. The inner circle is generally made up of godchildren who have been initiated, oloshas, the longest “elders” in ritual, as opposed to age, and/or have received many different initiations or orisha. The outer circle is generally made up of aleyos, individuals who have been consecrated within the house with necklaces, warriors, or other rituals, but have not gone through the formal kariocha. Beyond that, people who may visit the house for readings or rituals intermittently are referred to as iworo (visitors).

Many houses are multi-religious, including Kardecian Spiritism in their work. These houses hold regular spirit masses, which serve to keep a schedule of open engagement. While Lucumí is hierarchical and based on years of initiation and experience, Spiritism is structurally distinct. Lucumí levels of initiation do not affect positionality in Spiritism, which is determined by how effective a person is as a spirit medium. To become a successful spirit medium requires training and discipline but does not involve initiation.

Some Lucumí rituals require an oriaté, a ritual expert. The oriaté conducts major ritual and divinations, such as the itan of initiation when a new olorisha is made. The oriaté is expert in the complete ritual corpus for every orisha and is more knowledgeable than the average olorisha. Oriatés work at many different houses and so they are often an outsider to any given casa templo, but are a link within the larger community. Oriatés can have their own godchildren and their own casa templos, but a person cannot be both godparent and oriaté at the same ritual, so when an oriaté is serving as a godparent, they have to hire another oriaté to conduct the ritual.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Mainstream stigma toward African derived religions remains a challenge for the Lucumí community. The religion is not as familiar as the adjacent religion of Vodou, a widely misunderstood and misrepresented religion often maligned in mainstream media and culture, but Lucumí still experiences some of this, often racially biased, negative coverage in social discourse. Animal sacrifice is often a source of discomfort for the mainstream American audience largely alienated from the food production that it relies so heavily on.

Leaders in the religious community and academics debate the use of the term syncretism and how it relates to questions of purity and authenticity. Many academics argue that the term syncretism is incorrect to describe the religion because the rituals and sacrifices that make up religious practice have no relation to Catholicism. Furthermore, Catholic iconography is easily disposed of with no effect on religious practice. Some African American religious nationalist members of the religious community have illustrated this by stripping Catholic iconography away and replacing it with West African iconography in an effort to “purify” religious practice, arguing this is more authentic. Cuban members of the religious community have argued that Cuba’s long history of religious practice constitutes authenticity. These debates often bleed into debates about racial identity and cultural appropriation. The debates have led to a branching off of devotees who look to Yoruba people in Nigeria today as a source of religious authority versus devotees who look to Cuba as a source of religious authority.

Questions of authenticity and authority also overlap with questions of gender and sexuality, especially in relation to divination and sacred batá drumming. Traditionally only cis-gender heterosexual men who have never experienced spirit possession can becomes babalawos. Conversely, the Diloggún divination system is open to all who have done the kariocha initiation. Some discourse places babalawos at the top of religious hierarchy. This approach to the religion has received push back from women and men specifically disqualified from reading Ifá who argue that babalawos cannot make santeros. Consequently, their religious role is ancillary to that of an iyalorisha/babalorisha. Mary Ann Clark observes two different approaches to religious practice, the “oriaté-centered” and the “babalawo-centered.” In the “oriaté-centered” house an oriaté conducts all major rituals and divinations except a few that only a babalawo can perform. In the “babalawo-centered” house, babalawos fulfill many more ritual functions, except those that only an oriaté can perform. That said, though it is controversial, there are women initiated into Ifá as iyanifa (mother of Ifa) or iyalawo (mother of the secrets), openly homosexual babalawos, and houses that have babalawos participate more extensively in ritual (Clark 2007:24-26). Initiation to the orisha of the drum, Aña, is also limited to men, meaning only men can call orisha into possession at sacred tambors, a very esteemed position. In both spheres there have been movements to start initiating woman into these ranks, but both have been highly controversial.

IMAGES

Image #1: Birthday celebration for Omo Shango. Credit: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Havana_-_Cuba_-_2939.jpg. Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported.
Image #2: Osain. Credit: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Normal_Osain.jpg. Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International.
Image #3: The Yemaya Temple in Trinadad, Cuba. Credit: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Trinidad-Santer%C3%ADa_(2).jpg. Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license.
Image #4: Omo Shango reading Diloggun. Credit: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Santero-omo-shang%C3%B2.JPG. Public Domain.

REFERENCES

Abimbola, W. 1971. “The Yoruba Concept of Human Personality.” Pp. 73-99 in La Notion de Personne enAfrique Noire. Collogues Intemationaux de Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique. Paris: Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, # 544.

Barnet, Miguel and Esteban Montejo. 1994. Biography of a runaway slave. Willimantic: Curbstone Press.

Bascom, William R. 1950. “The focus of Cuban santeria.” Southwestern Journal of Anthropology 6:64-68.

Brandon, George. 1993.  Santeria from Africa to the New World: The dead sell memories. Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press.

Brandon, George. 1991. “Sacrificial Practices in Santería, an African-Cuban Religion in the United States.” Pp. 119-47 in Africanisms in American Culture, edited by Joseph E. Holloway. Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press.

Clark, Mary Ann. 2007. Santeria: Correcting the myths and uncovering the realities of a growing religion. New York: Bloomsbury Publishing.

Knight, Franklin. 1977. “Origins of Wealth and the Sugar Revolution in Cuba, 1750-1850.” Hispanic American Historical Review 57:231-53.

Makinde, M. Akin. 1984. “An African concept of human personality: The Yoruba example.” Ultimate Reality and Meaning 7:189-200

Moreno Fraginals, Manuel. 1977. “Africans in Cuba: A Quantitative Analysis of the African Population in the Island of Cuba.” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 292:187-201.

Murphy, Joseph M. 2008. “Orisa Traditions and the Internet Diaspora.” Pp. 470-84 in Orisa Devotion as World Religion: The Globalization of Yoruba Religious Culture, edited by Jacob K. Olupona and Terry Rey. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.

Nodal, Roberto, and M. W. Ramos. 2005. “Let the power flow: Ebó as a healing mechanism in Lukumí orisha worship.” Pp. 167-86 in Fragments of Bone—Neo-African Religions in a New World, edited by Patrick Bellegarde-Smith. Champaign, IL: University of Illinois Press.

Palmié, Stephan. 2013. The Cooking of History: How Not to Study Afro-Cuban Religion. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Palmié, Stephan. 1995. “Against Syncretism: Africanizing and Cubanizing Discourses in North American orisa worship.” Pp. 73-104 in Counterworks: Managing Diverse Knowledge, edited by Richard Fardon. New York: Routledge.

Ramos, Miguel “Willie.” 1996. “Afro-Cuban Orisha Worship.” Pp. 51-76 in Santería Aesthetics In Contemporary Latin American Art, edited by Arturo Lindsay. Washington: Smithsonian Institution Press.

Publication Date:
27 May 2025

Share

Axelle Brodiez-Dolino

Axelle Brodiez-Dolino is a senior researcher at the CNRS (National Center for Scientific Research, France). Her work focuses on the history of poverty and precariousness, solidarity associations, and humanitarian action from the 19th to the 21st century. She has authored numerous articles and has published six monographs: ATD Quart Monde, une histoire transationale. La lutte contre la pauvreté, d’un bidonville à l’ONU (ATD Quart Monde: A Transnational History. The Fight Against Poverty, from a Shantytown to the United Nations) (2025, Paris: PUF); Notre part de solidarité (Our Share of Solidarity) (2022, Paris: Belopolie); Des sans-logis aux sans-domicile. Le Foyer Notre-Dame des Sans-Abri à Lyon depuis 1950 (From the Homeless to the Shelterless: The Foyer Notre-Dame des Sans-Abri in Lyon Since 1950) (2020, Saint-Etienne: Publications de l’Université de Saint-Etienne); Combattre la pauvreté. Vulnérabilités sociales et sanitaires de 1880 à nos jours (Fighting Poverty: Social and Health Vulnerabilities from 1880 to the Present) (2013, Paris: CNRS Editions); Emmaüs and Abbé Pierre (2009, Paris: Presses de Sciences Po), also available in an English Version: Emmaüs and the Abbé Pierre. An Alternative Model of Enterprise, Charity and Society (2013, Paris : Presses de SciencesPo) ; and Le Secours Populaire français, du communism à l’humanitaire (The French Popular Relief, 1945–2000: From Communism to Humanitarianism) (2006, Paris: Presses de Sciences Po).
She is editor-in-chief of the historical journal Le Mouvement social.
Since 2017, she is also a member of the National Council for Policies Against Poverty and Social Exclusion, a French body reporting to the Prime Minister.
Professional website: https://histoire-sociale.cnrs.fr/axelle-brodiez-dolino/

Share

Emmaüs

EMMAÜS TIMELINE

1912 (August 5):  Abbé Pierre was born Henri Marie Joseph Grouès in Lyon, France.

1931—1939:  Abbé Pierre became Capuchin.

1942—1945:  Abbé Pierre joined the Resistance movement.

1945—1951:  Abbé Pierre became deputy and pacifist.

1949:  The Emmaus movement was established through three significant milestones: the founding of the first Emmaus Association (summer), the reception of the first companion (September), and the arrival of the first homeless family (December).

1954 (February 1):  Abbé Pierre delivered a radio appeal in support of the homeless, garnering substantial national and international resonance.

