City Harvest Church

CITY HARVEST CHURCH (CHC) TIMELINE

1989:  With the help of twenty youths, Kong Hee founded a new congregation on May 7 at Peace Center, Singapore.

1992:  City Harvest Church (CHC) was set up as a society.

1994:  CHC’s training school, the School of Theology (formerly known as City Harvest Bible Training Center), was started.

1995:  CHC started holding its services at the former Hollywood Theatre and continued there for another six years.

1996:  Kong Hee and his wife, Sun Ho (Ho is the last name), began Church Without Walls, a community service project.

1996:  Ho founded a social work agency, City Harvest Community Services Association.

2001:  The church built a church complex at Jurong West Street 91 and moved into its first permanent location.

2001:  The church claimed to have 10,310 attendees at its fifteen weekend services. It also had offices and schools in five different locations.

2002:  The church launched the “Crossover Project,” aiming to reach the secular world through Ho’s music.

2002:  The church supported the founding of City College, a social enterprise committed to providing alternative education for young people.

2003:  Ho was named “The Outstanding Young Person of the World” for her humanitarian efforts.

2004:  Ho was named an “Ambassador of Love” for the Children and Youth Foundation of China.

2005:  Kong took himself off the staff payroll and began serving the church as the honorary founder/senior pastor.

2005:  As the church grew, CHC rented another worship site at Singapore Expo for the weekend English service.

2006:  CHC started O School, a street dance training school for young people.

2008:  CHC began a Christian news portal, City News.

2009:  CHC claimed to have a congregation of 23,565 people.

2010:  CHC announced that it had purchased a significant stake in  Suntec Convention Centre, located in the Central Business District, which it would use for its church services.

2010:  CHC claimed to have an average attendance of 23,256 with forty-seven affiliate churches and six Bible schools in Asia.

2010:  Sixteen individuals linked to CHC, including Kong and Ho, were investigated by Singapore police for possible falsification of accounts and criminal breach of trust.

2011:  CHC moved to the  Suntec Convention Centre and claimed to have a congregation of 20, 619.

2012:  CHC reported a congregation of 19,819. There were also 5,937 students from at least thirty countries who were graduates of its training center.

2012:  Kong and five other church leaders were arrested and charged with misuse of funds.

2012:  Ho led a new management and board, which ran the operations of the church. She initiated a new church vision, called CHC 2.0, which was formulated by Kong.

2013 (May): The trial began; it continued for over two years.

2013:  CHC claimed a congregation of 18,192.

2014:  CHC claimed a congregation of 17,522.

2015:  Kong and five other church leaders were found guilty of falsification of accounts and criminal breach of trust. Kong initially received as sentence of eight years in prison, the heaviest sentence among the six who were charged.

2015:  Ho was ordained during CHC’s twenty-sixth anniversary celebrations and became the leader of the church.

2015:  CHC claimed a congregation of 16,482.

2018 (February): The Court of Appeal upheld a decision by the High Court to convict the church leaders of less serious criminal breach of trust charges.

2019 (August 22):  Kong was released from incarceration after serving two years and four months of a three-and-a-half year sentence.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Kong Hee [Image at right] was born on August 23, 1964, in Singapore. He was the fifth child of Kong Leng, an engineer, and Toh Poh-Eng, a diamond trader. He graduated with a degree in Computer and Information Sciences from the National University of Singapore in 1988. Upon graduation, he worked for a short time in a local publishing house. In 1989, Kong became a staff evangelist with Christ for Asia, a mission organization based in the Philippines. When an opportunity for Kong to pioneer a new church in Singapore arose, Kong returned to Singapore and helped set up a new congregation of twenty youths, with the support and encouragement of some senior pastors in Singapore. On May 7, 1989, City Harvest Church was founded as a department (known as Ekklesia Ministry) of Bethany Christian Centre (Assemblies of God).

The church was set up as a society in 1992 and was registered under the Charities Act on October 16, 1993. In 1994, with the purpose of training pastors, missionaries, and church workers in Asia, the church started its own training school, the School of Theology. For six years from 1995, the church rented the former Hollywood Theatre on Tanjong Katong Road and held its services there.  Then in 2001, it moved to a permanent location at Jurong West Street 91. The 2,200-seater, titanium-clad church complex, which cost S$48,000,000, is one of the largest church buildings in Singapore. In 2005, as the church continued to grow, it had to rent another worship site at Singapore Expo for its weekend English congregations. On March 6, 2010, the church announced that it had purchased a significant stake in Suntec Convention Centre, which is located at the center of Singapore’s business district, and it would be using these facilities for its church services.

Kong’s wife, Ho Yeow Sun (popularly known as Sun Ho), is as (or more) popular and significant to the development of the CHC as Kong. Ho was born on June 2, 1972 in Singapore. The couple got married in 1992 and Ho became involved in the church from its inception. She was one of the youth leaders that helped Kong establish the CHC church. She served as the director of the church’s community services and also led its Creative Department from 1992 until late 2000. In 2004, in recognition of her contributions to the building and betterment of schools and educational facilities in China, Sun was named an “Ambassador of Love” by the Children and Youth Foundation of China.

When Kong and Ho began to promote the idea of “Cultural Mandate” in the CHC in 2002, one that encouraged the church members to excel in the marketplace, they started the Crossover Project to demonstrate their desire to reach out to the secular world. With Kong’s support, Ho resigned from her church position and began a singing career. According to Kong, the plan was for Ho to break into the music market as part of the church effort to do evangelism through her pop music (Miller 2014). By selling over 50,000 copies of her debut album of Mandarin pop, Sun with Love, which was followed by two sold-out concerts at the Singapore Indoor Stadium in June 2002, Ho had the opportunity to advance her career outside of Singapore, and to Taiwan and China. In 2003, she moved to Hollywood to pursue her singing career. Ho’s seven years in the U.S. were glamorous years for her. Local news and church reports showed that she received private dance lessons from top choreographers and worked with top artists, directors, and producers in the U.S. on her music videos. Ho worked with veteran record producer and sixteen-time Grammy Award winner David Foster, who helped produce her debut English single, Where Did Love Go. The song reached the top spot on Billboard’s dance breakout chart (Sen 2015) .

Nevertheless, throughout her music career, she faced serious criticism. Her boldness in trying new things received polemic responses, even though many of her church members adored her. As one of the reports on the church’s online magazine describes her:

…with strik ing blonde streaks highlighting her tender-brown tresses…and with her very J-Lo but not as revealing dressings… have defied all prior definitions one may have had of what a pastor ‘should’ be like (Harvest Times, v.17 March-June 2002).

But there were also many who were perplexed by her seemingly contradictory “pastor-singer” roles. One of the most notorious examples was “China Wine,” a song depicting her as a Chinese exotic dancer in Jamaica, and “Mr. Bill,” i n which she sang about killing her husband. In the China Wine movie she was “ gyrating furiously to the music in a low-cut, midriff-baring top and nothing shorts” (Miller 2014). According to the report, “…horror, scorn and disdain were the primary reactions [towards her MTV]; at their mildest, puzzlement and skepticism at how such a song could help spread the gospel.”

Also, since the beginning of her career, Ho faced criticism that she used her church’s support to aid her album sales. Rumors have been rife that her ventures into local and international stardom were largely engineered and sponsored by Kong and that the church’s leadership using the church’s financial resources. Questions have been raised in regards to the suitability of the church in supporting her pop career by, among other things, reporting her news in the pulpit or in church magazines and requiring church members to buy her CDs as well as to participate in her concerts. Many people raised eyebrows when her luxurious lifestyle in Hollywood was exposed. According to The New Paper, Ho rented a Hollywood Hills mansion for $20,000 per month . It is noted that the property is worth $5,600,000.

Ho’s singing career ended in 2010 after the police began probing into sixteen church leaders, including Kong and Ho, about the misuse of funds at CHC. Following a 2012 arrest and a trial beginning in 2013, there were allegations that Kong and five other church leaders were illegally funding Ho’s singing career and then using another $26,000,000 Singapore dollars to cover it up.   Reports also revealed that her success in the Mandarin-speaking market was exaggerated as two of her Mandarin albums sustained significant losses, and church members had to buy 32,500 copies of her unsold albums (Sen 2015).

The trial ended her pop career but not her leadership in the CHC. On October 21, 2015, Kong and the other five leaders were found guilty of all charges. Two days before the verdict came out on Oct 19, 2015, Kong posted on Facebook that Sun Ho had been ordained as pastor. She was never charged and is now replacing her husband as the leader of the church.

DOCTRINE/BELIEFS

City Harvest Church’s Essential Faith Doctrines are seventeen Bible-based statements which are

1. We believe in the plenary-verbal inspiration of the accepted canon of scriptures as originally given. The scriptures are infallible, inerrant and the sole and final authority for all matters of faith and conduct (2 Timothy 3:16; 1 Corinthians 2:13).

2. We believe in the eternal Godhead who has revealed Himself as one God existing in three persons, Father, Son and Holy Spirit, distinguishable but indivisible (Matthew 28:19; 2 Corinthians 13:14).

3. We believe in the creation, test and fall of man as recorded in Genesis; his total spiritual depravity and inability to attain to divine righteousness (Romans 5:12, 18).

4. We believe in the Lord Jesus Christ, the Savior of men, conceived by the Holy Spirit, born by the Virgin Mary, very God and very Man (Luke 1:26-35; John 1:14-18; Isaiah 7:14; 9:6).

5. We believe Christ died for our sins, was buried and rose again the third day, and personally appeared unto His disciples (1 Corinthians 15:1-4; Romans 4:25).

6. We believe in the bodily ascension of Jesus to heaven, His exaltation and personal, literal and bodily coming again the second time for His Church (John 14:2,3; and 1 Thessalonians 4:13-18).

7. We believe in the salvation of sinners by grace, through repentance and faith in the perfect and sufficient work of the cross of Calvary by which we obtain remission of sins (Ephesians 2:8-9; Hebrews 9:12, 22; Romans 5:11).

8. We believe in the necessity of water baptism by immersion in the name of the eternal Godhead in order to fulfill the command of the Lord Jesus Christ (Matthew 28:19; Acts 2:34-36; 19:1-6).

9. We believe in the baptism in the Holy Spirit as a real experience at or subsequent to salvation, with the scriptural evidence, namely, speaking in other tongues as the Spirit gives utterance (Acts 2:1-4; 8:14-17; 10:44-45; Galatians 3:14-15).

10. We believe in the operation of the gifts and ministries of the Spirit as enumerated in 1 Corinthians 12-14 and Ephesians 4, as manifested in the early Church.

11. We believe in the Spirit-filled life, a life of separation from the world and perfecting of holiness in the fear of God as expressing the true Christian faith (Ephesians 5:18; 2 Corinthians 6:14; 7:1).

12. We believe in the healing of the body by Divine power, or Divine healing in its varied aspects as practiced in the early Church (Acts 4:30; Romans 8:11; 1 Corinthians 12:9; James 5:14) and by deliverance in the name of Jesus (Mark 16:17).

13. We believe in the table of the Lord, commonly called the Communion or the Lord’s Supper, for believers (1 Corinthians 11:28-32; Matthew 26:26-28).

14. We believe in the reality and personality of the Devil and eternal judgment in the Lake of Fire for the Devil and his angels (Matthew 25:41; Revelation 20:14-15).

15. We believe in the eternal life for believers (John 5:24; 3:16), and eternal punishment for the unbelievers (Mark 9:43-48; 2 Thessalonians 1:9; Revelation 20:10-15).

16. We believe that there is one true universal Church, made up of genuine believers, but this one universal Church is also composed of many local Churches in given localities. These Churches are under the sovereign headship of the Lord Jesus Christ, exercising autonomous government under Him, administering all its local affairs and ministry, as well as the propagation of the gospel (Acts 15:22; Matthew 16:18; 18:15-20).

17. We believe that Government is ordained of God, and the powers that be are ordained as ministers of God to us for good. To resist the powers and the ordinances is to resist the ordinance of God. We are subject not only for wrath sake but for conscience sake, rendering to all their dues, custom to whom custom, fear to whom fear, honor to whom honor. We declare our loyalty to our Government and its leaders, and will assist in every way possible, consistent with our faith in the scriptures as Christian citizens (Romans 13).

CHC embraces a conventional and evangelical theological stance just like most of the Chinese P rotestant churches in Asia and the U.S., along with charismatic/Pentecostal beliefs. Salvation is based on a personal relationship with God and baptism is reserved for adults who have made a decision leading to conversion. Sanctification is the integration of life and belief resulting in a new lif e style. In terms of its charismatic and Pentecostal beliefs, CHC emphasizes, as mentioned in its Mission Statements, “the baptism in the Holy Spirit as a real experience at or subsequent to salvation, with the scriptural evidence, namely, speaking in other tongues as the Spirit gives utterance,” “the operation of the gifts and ministries of the Spirit,” and “the healing of the body by Divine power.”

There are a few rather distinctive teachings and values of the church, which are largely responsible for the uniqueness of its ministry and its rapid growth in size and fame. One is its emphasis on Cultural Mandate. In the church’s Mission Statement, for example, it is mentioned that the church goal is “to build a church….to obey the Great Commission and the Cultural Mandate.” This shows the equal importance of the gospel mandate along with the Cultural Mandate, i.e., evangelism and cultural mandate mean being salt and light in the marketplace/secular world. Indeed, the church describes its DNA as the Great Commission, Great Command me nt, and the Cultural Mandate. Since 2002, Kong began to teach about the Cultural Mandate, and many of his teachings and sermons have been based on the idea that believers should excel in the marketplace and that the church should not limit itself to “within the four walls” but rather should engage in the world. As he mentioned in one of his writings (Kong 2007):

Let us decide to be relevant to our society. We shouldn’t be afraid to engage a world that God has created and always loved. We should not be fearful to engage culture by being as creative, as colorful, and as progressive as we could possibly be for the glory of God. We mustn’t shun the sciences and arts out there in the marketplace. Rather, we should work hard and excel in the arena of life God has planted us in. As you do that, you will become the salt of the earth and the light of the world. Ultimately, you will bring many into the kingdom of God!

The Cultural Mandate message targets primarily, as mentioned on its website, “believers who are successful in the business arena and the entertainment world.” Also, “many successful business people and celebrities have discovered a newfound passion for their secular endeavors” and “have been inspired to harness their platforms” to further the kingdom of God.

Both Kong’s and Ho’s lives have been the most successful models of how believers can engage in the secular world. In his writing “Discovering your purpose in the secular,” Kong said:

Sun has always felt drawn to the world of arts and entertainment. Maybe because of the Indonesian-Chinese blood in me, I have always been drawn to business and the corporate world. In the last few years, as we engaged our society more as salt and light, we began to discover our purpose: which is not to be a stereotypical religious couple confined within the four walls of a local church, but to take the kingdom of God into the marketplace of society…Sun got into her singing career and I became a businessman.

Soon Kong and Ho began the Crossover Project, which involved reaching out or crossing over to other cultural strata unreached by Christian faith, and in their case, the “pop culture.” The Crossover Project aims to “redeem” the popular culture through embracing, utilizing, and mastering it as a means of reaching out to the world, and hopefully, remaking it to be an alternative and relevant form of Christianity to the (post)modern world. With Kong’s strong endorsement and the support of the church, Ho embarked on her music career and has become one of Singapore’s leading Mandarin pop stars. Very soon Ho had already scored a number of hits in the Mandarin pop scene, had performed to packed stadiums in Taiwan, and had produced double-platinum selling CDs. Meanwhile, as he was still serving as the senior pastor of the church, Kong also stopped receiving a salary from the church and became like a lay person who volunteered in the church. In doing so, he became free to cross between the two worlds of sacred and secular. Kong was a board member of Dr. David Yonggi Cho’s Church Growth International  (South Korea) and Dr. Luis Bush’s Transform World (Indonesia). Also, he and his wife once owned several companies,  including International Harvest, Skin Couture, and boutiques.

Another related and equally important value of the CHC is its emphasis on “excellence, success, and prosperity.” Worldly success, as viewed by CHC, if not always a sign of grace, is an indication that one is going in the right direction with God. Some quotations from Kong’s writings include, “When your vertical relationship with God is strong, your horizontal relationship in the marketplace will be successful.” Kong said:

Make no mistake about it, God wants the world to envy us and say to us: “We must have your way of life!” Yet, how many among the unchurched are actually jealous of Christians today? Why aren’t the unbelievers rushing to church every weekend, or knocking on our doors saying, “Help me, I have to get into the kingdom of God! I want to be like you—happy, successful and creative!” (Kong 2007).

In the same writing, Kong, using examples from the Old Testament, mentioned Adam, who “plowed the ground, sowed his seed and reaped a harvest to feed his family, but he didn’t stop there. He explored the geology of the land, dug deeper into the ground, and discovered gold and all kinds of precious stones. The more you apply yourself and the harder you work, the richer you will become in life.” There was also Joseph, who “became so successful in his secular vocation that he was promoted to be the number two man to Pharaoh…” And then there were the Israelites, to whom God guaranteed that His laws would make them “wealthy and prosperous.” But, to be successful and wealthy, one needs to show excellence in one’s work.

In one of his writings entitled Understanding Excellence, Kong set the standard of excellence, which would be “to be superior in quality, greater in quantity, to transcend your job description, and to outdo yourself each time.” The values are to be demonstrated not only in peoples’ lives, but also on the corporate level. He adhered to a standard of excellence in constructing an “ultra-modern” church building in which even the toilets “exemplify the very meaning of style” (Harvest Times, v.18 July-December 2002) as well as the corporate office, which is located in the heart of Singapore’s central business district in Suntec City Tower. The church building project is a perfect and concrete manifestation of the value of excellence, as mentioned by Kong in the church’s publication:

…all the finer details of the entire construction were extremely vital to the church leadership. The cleanliness and hygiene, the greenery and landscaping, the positioning of our furniture, the comfort of our chairs, the color scheme and lightings of our halls, the quality of air in the building, the paint job, the cleaning of unsightly scratch marks, fingerprints and sawdust in the facility were all important details that reflect excellence (Harvest Times, v.17 March-June 2002).

RITUALS/PRACTICES

The church has been successful in providing an attractive and distinctive religious experience and collective identity for its young attenders, who either attend a church for the first time or have been turned off by traditional religious settings, through effectively integrating rational structure, emotional expressivity, and consumer ethic in its Sunday services.

The church has multiple services, organized in different languages, on each Sunday. To ensure the high quality of each service, it is well-structured. The sermons, although preached by different pastors, have a common theme and application points. It is also carefully timed and programmed. For instance, in the case of serving the Holy Communion to thousands of people (the pastor reciting The Apostle’s Creed and offering his prayer, hundreds of ushers passing on pre-packaged pieces of bread and cups of drinks, which the congregation consumes and throws away spontaneously) all are accomplished in minutes.

The service is always bound up with expectation and entertaining, with its bright colors, garish signs, spotlights beam onto the stage, enthusiastic and contemporary music bounces through the hall, as well as well-harmonized vocals, a sizable choir, and a band. The whole environment is similar to a pop music concert. Thousands of people in the audience rise to their feet, at times shout and jump, at times weep and kneel.

Preaching is another main attraction of the service. Kong has been known as an anointed and popular preacher, both locally and internationally. Also, there are a number of international speakers who regularly preach at CHC. Unlike traditional churches, Kong’s preaching styles are very engaging in nature. His sermons are usually highly relevant and practical to its young audience, and are always easily remembered and inspiring. His preaching is also highly interactive. Instead of confining himself to the pulpit, Kong used to move around with passionate voice, gestures, and personal stories to engage the audience. He would normally encourage or even urge responses from the audience, such as repeating their words to their neighbors. Besides taking notes, the audience frequently show their support or agreement through a simultaneous “yeah” or “Amen” response or applause. On some occasions, after the preaching, Kong would offer an alter call and launch the service into a healing time. Hundreds of people would stream to the stage, to receive praying, miraculous healings and prophetic utterances, opening up their emotional and physical needs to be ministered in a unique and collective way. His preaching, through multiple television programs and internet webcast, have reached millions of viewers from hundreds of countries.

As already mentioned, the church emphasizes the values of success and excellence. To be successful in career and life, one needs to receive divine blessings through generous offering to the church. This practice is part of a belief in a “prosperity gospel:” that is, by giving to God as much as one can, the Christian will reap the fruits of his/her investments in higher returns, both spiritually and materially. Plenty of messages have been carefully built on this concept, and testimonies of many, including business, academic, relationship successes, have proved the message to be true.

In short, from the “proper” way of worship (when to raise hand, knee, shout, etc.), “proper” timing of responding to the sermons or whoever is on the stage (i.e. taking note, the unified “yeah” response after the preacher has said something interesting or challenging), to their weekly and monthly offerings, members receive cues that indicate what is expected of them. Disciplinary actions, taken mainly by cell-group leaders or pastors to correct uncooperative attitude, are not unusual. One can be censured for one’s disagreement with the church’s teachings or over one’s unwillingness to participate in the church’s activities, such as church building project. Discipline is even stricter for students of the Bible Training Center. For instance, according to its Student Handbook item no. 6.5.5., “Students are to be respectful and polite toward the pastors and leadership appointed over them in the Bible Training Center and in the CHC. All students must address all pastors by their titles whenever they meet. Failure to do so will bring about disciplinary action.” The Center had dismissed fifteen students in 2004 because of their problems of “integrity and honesty;” ten were international students (many were full-time workers in their home church).

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

The CHC is run as a centralized corporation with a Board of Director s that is legally responsible for the charter of the Church. Kongis at the top of the hierarchy, with all spiritual and practical authority, and below him are other ordained pastors and pastoral staff (there are twenty-two pastors and assistant pastors and sixty-five full-time staff) and hundreds of executive members (these are lay leaders, including senior members and leaders of cell groups), who interact most frequently with the congregations. But the ultimate authority resides with Kong. According to Chan (forthcoming), the church has no concrete church polity as it is still in the stage of development. For example, when responding to questions about ordination, the church leaders told Chan that there is no established rule or regulation on who is able to be ordained.

Judging from the size and operation of the church, Kong seems to have exhibited an outstanding leadership style, a combination of both rational and charismatic authority. The former includes his highly efficient management capabilities and his “logical and systematical” thinking, which he attributes to his training in Computer Science. In 2004, the business-savvy senior pastor brought the church one great leap forward by obtaining ISO 9001:2000, which makes it the first church in the world to be awarded such certification. The latter includes his very personal calling from God, which he describes in this way: God “ said the obvious to me, ‘Kong, raise me a new generation that will take Asia by storm’.” Also, there is his charismatic and visionary personality, which he uses to “both inspire and challenge people to dream big dreams for God,” and his preaching style, which according to his website, is “deeply modern” and “strongly aspirational.”

Seeing his own role as “ transformed from that of a shepherd to a rancher” (The Straits Times, April 8 2004), Kong formed the church on a small-group (cell groups) basis and depended mainly on the lay leaders to perform the regular activities. According to the 2015 annual report, the church has 544 cell groups, which connect 10,825 people with each other, and 665 cell group leaders. Divided into youth and adult cell groups, the meetings take place mostly on a weekly basis following centrally-designed materials. The church offers training and detailed guidelines in order to produce consistent and uniform leading and preaching style, on the one hand, and to equip the leaders with set answers for frequently asked questions, on the other. Likewise, the plans for membership (three levels including ordinary, ministry, and executive member) are neatly structured.

As for its ministerial coverage, CHC places equal emphasis on both evangelism and social services. In terms of its religious services, besides Sunday services, it offers Bible studies and various education classes/programs about the Christian faith in several languages and dialect s. The ministries cover programs from young children to older people, including services for the hearing impaired and mentally challenged people , the first church in Singapore which has dedicated special resources for this group. CHC also runs a School of Theology for local and oversea s students. The School offers seven months of theological and practical training for Christian leaders and pastors as well as ordinary believers. From 1994 to 2015, its cumulative student intake reached 6986 students. In the year 2015, the School had 324 students, most of whom came from Singapore and China.

In terms of social service, there are independently incorporated groups affiliated with CHC, which carry on various tasks: Citycare runs the local and international humanitarian programs including corporate training, and the City Harvest Community Services Association serves the local community. There are other services or businesses that are provided by the church, such as the City College, which provides alternative education pathways for young people , the O School which offers street dance training to young people, and the Little Big preschool which promotes early childhood education emphasizing “creativity, expression and exploration.”

In order to keep the organization running smoothly, the church has an expertly rationalized system in place. It sets quantified targets for each ministry and judges its success in terms of quantity, as highlighted in its annual report: “We count numbers because numbers count!” For example, in its 2015 annual report, everything is about big numbers: It claims that the church has a total of 6303 decisions (salvation and rededication), which includes 2189 adults and 4114 children; 4107 individuals have prayed the sinner’s prayer for the first time; 463 people have been baptized; and 705 people have participated in 181 mission trips to 87 cities in 16 countries. Also, the church has 49 affiliate churches and 29 associate churches in China. The total attendance within the “CHC movement,” including at its Singapore “headquarters,” is 49,032. Other numbers include the total number of patients, 2933, that have been seen by its four humanitarian teams; the total number of people who have attended its 386 mission conferences led by CHC pastors and staff, 120,910; the number of visitors to its website, 14,092,397; its webcast viewership, 576,023; its Twitter followers, 18,036; its Facebook followers, 41,430; total number of mobile app installations, 28,109; its city radio total broadcasting time, 25,710 mins; number of hits per week, 10,912; and so on.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

The scandal involving the church was the biggest charity scandal in Singapore history (“City Harvest Church” 2019; Sin 2019; Tan 2019). It revolved around Kong and five other church leaders and fund or finance managers. A total of $50,000,000 Singapore dollars ($35,000,000) of funds were misused to support Sun Ho’s music career. Alarm bells were raised much earlier than the formal investigation, which began in 2010. In 2003, soon after Ho began her singing career, a church member went to the press with allegations of financial impropriety on the part of the church. But then he backed down and apologized after the church threatened to sue him (Wong 2015).

Several years later, on May 31, 2010, the Office of the Commissioner of Charities and the   Commercial Affairs Department   of the Singapore Police began investigating more than sixteen individuals linked to the church, including Kong and Ho, after receiving complaints . The police looked into financial transactions involving the possible falsification of accounts and continuing breach of trust, all of which dated back a number of years.

In 2012, after a review by the commissioner of charities uncovered “ misconduct and mismanagement in the administration,” Kong and five church leaders were arrested. In court, prosecutors outlined a complex web of sham financial transactions in which six church leaders misappropriated $24,000,000 Singapore dollars ($18,900,000) from one of the church building funds to support Ho’s pop music career. Ho herself was never implicated in the legal charges. There was also a second allegation of these six people taking another $26,000,000 Singapore dollars ($20,500,000) to cover up the initial embezzled amount. All six were serving in some capacity on the church board.

In 2015, all six initially were found guilty of criminal breach of trust. Kong was sentenced to eight years in jail as the “key man” behind the scandal and as the one who had led his five accomplices in the criminal breach of trust. Kong apologized for “unwise decisions.” The remaining five were handed prison terms varying from twenty-one months to six years.The case extended on for several years as there were several appeals. Ultimately, Kong’s sentence was reduced to three-and-one-half years; he served two years and four months. On August 22, 2019, Kong was released from incarceration. He returned to the church and was greeted by a cheering congregation (Tan 2019).

There have been longer-term consequences for Kong and the church..In 2017, Kong was permanently barred by the Commissioner of Charities from holding any formal management positions in the church or serving on its board. He does, however, continue to serve as the church’s spiritual leader. In addition, The Straits Times reported that more than twenty-five percent of the members left the church when news of the scandal exploded in 2010. In 2009, CHC had around 23,565 members (according to its annual report), but that number decreased to 16,482 in 2015. Nonetheless, City Harvest remains one of the largest churches in Singapore and in Asia.

IMAGES
Image #1. Photograph of Kong Hee, founder of City Harvest Church.

REFERENCES

Chan, Kim-kwong. Forthcoming. “City Harvest Church of Singapore: an Ecclesial Paradigm for Pentecostalism in the Postmodern World.” In Global ReOrient: The Rise and Impact of Chinese Charismatic and Pentecostal Christianity, edited by Fenggang Yang, Joy K.C. Tong and Allan Anderson.

Cheong, Danson . 2015a. Controversy Over City Harvest Church’s “Prosperity Gospel.” The Straits Times, November 11. Accessed from htts://www.straitstimes.com/Singapore/controversy-over-city-harvest-churchs-prosperity-gospel on 10 May 2016.

Cheong, Danson. 2015b. Kong Hee “Key Man Behind Church Scandal” The Straits Times, October 23. Accessed from http://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/courts-crime/kong-hee-key-man-behind-church-scandal on 10 May 2016.

“City Harvest Church: A timeline of Singapore’s biggest case in misuse of charitable funds.” 2019. Channel News Asia, August 22. Accessed from https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/singapore/city-harvest-church-kong-hee-a-timeline-of-the-largest-case-11830638  on 10/1/2019.

Kong, Hee. 2007a. Discovering Your Purpose in the Secular. Accessed from https://kongheewiki.wordpress.com/2007/04/03/discovering-your-purpose-in-the-secular-by-kong-hee/ on 10 May 2016.

Kong, Hee. 2007b. Our Cultural Mandate (Part 1). Accessed from https://kongheewiki.wordpress.com/2007/07/03/our-cultural-mandate-part-1-by-kong-hee/ on 10 May 2016.

Miller, S. 2014. “City Harvest Church Investment Manager Chew Eng Han Said in Court That He Had Deferred to Founder Kong Hee’s Preference to Keep the Funding of the Crossover Project Discreet.” Strait Times, August 15. Accessed from http://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/the-straits-times-news-in-a-minute-aug-15-2014 on 10 May 2016.

Sen, N.G. Jun. 2015. “Sun Who? Why Sun Ho Failed to Crack US Market.” The New Paper, October 25. Accessed from http://www.tnp.sg/news/singapore-news/sun-who-why-sun-ho-failed-crack-us-market on 10 May 2016.

Sin, Yuen. 2019.”City Harvest founder Kong Hee makes his first appearance in church since release from jail.” Straits Times, August 24. Accessed from https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/city-harvest-founder-kong-hee-makes-his-first-appearance-in-church-since-release-from-jail on 1 October 2019.

Tan, Theresa. 2019. “At its peak, it had 33,000 members but numbers fell to 16,000 last year; it had $132m in reserves in 2018.” Straits Times, August 25. Accessed from https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/city-harvest-fewer-followers-but-still-among-richest-charities on 1 October 2019.

Tong, Joy K.C. 2008. “McDonaldization and the Mega-Church: A Case Study of City Harvest Church in Singapore.” Pp. 186-204 in Religious Commodifications in Asia: Marketing God, edited by Pattana Kitiarsa. London: Routledge.

Wong, Tessa. 2015. Inside Singapore’s City Harvest Megachurch Scandal. BBC, October 21. Accessed from http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-34589932 on 10 May 2016.

Post Date:
17 May 2016

 

Share

Boko Haram

BOKO HARAM TIMELINE

2002-2004:  The genesis of the Nigerian Taliban in Yobe took place.

2003-2004:  Disturbances in Kanamma and Gwoza were attributed to Boko Haram.

2009 (July 26-29):  Boko Haram revolted; founder Muhammad Yusuf was killed.

2010 (September 7):  A prison break, the foundation of militant Boko Haram, and the ascendancy of Shekau took place.

2011 (June 16):  The suicide bombing of police GHQ in Abuja occurred.

2011 (August 26):  The suicide bombing of U.N. headquarters in Abuja occurred.

2012 (December 25):  Boko Haram attacked churches, killing at least twenty-seven in Maiduguri and Potiskum.

2013 (September):  A major Nigerian military offensive against Boko Haram was undertaken.

2014 (February 14):  121 Christian villagers in Borno state were massacred, beginning the large-scale Boko Haram massacres.

2014 (April 15):  Approximately 276 schoolgirls were kidnapped from Chibok.

2014 (June 2):  Approximately 200 Christians were massacred in and around Gwoza.

2014 (November 28):  At least 120 people were killed by suicide bombing and gunfire at the Kano major mosque.

2015 (January 3-7):  The Baga massacre occurred; approximately 2000 people killed near Lake Chad.

2015 (January 31-February 1):  The final attack on Maiduguri took place; this was a high-point for Boko Haram political control.

2015 (March 8):  Boko Haram pledged allegiance to Islamic State and changed its name to Wilayat Gharb Ifriqiya.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Boko Haram is a Salafi-jihadi organization, whose true name until the organization swore allegiance to the Islamic State in March 2015, was Jami`at Ahl al-Sunna li-l-Da`wa wa-l-Jihad (The Gathering of the People of the Sunna for Missionization and Fighting). It is now known as Wilayat Gharb Ifriqiya (State of West Africa). The name Boko Haram means “Western Education is Forbidden,” aname accorded to the group by Nigerians, and by which it still is popularly known.

The group has two very distinct phases: one under the charismatic leadership of Muhammad Yusuf (d. 2009), who founded the group as a protest against secular education in northern Nigeria, and the second under the flamboyant Abubakar Shakau (whereabouts unknown), who transformed the group into an armed insurrection calling for an Islamic state. A third phase, one in which Boko Haram has been subsumed into the Islamic State (IS), is possibly underway, although thus far it is impossible to draw any final conclusions.

