TOLSTOYAN COMMUNITIES TIMELINE
1828: Leo Tolstoy was born.
1860s–1870s: A peaceful offshoot of Russian populism, a communitarian movement, arose in the Russian Empire.
1880s: Leo Tolstoy wrote Confession, What do I believe?, What Then Must We Do?, and The Kingdom of God is Within You. Their uncensored distribution prompted the appearance of followers of Tolstoy, tolstovtsy (Tolstoyans).
1884: The populist writer Gleb Uspensky in his article “By the Labor of One’s Own Hands” articulated the ideas of the Siberian peasant Timofei Bondarev on the moral necessity of physical labor for all.
1884 (November): Tolstoy and his followers established the publishing house “Posrednik” (The Mediator).
1886: In the south of Russia in the small settlement of Uch-Dere near Sochi, Tolstoyan Nikolai Ozmidov founded the first Tolstoyan community, which disbanded within a year.
1886: Near Gelendzhik the commune “Krinitsa” was established. It exists for approximately forty years and became the largest and most economically successful communitarian settlement with Tolstoyan participation.
1888: Leo Tolstoy published Timofei Bondarev’s essay Industry and Idleness, or the Triumph of the Land-Tiller.
1888 (Winter): An informal Tolstoyan “conference of the like-minded” took place at which the decision was made to create a network of interconnected agricultural communes.
1891–1893: Tolstoyans took part in famine relief for peasants, organized by Leo Tolstoy. As a result, many began to think that the movement should shift from a purely escapist stance to a more active public position.
1895: The burning of weapons by pacifist-minded Doukhobors and the Cossacks’ violence against them spurred Tolstoyans to active defense of freedom of conscience and provoked an even greater rise in pacifist sentiments in the Tolstoyan milieu.
1898: Tolstoyan emigrés founded the publishing house “Svobodnoe slovo” (The Free Word) with centers in England and Switzerland.
1909 (February 28): The Moscow Vegetarian Society (MVS [in Russian, MVO]) opened and became a stronghold and information center for the movement.
1910: Leo Tolstoy died.
1911: In Voronezh province, Ivan Benevsky created the Rzhev Production Artel, which became the largest communitarian settlement of Tolstoyans in the pre-revolutionary period.
1917 (June): After the February Revolution, which established civil liberties, the first legal association of Tolstoyans was created, the Moscow Society of True Freedom in Memory of Leo Tolstoy (STF or MSTF [in Russian, OIS]), followed by numerous local branches.
1918 (October): Tolstoyans created the United Council of Religious Communities and Groups (UCRCG [in Russian, OSROG]), an interfaith body that became a coordinating center for religious communists and pacifists.
1920–1921: Tolstoyans Pavel Biriukov and Ivan Tregubov developed and proposed to the Bolsheviks a plan for Soviet authorities’ economic and political cooperation with sectarian communists that would ensure autonomy and freedom of conscience for communities of peaceful religious communists in Soviet Russia.
1921: Members of Tolstoyan agricultural communities took part in famine relief in the Volga region, independent from the state.
1921 (March): Tolstoyans held the First All-Russian Conference of Sectarian Agricultural and Production Communes, Communities, and Artels, which adopted resolutions sharply critical of Bolshevik policies.
1921 (October 5): The People’s Commissariat of Agriculture of the Soviet Republic issued an appeal “To sectarians and Old Believers living in Russia and abroad,” inviting religious communists to occupy the land taken from landowners, to establish religious communes that modeled economically efficient communist agriculture.
1921 (December 31): On the former landowner’s estate Shestakovka near Moscow the Tolstoyan commune “Life and Labor” was established.
1923: The Leo Tolstoy agricultural commune near the New Jerusalem station in the Moscow suburbs was founded.
1924: Tolstoyan peaceful anti-militarists attended a reception with General Secretary of the Central Committee of the Russian Social-Democratic Party (Bolsheviks), Joseph Stalin, with a petition for noninterference in their lives.
1928 (September 9–16): The USSR celebrated the centennial of Tolstoy’s birth on a grand scale. Hundreds of Tolstoyans gathered from all over the country at the unofficial celebration of the anniversary on the premises of the MVS (MVO; the Moscow Vegetarian Society). The Tolstoyans’ speeches at this celebration, vehemently opposed the Soviet authorities, resulting in repression.
1929 (February): The MVS [MVO] was closed upon the demand of the authorities.
1929–1931: The forcible conversion of religious communes into collective farms [kolkhozy] began; Tolstoyans protested against collectivization.
1929–1931: Tolstoyan and sectarian communes relocated to Siberia to avoid conversion into collective farms. In the Novokuznetsk region, the Peaceful Plowman artel, the Universal Brotherhood community, and the Life and Labor commune appeared.
1936–1940: Mass arrests and trials of members of Tolstoyan communes took place. Sixty-five Tolstoyans were arrested and convicted; twenty-four of them perished in the camps.
1937–1938: The last Tolstoyan commune, “Life and Labor,” was liquidated.
1941–1945: More than 100 Tolstoyans were convicted for refusing to go to war with weapons in their hands; many of them were shot.
1949: Tolstoyans from the Life and Labor commune who survived the repressions and the war built the village of Talzhino near Novokuznetsk.
1951: A group of Tolstoyans were arrested in the case of the “illegal Tolstoyan center;” they were accused of creating a terrorist organization that was preparing an attempt on the life of Joseph Stalin; several of those arrested were shot.
1976–1977: The process of rehabilitating the Tolstoyans began.
1978 (September): Soviet hippies attended Tolstoy’s anniversary at Tolstoy’s estate, Yasnaya Polyana.
1983: In London, writer and emigré Mark Popovsky published Russian Peasants Tell Their Story, a book about the Tolstoyan communes.
1988 (September): In the Soviet “thick” journal Novyi mir, the first permitted publication in the Soviet era of Boris Mazurin’s memoirs concerning the Tolstoyan commune “Life and Labor” appeared.
1989: Arseny Roginsky published Memoirs of Peasant Tolstoyans, with a print run of 75,000 copies.
1988–1991: Hippy-Tolstoyan Georgy Meitin published the samizdat [self-published] periodical Yasnaya Polyana in Riga, Latvia.
FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY
Tolstoyan communes appeared in the Russian Empire in the last quarter of the nineteenth century and were destroyed during the years of Stalin’s terror. They also existed in other countries: the Tolstoyan communities in Bulgaria, England, and the United States were especially well known.