1957:  Abbé Pierre fell seriously ill and was hospitalized in Switzerland. Concurrently, amid allegations related to a morality scandal, he was marginalized by certain members of the association and the Church, precipitating a severe internal crisis and leading to fractures within the Emmaus movement.

1963:  Abbé Pierre survived a shipwreck in the Río de la Plata. Initially presumed dead, this experience profoundly impacted him, reinforcing the necessity of establishing a formal international structure for the movement.

1969:  The “Universal Manifesto” of Emmaus was promulgated, setting forth the movement’s fundamental principles and global mission.

1971:  The first statutes of Emmaus International were formally adopted, providing a legal and organizational framework for the movement’s international activities.

1985:  Emmaus France was officially established, with the aim of unifying and structuring the diverse Emmaus groups operating within the national territory.

1996:  During the “Garaudy affair,” Abbé Pierre publicly supported his friend Roger Garaudy’s work denying the Holocaust, resulting in widespread public outrage and significant controversy surrounding his figure.

2001:  A major organizational reform led to the restructuring of Emmaus into three distinct “branches,” enhancing its operational clarity and governance.

2007 (January 22):  Abbé Pierre died in Paris, France at ninety-four.

2024: A major scandal erupted as numerous women accused Abbé Pierre of sexual violence, casting a new and serious shadow over his historical role.

2024-2025:  Three investigatory reports on sexual violations were released containing corroborating evidence of the violations.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

The founder, born Marie Joseph Henry Grouès, and later widely known as Henri Grouès (he himself sometimes wrote it with an I, sometimes with a Y), was born on August 5, 1912 in Lyon into an upper-middle-class Catholic family. His father, Antoine Grouès, came from a lineage of textile merchants. Having begun to make his fortune in Mexico, he returned to become one of the board members of the Alliance Textile de Lyon and of the Fonderies du Rhône. His mother, Eulalie Perra, was the daughter of a manufacturer specializing in tulle and muslin.

The family members were devout Catholics. Antoine was actively involved in charities, notably the Hospitaliers-Veilleurs, an old association devoted to washing, grooming, and shaving beggars each Sunday. Henri vividly recalled when his father, at the age of  eleven or twelve, first introduced him to the charity’s activities. The family also experienced a traumatic event, that would cast a long shadow over Henri’s life. In 1920, Antoine’s sister, Louise Grouès, was accused of murdering her husband; after a widely publicized trial, she was convicted in 1922 and sentenced to twenty years of hard labor (Leroy 2018).

In 1925, Henri joined the scouts, where he was given the totem name “Meditative Beaver.” He pursued most of his education at the Jesuit College, followed by studies at the Catholic Faculty of Lyon. In late 1926, during his adolescence, he fell in love with a boy named Yves, whose “voice was like that of an angel,” a passion that deeply tormented him for four years (Violet 2007).

A turning point came during a 1927 visit to Assisi, where he experienced a spiritual revelation centered on the figure of Saint Francis, solitude, and renunciation. Frail in health and often bedridden, he spent considerable time reading and reflecting, gradually forming a religious vocation. This process culminated in his decision to become a monk, a path he saw as a way to atone both for his personal sexual turmoil and his family’s disgrace. In November 1931, he took his vows with the Capuchins, the most austere branch of the Franciscan order, which he regarded as the most ascetic. In 1932, now known as Brother Philippe, he entered the convent at Crest (Drôme), where he studied for seven years. He was ordained a priest on August 24, 1938. Yet archival records reveal a series of crises during his monastic life, which he eventually left in April 1939. He was then assigned to the Diocese of Grenoble as vicar of the Basilica of Saint Joseph.

Following military mobilization and a bout of pleurisy, he took up a post as hospital chaplain (September 1940), then as a priest overseeing religious instruction at a state orphanage (January 1941). In the summer of 1942, he returned to Grenoble as vicar of the cathedral, marking the beginning of his involvement in the Resistance. Initially tasked with sheltering Jews and helping them escape to Switzerland (July 1942), he went on to establish Alpine smuggling routes and forge identity documents.

By February 1943, he began hiding men evading the Service du travail obligatoire (Compulsory labor service in Germany for French men). He founded a Resistance group (maquis) in the Chartreuse mountains, later expanding into the Vercors, and launched a newspaper for training maquis leaders. He also produced and distributed underground leaflets titled Résistance, promoting the spiritual dimension of the movement and assisting in the dissemination of Témoignage chrétien publications. Forced to flee Grenoble, he went into hiding in Lyon in September 1943, adopting the pseudonym “Abbé Pierre.” From November 1943 to January 1944, he worked with the regional Resistance headquarters and served as a liaison officer. He also aided in the escape of General de Gaulle’s paralyzed brother to Switzerland. Pursued by authorities, he relocated to Paris in February 1944 under the alias “Abbé Houdin” and joined the Information and Documentation Centre (CID) of the National Resistance Council. Arrested by the Gestapo in May on his return from Spain, where he was organizing a Pyrenean escape network, he managed to escape and was subsequently sent to Algiers. There, he served in the Information and Diplomatic Departments, met General de Gaulle, and continued his Resistance work as a naval chaplain in Morocco. In January 1945, he was appointed to the Ministry of the Navy in Paris. At the end of the war, he was decorated with several honors. It was also during the war, in 1943, that he met Lucie Coutaz-Repland (1899–1982), a Christian trade unionist, affiliated with the Daughters of the Heart of Mary, and member of the Resistance. She became his devoted collaborator from 1945 until his death.

In the postwar period, he was invited to stand for election to the National Constituent Assembly as a deputy for the Mouvement Républicain Populaire (MRP), serving from 1945 to 1951. He resigned from the party in protest over the government’s repression of the Brest construction workers’ strike in April 1950 and its colonial war policies in Indochina. During his tenure as a deputy, he advocated for the legal recognition of conscientious objection.

Simultaneously, he became an active pacifist and was elected vice-president of the Universal Movement for a World Confederation, an organization promoting global peace. In December 1947, he contributed to the work of the United Nations Commission on the drafting of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in Geneva, where he met Albert Einstein. In 1948, he also helped found the Support Committee for Garry Davis, a pacifist activist and self-declared “citizen of the world.”

As deputy, he rented in 1947 a large, dilapidated house in the Paris suburb of Neuilly-Plaisance in which to reside during sessions of the National Assembly. He began renovating the property with the intention of transforming it into both a youth hostel and an international reception center for Christians (including seminarians and priests associated with the Mission de France). This initiative coincided with a period during which Christians sought to recover hope in the aftermath of the Shoah. The center was named “Emmaus” by Abbé Pierre, in reference to the biblical account of Easter Monday, when the disciples, encountering the resurrected Jesus, regained their hope.

In September 1949, a former convict from Cayenne (Guyana), Georges Legay, attempted suicide. Upon returning to France, he had lost everything (his wife, his daughter) and had fallen into complete despair. He was brought to Abbé Pierre. Shortly thereafter, in December, a family left homeless shortly before Christmas also found refuge there. At the end of the 1940s, France was indeed grappling with a very severe housing crisis, exacerbated by decades of political inertia, wartime destruction, rural exodus, and the post-war baby boom. The plight of isolated men (former legionnaires, ex-prisoners, alcoholics…) was similarly neglected by existing social structures. The development of what would become the modern Emmaus movement thus emerged at the intersection of these two pressing needs: welcoming isolated men into communities where, through salvaging and constructing homes, they could serve homeless families.

From 1950 onwards, the Emmaus movement expanded significantly, welcoming an increasing number of isolated and destitute men, as well as homeless families. However, its real breakthrough occurred following Abbé Pierre’s widely publicized appeal on February 1, 1954, broadcast on two major French radio stations. Within a month, the campaign raised the equivalent of $28,650,000. The appeal was further amplified by L’Osservatore Romano, the Vatican’s official newspaper, and received international press coverage. Referred to as the “insurrection of kindness,” this mobilization led to the creation of numerous shelters and Emmaus communities across France.

In the years that followed, Abbé Pierre [Image at right] enjoyed widespread international acclaim and was invited to speak at conferences around the world. These included the United States and Canada (1955), Germany (1956), the Netherlands and Portugal (1957), Austria, India, Sweden, and Belgium (1958), Lebanon and South America (1959), and Gabon alongside Dr. Albert Schweitzer (1960). During his travels, he developed relationships with Indian leaders and disciples of Gandhi, including Vinoba Bhave, and established lasting friendships with Dom Hélder Câmara, then Auxiliary Bishop of Rio de Janeiro, and Mgr Georges Mercier, Bishop of Laghouat in the Sahara, both of whom shared his commitment to the cause of the underprivileged. Convinced that development was integral to peace, Abbé Pierre became one of the first French Christian leaders to advocate for the development of the Global South and the fight against world hunger.

Emmaus groups were subsequently established in numerous countries, each pursuing diverse missions: assisting individuals affected by leprosy (Rwanda), maintaining a presence in shantytowns (Argentina, Peru, Brazil), organizing ragpickers’ cooperatives (Japan, Lebanon, Italy, Canada), sending volunteers to developing countries (Sweden, Denmark), supporting men in distress (United States), expanding health and social services (India, Indonesia), and caring for war orphans (South Korea). Some of these groups formally joined the Emmaus movement after initially engaging in related activities independently, while others were founded by returning volunteers inspired by their experiences in France or by the example set by Abbé Pierre.