Boko Haram has two basic tactical methods: one, which is individual or small group, and focuses upon individualized terror (assassinations, drive-by shootings, local terror and suicide attacks against local targets), and two, which is massive concerted attacks, usually highly mobile utilizing motorcycles or trucks to attack a given smaller or comparatively less-defended target, and then massacring the target population (or in some cases recently taking them captive). Initially, during the period 2010-2011 Boko Haram favored the first tactical method, and even at the present time still utilizes it. But since the beginning of 2014 Boko Haram has favored the massive attack method. The goal of the secondary method is to create a territorial state.

Although the targets focused upon by Boko Haram have shifted considerably during the last five years, it is possible to make some generalizations. During its first two years (2010-1011), Boko Haram favored local targets that were closely associated with its doctrinal positions. These included attacks on educational and medical facilities, attacks on public-order offenses (from a Muslim point of view), which included bars, gambling establishments, marketplaces where the selling of non-halal meat took place. Above all others were the targeted assassinations of Muslim religious figures who had opposed the group. A second broad group of targets constituted “vengeance for Muhammad Yusuf” targets; these included security forces or military targets. During this period Boko Haram in its public statements usually emphasized that it demanded justice for the murder of Yusuf, among other demands.

During the period 2011-2013 Boko Haram shifted its targets somewhat. While local terrorism of the type described abovecontinued, the group projected its power into two areas: the Fulani-Hausa heartland around Kano and Zaria (north-central Nigeria), and the Middle Belt, most especially the flash-point city of Jos. There are frequent clashes between Christians and Muslims in Jos; Kaduna, capital of the major Middle Belt state, and most especially in the federal capital of Abuja. These attacks were mostly spectacular in nature, and many of them were suicide attacks on very distinctive locations (churches, government buildings, Army bases) that obviously were chosen for their symbolic value. Churches and Christian locations were often attacked on Sundays or at other key Christian holidays, such as Christmas and Easter, again in order to maximize the casualties and symbolism.

During the period commencing late 2011, the Nigerian military enjoyed a period of some success against Boko Haram, especially during later 2012 through summer 2013. Boko Haram continued to carry out operations in northeastern Nigeria, but it was unable (or unwilling) to carry out operations elsewhere in Nigeria. This period of comparative containment ended on May 14, 2013, when President Goodluck Jonathan declared a state of emergency in the three northeastern states hardest hit by Boko Haram.

Operations conducted by Boko Haram during this 2012-2013 period tended to revert back to low-technological means. During this period operations tended to be carried out by small weapons (knives, machetes, and small guns) rather than the automatic weaponry currently favored. It is clear, once again, that the change occurred with the glut of fighters and weaponry that flooded West Africa in the wake of the fall of Libya’s ruler Qadhafi at the end of 2011. At first these fighters and their weapons aided the rise of al-Qaeda in the Maghrib (AQIM), but with its defeat at the hands of the French in January 2013, apparently a large number of fighters and weapons became available in both Nigeria (to Boko Haram) and in the Central African Republic (aiding in the rise of Seleka in March 2013). It is striking how there is a wave-effect on radical organizations throughout the region; when one is defeated, those fleeing the defeat can cause a great deal of destruction to weaker states.

By the end of 2013, it is possible to see a new phase in Boko Haram’s tactics. The first manifestation of this change is the rise inlarge-scale massive attacks, usually on villages, with a heavy loss of life. At least 2,053 people were killed during the first half of 2014 by these mass attacks. Starting in spring 2014 Boko Haram began a campaign of kidnappings, most famously the some 279 schoolgirls who were kidnapped on the night of April 14-15, 2014 from a boarding-school at Chibok. Although some of the girls managed to escape, it is clear from video taken of them (May 12, 2014), and from the statement of Shekau that the vast majority of them remain under the control of Boko Haram, and most probably as he stated, have either been married to the fighters, or sold into slavery. Nor is this the only kidnapping of women and girls carried out by Boko Haram; a number of other raids have been focused upon this end through the summer of 2014. By the end of 2014, Boko Haram probably had at least 10,000-15,000 soldiers, and perhaps as many as 50,000 supporters.

Another concurrent manifestation of the caliphate phase of Boko Haram has been the reintroduction of suicide attacks, which are reflected in recent mass-casualty attacks. These have been directed against civilian targets for the most part, and the perpetrators include a large number of female suicide attackers. Targets have been mosques, markets, bus stations, schools, military encampments, and residential areas. The numbers of dead from the various massacres have yet to be fully tallied.

Although the Nigerian army’s record during the year of 2013-14 is a miserable one, during the course of which Boko Haram managed to carve out for itself a fairly substantial state in the northeastern three states of Nigeria (Borno, Yobe and Adumawa), after a large-scale attack on the key capital-city of Borno, Maiduguri, was repulsed in January 2015, Boko Haram began to retreat. Most of its important towns were recaptured by the Nigerian military through spring 2015, and many of its bases in the Sambisa Forest (along the Cameroonian border) were overrun during the summer and fall of 2015. However, there is still a core Boko Haram following, and virtually none of its leadership has been apprehended.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Boko Haram is a Salafi-jihadi organization that has its religious-ideological roots in a Wahhabi interpretation of Islam. Its name is one bestowed upon the group by outsiders, who identified the primary difference between it and other Salafi groups as beingBoko Haram’s opposition to any forms of secular education. Indeed, Muhammad Yusuf’s book, Hadhihi `aqidatuna wa-minhaj da`watina (This is Our Creed and Method of Proclamation) (c. 2007), does have a substantial section concerning education. Yusuf’s opposition to education stems from the charges that a number of teachings, such as the heliocentric system, the theory of evolution, and other foundational learning methods are un-Islamic. He states, enumerating the negative factors:

1. Mixing of the sexes which is forbidden in our Islamic religion, and its forbiddance is well-known as a necessity.

2. A woman adorning herself, in spite of what God said: ‘Stay in your homes and do not display your finery as the pagans of old did.’ (Q 33:33)

3. Physical exercises which distract from religion, like football (soccer), handball and the Olympic competitions.

4. For the woman to travel alone, without a (male) guardian or a husband, in spite of the forbidding of the Prophet of her, saying: ‘It is not permitted for a woman who believes in God and the Last Day to travel day or night without a (male) guardian or her husband.’

5. Spreading of fornication, and disgusting actions, like forbidden sexual relations (zina), lesbianism, and homosexuality” (Hadhihi `aqidatuna c. 2007: 92-93).

There are sections in the book that detail Islamic opposition to democracy, which is characterized as a religion (similar to the characterization of Abu Musa`b al-Zarqawi, who is cited directly), and there are sections devoted to denouncing Shi`ism and Sufism, as well association with secular government as leading to polytheism.

Yusuf’s thought was fairly marginal within the context of northern Muslim Salafi thought, and it is known that he was taken to task by several scholars, a number of whom were assassinated during the early period of Boko Haram’s activities.

The period of Shekau’s ascendancy has not been characterized by intellectual development. Shekau’s thought is that of a Salafi-jihadi militant, who in contradistinction to Yusuf rarely cites the Qur’an directly, but frequently alludes to Salafi ideas. A good example of his video statements is from the video of May 10, 2014:

“This is a war against Christians and democracy and their constitution; we have not started, we will be in Abuja, and in every state in Nigeria.

This war is against Christians, I mean Christians, generally the infidels. Allah says we should finish them when we get the chance…I am working for Allah and will die for it. No one can stop me. You killed Mohammed Yusuf. Are you not saying he is even better than Shekau? Even if you kill me, other fighters will rise better than me; I am nothing and worthless before Allah, for whom I am working. You are sitting with Christians and saying we are one, saying there is no difference. We are not one with infidels. We are friends with [the Muslims of] Afghanistan, Mali, Yemen and Pakistan, and we are going to wipe out the Christians. Are Christians the people with whom we should play? It is either you are with us or you are with them, and when we see you, we will harvest your neck with knife” (Cook 2014).

Shekau’s style is not an easy one, and although he is capable of producing sensational or chilling quotes for his non-Muslim audience, there is no evidence that his presentation is an effective one in gaining support from his Muslim audience.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

The founder of Boko Haram, Muhammad Yusuf, was a charismatic figure, and apparently attracted a number of people in thenortheast of Nigeria by the strength of his personality. It is by no means clear that he achieved complete operational control over the group that would become Boko Haram, however, and there were probably a number of different small cells throughout northern Nigeria.

Boko Haram under Yusuf’s leadership, and during the period 2010-2012 was much more of a broad-based leadership than it was to become during the period 2013-2015. Two leaders, Manman Nur and Khalid al-Barnawi, were both prominent, and at least Nur was Cameroonian. Both seem to have been disaffected by Shekau’s strategy during the period 2012-13, and apparently were the driving force behind the foundation of Ansaru. This latter group had many of the same goals as Boko Haram, but was careful to direct its violence against non-Muslims. However, Ansaru has not carried out operations during the period 2014-2015, and it is not clear whether it still exists. (Zenn 2014)

Abubakar Shekau concentrated Boko Haram around his person, and during the period of his ascendancy, roughly 2011-2015, hewas virtually the public face of the group. Several times the Nigerian military made the claim that he was dead, or that the person on the over forty videos issued during this period was an impersonator. Whatever the truth of these allegations, the person known as Shekau invariably appeared in military fatigues, spoke in an aggressive, belligerent manner, and did not project a high level of Islamic knowledge. The content of these videos was never very sophisticated, and the text more of a ramble rather than a prepared, carefully thought-out statement.

Since May 2015, Shekau has disappeared entirely from Boko Haram’s videos, giving rise to rumors that he might have been removed or has departed for another section of the Islamic State. At this point, November 2015, there does not seem to be a replacement for Shekau. Perhaps Islamic State has chosen a comparatively leaderless image in order to counteract the personality cult that Shekau cultivated.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Boko Haram suffers from several fundamental contradictions: it is basically a Salafi-jihadi organization that is committed to the establishment of an Islamic state throughout Nigeria. However, because of its lack of appeal among the majority Hausa-Fulani Muslim population of northern Nigeria (not to speak of its inability to gain support among Muslims in the south), Boko Haram effectively turned itself into a local, Kanuri group. This fact created a boundary beyond which Boko Haram has been unable to penetrate: although it can carry out operations in major northern and Middle-Belt cities, it has not demonstrated any ability to generate a mass following outside of its ethnic limits.

This fact is compounded by Boko Haram’s methods of violence, and its inability to demonstrate links between violent actions (for example, suicide attacks or large-scale massacres) and the stated goal of establishing an Islamic state. Many of the victims of its violence have in fact been Muslims, and although Boko Haram highlights its attacks upon Christian or governmental targets, the reality is that it frequently targets mosques and Muslim religious leaders as well. Attacks upon Muslim targets are consistent with the doctrines of takfir, but are inconsistent with the larger range of Islam in northern Nigeria, and even with Salafism. Boko Haram has not demonstrated the ability to attract any serious Muslim scholars to its cause.

For the above reasons, the operations of 2014 were critical. Boko Haram was unable to move beyond the Kanuri region of northeastern Nigeria, and therefore was constrained to attack Kanuri regions in the neighboring countries of Cameroon, Chad and Niger. These attacks had the immediate result of drawing the governments and armies of these countries into fighting Boko Haram. Especially the militaries of Chad and Niger proved to be quite serious in fighting Boko Haram, and the successes of these militaries may have shamed the Nigerian government into taking the Boko Haram insurgency more seriously.

With the union of Boko Haram and Islamic State, there are a number of challenges for the new province. One is to survive the onslaught of the Nigerian, Cameroonian, Chadian and Nigerien forces, which are backed by U.S. and French troops as well. Thus far, Boko Haram has accomplished this task. Presumably its best strategy is to wait the coalition out, until new opportunities present themselves. A second is to find new leadership to replace that of Shekau, whose presence precludes any success for Boko Haram throughout the region of northern Nigeria. As he appears to have been sidelined since summer 2015, most probably this is taking place at the current time. The third is to generate a series of tactics and operations that will be consistent with Salafi-jihadism, but will highlight the divide between the Nigerian government and the northern Muslim population. Logically, such tactics and operations would focus violence upon the Christian population instead of upon the Muslims. This change has not yet occurred. Fourth, Boko Haram has to develop a coherent structure coupled with a media program that can both inspire confidence in its leadership, and communicate its message to the Muslim population. This has not occurred either.

The prospects for Boko Haram in the short-term are not good. However, it is very possible that the Nigerian government will make a mess out of its otherwise successful containment of the group. It remains to be seen, also, to what extent the subservience to Islamic State will affect the group ideologically and strategically.

REFERENCES

Cook, David. 2014. “Boko Haram: A New Islamic State in Nigeria.” Accessed from http://bakerinstitute.org/research/boko-haram-new-islamic-state-nigeria/ on 15 November 2015.

Yusuf, Muhammad. c. 2007. Hadhihi `aqidatuna wa-minhaj da`watina. Maiduguri. Thanks to Alex Thurston for supplying me with a copy of this work.

Zenn, Jacob. 2014. “Boko Haram: Recruitment, Financing, and Arms Trafficking in the Lake Chad Region.” Center for Combatting Terrorism at West Point. Accessed from https://www.ctc.usma.edu/posts/boko-haram-recruitment-financing-and-arms-trafficking-in-the-lake-chad-region on 15 November 2015.

Post Date:
19 November 2015

 

Share

Concerned Christians

CONCERNED CHRISTIANS TIMELINE

Founder : Monte Kim Miller.1

Date of Birth : April 20, 1954 2 .

Birth Place : Burlington, Colorado 3 .

Year Founded : 1985 4 .

Sacred or Revered Texts : Bimonthly newsletter, Report from Concerned Christians . Our Foundation radio program. The Old Testament is also used, but their beliefs primarily deal with the New Testament.

Size of Group : There were 78 members of the group in September 30, 1998. How many perceive themselves to still be members of the group is unknown. 10

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Monte Kim Miller was born on April 20, 1954 and raised in the small farming community of Burlington, Colorado. Miller’s family did not attend church, but he claims to have converted to Christianity after listening to Bill Bright, founder and president of Campus Crusade for Christ. He allegedly worked for Campus Crusade, but no record of that work can be found. Miller received no formal theological training. Thus, he claims he avoided any “disciplining in ‘man’s’ traditions” and was able to learn solely from God. 5

Miller was an anti-cult activist in the early 1980’s, around the same time he formed Concerned Christians. He was working as a marketing executive at Proctor and Gamble at the time and he began to lecture at local Denver churches. Miller formed Concerned Christians in response to the New Age movement and his perception of anti-Christian bias in the media. His newsletter, Report from Concerned Christians focused on such topics as feminist spirituality, the Harmonic Convergence of 1987, New Age trends in the Christian church, and alternative medicine. 6

By the mid-1980s Miller’s views began to deviate from orthodox evangelical Christian doctrine and practice. It is claimed that Miller began to have conversations with God at this point, but this is disputed. By around 1988 Miller’s focus began to shift even more. This is evidenced in a series of newsletters criticizing the World-Faith movement and the Roman Catholic Church. Although this in itself is unremarkable, as many religious organizations were also voicing concern in regards to these groups, it served as a precursor to Miller’s attacks on organized Christianity.

Miller began to isolate himself starting in the early 1990’s. In 1996 he began producing a radio program entitled Our Foundation . The program was removed from the air after Miller refused to pay for air time, claiming that God had ordered him not to pay. Miller declared bankruptcy after becoming more than $600,000 in debt. He asked his followers to contribute up to $100,000 apiece. When they refused, it is alleged that he advised his followers that they were going to hell. 7

It was also during this time that Miller began to channel messages from God. His prophecies became increasing apocalyptic. He proclaimed himself to be one of the two witnesses of Revelation 11, who would be killed in Jerusalem in December 1999, and then resurrected after three days. He also prophesied that the Apocalypse would begin after Denver was to be destroyed by and earthquake on October 10, 1998. 8

Seventy-two members of the Concerned Christians group abandoned their homes on September 30, 1998 and apparently fled to Jerusalem. The alleged reason for their abrupt departure was both to avoid the destruction of Denver and also to prepare themselves to witness the coming of the Messiah in Jerusalem during the millennium. Israeli authorities raided the homes of 14 members of the group on January 3, 1999, alleging that the group was planning to commit a violent action in an attempt to instigate Christ’s Second Coming. The members were deported on January 8, 1999, and they were returned to Denver. 9

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

The beliefs of the Concerned Christians group reflect those of many religious fundamentalist groups. Monte Kim Miller focuses on several key issues and is concerned primarily with the New Testament, especially the Book of Matthew. The following concepts are derived from the only known source available regarding the beliefs of this group, the transcripts of a radio program, Our Foundation , preached by Miller. There are 45 numbered programs.

First and foremost, Miller teaches about the importance of spiritual rebirth. This spiritual birth, as opposed to our natural birth, leads to eternal life. To glorify the importance of flesh is to lead a life contrary to the spirit of God. Following that, Miller preaches that humans must become meek and lowly in heart so that they can decrease themselves and Christ can increase himself in them. This suffering and the death of self (and his own ways and desires) correlates with the theme of diminishing so Christ can prosper, and this is accomplished through the Holy Spirit.

Through this decreasing/increasing of the self and Christ and the concept of “cross- carrying” (the idea of suffering identified with Christ bearing the cross), the fruits of the Holy Spirit can be attained. When it is no longer the self that lives, but Christ within the self, it is then that the fruit of the Holy Spirit can be manifested. The fruits of the Spirit include meekness, temperance, longsuffering, gentleness, love, joy, peace, and goodness. Faith is also a fruit of the Spirit, but more importantly it is the means by which these fruits can be achieved.

Humility and self-denial are the next two issues dealt with in the radio programs. Humility is produced by faith, and humility is a centerpiece of each fruit of the spirit. Christians are to humble themselves before one another and also before non- believers. Christians are not to attempt to achieve ruler ship status over the governments of the world during this age (the present). This is the age for humility, not reigning over the fallen world system. Miller believes that the Heavenly Kingdom Teachings are what Christians should live by, and they include:

By denying ourselves,

Carrying our crosses,

Being humble before others, and

Living in Faith.

One cannot abide by these teachings unless the Holy Spirit is in the heart. These teachings to Miller represent the divine edict to turn the other cheek and to love your enemies. It is this concept that is later expounded on it great detail in future programs. Miller’s focus in the programs numbered 10-20 is on self-denial and its consequences.

One should submit to the Holy Spirit and deny oneself. Men who do not know Jesus Christ pursue self; they pursue their own lives and dreams. They pursue the desires of their flesh, and these are the fruits of self-will. The fruits of the Spirit come from self-denial – and that self-denial is a result of the giving up of your own life for the pursuit of Christ’s. One must ignore the earthly kingdom’s “wisdom of this world” because it will lead to the pursuit of self and the fallen natural man. One must strive at all costs to avoid this downfall. The fallen natural man, for example, will take revenge when wronged. Miller then describes the various characteristics ascribed to the self, such as selfishness, self-importance, self-centered, self-serving, self-interest, self-love, and self-pity, among a few.

Miller contends that the only positive aspect of self is self-improvement, which comes about only through a denial of self (a “death to self”) and a subsequent victory in Jesus Christ. There should be no self-defense, even in the example of slanderous accusations are made against one’s nature. Like Christ on the cross, one should merely accept those accusations and forgive his enemies. Along these lines, Miller challenges people to:

Bless them that curse us,

Do good to them that hate us,

Pray for them which despitefully use us.

The next issue that Miller addresses is resistance to evil. He argues that true believers should not resist evil, but should resist Satan. Consequently, Miller argues that one is in fact resisting Satan when one refuses to resist the evil perpetrated by those who do not have Jesus Christ in their lives, and who are Satan’s agents in the flesh. Miller contends that any form of resistance to evil, even non-violent (as demonstrated in the actions of Ghandi and Martin Luther King, Jr.,) is unbiblical.

The rest of Miller’s sermons are devoted to the transition from the Old Testament rule of law to the New Testament world of grace.

One should not merely see God’s grace directed to the believer, but one should see God’s grace shining through the believer. One is not to render judgment and attempt to punish non-believing sinners according to Old Testament law, because the new covenant is stronger than the old.

Miller’s emphasis in the last sermons is to establish the idea that believers not challenge government, or attempt to create laws that would punish sinners, but rather to not resist their evil, because one had no legitimate right to judge non-believers.

Like Christ, who came to earth without judging but only to save, believers should try to offer the non-believer eternal life through Jesus Christ, in the same spirit that Christ saved the world. Miller cautions his listeners against the easy trap of a “common religious purpose”, which serves to bring together true believers into deception and alliance with those who are religious but do not truly follow Jesus Christ into the resistance of evil in society. This deception can lead a believer to think is acceptable to resist evil in order to make society more righteous. An example of this is an anti-abortion law. Miller argues that it is not the place of believers to make these laws, because that is an example of resistance to evil.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

“There’s a gulf of Biblical dimensions between what Monte Kim Miller preaches on tape and what some have heard firsthand” 11 .

So begins an article in the Denver Rocky Mountain News , and so also begins the difficulty of distinguishing and discerning the truth from opinion, not only in this article but also all articles written about the Concerned Christians. There most certainly is a discrepancy between the written and/or oral teachings of Monte Kim Miller and the accounts given by family, friends, former members, and self proclaimed “cult experts”. While there doesn’t seem to be any immediate consequences arising from this simple fact, complexities arise because only one faction of this divide is talking to the media – and it isn’t Mote Kim Miller and his followers.

A careful examination of the archive of newspaper articles written about the Concerned Christians, suggests that local newspapers have been less than objective. The statistics that follow are derived from the archives of the Denver Post – I have also read through all of the articles from the Rocky Mountain News and found that the articles presented in it follow the trend that is illustrated below, therefore I have chosen to only focus on one newspaper for the sake of clarity.

There were 39 total articles published on the subject of the Concerned Christians between October 7, 1998 and January 3, 2000. In those articles there were 57 sources quoted. By calculating the number of times any given source was quoted, I concluded there are 132 “quotes” in the 39 articles. A few persons accounted for many of the quotes. To clarify, a quote is not calculated by ascertaining the number of times a certain person spoke throughout the same article, but rather if that person is quoted at least once in the article, that is considered a “quote” for him or her. The “quote” number ascribed to a person or group is the number of times that person or group was cited as a source in the articles. The majority of these sources (35) were quoted only once. The breakdown of the sources is as follows:

There were 22 family members or friends quoted. These family members and friends accounted for 52 “quotes”.

There were 5 anonymous sources quoted. These sources accounted for 10 “quotes”.

There were 13 “official” sources quoted. These sources accounted for 15 “quotes”. Of these 13 “official” sources, 9 issued neutral statements regarding Concerned Christians, 3 issued what can be considered negative statements, and 1 issued a positive statement on their behalf.

Perhaps most interestingly, there were 3 anti-cult activists quoted as sources, but between the three of them they make up 35 “quotes”. That is almost 1/3 of the quotes attributed to 3 people.

Family spokespersons

Among the family members and friends portion, the most often quoted include John Weaver, Sherry Clark, Jennifer Cooper and Del Dyck.

John Weaver is the father of Nicolette Weaver, an outspoken critic of the group who falls under both the family member and former member rubric. Nicolette’s mother, Jan Cooper, is believed to be a high-ranking member of the group and Nicolette has testified that her mother often told her of the short time they had left on earth and that if directed by Miller, she would kill Nicolette. 12 John Weaver often makes highly derogatory statements regarding the group, including claims that the group demands members surrender their lives to Miller’s dictums, charges that Miller is a “con” and “biblical illiterate” 13 and beliefs that Miller is like Almighty God to members and has the ability to plot his own martyrdom and lead them to mass suicide.

Sherry Clark is often the unofficial spokeswoman of the family members, and she testifies that when she met with Miller he told her the only way to be saved was to write a check for $70,000 while simultaneously twisting his mouth and talking in a “weird voice” 14 . She has also questioned his ability to make choices. She is the primary source for characterizing the feelings of family members regarding the cult – she has said that the experience has tragically divided and pulled families apart. 15

Jennifer Cooper is the daughter of John Cooper, who is the husband of Jan Cooper and who also is believed to be the primary financer of the group’s activities. Jennifer successfully petitioned for a conservatorship for control of her father’s estate. To do so, she had to convince a judge that her father was unable to make financial decisions for himself. Cooper claimed that her father had been “brainwashed” and was acting out of character. 16 She feels as though Miller is only after her father’s money.

Lastly, Del Dyck only made the news around January 7, 1999, when 14 of the members were being deported from Israel back to the United States. Knowing his son would be among the members returning, he flew to Denver and met every incoming flight from Tel Aviv – to no avail. These four people are characteristic of the family member’s testimonies as a whole. Generally, family and friends express frustration, anger, sadness, and hurt, which is not surprising. Their sentiments, however, cannot be considered objective.

The anti-cult experts

It is understandable that a group that believes the media to be biased against them would be reluctant to respond to requests for interviews. How much effort the Denver media made to speak with group members is not known, but there are no quotes from members of Concerned Christians in the news stories I examined. One would expect the media would call upon family members for perspective about a group that was believed to be controversial even before they disappeared. If this is understandable, it is also clear that the media have not sought more objective or neutral perspective. Indeed, as I noted above, three local anti-cult activists account for approximately one-third of all quotes. To more clearly understand the context of the quotes used by the media, it may be instructive to offer brief sketches about the three most frequently cited “experts.” In each instance, it is clear that these “experts” are working with presuppositions that preclude much objective analysis.

Bill Honsberger is referred to in many news articles as a “local cult expert.” He is, in fact, a Christian missionary with the Baptist church. Honsberger virulently attacks the legitimacy of both Miller and his followers. He is quoted in 15 of the 39 articles. Some of his more aggressive accusations include:

“Miller is liable to do something bizarre to ensure his place in history” 23 .

“[H]e has that much control. You question him, you question God” 24 .

Honsberger also believes Miller’s divine edicts could turn violent, and that he [Miller] is capable of ordering a group suicide. Honsberger feels that Miller would not mind dying if his prophetic role in the universe was intact. He further considers Miller to be a danger both to those in his group and those around him. Miller’s power, Honsberger asserts, lies in his ability to convince his followers to abandon their families and isolate them completely. 25

Honsberger has also said that Miller has threatened to kill him and casts him as the Antichrist. 26 What is more interesting than all of these characterizations, however, is the fact that Honsberger is one of the only people who can testify to the beliefs of the Concerned Christians. He is often called upon to present their beliefs to the media. This can raise some concerns, as will be discussed later, with the validity of the presentation of their beliefs.

Mark Roggeman , tied with Honsberger as the most quoted source about Concerned Christians, is a Denver police officer who “tracks cults in his spare time”. 27 Roggeman often issues statements of a rather generic sort, usually he comments on the status of family members or general concepts of the members’ beliefs. While he may not provide harsh attacks on the cult members, Roggeman is clearly anti-cult. He was indicted on June 11, 1981 for second degree kidnapping and false imprisonment. He was charged with forcibly kidnapping Emily Dietz and holding her against her will for nearly two weeks before she finally escaped by jumping from a second story window in the middle of the night. 28 It is clear that Roggeman should not be considered an unbiased source.

Hal Mansfield is the director of the Religious Movement Resource Center. The Center is concerned with dissuading people from entering into what they term “destructive cults”. They define a destructive cult as “an organization that inhibits individual freedom of thought through the use of violence, deception and mind control”. 29 A destructive cult is not defined on the basis of its belief system or theology, but rather the dynamics of group organization. There are two different methods by which a group is deemed to be a “destructive cult”. First, from “Thought Reform and the Psychology of Totalism” by Dr. Robert Jay Lifton, there are eight points of mind control. They are:

Milieu control

Mystical manipulation

The demand for purity

The cult of confession

Sacred science

Loading the language

Doctrine over person

Dispensing of existence. 30

Another guide used by the Center is the Cult Danger Evaluation Frame developed is P. E. I. Bonewits. This evaluation uses a ten-point scale. The areas rated are:

Internal control

Wisdom claimed

Wisdom credited

Dogma

Recruiting

Front groups

Wealth

Political power

Sexual manipulation

Censorship

Dropout control

Endorsement of violence

Paranoia

Grimness

Surrender of will. 31

Both of these resources are considered by scholars of religious movements to have dubious validity.

Mansfield is the most outspoken and derogatory of the anti-cultists. He often compares the Concerned Christians to the members of Heaven’s Gate, Jonestown, and the Branch Davidians. He has said he considers the Concerned Christians a “very dangerous group”, 32 .and charges that Miller is wrapped up in a power trip. Hansfield also has made assumptions about the violent tendencies of the group. When there were no weapons found on the members after a raid on their house in Jerusalem, Mansfield indicated that weapons were readily accessible to the members. “Come on, that’s the Middle East. You can go across the border and come back with an armful of AK-47s,” he said. 33

Mansfield has also alluded to previous instances of Miller’s “violent tendencies,” but there is no verifiable evidence to support his statements.

Official sources

The “official” sources that were quoted usually offered neutral statements, and many times were not directed at Concerned Christians specifically but rather at new religious movements generally. There were, however, some interesting contradictions among these sources. Consider the following:

Linda Menuhin, and Israeli police spokeswoman, said that Israel would act vehemently against any attempt of extremist groups that distract the arrival of Christians. 17

Yair Yizahki, the Jerusalem police commander, also said that the deportation was merely a reaction to the need to fight for freedom of religious worship. 18 This raises an interesting question – how can barring the existence of one religious group promote the freedom of others? This might follow only if, as alleged by the Israeli police, the members of that group are plotting violence.

Brig. Gen. Elihu Ben-Ohn, the national police spokesman, said that the members of Concerned Christians planned to carry out violent and extreme acts in the streets of Jerusalem. 19

There were not, however, any charges filed. John Russel, a spokesman for the U.S. Justice Department said there were no charges against the deportees and Bill Carter, a FBI spokesman, said no action was going to be taken against the members. 20

A police source said it was “not in the public interest to spend the time and money to try these men in Israel” 21 .

David Parsons, the director of the International Christian Embassy in Jerusalem believed the action was overzealous and was just an excuse to get them “out of Israel’s hair”. 22

Many have argued that Israel was acting in order to defer other “extremist” groups from causing trouble. The Concerned Christians were used to make an example.

Conclusions

There is no question that there is an obvious discrepancy between the theology presented in the Our Foundation radio program and the reports of mass suicide and violent tendencies, apocalyptic predictions, “God-voice”, and anti-government rhetoric.

The only testimony relating Miller and his followers to the extremist ideas presented in all of the news articles are former members, family members, and anti-cult activists. The problem at hand is assessing the objectivity of these sources and getting to the truth of what really happened.

An issue of considerable importance is why the media so readily adopted these stories as the truth, and why the media seemingly made such little effort to engage Miller and current members. In the early articles about the Concerned Christians, Bill Honsberger was the only person who could attest to Monte Kim Miller’s prophesies and “extreme” beliefs. Consequently, the statements about these beliefs were always credited to Honsberger. For example, “Honsberger said that Miller teaches Concerned Christians members that he is God and prophesies he will die in the streets of Jerusalem in December 1999, only to rise again in three days. He also believes the apocalypse will strike Denver on Saturday,” 34 .

However biased the presuppositions of the source, this is probably proper journalism. Around November, 1998 the attribution “Honsberger said” began to be left out of stories. So, for example, we read “Miller, who considers himself the last prophet of God, has said he will die on the streets of that ancient city [ Jerusalem] in December 1999 and be resurrected three days later” 35 . This leads the reader to the impression that these statements are a proven fact, when in reality that can only be attributed to one anti-cultist.

The group known as Concerned Christians remains shrouded in mystery. Monte Kim Miller seems clearly to be a charismatic leader who holds (or has held) considerable influence over his small group of followers. Whether Miller and his followers are dangerous to themselves and others is not clear. The uncertainty pivots very substantially on the credibility of the evidence about them.

We have essentially no first hand information about the group — only accounts of a few persons who claim some level of involvement in the group in the past. And, at this point, we have little basis for assessing the reliability of their accounts.

What we do know is that a small number of zealous anti-cultists have waged an assault on the Concerned Christians, and these attacks have been transmitted uncritically by the mass media. I have focused on the Denver media, but the national media in the U.S., as well as well as Israel and Great Britain, have largely accepted the anti-cult presuppositions.

Religious movements are the product of human initiatives and, thus, are subject to all the shortcomings of human beings. Monte Kim Miller may turn out to be a real scoundrel, but that is not clear to me at this point.

As a student of religious movements, I am struck by how closely this case seems to conform to the gulf between public perceptions and the objective reality of so many other religious movements in the course of American history.
REFERENCES

Abanes, Richard. 1998. End-time Visions: The Road to Armageddon? New York: Four Walls Eight Windows.

Elliot, Paul. 1998. Warrior Cults: A History of Magical, Mystical, and Murderous Organizations. London: Blandford.

Hubback, Andrew. 1996. Prophets of Doom: The Security Threat of Religious Cults. London: Alliance Publishers for the Institute for European Defence and Strategic Studies.