The appearance of the first Tolstoyan communities marked the beginning of a new stage of development in the Russian communitarian movement. Ideologically, the Russian communitarian movement originated in the 1830s and 1840s, and it became a peaceful offshoot of Russian populism in the 1860s and 1870s. While some populists went to the people seeking to rouse the peasants to revolution, representatives of nonviolent populism pursued cultural aims: they sought to create model agricultural communes in the countryside, consisting of members of the intelligentsia or of the intelligentsia and peasants together, first, to live in accordance with their conscience, and second, to render various kinds of assistance to the peasantry (medical, educational, legal, and agronomic). This entailed the “simplification” (oproschenie) of one’s way of life, having to take the position of a person living by his or her own physical labor. Contemporaries called these settlements of members of the intelligentsia “cultured (intelligentnye) agricultural” communes or colonies.
The first Tolstoyan communities appeared in the mid-1880s; they were composed primarily of educated individuals and representatives of the privileged social estates (sosloviia). These communities broke up very quickly, because of ignorance of how to work and internal squabbles. Nikolai Ozmidov founded the first of these communities in August 1886 in the small town of Uch-Dere near Sochi. The number of permanent members of the first Tolstoyan community/commune did not exceed ten people. The settlement did not last as a community/commune even a year.
In the winter of 1888, an informal Tolstoyan “conference of the like-minded” took place at which it was decided to create a network of agricultural communities/communes with the goal of “union with the people” and “hastening the realization of the Kingdom of God on earth.” After the conference, at least seven Tolstoyan settlements in the countryside and several Tolstoyan circles on estates belonging to Tolstoyans arose. The Tolstoyan settlements were in constant communication with each other.
The years from 1891 to 1893 were a time of “intelligentsia” community members’ participation in famine relief. Tolstoyans from various communities gathered in Ryazan province to help with distributing among the needy population the donations sent to Tolstoy from all corners of the country. One of the main topics of conversation among Tolstoyans working “on the famine” was the future fate of the Tolstoyan agricultural communities.
The geography of the placement of Tolstoyan agricultural communities gravitated toward locations with a mild climate favorable for agriculture, as well as to places of traditional settlement for sectarianism. In search of remote areas free from police harassment and other forms of state control, Tolstoyans gradually moved their settlements from the central provinces to the south, to the Black Sea coast of the Caucasus, and to the Transcaucasus. (The issue of emigration to America was also repeatedly discussed.) These areas were a traditional place of exile for religious dissidents, with whom these intellectuals easily found a common language and with whom they felt a spiritual kinship.
In 1886, the Krinitsa (that meant spring of water) agricultural community/commune was established on the Black Sea coast of the Caucasus near Gelendzhik. Its founders were representatives of two early branches of Russian communitarianism. One of these branches was the radical circle that gathered around the doctor Osip Kogan and his friends, Princess Natalya Drutskaya-Sokolinskaya and Vladimir Eropkin. The second branch was initially formed by students of chemistry professor Alexander Engelhardt who, in the mid-1870s and early 1880s at his Batishchev estate in Smolensk province, conducted a social experiment on the “education” (training in agricultural work) of “intellectual tillers of the land.” From the 1890s to the 1920s, many Tolstoyans lived in and around Krinitsa. Despite internal conflicts, a lack of resources for the development of communal economy, and problems in relations with the authorities, Krinitsa exerted significant influence on the cultural life of the local population from the 1890s to the early 1920s.
In the last quarter of the nineteenth century the social base of the Tolstoyan movement consisted of members of the privileged strata of the population; among them were many aristocrats and individual representatives of the bourgeoisie. There were instances in which Tolstoyan landowners transferred their land to the peasants for free or for a nominal fee. Over time the Tolstoyan movement was democratized through both the “simplification” of its “elite” elements and the influx of a large number of peasants and workers into the movement. Women constituted approximately a third of the movement’s members, but they were not always voluntary and independent participants; often they were the wives of Tolstoyans. Tolstoyan communities, even in the Soviet period, were small: according to historian Tatiana Petukhova (2008), they can be classified as small and medium-sized collectives, whose membership ranged from five to one hundred people. Thus, they were much smaller than both religious communes of sectarians and collectives set up in the countryside by the Bolsheviks, which numbered hundreds of members.
The “intelligentsia” colonies constructed their various communitarian ideologies on their conscious opposition to revolutionary values, on striving to “repay [their] debt” to the people, [and] in a polemic with philistine “bureaucratic” ideals. Their members also rejected the values of “civilization” and, wanting to escape its “pernicious” influence, organized communities in desolate, remote locations. Tolstoyans’ life in close contact with the peasants, their work to help the hungry and sectarians persecuted for their faith, and their frequent communication with each other and with Leo Tolstoy did not pass without a trace in Tolstoyans’ self-consciousness: many of them came to think that the escapism of the communal/community movement should be replaced by a more active public stance.
One impetus to choose social activism was Tolstoyans’ participation in the defense of the Doukhobors who, after moving to a position of absolute pacifism with the act of burning their weapons, in 1895 suffered severe persecution by the authorities, as well as Tolstoyans’ participation in the international act to resettle the Doukhobors in Canada. From this point on, Tolstoyans would proclaim as their goals the active struggle for freedom of conscience and the building of a nonviolent society.
Tolstoyan communities, as a rule, existed from one to three agricultural seasons, after which they disbanded. There were many reasons for this. First, there were ideological disagreements among the participants. Second, there were financial and material problems, which entailed economic difficulties and physical hardships. Third, the insistence on the obligation of personal physical labor and the principled rejection of wage labor resulted in community/commune members suffering from a lack of free time to devote to intellectual pursuits and discussions on important topics. Police harassment of the movement’s participants was also a frequent cause of communes’ dissolution.
The practical failures of life in Tolstoyan communes and theoretical disagreements led to Tolstoyans’ preference in the decade from 1895 to 1905 for creating neighboring settlements and farms (khutors) but not communes with joint property and labor. The gradual return of Tolstoyans to the practice of establishing collective settlements would occur after the first Russian revolution, amid a wave of rising anarcho-socialist sentiments in their circles and the gradual democratization of the Russian communitarian movement.
The lack of political rights and freedoms in the Russian empire meant that Tolstoyans could not have their own legal press organs and organizations. During this period, the dissemination of Tolstoyan communitarian ideas was carried out through personal correspondence and samizdat, as well as with the help of censored books and pamphlets from the publishing house “Posrednik” (Mediator) founded by Leo Tolstoy and his friends in 1884. In 1898, Tolstoyan emigrés established the “Svobodnoe Slovo” (Free Word) publishing house with centers in England and Switzerland. Free Word’s books and periodicals served to spread Tolstoy’s ideas and especially the idea of a peaceful revolution. From the time of the first Russian revolution, Tolstoyans interpreted the movement to create communities in the context of this idea.