The history of Emmaus was profoundly shaped by two major events. Between late 1957 and July 1958, Abbé Pierre was hospitalized in Switzerland under the official pretext of illness and exhaustion, although a personal inclination towards women, then considered unspeakable, was the principal reason for the decision. The decision was made by the highest authorities of the French Church under pressure from the Vatican. This hospitalization, orchestrated jointly by the Church and Emmaus leadership, led to significant tensions and an internal split within the movement.

Following his discharge, Abbé Pierre became less involved with the French groups, focusing instead on the international expansion of Emmaus. A second turning point occurred in July 1963, when, during a trip to South America, he survived a shipwreck on the Rio de la Plata. Having been initially presumed dead, he came to recognize the urgent need to formalize the organization’s structure. This realization led to the adoption, in 1969, of a “Universal Manifesto” articulating Emmaus’ core values and principles, followed by the establishment of its first international statutes in 1971.

In the 1970s, various Emmaus groups across the world shifted towards the left, influenced by Marxist ideologies and/or liberation theologies, while others remained more conservative, maintaining a charitable, apolitical stance. As a result, the movement as a whole did not adopt a unified political orientation.

In the early 1980s, in the aftermath of the oil crises and the economic downturns of the previous decade, mass unemployment and homelessness re-emerged prominently in France. Once again sought after by the media, Abbé Pierre experienced a renewed period of widespread fame throughout the 1980s and 1990s. In 1984, to mark the 30th anniversary of his 1954 appeal, he played a central role in “Abbé Pierre’s Christmas,” a major fundraising campaign that triggered an outpouring of donations. That same year, he was invited by the Prime Minister as part of the government’s anti-poverty initiatives, and contributed to the launch of Food Banks in France. In 1989, he was again in the spotlight during the 40th anniversary of the Emmaus movement, marked by the release of the widely publicized film Hiver 54 (Winter 1954).  From 1990 to 1994, he remained a prominent figure in the media, adopting a notably avant-garde position on the issue of undocumented and homeless people. During this time, he was even voted France’s most popular public figure sixteen times.

During the 1980s-1990s, in response to growing social needs, Emmaus significantly expanded its initiatives targeting the unemployed (through various work integration programs), the homeless, and those living in substandard housing, extending its activities well beyond its traditional communities. In 1992, the Fondation Abbé Pierre pour le logement des défavorisés (Abbé Pierre Foundation for Housing the Disadvantaged) was established, the only Emmaus entity to bear the founder’s name.

Internationally, the movement was strongly influenced by alter-globalization currents between 1980 and 2000.  This turning point is particularly due to Abbé Pierre. In October 1987, he publicly advocated for the cancellation of foreign debt in developing countries (a cause then supported by the Pontifical Commission for Justice and Peace) and co-signed a letter addressed to the International Monetary Fund. In July 1989, he participated in the foundational mobilization of the alter-globalization movement in Paris and endorsed an open letter to the G7 heads of state. He was subsequently invited to serve as an international expert at TOES (The Other Economic Summit), a counter-summit representing the seven poorest countries. In 1994, alongside Ricardo Petrella, he spoke on behalf of Emmaus International at the meeting held in parallel with the G7 summit.

Abbé Pierre also maintained a steadfast commitment to peace: supporting democratic renewal in Benin with Emmaus International in 1990; campaigning against the Gulf War in 1991; meeting the Dalai Lama at the Interfaith Days for Peace in 1992; and, in 1995, traveling to besieged Sarajevo.

Abbé Pierre had been awarded France’s highest honors (Grand Cross of the Legion of Honor in 2004). He passed away on January 27, 2007 at the age of ninety-four. His death prompted widespread national tributes.

Since 2000, Emmaus has continued to diversify its activities in France, placing particular emphasis on supporting refugees and undocumented migrants, as well as aiding in the rehabilitation of individuals completing prison sentences, or developing innovative approaches to reconcile social assistance for vulnerable populations with the imperatives of ecological transition. Internationally, the organization has broadened its mission to encompass the fight for social justice, world peace, universal access to fundamental rights, and the linking of social and environmental struggles, while also promoting the concept of universal citizenship. Emmaus now comprises 300 groups within France and operates in forty-one countries worldwide. Its activities include recovery and recycling; promoting access to health care, education, housing, culture, and peace; advocating for democracy, gender equality, access to clean water, and environmental protection; supporting fair trade, micro-credit initiatives, and efforts to combat over-indebtedness.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Until the 1960s, the majority of Emmaus activists, like French society at large, were Catholics, drawn from both the political right and left. Abbé Pierre once envisioned the creation of an “Order of Monks of Misery,” although this project never materialized. Each community, and often groups of communities, had its own chaplain, a practice that persisted in some cases into the 1970s or 1980s. Subsequently, the role of chaplains gradually diminished. Since the 1980s, Emmaus has been explicitly non-denominational, although it continues to include a number of Christian members.

From its inception, Emmaus has promoted autonomy through work, even if, in practice, this ideal could not be fully realized across all activities, particularly those involving the care of homeless individuals or people living in inadequate housing. The dual objective is to empower individuals, through recovery work that restores their dignity, providing not merely “something to live on” but rather “a reason to live.” It also ensures the financial independence of the organizations themselves, thereby preserving their autonomy from public authorities.

Among other foundational principles, Emmaus advocates solidarity with the most disadvantaged and adheres to the guiding ethic of “serving those who suffer most first.”

RITUALS/PRACTICES

The community, in which “companions” live and work together, has been the most emblematic form of Emmaus since its inception, reimagining the utopian ideal of the Christian community. For many years, communities observed religious practices such as reciting grace before meals and celebrating Mass; however, these rituals gradually disappeared from the 1980s onward.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Non-community structures were established as early as 1954, including groups of volunteer “friends” assisting individuals in debt, sending milk shipments or volunteers to the Global South, maintaining a presence in shantytowns, supporting persons with disabilities, and other activities (See, Group History). These initiatives have expanded significantly since the 1980s to encompass work-based social integration programs, shelters for the homeless and inadequately housed, reception centers for asylum seekers, and rehabilitation facilities for individuals nearing the end of their prison sentences.

Since 1957, Abbé Pierre has not served as the president of any Emmaus organization, either in France or abroad. Nevertheless, he continued to act as a tutelary figure, offering advice, participating in general assemblies, and maintaining a strong symbolic presence across the movement.

In France, starting in 1954, various activities began to organize autonomously: a social housing company, community groups, a newspaper, and “committees of friends without communities,” among others. Over time, “federations” of communities emerged, each advocating different principles; for instance, whether or not to professionalize communities, whether or not companions should be granted responsibilities, whether to emphasize national or international solidarity, and whether to welcome women, couples, and children. By the 1990s, there were as many as seven federations of communities.

As activities diversified, an umbrella organization, “Emmaus France,” was established in 1985 to serve as the institutional representative of the movement vis-à-vis public authorities. Since 2001, Emmaus France has been structured into three “branches:” communities; social action and housing; and solidarity economy and inclusion.

In parallel, Emmaus International was founded in 1971 to unite all Emmaus groups worldwide. Since 2000, continental groups have also been formed. All member groups are required to adhere to the Emmaus International Charter and to pay an annual membership fee.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Throughout its history, Emmaus has faced several local financial scandals, although these were isolated incidents. It has also been revealed that Paul Desort, one of Abbé Pierre’s key collaborators from 1953 to the early 1970s, led a life marked by fraudulent activities (both before, during, and after his time with Emmaus), including the embezzlement of funds within the organization (Leray 2016).

More recently, in 2023, Emmaus was significantly affected by a case involving the exploitation of undocumented migrants in certain communities in northern France.

Additionally, Abbé Pierre himself was implicated in two scandals, both of which had repercussions for Emmaus: one during his lifetime and the other posthumously. The first, known as the “Garaudy affair” in 1996, involved Roger Garaudy, a former Communist Party official and member of parliament from 1946, who had remained close to Abbé Pierre throughout their lives. Garaudy, having been expelled from the Communist Party in 1970 due to disagreements over policy, converted to Islam in 1982. In December 1995, Garaudy published Les Mythes fondateurs de la politique israélienne (The founding myths of Israeli policy), which included statements that denied the Holocaust. This led to legal action against him in the spring of 1996. The situation escalated when Abbé Pierre, without apparently really reading the book, publicly supported his friend’s work in April 1996. He persisted in his support for several weeks, despite mounting controversy. Abbé Pierre’s stance was widely condemned by the political class, and as a result, Emmaus was forced to temporarily exile him to Italy. From that point onward, Emmaus assumed full control over media coverage, which had previously been dominated by Abbé Pierre.

The second major scandal emerged in July 2024, set against the backdrop of the #MeToo movement and the revelations of widespread sexual abuse by clergy. In France, this led to a comprehensive independent investigation and the 2021 publication of a high-profile report by CIASE, the “Independent Commission on Sexual Abuse” in the Catholic Church. In 2023, initial testimony regarding sexual violence committed by Abbé Pierre was presented to the Church authorities, prompting a request for a broader investigation. Emmaus then commissioned Egaé, a firm specializing in sexual violence, to conduct the inquiry and issued a public call for testimonies. Three reports were published, one in July 2024, another in September 2024, and the final one in January 2025. It was revealed that Abbé Pierre had committed sexual assaults throughout his life, from at least the early 1950s to 2006. The majority of the incidents involved inappropriate touching of women’s breasts and forced kissing, though more serious allegations, including rape, incest, and pedophilia, were also reported. A total of fifty-seven cases have been documented to date, with thirty-three of these fully corroborated; but it is likely that these represent only a fraction of the assaults perpetrated by the priest.