Lewis, James R. 1999. Peculiar Prophets: A Biographical Dictionary of New Religions. St Paul, Minn.: Paragon House.

WILSON, Bryan, and Jamie Cresswell. eds. 1999. New Religious Movements: Challenge and Response. London; New York: Routledge.

Weber, Eugen Joseph. 1999. Apocalypses: Prophecies, Cults, and Millennial Beliefs Through the Ages. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.

References

  • www.watchman.org/concernedchristianspro.htm
  • Ibid.
  • Ibid.
  • Ibid.
  • Ibid.
  • Ibid. and www.religioustolerance.org
  • www.watchman.org
  • Ibid.
  • Ibid.
  • www.religioustolerance.org
  • Rocky Mountain News , December 13, 1998.
  • Denver Post , January 4, 1999.
  • Denver Post , November 1, 1998.
  • Ibid.
  • Denver Post , January 10, 1999.
  • Denver Post , January 9, 1999.
  • Denver Post , January 4, 1999.
  • Ibid.
  • Denver Post , January 4, 1999.
  • Denver Post , January 6, 1999.
  • Denver Post , January 7, 1999.
  • Denver Post , January 5, 1999.
  • Denver Post , October 7, 1998.
  • Ibid.
  • Denver Post , October 8, 1998.
  • Denver Post , January 9, 1999.
  • Denver Post , October 7, 1998.
  • http://cultawarenessnetwork.org/cani1/page09.html
  • http://lamar.colostate.edu/~ucm/rmrc1.htm
  • Ibid.
  • Ibid.
  • Denver Post , October 8, 1998.
  • Denver Post , January 4, 1999.
  • Denver Post , October 7, 1998.
  • Denver Post , November 9, 1998.
  • Denver Post , January 18, 1999.
  • Ibid.
  • http://www.jeack.com.au/~parkdale/cultaware_unzipped/intro.htm
  • Ibid.
  • Ibid.

 

Created by Kacey Chappelear
For Soc 257: New Religious Movements
University of Virginia
Spring Term 2000
Last modified: 04/19/01

CONCERNED CHRISTIANS VIDEO CONNECTIONS

 

Share

Braco

BRACO TIMELINE

1967 (November 23) Josip Jelavic was born in Zagreb, Croatia.

1993 (Autumn) Jelavic met Serbian prophet Ivica Prokic, who became his mentor.

1995 Prokic drowned on a beach in South Africa, leaving Braco as his successor.

2002 Braco held his first healing gazing session for two thousand attendees.

2009 Braco first visited the United States.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Josip Jelavic (alternately spelled Grbavac) was born in Zagreb, Croatia to Viktor and Ivanka Grbavac as an only child on November 23, 1967. Few details of his early life are known. He is married, and he and his wife, Dinka, have given birth to one son, Andelon. It is known that he obtained a Master’s degree in economics in 1991 and then worked as a businessman for two years before meeting his future mentor, Ivica Prokic in 1993. Jelavic was immediately drawn to Prokic, and he quickly gave up his business career to work with Prokic. Jelavic’s father, also a businessman, was opposed to his son’s change in direction and had him drafted into the armed forces to separate him from Prokic. Jelavic refused gun training, however, and was incarcerated for his refusal. Jelavic then commenced a hunger strike and was hospitalized briefly before escaping from the hospital, gaining a discharge from the armed services, and returning to work with Prokic (Whitecliff 2009c:17-20). Additional details of both Jelavic’s and Prokic’s lives are spiritual careers are largely available from hagiographic accounts, primarily Whitecliff (2009c).

Jelavic’s mentor, Ivica Prokic, was born on August 4, 1950 in a village in southern Serbia, an area noted for its spiritualenvironment. It is reported that he experienced bodily pain, visions and out-of-body experiences during his childhood. When he was only seven years old he fell and passed out while playing in the water with other children. He later described this moment as one in which “he felt like a piece of the sun did enter his body,” and this moment is understood to be “the determining moment at which his outstanding abilities have been activated” (Ivica n.d.). Prokic moved from Serbia to Zagreb, Croatia in 1971 and worked for a time selling fish. He is reported to have had a variety of visions during this time and to have engaged in astral travel. His powers continued to increase, and by 1989 he could see both past and future clearly; in November of that year he foresaw a local mining accident (Whitecliff 2009c:38). His healing powers emanated from an event in 1989 when he was bathing: “Ivica saw a man falling from a cross. The cross hit Ivica on the forehead and left a permanent physical scar and blood flowing from his hands. Since that time, he had a special ability to heal and could touch someone and make him or her feel better” (Whitecliff 2009c:38). Because he regarded this healing power as a gift, he followed the Croatian tradition of not accepting payment for his services. Prokic reports that he experienced a prophetic vision in which he “was shown the symbol of the thirteen-ray Golden Sun symbol in a prophetic vision, and told that it would be a direct means for the gift of Source, through the Sun, to reach the people. The symbol was to become a physical manifestation in our material reality, a completion of the circle of life expressing both the spiritual and material elements for the body” (“The Golden Sun, Braco & Ivica Prokic.” n.d.). Prokic adopted the thirteen-ray sun as his symbol. He was 43 years old in 1993 when Jelavic approached him with a gift, a gold necklace with a replica of the thirteen-ray sun. Initially Prokic was angered by the gift. However, once Jelavic told Prokic of his dreams concerning the gift, Prokic realized the spiritual nature of the gift and recounted that, ‘The voice of God said, ‘Accept this from the young man and buy him a sun and chain for his birthday too’” (Braco n.d). The two began to work as healers together, both wearing Golden Sun pendants and other golden jewelry. It was Prokic who gave Jelavic the name Braco (pronounced Braht-zoh), meaning “little brother,” which Jelavic then adopted.

Jelavic spent the next two years studying under Prokic, until the latter’s death in 1995. Braco biographer Angelika Whitecliff relates that when Ivica Prokic drowned when he was caught up by a “rogue wave” during a trip with his protege to South Africa, “Braco’s gift of healing emerged spontaneously” (Whitecliff b:2009). Upon Prokic’s death his pupil continued Prokic’s work. Braco built a center in Zagreb to receive visitors and quickly accrued interest from devotees, journalists and scientists. Whitecliff reports that “Braco’s first act of healing occurred when he touched the picture of a very ill boy whose mother came to him after having a dream that Braco would make her son well” (Whitecliff b:2009). In 2002, Braco held his first healing gazing session, with an audience of two thousand attending. Braco continued to hold sessions at his Zagreb center, but also traveled extensively, holding gazing sessions regularly in such countries as Germany, Switzerland, Austria, Slovenia, United States, Denmark, Italy and Japan. Braco first visited the U.S. in 2009. According to the hagiographic account, before his death Ivica had prophesied that Braco would not visit the U.S. until there had been a “great change of consciousness,” a transformation that is identified as the election of Barack Obama to the presidency in 2008 (Whitecliff 2009c:1).

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Braco is not associated with any doctrines, religious beliefs, or religious institutions. As Braco puts it, “I am not a guru or leader or any sect’” (Remez 2010). He also does not claim to be a healer. As Stollznow notes, “Braco doesn’t call himself a healer because he doesn’t make any claims directly; his claims are made by his staff and devotees” (Stollznow 2011). Braco draws the distinction between a healer and his own helping activity; healers claim that it is their energy that producing healing while he asserts that he is the conduit but not the source of healing energy. Braco acknowledges that “ He sends his love and his warmth to the people, but he feels that something positive is flowing through him while he is gazing.” (“Braco – The Gazer 2011). Although he does not provide a detailed explanation of the source of his energy, he ultimately attributes it to the sun (“Il movimento di Braco” 2008). Despite his disclaimers, Braco is often referred to as a healer.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

Since 2002 Braco’s ritual events consist entirely of Braco gazing silently. During these sessions Braco makes “fleeting eye contact with each member of the audience” (Stollznow 2011). The sessions typically last five to ten minutes, for groups ranging from fifty to a thousand persons. Attendees are encouraged to bring photos of loved ones who cannot attend, so that they too may experience the power of Braco’s gaze. Braco’s energy is considered so potentially overwhelming that children under eighteen and pregnant women are not admitted to the sessions. Those who participate in gazing sessions through videos are cautioned that eye contact must be limited to seven seconds at most.

Whitecliff describes the ritual in the following way: “Braco simply stands on a platform in front of his audience and silently looks
ahead with a gentle gaze. All present are instructed beforehand to stand and to look at his eyes and to think of their illnesses and problems. During the five-minute healing session, many immediately feel an intensity of energy and bodily sensations; others shed tears or have profound experiences of joy” (Whitecliff b:2009). A group of staff members, called “Guardians,” are available to assist participants who have intense emotional experiences. The Miami Herald reported that a spectator at a Miami Beach Convention Center likened the sensation of Braco’s gaze as similar to his emotional experiences at Woodstock; “others described sensations that also evoked memories of the 1969 concert, such as seeing a glowing aura around the healer or watching his face morph into that of Jesus or their children” (Smiley 2011). For his followers Braco is “a conduit of an ethereal energy” (Smiley 2011). Following the gazing session the session host plays a pre-recorded speech by Braco in his native Croation language.

Accounts on Braco’s website describe his energy as curing people of such ailments as “anxiety, depression, fibromyalgia, endometriosis, post-traumatic stress disorder, thyroid conditions, asthma, brain tumors and cancer of various kinds. He reportedly “restored someone’s sight, healed a paraplegic woman, and even cleared someone’s blocked nostrils” (Stollznow 2011). Healings have been reported by individuals who have simply viewed Braco’s videos.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Braco eschews spiritual authority for himself, although he acknowledges that miraculous events do attend his gazing sessions. He has stated that “‘I am only here for those who need me or will need me without their yet knowing it. I look for no gratitude for I am also a man with his own sorrows and joys. I can speak only in respect with what deeds pass through me and which sometimes astound even me by the things they can do’” (Remez 2010).

Braco operates from his center in Zagreb, Srebrnjak 1, but also tours the world to hold gazing sessions in various locations. The groups run from fifty to one thousand people per session. According to his website, his “current form of delivering the energy to the people is by simply gazing at his visitors in groups between 50 and 1000 people without doing any individual meetings or treatment” (Braco n.d.). He performs “twenty sessions a day working 10-12 hours each day at locations across Europe. He is booked with appearances four years in advance” (Whitecliff b:2009). Braco does not charge for his work, though there is an eight-dollar fee at his international appearances to cover organizational costs, such as renting the venue. Braco’s followers also sell books and DVDs about Braco’s life and gazing sessions as well as jewelry. As Braco has begun scheduling gazing sessions around the world, the total attendance at these sessions has climbed above 200,000 (Whitecliff 2009a).

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

While Braco’s mentor, Ivika, was an established healer in Serbia, he encountered some resistance to his healing practice prior to his death. According to Whitecliff (2009c:161), “The church, health profession and media attacked him, and he started to lose some power.” Early in his career Braco did speak to participants in his gazing sessions, but this practice stopped when he also faced media scrutiny, criticism and skepticism. Braco’s response was to end all public communication at his events. Whitecliff (2009a) reported that “Many in the scientific community and media have been distrustful, explaining originally that Braco only hypnotized the people, but when he stopped talking completely during healing sessions this explanation could no longer apply.” The controversy continues. Corroboration of Braco’s healing power has been offered by figures such as Professor Alex Schneider, President of the Parapsychological Association of Switzerland and Founder of the World Healing Congress as well as Dr. Harald Wiesendanger, Founder of the International Agency for Outstanding Healers. On the other side skeptics are dismissive of his reputed powers. For example, Stollznow (2011) has concluded that There is no evidence that Braco’s kind of gazing has any benefits at all, but he takes credit for any perceived successes, and absolves himself of failure by claiming he makes no claims. However, the “no claim” claim is disingenuous; whether the claims come from the public or his crew, the claims are promoted by and therefore made by Braco. For his part, Braco no longer speaks in public, nor does he grant interviews to news media; he relies exclusively on his silent gazing sessions to communicate with his audiences. Despite the debate over his healing power, his audiences have continued to grow in size.

REFERENCES

“Braco.” n.d. Accessed from http://www.braco.net/ on 20 February 2012.

“Braco -The Gazer – Biography (and his Teacher Ivica Prokic).” 2011. Accessed from http://lylescott89.wordpress.com/2011/01/14/braco-the-gazer/ on 26 February 2012.

“Il movimento di Braco. 2008. Accessed from http://www.cesnur.org/religioni_italia/m/metafisica_08.htm
on 26 February 2012.

“Ivica.” n.d. Accessed from http://www.braco-info.com/dcms/about-braco/ivica?lang=en on 25 February 20012.

Remez, Sherry. 2010. “Braco: Man of Miracles Returns to Maui.” Maui Weekly, June 3. Accessed from http://www.mauiweekly.com/page/content.detail/id/501548/Braco.html?nav=103 on 20 February2012.

Smiley, David. 2011. “Hundreds Flock to Miami Beach to feel Rare Power of Man’s Gaze on 1-11-11.” Miami Herald, January 11. Accessed from http://www.palmbeachpost.com/news/hundreds-flock-to-miami-beach-to-feel-rare-1177907.html?printArticle=y on 20 February 2012.

Stollznow, Karen. 2011. “Braco the Gazer: The Silent Evangelist.” Skeptical Inquirer, April 26. Accessed from http://www.csicop.org/specialarticles/show/braco_the_gazer on 20 February 2012.

“The Golden Sun, Braco & Ivica Prokic.” n.d. Accessed from http://www.braco.net/golden-sun on 26 February 2012.

Whitecliff, Angelika. 2009a. “Braco: Mystery Healing Gazes Causes Miracles.” Examiner, March 17. Accessed from http://www.examiner.com/earth-transformation-in-national/braco-mystery-healing-gaze-causes-miracles on 20 February 2012.

Whitecliff, Angelika. 2009b. “Braco: The Lineage of a Super Healer.” Examiner, March 19. Accessed from http://www.examiner.com/earth-transformation-in-national/braco-the-lineage-of-a-super-healer#ixzz1fO2DJzTR on 20 February 2012.

Whitecliff, Angelika. 2009c. 21 Days with Braco. Kealakekua, Hawaii: Awakening Within.

Authors:
David G. Bromley
Stephanie Edelman

Post Date:
29 February 2012

Share

Covert Shin Buddhists

COVERT SHIN BUDDHISTS TIMELINE

1263:  Shinran, the reputed founder of Shin Buddhism, died.

1499:  Rennyo died. Although critical of secret teaching in his pastoral letters, he purportedly entrusted the “true” secret teachings to the laity rather than priests.

1722:  Tsukiji, a Shin Buddhist temple, issued an edict that prohibits the practices of covert Shin Buddhists.

1754:  Yamazaki Mokuzaemon was executed for teaching secret Shin doctrine in northern Japan.

1755:  Covert Shin Buddhists were infiltrated and exposed by Shin Buddhist clergy.

1846:  Ten people who were arrested in northern Japan for covert Shin activities were sent to prison for six months and were required to pay fines.

1879:  Around this year, D.T. Suzuki, who became popular in the West for his works on Zen, was brought by his mother to participate in a covert Shin initiation. He was about nine years old.

1936:  Kida Kohan published a book critical of covert Shin Buddhists in which he claimed they were increasing in popularity in all regions of Japan.

1938 (March 25):  A newspaper article in Yomiuri Shinbun stated that police were instructed to find and expose covert Shin groups.

1956:  Takahashi Bonsen, a professor at Tōyō University in Tokyo, published a major study on covert Shin Buddhists in northern Japan.

1957 (February):  The Asahi Shinbun newspaper reported that the leader of a covert Shin group in Iwate Prefecture lost in a court of law his case for libel against the researcher Takahashi Bonsen.

1959:  Children in southern Kyushu refused to eat a school lunch with chicken meat. Later it was discovered that they were from families of a particular covert Shin Buddhist lineage in which it was taboo to eat chicken.

1971 (January):  Leaders of a covert Shin group in southern Kyushu refused to cooperate with a research team from Ryukoku University after the researchers sent them a letter with documentation on two secret texts.

1995:  After Aum Shirikyō released poisonous gas in a Tokyo subway, a covert Shin leader went to local authorities to explain that his group was not involved in any illegal activities.

2001:  A leader of Kirishimakō, a secretive Shin group in southern Kyushu that identified itself as Shinto, reported to a researcher that the size of his group had declined to about 700 members, about half of what it was in the 1960s.

2008:  A covert Shin Buddhist leader in central Japan told a researcher than there has been a drastic decline in the numbers of members in his group over the past fifty years.

BACKGROUND/FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Because “Covert Shin Buddhism” covers a range of religious traditions that, unlike most delineated religions , do not have clear institutional structures or formal organizations that are legally or publically recognized, a few words of introduction on its varieties and relationship with non-secretive forms of Shin Buddhism are in order before focusing on a particular covert Shin tradition referred to as Urahōmon.

Shin Buddhism, also known as “True Pure Land Buddhism,” has been one of the most popular forms of Buddhism in Japan for the past several hundred years. The vast majority of Shin Buddhists believe that Shin, with its emphasis on trust in Amida Buddha, is a tradition without secrecy – unlike some other Japanese Buddhist sectarian traditions such as Shingon and Tendai Buddhism. Yet we have evidence that shows that over the past 700 years there have been Shin Buddhists who practiced their religion in secrecy and have claimed knowledge of secret teachings.

Among the different covert Shin Buddhists groups that have formed since the thirteenth century, we find the following similarities: they conceal their existence from the public; they do not have a professional clergy; and, although they accept the basic doctrines, texts, and practices of mainstream Shin as valid, they have additional distinctive teachings and practices that temple Shin clergy see as not valid.

Beyond these similarities, however, there is diversity among the dozens of different lineages of covert Shin groups in terms of their histories, specific practices, doctrines and social organizations. The greatest diversity exists between two basic types. The first and most numerous type has existed in many regions of Japan and consists of groups that claim secrecy has always been a part of their tradition. The second type consists of groups located in the southern Japanese island of Kyushu that originally went into hiding when Shin Buddhism was prohibited there from the late sixteenth century until 1875. The covert Shin Buddhists of the second type are similar to Japan’s covert Christians (Kakure Kirishitan also known as ‘hidden Christians’), who went into hiding in the early seventeenth century, in so far as they also stayed in hiding even after the ban on their religion was removed in the 1870s.

Both types of covert Shin have been secretive so as to avoid outside interference and because over many generations secrecy has become a customary protocol that is part of their identity. Only the first type claims its secrecy is to protect teachings that contain ultimate truths unknown to outsiders. The rationale they give for their secrecy is primarily to protect these teaching s from corruption. In particular, they fear that if the teachings were made public Shin priests would want to use them to make money and in the process corrupt them. Neither type of covert Shin Buddhism over at least the past 130 years has been secretive due to involvement with antinomian or illegal behavior or anything that the wider public would find especially nefarious. What causes the most suspicion is the act of concealment itself, not what is being concealed.

Below is an overview of one lineage of the first type of covert Shin. It is located in central Japan and claims to preserve the ultimate Shin teachings. They call themselves shinjingyōja (practitioners of the entrusting heart) and their form of Shin “Urahōmon” (Hidden Teachings). Unlike many religious groups labeled as “esoteric” that advertise the existence of secret knowledge and use it to allure new members, the shinjingyōja are covert in that they hide the very existence of their religion. To protect what they regard as the ultimate teachings from those who would corrupt them, they conceal from the public the existence of such teaching s and where someone might go to learn them. The existence of their Shin Buddhism is only revealed to those that their leaders deem worthy. The teachings are orally transmitted, and mostly passed along family lines. Occasionally close friends are introduced to an Urahōmon leader (zenchishiki), who then decides whether to reveal the existence of secret Shin teachings to them. For Urahōmon’s leaders, protecting the purity of the teachings takes precedence over increasing the number of shinjingyōja .

This overview is based on published sources, which were written either by outsiders who infiltrated a group to expose it, or ethnographers, who through various means were able to do fieldwork on an Urahōmon group. For more in-depth information on covert Shin Buddhists and our sources of information on them, see Chilson 2014.

The existence of secrecy and the problems it caused in Shin can be traced back to when Jishin (a.k.a., Zenran) upset his father, Shinran, for claiming knowledge of secret teachings. Shinran (1173–1263), who all Shin Buddhists venerated as their founder, became so displeased with his son for claiming knowledge of secret teachings, that in a letter believed to have been written in 1256, he disowned him saying, “I no longer consider you my son.” Shinran, to assure his disciples in a distant province that he had not given his son a secret teaching, wrote the following in a letter:

I have never instructed Jishin alone, whether day or night, in a special teaching, concealing it from other people. If, while having told Jishin these things, I now lie and conceal it, or if I have taught him without letting others know, then may the punishment, first, of the Three Treasures, and of all the devas and benevolent gods in the three realms of existence, of the naga-gods and the rest of the eight kinds of transmundane beings in the four quarters, and of the deities of the realm of Yama, the ruler of the world of death—all be visited on me, Shinran. (Hirota 1997, vol. 1:575–76)

Yet the idea that there were secret teachings did not die with Jishin. Shinran’s great-grandson Kakunyo tells us in the fourteenth century about Shin Buddhists holding secret rituals in the middle of the night. Then in the fifteen century, Rennyo (1415–1499), the most prominent figure in Shin history after Shinran, repeatedly criticized those who claimed knowledge of secret teachings. In one of his pastoral letters in 1474 he wrote “The secret teachings (hiji bōmon) that are widespread in Echizen province are certainly not the Buddha-dharma; they are deplorable, outer (non-Buddhist) teachings. Relying on them is futile; it creates karma through which one sinks for a long time into the hell of incessant pain” (Ofumi 2.14; translated in Rogers and Rogers 1991).

In the Edo Period (1603–1868), those who claimed knowledge of secret Shin teachings were not just criticized by Shin leaders but were subject to persecution by local authorities who saw them as a practicing an illegal religion. Documents from the eighteenth century mention covert Shin Buddhists being fined or sent into exile or into prisons. One of the most extreme cases of persecution occurred in 1754 in northeastern Japan where twenty four covert Shin Buddhists were convicted and punished. Most were sent into exile, one was decapitated, and two others were tied to a pole and killed by repeated stabbings in the torso.

Leaders of the shinjingyōja, called zenchishiki, are aware of the early criticisms of secret teachings by Shinran and Rennyo, but are not bothered by them because they claim those criticisms were not about the secret teachings given to them and their ancestors. What Shinran’s son was teaching was indeed, they say, illegitimate.Shinran did not give his ultimate teachings that they have possessed to Jishin but rather to Nyoshin, Shinran’s grandson. These secret, ultimate teachings were then transmitted among the head priests of the temple Honganji up to the time of Rennyo. According to the zenchishiki, Rennyo decided to pass these authentic secret teachings (not the false secret teachings he criticized), to nine laymen because he felt that Shin priests could not be trusted with them. Among these nine laymen was a doctor of Chinese medicine named Yoshimasu Hanshō, back to whom the zenchishiki of Urahōmon trace their lineage.

The zenchishiki seem less aware or concerned with the persecutions that occurred during the Edo (1603-1868) Period. The zenchishiki do not describe episodes of persecution in their sermons or characterize covert Shin Buddhists as victims of misunderstanding; nor do they use stories of persecution to vilify Shin priests or to warn their followers of the importance of secrecy. Surprisingly, the persecution that earlier generations of covert Shin Buddhists suffered are not talked about and victimhood is not part of their identity.

After the Edo period, in the 1880s one prominent leader of Urahōmon named Ōno Hansuke, formed a relationship with the Kūyadō, a Tendai temple in Kyoto that had connections to both social pariahs (hinin) and the imperial family. The Kūyadō helped Ōno and his disciples avoid suspicion because , when large gatherings met at his home or elsewhere, they could tell outsiders they were members of the Kūyadō; but it also led to some Shin priests investigating why members of a Tendai temple did practices that were most closely associated with Shin Buddhism. A strong relationship with the Kūyadō continued into the 1990s but began to wane in the 2000s and is now largely, although not entirely, non-existent.

Shinjingyōja fear that if their secrecy is discovered they will be regarded as dangerous. This so concerned one Urahōmon leader that after the Aum Shinrikyō poisonous gas attack on a Tokyo subway in 1995 (see the profile on Aum Shinrikyō on this site) , he went to the local authorities to explain that he and his disciples were not involved in any nefarious activities. Although the authorities did not seriously investigate him or cause his group trouble, other Urahōmon leaders chose not to expose themselves and continued to conceal their religion.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

The shinjingyōja say there are two types of Shin Buddhism: overt and covert (or omote and ura in Japanese). Overt Shin is found at
Shin temples and in publications on Shin Buddhism. Its most basic authoritative texts are the three Pure Land sutras and the writings of Shinran and Rennyo. Prominent among its teachings is dependence on the other power of Amida Buddha rather than self-power. Amida brings those who have a heart that trusts him (i.e., shinjin) to his Pure Land, which is a paradise from which its occupants all eventually enter nirvana. The most common overt Shin practice is the nenbutsu, which is the recitation of “na-mu A-mi-da bu-tsu” to show gratitude to Amida.

Shinjingyōja agree with and follow overt Shin’s basic texts, teachings, and practices. They see them as correct but incomplete. In addition to Shin’s public scriptures, they say Shinran passed on orally the ultimate Shin teachings in secret. These ultimate teachings were at some point encapsulated in a secret text called the Gosho, which only a zenchishiki (i.e., a Urahōmon leader) can possess and read. To protect its contents, it is concealed even from all other shinjingyōja who are not zenchishiki .

Although the Gosho can only be understood by zenchishiki who were trained by other zenchishiki , there are two basic teachings that are taught to all initiates that clearly diverge from mainstream Shin. First is that the shinjin (i.e., the entrusting heart) can be received from Amida in a ritual in which a person asks for it. The zenchishiki teach that the overt Shin clergy do not know this because they are ignorant of the true meaning of the word tanomu, which appears in the writings of Shinran and Rennyo. Urahōmon teachers say that tanomu does not simply mean to “rely on” as overt Shin clergy preach, but “to ask,” particularly to ask Amida to save them.

Second, initiates are taught that once they receive the shinjin from Amida, they are ontologically equivalent to a buddha. Therefore no other types of religious practice are necessary. Shinjingyōja may go to other temples and participate in other religious activities, but there is no need to do so because there is nothing they can get from them that is greater than what they already received from Amida.


RITUALS/PRACTICES

Urahōmon groups hold religious services one to five times a month. These regular services last for three or more hours, from late morning into the afternoon. They commonly include recitation of the Amidakyō (i.e., the Smaller Sukhāvatī-vyūha Sutra), lunch, and several sermons, one by the zenchishiki, and others by his assistants on non-secret teachings.

Similar to overt Shin clergy, shinjingyōja perform an annual hōonkō (memorial service honoring Shinran) and eitaikyō (memorial services for ancestors). The hōonkō includes recitations of scripture (e.g., Shōshinge and Amidakyō ) and sermons on Shin history and on the life of Shinran. The eitaikyō are done several times a year to honor familial ancestors and express gratitude to them. During these services the same scriptures are recited as in the hōonkō, and incense offerings are made.

The practices most important to Urahōmon and which distinguish it from overt Shin are the ten initiation rites. Before the first initiation rite, an introductory religious service is held during which the existence of a secret Shin tradition is taught. After this service the person will typically be invited to start the initiation process. The first initiation is called ichinen kimyō (literally, “one-thought moment of entrusting”). This is the most important of the initiation rites because it is the one in which the initiate receives the shinjin from Amida. During it, the initiates first listen to sermons on Rennyo’s letters (Ofumi ). Later they are instructed to get on their knees in front of an image of Amida in a darkened room, and bow up and down over and over again while reciting tasuketamae, tasuketamae, tasuketamae (“save me, save me, save me”). This may go on for a few minutes or as long as an hour. The zenchishiki observes the person; then at some stage he says “ yoshi ” (good), indicating that he has discerned that Amida has bestowed the shinjin on the initiate. The receiving of the shinjin often happens on the first attempt, but not always; so some people have to do the rite more than once. After the initiate has done the ritual, he or she is reminded not to tell non- shinjingyōja anything about it.

After having received the shinjin, the person is ontologically ready to understand the secret teachings of Shinran. The next five initiation rites are primarily didactic. These are typically done in order but do not have to be. Because most of them take more than a couple of hours, they are done on separate days, often weeks or months apart. The last three initiation rites are shorter festive ones of celebration that are done in the springtime. All three may be done on the same day. To keep track of where an initiate is in the initiation process, a list of all ten rites are listed on a sheet of paper, and after each rite is complete, the zenchishiki puts a stamp in red ink next to the name of the rite.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Urahōmon is made up of a network of independent groups headed by a leader called a zenchishiki, who is commonly referred to as sensei (teacher). To become a zenchishiki, one must be chosen and trained by a zenchishiki, who instructs the trainee in the most secret of doctrines. The training is orally based and typically involves extensive memorization over a period of years. Writing down instructions or recording them in any way has been forbidden. The memorization is said to be better for remembering the teachings with the body rather than just knowing them with the mind. Those chosen to be a zenchishiki are always men and almost always over the age of fifty when their training starts. It is considered undesirable for a zenchishiki to choose one of his sons to train as a zenchishiki; it is preferable and expected that he will chose a non-relative. A man becomes a full zenchishiki after receiving a copy of the Gosho. Because custom mandates that the zenchishiki not transmit more than three copies of the Gosho , he is limited in the number of men he can make zenchishiki.

No one has authority over the zenchishiki. There is neither a headquarters nor a central place or organization that regulates them or Urahōmon more generally. A group led by a zenchishiki is an independent entity. Different groups are related to each other only through social networks. Two or more zenchishiki of two different groups, for example, may have had the same zenchishiki train them. Zenchishiki might also meet zenchishiki who were trained by their teacher’s teacher. So there is knowledge of and some interaction between the cell-like groups. When shinjingyōja moves to a new area, a zenchishiki, depending on his social connections among other zenchishiki, may be able to introduce a person to another covert Shin group.

What regulates zenchishiki is custom and social obligation. Those who are chosen to become zenchishiki and who give extensive time over the years to becoming one are almost always very committed to the traditions and customary protocols of Urahōmon. They also see themselves as part of a lineage that they are obligated to protect. To act radically different from their teachers would be disrespectful and regarded as dishonorable among shinjingyōja, particularly among older ones who remember previous zenchishiki .

A zenchishiki commonly has assistants who help him with running his group, which may have anywhere from a couple of dozen to a couple of hundred members. The tasks of the assistants may involve giving sermons, managing donations given to the organization, preparing altars by lighting candles, arranging food offerings, and helping clean the area of worship, which is commonly in the home of a zenchishiki or at a privately owned building. Assistants require no special training and include men and women, although the men in this role far outnumber the women.

To become a member of an Urahōmon group, a member needs to introduce the person to a zenchishiki, who then needs to consent to the person joining. Because most new members are born into Urahōmon families, consent is usually given. A simple initiatory rite is often done for newborns and a more extensive initiation rite is done later when the child is mature enough to understand it, which may not be until early adulthood. On occasion other friends or relatives might be introduced to a zenchishiki. After a discussion with this person, the zenchishiki may invite him or her to come back to attend sermons or start the initiation process. One becomes a full shinjingyōja and able to introduce new people to a zenchishiki only after having completed the initiation process, which often takes about a year.

It is hard to know the exact number of Urahōmon members. Among all the lineages of covert Shin there are probably tens of thousands of initiates today, but all the evidence suggests that the numbers have decreased dramatically since the 1960s, in part due to urbanization and the weakening of social ties in local communities. The decline also reflects a general decrease throughout Japan in recent years in participation in Buddhist organizations (Reader 2011, 2012; Nelson 2012). An estimate of several thousand Urahōmon initiates in central (Chūbu) Japan today is reasonable, but the current number may be less than ten percent of what it was fifty years ago.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Many of the issues and challenges that shinjingyōja face are, and have been, directly related to their secrecy. Thus they are suggestive more generally of how secrecy not only results in benefits for those in covert organizations but can also cause problems as well. The issues that shinjingyōja have grappled with show that in a particular situation secrecy can have multiple consequences: some intended, some not, some complementary, and others contradictory.

One problem that secrecy has led to is suspicion by outsiders. Although the shinjingyōja have not faced persecution or even attracted much criticism from Shin clergy since the 1940s, they fear that if a group is discovered, its secrecy will make them appear suspicious, as if they are hiding something vile. Secrecy can help avoid interference, but it can also lead to suspicion that has the exact opposite consequence, namely attracting unwanted attention that leads to interference. For the shinjingyōja secrecy has protected them from intrusion by keeping outsiders ignorant of their existence, but it has also incited outsiders who discover a group’s existence to investigate it to see what it was hiding.

A second problem secrecy has caused shinjingyōja is the preclusion of a public defense of themselves. When Shin clergy have criticized them by saying they were teaching a heresy or were ignorant, they could not publically challenge those criticism by, for example, providing evidence that would counter them because their tradition mandates that they not openly talk about their religion and because it would risk revealing some things about their religion that they want to keep secret.