At the end of the nineteenth century and in the early twentieth century, under the influence of Tolstoy’s ideas, communities emerged in other countries, and Russian Tolstoyans established communication with them. Ties between Tolstoyan communities in Russia and Bulgaria were especially close.
On February 28 (16 March) 1909, the Moscow Vegetarian Society (MVS [in Russian, MVO]) was opened, which for a long time served as an informal organizational and information center for Tolstoyans. The society proclaimed as its main purpose the establishment of love and peace between all living beings; its motto was the words “One soul in all.” Within the MVS the “Information Bureau on the Organization of Agricultural Communities, Communes, and Artels” was created. The MVS periodical The Vegetarian Review published materials about communes and addresses for correspondence with those interested in the communal issue; meetings and discussions on the topic of communes took place in its dining rooms; and the bookstore at the MVS also facilitated the dissemination of the communal idea.
In early 1911, on the Rzhev estate in the Bogucharsky district of Voronezh province, which belonged to the mother of Tolstoy’s friend Vladimir Chertkov, the Rzhev Production Artel was created under the leadership of Ivan Benevsky. This artel became the largest communitarian settlement of Tolstoyans in the pre-revolutionary period. The artel united about one hundred Tolstoyans, most of whom were workers and peasants. In addition to Tolstoyans, Baptists, followers of Alexander Dobrolyubov and Vladimir Solovyov, and even Orthodox [believers] were members of the artel.
After the February Revolution of 1917, basic political freedoms were proclaimed in Russia, and the existence of legal Tolstoyan organizations and periodicals became possible. In June 1917, the Society of True Freedom in memory of Leo Tolstoy (STF or MSTF [in Russian, OIS]) was founded in Moscow. Its name came from one of Tolstoy’s articles, which quoted the Gospel saying, “And you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free” (John 8:32 ESV). According to the group’s charter, its goal was to strive for the radical transformation of modern society, which is based on state violence, into a peaceful, stateless community by means of the moral improvement of the people. Similar societies modeled on the Moscow STF began to arise throughout Russia. Among other activities, these societies engaged in the promotion of physical labor and the creation of agricultural communities. In the Soviet era, the Moscow Vegetarian Society also continued its activities. A program of lectures and numerous circles functioned under its auspices. The topics raised in the lectures included the creation of agricultural settlements, Christian socialism, the “natural life,” the land theory of Henry George, and the like.
The problems of the movement to the land in forming communes were widely covered in the Tolstoyan press. The periodicals Unity (“a journal dedicated to the renewal of life in the light of reason and love”), The Voice of Tolstoy, The Voice of Tolstoy and Unity, True Freedom, Brotherhood, The Open Word, The Word of Truth, The Way to the Light, The Seeker of Truth, and The Renewal of Life had sections that featured the facts “of awakening and moving to true life.” The periodicals of the vegetarians and Esperantists also dealt with issues of communal living, and an attempt was made to publish a transnational organ on community themes, World Unity: The Organ of Human Unity in All Forms of Thought and Action (1913–1914, published in three languages: Russian, English, and Esperanto).
After the Bolsheviks came to power, the members of Tolstoyan agricultural communities saw themselves as full-fledged participants in the revolution, not the “violent,” “materialist” revolution the Bolsheviks effected, however, but a nonviolent, religious movement within the revolution. They hoped to influence the Bolsheviks toward a softening of their policies. In this regard, Tolstoyans Pavel Biryukov and Ivan Tregubov proposed a plan to the Bolsheviks in 1920 and 1921 for the economic and political cooperation of the Soviet regime with sectarian communists, who had been called upon to provide an example of the new, communist life to the patriarchal Russian peasantry. They hoped that should this project be realized, peaceful religious communists would be able to preserve their autonomy and quietly engage in economic activities.
The People’s Commissariat of Agriculture met with the Tolstoyans and on October 5, 1921 issued the appeal “To sectarians and Old Believers living in Russia and abroad,” which called upon religious communists to engage actively in economic cooperation with the Soviet regime, occupying lands taken from landowners and creating religious communes on them.
During the implementation of this project, Tolstoyan Ivan Tregubov, who had become a staff member of the People’s Commissariat of Agriculture, defended the interests of Tolstoyans and sectarians before the Soviet government. Religious communes, including Tolstoyan communes, were most often created in this period on former landowners’ estates with the active assistance of the authorities. For example, the Tolstoyan commune “Life and Labor” was founded on the former landowner estate of Shestakovka on December 31, 1921 not far from Moscow, and the New Jerusalem community was established in 1923 in the Moscow region, also on former landowners’ land.
In addition to economic activities, Tolstoyan communes engaged in cultural and educational work, educating children in the spirit of nonviolence, and they also were collective participants in the transnational pacifist movement, particularly the War Resisters International and the International Fellowship of Reconciliation.
In the years 1921–1923, Tolstoyans participated in famine relief in the Volga region: they not only cooperated with the Soviet government’s Central Commission for Famine Relief (Pomgol) but also established the autonomous L. N. Tolstoy Committee for Famine Relief and the Committee for Public Assistance to Starving Children, which collected donations for the hungry from Tolstoyans and sectarians in Soviet Russia and abroad.
The economic successes of religious communes during the period of the New Economic Policy and the growth of their religious and cultural influence resulted by 1924 in the “sectarian project” facing imminent closure and Tolstoyans beginning to experience harassment for their antimilitarism. In 1924, at a reception with General Secretary of the Russian Social-Democratic Party (Bolsheviks), Joseph Stalin, Tolstoyan pacifists requested the legalization of their social organizations and non-interference in their lives. Participants in the meeting reported that Stalin seemed to receive them well and said: “In military affairs you are not our helpers but in peaceful construction we know you as honest and hard-working people.”
Under the Bolsheviks, Tolstoyans actively engaged in defending those who refused military service. In 1918, they created the United Council of Religious Communities and Groups (UCRCG [in Russian, OSROG]), an interfaith body that filled the role of expert witnesses in the courts for conscientious objector cases, helping to free the objectors from punishment. In addition to defending freedom of conscience, the UCRCG set itself the goal of facilitating the “rapprochement of various free-religious movements on the basis of spiritual interests.” The council’s membership included representatives of the Evangelical Christians, Baptists, Mennonites, Seventh-Day Adventists, and members of the Moscow people’s temperance group, in addition to Tolstoyans.
In March 1921, the UCRCG convened the First All-Russian Conference of Sectarian Agricultural and Producers’ Communes, Communities, and Artels, which adopted resolutions sharply critical of Bolshevik policies. The UCRCG aspired to become the central representative body for religious communists throughout Soviet Russia, who were perceived as an alternative to the Bolsheviks, embodying a peaceful, religious Russia.