These reports garnered significant media attention and spurred further journalistic investigations. In September 2024, the French Church agreed to open its archives on Abbé Pierre to journalists and researchers, prompting new journalistic investigations and numerous revelations about the priest’s life, including its darker aspects (Cherel and Etchegoin, 2025).

IMAGE

Image #1: Abbé Pierre, by Wim van Rossem, in the World Union Conference Peace Organisation at Pieterberg, 27 August 1955 (Nationaal Archief, Fotocollectie Anefo).

REFERENCES**

** Unless otherwise noted, the material in this profile is drawn from Axelle Brodiez-Dolino, Emmaüs et l’abbé Pierre. Paris: Presses de Sciences Po, 2009.

SUPPLEMENTARY RESOURCES

Bonnet, Roland and Marin, Gérard. 1969. La grande aventure d’Emmaüs. Paris: Grasset.

Brodiez-Dolino, Axelle. 2017. “1954. Vers un nouvel humanitaire.” pp. 654-57 in Histoire mondiale de la France, edited by Patrick Boucheron. Paris: Le Seuil.

Brodiez-Dolino, Axelle. 2009. Emmaüs et l’abbé Pierre. Paris: Presses de Sciences Po.

Brodiez-Dolino, Axelle, with Mary, Brigitte. 2014. “GROUÈS Marie, Joseph, Henri, dit l’abbé Pierre.” dans Le Maitron. Dictionnaire biographique du mouvement ouvrier français, en ligne. Accessed from https://maitron.fr/spip.php?article157926 on 12 May 2025.

Chabaud, Céline. 1998. Hiver 1954: l’apparition de l’abbé Pierre et d’Emmaüs dans la conscience sociale française. Mémoire de maîtrise d’histoire, Université Paris X-Nanterre.

Cherel Laetitia and Etchegoin Marie-France. 2025. Abbé Pierre: La fabrique d’un saint. Paris: Allary Editions.

Chevallier, Bernard. 1979. Emmaüs ou venger l’homme. Paris: Le centurion.

Coutaz, Lucie. 1976. Avec les chiffonniers d’Emmaüs. Charenton: SCEPES.

Doudet, Sophie. 2022. L’abbé Pierre. Paris: Gallimard.

Dreyfus, Michel. 2009. “GARAUDY Roger, Jean, Charles.” dans Le Maitron. Dictionnaire biographique du mouvement ouvrier français, en ligne. Accessed from https://maitron.fr/spip.php?article50436 on 12 May 2025.

Emmaus International, Emmaus France, Abbé Pierre Foundation. 2024. Investigation Report. Paris, France.

Lefevre, Denis. 2001. Les combats d’Emmaüs. Paris: Le Cherche-midi.

Leray, Gérard. 2016. Monsieur Paul, l’escroc qui aimait les pauvres. Lèves: Ella Éditions.

Leroy, Michel. 2018. Le Procès de Madame Bassarabo: La ténébreuse affaire de ” l’Amazone rouge.” Paris : L’Harmattan.

Lunel, Pierre. 1992. Quarante ans d’amour. Paris: Éditions n°1.

Lunel, Pierre. 1989. L’abbé Pierre, l’insurgé de Dieu, Paris: Éditions n°1/Stock.

Rodet, Anne-Sophie. 2003. Naissance et fonctionnement d’Emmaüs International (1949-1988), un rassemblement d’initiatives autour de l’esprit “Emmaüs,” Mémoire de maîtrise, Université Paris IV-Sorbonne.

Simon, Boris. 1971. L’abbé Pierre et les chiffonniers d’Emmaüs. Paris: Le Seuil.

Violet, Bernard. 2007. L’abbé Pierre. Paris: Fayard.

Publication Date:
22 May 2025

Share

The Family International (1919-2010)

THE FAMILY INTERNATIONAL TIMELINE

1919:  David Brandt Berg was born in Oakland California.

1935:  Berg graduated from high school in Monterey, California.

1944:   Berg married Jane Miller.

1946 (July):  Karen Elva Zerby was born in Camden, New Jersey.

1948:  Berg became a minister in the Christian and Missionary Alliance, leading a congregation in Valley Farms, Arizona.

1954:  Berg met Fred Jordan, head of the Soul Clinic located in Los Angeles, and partnered with him in ministry.

1968:  The Children of God was founded.

1968:  Berg separated from his wife, Jane Berg, and married Karen Zerby (known within the movement as Maria Fontaine).

1969:  Berg wrote the first in his series of “Mo Letters,” which became the means by which he communicated with followers.

1971 (April):  Berg and Maria relocated to London.

1972 (February):  Berg announced his status as God’s prophet and therefore his voice.

1972:  Members began migrating to Europe, Latin America, and East Asia at Berg’s behest. The movement claimed 130 communities in seventy nations with 10,000 members.

1975 (January 25):  Richard P. Rodriguez (Ricky), was born to Karen Zerby in Tenerife, Spain.

1978: Berg introduced the doctrine of the Law of Love, permitting sexually liberal practices.

1978:  The Children of God changed its name to the Family of Love.

1978:  Berg implemented a reorganization of the movement, the “Reorganization Nationalization Revolution.”

1986:  Maria forbade sexual contact between adults and minors. This prohibition subsequently became an offense that warranted excommunication.

1987:  “Flirty Fishing,” a sexually liberal form of proselytization was officially discontinued.

1991:  The Family of Love shortened its name to The Family.

1991 – 1994:  Dozens of communal households of Family members were the target of government raids in seven countries on three continents, with ensuing court cases.

1994 (October):   David Berg died in Costa de Caparica, Portugal. Karen Zerby assumed leadership of the movement and married another group leader, Steve Kelly.

1995: The Family’s Charter of Rights and Responsibilities was instituted.

2001: The Family adopted digital platforms for all communications and publications and developed a public online presence.

2002: The Family Board Structure was introduced on local, regional, national and international levels to democratize the leadership structure.

2004:  The Family changed its name to The Family International.

2005 (January 5):  Karen Zerby’s son, Ricky Rodriguez, murdered former group member Angela Smith and committed suicide.

2010:  A far-reaching reorganization, known as “the Reboot” was initiated.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

The Children of God/The Family International was founded by David Berg (referred to as Moses or Mo in the early years of the movement). Berg was born in Oakland, California in 1919. His maternal grandfather had been a Methodist circuit rider and later the leader of a movement within the Disciples of Christ. Berg’s parents, Hjalmer Emmanuel Berg and Virginia Lee Brandt, were both Christian evangelists. After they parted ways with the group (that later became the Disciples of Christ) over doctrinal issues, they joined the Christian and Missionary Alliance, but they pursued their mission largely independently. During his childhood Berg often traveled with his parents as they evangelized. For much of Berg’s early life evangelizing took place around Miami, Florida where his parents led a number of large revival meetings.

After Berg graduated from high school in 1935, he became a minister in the Christian and Missionary Alliance in Valley Farms, Arizona in 1948. He was subsequently expelled from his ministry position after some conflict with local church authorities involving “integration policies and radical preaching that they should share more of their wealth with the poor” (Van Zandt 1991:32).

Berg took a three-month course on evangelism conducted by Fred Jordan, who ran the Soul Clinic in Miami, Florida in 1954. He went on to work with Jordan, booking his radio programs in stations across the country. He also established a small clinic of his own, the Florida Soul Clinic. Berg persisted amid considerable conflict with local authorities for a period after which Jordan commissioned Berg and his family to run a branch of the Soul Clinic located on a ranch near Mingus, Texas as a missionary training school. Ultimately, Berg and his family left Florida to evangelize independently. It was during this period that his musically inclined children formed a singing group, Teens for Christ (Bainbridge 1997:218).

The Berg family returned to Jordan’s ranch in 1964. The following year Berg’s mother visited the ranch and reported that she had received a Warning Prophecy that the Endtime was imminent and the Antichrist would appear (Bainbridge 1997:218):

Even now the skies are RED, RED with WARNING, and BLACK, BLACK with clouds gathering for the GREAT CONFUSION which is ALMOST UPON YOU!

Berg became convinced of the accuracy of his mother’s prophecy.

Berg and his family moved to Huntington Beach, California in 1967 to be close to his mother, who died the following year. She had appealed to him to come to California to reach the hippie generation. Berg then determined that he was called to rescue the members of the hippie counterculture who he regarded as a lost generation. He and his four children began this initiative through a gathering place for young adults, the Light Club coffee house in Huntington Beach, California. Berg’s children ministered on the beaches and evangelized through the coffee house where they offered free meals.