A third problem secrecy causes shinjingyōja relates to a dilemma that secrecy causes. To preserve a secret, those who know it must refrain from telling it to others; but if they do not tell it to others, the secret will die with the last person who knows it, and thus not be preserved. So shinjingyōja must both conceal and reveal their secrets to preserve them as secrets. To protect their tradition, and the purity of their doctrines and practices, which they claim are based on the ultimate teachings of Shinran, they must hide them. But if they do not also reveal them to new people, their tradition will not survive and what they see as the ultimate Buddhist teachings will be lost forever. In response to this dilemma, the shinjingyōja try to minimize the scope of people who need to negotiate the conflicting obligations to both conceal and reveal, by only giving their top leaders, the zenchishiki, the authority to reveal; all other shinjingyōja must only conceal.

A fourth problem secrecy causes is that it limits shinjingyōja ‘s abilities to proselytize when their tradition is threatened with extinction, as it currently is. Today the numbers of shinjingyōja is dangerously low and within a few generations Urahōmon may be extinct. Because the tradition must be kept secret, the shinjingyōja , including the zenchishiki, cannot advertise their meetings or openly recruit new members. It is important to find trustworthy people to whom to reveal the secrets so that they may stay alive, but this has become more difficult because families of shinjingyōja, who were the main sources of new members, are now drifting away from Urahōmon. For secretive religions that do not hide their existence (e.g., Theosophy, Scientology, Candomblé), secrecy might help allure new members. But the allure of secrecy to attract outsiders is very limited for shinjingyōja because they are required to conceal the fact that there is a secretive Shin tradition. The diminishing numbers of adherents has had a snowball effect: as numbers of members diminish, so proportionately do the number of people who can find and introduce new trustworthy people to the zenchishiki, to whom he can then reveal the secret teachings.

A fifth and final issue worth mentioning relates to finding and training new zenchishiki to replace those that are dying off. To become a zenchishiki requires an extensive commitment of years to memorize lengthy texts and to receive proper instruction of the secrets in the Gosho. As there are fewer shinjingyōja than in the past, there are also fewer who are willing to give this commitment. This problem also relates directly to Urahōmon’s secrecy. Because secrecy discourages the writing down of instructions and interpretations of texts, it makes the training process more arduous as instruction has to take place in person and with oral verbatim memorization. If things could be written down in words or in illustrations, it would be easier to teach and learn the material that needs to be mastered, and more might be willing to pursue becoming zenchishiki. The current decline in zenchishiki is what most threatens the future of Urahōmon because without them there will be no one who knows or be able to convey what shinjingyōja see as the ultimate teachings.

* Due to attempts by covert Shin Buddhists to conceal their existence and activities from outsiders, knowledge of events in their history has remained limited and largely undocumented. The timeline in this profile includes some of the small number of events and episodes over a long period of history during which covert Shin Buddhists were brought into public view.

REFERENCES

Chiba Jōryu. 1996. “Orthodox and Herterodoxy in Early Modern Shinshū: Kakushi nenbutsu and Kakure nenbutsu.” Pp. 463-96 in The Pure Land Tradition: History and Development, edited by James Foard, Michael Solomon, and Richard K. Payne. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Chilson, Clark. 2014. Secrecy’s Power: Covert Shin Buddhists in Japan and Contradictions of Concealment. Honolulu: University of Hawai‘i Press.

Chilson, Clark. 2012. “Preaching as Performance: Notes on a Secretive Shin Buddhist Sermon.” Pp. 142-53 in Studying Buddhism in Practice, edited by John Harding. London: Routledge.

Dobbins, James. 1989 Jōdo Shinshū: Shin Buddhism in Medieval Japan. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.

Hirota, Dennis, translator. 1997. The Collected Works of Shinran, 2 vols. Kyoto: Jōdo Shinshū Hongwanji-ha.

Nelson, John. 2012. “Japanese Secularities and the Decline of Temple Buddhism.” Journal of Religion in Japan 1:37–60.

Reader, Ian. 2012. “Secularisation, R.I.P.? Nonsense! The ‘Rush Hour Away from the Gods’ and the Decline of Religion in Contemporary Japan.” Journal of Religion in Japan 1:7–36.

Reader, Ian. 2011. “Buddhism in Crisis? Institutional Decline in Modern Japan.” Buddhist Studies Review 28:233–63.

Rogers, Minor and Ann Rogers. 1991. Rennyo: The Second Founder of Shin Buddhism. Berkeley: Asian Humanities Press.

Suzuki, D. T. 1986. “An Autobiographical Account.” Pp. 13-26 in A Zen Life: D. T. Suzuki Remembered, edited by Masao Abe. New York: Weatherhill.

Post Date:
2 September 2015

 

Share

Davidians and Branch Davidians (1929-1981)

DAVIDIAN AND BRANCH DAVIDIAN TIMELINE

1885 (March 2)  Victor Tasho Houteff was born in Raikovo, Bulgaria.

1902 (January 5)  Benjamin L. Roden was born in Bearden, Oklahoma.

1907  Houteff immigrated to the United States.

1919   Houteff became a Seventh – day Adventist.

1928  Houteff began intensive study of Bible prophecy.

1929  Houteff began to teach his ideas at his local Seventh-day Adventist church in Los Angeles.

1929  Houteff began to publish his ideas in The Shepherd’s Rod.

1934  After a hearing with Seventh-day Adventist officials, Houteff was officially removed from the church rolls because of his teachings.

1935 (May)  Houteff and a small group of followers moved to a 189-acre parcel of land outside of Waco, Texas, which they named Mount Carmel.

1937 (January 1)  At age fifty-two, Houteff married Florence Hermanson, the seventeen-year-old daughter of two of his followers.

1937 (February 12)  Ben Roden married Lois I. Scott.

1940  Ben and Lois Roden joined the Seventh-day Adventist Church, first in Kilgore then in Odessa, Texas.

1940s  In the early to mid-1940s the Rodens encountered Houteff’s Shepherd’s Rod movement.

1943  Houteff’s group was formally incorporated as “the General Association of Davidian Seventh-day Adventists.”

1952  Houteff sent out thirty missionaries from Mount Carmel, with the goal of spreading his message to every Seventh-day Adventist family in North America.

1955 (February 5)  Houteff died at the age of 69.

1955  Florence Houteff assumed leadership of the group of her husband’s followers.

1955  Identifying himself as “the Branch” mentioned in Zechariah 3:8 and 6:12, Ben Roden laid claim to leadership of the Davidians.

1955 (December 7)  The Davidians sold their original parcel of land and relocated to “New Mount Carmel,” 941 acres near the town of Elk, Texas, nine miles east of Waco.

1958  Ben Roden went to Israel to set up a community that would form the core of the new Davidian community of 144,000.

1959  Florence Houteff became convinced that the events of the end would take place during the Passover season, culminating on or about April 22.

1959  Some 1,000 Davidians gathered at New Mount Carmel for Passover, but their numbers dwindled when no significant events transpired.

1959  Florence Houteff left New Mount Carmel for California and ceased to exercise any leadership over the Davidians.

1959  Ben Roden emerged as the leader of the group at the New Mount Carmel Center.

1961  In the wake of Florence Houteff’s failed prophecy, some Davidians decided to relocate first to Riverside, California and then in 1970 to Salem, South Carolina; this splinter group has remained faithful to Houteff’s theology.

1962 (March 1)  Florence Houteff formally resigned as leader of the Davidians.

1960s  Rival factions battled in court for control of the New Mount Carmel property.

1973 (February 27)  Ben Roden and the Branch Davidians completed the purchase of Mount Carmel .

1977  Lois Roden initiated her own prophetic claims and received revelation that the Holy Spirit is a feminine figure.

1978  Ben Roden dies and is succeeded in his leadership role by his wife, Lois.

1980  Lois Roden published the first edition of her magazine, Shekinah.

1981  David Koresh, then known as Vernon Howell, joined the Branch Davidians at Mount Carmel.

1983  Lois Roden recognized David Koresh as her successor.

1986  Lois Roden died and was buried next to her husband on the Mount of Olives in Jerusalem.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

The sectarian group that became known as the Branch Davidians was part of a complex religious history. The Branch Davidians led by David Koresh, so familiar from the disastrous BATF raid on their Mount Carmel Center on February 28, 1993 and the ensuing fifty-one day siege conducted by the FBI that ended with a fire that destroyed the Center and took 74 lives, were part of a tradition that reached back at least to the nineteenth century.

In the mid-nineteenth century in upper New York state the Baptist layman William Miller (1782-1849) proclaimed that through
diligent study he had been unable to unravel the mysteries of the biblical book of Revelation and, hence, of the time of the end of the world and the second coming of Jesus. From 1831 to 1843 he estimated that he had brought his message to a half million persons. By Miller’s calculation, the return of Jesus would happen between March 21, 1843 and March 21, 1844. When latter date passed without anything significant happening, Miller, like many others who have prophesied the end, did not lose faith in his prediction. Instead, he adjusted his calculations and reset the date for October 22, 1844. Expectations heightened as summer turned into fall, but the date again came and went without incident. Those who had believed Miller’s prophecy experienced what came to be called the “Great Disappointment , ” and his prophetic career came to an end. But even that second experience of disconfirmation was not sufficient to quell completely an interest in the imminent dawn of the millennium (Rowe 2008: 192-225).

Among the Millerites who held onto the conviction that Miller had actually been correct in his prophecies, was a small group in Washington , New Hampshire led by Joseph Bates, James White and Ellen G. Harmon (1827-1915), whom White married in 1846. They believed that Miller’s prophecy correctly referred to Christ entering the inner room of the heavenly temple in order to begin his final work of judgment. So, the events of the end had in fact begun, but they had not yet manifested themselves on earth. Based on their interpretation of Revelation 14 and other biblical texts, the Whites and Bates advocated for observing the Lord’s Day on Saturday as the seventh day of the week, believed that the final judgment was currently unfolding, and expected to be guided by revelation from God in their own time. Ellen G. White, who became the group’s prophet, came to call that contemporary revelation “present truth” or “new light.” The twin foci of observing the Lord’s Day on Saturday and maintaining the expectation of Jesus’ imminent return to initiate the final judgment would remain central characteristics of Seventh-day Adventism from the time of its origins in the small band of New Hampshire Millerites through its entire history. The openness to receiving prophetic “present truth” introduced a principle of dynamism into the broad Adventist tradition that played an especially important role in the origins of both the Davidians and the Branch Davidians (see Gallagher 2013) .

The more proximate origins of the Branch Davidians can be traced to the activities of Victor Houteff (1885-1955), a Bulgarian
immigrant to the United States who joined the Seventh-day Adventist (SDA) Church in 1919 in Illinois . As Houteff studied the Bible, he developed two distinctive ideas that were out of conformity with established SDA doctrine. First, expressing a vivid sectarian indictment of the SDA Church, he disagreed with Ellen G. White that the 144,000 mentioned in Revelation 7 as being worthy of entering the new Jerusalem referred to the Adventists themselves. Instead, he argued that the Church had become complacent and pervaded by “worldly” influences. He saw his own mission as purifying the church from within and gathering a truly faithful 144,000 in anticipation of the Lord’s return. Second, he argued that it was his task to lead the purified 144,000 to the ancient land of Israel , where they would meet Christ at his return. Both the Davidian and Branch Davidian traditions developed an elitist self-conception according to which they would be the first to be redeemed upon the return of Jesus. Borrowing a concept from the agricultural festivals of the ancient Israelites, Ben Roden , one of the leaders who followed Houteff, described the Branch Davidians as “the first of the first fruits – wave-sheaf, vanguard NOT wave-loaves – 144,000, army” of the final harvest of salvation (Ben Roden 1959: 4).

Unlike Ellen G. White, Houteff did not base his authority on visions or other kinds of immediate interaction with the divine, but he did claim that his own work was important in his day as Moses’ work was in his. He was convinced that the moral and spiritual decline of the SDA Church had led it to a crisis point and that its members could either choose to follow him and embark again on the path towards salvation or stick with the Church’s teachings as recently articulated and experience damnation. In 1929, Houteff, then in Los Angeles , began to teach his message. When the SDA Church formally rejected Houteff’s teachings in 1934 and excommunicated him, he felt he had no choice other than to form his own organization. By 1935, Houteff had decided to relocate with his followers to Texas and he arranged for the purchase of a large tract of land outside Waco where they established the Mount Carmel Center (based on their understanding of the prophecy in Amos 1:2). Signaling his hope for the restoration of a physical messianic kingdom in the land of Israel , he named his group the Davidian Seventh-day Adventist Association to evoke the ancient kingdom ruled by King David.

Houteff first published his theological ideas in a tract entitled The Shepherd’s Rod , and the group of his followers was informally known by that name ( Victor Houteff 1930) . The first volume was quickly followed by a second and throughout the 1930s, 1940s and early 1950s Houteff produced multiple religious tracts and collections of his sermons that were distributed by the Davidian publishing operation to a growing list of SDA Church members. In February, 1943 he published The Leviticus of the Davidian Seventh-day Adventists , which details the constitution, by-laws, system of government, and form of education for the Davidian community (Victor Houteff 1943) . Much of the one hundred page document is devoted to citing the authorizing precedents from both the Bible and the writings of Ellen G. White.

Under Houteff’s leadership the Davidians consolidated and developed the community at the Mount Carmel Center and devoted considerable time, effort, and money to spreading their message to all SDA Church members in North America and beyond (including Australia, England, India, and the West Indies). They continued to refine their understanding of biblical prophecy while maintaining their hope that the return of Jesus to conduct the final judgment would happen soon.

When Houteff died in February, 1955, the Davidians lost their leader and faced a dilemma that affects virtually every first-generation religious group. Kenneth Newport suggests that at least some of the 100 or so members of the Mount Carmel community probably left after Houteff’s death, but those who remained faced the task of developing new leadership (Newport 2006: 66). Into that breach entered Houteff’s wife, Florence, along with several other contenders. Soon after Victor’s death, Florence began to make predictions about the future of the community, apparently including the idea that Victor himself would be resurrected. Claiming that on his deathbed Victor had urged her to take over his position, Florence quickly and persistently made her case to the Executive Council of the Davidian Association and eventually garnered their recognition.

During her time as the leader of the Davidians, Florence Houteff continued to put out new issues of the periodical The Symbolic Code, of which nine volumes had been published during her husband’s life (Florence Houteff 1955-1958). To this day there remains controversy about whether Florence ‘s “new Codes” contain the genuine teaching of her husband. But by far the most dramatic and controversial move that Florence made was to set the date of the beginning of the end times. Echoing William Miller’s decision that produced the Great Disappointment, Florence proclaimed that at the end of the Passover season, on April 22, 1959, the events of the end would begin to take place (Newport 2006:101). She urged the Davidians to assemble at the Mount Carmel Center, and some 1,000 did.

The scenario that Florence envisioned replicated much of what her husband had already preached. War would devastate the Middle East and open the possibility for the Davidians to set up their messianic kingdom in the land of Israel; the SDA Church would be purified and the 144,000 eligible for salvation would be gathered.

The failure of Florence Houteff’s prophecy nearly devastated the Mount Carmel community. Those who remained in the community resorted to another familiar strategy for dealing with the disconfirmation of prophecy. A 1960 report argued that the kingdom had failed to materialize because Davidian evangelization efforts had been limited only to the SDA church. It urged that the mission be extended to all Protestant churches (Newport 2006:107). That decision, at least, bought the community more time to spread its message.

There was additional fallout from the disconfirmation as well. A 1961 meeting in Los Angeles effectively split the Davidians into two separate groups. One remained centered at Mount Carmel and the other ended up being based in Salem, South Carolina, where it continues to this day (The General Association of Davidian Seventh-day Adventists 2013; Newport 2006:108).

It then took some time for clear leadership to emerge among the Mount Carmel Branch Davidians. When it did, it was in the person of Benjamin Roden (1902-1978). After joining the SDA church in 1940 Roden and his wife Lois (1905-1986) had first encountered Victor Houteff’s Shepherd’s Rod message sometime in the mid-1940s. It appears that the Rodens had first visited Mount Carmel no later than 1945. They returned several times over the next decade, and when Victor Houteff died in 1955, Ben Roden was confident enough of himself that he made an unsuccessful bid for the leadership of the community.

Roden justified his claim to leadership on the foundation of his own prophetic call. Building on texts like Isaiah 11:1, Zechariah 3:8 and 6:12, and John 15:1-3, he began to conceive of himself as “The Branch,” the individual chosen by God to complete the work that Victor Houteff had begun (Ben Roden 1958) . Roden’s self-designation would also carry over to his followers, who came to be known as the Branches or Branch Davidians. Although Roden did not really acknowledge that he was not the leader of Mount Carmel community, he directed his attention elsewhere in the later 1950s. With his wife and family, he turned to Israel and setting up a community that would form the basis of the eventual Davidic messianic community in the Holy Land Ben Roden 1960). While Florence Houteff and the Mount Carmel Davidians moved inexorably towards the date of April 22, 1959, Ben Roden busied himself with establishing a community in Israel, developing his own distinctive teachings as “The Branch,” and setting up a headquarters in Odessa, Texas. In 1965, after Florence ‘s abdication, he tried to purchase the remaining Mount Carmel property from the trustee who was assigned to liquidate it. After extensive legal wrangling about who really held title to the property, among other things, Roden finally completed the purchase in February of 1973 (Newport 2006:128) .

Throughout the 1960s and 1970s Roden continued to develop and refine his theological ideas. The establishment of a literal kingdom of God in Israel remained a central focus, and Roden even had himself crowned “Viceregent of the Most High God” in June, 1970 at Mount Carmel (Newport 2006: 148). Ben Roden’s writings are not easily accessible. He follows the example of Victor Houteff in compiling complex mosaics of quotations from the Bible and other authorities like Ellen G. White. Their meaning is apparently intended to be self-evident because he offers very little guidance about how they are to be interpreted. David Koresh would later adopt the same expository style in his unfinished manuscript on the meaning of the seven seals in the book of Revelation.

Roden also emphasized that true Adventists should observe not only the moral law of the Christian Old Testament but the ceremonial law as well. Consequently, he introduced the observation of festivals like Passover, Pentecost, and Tabernacles to the Mount Carmel community and framed the understanding of them in eschatological terms. The observation of Passover at Mount Carmel would play an important role in the negotiations between the FBI and members of the community during the fifty-one day siege (Tabor and Gallagher 1995:15).

Like the Adventist leaders before him, Ben Roden did not live to see his fondest hopes fulfilled. The return of  Jesus to conduct the Last Judgment was again delayed. But Roden’s death did not threaten the community with disintegration because his wife Lois was already poised to assume the responsibility of leadership, although the Roden’s son George did dispute her right of succession and would remain a serious irritant to the Mount Carmel community for some time. Like her husband, Lois based her claims on charismatic grounds. She had begun to receive revelations in 1977, and they were the driving force for her innovative theological program, particularly the idea that the Holy Spirit was feminine (Lois Roden 1980). George resorted to more traditional grounds for his claims, asserting that his father had appointed him to a central role in the movement, since Ben Roden believed that his sons would live to see the rebuilding of the temple in Jerusalem .

Even though his mother was clearly elected to lead the Branch Davidians in 1979, George Roden continued to agitate on his own behalf, directing his vitriol first against his mother and then against her and David Koresh, who, as Vernon Howell, joined the Mount Carmel community in 1981. George eventually succeeded in winning a leadership election in 1984, after which he assertively changed the name of Mount Carmel to “Rodenville” and vigorously argued for his primacy. It took a complex series of events, including multiple hearings in court, George’s conviction on contempt of court charges, and his 1989 arrest for murder and eventual confinement in a mental institution, before Koresh could enjoy uncontested leadership of the Branch Davidians.

In the meantime Lois worked assiduously to develop the ideas stemming from her 1977 vision which revealed that the Holy Spirit was the feminine aspect of God. Beginning in 1980, she published Shekinah magazine (always capitalizing or otherwise emphasizing the first three letters in whatever typography she used), which reprinted materials that supported her theology from a variety of popular sources (Lois Roden 1981-1983; Pitts 2014. Like others before her, Lois understood her work as the last stage in the reformation of the SDA church in preparation for the imminent last judgment.

Through the early 1980s Lois continued spread her message, travelling through the U.S., to Canada, Israel, and the Philippines. At the same time, the future David Koresh both learned from her, largely through her Bible Studies, and began to develop his own distinctive theology, which is outlined in the entry on the Branch Davidians (1981-2006). Koresh eventually succeeded Lois as the central teacher for the Mount Carmel Community, though not without interference from George Roden and a contentious break from his former mentor, Lois.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Since the Davidians originated in a sectarian desire to purify the SDA church and that goal remained prominent from Victor Houteff through the time of the Rodens, it is not surprising that many of the distinctive ideas of the SDA church were carried over into the Davidians and Branch Davidians. No matter what theological innovations were introduced, the Davidians and Branch Davidians retained the hope that that the return of Jesus to conduct the last judgment was imminent. Like the Millerites and SDAs before them, they arrived at that conclusion through a painstaking examination of the scriptures, in which the decipherment of the symbolic language of the book of Revelation figured prominently. Their interpretative efforts are preserved in a wide array of theological tracts, Bible Studies, and other literature , much of which is archived on the internet . Davidian and Branch Davidian exegesis frequently makes elaborate and complex typological arguments, in which, for example, figures or events from the Christian Old Testament are viewed as types of figures and events from the New Testament, are viewed which in turn are seen as as their antitypes. The new name adopted by the former Vernon Howell rested on that sort of biblical interpretation in which he could be seen as the antitypical David and Cyrus.

From the time of Victor Houteff through the leadership period of David Koresh, the establishment of a physical Davidic messianic kingdom in the land of Israel was also a prominent theological theme. Ben Roden worked hardest to bring such a kingdom into being in anticipation of the dawning of the end times, taking many trips to Israel in order to set up a community there to which his followers could then emigrate. The central role of Israel in Branch Davidian thinking would later figure into the 1993 siege of the Mount Carmel Center, as David Koresh and his followers struggled to fit the BATF attack into the end-times scenario that they expected.

The SDA notion that a contemporary prophetic figure could be the bearer of “present truth” also animated the various sectarian offshoots from that tradition. In the early days of the SDA Church, James White, a founder of the SDAs along with his wife Ellen, published a periodical entitled The Present Truth. On the first page of its first issue in 1849, he cited the promise of the author of II Peter 1:12 to the early Christian church, “I will not be negligent to put you always in remembrance of these things, though ye know them, and be established in the present truth.” White argued that such present truth could not be limited to the apostolic age but must at least potentially be continually available. He wrote that “Present truth must be oft repeated, even to those who are established in it. This was needful in the apostles (sic) day, and it certainly is no less important for us, who are living just before the close of time.” (James White 1849:1). Similarly, with regard to the observance of the Sabbath on Saturday, Ellen G. White wrote in her second volume of Testimonies for the Church (1885) that “The present truth, which is a test to the people of this generation, was not a test to the people of generations far back. If the light which now shines upon us in regard to the Sabbath of the fourth commandment had been given to the generations in the past, God would have held them accountable for that light.” (Ellen White 1885: 693).

In their own distinctive ways, each of the leaders of the Davidians and the Branch Davidians laid claim to deliver such present truth. Victor Houteff was the most reticent about claiming any kind of prophetic authority, but that did not stop him from depicting the Shepherd’s Rod teachings as being of momentous consequence. In the first volume of The Shepherd’s Rod , he wrote concerning his own teaching that “no new-revealed truth was given to the church during the forty years from 1890 to 1930, and that therefore every claimant to a heaven-sent message during that period was a false one.” (Houteff 1930: 86 ). With Houteff’s own teaching, he implies, “new light” once more shone on the SDA church. Florence Houteff’s contribution of present truth centered on her prediction that April 22, 1959 would initiate the times of the end. Ben Roden had a robust prophetic self-consciousness and introduced a number of theological and ritual innovations based on his own ability to deliver present truth. So also did Lois Roden, especially with her teaching that the Holy Spirit was female. In general, appealing to the Adventist theological conception of “present truth” was the primary way in which a succession of Branch Davidian leaders strove to legitimate their authority. In constructing their prophetic personae, they drew on a well-established theological idea that simultaneously linked them to an authoritative past and justified their efforts at innovation. Their theological innovations were grounded in the idea of present truth.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

Given the importance of deciphering the Bible’s message about the end of the world and the last judgment, it is not surprising that a central ritual for the Davidians and Branch Davidians was the Bible Study. As conducted by leaders like Lois Roden, and later David Koresh, Bible Studies were less free-ranging investigations into the meanings of certain passages than they were catechetical exercises designed to reinforce the proper understanding of the text. In both Bible Studies and the various theological writings of Davidian and Branch Davidian leaders, the Bible was viewed as a single, coherent, self-interpreting whole. The interpreter’s exegetical ingenuity focused on arranging a mosaic of biblical passages that would clarify any obscurities in the text under consideration and deepen readers’ understanding of it. Transcriptions and audiotapes of Bible Studies also were a way for leaders to spread their messages to audiences well beyond the Mount Carmel Center .

The SDAs were well aware of the Jewish roots of Christianity, which originally led them to the observance of the Sabbath on Saturday. Among the Davidian and Branch Davidian leaders Ben Roden was particularly interested in extending ritual practice at Mount Carmel to include the major Jewish festivals as well (Ben Roden 1965). The Davidians and Branch Davidians favored a contemporary form of Jewish Christianity that emphasized the ritual continuities between the Judaism of Jesus’ day and the movement that he founded.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Although the Davidians and Branch Davidians had well-developed bureaucratic organizations, they were nonetheless highly dependent on charismatic forms of leadership. The concept of present truth prepared Adventists to look favorably on contemporary claimants to prophetic authority, even as religious authority came to be concentrated in one family and then another. In distinctive ways, each of the leaders from Victor Houteff through David Koresh claimed to provide just such guidance. Ben Roden, for example, not only came to understand himself as the biblical “Branch,” he also understood his work to continue that not only of Victor Houteff but of Ellen G. White herself, not to mention the prophets from the Bible. He wrote that “it is plain to see that Ellen G. White and Victor T. Houteff were indeed prophets of God and were, truly, writing under the influence of the Spirit of Prophecy. See Amos 3:7. Since Mrs. White and V. T. Houteff both are in the grave, as are the Bible prophets, it is necessary to consult the Branch and Joshua, the Living Testimony of Jesus in the church today, for an interpretation in harmony with the Scriptures and their writings.” (Ben Roden 1955-1956:95). Lois Roden legitimated her own authority primarily by reference to her 1977 vision in which she learned the true nature and gender of the Holy Spirit. Against the backdrop of his predecessors, David Koresh’s claims to authority in the Mount Carmel community appear as variations on a theme. Like Ben Roden, he saw himself in the pages of the Bible, specifically in the figure of the Lamb of God mentioned in Revelation 5, as being worthy of opening the scroll sealed with seven seals. Like Lois Roden, Koresh also claimed an extraordinary revelatory experience, something like an ascent into the heavens while he was in Jerusalem in 1985. Also, like Victor Houteff and Ben Roden, Koresh saw himself as playing a distinctive role in the establishment of a Davidic messianic kingdom.

Charismatic claims to authority do not have a social impact unless they are recognized and acted upon. All of the Davidian and Branch Davidian leaders proved capable of attracting at least some followers to the Mount Carmel Center and, through the dissemination of their teachings, to persuade others that they had achieved substantial new insight into the meaning of the scriptures. The introduction of distinctive theological innovations, such as Florence Houteff’s setting a date for the beginning of the end times and Lois Roden’s proclamation that the Holy Spirit was feminine, typically provoked moments of crisis for at least some of their followers. Defections and at least one significant schism among the Davidians can be traced to moments like those. On the other hand, those who managed to assimilate the new theological ideas into their pre-existing repertoires of commitments only strengthened their commitment to the group and its current leader. The process of strengthening commitment can be seen clearly in the interactive Bible Studies. Since the Bible Studies had more of a catechetical than exploratory function, every time someone attended one in person, read one, or heard one on audiotape, it became an opportunity for demonstrating and reinforcing commitment to the message being taught. In addition to being occasions to expound the distinctive theology of the Davidians and Branch Davidians, the Bible Studies became opportunities for successive leaders to enact and reinforce their leadership.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Both Davidians and Branch Davidians continued to face a challenge that they had in common with all other millennialists. Like the followers of William Miller who faced the Great Disappointment, they continually had to reckon with the delay of the advent of Jesus at the final judgment. When Florence Houteff, like Miller and others before her, actually set a particular date for the events of the end, the challenge became all the greater. The continued delay of the end inevitably cost the various groups that occupied the Mount Carmel Center members, but even those whose commitment was not thoroughly shaken by failed predictions or evident delays consistently had to calibrate their understanding of when and how the events of the end would, finally, unfold. Leaders faced the challenge of maintaining a sense of urgency in the expectation that the world would soon be transformed at the same time that they had to develop explanations for its undeniable delay.

Despite their substantial missionary efforts, primarily among members of the SDA church, Davidians and Branch Davidians also had to reckon with the reality that their message was being rebuffed by their target audiences much more often than it was being accepted. From Victor Houteff on, Davidian and Branch Davidian leaders were unsparing in their indictments of the SDA church. They also, however, made members of the church their primary targets for proselytization. The comparatively small numbers of members of the Mount Carmel community and sympathizers over time, however, show that the groups remained as deviant and heretical in the eyes of the SDA church as they were when Houteff was first excommunicated in 1934. The various traditions initiated by Houteff’s challenge to the SDA church remained small sects in relatively high tension with their parent body and were persistently unable to recruit more than a few hundred followers. The ongoing tension that the Davidians and Branch Davidians experienced with the SDA church eventually paled next to the armed conflict that the Mount Carmel community of David Koresh experienced with the forces of the U. S. government.

REFERENCES

Gallagher, Eugene V. 2013. “’Present Truth’ and Diversification among the Branch Davidians” Pp. 115-26 in Revisionism and Diversification in New Religious Movements, edited by Eileen Barker. London: Ashgate.

Houteff, Florence. 1958. The Symbolic Code , Vols. 10-13. Accessed from http://www.davidiansda.org/new_codes_or_false_codes.htm on 2 August 2013.

Houteff, Victor. 1943. The Leviticus of the Davidian Seventh-day Adventists. Accessed from http://www.the- B ranch.org/Davidian_Association_Leviticus_Bylaws_Constitution_Houteff on 2 August 2013.

Houteff, Victor. 1930. “The Shepherd’s Rod, Vol. I Tract.” Accessed from http://www.the-branch.org/Shepherds_Rod_Tract_Israel_Esau_Jacob_Types_Houteff on 2 August 2013.

Newport, Kenneth G. C. 2006. The Branch Davidians of Waco : The History and Beliefs of an Apocalyptic Sect. New York: Oxford University Press.

Pitts, William L. 2014. “SHEkinah: Lois Roden’s Quest for Gender Equality.” Nova Religio 17::37-60.

Roden, Ben L. 1965. “God’s Holy Feasts.” Accessed from http://www.the-branch.org/Six_Holy_Feasts_In_The_Old_And_New_Testaments_Ben_Roden on 2 August 2013.

Roden, Ben L. 1960. “Branch Field Letter to the Believers in the Land of Promise.” Accesed from http://www.the-branch.org/Lois_Roden_In_Israel_As_Chairman_Ben_Roden on 2 August 2013.

Roden, Ben L. 1959. “ The Three Harvest Feasts of Exodus 23:14-19; Lev. 23.” Accessed from http://www.the-branch.org/Passover_Wavesheaf_Antitype_Branch_Davidians_Ben_Roden on 2 August 2013.

Roden, Ben L. 1958. “ The Family Tree—Isaiah 11:1.” Accessed from http://www.the-branch.org/Isaiah_11_Family_Tree_Judgment_Of_The_Living_Ben_Roden on 2 August 2013.

Roden, Ben L. 1955-1956. “Seven Letters to Florence Houteff. ” Accessed from http://www.the-branch.org/Jesus%27_New_Name_The_Branch_Day_Of_Atonement_Ben_Roden on 2 August 2013.

Roden, Lois I. 1981-1983. SHEkinah. Accessed from http://www.the-branch.org/Shekinah_Magazine on 2 August 2013.

Roden Lois I. 1980. “By His Spirit . . . .” Accessed from http://www.the-branch.org/Godhead_Masculine_Feminine_Father_Mother_Son_Lois_Roden on 2 August 2013.

Rowe, David L. 2008. God’s Strange Work: William Miller and the End of the World. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans.

Tabor, James D. and Eugene V. Gallagher. 1995. Why Waco? Cults and the Battle for Religious Freedom in America Today. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

The General Association of Davidian Seventh-day Adventists. 2013. Accessed from http://www.davidian.org/ on 2 August 2013.

White, Ellen. 1885. Testimonies for the Church , vol. II. p. 693. Accessed from http://www.gilead.net/egw/books/testimonies/Testimonies_for_the_Church_Volume_Two on 2 August 2013. .

Post Date:
3 August 2013

 

Share

Army of Mary / Community of the Lady of All Peoples

ARMY OF MARY / COMMUNITY OF THE LADY OF ALL PEOPLES TIMELINE

1921 (September 14):  On the feast day of the Holy Cross, Marie-Paule Giguère was born in Sainte-Germaine du Lac-Etchemin, Quebec, Canada.

1944 (July 1):  Marie-Paule Giguère married Georges Cliche.