Beginning in 1922, the authorities began to restrict Tolstoyans’ activities, Societies of True Freedom throughout the country were forced to close, repression against individual Tolstoyans began, and conflicts between Tolstoyans and local authorities became more frequent. During these years the publication of Tolstoyan periodicals was banned. Instead of legal periodicals, illegal samizdat bulletins from Tolstoyans were sent to subscribers under the auspices of the Moscow Vegetarian Society (MVS) until the mid-1930s. These bulletins published articles by Tolstoy, addresses for correspondence between like-minded individuals, and articles on topics related to the movement to create communes around the world.
The confrontation with the authorities reached its peak in the late 1920s. In September 1928, the USSR celebrated the centennial of Tolstoy’s birth on a grand scale. At the official celebrations, Tolstoy was praised as a writer but ridiculed as a religious thinker. In contrast, Tolstoyans held an unofficial celebration in the building of the Moscow Vegetarian Society, where they gave speeches in which they openly criticized the violent and antireligious policies of the Bolsheviks. Soon after this anniversary, a new wave of arrests of Tolstoyans began, and in February 1929 the MVS was closed.
As the collectivization of agriculture got underway, the state began the forcible transformation of Tolstoyan and other religious communes into collective farms (kolkhozy). Krinitsa was liquidated, and many other religious communes ceased to exist at that time. Tolstoyans protested vigorously against collectivization through letters to the authorities, passive protest in their communes, and articles and letters they published in their underground samizdat.
Seeking to avoid conversion into collective farms, Tolstoyan and sectarian communes began to relocate from central Russia to western Siberia, with the government’s permission in the years 1929–1930. One of the key centers of religious communitarian settlements arose near Novokuznetsk in the Altai, where the Peaceful Plowman artel, the Universal Brotherhood commune, and the Life and Labor commune were established. These communes achieved impressive economic results despite constant harassment by the authorities and repressive tax policies. In the 1930s, the Life and Labor commune was the largest of the surviving Tolstoyan communes. Until its destruction in 1938, the commune was an oasis of social, economic, and cultural practices that were an alternative to the Bolsheviks’ communism.
During the Great Terror, sixty-five Tolstoyan-communitarians were arrested and convicted; twenty-four of them perished in the camps. Tolstoyan communes were liquidated and their property was transferred to collective farms. More than one hundred Tolstoyans who had refused to take up arms in military service during the war (1941–1945) were convicted; many of them were shot.
In 1949, Tolstoyans from the Life and Labor commune who had survived the repressions and the war built the Talzhino settlement not far from Novokuznetsk and organized a collective farm within it. Descendants of Tolstoyans still live in Talzhino. In 1951, a group of Tolstoyans was arrested in the fabricated case of an “illegal Tolstoyan center.” According to the investigation, some of the founders of this “center” had been exposed in 1937, and now others were arrested who had established a terrorist organization that was preparing an attempt on Stalin’s life. Two of those arrested in this case were sentenced to death, and one, Vasily Shershenev, received twenty-five years in the camps (he was released in an amnesty after five years and died very soon thereafter).
Surviving Tolstoyans preserved the Tolstoyan movement’s archives and wrote memoirs, but they did not engage in public social activity. In 1963, the Tolstoyan Dmitry Morgachev appealed to the Procurator General for the rehabilitation of the Tolstoyans and was refused; the rehabilitation process for Tolstoyans began only around 1976-1977 (they started slow and unwillingly).
Official propaganda did everything to ensure that the history of the Tolstoyan communitarian and pacifist movement would be forgotten. The vast Tolstoyan archives were closed to researchers; Tolstoy was studied only in courses on Russian literature, not in those on history and philosophy. All academic interpretations of Tolstoyanism were subordinated to Lenin’s conception of Tolstoy as a “mirror of the Russian Revolution,” a great artist and a “ridiculous” thinker. Lenin called Tolstoyans “hysterical milksops,” bourgeois and philistines, “stuffed with a moral theory about not opposing evil with violence,” “a miserable little group of people,” “who wanted to turn into dogma precisely the weakest aspect of Tolstoy’s teaching.
Nevertheless, some members of Soviet society managed to discover Tolstoy’s ideas and the history of the Tolstoyan movement on their own. Soviet dissidents and hippies did this almost simultaneously. In the mid-1970s, the writer and dissident Mark Popovsky came upon some old Tolstoyans by chance and became acquainted with their archives, on the basis of which he wrote and published in exile in 1983 the book Russian Peasants Tell Their Story, dedicated to the Tolstoyan communes. Several other dissident historians, among whom were the future founders of the Memorial society Arseny Roginsky and Dmitry Zubarev, published the memoirs of Tolstoyans in the underground historical collection Memory. Thanks to them, in 1988 during perestroika the memoirs of Boris Mazurin about the Life and Labor commune appeared in the Soviet “thick” journal Novyi mir (New World), the first permitted publication of the memoirs in the Soviet period; and one year later, the book Memoirs of Peasant Tolstoyans was published with a large print run. Dissidents interpreted the history of the Tolstoyan movement as a history of popular resistance to totalitarianism.
In September 1978, on the anniversary of Tolstoy’s birth, several dozen Soviet hippies organized a pilgrimage to Tolstoy’s estate Yasnaya Polyana in Tula oblast; among them there were those who considered themselves Tolstoyans. One of them, Georgy Meitin, would publish a Tolstoyan samizdat journal, Yasnana Polyana, in Riga from 1988 to 1991, on the pages of which he would revive anew the forgotten themes of the Tolstoyan communitarian and pacifist movement.
In the 1990s and the first decade of the twenty-first century Tolstoyans and anarchists made several attempts to establish settlements on the land on the basis of Tolstoyan ideas, but these attempts did not have any social or cultural significance.
DOCTRINES/BELIEFS
Leо Tolstoy (1828-1910) is a world-famous Russian writer and religious thinker. In the late 1870s, when Tolstoy was at the peak of his literary career, he underwent an existential crisis that changed his life completely. Tolstoy rejected institutional Christianity for the sake of the “Law of Love.” He revised world religious traditions and found that the fullest version of the “Law of Love” is given in the Christ’s commandments. However, it is also imprinted in the human heart, comprehended by the founders of religions and by the eminent philosophers, such as Confucius, Lao Tzu, Buddha, Socrates, and others. In this spirit, Tolstoy wrote numerous essays and tracts, such as: What I Believe (1883-1884); What is Religion, and What is the Essence of It? (1884); The Kingdom of God Is within You (1890-1893); Do Not Kill (1900); Christian Teaching (1897); What Then Must We Do? (1886); A Law of Violence and A Law of Love (1908); I Cannot Be Silent (1908).