Berg embraced the anti-establishment orientation of the 1960s counterculture, offering as a solution the withdrawal from corrupt, established institutions and a total commitment and devotion to Christ (Bainbridge 1997:219). In line with this iconoclastic stance, his children and the early followers began picketing local churches, which Berg referred to as “old bottles” and  part of a religious system he referred to as “churchianity” (Van Zandt 1991:33). The resistance from the churches and local law enforcement and a prophecy that one of the new recruits received in 1969 warning that an earthquake would strike California led to a decision in 1969 to organize the fledgling group of followers into a caravan and embark on an evangelizing mission that centered on proselytization and Bible study. The group attracted considerable publicity as a result of its public demonstration which featured members proclaiming a message of warning to America while dressed in red sackcloth, carrying Bibles and long staffs. Their foreheads were smeared with ash, and they wore large wooden yokes around their necks that symbolized their mourning for America’s forsaking God. They proclaimed their message with large scrolls that contained a Warning Prophecy (Van Zandt 1991:35). A local reporter took note of the group and referred to them as The Children of God and to their leader as Moses (Bromley and Cowan 2015:103). By the end of the 1960s, the group had about fifty members.

Early in 1970, the caravan arrived at the 400-acre Texas Soul Ranch. This began a period of change, organization and growth. As there were now children in the group, they began developing a system of child socialization and established a communal lifestyle. Members adopted biblical names. The group also gained use of an abandoned building in Los Angeles and used it as a proselytization center. The movement was very successful in its proselytization during the early 1970s, establishing a number of colonies in the U.S. and Europe. There was, however, a falling out with Fred Jordan with the result that the group left the ranch and formed colonies in a number of other locations.

The movement’s mobility, aggressive evangelization, and recruitment successes soon attracted opposition, not only from churches but also from parents of converts. The organization of opposition, media coverage, and the emergence of “deprogramming” to “rescue” members created a more hostile environment for the movement. (See, Issues/Challenges) Partly as a result of this more hostile climate, Berg and Maria moved to London in 1971 and thereafter communicated with movement members solely through “Mo Letters.” Over the following decades Berg would write and distribute to movement members some 3,000 letters containing his revelations, teachings on the Bible, and directives for organizing the movement and its missional activity. This distancing from his followers served to increase and preserve Berg’s charismatic standing.

Berg also encouraged members to exit the U.S., and 1972 witnessed the beginning of a mass exodus to Europe, South America and parts of Asia. For group members this exodus represented a rejection of corrupted western societies and bringing the gospel to third world nations.  Soon a majority of the membership had migrated to other nations and began forming colonies and proselytizing in their new locations, often with less targeted opposition.

The emphasis on proselytization and new opportunities created by migration produced movement growth to around 1,400 members in 1972. A year later the movement claimed another thousand members in 140 colonies in forty nations.  As the movement spread out geographically and into other cultural settings, the size of the individual “colonies” that were formed was reduced and their cultural diversity increased. Another effect was that the small, separated colonies relied on the Mo Letters for movement continuity. These letters grew in importance in February 1972 when Berg announced that he was the voice of God and God’s prophet (Van Zandt 1991:42). In 1973, Berg decided to use the Mo Letters for public distribution through “Litnessing,” which effectively combined proselytization and fundraising.

In January 1975 Richard P. Rodriguez (Ricky), was born to Karen Zerby and Carlos Rodriguez as the result of a flirty fishing liaison while the group was residing in Tenerife, Spain.

In February 1975, more radical changes were made to the group’s organization and structure. The “New Revolution” placed a “renewed emphasis on recruitment and personal proselytization and sought to reorganize and democratize local colony life” (Van Zandt 1991:44). This had the effect of limiting the size of colonies and the rate at which they could admit new members. By the year’s end there were 725 colonies in 70 countries with 4,215 full-time members (Van Zandt 1991:44). Recruitment techniques, at this time, were focused more on educated people who were both more receptive to the message than dropouts as well as brought along fewer personal problems to deal with and solve. Younger potential converts were also being allowed to participate though not to live in the colonies, and a new designation of “catacomb member” was given to them. The New Revolution also established new, elected leadership positions.

What proved to be a significant event in the movement’s history took place in 1976 when a series of Mo Letters was published displaying the theme “King Arthur’s Nights.” In those letters Berg outlined a new form of missionizing that came to be known as “flirty fishing” (or FFing, as it was called), which he connected back to a biblical passage referring to Jesus calling his disciples to be “fishers of men.” The idea originated when Berg and Maria were on the island of Tenerife in 1974. When Maria danced with a man named Arthur in a nightclub, Berg saw the potential for incorporating this kind of relationship into proselytization, using dating and sexual attraction to create the conditions for sharing a spiritual, salvationist message (Barker 2016:408). Berg began experimenting with this approach, which came to include sexual relationships (Bainbridge 1997:222). He and Maria first experimented with this followed by  other women in Berg’s colony. Out of these experiences he developed a script for such encounters and went on to promote the practice from 1976-1977. The practice spread through some, but not all segments of the movement, until it was discontinued in 1987, in part due to the dangers of sexually transmitted diseases. By the movement’s own account, about 1,000,000 individuals had been approached in this way, and 200,000 of these relationships involved some form of sexual connection.

In January 1978, Berg initiated yet another radical change in movement leadership. After receiving reports of abusive practices by leaders at various levels, some of which were his own family members, he announced the “Reorganization Nationalization Revolution” (RNR) (Bainbridge 1997:222; Melton 2004:8-10). The leadership structure was dismantled, and many members left the movement. The governance structure was replaced by a democratic system at the colony level. Since the movement had expanded into many nations, representation of national and cultural groups was emphasized. All members now received all Mo Letters personally and were free to correspond with Berg directly. The year following  the RNR a Mo Letter was circulated, inviting members who had exited to return. A level of membership was also established whereby non-communal members could affiliate with the movement.

In the aftermath of the murders/suicides at the Peoples Temple in Guyana Berg grew concerned that the movement could be swept up in the media coverage warning of dangerous cults. He wrote a series of letters under the title “Nationalise Re-organise Security-wise Revolution” encouraging members to seek a lower profile in their missional activities and to return home for family visits. This combination of events made it difficult to maintain movement solidarity  and reduced  proselytization activity of the membership (Van Zandt 1991:52). Berg addressed the issue of movement cohesiveness in 1981 with the “Fellowship Revolution,” which represented an attempt to coordinate weekly gatherings amongst local homes, as well as on a regional and national level (Melton 2004:9-10). At the same time, Berg reaffirmed himself as the movement’s prophetic source of authority. The Fellowship Revolution was followed in 1984 by publications encouraging “combos,” larger homes formed by combining smaller ones.

One the innovations that the movement incorporated in the early 1980s was musical ministry. A Music with Meaning international radio program ministry, developed in 1980, became very popular, particularly in Asia and its counterpart, Musica con Vida in Latin America and aired in hundreds of radio stations.  Despite its success, Berg was not enthusiastic about this as he considered radio programs to be a form of mass evangelism, which he considered less effective as a proselytization tool and he worried about drawing undue attention to the movement. This led to the production of music cassettes and eventually CDs for personal evangelism, as well as videos, which the members distributed in multiple languages around the world and became a significant means of financial support.

By the late 1980s, childhood socialization and education had become a significant issue, as hundreds of children were born into the movement. Homeschooling was the preferred method for education and the movement began producing materials to support the upbringing of the children within the Family’s worldview (Bainbridge 2002:150-52). For example, “Kiddie Viddies” which were music videos of children singing inspirational songs, were developed and distributed to the general public, as well as viewed internally. Not surprisingly, religious education was a major concern. As parents began homeschooling, World Services, the movement’s international administrative infrastructure, issued publications to families that were intended to provide a suitable educational curriculum and appropriate teaching techniques.

Around 1990 a major demographic development began as migration reversed with some families returning to Europe and North America and establishing Family centers. At this time, a new category of membership was developed, TRF Supporter. These members expressed commitment to movement teaching and supported it with their tithes but stopped short of communal commitment. This development created greater potential support for the movement. A “Disciples Only” (DO) category was created for full-time members in communal settings. There was also an effort to strengthen member obligations to childcare and home responsibilities (Bainbridge 1997:224).

The early 1990s were an extremely tense period for the movement as there was a succession of raids on Family homes in several nations, which had a major impact on the movement, the members, and its future trajectory. Although the movement was successful in the legal forums in each case, these events were disruptive and unsettling and resulted in far-reaching organizational change. In particular, during a child custody dispute between a mother and grandmother, Berg was severely reprimanded by the presiding judge, who demanded certain assurances from Family leadership (See, Issues/Challenges).

In the midst of this highly tumultuous period, David Berg died in 1994 at age seventy-five. Berg, who had been in semi-retirement for several years, had already prepared for leadership succession, and Maria quickly assumed the reins of leadership. Shortly thereafter, Maria married another movement leader, Steve Kelly (known within the movement as Peter Amsterdam), which re-established a family leadership unit (Bainbridge 1997:225).

In the aftermath of Berg’s passing and the court cases, movement reshaping began in 1995 with the adoption of the “Love Charter,” or as it was subsequently retitled, Charter of The Family International. This document, prepared by World Services under Peter Amsterdam’s direction, consisted of two parts, the Charter of Responsibilities and Rights and the Fundamental Family Rules. The creation of the Charter was a collaborative project, drafted in consultation with both legal counsel and input received from members via a series of grassroots workshops conducted around the world, and voted on by the continental leadership. The Family’s Charter was a legal, rational-statutory document, created in response to internal pressures that arose due to the second generation’s demands for change and external pressures in response to the government raids and court cases of the early to mid-1990s (Shepherd and Shepherd 2007:235–36).