1945 (March 25):  A series of apparitions and messages of the Lady of All Nations to visionary Ida Peerdeman began in Amsterdam, The Netherlands.

1950 (January 2):  Giguère heard a voice stating that the reason for her suffering “will be all unveiled.”

1954:  Giguère started working for the radio and adopted her media identity as Marie-Josée. God spoke to her about The Army of Mary.

1957 (April):  Giguère became a member of local groups of the earlier established Legion of Mary.

1957 (September):  Cliche and Giguère divorced and their children were placed out of house.

1958:  Giguère was ordered by her spiritual leader to start writing on her life and mystical-spiritual experiences.

1968:  Giguère formed a prayer group with lay and religious friends.

1971 (August 28):  During a pilgrimage with her prayer group to the Marian shrine at Lac Etchémin, the creation of an Army of Mary was revealed to Giguère.

1971:  The first contact with French eschatology author, Raoul Auclair, was established; Giguère gets knowledge from him of the Amsterdam apparitions and the messages of the Lady of All Nations.

1973 (March 20):  For the first time Giguère met Lady of All Nations-visionary Ida Peerdeman in Amsterdam.

1975 (March 10):  Cardinal Maurice Roy of Quebec approved the Army of Mary as a formal Roman Catholic pious association.

1978:  Giguère introduced herself as the (mystical) reincarnation of Mary.

1979:  The publication of the autobiographical and spiritual writings (“Vie d’amour”) of Marie-Paule Giguère started.

1983:  Major land acquisitions were realized in Lac-Etchémin for the creation of a major devotional complex for the movement.

1987 (February 27):  The congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith declared the writings of the movement to be in “major and severe error.”

1987 (May 4):  A declaration by archbishop Louis-Albert Vachon of Quebec called the Army of Mary schismatic; it ceased to be a Catholic association.

1988 (March 2):  An appeal by the movement to annul the declaration of May 4, 1987 was rejected by the Canadian archbishop.

1991 (20 April):  The Supreme Tribunal of the Apostolic Signatura in Rome confirmed the declaration of May 4, 1987; it was the ‘final’ decision in the appeal of the Army of Mary to the verdict of being schismatic.

1997:  Giguère is elected as Superior-General of the Community.

1998:  The sympathizing Canadian bishops of Antigonish and Alexandria-Cornwall secretly ordained Army of Mary priests.

2001 (June 29):  A doctrinal note of the Canadian Bishops Conference on the Army of Mary stated that the doctrines are contrary to those of the Catholic Church.

2002 (May 31):  Bishop Punt of Haarlem-Amsterdam declared the Amsterdam apparitions and messages for authentic; he rejected the pretentions of Marie-Paule regarding the devotion of the Lady of All Nations/Peoples within her movement.

2007 (March 26):  Archbishop Marc Ouellet of Quebec stated that the teachings of the Army of Mary are false and that its leaders are excluded form the Catholic Church.

2007 (May 31):  Padre Jean-Pierre, superior Father of the movement and newly called the “Church of John,” promulgated the dogma of Mary Coredemptrix, Mediatrix and Advocate under the title of Lady of All Peoples.

2007 (July 11):  The Roman Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith excommunicated the regular members and ordained deacons and priests of the Community of the Lady of All Peoples; the movement was judged as “heretical.”

2013:  Visionary Giguère, old and bedridden, was supposed to pass away on her birthday, September 14, day of the Holy Cross; the movement keeps low profile.

2015 (April):  Visionary Giguère died at age ninety-three.

2020:   The Amsterdam apparitions were again declared  not to be of a supernatural nature.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Marie-Paule Giguère was born in the French Canadian municipality of Sainte-Germaine du Lac-Etchemin (sixty miles southeast ofQuebec) on September 14, 1921. Despite an early wish to live a celibate religious life, she was advised against that course by the Church. In 1944, she married Georges Cliche (1917- 1997 ) who worked at various jobs and also went into local politics. In 1948, they moved to the town Saint-Georges de Beauce. A life full of sickness and suffering for both her and her husband ensued. Her marital life proved to be so problematic (a “nightmare” in her words) that it led to a divorce in 1957 and an out-of-home placement of her five children (André Louise, Michèle, Pierre, and Danielle). However, much later, after she had established the Army of Mary, she partially reconciled with her husband when he became a member of the movement. Meanwhile, while trying to overcome her traumas by giving a place to the celestial voices she had been hearing since she was twelve, Giguère was increasingly drawn into Marian spirituality and devotionalism. Although Giguere had been hearing certain “interior voices” since her teenage years, these mystical encounters increased significantly after 1957. The unveiling of her providential destiny, which was first announced to her in 1950, finally took place in 1958. While hearing voices and receiving messages from Jesus Christ and Mary, she started writing down her life story and started interpreting the mystical phenomena she was experiencing. The titles of her autobiographical volumes, such as Vie Purgative (Purgative Life), Victoire (Victory), and Vie Céleste (Heavenly Life), indicate the progressive transformations she experienced.

In her journalistic work for magazines and radio during the 1950’s, she used the pen name Marie-Josée. After 1958, she referred to herself as Marie-Paule (although also sometimes “Mère Paul-Marie”). She established a foundation for moral support to other organizations and to stimulate priestly vocations under the name Mère Paul-Marie.

After participating in a group visit to an existing small Marian shrine on the edge of Lake Etchemin in the evening on August 28, 1971, Marie-Paule received a revelation confirming the necessity of creating an Army of Mary (“Armée du Marie”). She started the new religious community with approximately seventy five like-minded devotees. This new Army of Mary group was meant to be an alternative to the existing Legion of Mary ( Legio Mariae ), the lay Marian world association founded in 1921 in which she had been involved previously. Against the backdrop of the 1960s counterculture and the Second Vatican Council, her new Army required for members to manifest “personal interior reform” toward the traditional devotional trinity: “The Triple White” (the Eucharist, Mary and the Pope) was to be performed in “an authentically Christian way of life” and also in “fidelity to Rome and the Pope.”

Through the appeal of her messages, her charismatic gifts and her vocal and singing capacities, she enthused her followers and established a successful traditionalist grass-roots Marian movement. The next year, in 1972, a Quebec priest, Philippe Roy, joined the movement and became its director.

It was due to the friendship (through their joint Militia of Jesus Christ membership) of Marie-Paule with an important Church official, the Dutch-Belgian Jean-Pierre van Lierde, sacrista/vicar general of the Vatican State and supporter of the Amsterdam apparitions, that Québecqois archbishop Maurice Roy was persuaded to acknowledge the movement in 1975 as a formal pious association of the Church. This move was the result of inattention and eagerness from his side towards religious initiatives in a time of decay of the Church. He neglected – whether or not intentiously – to conduct a proper investigation on the movement’s ideological stance. Presumably due to the fact that the texts with Marie-Paule’s views were not published before 1979, the movement remained under the radar and unknown to those who were responsible to check its compliance with the doctrines of the faith. It has been reported that Van Lierde stimulated both visionaries, Ida and Marie-Paule, to meet each other.

As a consequence of recognition by the Church, the now formalized movement peaked in the following years. In about ten years the movement, stimulated by their own proselytes and official status, the movement started to expand outside Quebec, finding some thousands of devotees (and not more than that) distributed over approximately twenty (Western) countries.

In 1977, due to another revelation to Marie-Paule, the Militia of Jesus Christ was introduced in Canada and connected to the Army of Mary. That year 200 soldiers of the Army also joined the Militia Christi. The Militia, a chivalric neo-order for stimulating Marian devotion and doing social work, was instituted in France in 1973 without approval of the Church. In 1981, Giguère’s Army of Mary movement modernized its name as the Family and the Community of the Sons and Daughters of Mary. Although this renaming seems less offensive, it connected the movement or “Family” provocatively and directly to its leader, Mary (her reincarnation), or Marie-Paule.

The growth of the movement since the 1970’s also quietly generated a strong flow of financial resources. The Quebec community was therefore taken by surprise when in 1983 major land acquisitions and investments took place in and around Lac-Etchemin in order to create a world center for the Army of Mary and its Militia. These expansions created for the sectarian group a closed, supportive, social and ideological habitat, one that was hostile to external world and authorities and one where not only the ideas grew and the mission started but also the religious practice took place. The group not only organized itself internally. It also created a semi-independent geographical zone, the international center, with monastery-like housing facilities, noviciate, retraites (Spiri-Maria-Alma and Spiri-Maria-Pietro), ateliers, guest houses, press office and radio station, in and around Lac-Etchemin, but mainly at the Route du Sanctuaire 626.

“ Misled” by the formal approbation of the Church, a part of the following did not fully realize the implications of the new teachings when they were published. But, from the early 1980s, people became increasingly worried after closely reading the first published volume of Marie-Paule’s Vie d’Amour. In addition, regional authorities and media were alarmed by the building activities of the Army at the edge of the lake, activities that strengthened the idea of an institutionalizing, self-supportive sectarian community. Nonetheless, it was only after a stream of newspaper articles expressing astonishment at what was actually professed in her scriptures that the bishop of Quebec realized his misjudgment and started to take action against the doctrinal deviations. It caused the new archbishop of Quebec to withdraw the approval of his predecessor. On May 4, 1987, he declared the movement schismatic and disqualified it as a Catholic association because of its false teachings. The Vatican judged their doctrine to be “heretical.” To be completely sure, the archbishop-to-be asked Cardinal Ratzinger to have Marie-Paule’s scriptures also screened by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. In a brief note of February 27, 1987, Ratzinger, too, concluded that the movement was in “major and very severe error.” The particular concern was the idea of the alleged existence of an Immaculate Marian Trinity, in which Mary is no longer just Mother of the Son of God, but the divine spouse of God. As a consequence, the theological exegesis of Marie-Paule’s writing by her “theologian,” Marc Bosquart, was likewise condemned. Hence, the Army was forbidden to organize any celebration or to propagate their devotion for the Lady of All Peoples. Priests from the Quebec diocese who got involved would be removed from their priestly functions, although the penalty of excommunication or condemnation was not yet called for.

Despite all measures, the movement did not seem to decline. On the contrary, its mission continued as members were convinced of the real truth that was revealed to them. In 2001, the media frequently reported that the movement consisted of 25,000 followers. In fact, the movement never reached that size; the movement itself estimated in 1995 that its membership was “several thousand” followers spread over fourteen countries. This included forty brothers/seminarians, forty three priests as The Sons of Mary (“Les Fils de Marie”), and 75 celibate women known as members of The Daughters of Mary (“Les Filles de Marie”). There were convents in Green Valley and Little Rock. Most of the following were located in Canada and the U.S., with a few hundred in the Western part of Europe. For example, in the Netherlands a group of approximately twenty devotees was and is active in a Nijmegen-based prayer group. After the interventions of the Church, many left the movement again, and a smaller group of dedicated followers remained.

2007 seems to have been a pivotal year for the movement. When the movement and its teachings were declared false in March, the group strongly reacted with a series of ceremonial feasts (May 31–June 3). During this period, their own new “pope,” Padre Jean-Pierre, promulgated the dogma of Mary/Lady as Coredemptrix, canonized the group’s first saint, Raoul-Marie, and ordained six priests. As a planned final blow to the movement, the Vatican excommunicated the whole movement in July. Since then, not much seems to have changed in community’s policy, although the various measures did winnow the following and, presumably, reduced its means for mission and propaganda. Following this period, the power of Marie-Paule appears to have declined while the influence of her theologians increased. The teachings became increasingly esoteric and the idea of an alternative Church of John (in place of the “degenerated” Church of Petrus) came into being (Martel 2010). After their excommunication, the core following has become more convinced on the demise of the Roman Church of Petrus and the false path the bishop walks by dancing to the tune of Rome and leaving out the major line within the prayer that was given by the Lady. That line (“the Lady who once was Mary”) demonstrated that Marie-Paule was indeed the incarnated, new Mary and Co-Redemptor.

A passing of bedridden Marie-Paule had been predicted for her birthday on September 14, 2013. The prophecy was based on an
“apocalyptic calculation” of verse 5-6 of the book of Revelation. Her passing was expected to take place 1260 days after the start of the Terrestrial Paradise on April 4, 2010. The day passed peacefully, however.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

The Community of the Lady of All Peoples regards itself a Catholic movement claiming “ Providential Work with Universal Dimensions.” With this phrasing and by positioning their “Church of St. John” in opposition to the apostolic Catholic tradition of the “Church of St. Peter,” they have distanced themselves from Rome. The group has been declared “non-Catholic” by the Vatican, as it is understood to be a schismatic movement with excommunicated leaders and “heretic” writings. Although it still spreads its theological material, which continues to assert its fidelity to Rome and the Pope, its actual practices are the opposite. The former Army/present-day Community is better understood as a visionary movement with Catholic roots that transformed into a millennial sectarian group with mixed Catholic-esoteric beliefs. They regard their deviating views as Catholic but with “extra” beliefs, for which the Roman Church, they explain, “is not yet ready.”

At the outset, the Army of Mary seemed to be more a new Catholic revival movement reacting to debated modernizations of the Church after the Second Vatican Council. As the role and position of the idiosyncratic visionary and leader Giguère became stronger, especially after her election as Superior-General in 1997, the movement showed more and more characteristics of a sectarian movement. The mystic prose was not focused on God, but became fully centered on Giguère as Mary and/or the Lady of All Peoples reincarnated in her. The Mother (Mary/Marie-Paule) is in their view equal to the Father and of the same nature as Jesus Christ, and so is represented in the Eucharist. Maria has become God for them. Given that position, the theology was not complementary to Christology or Mariology; it was replacement with a completely new doctrine. A growing distinction between adherents and non-adherents to her Vie d’Amour theology came to the surface, leaving less and less space for individual mysticism. New revelations to Marie-Paule, who had first-hand experiences with the divine, changed the movement into a cult of a revelatory kind, where the truth is revealed and individual seekers have to become strict adherents. However, the Army of Mary/Community is in fact not fully a closed cult. The Community has a particularized revealed truth that only partly rejects the paradigms of the Church. It elaborated on the public revelation of the Roman Catholic Church and on fundamental principles, but it started to deviate on some of the basic teachings and the course set out by the Vatican. The Army of Mary claims their teachings overrule verified truth, as mediated by Mary herself and adapted to the modern state of the world, despite their rejection and suppression by the ecclesiastical powers and institutions.

Although Giguère is the divine medium, she did not produce a full exegesis on all dimensions of her mystic experiences. Therefore, two “theologians” were appointed to systematize, elaborate and interpret her mystic writings into a more coherent theology and to elaborate her providential role within the universality of Christianity. This development enhanced the group’s sectarian character. Although the theology is Christian-based, it integrates millennial views, with Marie-Paule as savior (Mary/God), in combination with heretical theological, gnostic esoteric and cosmological teachings. The themes were documented in detail in the research of the movement’s teachings by the Canadian theologian Raymond Martel in 2010 . He described the theology of the Quebec movement as the making of a “Marian gnosis.” In this way the Quebec teachings also deviated from the apocalyptic and end-time interpretations of Hans Baum (1970) for whom the Amsterdam messages are anti-gnostic.

The basis of the theology, redemptive prophecies and eschatology, can be traced to two major sources. The first is Marie-Paule’s scriptures. These include a “revelation” consisting of a series of fifteen volumes titled Life of Love (Vie d’Amour), an auto-biographical and auto-hagiographical corpus of thousands of pages that deals with her life story and mystical experiences. Reading Theresia of Lisieux’s inspirational autobiography, The Story of a Soul (L’histoire d’une âme), and being active as a writer for journals, made Marie-Paule think of putting her life to paper. In 1958, her spiritual superior told her to commence. The text was said to be partly dictated by the Lord himself, not by means of voices or apparitions but by a communication, as she stated, “from spirit to spirit,” initially at the “level of the heart” and later at the level “of the head,” underlining in this way their concurrence. The books form the paradigm and the underpinning of her concept of the Lady of All Peoples and her role within the divine salvific plan. The works also ultimately position Giguère as the embodied appearance of the Lady of All Peoples.

The French Raoul Auclair (1906-1996), radio journalist and author of books on Nostradamus, apparitions, revelations and eschatology (nicknamed “The Poet of the End of the Times”) got notice of the Amsterdam apparitions. By 1966, he had already organized a successful conference on the Amsterdam Lady in Paris where he tried to connect the outcome of the Second Vatican Council on Mary to the Amsterdam messages. He stated that all issues that were brought up during and around the Council had to be interpreted as a confirmation of what was revealed in the Amsterdam messages. The text of the conference was published under the transparent title, La Dame de tous les peuples, and he became the single major international propagandist for the Amsterdam cultus. The French book found its way to Catholic Quebec and was given to Giguère by a friend. After rereading it several times, she recognized the resemblances in the messages she and Peerdeman received and became convinced of the structured connection of both mystic experiences. This idea ultimately brought Auclair and Giguère into contact with each other in 1971. Five years later he joined the Army. In those years, with the Church’s condemnation of the Amsterdam cultus and suppression of its local devotional practice, Marie-Paule’s interest in the Lady of All Nations became stronger. The universality of the Amsterdam messages matched her divine promptings and personal ambitions for a global Marian movement within the Marian era. As a result Marie-Paule wanted to meet visionary Peerdeman. In 1973, 1974 and 1977, she visited the Amsterdam shrine of the Lady of All Nations. Her last visit proved to constitute a new sequel to the Amsterdam apparitions and created an impulse for a shift of the core of cultus to Quebec. Marie-Paule claimed that during mass at the shrine in Amsterdam the visionary Peerdeman pointed at her (Giguère) while saying, “She is the Handmaiden.” This was taken as proof of what was proclaimed in the Lady’s fifty first message, in which Mary announced her return to earth: “I will return, but in public.” This moment was understood to be a recognition of The Lady of All Nations in the person of Giguère by the visionary Peerdeman. Through this maneuver, Marie-Paule retrospectively appropriated the prophesized public return of Mary on Earth ( Messages 1999: 151). Hence, Giguère claimed the devotion of the Lady in Lac-Etchemin to be the sole continuation of the Amsterdam cultus.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

In order to give public access to Our Lady of All Peoples in Lac-Etchemin, a church was built within the international Spiri-Marie Center complex. The complex is more a headquarters of an international movement than a dedicated shrine for the Lady of All Peoples or her reincarnation. In an adjacent building to the church, a big shop where books, images, DVD’s are stacked and show the missionary character of the center. Candles, rosaries and all kinds of other devotional material also can be bought for home use or in the Spiri-church. The morphology of the objects seems to be mainstream Catholic, although the symbolism is adapted to the Community’s teachings. Many of the devotional practices are to a large extent in line with those of the formal Catholic Church. The whole décor of the interior is directly inspired by the “original” Amsterdam shrine of the Lady and its imagery. However, a closer look at the décor also shows the symbolism and texts of the movement’s heretical doctrines. For example, one can pray with a combined image of Jesus and Mary that suggests that Mary is present in the eucharist. The central devotional practice is dedicated to the “Triple White” (the eucharist, the Immaculate Mary, and the Pope) through which the sanctification of one’s soul should be realized, inspire the world and the spread the evangelical message of love and peace in anticipation of the return of Christ. Within the cultus no public Marian apparition rituals are known; all messages and appearances seem to be privately received by Giguère.

In the Spiri-church, the devotion for the “Quinternity” is presented. The sacred number, 55 555, was introduced into the teachings as the basis for explaining the logic of the Marian Trinity, consisting of the Immaculate Mary, Marie-Paule, and the Holy Spirit. The devotion states that the combination of the Marian Trinity with the classic trinity (the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit) creates a total of five “elements,” as the Holy Spirit is regarded as the same for both Trinities. This ensemble is said to be one aswell, as the feminine (the immaculate) is also present in God. Their explanation states that the first coming of the Immaculate Mary is symbolized in the first number 5, and the second coming (Marie-Paule) is represented in double five’s. The double fives represents her actions with the “True Spirit,” namely the Holy Spirit of Mary, a work that started in the year 2000 and which will realize the number 555 when it is finished. This will occur when the new millennium has arrived. In the movement’s systematization, the numbers are supposed to connect the cultus to its origins and close the circle. It would place the formation of the cultus in line with what God reportedly prophesied to Giguère in 1958 about her crucifixion and reincarnation, and about the existence of a Marian trinity. The full number of 55 555 then (the Quinternity ) is the symbol of the actions of the Lady of All Peoples with the True (Marian) Holy Spirit. The figure is presented as a holy number that symbolizes future victory over evil (symbolized in the human number of the beast (666)) and the conditional coming of the new millennium (cf Baum 1970:49-63).

Apart from pilgrimages to the Spiri-Marie center, most of the devotional practices among the adherents take place in the various countries locally within prayer groups. These groups usually meet in informally constructed chapels in houses or garages, as the movement is not allowed to make use of Catholic church buildings. The clean and smooth Spiri-Maria buildings show few decorations and symbolism and do not have burning candles or offerings. An adapted (including a Holy Spirit) painting of the Lady of All Peoples is positioned next to the altar. A sign explains for the visitors the “quinternity.”

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

New branches have been added to the original Army of Mary since 1980. The present overall Community of the Lady of All Peoples consists of five “works” or branches:

● The Army of Mary (l’Armée de Marie ), established in 1971.
● The Family of Sons and Daughters of Mary (La Famille des Fils et Filles de Marie), established in the early 1980s.
● The Community of Sons and Daughters of Mary (la Communauté des Fils et Filles de Marie) established in 1981. This organization is a religious, pastoral order of priests and sisters, with Marie-Paule as Superior-General since 1997.
● Les Oblats-Patriotes, established in 1986 (August 15). The goal of this organization is renewal of society.
● The Marialys Institute, established in 1992. This organization serves priests who are not part of the Community but share the doctrines.

Those outside of the movement, the media and the Roman Catholic Church, usually still depict the overall movement in a reductionist way as the Army of Mary.

From the beginning, Marie-Paule Giguère has been the central figure. There is considerable information about her past due to her writings. There is less information about her later life as her movement came under pressure, she appeared less often in public, and the group became a more closed sect. Most of the contact with the outside world took place through her assistant, the Belgian sister Chantal Buyse, who also takes care of her hospitalization.

When in 1978 Raoul Auclair moved to Quebec and became the editor of L’Etoile (The Star), the then journal of the movement (since 1982 Le Royaume ), his role as intellectual within the Community started to rise. Ultimately he became the central theologian and interpreter of the movement, for which he was canonized by the Community after his death.

Since 2007, Father Jean-Pierre Mastropietro, wearing a Byzantine crown, has been “acting like a pope” according to the CatholicChurch. Father Jean-Pierre is the head of the Church of John, the Church of Love, which is described by the movement as a “transmutation” of the Roman Church of Peter.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

As of 2007, the Army of Mary was excommunicated, and the movement has been placed outside the Catholic Church and will not be allowed to return. The question is whether the Roman Catholic Church will fully ignore the movement or will continue to actively oppose it as the Community seems to still be able to contact and attract the “ignorant.” Presumably the Church will take a practical stance and will wait for the death of the visionary who reached the age of 92 in 2013, is half paralyzed, has mentally deteriorated, and lives in “great agony.” It is likely that after the death of the visionary, their leader and reincarnated Mary, the movement will fall into a crisis. However, followers state that then her Church will be taken over by others within the movement.

A second issue is the relation with the Amsterdam-based shrine of the Lady of All Nations, the inspirational apparitional source for Giguère. It had become a formally acknowledged apparitional site through the recognition by Bishop Jozef Punt of Haarlem-Amsterdam in 2002. Both sites and devotions became in competition with one another, while the organization in Amsterdam started, given its official recognition, to distance itself more strongly than ever from Giguère and her movement. Within the movement the number of references to its roots, the Amsterdam visions of Ida Peerdeman of the Lady of All Nations (instead of Peoples) has been reduced to a functional minimum and is usually limited to texts of the messages and the transfer of the status of being chosen from Ida to Marie-Paule. Since, on December 30, 2020 the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith in Rome, has also rejected the supernaturality claim by the Amsterdam bishop Jozef Punt. Nevertheless some of Marie-Paule’s following does not reject Amsterdam and its messages, as this is perceived as the basis for Marie-Paule’s church. The Community’s name and its logo are, however, still based on the Amsterdam apparitions. The Spiri-Maria center in Lac-Etchemin still functions as the religious heart of the Giguère-movement. Since the death of its leader in 2015, it has been reduced to the small, tightly organized religious community in Lac Etchemin (with approximately 100 members?) that has retained its infrastructure, but which attracts few devotees from the rest of the world.

REFERENCES

Au Sujet de l’Armée de Marie. 2000. Revue Pastorale Quebec 112, no. 8 (June 26).

Auclair, Raoul. 1993. La fin des temps . Quebec: Ed. Stella.

Baum, Hans. 1970. Die apokalyptische Frau aller Völker. Kommentare zu den Amsterdamer Erscheinungen en Prophezeiungen . Stein am Rhein: Christiana-Verlag.

Bosquart, Marc . 2003. Marie-Paule and Co-Redemption . Lac-Etchemin: Ed. du Nouveau Monde.

Bosquart, Marc . 2003. The Immaculate, the Divine Spouse of God . Lac-Etchemin: Ed. du Nouveau Monde.

Bosquart, Marc. 2002. New Earth New Man . Lac-Etchemin: Ed. du Nouveau Monde.

Communauté de la Dame de Tous Les Peuples. n.d. Accessed from http://www.communaute-dame.qc.ca/oeuvres/OE_cinq-oeuvres_FR.htm on 17 May 2013.

De Millo, Andrew. 2007. “Six Catholic Nuns In Arkansas Excommunicated For Heresy.” The Morning News , September 26, 2007.

“Note Doctrinale des Évêques Catholiques du Canada sur l’Armée de Marie.” n.d. Accessed from www.cccb.ca/site/Files/NoteArDeMarie.html on 17 May 2013.

“Declaration of the bishop of Haarlem-Amsterdam on the Amsterdam and Quebec Devotions.” 2007. Accessed from http://www.de-vrouwe.info/en/notice-regarding-the-qarmy-of-maryq-2007 on 20 May 2013.

“Declaration of the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith. 2007 ( July 11). Accessed from www.cccb.ca/site/images/stories/pdf/decl_excomm_english.pdf on 17 May 2013.

Geoffroy, Martin and Jean-Guy Vaillencourt. 2001. ‘Les groupes catholiques intégristes. Un danger pour les institutions sociales?’ Pp. 127-41 i n La peur des sects , edited by Jean Duhaime and Guy-Robert St-Arnaud. Montréal: Editions Fides.

Kruk, Ester. 2003. Zoals sneeuwvlokken over de wereld dwarrelen. De hedendaagse devotie rond Maria, de Vrouwe van Alle Volkeren. Amsterdam: Aksant.

Laurentin, René and Patrick Sbalchiero eds. 2007. Pp. 1275-76 in Dictionnaire des “apparitions“ de la Vierge Marie. Inventaire des origines à nos jours. Méthodologie, bilan interdisciplinaire, prospective . Paris: Fayard.

Marie-Paule [Giguère]. 1979-1987. Vie D’Amour , 15 vols. Lac-Etchemin: Vie D’Amour Inc.

Margry, Peter Jan. 2012. “Mary’s Reincarnation and the Banality of Salvation: The Millennialist Cultus of the Lady of All Nations/Peoples.” Numen: International Review for the History of Religions 59:486-508.

Margry, Peter Jan . 2009a. “Paradoxes of Marian Apparitional Contestation: Networks, Ideology, Gender, and The Lady of All Nations.” Pp. 182-99 in Moved by Mary: The Power of Pilgrimage in the Modern World , edited by Anna-Karina Hermkens, Willy Jansen, and Catrien Notermans. Aldershot: Ashgate.

Margry, Peter Jan . 2009b. “Marian Interventions in the Wars of Ideology: The Elastic Politics of the Roman Catholic Church on Modern Apparitions.” History and Anthropology 20:245-65.

Margry, Peter Jan. 1997. “Amsterdam, Vrouwe van Alle Volkeren.” Pp. 161-70 i n Bedevaartplaatsen in Nederland , volume 1, edited by Peter Jan Margry and Charles Caspers. Hilversum: Verloren.

Martel, Raymond. 2010. La face cachée de l’Armée de Marie . Anjou, Quebec: Fides.

Matter, Ellen A. 2001. “Apparitions of the Virgin Mary in the Late Twentieth Century: Apocalyptic, Representation, Politics.” Religion 31:125-53.

Messages of the Lady of All Nations, The New Edition . 1999. Amsterdam: The Lady of All Nations Foundation.

Paul-Marie, Mère. 1985. Lac-Etchemin. La Famille des Fils et Filles de Marie . Limoilou: Vie D’Amour.

Poulin, Andree, ‘Achats énigmatiques des terrains’, in La Voix de Ste-Germaine , 31 January 1984.

Robinson, Bruce. n.d. “Roman Catholicism. The Army of Mary: An Excommunicated Roman Catholic Group.” Accessed from http://www.religioustolerance.org/army_mary.htm on 9 June 2013.

Le Royaume. Périodique bimestriel christique, marial et oecuménique, organe de formation spirituelle et d’information de la Communauté de la Dame de Tous les Peuples . Accessed from http://www.communaute-dame.qc.ca/actualites-royaume/fr/archives.html.

Post Date:
28 October 2013

 

Share

Art of Living Foundation

ART OF LIVING FOUNDATION TIMELINE

1956 (May 13):  Ravi Shankar was born in Papanasam, Tamil Nadu, India.

1975:  Ravi Shankar gained a Bachelor of Science degree from Bangalore University.

1982:  Ravi Shankar discovered Sudarshan Kriya (the movement’s cornerstone breathing practice) during a silent retreat in Shimoga, Karnataka, India. He formulated the first Art of Living course, and founded The Art of Living Foundation in Bangalore, India.

1983:  Ravi Shankar held the first Art of Living course in Switzerland.

1986:  Ravi Shankar held the first Art of Living course in North America.

1993:  Ravi Shankar was excommunicated from Transcendental Meditation

1997:  Ravi Shankar established the International Association for Human Values (IAHV) In Geneva, Switzerland.

2006:  Art of Living’s twenty-fifth anniversary celebration was held at the Bangalore ashram, and attended by 2,500,000 million people

2012:  The campaign Volunteers for a Better India (VFABI) was launched, encouraging citizens to partake in nation-building efforts.

2013:  NONVIO campaign was launched by Shankar’s movement, to promote acts of non-violence through social media, and implementing non-violent principles in governance, health care and mass media.

2016:  A three-day World Culture Festival was held at the banks of the Indian river Yamuna, attracting visitors from 155 countries, among them 35.000 musicians.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

AoL’s guru/ leader/ founder Ravi Shankar (often referred to using the double honorifics Sri Sri, and his devotees often call him Guruji or Gurudev) was born on May 13, 1956, in Papanasam, Tamil Nadu, South India to parents Vishalakshi and Venkat Ratnam. The family moved to Jayanagar in Bangalore when Shankar was a small child. In India, Ravi is a fairly common name meaning “sun.” The name Shankar, however, is derived from the Hindu saint Adi Shankara, with whom Ravi Shankar shares a birthday.

The hagiographic accounts of Shankar’s childhood describe him in terms of the guru he would become, and in that sense, according to Stephen Jacobs (2015), they follow a very predictable storyline. These devotee accounts suggest that spiritual interests were evident in Ravi Shankar’s life from an early age. A well-known legend among devotees is that as an infant Shankar’s traditional Indian hanging cradle, supported by metal chains, fell to the ground. Instead of crushing Shankar in the cradle, the chains fell outward as if by a miracle of physics. The four year-old Shankar is said to have recited passages from the Bhagavad Gita, one of the holy texts of Hinduism. Likewise stories are frequently told about his young-age rebellion against the practice of untouchability and other forms of injustice, and his unwavering devotion to religious practice through daily pujas and Sanskrit studies. According to the hagiographies, Shankar was a studious and intelligent child. He preferred to write and study more than play, and he is said to have written poems and plays at an early age. Science was also an interest for the young Ravi Shankar; he graduated from St. Joseph’s College in Bangalore with a Bachelor’s degree in physics. However, for Shankar, [Image at right] this scientific interests and an ordinary life as a bank employee were not enough; he also became a scholar in Sanskrit literature, and ultimately chose to follow a spiritual path.

Art of Living literature tends to emphasize the favorable time of Shankar’s birth, his name, and his Brahmin heritage, thus orchestrating a hagiography to put him “under favorable skies in the eyes of Hindu believers. Furthermore, like many hagiographies, [the biography] puts emphasis on the predispositions and rare capacities shown by Sri Sri Ravi Shankar during his childhood” (Avdeeff 2004:2). The idea that Ravi Shankar was on a path to sainthood since he was a child, the “known fact” that he has attained enlightenment, and the numerous other stories that build up under his holiness, are all important within the organization. Alexis Avdeeff estimates that the majority of devotees believes in Shankar’s enlightenment, and believes that he became enlightened during a period of a ten-day silence in which he claims to have received the technique of Sudarshan Kriya, the cornerstone breathing technique taught in AoL. Ravi Shankar himself neither confirms nor denies the “rumors” of his enlightenment and divine inspiration. He rather maintains an ambiguous stance on the subject, through mystical utterances like “Many can cross with the help of the One who has crossed” (Avdeeff 2004:3). Shankar himself seems to extend this ambiguity and mysticism to his own biography. He favors the current moment and who he is right now, emphasizing how he has kept true to the child he once was, and, in good Peter Pan style, that he has never really grown up.