Tolstoy’s ideas were directed against the autocracy, the police, and the “official” Orthodox Church. His rejection of social injustice, the division of labor, the monetary economy, private property, and the parasitism of professional and aristocratic classes led him to abandon the idea of technological progress and embrace anti-capitalist and anti-modernization views. Instead, he advocated Christian anarchism, non-violence, and communitarianism.
Tolstoy lived on his estate Yasnaia Poliana and closely communicated with the peasants, tried to work physically himself, creating the ideology of the “bread labor,” the moral duty for everyone to earn one’s own food. Tolstoy considered that the genuine Christian teaching had been spread among people by the sectarians and freethinkers and since then had existed in self-sustained, beyond-Church forms. Tolstoy was eager to overcome the individuality, regarding it as an evil and illusion, and replace it by the “people’s truth” of common life, which he had found among Russian peasants. Tolstoy believed that both he and other people could find a way to a true faith and a true life by watching common people and learning the gospel commandments.
Although Tolstoy never called for the creation of communes, he pointed to the ideal of the back-to-the-land movement, manual labour, cooperation, private property refusal. Tolstoy’s communitarian ideas allowed for both escapist and radical revolutionary interpretations.
In most cases, communities considered “Tolstoyan” were not strictly Tolstoyan; they brought together adherents of a wide variety of communitarian ideologies. People confessing various religions and sympathizing with vastly different philosophical systems and political theories could get along in one community. In addition, many members periodically changed their views and even their religious identity.
In the 1860s and 1870s, participants in communitarian settlements in Russia were enamored with the ideas of Western utopian socialists and the “positive religion” of Auguste Comte; they went to the United States to join American communitarian settlements and developed their own teachings. With the appearance of Tolstoy’s works, many participants in these early experiments found in Tolstoyanism the most accurate language for expressing their ideal and joined Tolstoyan communities. Such works of Tolstoy as Confession, What Do I Believe?, What Then Must We Do?, and The Kingdom of God is Within You were especially popular.
The first Tolstoyan communities lacked a unified ideology; instead, a shared spirit, not a collection of ideas, united their members. This outlook resulted from social and cultural aspects of the process of modernization, which the Russian Empire was experiencing at that time. The communitarian aspirations of the first Tolstoyans were the product not so much of the need for social reform, as much as they were individual quests for the meaning of life, a striving to overcome alienation and a crisis of identity. A communal way of life met these people’s needs, in “face to face” interaction with “significant others,” for a “second birth” and for finding the meaning of life in the circle of a new, spiritual family. Tolstoyans’ search for an “ideology” as a “system of ideas that gives a convincing picture of the world” was already occurring within the communities. As Benjamin Zablocki, who studied American communes, suggests (1978:109), it makes sense to evaluate these communities not from the perspective of their success in the economic or political spheres, but from the perspective of their success as institutions of identity. With time the significance of the ideological and even political element in the Tolstoyans’ communal experiments grew, reaching its peak in the 1920s and 1930s, when adherents began to perceive their peaceful communist project as an alternative to the violent communism of the Bolsheviks.
The concept of a “Tolstoyan” does not correspond to any particular collection of ideas drawn from Tolstoy. It is possible rather to speak of a more or less general worldview, a shared ethic of the participants in Tolstoyan communes, as well as of the popularity among them of various kinds of “teachings” and ideas, the enthusiasm for which came in waves, one after another. Of chief importance for Tolstoyans were self-definition through the concept of freedom (they preferred to call themselves “free Christians” or even “persons of a free religious worldview”), the idea of conscience as the voice of God, which should be above any “external” authorities, the rejection of violence against a human being’s spirit and body, and faith in the universal brotherhood of people.
Tolstoyans’ conceptions of God varied. Most Tolstoyans adhered to various rational interpretations of Christianity; there were also mystics inclined toward Eastern religions and Orthodoxy, pantheists, atheists, and agnostics; many called love, truth, or goodness God. In the early twentieth century, theosophy and anthroposophy became widespread in Tolstoyan communities; and in the 1920s, spiritual monists (followers of Petr P. Nikolaev) appeared in them. One might also encounter in Tolstoyan communities individual representatives of Russian sectarianism and independent God-seekers from the people and the intelligentsia (Syutaevtsy, Dobrolyubovtsy, teetotalers temperance activists, Evangelical Christians and Baptists, Malevantsy, and the like).
With respect to worldview, among the first Tolstoyans one finds a whole range of anti-modernization ideas that brought them closer to both Russian Slavophilism and European conservative Romanticism. Almost all Tolstoyans had a negative attitude toward capitalism and urbanization, opposed the division of labor, and aspired to a rural life in the bosom of nature, physical labor, and the “natural” upbringing of children. In the most radical cases Tolstoyans came to a complete repudiation of “civilization.”
An interesting blend of individualism and collectivism was characteristic of Tolstoyans. They combined the principle of “faith in oneself,” an individual quest for God, with the idea of inner moral self-improvement in a close circle of like-minded individuals, pursuing ethically lofty and socially significant goals. They regarded communes as local experiments, designed to change the existing order gently and gradually, to promote the establishment of new social, economic, and cultural ways of changing society. This, the most general set of social ideas on which Tolstoyan communities were built, may be called communitarianism, in the sense in which Arthur Bestor defined this movement (1978:3-4).
This understanding of a social mission developed largely in a polemic with revolutionary populism: the ideas of equality and social justice were dear to Tolstoyans, but they disliked violent methods of social change, and one can consider the communitarian movement they founded a peaceful strand of Russian populism. There were frequent cases of transition into the Tolstoyan movement from the revolutionary one due to disillusionment with violent methods of struggle.
The Tolstoyans’ ideal of a future society was an association of free, self-governing communities based on the ideals of agricultural labor and nonviolence. In the early twentieth century, thanks to close communication with like-minded individuals abroad, Tolstoyans increasingly began to define themselves as a religious-anarchist or religious-communist movement, and with time a pacifist identity came to the fore: Tolstoyan communitarianism became radical pacifism. During the First World War and the revolutionary years, many Tolstoyans already understood their movement as a peaceful revolutionary movement, regarding a worldwide revolution of brotherhood as the ultimate goal of their movement.
Ideas about a “special Russian path,” the unique spiritual and social qualities of the Russian people, and the Russian people’s tendency to collectivism were not uncommon among first-generation Tolstoyans, but over time the movement became increasingly cosmopolitan, and by the 1920s such ideas had almost completely lost their influence.
The perception of agricultural colonies as environments conducive to the development of a person’s higher individual and social attributes was widespread among the members of Tolstoyan communes. They were convinced that leaving the cities, living in the bosom of nature, and having close contact with the peasants were necessary for a person’s moral purification. Such sentiments could be justified by the ideas of Tolstoy, Rousseau, Henry Thoreau and other American transcendentalists, Edward Carpenter, and the like. The idea of common, joint labor was more popular than the idea of collective property, but still only a few Tolstoyans were advocates of private property and farming: they preferred the image of a spiritual community to its socioeconomic, material interpretations.