The document defined the movement’s identity, beliefs, goals and mission. Notably, it described members’ rights and responsibilities, while documenting the rights of parents and children. Three levels of membership were introduced to accommodate people’s varying levels of commitment as members progressed through the life cycle of the movement, as well as the difference in experience and commitment of second-generation members approaching adulthood. The Charter emphasized the implementation of democratic processes for leadership roles in all aspects of movement governance. Those unwilling or unable to accept the membership terms specified in the Charter for the “Disciples Only” category were offered a choice between two new, more flexible affiliation categories: Missionary Member or Fellow Member.

In 2002, to further expand democratization in the oversight and development of the Family and its growth agenda, the Board Vision was introduced, which resulted in the creation of a board structure for core elements of the Family. Boards were formed on the national, regional and international levels that addressed various areas of Family life, including church growth and outreach, children and parenting, homeschooling education; coaching and shepherding; and public relations. While the boards were introduced to democratize and promote areas of the Family’s life and mission, it also afforded WS a more effective system of institutional guidance and control of the communal homes’ Christian outreach programs and basic home standards (Shepherd and Shepherd 2005:76-77).

As second-generationers came of age and began to depart from the movement in increasing numbers from the mid-1990s onward, corporate direction in the writings became focused primarily on TFI’s internal world, the sheltering of youth from corrosive influences, and the preservation of “the spirit of the Revolution for Jesus” (Fontaine 2001). As the leadership sought to retain the purity of its beliefs and communal lifestyle, authority became increasingly more centralized. The use of corporate prophecy for guidance and direction for the movement was institutionalized from the late 1990s onwards, and prophecy was regularly published with specific instructions on policy and lifestyle issues and beame the essential mechanism for directing the Family’s communal way of life (Shepherd and Shepherd 2009:740–42).

In 2006, Peter and Maria announced that the focus of the movement would be shifted from internal matters to its evangelical mission in what was referred to as “the Offensive.” Numerous missives were published to that end and homes were required to meet and create strategies for enhancing their evangelistic reach and growing the membership of the movement in a new category of congregational style “general members” loosely affiliated with the movement (Amsterdam 2006). In preparation for growth, a process of examination of the movement’s communal lifestyle, worldview and approaches were the subject of in-depth analysis by leadership in 2009 and the “Change Journey” was enacted with the goal of making the movement more relatable to the contemporary world (Amsterdam 2009).  Unexpectedly, this process would result in the disassembling of the movement’s governance structure and communal homes at the Reboot in 2010 and the movement’s transition to online religion (Shepherd and Shepherd 2013:79).

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Many of the movement’s doctrines are consistent with central conservative Christian doctrine (the Bible as the inspired Word of God, the Trinity, the Virgin birth, salvation by faith in Christ), but was distinctive in other respects up until 2010. Similar to the beliefs of the Jesus People Movement from which it came out, the Children of God embraced biblical literalism, the conviction that followers were living in the “time of the end,” and the urgency of sharing the Gospel with the unsaved. An “essentially anti-intellectual, anti-historical, and anticultural view of the world” were evident in Berg’s writings (Enroth et al. 1972: 16). For committed members, there was a clear biblical injunction: “So likewise, whoever of you does not forsake all that he has cannot be My disciple” (Luke 14:33). Members were expected to “drop out” of the World (referred to as the System) and “forsake all” by abandoning their studies, possessions and careers. This total commitment was strengthened by the belief that the moral and spiritual corruption of contemporary society was so profound that a moment of divine reckoning was at hand.

Prophecy and revelation were prevalent in the writings of the movement from its early days, with David Berg being proclaimed as in those writings as “the Endtime prophet” and in corporate prophecy published after his death from 1995-2010. Berg’s writings, and subsequently Maria’s, were considered to be “God’s Word” for today and placed on an equal footing with the Bible up until the Reboot in 2010. Berg’s prophetic ministry was focused on eschatological interpretations, including the prediction that the fulflillment of the book of Revelation in the Bible and the end of the world would occur in the early 1990s during the lifetime of the membership. Maria later developed a collaborative process for the publishing of corporate prophecy, which involved the participation of members of World Services, the Family’s administrative body, and an editing process (Shepherd and Shepherd 2006:44).

Evangelism has been central to the movement’s belief system throughout its history, as expressed in its Mission Statement (The Family International 2012):

The Family International (TFI) is committed to sharing the message of God’s love with people around the globe. We seek to bring hope and spiritual renewal through the unconditional love of Jesus Christ that knows no borders or boundaries of race, creed, or social status. We strive to make a difference in our world by offering spiritual solutions for the challenges of life and translating God’s love into actions that manifest kindness and compassion and improve the lives of others. We endeavor to follow the example of Jesus, whose ministry was ‘to preach the Gospel … to heal the brokenhearted, to proclaim liberty to the captives and recovery of sight to the blind’ (The Bible, Luke 4:18 NKJV).

We are committed to:

Making the World a Better Place: Sharing the message of God’s love for humankind.

Spiritual Development: Providing spiritual and emotional support for managing the challenges of modern life.

Humanitarian Assistance: Enhancing the quality of life of the disadvantaged, displaced, and those without hope.

Beyond the movement’s idealistic, salvationist message Berg’s writings from 1968-1978 clearly expressed an uncompromising, iconoclastic message that challenged the established social order, the “System.” Berg critiqued the entire range of established institutions for its adherence to the status quo, materialism, oppression of the poor, and abandonment of preaching the Gospel. His message called for adherence to the basic message of the Gospel of love of God and love for others as the path to elimination of human suffering and division. As Berg expressed it in his early writings):

Jesus Christ was a revolutionary! He was not a reformist! He attacked the System of His day!—Not the Roman government, that was ordained of God, but He attacked tooth and tong in no uncertain terms the false religious system and its advocates and participants and leaders.—If you don’t believe it, just read the Bible! (See Matthew 23)

The most controversial component of Berg’s theological doctrines was the Law of Love, in particular its applications to sexuality. These emerged out of Berg’s announcement that Christians were no longer beholden to the Mosaic Law but through the introduction of Christ’s Law with his death and resurrection were to be guided by the Law of Love. This doctrine was based on Jesus’ proclamation in the Bible that all the law depended on two commandments: “Love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind” … “Love your neighbor as yourself” (Matthew 22:36-40).

Berg’s pronouncement meant that the Ten Commandments no longer applied, which included prohibitions of extramarital relationships. Therefore, consensual sexual relationships amongst the membership that did not cause harm were deemed acceptable (Berg 1984; Melton 2004:11–12). This conclusion was part of Berg’s wide ranging consideration of those implications. According to Van Zandt, at one point Berg concluded that “neither incest nor sex with capable children was prohibited by God and that there should be no age or relationship limitations on sexual activity” and cited cases from other cultures in which young children were married (Van Zandt 1991:54).

In 1986, Maria published a prohibition of sexual contact between adults and minors, which was pronounced an excommunicable offense in 1989, and previous publications by Berg that speculated on the boundaries of sexual interactions were banned and officially removed from circulation in a movement wide “Pubs Purge” (Melton 2004:55-56).

The Law of Love doctrine  also served as the rationalization for  the implementation of “flirty fishing” into the movement’s proselytization campaigns. Flirty fishing (introduced in 1977 and discontinued in 1987) led to sensationalized media coverage of the movement as a “sex cult” (Wallis 1979:78–80; Van Zandt 1991:46–48; Barker 2016:408–09).

RITUALS/PRACTICES

From its early days as the Children of God, the movement was organized as a communal society, with members living under one roof and common-potting expenses and sharing in homecare duties, the care of children, outreach, and the procurement of food (known as “provisioning”). The movement adopted the model of the early church, as per Acts 2:44 in the Bible: “All who believed were together and had all things in common. And they were selling their possessions and belongings and distributing the proceeds to all.” As the movement grew and spread to different regions and cultures, life in the communes became increasingly institutionalized. Each home was financially autonomous and responsible to procure donations and other means of financial support.

Throughout much of the movement’s history, secular employment and education were considered incompatible with full-time missionary membership, and children were homeschooled within the communal homes. Children’s educational resources were created in-house, in particular for religious education, many of which were also made available to the public.

Prophecy and revelation were core beliefs of the Family from its early Children of God days.  In his prophetic role, Berg’s writings contained revelations and prophetic claims, which confirmed his charismatic status and oriented the periodic disruptive restructuring, known are revolutions, introduced into the movement (Shepherd and Shepherd 2006:35). Prophetic revelations published by Berg, and subsequently Maria, were considered to be the “Word of God” on a par with, and an extension of, the Bible (Chancellor 2008:19). Members were also encouraged to exercise the “gift of prophecy” as noted in the Bible for their personal direction, as well as within the communes for guidance for their collective work.

Most significantly, Berg predicted that the Second Coming was imminent, potentially during the early 1990s. He predicted that America would be destroyed forty days after the Comet Kohoutek’s appearance in 1973. There also were several predictions of economic collapses. He took the precaution of not forecasting these crises with absolute certainty. He also created plausible deniability in some cases by suggesting that his prophecy had been misinterpreted or that prophesied events had occurred but were not visible to humans (Van Zandt 1991:55; Borowik 2023:21-22).  After Berg’s death, Maria introduced a new understanding of disconfirmed prophecy, theorizing that God’s sovereign will was changeable and fluid, due to the decisions of people or nations or other intervening factors (Fontaine 1994).