Ravi Shankar was introduced to Maharishi Mahesh Yogi and his Transcendental Meditation movement at a meeting in Bangalore when he was a young man (Gautier 2008). Shankar followed the Maharishi to his ashram in Rishikesh, spent some time there, and gradually gained the trust of the TM guru/ leader/founder. After “learning the ropes,” Shankar was gradually given more responsibility within the organization. “Although Sri Sri was very young, Maharishi recognized his abilities and put him to work. He was thus sent to various places to give talks on the Vedas and science” (Gautier 2008: 36). Ravi Shankar was also sent to various countries in Europe to continue his teaching and to set up centers for learning. He furthered his organizational talent through event management within Transcendental Meditation. Gautier states that even though very little is known about the time Shankar spent in the TM organization, he believes this to have been a formative period for Shankar as a young man. Through his stint in TM, Shankar seems to have learnt the necessary skills to start his own spiritual venture, which he named The Art of Living Foundation (Humes 2009: 295-96). It is also more than likely that Ravi Shankar based the name of his movement on one of Maharishi’s best-known publications, The Science of Being and the Art of Living (1963).

Throughout the years, both Shankar’s parents became deeply involved in Shankar’s trust, in the Ved Vignan Maha Vidya Peeth (VVMVP), and in running the Art of Living Ashram in Bangalore, India. Pitaji is one of his son’s most ardent followers, and the enormous meditation hall in the Bangalore ashram is named Vishalakshi Mantap for Shankar’s mother. Ravi Shankar’s father seems, among the family and personal friends, to be the most vocal about his son’s spiritual maturity, asserting that “He is both my son and my master.”

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Art of Living can be understood as a world-affirming religion, which, according to Eileen Barke, “embrace the world’s secular values and goals while using unconventional means to achieve these” (1998: 21). Through its many humanitarian initiatives, such as rural education and health initiatives, the NGO parts of the organization work hard to make the world a better place. The importance of humanitarian values within the AoL organization align with many other Asian NRMs, which often focus on socially engaged spirituality (Clarke 2006; Warrier 2005). This reinforces positive public relations, and reinforces the organization’s world-affirming ideas.

Personal and spiritual development goes hand in hand with social and humanitarian work in AoL. However, the Art of Living Foundation is primarily a religious/ spiritual organization, and aligns itself with a modern Hindu framework. The guru regularly performs Hindu rituals (pujas), and many Hindu religious festivals are celebrated in Art of Living’s Bangalore ashram. Gautier (2009) and Humes (2009) note that Ravi Shankar grew up in the Hindu faith, and that Shankar himself takes a devotional stance toward the supernatural. The Hindu practice of bhakti (devotion) is important in Shankar’s teachings of Divine Love. Ideally, love is ego-less, and this selfless love should be given to one’s fellow people, to the guru and to God.

Cynthia Humes notes that guru worship is important in AoL:

Shankar […] allows others to fawn over him as Hindus characteristically do to their masters – thereby locating his teachings within a Hindu mode of legitimacy, making him a popular choice in guru for Indians. Expressions of love and attachment to the guru is common in weekly Satsangs, “gatherings of holy people,” devoted to Sri Sri […] (2009: 384).

Fred Clothey (2006) states that in India a tradition of religious seeking and guru worship can be traced back to the times of the Upanishads (a collection of texts that contain some of the central philosophical concepts of Hinduism, written in Sanskrit ca. 800-200 BCE). This tradition is common even today. In the Bangalore ashram, when Ravi Shankar attends, there are large gatherings where the devotees meet the guru. These are interchangeably called darshan (where one sees and is seen by the guru), or satsang. Steven Jacobs (2015) translates satsang as “good company,” a time where devotees can spend time with their beloved Sri Sri. These events are immensely popular, and the large prayer/meditation hall is filled to the brim every night. Devotion to the guru is highly emotional, and is expressed through bhajans (devotional songs), as well as individual songs, poetry recital, and testimonials in open-mike sessions. Devotion to the guru is also expressed in the innumerable acts of seva (selfless service/ divine work) performed every day at ashrams, centers, and humanitarian projects around the world, by devotees and volunteers.

Teaching traditional knowledge and “ancient Indian wisdom” is an important part of AoL activity. This knowledge is a hybrid of traditional Hindu wisdom (for example through commentaries on Hindu philosophical texts) self-help rhetoric, and plain common sense. Milda Ališauskienė (2009) notes that

In this teaching, which takes the form of daily messages to followers that are later published, Shankar quotes various Hindu-origin concepts and Hindu writings such as the Bhagavad Gita and Ashtavakra Gita, which raises questions about the origin of his ideas. For example, in his messages about the laws of the nature he explains:

“There are three powers in nature: Brahma shakti, Vishnu shakti and Shiva shakti. Usually one of these powers dominates. Brahma shakti is a power that creates something new. Vishnu shakti is the power that sustains existence while Shiva shakti is the power that transforms, gives the life or destroys. (Šankaras 2001: 208)”

But at the same time, in his messages to his followers Ravi Shankar also uses concepts and metaphors from Christianity, thus making his teaching more accessible to a Western audience. (Ališauskienė 2009: 343)

One of the most important “learning strategies” in AoL is the guru’s daily messages to his followers, which are published online, and collected in books. These are called Wisdom Quotes, and in them Shankar states things like “Finding security in inner space is spirituality.”

Ravi Shankar finds legitimacy in historical religious traditions such as Hinduism, and to some extent Christianity. However, the guru himself is the main source of power and wisdom in AoL. Shankar is a charismatic guru, and devotees experience his person, his teachings and the movement’s practices as true and authentic. Also, by learning the practices and learning how to be a guru devotee, participation in AoL often entails some form of personal transformation. The idea is that people become happier, healthier, and better through associating with the organization, and in AoL personal transformation is closely related to notions of learning, healing, and religious experience. These ideas are not only important in Hinduism, but also in the modern, global spiritual culture, of which Art of Living is a part. Guru worship and philosophy is important in AoL, but courses (in breathing practices, yoga, and meditation), that is, practical learning, is how participants are taught and socialized.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

Art of Living beliefs, rituals, and practices are primarily drawn from a Hindu-inspired worldview, and so yoga, meditation, and pranayama (breathing techniques) are the core practices in the movement. The courses and techniques taught by the organization are more or less the same everywhere, and all teachers receive similar training. Usually two teachers, one male and one female, teach each course on offer.

Art of Living has much in common with its parental organization Transcendental Meditation. In addition to being guru-centric movements, “[…] both teach techniques which help to reduce stress, both have Hindu origins and both claim they are not religious but NGOs” (Ališauskienė 2009:3-4).

Both organizations teach a simple mantra -style form of meditation. [Image at right] The form of meditation taught in TM is based on mantras from Indian tantric traditions (Lowe 2011). A certified teacher gives the mantra to the meditator, and the TM style of meditation is said to be natural, modest and uncomplicated. The meditation technique taught in AoL is quite similar: Sahaj Samadhi Meditation (or Art of Meditation) is what the organization calls a “graceful, natural and effortless” meditation technique.

Both TM and AoL teach a set of simplified hatha yoga postures. Yoga is an important part of AoL teachings, but in relatively “mild” forms that are suitable for everyone. Yoga is taught in both introductory courses and in special yoga courses, is said to warm up and relax the body, and make it ready to learn and practice the movement’s cornerstone practice, the Sudarshan Kriya breathing technique. The most common yoga practices in AoL are Surya Namaskara (sun salutations) and a few other asanas (yoga postures) that are said to offer physical, mental and spiritual benefits. In addition, AoL has introduced their own playful take on yoga, called “village yoga.” This short program mimics the everyday work done by women in Indian villages, such as “sweeping with a broomstick,” “grinding wheat on a stone flourmill,” “washing clothes with hands” and “pulling a bucket of water from the well.” The rationale behind the village yoga is, most of all, physical benefit. Physical labor is strenuous and will exercise the body, even if it is done only as yoga exercises. However, village yoga can also be interpreted as a way of bestowing worth to the work that is done in Indian villages on an everyday basis. Perhaps it is also a critique of an urban lifestyle seen as unnatural compared to the “romantic simplicity” of village life. These techniques are taught to (mainly) urban, middle-class participants, with the explanation that “people in the village naturally perform yoga postures as part of their daily work [which] stretches their arms and waist as they breathe accordingly in rhythm. In the village people lead a far more healthy and happy life.”

The cornerstone of Art of Living practices is the breathing technique called Sudarshan Kriya (SKY), which loosely translated means “healing breath.” Shankar himself says that “During a period of silence, the Sudarshan Kriya came like an inspiration. Nature knows what to give and when to give. After I came out of the silence, I started teaching whatever I knew and people had great experiences.” Teaching the Sudarshan Kriya was the very reason Shankar founded the Art of Living Foundation, and to this day, the technique is taught in every Art of Living beginner’s course.

The world-affirming quality of AoL is found also in its techniques. “Salvation” is not found after death, but in this life. The “[…] ultimate aim [of SKY] is to change the world and people, to make people happier and enable them to live without stress […]. The elimination of stress is associated with a greater quality of life in society as it currently exists, but ultimately it also brings people to a qualitatively different existence.” (Ališauskienė 2009:343).

According to Ravi Shankar, the rhythm of breath is very specific. It corresponds to one’s emotions and body, and to the rhythms of earth and nature. For various reasons, these rhythms are often out of tune with each other, and it is the mission of Sudarshan Kriya to bring them back into harmony. The technique itself is a cycle of rhythmical breath, where the practitioner sits on his/ her knees, in the yoga position known as vajrasana. The body is relaxed, and the practitioner breathes through the nose. After the Kriya , the practitioner relaxes, and ideally enters a state of meditation where the mind and body is aware but deeply rested. The technique is taught in two varieties. The long Kriya is guided, often by a tape with Ravi Shankar’s recorded instructions, and is meant to be practiced once a week in a group setting. There is also the short, “everyday” Kriya, which ideally should be practiced every day. By controlling the rhythms of breath, the Art of Living teachings say that people can also control their emotions, their bodies and their minds. The organization provides an example: when one is sad, the breathing comes in a long and deep fashion. Likewise, when one is angry, the breath becomes short and quick. Because the breath corresponds to emotions, the organization teaches that one can use the breath to change emotions too. “It ( Sudarshan Kriya ) flushes our anger, anxiety and worry; leaving the mind completely relaxed and energized.”

One of the main characteristics of the many educational courses offered by the Art of Living Foundation is the aim to provide participants with a set of techniques, skills and knowledge through which they can achieve a better quality of life. Stephen Jacobs (2015) sees the AoL techniques as consistent with what he calls the “therapeutic turn,” concerned with individual health and well-being. Practitioners are taught ways of coping with mental and physical stress, and how to react to the stressful situations that arise around different tasks and demands in daily life. The techniques, which consist of breathing techniques, meditation and yoga exercises promise to improve health and well-being.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

In the years since Ravi Shankar founded Art of Living, it has grown into a vast global religious/spiritual organization, with ashram headquarters in Bangalore, India [Image at right] and Bad Antogast, Germany. Creating a new religion can be a smart business strategy, and, in many ways, AoL functions like any multi-national company. The organization has centers and groups all over the world. Its participants are also customers, who pay for courses, retreats, and brand associated products (like books, DVDs, or Ayurvedic health supplements). AoL brand management is rather successful, which is reflected in the organization’s significant online and social media presence. Business-wise, it makes sense for a movement like AoL to use different “elements of successful branding [which] include fashioning visually striking material artifacts, instituting communally celebrated festivities, creating easily identifiable symbols that designate affiliation, and using iconography and public discourse in order to elevate the […] leader to near-mythic status” (Hammer 2009: 197). The guru can now travel comfortably around the world enjoying the fruits of his labor as a religious entrepreneur (Bainbridge and Stark 1985). While AoL does not attack competing movements, as many devotees have or have had connections to other gurus and movements, Shankar has been known to criticize other religious or secular leaders when the opportunity arises (Tøllefsen 2012).

As a guru organization, Art of Living is centralized and quite bureaucratic (Finke and Scheitle 2009) Local centers or groups have some autonomy, but the central organization provides worship- and course materials, a brand name and a common “history” to the local AoL branches. Local centers and groups throughout the world do provide some resource feedback to the central organization, but the power balance is clearly in favor of the head offices. This organizational structure also means that the movement is less likely to experience schism.

The leadership of the AoL organization is inextricably linked with the biography of the guru/ leader/ founder, who holds authority on many levels in the organization. One way of understanding Ravi Shankar is not only as a guru but also as a highly accomplished businessperson who has created a religious movement that in many ways is comparable to any multi-national company.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Like most New Religious Movements, AoL has faced some issues, challenges and controversies in its time. Among the most important are the break between Art of Living and Transcendental Meditation, at mass media and public relations, and politics.

An early issue was the public schism between AoL and Transcendental Meditation. In the early 1990s, Maharishi Mahesh Yogi excommunicated several young, charismatic, and high-ranking members of TM. Ravi Shankar and his ‘colleagues, Deepak Chopra and Robin Carlsen, had learnt how to run a spiritual organization from their guru, and had started their own competing spiritual ventures (Tøllefsen 2014; Humes 2009). From the time that Ravi Shankar founded the Art of Living in 1982, AoL and Transcendental Meditation co-existed and catered to a similar audience. Ravi Shankar was a teacher in TM, and considered Maharishi Mahesh Yogi his guru. Humes (2009) notes that Ravi Shankar recommended devotees in the U.S. continue their involvement with Maharishi’s organization, and he encouraged them to use the Sudarshan Kriya technique as complimentary to their TM meditation. Maharishi even supported Shankar’s teachings, as “TM practitioners were initially allowed to take his [Ravi Shankar’s] techniques and attend his courses” (Humes 2009:296). Ravi Shankar continued to work within the TM movement while setting up his own ashram in Bangalore and conducting his own courses on his newfound breathing technique. However, the conflict between the two guru-led movements peaked in the early 1990s, as TM began to adopt a hostile attitude toward Shankar’s organization. “[N]o overt action was taken by the TM movement hierarchy in the United States against Shankar’s programs until 1993” (Humes 2009:296). At this point, the devotees who practiced Sudarshan Kriya along with TM started facing sanctions, and when AoL workshops started to outrank TM in popularity in the U.S., “[b]rand loyalty to Maharishi was insisted upon” (Humes 2009: 302). Maharishi now faced the very real risk that devotees would leave his movement and spend money on the more affordable programs run by Ravi Shankar and Deepak Chopra (another ex-TM devotee and “rival Indian leader” who became a religious entrepreneur in his own right). Shankar and Chopra became obvious threats to the TM organization, and their excommunications represented an organizational defense based on competition for adherents and the need for maintaining organizational uniqueness.

Deepak Chopra was literally thrown out of the TM organization. However, the break between Maharishi and Ravi Shankar was less unexpected and less dramatic. Ravi Shankar seems to have kept his respect for his old teacher. Humes (2009) notes that:

The strong emphasis on guru veneration in the Hindu tradition has ensured that Shankar never openly criticizes or speaks out against his master Maharishi. But the affection seems to have been mutual: only when the Art of Living workshops threatened to become more popular than standard TM fare did Maharishi take action against Sri Sri in North America.

A contested point for New Religious Movements is often public relations, both in relation to mass media and to mainstream society. However, AoL is not a very controversial movement. Its philosophy and practices are quite “soft,” and geared towards the urban, middle-class. Although Art of Living is not mentioned very often in online or printed news, many of the headlines are quite positive. The most comprehensive source for positive AoL PR is actually the organization’s own webpages, where their press report archives go back a few years. The headlines build up under Ravi Shankar’s image as an ambassador for peace: “Global Humanitarian and Spiritual Leader Sri Sri Ravi Shankar Embarks on a Peace Mission to Pakistan” and “Karnataka lawyers boycott courts; spiritual guru Sri Sri offers to mediate.” AoL press coverage does not generally report that the organization is in conflict with the wider society. Rather, news reports have until recently covered AoL and Shankar entering areas of conflict in society (both nationally and internationally) in an attempt to spread a message of peace, and facilitate public discourse and communication. In more recent years, however, the public image of AoL has changed, and less positive reports have been published. The organization has faced criticism from bloggers and the conventional press both.

The advent of the Internet has yielded mixed results for AoL and groups like it. On the one hand, the public can easily find information on AoL and easily communicate with it and its devotees. An online media also allows organizations to exert control over their (self) presentation. This is very important for an organization like AoL, which aims to create a global spiritual and humanitarian community (Jacobs 2015). However, AoL also faces the problem of critique on the internet. In AoL’s case, the bulk of critique has come from online blogs run by disgruntled ex-devotees. The blogs accuse AoL of cultism (in the negative sense), and brainwashing. In 2010, AoL sued two of the most influential bloggers (“Klim” and “Skywalker”) for publicizing trade secrets, defamation, trade libel and copyright infringement. Only the trade secret issue could have been used in a trial. However, formal litigation was avoided, and in 2012 AoL and the bloggers reached a settlement through which AoL dropped the lawsuit, paid the bloggers’ lawyer fees, and agreed to initiate legal action against the bloggers again. The bloggers were allowed to remain anonymous, froze their existing blogs, but were not restricted from starting new blogs on the same theme.

The lawsuit against the bloggers was not a major issue in the “conventional” press. However, Art of Living Foundation has been criticized for other issues, such as land encroachment on a tank area in Mysore, Karnataka. The local authorities allegedly wished to fine the organization and dismantle the meditation center at the locale. However, Ravi Shankar’s political connections seem to have helped to prevent that outcome. A news report from Oneindia (2011) states that “Though a timely intervention by the then Chief Minister of the state, BS Yeddyurappa reportedly had saved Sri Sri and his Art of Living foundation from facing any legal trouble.”

More recently, AoL has been heavily criticized by environmentalists and concerned citizens regarding the environmental damage done to the Yamuna floodplain during the organizations’ World Culture Festival in March 2016. [Image at right] The Huffington Post reported extensive damage to water bodies and vegetation at the 1,000-acre festival venue, and a National Green Tribunal committee suggested a fine of 120 crore rupees (about $28,000,000). The fine was subsequently reduced to 50,000,000 rupees (a little over $750,000). A news report in The Diplomat reports “Sri Sri declaring defiantly ‘We’ll go to jail but not pay the fine. We have done nothing wrong’. The matter was ultimately settled after much hullabaloo with AOL coughing up a tiny fraction of the imposed fine.” The World Culture Festival and AoL’s political connections can, however, open the door to further analyses of the organization in a Hindutva context.

Hindutva (Hindu-ness) is a form of contemporary religious [right-wing] nationalism, where India is touted as the Hindu motherland, and where other religions (particularly Islam, but also Christianity) are referred to as foreign, and therefore, unwanted. Hindutva politics define Indian culture through a particular set of ”Hindu” values, and is strongly anti-secular. Hindutva politics has been adopted as the core ideology of the ruling right-wing nationalist party Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), the party to which India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi belongs. The prime minister was a guest of honor at Art of Living’s World Culture Festival, and his party offered military services during festival preparations. Although Ravi Shankar is careful about how his political leanings come across to the public (often opting for PR on peace and religious dialogue), his organization seems to, as noted above, directly benefit from his right-wing political connections.

Ravi Shankar’s nationalist politics are in some contexts highly visible. For example, regarding the Ayodhya dispute over the Ram temple/Babri Masjid, Meera Nanda (2011) notes that Sri Sri

hides a Hindu nationalist passion behind the carefully cultivated image of playfulness, love, and joy. He has repeatedly displayed his Hindutva colours on matters of the Ram mandir and minorities. The British magazine The Economist described his politics quite accurately: ‘Art of Living is open to people of all faiths. But, in fact, discussing the Ram temple, its guru starts to sound less like a spiritual leader and more like a politician, talking about the long history of “appeasement of the minority community”’ […] (2011:100).

IMAGES

Image #1: Photograph of Sri Sri Ravi Shankar, founder of the Art of Living Foundation.

Image #2: Image of an Art of Living Foundation devotee in a meditation position.

Image #3: Photograph of the central Art of Foundation ashram in Bangalore, India.

Image #4: Photograph of land in the Yamuna floodplain where the Art of Living Foundation’s World Culture Festival caused environmental damage in 2016.

REFERENCES

Ališauskienė, Milda. 2009. “Spirituality and Religiosity in the Art of Living Foundation in Lithuania and Denmark: Meanings, Contexts and Relationships.” Pp. 339-64 in Subcultures and New Religious Movements in Russia and East-Central Europe, edited by George M cKay and Christopher Williams. Oxford: Peter Lang.

Avdeeff, Alexis. 2004. “Sri Sri Ravi Shankar and the Art of Spreading Awareness over the World.” Journal of Dharma XXIX:321-35.

Bainbridge, William Sims and Stark, Rodney.1985. “Cult Formation: Three Compatible Models.” Pp. 171-88 in The Future of Religion . Berkeley: University of California Press.

Barker, Eileen. 1998. “New Religions and New Religiosity.” Pp. 10-27 in New Religions and New Religiosity, edited by Eileen Barker and Margit Warburg. RENNER Studies on New Religions. Aarhus: Aarhus University Press.

Clarke, Peter. 2006. Encyclopedia of New Religious Movements. London and New York: Routledge.

Clothey, Fred W. 2006. Religion in India, A Historical Introduction. London and New York: Routledge.

Finkle, Roger and Christopher P. Scheitle. 2009. “Understanding Schisms: Theoretical Explanations for their Origins.” Pp. 11-34 in Sacred Schisms, How Religions Divide, edited by James Lewis and Sarah Lewis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Gautier, François. 2008. The Guru of Joy: Sri Sri Ravi Shankar and the Art of Living. Carlsbad, CA: Hay House.

Hammer, Olav. 2009. “Schism and Consolidation: the Case of the Theosophical Movement.” Pp. 196-217 in Sacred Schisms, How Religions Divide, edited by James Lewis and Sarah Lewis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Humes, Cynthia Ann. 2009. “Schisms within Hindu Guru Groups: the Transcendental Meditation Movement in North America.” Pp. 372-96, in Sacred Schisms, How Religions Divide, edited by James Lewis and Sarah Lewis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Jacobs, Stephen. 2015. The Art of Living Foundation: Spirituality and Wellbeing in the Global Context. Ashgate New Religions series. Oxford and New York: Routledge

Nanda, Meera. 2011. The God Market. How Globalization Is Making India More Hindu. New York: Monthly Review Press.

Tøllefsen, Inga Bårdsen. 2014.  “Transcendental Meditation, the Art of Living Foundation, and Public Relations: From Psychedelic Romanticism to Science and Schism.” Pp. 145-59 in Controversial New Religions, edited by James Lewis and Jesper Petersen. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Tøllefsen, Inga Bårdsen. 2012.  “Notes on the Demographical Profiles of Art of Living Practitioners in Norway and Abroad.” Alternative Spirituality and Religion Review 3:74-101.

Warrier, Maya. 2005. Hindu Selves in a Modern World: Guru Faith in the Mata Amritanandamayi Mission. London and New York: RoutledgeCurzon.

Post Date:
10 June 2016

 

Share

Assemblies of God (The General Council of AOG)

ASSEMBLIES OF GOD (AOG) TIMELINE

1885-1900 Healing and Holiness revivals swept through the U.S., laying a foundation for the emergence of Pentecostalism.

1901 Agnes Ozman spoke in tongues in a prayer meeting led by Charles Fox Parham (1873-1929) in Topeka, Kansas.

1906-1909 The Azusa Street Revival in Los Angeles was launched by William Joseph Seymour (1870-1922), African American son of former slaves. The revival is commonly regarded as the birthplace of the Pentecostal movement.

1913 Eudorus N. Bell, Howard Goss, Daniel C.O. Opperman, Archibald P. Collins, and Mack M. Pinson initiated a call to a general council.

1914 The First General Council of the Assemblies of God was held in Hot Spring, Arkansas.

1916 The Fourth General Council of the Assemblies of God that was held in St. Louis adopted the Statement of Fundamental Truths.

1920 Women were granted permission to vote at General Councils.

1935 Women were granted full ordination by the AG, permitting them to administer the ordinances of baptism and communion “when such acts are necessary.”

1942 The Assemblies of God joined the newly founded National Association of Evangelicals.

1948 The all-white Pentecostal Fellowship in North America (PFNA) was established.

Late 1940s The New Order of the Latter Rain (‘Latter Rain Revival’) sought to revitalize Pentecostalism.

1960s The Charismatic Movement in Mainline Protestant and Catholic Churches experienced significant growth.

1962 David du Plessis (“Mr. Pentecost”) was stripped of AG ministerial credentials

1989 The World Pentecostal Assemblies of God Fellowship, representing national Pentecostal churches that were historically connected to the AG, was founded.

1993 The World Pentecostal Assemblies of God Fellowship became the World Assemblies of God Fellowship.

1994 The “Memphis Miracle” and racial reconciliation; the all-white Pentecostal Fellowship of North American (PFNA) was replaced with the integrated Pentecostal Charismatic Churches of North America (PCCNA).

2006 The AG established the Office of Hispanic Relations; the Spanish version of the Pentecostal Evangel (Evangelio Pentecostal) began publication.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

The seeds for the General Council of the Assemblies of God (AG) were planted by the affective experiences common to the religious revivals that swept through the American heartland in the twilight of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries (Poloma 1989; Poloma and Green 2010). Revivalists claimed not only personal spiritual transformation but divine empowerment for Christian service. This empowerment was frequently marked by strange physical manifestations, reported miracles, new theologies, and a burning desire to spread the gospel before Jesus returns. Many would separate from their old denominations (or were kicked out) as they embraced the “‘four-fold’ gospel of personal salvation, Holy Ghost baptism, divine healing, and the Lord’s soon return.” It became the theological base for scores of small sects, including the AG (Wacker 2001:1).

The fourfold gospel demanded more than an intellectual assent. Reports of salvation, repenting and accepting Jesus as the divine reconciler, were filled with stories of unusual encounters with the divine. Baptism in the Holy Spirit, an intense experience available to all who had experienced salvation, was marked by the peculiar “evidence” of speaking in tongues (glossolalia). Thus, at the heart of this fourfold gospel were paranormal experiences (divine healing, prophecy, miracles, speaking in tongues and other signs and wonders) biblically reported by the early Christian church. Such experiences were believed to empower the believer for the mission of spreading the gospel throughout the world in the “last days” before the righteous were raptured into heavens and Jesus would come to judge the unrighteous.

America has always had its revivals accompanied by the turbid emotionalism of heart-felt religion, accounts of which seemed to intensify as the nineteenth century came to a close (McClymond 2007). To the countless emotional stories of personal salvation that marked the first four decades of the nineteenth century were added testimonies of miraculous healings in the latter half. Healing evangelists were modeling divine healing in revivals and teaching that Jesus had given his followers the commission and power to “heal the sick.” Many of these nineteenth-century healing revivalists and their followers would come to identify with Pentecostalism, a twentieth century religious movement that now accounts for more than one half billion Christians worldwide.

Although historians agree that pentecostal revivals occurred in parts of the world other than the United States, most also concede that the U.S. was one of, if not the major player in the birth of global Pentecostalism. They further concede that Charles Fox Parham provided a critical theological plank that differentiated Pentecostalism from other Protestant revivals and from the fundamentalist movement. Clearly the healing movement of the late nineteenth century paved the way for Pentecostal experiences, but not all who embraced divine healing would become Pentecostal. It was Parham’s theological linking of the “baptism in the Holy Ghost” to the “evidence” of speaking in tongues (glossolalia) that separated Pentecostals from critics who did not accept the validity of equating what they pejoratively labeled “gibberish” with biblical accounts of “speaking in tongues.” In 1901 Agnes Ozman, a student at Parham’s College of Bethel, a Bible school for adults, added credence to Parham’s theology when she was heard to speak in tongues, an event that many contend launched the Pentecostal movement (Seymour, 2012; Hollenweger 1997; Robeck 2006).

It is fair to say, however, that Charles Parham might not have had a major place in the history of Pentecostalism without William Joseph Seymour, the African American pastor of the Azusa Street Mission in Los Angeles. Seymour, the son of former slaves (born in 1870 in southern Louisiana) was involved in nineteenth century revivals emanating

from the Wesleyan Holiness Movement between 1895 and 1905. During a visit to Houston in 1905, Seymour came into contact with Parham, and in January, 1906 Seymour would return to Houston where he enrolled in a six week course at Parham’s Bible school. [Because of segregation laws, the black Seymour sat in the hallway while white students were enjoying the lectures in an adjoining classroom.] Seymour went to Los Angeles in February, 1906 in response to a request by a leader of a small Baptist storefront mission that had embraced the teachings of the holiness movement. After Seymour presented Parham’s controversial teachings on Spirit baptism and tongues, he found himself locked out of the church. For several weeks Seymour was forced to limit his teachings to a house where he was staying on Bonnie Brae Street. There a seedling revival erupted when people began experiencing the baptism and tongues (Seymour 2012; Blumhofer and Armstrong 2002). To accommodate the greater numbers coming to the meeting, the group relocated at a former Methodist church on Azusa Street in April, 2006 (Seymour 2012; Bartleman 2012). The meeting on Bonnie Brae Street would soon morph into the Azusa Street Revival, arguably the most important event in the early development of the global Pentecostal movement. Although the secular press did not take kindly to the revival, it did take note. Church historian Cecil M. Robeck (2006:1) opens his excellent book on the Azusa Street Revival with the following colorful, if pejorative, news report from the Los Angeles Herald that depicts the Revival through the eyes of the reporter:

All classes gathered in the temple last night. There were big Negroes looking for a fight, there were little fairies dressed in dainty chiffon who stood on the benches and looked on with questioning wonder in their baby-blue eyes. There were cappers from North Alameda Street, and sedate dames from West Adams Street. There were all ages, sexes, colors, nationalities and previous conditions of servitude. The rambling old barn was filled and the rafters were so low that it was necessary to stick one’s nose under the benches to get a breath of air.

It was evident that nine out of every ten persons present was there for the purpose of new thrills. This was a new kind of show in which the admission was free—they don’t even pass the hat at the Holy Rollers’ meeting—and they wanted to see every act to the drop of the curtain. They stood on benches to do it. When a bench wasn’t handy, they stood on each other’s feet.

From 1906 through1909 Seymour’s Azusa Street Mission would become a focus of religious news not only for the faithful in Los Angeles, but for countless people across the globe. Accounts and myths about the revival spread long after the revival fires on Azusa Street were reduced to a flickering flame. Many who were touched by the revival would carry the Parham’s theology and Seymour’s revival throughout the United States and beyond. Upon visiting Azusa Street, however, Parham, rejected the revival because of what he considered to be the “extremes” in the revival that he credited to “Negro” religion (Bartleman 2012).

Although the revival fires waned by 1909, Seymour continued to pastor the Mission until his death in 1922. But as we have suggested, this was hardly the end of the story. Revival fires carried by Azusa Street pilgrims to myriads of congregations and scores of small sects both nationally and internationally (Bartleman 2012; Seymour 2012). Its paranormal religious experiences also pentecostalized some existing denominations. Most noteworthy was the pentecostalization of the Church of God in Christ (COGIC), still predominantly African American and now the fifth largest American denomination.

But many white revivalists were turned off to what they regarded as the extremes of the Azusa Street Mission remained affiliated with Charles Parham’s Apostolic Faith Movement (AFM). By 1913, however, some affiliates of the AFM became concerned about whether the network had become too organized under Parham’s leadership to allow for the vitality of an “end-times revival.” As AG historian Edith Blumhoffer (1993:116) described it: “Troubled by excess yet committed to life ‘in the Spirit,’ they decided to explore the advantage of cooperating as a loosely structured network that would preserve their autonomy but also provide a forum for consideration of mutual concerns.” [An interesting lived-account of this period can be found in Ethel Goss’s (1958) book penned by her husband Howard Goss about his involvement in the revival and the founding of the Assemblies of God.]

In 1913, five ministers (Eudorus N. Bell, Howard Goss, Daniel C.O. Opperman, Archibald P. Collins, and Mack M. Pinson, men who were affiliated with the loosely organized white Churches of God in Christ) initiated a call to a “general council” through various Pentecostal publications. Within the next three months the names of twenty nine other leaders representing different parts of the country and pentecostal perspectives were added to this original list. On April 6, 1914, the first meeting of the General Council, hosted by Howard Goss and his congregation, opened at the Grand Old Opera House in Hot Springs, Arkansas, where Goss and his wife settled and began an Assembly in 1912. E. N. Bell [who, according to Goss’ (1958) account collaborated closely with him] and J. R. Flower were appointed as chairman and secretary (Blumhoffer 1989). Although still wary of formal organization and decreed doctrine, those gathered sought a greater degree of cooperation in missionary activities, better business practices in their use of existing resources, and the establishment of a Bible training center. Of this endeavor to bring some order and accountability to the newly emerging Pentecostal movement, Goss (1958; chapter 27) would write:

As our numbers increased, the influx brought with it leaders who did not believe in organization at all; some even preached that anything of that nature (when committed to paper) was of the devil. Opposing this viewpoint was the definite system existing in the New Testament church under the Apostles. As we were all inexperienced, we were carefully testing every step, lest we somehow lose our precious fellowship with God.