Tolstoyans also sought support in Russian folk-religious traditions. Especially popular among the participants in the Tolstoyan communes were the ideas of the peasant-communist Vasily Syutaev and the people’s thinker and apologist for physical labor Timofey Bondarev. In 1884, the populist writer Gleb Uspensky in his article “By the Labor of One’s Own Hands” outlined the ideas of this Siberian peasant on the moral obligation of agricultural labor for all. They made a strong impression on the youth of the populist movement and on Leo Tolstoy. Bondarev’s essay Industry and Idleness, or the Triumph of the Land-Tiller was published by Tolstoy in 1888 (Sibirskii 2010); Tolstoy himself wrote an introduction criticizing the division of labor and calling on educated people to “sit on the ground.”
As for economic theories, many Tolstoyans, taking their cue from Tolstoy, were adherents of the single-tax theory of Henry George, who proposed the abolition of all direct and indirect taxes and the move to a single tax levied on the value of land, regardless of the labor invested in it. Tolstoyans sent government agencies notes with a proposal to apply Henry George’s theory; the last such attempt was made by Sergei Bulygin, a Tolstoyan from the Life and Labor community, under Stalin in the 1930s.
The Tolstoyan movement was closely linked with the ethical wing of the Russian vegetarian movement. At a time when Tolstoyans could not have their own legal organizations and periodicals, their activities were carried out through vegetarian societies and their journals, which published materials on contemporary communitarian settlements in Russia and abroad, theoretical articles and practical recommendations on physical labor, the natural life, the creation of communities, and the like. In the 1920s, Tolstoyan communes often opened inexpensive vegetarian canteens in cities.
Considering themselves participants in a revolutionary project for the peaceful, nonviolent transformation of society, the members of Tolstoyan communities were fascinated by theories of nonviolence and civil disobedience (such as the theories of Petr Chelčický, Hryhoriy Skovoroda, Adin Ballou, Henry Thoreau, Gandhi, Romain Rolland, the idea of a general peaceful strike, and others) and thought of communes as practical experiments in the realization of life outside the existing violent structures, as seedbeds of a free, nonviolent, and natural life.
The Tolstoyan movement was also intertwined with the Esperantist movement: Tolstoyans studied Esperanto and used it in correspondence with like-minded people around the world. The publications of the Esperantists printed articles by Tolstoyans, and attempts were made to organize joint projects of Tolstoyans and Esperantists for uniting people and all living things in a single worldwide brotherhood.
Tolstoyans attached great importance to the education of children; they considered pedagogical work the most important dimension of creating new ways of life. They published literature for children, the pedagogical periodical Free Upbrining, worked with street children, and established orphanages, farm schools, and children’s colonies. It was assumed that graduates of Tolstoyan children’s institutions would acquire a certain worldview and the psychological inclination to agricultural labor and collective ways of life. The guiding principles of a Tolstoyan school were physical labor training, nonviolence, the demilitarization of consciousness, equality and mutual assistance, sobriety and vegetarianism, and school self-government.
Tolstoyan communities often had devotees of the most exotic philosophical theories: the communities were ready to accept anyone whose views did not contradict the principles of nonviolence, physical labor, and freedom of conscience. For example, “aoists,” who considered themselves “extarchists,” that is, “extragovernmentalists,” lived in the Life and Labor commune. Unlike the Tolstoyans, who aspired to the “natural,” they considered everything “natural” to be wild chaos and were convinced that in the sphere of human life it was necessary to invent something new all the time, to make everything reasonable and practical. They tried to reform language, devised their own language, “Ao,” and spoke it among themselves, came up with new names for themselves, dreamed of creating artificial suns and going on interplanetary flights, making human beings immortal, and developing a new, rational diet. They considered Tolstoy a great innovator in the field of morality.
Also, “nudists” sometimes appeared in Tolstoyan communities; they went about completely naked and even worked in this way, believing that this was a natural practice that brought them closer to nature. Although they wore trunks to the common table, they were tolerated with difficulty and excluded from the community because of the women’s displeasure.
Tolstoyans’ religious and communist aspirations are best captured in the names of their communities: Universal Brotherhood, Brotherly Life, Brotherly Labor, Banner of Brotherly Labor, Life and Labor, Unity, Goodwill, Free Life, the Free Life commune, Free Labor, the Equality commune, Kingdom of Light, the Leo Tolstoy Agricultural Artel, the Timofey Bondarev Working Agricultural Community, the Leo Tolstoy community of Free Christians, the At the Dawn of the New Life commune, the Free Conscience agricultural community of Free Christians, Good Gift, the Peaceful Plowman artel, Peace with All Living Things, the True Way of Life Universal Religious Community, the Friends of True Freedom community, the Society for the Renewal of Life in Memory of Leo Tolstoy, and the Laboring and Living Together agricultural community.
RITUALS/PRACTICES
Tolstoyan “life according to conscience” and “simplification” involved physical labor (living “by the labor of one’s own hands”), which meant training in self-sufficiency, agriculture, manual labor skills, and various DIY practices. Tolstoyans learned to plow the land and to mow, to grow grain, to tend the garden and kitchen garden, and to make their own clothes and shoes. The use of wage labor was ethically unacceptable to Tolstoyans, and practical failures to comply with this principle often caused disillusionment with communal agricultural ideals and the collapse of Tolstoyan communes.
Due to the widespread dissemination of vegetarianism in Tolstoyan communities, gardening, vegetable gardening, and beekeeping were preferred, and non-traditional methods of farming were also used. The most radical Tolstoyans extended the idea of universal brotherhood even to animals as well; hence, some Tolstoyan communities experimented with farming without the use of animals. Evgeny Popov even created a method of “manual farming” or “grain gardening,” the purpose of which was to provide oneself and one’s family with the necessary amount of plant-based food with one’s own hands, without draft animals, on a small plot of land. There were also communities that refused to send old animals no longer fit for agricultural work to slaughter; they had to keep retired animals.
In the biographies of Tolstoyans, there are numerous cases of “refusals”: refusals of social status, property, careers (military, bureaucratic, or academic), higher education, military service, church marriages, urban living, oaths to the sovereign, participation in elections, passports, and even given names. In the daily social and economic life of Tolstoyan communities, refusal to cooperate with the state was also widespread and was even enshrined at the level of the communities’ charters: there were refusals to officially register communes and land ownership, to pay all or specific taxes, to perform labor obligations, to participate in the state education system, and to obey certain laws that contradicted “conscience.” Such a position caused constant clashes with the authorities in every era and entailed severe repression in the Soviet period.