Following Berg’s death Maria introduced the practice of channeling messages from Jesus and other figures, referred to as “spirit helpers,” who were departed Christians or angelic beings. Messages were also channeled on occasion by mythic figures, recontextualized as angelic beings (Merlin, Aphrodite) or famous people (Elvis, Marilyn Monroe, Winston Churchill).

Routine movement activity also was ritualized. For example, as has been the case with many Christian groups, proselytization was not simply about membership growth; it was a spiritual encounter in which proselytizing members understood themselves as offering the gift of spiritual salvation. Similarly, in “flirty fishing,” members understood themselves as engaging in sexual intimacy in order to present the Gospel message. Ritualization of sexuality extended into sexual relations among members, as well as in their personal devotion through the introduction of the “Loving Jesus Revelation” by Maria in 1995, whereby members could imagine Jesus engaging with them in sexual activity.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

From the early days, Berg was the undisputed leader of the movement, as his charismatic status gradually increased to the status of  prophet. In 1972, Berg announced through the letter The Laws of Moses that his letter were “the voice of God Himself” and that he was God’s prophet  (Van Zandt 1991:42). In 1970, Berg introduced a leadership hierarchy, which included a structure for leadership on the local, regional, national and international levels (Davis and Richardson 1976:328-30). Initially, he appointed his family members to key leadership positions, but in 1978 during the RNR he disassembled this structure. By 1982, during the “Fellowship Revolution,” a new structure had been implemented, providing oversight on the regional, national and international levels. While variations to this leadership framework were introduced over time, the Family maintained some version of this form of structure until 2010.

When Berg left the U.S. in 1972 and urged his followers to do likewise, he went into seclusion and from that time onward, the location of his home was not disclosed to the public or to the membership. He communicated to followers exclusively through the Mo Letters from that time until his death, and was not directly involved in the leadership and administration of the homes or in international leadership meetings, known as Summits. In 1975, Berg implemented a movement-wide administrative infrastructure, known as World Services, tasked with the printing and distribution of publications, collection and analysis of reports, creation of evangelistic and children’s publications, and financial management of monthly tithes from the homes. World Services functioned as the Family’s administrative and oversight body until 2010, at which time it was disassembled.

Throughout the movement’s history, the communal units (colonies, homes) varied in size as movement priorities changed. The composition of homes also changed as movement members moved to Europe, South America and then Asia. Homes assumed characteristics of the surrounding culture both as a practical matter and because home culture individuals joined the movement. Two basic principles structured the movement: communal organization and family.  The basic unit of the movement was the communally organized “home” where disciples followed the early church model of holding all things in common. Followers understood themselves to collectively constitute the “Bride of Christ” family and pledged total commitment to the movement and its mission.

All of this changed, of course, with the stunning announcement in 2010 of the “Reboot” (Borowik 2018:62–63).

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

The movement has faced a variety of challenges through its history: oppositional groups, governmental raids on movement homes, membership attrition,  and the murder/suicide of Maria’s son Ricky.

Oppositional groups constituted a major challenge for the movement. When Berg and his children began their outreach at a coffee house in Huntington Beach, California amid the youthful protest culture, they quickly attracted a following. The then small group soon began a mobile witnessing and proselytizing campaign that stretched into Canada. The group’s high visibility and successful recruitment quickly drew opposition. What was then the Children of God and other new groups, such as the Unification Church and Divine Light Mission soon were labeled “cults” (Bromley and Shupe 1981). The early efforts to combat “cults” focused primarily on “rescuing” individual members. Much more significant for movements were elements of the opposition that were able to gain access to governmental legislative and regulatory mechanisms.

The first oppositional group to appear in the U.S. was FREECOG (Free Our Children from the Children of God), which was formed by William Rambur and other parents whose offspring had joined The Children of God (Shupe and Bromley 1980). FREECOG asserted that young affiliates actually had been brainwashed or programmed by various means, and sought the “rescue” of the recruits. The first “deprogrammer,” Theodore “Ted” Patrick, who was serving in the Great Society Program in California, was the first to offer his services to extract movement affiliates at the behest of parents of a young adult who had joined the Children of God. A deprogrammer network quickly developed that was moderately successful in extracting individuals who had only a short-term relationship with the movements it targeted (Patrick 1976). The threat of deprogramming created a more adversarial, defensive relationship between a number of new religious movements and outsiders, attracted enormous media coverage, and produced a number of former members willing to support cult/brainwashing claims. A steady stream of books, and newspaper articles, and television documentaries have followed the movement through its history, featuring brainwashing and abuse claims (Shupe and Bromley 1980; Williams 1999; Hough 2021; Young 2022). Berg’s daughter, Deborah Davis, collaborated with her husband one of these negative depictions, The Children of God: The Inside Story, that received considerable publicity (Davis 1984).

Oppositional groups also sought political support for their cause, particularly legislation that would allow parents to gain legal custody over their adult offspring. They led an effort that resulted in the production of a negative assessment of the movement by the New York state attorney general in 1974 (Wallenstein 1974). However, by that time the movement had largely completed its relocated to Europe, South America and Asia.

By far the most significant external campaign against the movement occurred over a five-year period from 1989-1994,  during which time there was a series of investigations and government raids on movement homes. . These occurred in Argentina (1989 and again in 1993), Peru (1990), Spain (1990), Australia (1992), Brazil (1992), France (1992), and Venezuela (1992). The 1990 raid in Barcelona, Spain resulted in twenty-one children being taken into custody. Although medical and psychological evaluations did not show evidence of abuse or neglect, the children were held in state custody for nearly twelve months. The appeal’s court found no supporting evidence for the removal of the children and exonerated the movement, while expressing outrage at the procedures and comparing the conduct of the police to the excesses of the Spanish Inquisition (Bainbridge 2002:10–12; Melton 2004:34-35). The 1992 raid in Australia involved six communities and 142 children were taken into custody; after a week the children were all returned to parental custody. A subsequent suit on behalf of the children resulted in a confidential financial settlement (Palmer 2011:60-62; Richardson 1999:180-81).

In 1993, two homes in France were raided by armed police, and ninety children were taken into custody. Some of the children were held for over a month. The cases took some time to resolve through the appeals court, but in 2000 all of the charges were dismissed by the appellate court (Borowik 2014:15-16; Richardson 1999:181). In that same year, five Homes in Buenos Aires, Argentina were raided at night; twenty-one adults were incarcerated on a pre-trial basis and 132 children were taken into state custody for examination. The adults remained incarcerated and the children were held in state custody in institutions for nearly four months before all charges were dismissed upon appeal. Similar to the case, in Spain, the appellate court castigated the lower court judge, comparing the raid ordered by the court to a witch hunt (Wright and Palmer 2016:73-92).

The raids, the seizure of over 500 children, the ensuing court cases, and the negative publicity attending them had a significant impact on the movement (Richardson 1999:181). The movement launched protests, invited journalists and court officials to visit and academics to interview members. It developed a public affairs department and became proactive in religious freedom issues (Borowik 2023:33-40).

A wardship case filed in 1992 had a major organizational impact, as remedial steps were introduced to satisfy the demands of the court. The presiding judge concluded that the Story of Davidito book (removed from circulation in 1989) was evidence that child abuse had occurred within the movement. Following a three-year investigation, the judge ordered the movement to distance itself from Berg’s teachings on childrearing, amongst other things before he would award the Family member in question the custody of her child to be raised in a Family home. Peter and Maria formally acknowledged that Berg’s influence and views were the source of sexually inappropriate behavior that had harmed children (Fontaine 1995; Barker 2022:23–24). The judge acknowledged that reforms had been instituted and that “the wrongs of the past had been stamped out” and granted custody of the child in question to the mother (Bradney 1999:217–18).

The requirements made by the court would impact the group at the organizational level, as it resulted in the drafting of the Family Charter, the implementation of standardized educational requirements for children, and establishing better relations with former members, as the leadership offered apologies to disaffected former members and sought reconciliation and dialogue. In 2007, the movement published “The Family’s History, Policies, and Beliefs Regarding Sex” in which it acknowledged and apologized for its past practices and the misapplication of Berg’s law of love doctrine (Amsterdam 2007; Fontaine and Amsterdam 2008).

Another significant challenge to the moment has been member disaffiliation. The movement’s growth in its early years derived from a surplus of conversions over defections, and membership turnover rates were always high, as they were for other movements of this era. Essentially, expansive membership growth was only achieved during the period when there was a large pool of available seekers. Procreation within the movement could only partially offset growth through new affiliates, and children also shifted members’ time and group resources to childrearing and away from full-time proselytization (Bromley 2013:254). Crises and restructurings within the movement, such as the RNR and the efforts to maintain a low profile where the movement was controversial, took a toll on membership, and its numbers declined during the 1990s. A further challenge to the movement occurred during the early 2000s as a significant number of second-generation members began to drift away from the movement. Some former members maintained contact for a time through the Moving On website (defunct since 2009) that offered resources for the transitional process.