As he continued his account Goss (1958; chapter 28) commented, “The smile of God seemed ot be on this union of many segments.” He went on to explain:

Whatever adjustments were needed were quickly, easily, and sweetly settled to everyone’s satisfaction. When those among us, who had doubted that the Conference would work out satisfactorily, saw how easily God had carried us past the shoals and hidden snags, they felt a mounting confidence in God and decided to co-operate. I think that what we Pentecostal people want to know, anyway, is that God is in any undertaking, and if He is, we are satisfied.

But despite perceptions of divine approval not all was well in this emergent network that eschewed both doctrine and structure. By 1916 the AG would lose an approximated quarter of its supporters due to an unacceptable “heresy” known as the “New Issue” that questioned the doctrine of the divine trinity. Although the initial two General Councils had been reluctant to deal with potentially divisive doctrine, the leaders were now forced to rethink the need for a basic statement of belief. Contributing more fuel to the doctrinal fire was the growing controversy over whether speaking in tongues was in fact “evidence” of Spirit baptism, as Parham and Seymour had taught (Blumhoffer and Armstrong 2002). The fourth General Council of the Assemblies of God held in St. Louis in 1916 would affirm Trinitarian theology within a doctrinal statement that adopted a list of sixteen “fundamentals.” The identity it espoused was “fundamentalism with a difference.” The two named points of “difference,” divine healing by the atonement and speaking in tongues as evidence of Spirit baptism, paradoxically would make the AG not only distinct from but also anathema to the twentieth century fundamentalist movement. Pentecostals, including members of the AG, became the target of the World’s Christian Fundamentals Association (WCFA), as illustrated by its resolution stating the WCFA was “unreservedly opposed to Modern Pentecostalism, including the speaking in unknown tongues, and the fanatical healing known as general healing in the atonement” (Blumhoffer 1993:159-60).

By 1920, a basic foundation had been laid by congregational leaders that proved to serve well the U.S. Assemblies of God as well as an emerging global network of AG congregations, which in 1993 would become known as the World Assemblies of God Fellowship. [The AG in the U.S. is but one of more than 150 national fellowships in the world’s largest Pentecostal network with over 65 million adherents .] Although originally rejected by fundamentalist congregations and isolated from other conservative denominations and sects (including other Pentecostal groups), the AG quietly continued on a path of steady growth. In 1942, the AG accepted an invitation to join the newly formed National Association for Evangelicals (NAE), a conservative umbrella organization that was able to overlook the doctrinal “differences” of glossolalia and healing. Despite some internal opposition within the AG to joining the NAE, leaders of the AG “embraced the vision of strength through unity” promised by this new evangelical organization that had tempered Fundamentalism’s antipathy toward Pentecostalism (Blumhofer 1993:184).

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Despite their initial resistance to a doctrinal statement, early leaders felt forced to adopt a common statement of faith in order toconfront what they regarded as major heresy. The Statement of Fundamental Truths (SFT) adopted in 1918 is a description of sixteen doctrinal statements that drew heavily on early fundamentalist confessions of faith. The AG founders added “healing by the atonement” and tongues as “initial evidence” providing a pentecostal twist to fundamentalist beliefs. The following is a summary of the 16 Fundamental Truths as presented by the denomination, as “nonnegotiable tenets of faith that all Assemblies of God churches adhere to” (Assemblies of God n.d.).

  1. WE BELIEVE… The Scriptures are Inspired by God and declare His design and plan for mankind.
  2. WE BELIEVE… There is only One True God–revealed in three persons…Father, Son, and Holy Spirit (commonly known as the Trinity).
  3. WE BELIEVE… In the Deity of the Lord Jesus Christ. As God’s son Jesus was both human and divine.
  4. WE BELIEVE…though originally good, Man Willingly Fell to Sin–ushering evil and death, both physical and spiritual, into the world.
  5. WE BELIEVE… Every Person Can Have Restored Fellowship with God Through ‘Salvation’ (trusting Christ, through faith and repentance, to be our personal Savior). [1 of 4 cardinal doctrines of the AG]
  6. WE BELIEVE…and practice two ordinances—(1) Water Baptism by Immersion after repenting of one’s sins and receiving Christ’s gift of salvation, and (2) Holy Communion (the Lord’s Supper) as a symbolic remembrance of Christ’s suffering and death for our salvation.
  7. WE BELIEVE… the Baptism in the Holy Spirit is a Special Experience Following Salvation that empowers believers for witnessing and effective service, just as it did in New Testament times. [1 of 4 cardinal doctrines of the AG]
  8. WE BELIEVE… The Initial Physical Evidence of the Baptism in the5 Holy Spirit is ‘Speaking in Tongues,’ as experienced on the Day of Pentecost and referenced throughout Acts and the Epistles.
  9. WE BELIEVE… Sanctification Initially Occurs at Salvation and is not only a declaration that a believer is holy, but also a progressive lifelong process of separating from evil as believers continually draw closer to God and become more Christlike.
  10. WE BELIEVE… The Church has a Mission to seek and save all who are lost in sin. We believe ‘the Church’ is the Body of Christ and consists of the people who, throughout time, have accepted God’s offer of redemption (regardless of religious denomination) through the sacrificial death of His son Jesus Christ.
  11. WE BELIEVE… A Divinely Called and Scripturally Ordained Leadership Ministry Serves the Church. The Bible teaches that each of us under leadership must commit ourselves to reach others for Christ, to worship Him with other believers, to build up or edify the body of believers–the Church and to Meet human need with ministries of love and compassion.
  12. WE BELIEVE… Divine Healing of the Sick is a Privilege for Christians Today and is provided for in Christ’s atonement (His sacrificial death on the cross for our sins). [1 of 4 cardinal doctrines of the AG]
  13. WE BELIEVE…in The Blessed Hope—When Jesus Raptures His Church Prior to His Return to Earth (the second coming). At this future moment in time all believers who have died will rise from their graves and will meet the Lord in the air, and Christians who are alive will be caught up with them, to be with the Lord forever. [1 of 4 cardinal doctrines of the AG]
  14. WE BELIEVE…in The Millennial Reign of Christ when Jesus returns with His saints at His second coming and begins His benevolent rule over earth for 1,000 years. This millennial reign will bring the salvation of national Israel and the establishment of universal peace.
  15. WE BELIEVE… A Final Judgment Will Take Place for those who have rejected Christ. They will be judged for their sin and consigned to eternal punishment in a punishing lake of fire.
  16. WE BELIEVE…and look forward to the perfect New Heavens and a New Earth that Christ is preparing for all people, of all time, who have accepted Him. We will live and dwell with Him there forever following His millennial reign on Earth. ‘And so shall we forever be with the Lord!’

The Assemblies of God also periodically releases statements on various issues not addressed in the SFT. Position papers cover a wide range of topics dealing with “biblical, theological and social concerns.” They include discussing proscribed behaviors (e.g., abstinence from alcohol; assisted suicide and abortion; divorce and remarriage; gambling; homosexuality); advise on questionable neo-pentecostal teachings (e.g., position of “prophets and apostles” in church organizations; demon possession and demonology; and “positive confession” (presuming to know the will of the divine and verbally professing the prayer need met by persistent positive professions rather than prayer). Position papers also have been written clarify other theological issues as they arise (e.g., creationism; inerrancy of scripture; and the rapture of the church). Position papers are not generally considered official positions of the AG, unless formal approval is requested by the Executive Presbytery and approved by the General Council.

The journey of AG doctrine from its original 1914 stance that tolerated doctrinal ambiguities to adopting the doctrinal SFT in 1918 is illustrated by its stance on baptism in the Holy Spirit. As succinctly summarized by AG historian C. M. Robeck (2003:170): “until late 1918, the Assembles of God was willing to tolerate ambiguity on the subject … with the adoption of the Statement of Fundamental Truths, however, the Assemblies of God had begun to close the door on differences of opinion.” AG has continued to closely align with Evangelical issues and doctrine while perhaps inadvertently distancing itself from “the vibrancy of an encounter with the living God” that has fueled the fires of the ongoing Pentecostal movement (Rybarczyk 2007: 8). This journey from primitivism to pragmatism (Wacker 2001) is reflected in AG rituals and practices.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

The worldview of the early Pentecostals accorded ideological legitimacy to the paranormal experiences reported in biblical times and restored them to a normative position in the twentieth-century Christianity. Although glossolalia and divine healing became the pivotal experiential doctrines in the AG, prophecy, miracles and demonic exorcisms were also part and parcel of the Pentecostal package. More controversial were the strange physical manifestations that generated the pejorative label “Holy Rollers” ascribed by outsiders to Pentecostal believers who sometimes fell in a faint to the floor, jumped pews, violently jerked and shook, laughed, barked or rolled in the aisles under the alleged influence of the Holy Spirit (Seymour 2012; see also Poloma 2005). Early Pentecostal ritual tended to be free-form and embraced the paranormal experiences reported throughout the Bible as being the work of the Holy Spirit. Ritual, as O’Dea and O’Dea (1983:58) have defined it, is “the cultic re-presentation of the religious experience [that] is central to the life of the religious group.” Experiences of the divine that are believed to empower evangelism remain the spiritual heartbeat for AG adherents, which find expression in the fluidity of AG rituals.

Some basic components for AG ritual can be gleaned from its doctrinal statement (SFT), especially the two biblical “ordinances” of baptism and Holy Communion (#6) and fundamental statements regarding personal salvation (#5), baptism in the Holy Spirit (#7 and #8), and divine healing of the sick (#12). Adult (anyone who has reached the age of reason) baptism by immersion is held periodically, generally during a Sunday service, and commonly in a baptistery found at the rear of the front platform of the church. The baptismal ritual is not deemed to be the essence of conversion or necessary for salvation, but rather a celebration of salvation, defined in the SFT as “trusting Christ, through faith and repentance, to be our personal Savior” (#5). Holy Communion, the second “ordinance” or Biblical mandate, is generally observed once a month during either the morning church service or less frequently in the Sunday evening evangelistic service. As with many other Protestant denominations, communion is marked with an appropriate reading from the Bible (generally from the accounts of Jesus’ last supper with his apostles or the Apostle Paul’s account) and the distribution of the “elements” of a wafer and grape juice to congregants in the pews. The focus of the communion ritual is the death of Jesus on the cross and its power to save and heal.

While some form of baptism and communion are celebrated by most Christians, the baptism in the Holy Spirit is an important Pentecostal marker that transcends AG belief and rituals. Spirit Baptism is an encounter with the divine believed to empower believers for ministry through the preternatural “gifts of the Spirit,” especially the “physical evidence” of speaking in tongues, but also prophecy, healing, and miracles. At one time much was made of “tarrying” for hours and even days actively seeking Spirit baptism at special meetings, revivals and church services. Rituals for praying for the baptism in the Spirit have become much less frequent and more subdued than in earlier days. Although there is no prescribed congregational ritual for baptism in the Holy Spirit, AG doctrine professes that it is available to all believers and must be accompanied by the “physical evidence” of speaking in tongues.

Poloma and Green (2010) found that the clear majority of the AG survey respondents (71%) claimed to have experienced Spirit baptism, with nearly all of these congregational respondents (70%) saying they prayed in tongues at least on occasion. As with prior generations, tongues is still used in private prayer, but, unlike the present generation, it appears that glossolaliac speech may no longer be heard in most AG church services. Only 29 percent of Poloma and Green’s respondents ever spoke in tongues at a corporate worship service and 16 percent ever provided an interpretation for glossolaliac speech. Pastors, who are required to have experienced Spirit baptism, with the “initial physical evidence” of speaking in tongues before being granted ordination, were more likely than congregants to pray privately in tongues. Poloma’s (2005:61)) survey of AG pastors found that a significant majority (82%) use tongues in their private prayer “weekly or more.” Like their congregants, pastors too are unlikely to speak in tongues during a congregational service. The once-common voice of glossolalia (a non-intelligible language) that could be heard during corporate worship and that required a vernacular response in the form of a prophetic interpretation (giving a message believed to be from God in intelligible speech) has become an infrequent practice, if found at all, in AG ritual.

Because of the congregational nature of the Assemblies of God, there is no one “typical” Sunday service or Wednesday evening gathering. There is no formal liturgy, and most church bulletins do not include details about the order of service as found in many other Christian congregations. Most Sunday services, however, do follow a familiar routine that begins with a congregational hymn that ushers in a time of worship in song, commonly interrupted at some point with a prayer and welcome from the pastor. During the time of “praise and worship” that follows, believers commonly stand with some raising their hands in prayer and swaying gently to the music as singing is led by the music director/pastor. The lone piano of AG services of old has been replaced in many churches with a full drum set, a guitar, keyboard, a piano, and/or other instruments. Old hymnals have been largely discarded and replaced with more contemporary Christian music, with words presented on an overhead. Congregational singing normally lasts from approximately twenty minutes to a half hour, with a welcome of visitors following as the pastor takes the podium. The service then shifts from prayerful music to comments from the pastor, a possible baby dedication, church announcements, or a congregant’s testimony. Following a short extemporaneous prayer, an offering is taken by the ushers, usually accompanied by a solo or special song by the choir. As with most evangelical churches, the sermon or “preaching of the Word” is the heart of the service, and the sermon is likely to last from thirty to forty-five minutes. (If communion is celebrated, it commonly occurs after the sermon.) Most churches have modified the once ubiquitous altar call for salvation that marked the end of a service into more general invitation to come forward for special prayer, including salvation, Spirit baptism, and physical healing.

Having sketched a general routine for AG services does not imply uniformity among congregations nor a predictable program on a given Sunday. AG congregational services differ considerably, reflecting the size and age of a congregation as well the social class, ethnicity and age of its members. For example, in 2011 there was a reported total of 12,457 AG congregations, 68 percent of which are primarily white; 20 percent, Hispanic; 4 percent, Asian and Pacific Islander; and 2.7 percent, black (primarily African). Churches ranged is size from less than fifty to thousands of adherents. The largest AG church in 2011 was New Life Covenant in Chicago with a reported attendance of 13,124. Both ethnicity and size can affect ritual styles, particularly when exploring the role of Spirit baptism and the use of the attendant “gifts.” Yet most congregants would acknowledge that the Spirit moves as the Spirit will, and some congregations are more intent in creating the space for the disruption of the normal by the paranormal than are others.

AG churches were once known for corporate affective and expressive worship that led their detractors to call them “Holy Rollers.” As the AG developed from loosely knit small fellowships into a top-ten denomination, many leaders and their congregations tried to distance themselves from their history to make their churches comfortable and acceptable to visitors. The primary weekly service is held on Sunday morning and typically lasts about an hour and a half. The once-common practice of having a second Sunday service, a less programmed evangelistic one on Sunday evening, seems to have become a thing of the past in many congregations. And Wednesday evenings are commonly devoted to adult Bible education and children/youth programs rather than tarrying in prayer.

Although this trend away from the expression of Pentecostal experiences during worship continues, the congregational nature of the AG assures that each congregation is free to pursue its own style. Poloma and Green (2010) have developed a four-fold typology – traditional, evangelical, renewalist, and alternative — based on the twenty-two AG congregations that they studied through observation and congregational surveys. Traditional congregations are the most likely to uphold their affiliation with the AG and the denomination’s well-established norms, beliefs and values and an affective worship style that allows space for the unexpected in ritual. Poloma and Green (2010:26) describe traditional ritual as follows: “These rituals have a unique acoustical feel, with occasional messages in tongues (glossolalia) followed by a prophetic interpretation; persistent calls (often with “tarrying” or waiting expectantly for God’s presence); loud, fervent prayer for special needs; shouts of praise that can be heard from the parking lot; and opportunities for testimonies that model experiences and expectations.”

While many Euro-American AG congregations have drifted away from the traditional model, ethnic churches (comprising over 30 percent of AG churches) are commonly found in this cell of the typology. Renewalist churches, like traditional AG congregations, tend to enjoy highly affective rituals, but they are more likely to identify with neo-pentecostal revivals outside the AG than with traditional AG norms and practices (see Poloma 2003). Renewalists may be the least stable of the four ritual types, with renewalists likely either drift toward neo-pentecostal networks outside the denomination or into the evangelical AG model. Evangelical AG congregations tend to score high on AG identity but low in affective ritual, as they model their services after the rituals of established evangelical Protestant churches. Alternative AG congregations, on the other hand, tend to be low on both AG identity and pentecostal experience. They contend that too much effervescence makes churches less “seeker sensitive” and therefore opt for less exuberant rituals. In both evangelical and alternative AG congregations one is less likely to find affective practices like speaking in tongues, physical manifestations, prophecy, and testimonies of divine healing.

A dilemma facing AG believers from the earliest days of the Azusa Street Street revival through today is how to allow the Spirit free movement during its rituals while controlling excesses judged to be fanatical. It is worth noting that the embodied worship of Azusa Street (including blacks hugging whites) was decried by Charles Parham and many followers of the Apostolic Faith Movement, including men who summoned the first “General Council” leading to the founding of the AG. For example, Howard Goss (1978:chapter 8), at whose church the first council convened, described how leaders of the Azusa revival permitted “ various kinds of fleshly manifestations to creep in under the impression that they were of God” and how Parham himself went to Los Angeles “hoping to help the workers to steady the work. But, as is often the case, they felt that they had received a greater power in Los Angeles than had been known before, so Brother Parham’s saving advice and counsel went unheeded and rejected.” In the AG glossolalia and healing soon became doctrine while many other alleged expressions of the Spirit’s presence were gradually relegated to the realms of fanaticism and heresy. Although what is perceived to be “extreme” and “fanatical” has fluctuated in AG history, its ritual has commonly been more than simply “remembering the past, but rather a forum for ongoing religious experiences” (Poloma 2005:60).

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

In describing the events that led up to the First General Council, Howard Goss believed that none “ever really wanted us to set up a separate organization, unless it became imperative. But . . . we soon knew that such a course was now imperative. Perhaps, it is also inevitable that our Movement will crystallize as it grows older and larger, and that it will not escape the vices which vast machinery and power have unwittingly fostered in older denominations. But may the dear Lord come before this materializes!” (Goss 1978:chapter 27). The “End Times” and the return of Jesus did not occur as expected by the early Pentecostals, leaving the AG to develop an impressive umbrella organization for its congregations and ministers. The once fluid relational fellowship of its founders would slowly evolve into what Goss and others might have considered a “vast machinery and power,” as it now serves over 12,000 U.S. churches and 35,000 credentialed ministers. It is an organization that for the most part has functioned well, and its workings appear to have the support of the vast majority of contemporary AG pastors (see Poloma 2005).

In keeping with the original intent of the formative first four General Councils (1914-16) the AG continues to self-identify as a “cooperative fellowship” rather than a denomination. Its formal designation as “The General Council of the Assemblies of God” reflects this value. The national headquarters is said to operate “primarily as a service organization – providing educational curriculum, organizing missions programs, credentialing ministers, overseeing the church’s colleges and seminary, producing communication channels for the churched and non-churched publics, and providing leadership for many national programs and ministries of the Assemblies of God” (“Our Form of Government”). Yet, there is no denying that the AG has developed a vast national organization that provides institutional covering for over three million adherents and thousands of churches and credentialed ministers who are served by its agencies and bureaus.

Permeating AG organization is a blend of congregational and presbyterian church polity. Churches elect their own pastors who, in turn, are responsible to church boards. Ministers are also directly responsible to their local District Council as well as to the Executive General Council. Churches are classified as either being affiliated with the General Council or affiliated with one of over sixty local or ethnic districts. Council affiliated churches enjoy full autonomy; district affiliated churches “have not yet developed to the point where they qualify for full autonomy.” While churches are autonomous congregational entities, the polity governing of ministers and district affiliated churches takes on a presbyterian mode of accountability through the General and Districts Councils and their executive staff.

Administering the General Council are six executive leaders and fourteen non-resident members of the AG Presbytery. Until relatively recently, executive leadership has been all white and all male, but that is slowly changing. In 2007, an African American (Zollie L. Smith Junior) was elected to serve on the executive team as “director of Assemblies of God U.S. Missions.” Over the years, fourteen non-resident members of the Executive Presbytery have been added to represent different factions, nine of which are white male, two Hispanic (elected in 2009 and 1995), one Korean (1999), and one Native American (2007). In 2009, an ordained female minister and missionary to India (Beth Grant) was selected to serve as “Executive Presbyter, representing Ordained Female Ministers,” a non-resident position on the Executive Council. The expanded General Council has created some space for persons of color and non-Euro ethnicity to serve as non-resident members. [In 2011, 68 percent of adherents were reported as being white (a proportion that continues to decrease) and 20 percent Hispanic (and growing in proportion)]. Opportunities for women, despite its long history of ordaining women, remain scarce. Poloma (2005) found in a survey of AG pastors that there was a greater openness to non-white men serving as church leaders than women (regardless of race or ethnicity). Although women have been ordained throughout AG history (with the exception of two years in the 1930s), women were not traditionally granted positions of leadership in the larger organization.

The AG seeks to maintain a loosely knit cooperative network that is increasingly more sensitive to cultural and regional differences. This once Euro-American denomination is making the transition to a culturally diverse body with a wide representation of a growing number of ethnic congregations. At the same time the AG still struggles to ensure a General Council with a leadership structure and polity permeable enough to reflect the charismatic play of the Spirit at work in these diverse congregations. The pragmatism of modern organizations and the primitive qualities of spiritual experiences continue to present dilemmas calling for resolution. The National Office of the Assemblies of God, which includes an administration building, the Gospel Publishing House, and the International Distribution Center, is located in Springfield, Missouri.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

The Assemblies of God was born out of religious revival, a charismatic moment when powerful prophetic experiences breathed new life into old religion. God seemed to be speaking to humans, and humans sought to respond with words of prophecy and the works of love. In its charismatic moment on Azusa Street old racial taboos were broken and feminine voices could be heard along with the masculine. Baptism in the Spirit was more than a new doctrine that involved glossolalia; it was a fresh experience of divine power and love. Contemporary AG theologians have reminded us that at the heart of the baptism was an empowering love for service (c.f. Macchia 2006) and that this baptism was “poured out on all flesh,” women and men, young and old, white and black people (c.f.Yong 2004). But as in all religious revivals, cultural weeds would soon spring up along side the prophetic wheat.

The Assemblies of God succinctly captures its core spiritual identity through a scriptural passage from the book of Zechariah 4:6, in which the Lord says, “Not by might, nor by power, but by my Spirit.” It provides a key for identifying the complex dilemma the AG has faced since its inception, namely how to balance modern rationality, its culture and organization, with primitive affective charismatic spirituality (Wacker 2001). Is it possible for Pentecostal experiences like tongues, healing, prophecy and miracles to continue to be passed down through the generations as more than doctrine or religious history? Put another way, how successful has AG been in maintaining its self-description as “Fundamentalism (Evangelicalism) with a difference?” Or has it pragmatically morphed into an Evangelicalism that is more doctrine than personal experience? It is with this important question in mind that we will consider three significant dilemmas that challenge the AG as the denomination approaches its centennial anniversary.

The first generation of AG adherents has been described as a loosely-knit congregational network that separated Pentecostals from secular society, other religious groups and often from each other. Convinced that the time was short before Jesus would return to earth, they had their work cut out for them with end-time prophecies proclaiming that the the end was fast approaching. In describing the path from “pilgrims to citizens,” historian Edith Blumhoffer (1993:142) writes: “Like other Pentecostals, early Assemblies of God members professed little interest in contemporary society; they had either not yet glimpsed a broader world or had consciously turned from it. Major political, social and intellectual transitions had significance primarily because they were interpreted through end-time prophetic lens to which Pentecostals subscribed.” These “pilgrims and strangers” on earth eschewed the mundane world in favor of ushering in the coming kingdom of God. This prophectic edge and separatist stance would be tempered by the passage of time during which the Lord seemed to “tarry.” Up until the last decades of the twentieth century, it was common for older “saints” to punctuate any talk of the future with “if Jesus tarries,” as a seeming reminder that they still believed Jesus would be coming soon.

Within a generation after its founding, however, the AG showed signs of pursuing a path antithetical to the expressed
“differences” found in its Pentecostal vision. It joined the newly formed National Association of Evangelicals (NAE) in 1942. Although the early AG, like their Fundamentalist forefathers and mothers, was wed to a literalist interpretation of the Bible and to separation from the larger culture, the AG was never accepted by Fundamentalists precisely because of the “differences,” namely teachings on Spirit baptism, tongue speaking, and divine healing. When more moderate fundamentalists established the NAE, the AG, differences and all, was welcomed into its fold. This union would strengthen the evangelical plank of the Statement of Fundamental Truths, arguably at the expense of the “differences” that marked unique Pentecostal beliefs and practices. In a process that has been called the “routinization of charisma,” more dissonance would develop between Pentecostal doctrine and experience (Poloma 1989; Ziefle 2013).

The seeds of dissonance between religious experience and organizational doctrine can be gleaned from the 1914 gathering when the loosely knit small group of Pentecostals first came together, desiring a fellowship to curb what they regarded as excesses in the new movement. Within the next two years, doctrinal schism caused by the “New Issue” would strengthen the organization and its doctrine, laying the foundation for the AG to grow into one of America’s top-ten denominations by the early twenty-first century. But aligning with the pragmatic necessity of Pentecostal doctrine and organization, it can be argued, resulted in a muting of the dynamic primal prophetic dimension. Thus emphasis placed on the doctrine by one group of Pentecostals undermined prophetic experiences that briefly united them despite their differences. Three significant issues will be briefly discussed to illustrate the tension between particularistic AG beliefs and practices and the diversity seeded by Pentecostal experiences, including (1) AG organization and revivals; (2) tensions in race/ethnic relations; and (3) the role of women.

AG has faced the continuing issue of revitalizing the spirit of Pentecost. As evident in the presentation of the history of the AG, the denomination was birthed in revival. Even as its early founders insisted on the AG’s not becoming another “dead denomination,” they were fearful of what they regarded as “wildfire” that was much a part of the Azusa Street Revival. They seemed to intuit that whatever else religious experience may be, it can be dangerous to religious institutions. Some of the doctrinal differences, as we have seen, were settled with the adoption of the FST in 1916 and the expulsion of Oneness Pentecostals (as many as one-fourth of the early group) who had a different understanding of the Godhead than the Trinitarian founders. As the decades wore on, the AG would slowly morph from a “fellowship” into a denomination that would seek to protect the organization from the potentially disruptive revivalistic movements, including the New Order of the Latter Rain (the late 1940s), the Charismatic Movement (“Second Wave”) of the 1960s/1970s, and the so-called “Third Wave” revivals of the 1990s extending through the present time. Even when a major revival broke out in one of its own churches in Pensacola, Florida at Brownsville Assembly of God in 1995, denominational reaction was decidedly mixed (see Poloma 1998:2005). More recently Bill Johnson [former AG who pastors the former AG Bethel Church in Redding, California and is the leader of a growing network of revival churches] would amicably resign from the AG. In withdrawing from the AG, Johnson would note: “Our call feels unique enough theologically and practically from the call on the Assemblies of God that this change is appropriate” (Poloma and Green 2010:102).

One particularly significant account of the “struggle for the soul of a [AG) movement” involves the story of David du Plessis, an
evangelist from South Africa who joined the AG when he moved to the United States in the middle of the twentieth century (see Ziefle 2013). Known as “Mr. Pentecost” by those in the “second wave” of Pentecostal revival known as the Charismatic Movement, du Plessis believed that church unity was a primary marker of the move of the Holy Spirit, the same unity of spirit that he believed characterized the earliest years of the Azusa Street Revival. Having the ear of many leaders of the Charismatic Movement, du Plessis spread the Pentecostal gospel of Spirit baptism and involved himself in ecumenism, a movement that was anathema to evangelicals and to the AG. His involvement in the World Council of Churches resulted in his being defrocked by his adopted denomination in 1962; his ministerial credentials  would not be restored until 1980. Forced to leave the AG because of his ongoing work with Second Wave leaders (including Roman Catholics) left du Plessis on the margins even when he was reinstated as an AG minister toward the end of his life.

The pragmatic evangelicalization of the AG at the expense of its primitive spirituality has long been noted (c.f. Poloma 1989; Poloma and Green 2010; Ziefle 2013), but this observation is only part of the story. The AG in the United States combines its Presbyterian polity with Congregational government allowing for the congregational diversity as reflected in the different types of congregations and rituals discussed in an earlier section. Although the Evangelical AG congregations arguably may be the predominant type, it is important to assess the growing number of Hispanic and other ethnic churches that are commonly categorized as Traditional AG in beliefs and rituals (Poloma and Green 2010). Rooted in its history a cultural dynamic is at work that is transforming the formerly predominantly Euro-American denomination with strong rural southern roots into an increasingly multicultural one with a diverse urban presence.

AG has also faced racial/ethnic tensions through its history. “The evidence is clear:,” says Don Meyer, AG leader and president of one of its universities, “The Assembles of God has not had a good track record on race. Whether one looks at this issue ecclesiastically, theologically, sociologically, or biologicallty, we have been ‘weighed in the balances and found wanting’” (Newman 2007:1). From its beginning days, the AG saw itself as a “white denomination,” as it disengaged from the Church of God in Christ (COGIC), the fifth largest denomination in the U.S. African Americans who sought ordination within the AG were officially referred to the “colored organization” (COGIC).

It was not until 1994 in what was known as the “Memphis Miracle” that the AG officially disavowed its racist past. In what was described as a “historic gesture,” General Superintendant Thomas Trask (the highest-ranking official in the AG) participated in a ceremonial footwashing (Newman 2007) at a conference of black and white Pentecostal leaders in Memphis. Prophecies were given about black and white unity, as a white AG pastor (Donald Evans) came forward and explained that “the Lord had called him to wash the feet of a black leader (Bishop Clemmons) as a sign of repentance” (Synan 2010). It was also at the Memphis gathering that the all-white Pentecostal Fellowship of North American (PFNA) was disbanded to be replaced with the integrated Pentecostal Charismatic Churches of North America (PCCNA).

The Memphis Miracle has done little to bring African Americans into the AG fold, but it can be regarded as a marker for the AG losing the questionable distinction of being an “all-white” American denomination. Its once nearly lily white constituency is now a multi-cultural one that reflects recent immigration patterns, especially the growth of the Hispanic population in the U.S. As of January, 2012, there were more than 2,400 officially recognized Hispanic organizations in the General Council of the Assemblies of God, USA, with 12 Hispanic districts that include more than 3,300 ministries (“Office of Hispanic Relations” n.d.). The figures for Hispanics represent some 20 percent of AG adherents, while only 2.7% of adherents are black (mostly Caribbean or recent African immigrants), 4 percent are Asian or Pacific Islanders, and 1.5% are of Native American heritage (“Statistics of the Assemblies of God” 2007)

Despite these demographic changes, the leadership of the General Assembly has tended to be disproportionately white, althoughmoves have been made within the past decade to establish closer relations with the Hispanic churches. In 2006, the Office of Hispanic Relations was established as part of the National Leadership and Resource Center, with a Spanish version of the AG publication of Pentecostal Evangel and a Spanish website. It should be noted that ethnic churches enjoy the autonomy inherent in the AG’s congregational polity. Furthermore, these congregations are often founded and led by indigenous ministers involved in what can be termed “reverse missiology.” Early in its history of an aggressive missions program, the AG departed from the colonial model of other denominations, “establishing mission stations as beachheads in other nations, led by missionaries, and with national pastors on their payroll” (Molenaar, n.d.:1). Instead, the AG sent out its missionaries and trained indigenous leaders who have developed autonomous AG churches throughout the world. As immigrants have come from South and Central America, Africa, Asia, and other places to the U.S., they have been increasingly served by their indigenous clergy.

The congregational polity that has promoted indigenous leadership, however, has not yet been translated into leadership within the AG Executive Council and its headquarters in Springfield, Missouri. The history of the World Assemblies of God Fellowship may be a predictor of things to come if the growing ethnic constituency is not more fully acknowledged on the national level. The roots of the World Assemblies of God Fellowship (with over 65 million adherents within over 150 national fellowships), as we have noted earlier, was American and guided by the US church. This would change as the twentieth century came to a close; the AG USA is but one equal member of this global organization. It is conceivable that without increased recognition and representation on the national level, ethnic districts may seek a more autonomy and equality with the largely Euro-American leadership in the denomination.

Finally, the history of women in Pentecostalism has been aptly characterized as “complex and contradictory” ( Griffith and Roebuck 2002:1203). On one hand, a case can be made for gender equality, citing the fact that the AG ordained women decades before women were ordained in mainline denominations. On the other hand, there have always been limitations, at times formally defined but primarily culturally and structurally proscribed. Dr. George O. Wood (2001), who as a district leader in California and more recently as the AG’s General Superintendent has been highly supportive of AG ordination of women, succinctly describes the early history as follows:

At the organizational meeting of the Assemblies of God in 1914, women were granted the right of ordination as evangelists and missionaries, but not as elders. Ordained women were at first not permitted to vote in the General Council since such was regarded as an eldership function. However, women were accorded voting rights beginning with the 1920 General Council, the same year the 19 th Amendment was adopted which granted women in the United States the right to vote.