Although Tolstoy’s “Kreutzer Sonata,” written in 1890, and in general his criticism of the institution of the family, greatly impressed many Tolstoyans, few in Tolstoyan communities professed the principle of celibacy. Interest in the topic of celibacy in some of the first Tolstoyan communes can rather be explained by their religious and ascetic aspirations, as well as the perception of the community as a spiritual family in which everyone was “brother” and “sister” to each other. The statement of Benjamin Zablocki (1978:114) was also true of the Tolstoyan communes; he believed that the participants in the communitarian movement were dissatisfied with the traditional form of the family and tried to find new forms of family life. Adoption or collective upbringing of orphans, more equal relations between men and women and between parents and children, giving children unconventional, “ideological” names, addressing parents by name instead of calling them “mama” and “papa,” giving children great independence from an early age were typical Tolstoyan practices but were exotic in terms of the “larger society” in both the Russian Empire and Soviet Russia.
Specific communication practices characterized Tolstoyans. They built their movement on the network principle. The networks’ anchor points were the Tolstoyan communes, the homes of individual Tolstoyans, legal and illegal organizations and circles, vegetarian canteens, publishing houses, periodicals’ editorial offices, and book warehouse reading rooms. Important texts and useful information were disseminated through these networks, and legal and material assistance was provided. Close ties and active correspondence were established with members of Tolstoyan communities abroad, which gave them the opportunity to perceive themselves as participants in transnational movements: Christian-anarchist, pacifist, vegetarian, Esperantist.
Communication, especially conversations, discussions, and debates, played a large role in the life of Tolstoyan communities. Many guests from both the outside world and from other colonies visited the communities to exchange ideas. In some communities, the tradition arose in which guests who live in the community for more than three days are required/obliged to join in the common work. During Tolstoy’s lifetime, Tolstoyans often made “pilgrimages” to Yasnaya Polyana or to his Moscow home to talk with him about life; they also visited other Tolstoyan and sectarian communities.
Early communitarian settlements, including Tolstoyan examples, often practiced a ritual similar to the “criticisms” of the American perfectionists. These involved discussing the actions, character, and disposition of each individual member at regularly held meetings that were mandatory for all community members. Over time, such meetings were almost entirely replaced by cultural and educational discussions and musical and theatrical entertainments.
Successful Tolstoyan communes had a significant effect on the surrounding population. At the same time, the Tolstoyans never engaged in direct propaganda of their views. Like the new social movements that appeared later, they preferred the “politics of example” and strove to create “model” farms, the high cultural and economic level of which should itself prompt interest and imitation among the local population.
Tolstoyans rarely produced ideological texts, but the expression of their ideas and emotions through amateur poetic creativity was widespread among them. Many members of agricultural communities wrote amateur verses and songs in which they described their lives and ideals. These works showed varying degrees of talent: some were purely the products of an urge to write, but sometimes one encountered examples of poetic creativity whose authors can be considered truly original folk poets.
ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP
Tolstoyans considered themselves free Christians and religious anarchists; they disliked inequality, any social hierarchy, and rigid bureaucratic structures. Tolstoyan communities often refused to obtain official registration and sometimes lacked written charters. And while before the revolution of 1917 self-government among the Tolstoyans was more often informal, in Soviet times almost all communes sooner or later had to formalize their procedures of self-rule in written charters. Initially, these were charters based on Tolstoy’s principles of nonviolence and autonomy from the state.
As a rule, the highest governing body in the Tolstoyans’ communes and artels was the general assembly. Decisions concerning all major economic and organizational issues lay within its competence. The general assembly could elect a council as an executive body in the commune, headed by the chairman of the commune, and it also appointed an auditing commission. The issues of the admission of new members and exclusion from the community were also decided collectively. Communities sought to act fairly toward departing community members, allowing them to take not only their personal property but also, if available, part of the community’s property corresponding to the departing members’ contribution to the common economy. The voluntary principle governed the assignment of work in Tolstoyan communes: as a rule, people inclined to a particular kind of work were assigned to that work.
Already in the early 1920s, the Soviet government insistently recommended that Tolstoyans change to the standard Soviet charter for an agricultural commune, and at the end of the decade, the state began the forcible transition of Tolstoyan communes to the standard charter. The Soviet authorities also insisted that the Tolstoyans accept into their collectives all those who wished to join them or whom the authorities would send, even if these people did not share Tolstoyan values. At the turn of the 1920s and 1930s, as collectivization began, the typical practice was the closure of Tolstoyan communes by expelling the Tolstoyans from them and transferring the property to a neighboring collective farm. This pressure forced Tolstoyan communities from all over the country, with the help of the government, to move to Siberia in an organized manner, where for some time the hope remained that Tolstoyan communes would be able to continue their autonomous existence without coming into conflict with the state.
ISSUES/CHALLENGES
The internal problems of Tolstoyan communities differed little from similar problems in other communitarian settlements. As a rule, the causes of their troubles and disillusionment with community life were ideological disagreements between the participants and the financial difficulties and material hardships that led to the collapse of the enterprise, as well as conflicts between the interests of community members with families and those who were single. Involuntary violation of principles (for example, recourse to hired labor or external sources of funding) also often led to disillusionment with community life. In large communes that managed to survive for a considerable length of time, generational differences between “fathers” and “children” could be the source of internal problems. Perhaps one can consider the distinctive characteristics of Tolstoyan communes most often to be not their excessive rigidity and authoritarianism, but rather the inordinate leniency of their internal administration. This leniency was based on the ideals of a free-religious worldview, which caused organizational confusion, economic problems, and subsequent disintegration.
With respect to the departure of Tolstoyans from the Tolstoyan movement to other groups, the largest exodus at the beginning of the twentieth century was observed to the Orthodox Church, with subsequent criticism of Tolstoyanism. In the Soviet era, Tolstoyans also left for theosophical, anthroposophical, and mystical-anarchist communities, which, as a rule, did not maintain a communal economy and were merely secret spiritual societies. There were no cases of mass emigration of the members of Tolstoyan communities.
External factors, especially harassment by the authorities, often led to the collapse of a community. Tolstoyans were considered politically unreliable throughout the history of their movement, in both the Russian Empire and Soviet Russia. In the late nineteenth century, the authorities did not distinguish between Tolstoyans and revolutionaries, believing that Tolstoyans also posed a threat to social stability and suspecting that revolutionaries could be hiding in Tolstoyan communes. Before 1917, surveillance by the political police and administrative and criminal prosecutions were prompted by the Tolstoyans’ involvement in the distribution of Tolstoy’s works (which were banned by the censors), their close contact with sectarians (who exerted a “harmful influence” on them), their protection of sectarians from persecution, and their efforts to publicize cases of the violation of freedom of conscience.