The murder/suicide of Ricky Rodriguez in 2005 exacerbated the already contested image of the movement. Maria gave birth to Richard P. Rodriguez (Ricky) in 1975. Ricky was expected to become the movement’s guide for the endtimes, and his childhood years were recorded in The Story of Davidito, written by his caregiver as a model for childrearing. However, Ricky left the movement, reporting sexual abuse that he and other children growing up in David Berg’s household had experienced. In 2005, he murdered former member Angela Rodriguez who was previously a member of WS  and then committed suicide. He left a video note describing the violence as retribution for the abuse that he and other children had experienced.

The movement has had an interesting trajectory, one that parallels other movements of its era and another that diverges substantially. The movement took advantage of the 1960s protest environment, locating in one of its most active areas in Southern California, successfully recruiting more new members than it lost, and offering an attractive countercultural vision. It outflanked initial opposition by relocating outside the U.S. and building numerous outposts with potential for membership growth. There were no serious schisms. The RNR did result in a loss of membership and the formation of opposition to the movement, but it was not a serious challenge to the movement. It survived numerous “revolutions” and prophetic disconfirmations that might have undermined Berg’s charismatic stature. There was a smooth leadership transition at the passing of the founder/leader. After Berg’s passing, numerous democratizing changes were introduced, first through the introduction of the Charter and then the board structure. The missionizing was also modernized through the publishing of resources geared toward a larger audience, in particular with the Family’s signature magazine, Activated, which has been in print for over 20 years in 19 languages.

The movement faced new challenges from 2002-2009, which led to monumental change being introduced at the Reboot, essentially disassembling the organizational structure, disavowing its extrabiblical doctrines and deconstructing its communal household model. The Reboot was the final result of numerous issues and challenges the movement was dealing with from the early 2000s onwards, including the coming of age of the second generation and their dissatisfaction with the world-rejecting philosophy of the movement and desire for modernization; the aging of the first generation and implications of their care, and the inability to successfully build congregational style membership due to the internal focus of the writings and its communal lifestyle, and the controversy surrounding the movement from past issues.

At the same time, the movement ultimately was unable to prevent opponents from influencing governments in a number of countries to undertake police actions against the movement. While the movement was successful in countering most of these initiatives, they were disruptive and discrediting. The sexual abuse allegations were particularly damaging as they overlapped the wave of scandals that impacted many religious traditions and offered a new angle of attack for opponents. The movement undertook a number of initiatives to distance itself from its earlier history, but the damage had been done and has continued to haunt the movement given the ease of dissemination of information online. Internally, the movement faced the kind of mobilization fatigue from first generation members and loss of passion among second generation members that has beset many new movements. This combination led to the sudden “Reboot” that essentially brought the communal experiment to an end. While the movement continues to have an online presence, there is little evidence that there will be a regeneration of the movement to its earlier form and vision.

IMAGES

Image #1:

REFERENCES

Amsterdam, Peter. 2009. The Change Journey. Internal document. The Family International.

Amsterdam, Peter. 2007. The Family’s History, Policies, and Beliefs regarding Sex, Parts 1–3. Internal documents. The Family International.

Amsterdam, Peter. 2006. Training for the Winning Offensive. Internal document. The Family International.

Bainbridge, William S. 2002. The Endtime Family: Children of God. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.

Bainbridge, William Sims. 1997. The Sociology of Religious Movements. New York: Routledge.

Barker, Eileen. 2022. “What Did They Do about It? A Sociological Perspective on Reactions to Child Sexual Abuse in Three New Religions.” Pp. 13–38 in Radical Transformations in Minority Religions, edited by Beth Singler and Eileen Barker. London: Routledge.

Barker, Eileen. 2016. “From the Children of God to the Family International: A Story of Radical Christianity and De-radicalising Transformation.”Pp. 402-421 in Handbook of Global Contemporary Christianity: Movements, Institutions, and Allegiance, edited by S. J. Hunt. Leiden: Brill.

Berg, David. 1984. Amazing Grace!—Free at Last! Internal document. The Family.

Berg, David. 1977. “Our Declaration of Love.” Children of God. Accessed from https://childrenofgod.com/en/message/ on 19 February 2025.

Borowik, Claire. 2023. From radical Jesus People to virtual religion: The Family International. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Borowik, Claire. 2018. “From Radical Communalism to Virtual Community: The Digital Transformation of the Family International.” Nova Religio 22:59–86.

Borowik, Claire. 2014. “Courts, Crusaders and the Media: The Family International.” Pp. 19-40 in Legal Cases, New Religious Movements, and Minority Faiths, edited by James T. Richardson and François Bellanger. Farnham: Ashgate.

Bradney, Anthony. 1999. “Children of a Newer God.” Pp. 210-23 in Children in New Religions, edited by Susan Palmer and Charlotte Hardman. London: Rutgers University Press.

Bromley, David. 2013. “Changing Vision, Changing Course: Envisioning/Re-Visioning and Concentration/Diversification in NRMs.” Pp. 247-60 in Revisionism and Diversification in New Religious Movements, edited by Eileen Barker. Burlington, VT: Ashgate.

Bromley, David. G. and Anson Shupe. 1981. Strange Gods: The Great American Cult Scare. Boston: Beacon Press.

Chancellor, James D. 2008. “The Family International: A Brief Historical and Theological Overview.” Sacred Tribes Journal 3:5–32.

Cowan, Douglas E. and David G. Bromley. 2015. Cults and New Religions: A Brief History (Second Edition). Oxford: Wiley Blackwell.

Davidito, Sara. 1982. The Story of Davidito. Spain. The Family. [Publication removed from circulation in 1989.]

Davis, Deborah (Linda Berg). 1984. The Children of God: The Inside Story. Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan Books.

Davis, Rex and James T. Richardson. 1976. “The Organization and Function of the Children of God.” Sociological Analysis 37:321-39.

Enroth, Ronald., E. E. Ericson, and C. B. Peters. 1972. The Jesus People: Old-time Religion in the Age of Aquarius. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans.

Fontaine, Maria. 2001. “Be True to the Revolution!” Internal document. The Family.

Fontaine, Maria. 1995. “An Answer To Him That Asketh Us!” Internal document. The Family.

Fontaine, Maria. 1994. “The Jonah Phenomenon!” Internal document. The Family.

Fontaine, Maria and Peter Amsterdam. 2008. “An Open Letter of Apology to Current and Former Second-Generation Family Members.” The Family International. Accessed from https://thefamilyinternational.org/en/about/letters-of-apology/ on 10 May 2025.

Hough, Lauren. 2021. Leaving Isn’t the Hardest Thing. New York: Vintage.

Melton, J. Gordon. 2004. The Children of God: ‘The Family’. Salt Lake City: Signature Books.

Palmer, Susan J. 2011. “Rescuing Children? Government Raids and Child Abuse Allegations in Historical and Cross-Cultural Perspective.” Pp. 51-79 in Saints under Siege, edited by Stuart. A. Wright and James T. Richardson, eds. New York: New York University Press.

Patrick, Ted and Tom Dulack. 1976. Let Our Children Go! Dutton.

Richardson, James T. 1999. “Social Control of New Religions: From Brainwashing Claims to Child Sex Abuse Accusations.” Pp.172–86 in Children in New Religions, edited by Susan J. Palmer and Charlotte E. Hardman. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.

Shepherd, Gary and Gordon Shepherd. 2013. “Reboot of The Family International.” Nova Religio 17:74–98.

Shepherd, Gary and Gordon Shepherd. 2005. “Accommodation and Reformation in the Family/Children of God.” Nova Religio 9:67–92.

Shepherd, Gordon and Gary Shepherd. 2009. “Prophecy Channels and Prophetic Modalities: A Comparison of Revelation in the Family International and the LDS Church.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 4:734–55.

Shepherd, Gordon and Gary Shepherd. 2007. “The Family International: A Case Study in the Management of Change in New Religious Movements.” Religion Compass 1:229–44.

Shepherd, Gordon and Gary. Shepherd. 2006. “The Social Construction of Prophecy in The Family International.” Nova Religio 10:29–56.

The Family International. 2025. “Charter of The Family International.” Accessed from https://portal.tfionline.com/en/pages/charter/ on 10 May 2025.

The Family International. 2011. “The Legacy of the Children of God.” Children of God. Accessed from https://childrenofgod.com/en/legacy/ on 19 February 2025.

The Family International. 2011. “The Message of the Children of God.” Children of God. Accessed from https://childrenofgod.com/en/message/ on 19 February 2025.

Van Zandt, David E. 1991. Living in the Children of God. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Wallenstein, H. J. 1974. “Final Report on the Activities of the Children of God.” Report Submitted to Louis J. Lefkowitz, Attorney General of the State of New York.” New York: Charity Frauds Bureau.

Wallis, Roy. 1979. Salvation and Protest: Studies of Social and Religious Movements. New York: St. Martin Press.

Williams, Miriam. 1999. Heaven’s Harlots: My Fifteen Years as a Sacred Prostitute in the Children of God Cult. Pasadena, CA: Quill.

Wright, Stuart A. and Susan J. Palmer. 2016. Storming Zion: Government Raids on Religious Communities. New York: Oxford University Press.

Young, Daniella Mestyanek. 2022. Uncultured: A Memoir. New York: St. Martin’s Publishing.

World Services. 1995. The History of the Family. Zurich, Switzerland.

Publication Date:
16 May 2025

Share