The ban on eldership meant that ordained women should not serve as pastors, marry people, and administer the ordinances of water baptism and the Lord’s supper. However, the Assemblies of God had ordained women fulfilling all these functions anyway. In 1922, then general superintendent E.N. Bell, writing on behalf of the Executive Presbytery to ordain women, wrote: “It has nevertheless been understood all along that they could do these things when some circumstance made it necessary for them to so do. . . . The Executive Presbytery authorized the Credential Committee to issue new credentials to all our ordained women who are actually preaching the Word just the same as ordained men do, and that these credentials should state these women are authorized to do these things when necessary.” So sensitive and potentially divisive was that decision that Brother Bell requested at the end of his letter to ordained women: “TAKE NOTICE: This letter is not to go out of your personal possession.”

Aimee Semple McPherson had been ordained in the AG as an “evangelist” and was one of many women functioning as a fully
ordained minister despite the proscriptions cited above. She was highly popular in Pentecostal circles and would withdraw from the AG in 1922, the same year as Bell’s letter, as she founded the International Church of the Four Square Gospel. The ordination issue continued to simmer until it came to a head in 1933 when the General Council formally limited the ordination of women to “evangelist.” Although the right of ordained women to officiate the ordinances “when such acts are necessary” would be reinstated in 1935, “the patterns of limitation continued to be generally accepted” (Griffith and Roebuck 2002:1205).

With the rise of feminism in the United States in the 1970s, the AG was intent on distancing itself from advocating equal rights for women. With this antipathy toward feminist issues, the percent of women ministers in the AG slowly but steadily decreased in the AG during the 1970s and 1980s (Pulliam 2009). The new millennium has seen an increase of the number and percent of women ministers, with the percent of women ministers increasing from 14 percent to nearly 21 percent in 2010. The vast majority of the 7,000 plus ordained women, however, serve the denomination on staffs of churches or as world missionaries. Women serving as lead pastors of congregations continue to be few and far between. Beth Grant, a missionary to India, was elected in 2009 to serve on the Executive Presbytery as “Executive Presbyter, representing Ordained Female Ministers.”

General Superintendent George Wood has been a leading voice in promoting equality for women in the AG. Growing up with a mother who was ordained in 1924, Wood has reminded adherents that “the credentialing of women in our Fellowship is not some late popular cultural fad.” Wood (n.d.) explains: “Our early pioneers were convinced that Scripture meant what it said when the promise of Pentecost was realized: In the last days, God says, ‘I will pour out my Spirit on all people. Your sons and daughters will prophesy. . .Even on my servants, both men and women, I will pour out my Spirit in those days, and they will prophesy’ (Acts 2:17,28).”

The Spirit may have been poured out on all, but women have always been on a short leash. In its charismatic moment, women played a major role in revivals as did people of color. But as the denomination aligned with Evangelicalism, arguably the AG it took on its pragmatic culture and modern issues at the cost of Pentecostalism’s prophetic thrust. Whether or not the AG can continue to effectively balance its primitive spirituality with its pragmatic orientation can be monitored through its openness to new waves of pentecostal revival, to its ability to learn from the charismatic spirituality found in immigrant churches, and to granting equality to its prophetic women.

REFERENCES

Assemblies of God. n.d. “Statement of Fundamental Truths.” Accessed from http://ag.org/top/Beliefs/Statement_of_fundamental_truths/sft_short.cfm on 5 February 2013)

Bartleman, Frank. (2012; 1925). Azusa Street. How Pentecost Came to Los Angeles. Kindle Edition: Jawbone Digital. Accessed from http://www.JawboneDigital.com on 20 April 2013.

Blumhofer, Edith L. 1993. Restoring the Faith. The Assemblies of God, Pentecostalism, and American Culture. Chicago: University of Illinois Press.

Blumhofer, Edith L. 1989. The Assemblies of God: A Chapter in the Story of American Pentecostalism, Volume 1. Springfield, MO: Gospel Publishing House.

Blumhoffer, E. L. and C. R. Armstrong. 2002. “Assemblies of God.” Pp. 333-41 in International Dictionary of Pentecostal Charismatic Movements, edited by Stanley M. Burgess and Eduard M. Van Der Mass. Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan.

Goss, Ethel E. 1958. The Winds of God. The Story of the Early Pentecostal Days (1901-1914) in the Life of Howard A Goss. A Christian Reality Books Pentecostal History Classic Reprint. Kindle Version.

Griffith, R.M. and D. Roebuck. 2002. “Role of Women.” Pp. 1203-09 in The New International Dictionary of Pentecostal and Charismatic Movements, edited by Stanley M. Burgess and Eduard M. Van Der Maas. Grant Rapids, MI: Zondervan.

Hollenweger, Walter J. 1997. Origins and Developments Worldwide. Peabody, MA: Hendrickson Publishers.

Macchia, Frank D. 2006. Baptized in the Spirit. A Global Pentecostal Theology. Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan.

McClymond, Michael, ed. 2007. Encyclopedia of Religious Revivals in America. Volume 2. Primary Documents. Westport CT: Greenwood Press.

Molenaar, William. n.d. “The World Assemblies of God Fellowship. United in the Missionary Spirit.” Accessed from www.worldagfellowship.org on 29 January 2013).

Newman, Joe. 2007. Race and the Assemblies of God Church. The Journey from Azusa Street to the “Miracle of Memphis” Amherst, NY: Cambria Press.

O’Dea, Thomas F. and Janet Aviad O’Dea. 1983. The Sociology of Religion. Second Edition. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.

“Office of Hispanic Relations.” n.d. Assemblies of God. Accessed from http://ag.org/top/Office_of_Hispanic_Relations/index.cfm on 20 April 2013.

Poloma, Margaret M. 2005. “Charisma and Structure in the Assemblies of God: Revisiting O’Dea’s Five Dilemmas.” Pp. 45-96 in Church, Identity, and Change: Theology and Denominational Structures In Unsettled Times, edited by David A. Roozen and James R.; Nieman. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans.

Poloma, Margaret M. 2003. Main Street Mystics: The Toronto Blessing and Reviving Pentecostalism. Walnut Creek, CA: AltaMira Press.

Poloma, Margaret M. 1998. “The Spirit Movement in North America at the Millennium: From Azusa Street to Toronto, Pensacola and Beyond.” Journal of Pentecostal Theology 12:83-107.

Poloma, Margaret M. 1989. The Assemblies of God at the Crossroads: Charisma and Institutional Dilemmas. Knoxville, TN: The University of Tennessee Press.

“Our Form of Government.” n.d. Assemblies of God. Accessed from http://ag.org/top/about/structure.cfm on 20 April 2013.

Poloma, Margaret M. and John C. Green. 2010. The Assemblies of God. Godly Love and the Revitalization of American Pentecostalism. New York: New York University Press.

Pulliam, Sarah. 2009. “Women Pastors Remain Scarce.” Christianity Today. Accessed from http://www.christianitytoday.com/women/2009/august/women-pastors-remain-scarce.html on 20 April 2013.

Robeck, Cecil M., Jr. 2006. Azusa Street. Mission and Revival. The Birth of the Pentecostal Movement. Nelson Reference & Electronic.

Robeck, Cecil M. Jr. 2003.“An Emerging Magisterium? The Case of the Assemblies of God.” Pneuma 25:165-215.

Rybarczyk, Edmund. 2007. “American Pentecostalism: Challenges and Temptations.” Pp. 1-13 in The Future of Pentecostalism in the United States, edited by E. Patterson and E. Rybarczyk. New York: Lexington Books.

Seymour, William. 2012. 1906-1908. The Azusa Papers (written from September 1906-May, 1908). Jawbone Digital. Accessed from http://www.JawboneDigital.com on 20 April 2013.

“Statistics of the Assemblies of God.” 2007. Assemblies of God. Accessed from http://ag.org/top/about/statistics/Statistical_Report_Summary.pdf on 20 April 2013.

Synan, Vinson. 2010. “ Memphis 1994: Miracle and Mandate.” Accessed from www.pcna.org/about_history.htm on 18 April 2013.

Wacker, Grant . 2001. Heaven Below. Early Pentecostals and American Culture. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Wood, George O. 2001. “Exploring Why We Think The Way We Do About Women In Ministry.” Enrichment Journal. Accessed from http://enrichmentjournal.ag.org/200102/008_exploring.cfm on 20 April 2013.

Wood, George O. n.d. “Why Credentials Are Important for Women Ministers.” The Nework. A Called Community of Women. Accessed from http://ag.org/wim/0509/0509_credentials.cfm on 20 April 2013.

Yong, Amos. 2004. The Spirit Poured Out on All Flesh. Pentecostalism and the Possibility of Global Theology. Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic.

Ziefle, Joshua R. 2013. David du Plessis and the Assemblies of God. The Struggle for the Soul of a Movement. Boston: Brill.

Post Date:
20 April 2013

ASSEMBLIES OF GOD VIDEO CONNECTIONS

 

 

Share

Against the Stream Buddhist Meditation Society (ASBMS)

AGAINST THE STREAM BUDDHIST MEDITATION SOCIETY (ASBMS)

1971:  Noah Levine was born to parents Stephen and Ondrea Levine in Los Angeles, California.

1988:  Levine was incarcerated in a juvenile hall detoxification cell.

1991:  Levine attended his first meditation retreat with Jack Kornfield and studied with him for ten years.

2000 (June):  The Mind-Body Awareness Project was created.

2003:  Levine launched a Dharma Punx group on the New York City Lower East Side.

2004:  Levine’s memoir, Dharma Punx was published.

2005:  Levine moved to Los Angeles.

2007:  The documentary focusing on Levine’s life, “Meditate and Destroy,” was released.

2007:  Levine published his second book, Against the Stream.

2008:  The first Against the Stream center opened in Melrose, California.

2009:  A second center opened in Santa Monica, California.

2014 (April):  An outpatient facility opened in Los Angeles.

2014 (May):  The sober living facility for the Refuge Recovery program opened in Hollywood.

2014 (June):  Levine published Refuge Recovery.

2018 (March):  Against the Stream released a statement announcing that an investigation of Noah Levine regarding allegations of sexual misconduct by Noah Levine.

2018:  The Against the Stream released a statement indicating that Levine had probably committed the offenses alleged, removed him from the Board of Directors, and closed several of its centers.

2018 (June):  Levine resumed teaching through Refuge Recovery.org.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

The emergence of punk subculture in the U.S., U.K., and Australia followed on the heels of the demise of the hippie subculture in the mid-1970s (Mageary 2012; Milenković 2007). The two subcultures shared opposition to established institutions, but punks rejected hippies for a “do whatever you want as long as no one else is hurt” philosophy and a lack of real understanding about what would be necessary for systemic change. Punk subculture has evidenced considerable class diversity but has been overwhelmingly white. The subculture has developed and been shaped differently internationally, reflecting specific cultural traditions.

As Against the stream described the philosophy (ASBMS nd):

Dharma Punx is not just a book it is a way of being, it is how we have come to integrate our political and spiritual beliefs. we sought a different path than our parents, the once idealistic hippie generation that had long since cut their hair, left the commune and bought in to the system. peace and love had failed to make any real changes and in response to the despair and hopelessness we felt came the punk rock movement. seeking to rebel against society’s fascist system of oppression and capitalist driven propaganda the kids responded in our own way, different from those before us, a new revolution for a new generation.

At the center of punk subculture, of course, was punk rock, which incorporated rebellion against both conventional society and commercialized mainstream rock music. Punk musical style emphasizes relatively short, intense, fast songs containing strong anti-establishment messages. Distinctive punk rock performance characteristics have been shouting of song lyrics, DIY chorus, storming the stage, gang vocals, mosh pits and slam dancing. The punk subculture that developed around punk rock spawned numerous offshoot groups and evolved and diversified over time. However, common themes in the subculture, and particularly hardcore punk, have been an anti-authoritarian stance, non-conformity, individualism, opposition to a range of conventional values (militarism, capitalism, racism, sexism, nationalism, consumerism) and established institutions, and promotion of alternative values (animal rights, vegetarianism, environmentalism). A larger objective of the punk subculture has been replacing capitalist society with a social order built around decentralized, autonomous, egalitarian communities.

Early punk style (clothing, tattoos, piercings of various kinds, and body modification, jewelry, hairstyles) was flamboyant (tattoos, dyed hair, safety pins, metal studs/spikes, colored and spiked hair, torn clothing, display of the swastika) while later hardcore punk style was more mundane (jeans, tee shirts, working class street attire). The subculture has also been known for its explicit displays of sexual identity, such as wearing underwear as overwear. Tattooing has been a central means of symbolizing and affirming membership in the punk community. Within the context of strong individualism, there also has been an emphasis on community within punk culture. Loose punk communities are built around punk bands, with their distinctive musical styles and political messages. In addition to rejection of conventional society, unifying values within decentralized, punk communities include a sense of being outsiders, strong individualism, egalitarianism, personal autonomy and authenticity, the DIY (Do It Yourself) ethic, and aversion to “selling out.” Members wear X or XXX tattoos (a symbol that was stamped on the hands of underage individuals entering nightclubs to forestall their purchase of alcohol) on their hands as symbols of group membership. Although the place of religion in punk subculture was a matter of some controversy, during the 1990s Christian, Krishna consciousness, Islamic (Taqwacore – “piety” core), and Buddhist (Dharma Punx) strands of punk subculture emerged (Fiscella 2012; Stewart 2011, 2012).

Heavy drug and alcohol use was characteristic of early punk subculture. One of the groups that emerged within punk subculturein response to the heavy drug use was Straight Edge punk. Straight Edge originated in 1981 when Ian MacKaye wrote a song by that title for Minor Threat, a hardcore punk band. In the song he asserted that he was claiming “the straight edge” by rejecting drugs, alcohol, and casual sex. In addition to these three primary principles, many straight edge punks support vegetarianism, feminism. There is also a positive orientation in the culture, which involves making choices in one’s life that produce positive outcomes.

The founder of Against the Tide Buddhist Meditation Society (ASBMS), Noah Levine, was born in 1971 to Stephen and Ondrea Levine in Los Angeles, California. His father is an American author and poet who has written extensively on Buddhist teachings, with a focus on death and dying. Levine was brought up in a Buddhist family, but he initially rejected Buddhist practice. By his own account, he had a difficult childhood. He began using marijuana and drinking alcohol at a young age and states that he was suicidal at age five. During his teenage years, he spent his time with a group of punk friends who were heavily involved in drug and alcohol use. At age sixteen he dropped out of high school and was then using both heroin and crack cocaine. Levine was arrested on a number of occasions and at age seventeen was placed in a juvenile detention facility after trying to steal a car radio to get money for drugs. Levine had already been involved with the twelve-step recovery plan of Alcoholics Anonymous. It was during his detention that he began using the Buddhist meditation techniques his father had taught him in order to rehabilitate himself. He first attended a meditation retreat in 1991 and then studied with Jack Kornfield for ten years at Spirit Rock Meditation Center in Woodacre, California. Levine also earned a Masters degree in Counseling from the California Institute of Integral Studies in San Francisco (“Dharma Punx” n.d.).

After he had practiced mindfulness-based meditation for about five years, Levine and a close group of his friends started the MindBody Awareness Project in 2000, which had the objective of teaching troubled youth mindfulness meditation and emotion coping strategies. In 2006, the organization was merged with a sister non-profit, and then in 2007, was merged again with Vision Youthz, an aftercare program for youth located in San Francisco. The three organizations have continued to work together in an effort to serve at-risk youth in the area. Levine currently serves on the Board of Directors (“Mind Body Awareness Project” n.d.). Levine went on to found the Against the Stream Buddhist Meditation Society in 2008 as a means of making Buddhist teachings accessible to everyone. The first center was located in Melrose, California, and about a year later the organization moved to Santa Monica. Subsequently, many chapters have been established across the U.S. Levine himself resides in Los Angeles California (“Dharma Punx” 2014).

Levine began his publishing career in 2004 with his memoir, Dharma Punx, in which he traces the path toward the connection between the punk scene and Buddhist teachings. He recounts his troubled youth, addiction, andsubsequent recovery. He describes his trips to monasteries in Asia and his later return to the juvenile hall where he was incarcerated, this time to teach meditation. In 2007, Levine published a second book, Against the Stream, that includes a variety of meditation techniques and instructions for both novices and skilled practitioners. He outlines a “path to freedom” The first stage, “The Rebel’s Path,” involves daily practice, an annual retreat, and following the five precepts. These practices and commitments are intensified in “The Revolutionary’s Path.” The culminating state, “The Radical’s Path,” involves an increased multi-year commitment and a willingness to teach others. His most recent book, Refuge Recovery: A Buddhist Path to Recovering from Addiction (2014), discusses the application of the Four Noble Truths and the Eight-Fold Path to the recovery program that he has created.

The organizational trajectory of ASBMS remained positive until 2018 when Levine and ASBMS experienced a major turn of events [See, Issues/Challenges]

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

The melding of Buddhism and Punk subculture in Dharma Punx includes a brickolage of beliefs drawn from a number of religious traditions, but it is fundamentally rooted in the Vispanna Buddhist tradition, which emphasizes seeing the world as it actually is. In Against the Stream there is both a rejection of traditional Buddhism and contemporary protest subculture. Asian Buddhism is found to be corrupted through racist, sexist, classist doctrines and practices. As Against the Stream puts it, “we do not have blind faith in doctrine,” and the new tradition remains wary of the superfluous mythology and folk stories (Preston 2009; “Against The Stream Buddhist Meditation Society” n.d.). The hippie subculture was dismissed as unrealistic; the hardcore punk subculture was deemed to be overly negative. Levine, along with Jack Kornfield, instead allied himself with emerging American Buddhism, which emphasizes relevance, accessibility, and applicability for contemporary Americans. Levine sought a return to what he believes is the original, pure, core teachings of Buddhism contained in the Pali Sutta. For Levine, Siddhartha Gautama, who he refers to as “Sid,” was a revolutionary who taught anti-establishment rebellion and advocated a path of “Patisotagami,” that is, “against the stream” (“Against the Stream Buddhist Meditation Society” n.d.). Levine has adopted as his motto, “Meditate and Destroy” (dark thoughts).

As a Straight Edge movement, Against the Stream has three primary distinguishing tenets, abstinence from alcohol, drugs (tobacco included), and casual sex, although there are varying interpretations of what constitutes casual sex. Other values commonly found in Straight Edge groups are vegetarianism/veganism and anti-consumerism. The irrevocable commitment in claiming an edge is one made both to oneself and to the community. Given the highly individualistic nature of punk subculture, adherence to those tenets is achieved through ongoing self-monitoring and self-regulation. ASBMS centers its teachings around the Four Noble Truths: the truth of  dukkha  (anxiety or suffering), the truth of the origin of  dukkha,  the cessation of  dukkha,  and the truth of the path leading to the cessation of dukkha.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

ASBMS offers meditation practice as well as a variety of talks and classes on Buddhist practice with the larger goal of making Buddhist meditation as accessible as possible. Many of the classes involve Guided Meditation supplemented by a Dharma talk given by Levine or another teacher. Other classes focus on a specific type of meditation, such as relational mindfulness, which emphasizes the importance of intimacy in a community, with a new Buddhist theme incorporated each week. Another type of meditation is Recollective Awareness Meditation, where the emphasis is on remembering what was experienced during the practitioner’s meditation sitting. In addition, there alternating weeks of concentrations and insights practices as well as lovingkindness practices for the more experienced meditator.

The Refuge Recovery Program is central to ASBMS. Some of the precepts resemble the Twelve-Step Programs like Alcoholics Anonymous with which Levine initially worked. Refuge Recovery, however, operates from a Buddhist perspective. The fundamental principle of the program is that everyone has the capacity to free themselves from suffering. The four precepts that guide one’s liberation from suffering are (Levine 2014):

Addiction creates suffering. There are many forms of addiction (drugs, alcohol, sex, gambling, money, food, other people) and many forms of suffering (greed, hatred, delusion, endless craving, shame, lying, fear, hurting others or ones self, isolation, jealousy).

Addiction is not all your fault. Craving, the source of addiction, is natural Individuals therefore are not responsible for the underlying causes of addiction, but they are responsible for the behaviors that sustain addiction.

Recovery is possible. Individuals have the capacity to restore themselves to meaningful lives in which they experience well-being.

The path to recovery is the based on Buddhism’s Eight-fold Path.

According to Levine (2014:24-26), the Eightfold path of Refuge Recovery is

Understanding: We come to know that everything is ruled by cause and effect.

Intention: We renounce greed, hatred, and delusion. We train our minds to meet all pain with compassion and all pleasure with non-attached appreciation.

Communication/Community: We take refuge in the community as a place to practice wise communication and to support others on their paths. We practice being careful, honest, and wise in our communications.

Action/Engagement: We let go of the behaviors that cause harm. We ask that one renounces violence, dishonesty, sexual misconduct, and intoxication. Compassion, honesty, integrity, and service are guiding principles.

Livelihood/Service: We are of service whenever and wherever possible. And we try and ensure that our means of livelihood are such that they don’t cause harm.

Effort/Energy: We commit to daily contemplative practices like meditation and yoga, exercise, and the practices of wise actions, kindness, forgiveness, compassion which lead to self-regulatory behaviors in difficult circumstances.

Mindfulness/Meditations: We develop wisdom by means of practicing formal mindfulness meditation. We practice present-time awareness in our lives.

Concentration/Meditations: We develop the capacity to focus the mind on one thing, such as the breath, or a phrase, training the mind through the practices of lovingkindness, compassion, and forgiveness to cultivate that which we want to uncover.

Within the Refuge Recovery program, the Four Truths of Refuge Recovery serve as the guiding principles for participants, and, combined with meditation practice, help addicts apply the truths to their recovery process. M indfulness, forgiveness, and compassion are practiced through meditation and discussion at the meetings to aid participants. Consistent with the ASBMS principle of egalitarianism, meetings begin with a statement from the teacher: “My role is not authoritative. I am not an empowered Buddhist meditation teacher; I’m here to facilitate the group and lead our discussion.” The meeting sequence is a twenty to thirty-minute guided meditation, a reading, a group share period on a prearranged topic, and a final reading.. Members are reminded of the need to preserve anonymity and confidentiality. A small donation is suggested (Kremar 2014).

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Noah Levine, the founding teacher of ASBMS, locates the organization relative to the 1960s hippie movement (which he criticizedfor being unrealistic about the sacrifices that would be necessary to produce systemic change), conventional society (which he characterizes as corrupt), traditional Buddhism (which he assesses as having been corrupted). By contrast, Against the Stream is part of the New Buddhism that rejects traditional Buddhist practice in favor of a more contemporary, accessible, and attainable practice for present-day conditions. Levine symbolizes and embodies his oppositional stance and Buddhist commitments in part through extensive tattooing, which includes a large image of Buddha on his abdomen and a Buddhist wheel of existence covering his entire back (Swick 2010).

Levine works in the two centers in Los Angeles, as well as advising over twenty different groups across the U.S. A group of teachers and facilitators for meditation classes has been trained for work in the ASBMS centers. The facility offers weekly classes on American Buddhism and meditation, half-day and day-long programs, retreats, and ten month-long intensive programs in meditation. The facilitators offer a Women’s Group, and a Young People’s Group monthly (“Against the Stream Buddhist Meditation Society” n.d.). Bimonthly group classes are offered for all those who identify as people of color. There is also a bimonthly Family Program offered by Levine and the facilitators for parents and children. The services offered continue to expand as an outpatient program opened in April, 2014 in Los Angeles and a sober living program opened in May in Hollywood (Kremar 2014). Both Los Angeles centers offer weekly meetings to those interested in the Recovery Refuge program, for those recovering from addiction, led by Levine and other teachers.

Since 2008, the organization has grown to offer seventeen weekly classes and groups that included as many as 500 participants. The clientele has both grown and diversified. The teacher at the New York City group, Josh Korda, commented that “At first, the core members were just from the punk/hardcore community. Now, there are a lot of people who have never listened to hardcore or punk, never gotten tattoos or worn hoodies” (Pelly 2010). At least in New York, about one-third of attendees are “recovering addicts who are looking for nontheistic but spiritual ways to deal with their demons” (Buckley 2008).

Levine has sought to create a group of peers and eschews hierarchy in ASBMS affiliated groups. As he puts the matter: “We are all in this together seeking happiness…we are all the students. Can we take the wisdom and the compassion of the Buddha’s teachings and roots and leave behind some of the other things that I see as corruptions — the dogma, the power, the patriarchy and superstition?” (Linthicum 2009).

The teachers that work at the two centers operate under a defined Code of Ethics that dictates their relationships within their environments (“Teacher Code of Ethics n.d.). The guidelines to which all of the teachers agree are adapted from those at the Spirit Rock Meditation Center in Woodacre, California (“Against The Stream Buddhist Meditation Society” n.d.).

We undertake the precept of refraining from killing.

We undertake the precept of refraining from stealing.

We undertake the precept of refraining from false speech.

We undertake the precept of refraining from sexual misconduct.

We undertake the precept of refraining from intoxicants that cause heedlessness or loss of awareness.

As the movement developed organizationally, it came to include the Against the Stream Buddhist Meditation Society, Refuge Recovery, which is a for-profit drug and alcohol treatment center, and Refugerecovery.org, which resembles a Buddhist version of Alcoholics Anonymous that has affiliated chapters and meetings across the U.S.  AA-like nonprofit program based on Buddhist principles with chapters and meetings across the country, where he’s the president. Levine is president of Refugerecovery.org. ASBMS was developed as a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization, and it relies on donations (dana) and class fees for operating costs (Pelly 2010). 

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

ASBMS initially met little external opposition. Within the Buddhist tradition, however, New Buddhism has not been enthusiastically embraced by more traditional elements of the Buddhist community. And Levine, given his personal style, has both admirers and detractors (Jones 2007). As Kremar (2014) has noted with regard to his books, “I read the very polarized reviews of his first book on Amazon, which made him out to be the real deal or a fraud—there was no in-between.”

As the movement developed initially, the greatest internal challenge that ASBMS faced was expansion of both locations and services within the constraints of dana. As is planned new facilities, it relied on gifts to support the building projects and supplement ongoing operating costs (Pelly 2010).

The preceding text describes the developmental history of Against the Stream until 2018. However, its fortunes and those of its founder shifted dramatically in March 2018 when allegations of sexual misconduct were made against Levine. An investigation was launched, and an independent attorney was retained to conduct the investigation. Pending a completion of the investigation, Levine’s teaching privileges and participation on the Board of Directors were suspended. In August a report was issued by the Against the Stream Board of Directors and attorney that concluded that, while there were no formal complaints filed against Levine, the evidence indicated that Levine probably had violated the Teachers’ Code of Ethics prohibited teachers creating sexual harm. Levine was then removed from the Board of Directors and several centers were closed. Levine strongly denied the allegations. Evidence gathered subsequent to the investigation created additional doubt concerning Levine’s denials (Abrahams 2018; Merlan 2018; Elder 2019).

The accusations of sexual misconduct against Levine have created ongoing tension between defenders and accusers. Beyond the questions of responsibility and  accountability is the issue of how the behaviors at issue were undisclosed for an extended period. The most plausible answer is that Levine was the son of respected Western Buddhist icon Stephen Levine and had been mentored by Spirit Rock’s Jack Kornfield, he developed an outsized presence among American Buddhist teachers, his work was central to the formation of Against the Stream, he held major leadership positions in Against the Stream and  and Refuge Recovery, he trained organizational trainers and facilitators, there were both financial and reputational implications of his continued presence in the organizations, and his personal successes in working with clients who report that he turned their lives around created an impressive personal aura around him. As one observer succinctly summarized this combination of factors, “He’s like the banks: he’s too big to fail” (Merlan 2018).

In the aftermath of the sex abuse allegations, there were a variety of  adjustments. Some ATSBMC centers closed, others went independent, and others changed their names. Refuge Recovery announced his expulsion, and Spirit Rock revoked his authorization to teach. Levine has continued to teach through Refuge Recovery.org, which has offered a stout defense of his teachings and of his response to the allegations made against him (Souhrada, Savage, and Smith n.d.).

IMAGE
Image #1: Noah Levine. Credit: Fountain Posters.

REFERENCES

Abrahams, Matthew. 2018. . “Leaked Against the Stream Report Challenges Previous Accounts.” Tricycle: The Buddhist Review, November 1. Accessed from
https://tricycle.org/article/leaked-against-the-stream-report/ on 11 November 2025.

Against the Stream Buddhist Meditation Society. n.d. Dharma Punx Book. Accessed from https://www.againstthestream.com/dharma-punx-merch/dharma-punx-book on 11 November 2025.

Buckley, Cara. 2008. A Place to Mellow Out, Without Losing Your Edge.” New York Times, December 12. Accessed from http://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/13/nyregion/13metjournal.html?_r=0 on 15 August 2014.

“Dana.” n.d. Against the Stream Buddhist Meditation Society. Accessed from http://www.againstthestream.org/ on 24 June 2014.

“Dharma Punx.” 2014. Accessed from http://www.dharmapunx.com/ on 15 August 2014.

Elder, Sean. 2019. “Noah Levine Blames the #MeToo Movement for the Demise of His Punk Rock Buddhism Empire.” Los Angeles Magazine, July 10. Accessed from https://lamag.com/crimeinla/noah-levine-buddhism-me-too/ on 11 November 2025.

Fiscella, Anthony. 2012. “From Muslim Punks to Taqwacore: An Incomplete History of Punk Islam.” Contemporary Islam 6:255–81.

Jones, Charles. 2007. “Marketing Buddhism in the United States of American: Elite Buddhism and the Formation of Religious Pluralism.” Comparative Studies of South Asia, Africa and the Middle East 27:214-21.

Kremar, Stephan. 2014. “The Buddhist Punk Reforming Drug Rehab.” The Daily Beast, June 16. Accessed from http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2014/06/16/the-buddhist-punk-reforming-drug-rehab.html on 24 June 2014.

Levine, Noah. 2014. Refuge Recovery: A Buddhist Path to Recovering from Addiction. New York: HarperOne.

Levine, Noah. 2007. Against the Stream: A Buddhist Manual for Spiritual Revolutionaries. New York: HarperOne.

Levine, Noah. 2004. Dharma Punx. New York: HarperOne.

Linthicum, Kate. 2009. “In the Stillness, Place For a Rebellious Spirit.” LA Times. Accessed from http://articles.latimes.com/2009/may/04/local/me-beliefs4 on 24 June 2014.

Mageary, Joe. 2012. “Rise Above/We’re Gonna Rise Above: A Qualitative Inquiry into the Use of Hardcore Punk Culture as Context for the Development of Preferred Identities.” Ph.D. Dissertation. San Francisco: California Institute for Integral Studies.

Merlan, Anna. 2018. “A Murky Scandal Involving a Powerful Punk Rock Dharma Teacher Is Dividing a Major Buddhist Community.” Jezebel, August 14. Accessed from https://www.jezebel.com/a-murky-scandal-involving-a-powerful-punk-rock-dharma-t-1827742746

Milenković, Dario. 2007. “The Subcultural Group of Hardcore Punk: Sociological Research of the Group Members’ Social Origin and Their Attitudes to Nation, Religion and the Consumer Society Values.” Philosophy, Sociology and Psychology 6:67 – 80.

“Mind Body Awareness Project.” n.d. Accessed from http://www.mbaproject.org/ on 24 June 2014.

Pelly, Jenn. 2010. “A Fusion of Buddhism and Punk Rock” The Local East Village. Accessed from http://eastvillage.thelocal.nytimes.com/2010/11/15/a-fusion-of-buddhism-and-punk-rock/ on 24 June 2014.

Preston, Mark W. 2009. “The Myth of the Elephant: American Buddhist Identity and Buddho-Punk Bricolage.” Over Dinner: The Laurier M.A. Journal of Religion and Culture 1:152-69.

“Refuge Recovery- A Buddhism Based Program for Overcoming Addiction with Noah Levine” 2012. Buddhist News. Accessed from http://enews.buddhistdoor.com/en/news/d/35284 on 24 June 2014.

Smith, Bardwell. 1968. “Toward a Buddhist Anthropology: The Problem of the Secular.” Journal of the American Academy of Religion 36:203-16.

Souhrada, Joseph, Rachael Savage, and Russell Smith. n.d. REFUGE RECOVERY FOUNDER NOAH LEVINE. Accessed from https://www.refugerecovery.org/news/founder-noah-levine on 11 November 2025.

Stewart, Francis. 2012. “Beyond Krishnacore: Straight Edge Punk and Implicit Religion.” Implicit Religion 15:259-88.

Stewart, Francis. 2011. Punk Rock Is My Religion: An Exploration of Straight Edge Punk as a Surrogate of Religion. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Stirling.

Swick, David. 2010. “Dharma Punx.” Shambhala Sun, May. Accessed from
http://www.shambhalasun.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=3522 on 15 August 2014.

“Teacher Code of Ethics,” n.d. Against the Stream Buddhist Meditation Society. Accessed from http://www.againstthestream.org on 24 June 2014.

Publication Date:
20 June 2014
Update:
11 November 2025 by David Bromley

 

 

Share