Constant surveillance and harassment affected the psychological state of the participants in the Tolstoyan movement, some of whom were brought to nervous and mental disorders or concluded that it was impossible to establish communities in such conditions in Russia. The decree on religious toleration of 1904 and the introduction of basic constitutional freedoms in the years 1905–1906 significantly improved the situation, although these changes did not completely free the Tolstoyans from persecution. The religious toleration proclaimed by the law was upheld in practice only with difficulty.
The persecution of the Tolstoyans during the First World War and the Civil War was brought on by their pacifist position: they signed a series of anti-war appeals and intensified their defense of conscientious objectors, the number of which increased dramatically at that time. In Soviet times, the persecution resumed due to the presence among the Tolstoyans of their own alternative project of building communism in a peaceful, non-violent way. In the early years of Soviet rule, many sectarians supported the Tolstoyan plan for a “peaceful revolution” as a spiritual revolution, which was occurring at the same time as the Bolsheviks’ violent, materialist revolution.
This project became a real challenge for the Bolsheviks, who responded with several waves of repression. The first wave occurred in the years 1921–1924, at which time all legal Tolstoyan organizations and publishing houses were closed, and pressure on sectarians friendly to Tolstoyans began. As a result of the extensive campaign against the Tolstoyans in the late 1920s, their last legal organization, the Moscow Vegetarian Society [MVO], was closed, and many active figures in the “free–religious” movement were repressed. In the 1930s, Tolstoyan communes remained the last centers of the radical pacifist movement, the destruction of which was completed during the years of the Great Terror.
In the late Soviet Union, Tolstoy’s religious and philosophical teachings were unofficially banned. Only a few groups referred to themselves as “Tolstoyans”: elderly survivors of repression and World War II, individual intellectual dissidents (including religious ones), and members of youth subcultures such as hippies and anarchists, numbering in the dozens but not even in the hundreds. Most of them valued Tolstoyan ideas of reformed Christianity and nonviolence. His communitarian ideas were less popular: in the late 1980s and 1990s. Only a few attempts were made to establish agricultural settlements based on Tolstoyan principles, but all failed. Participants in ecovillages of the 2000s also showed interest in Tolstoy’s ideas. In 2024, the last Tolstoyan in Russia, Boris Zolotov, passed away; since the 1990s, he had attempted to live a communal life “on the land.”
Various types of alternative movements, especially pacifist-anarchists and communitarians, outside Russia, tended to use the ideas of Leo Tolstoy. The first Tolstoyan colony was founded in 1896 at Purleigh, Essex, by a Tolstoyan anarchist Kenworthy and Aylmer Maude, the translator of Tolstoy. The number of colonies rose to over sixty, a quarter of whom lived on land owned by the colony, whilst the remainder resided nearby. In accord with the concept of the “bread labor” that Tolstoy had taken over from peasant Timofei Bondaref, each colonist had to earn their livelihood by their labor. The colony sustained itself for about three years and then collapsed, but the Tolstoyan communitarian movement in England did not disappear until the First World War.
Tolstoyan communes also emerged in Holland, Bulgaria, U.S., Korea, Japan, and Chile. Despite the fact that most of them existed for a very short time, their history is not a story of disappointment in utopia, but a history of a laboratory for creating alternative values, foremost of which was freedom and non-violence.
The two world wars became a serious test for the followers of nonviolence in the spirit of Tolstoy. In the post-war period, interest in Tolstoy’s religious and philosophical works was limited mainly to small pacifist groups that could still be found in the West, especially in England and America.
In the late 1960s and 1970s, communes that were ideologically or symbolically connected to Tolstoyanism became widespread in the United States, particularly within the youth counterculture. The most vivid example is Tolstoy Farm in Eastern Washington, which was established in 1963. These communities combined the Tolstoyan principle of living “on the land” with values of nonviolence, ecological ideas, anarchism, psychedelia, and elements of the New Age, movement. Thereafter, the movement almost entirely faded away.
REFERENCES**
** Unless otherwise specified, the profile contents are drawn from
Petukhova, Tatiiana. 2008. Kommuny i arteli tolstovtsev v Sovetskoi Rossii (1917-1929 gg.). Ul’ianovsk.
Bestor, Arthur. 1978. Backwoods Utopias: The Sectarian Origin and Owenite Phase of Communitarian Socialism in America, 1663-1829. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Sibirskii krest’ianin. 2010. Timofei Bondarev i graf Lev Tolstoi: Bibliogragficheskii ukazatel’. Abakan, 2010.
Zablocki, Benjamin D. 1987. “Communes, Encounter groups and the Search for Community.” Pp. 97-142 in Search for Community: Encounter Groups and Social Change, edited by Kurt W. Back. New York: Routledge
SUPPLEMENTARY RESOURCES
Agarin, Efim. 2019. Trudami ruk svoikh. Tolstovskie zemledel’cheskie kolonii v dorevol’utsionnoi Rossii. Moscow: Common Place.
Alston, Charlotte. 2014. Tolstoy and His Disciples: The History of a Radical International Movement. London: I.B. Tauris & Co.
De Lange, Dennis. 2016. “Die Revolution bist Du!” Der Tolstojanismus als soziale Bewegung in den Niederlanden. Heidelberg: Verlag Graswurzelrevolution.
Etkind, Aleksandr. 1998. Khlyst. (Sekty, literatura i revolutsiia). Moscow: NLO.
Fairfield, Richard. 2010. Tolstoy Farm.” Pp. 62-65 in The Modern Utopian. Alternatives Communities of the ‘60s and 70’s, edited by Richard Fairfield. Process Media.
Gordeeva, Irina. 2003. “Zabytye L’udi”: Istoriia rossiiskogo kommunitarnogo dvizheniai. Moscow: AIRO-XX.
Marks, Steven G. 2003. How Russia Shaped the Modern World: From Art to Anti-Semitism, Ballet to Bolshevism. Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press.
Popovskii, Mark. 1983. Russkie Muzhiki Rasskazyva’ut: Posledovateli L.N. Tolstogo v Sovetskom So’uze, 1918 – 1977. London: Overseas Publications Interchange (OPI).
Rigby, Andrew. 1974. Alternative realities: A study of communes a. their members. London; Boston: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Roginskii, Arsenii, ed. Vospominaniia krest’an-tolstovtsev, 1910-1930-е gg. Moscow: Kniga, 1989.
Parker, Martin, Fournier, Valerie, and Reedy, Patrick. 2007. “Tolstoy Leo.” Pp., 285-287 in The Dictionary of Alternatives. Utopianism and Organization. London; New York: Zed Books.
Publication Date:
15 March 2025
