Burning Man

BURNING MAN TIMELINE

1977:  The Suicide Club was founded by Gary Warne in San Francisco.

1982:  The Suicide Club disbanded.

1986:  The Cacophony Society was founded in San Francisco by former members of the Suicide Club, including John Law.

1986:  Larry Harvey and Jerry James constructed an eight-foot high humanoid wooden effigy and set it on fire with a handful of friends at Baker Beach in San Francisco.

1988:  John Law and other members of the Cacophony Society became involved in what is now an annual event called Burning Man.

1990 (June):  An estimated 800 people converged on Baker Beach for Burning Man, but the event was halted by law enforcement. In September, fewer than 100 people took the Burning Man to the Black Rock desert in Nevada for a Labor Day weekend campout.

1993:  Distinctive artistic and performative elements emerged, including the first “theme camps” and “art cars.”

1996:  John Law departed the organizing team following the aftermath of the first accidental death and other serious injuries.

1997:  Larry Harvey and a handful of close friends formed the Black Rock City LLC to manage and organize the event.

1998:  The first official regional event was Burning Flipside in Austin, Texas.

2000:  David Best created a structure called the Temple of the Mind, which led to the development of Burning Man’s annual “Temple” tradition.

2005:  Burners Without Borders formed as a volunteer response to Hurricane Katrina.

2007:  The first Burning Man Global Leadership Summit (initially named the Regional Leadership Summit) was held at Burning Man headquarters in San Francisco.

2010:  Larry Harvey announced the decision to dissolve the LLC and transition the ownership of the event to a 501(c)3 non-profit structure.

2011:  Burning Man tickets sold out for the first time, leading to scalping of event tickets.

2014:  Burning Man transitioned to becoming a non-profit. The Burning Man Project, a nonprofit organization, succeeded Black Rock City LLC, a for-profit limited liability company.

2014:  In addition to the annual Global Leadership Conference gathering in San Francisco, more than 100 European regional contacts, community leaders and regional event “leads” gathered in Berlin with Burning Man staff for the inaugural Burning Man European Leadership Summit.

2016:  The Burning Man Project bought Fly Ranch, a 3,800-acre property next to the event site, as a more permanent home for art installations and innovative projects of all kinds.

2018:  Larry Harvey died. Marian Goodell took on the leadership role going forward, and as of this writing is current CEO of the Burning Man Project.

2019:  A record 78,8500 attended Burning Man.

2020:  The Burning Man Project held its first Diversity & Radical Inclusion Town Hall.

2020-2021:  In-person Burning Man was canceled and Burning Man went virtual as the “Multiverse” due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The Multiverse was visited by an estimated 500,000 people.

2022: Burning Man returned to the Black Rock Desert with 75,069 participants..

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

In 1977, a man named Gary Warne and a handful of friends formed a group called the Suicide Club as part of San Francisco State University’s experimental “Communiversity.” Drawing loose inspiration from a cultural legacy including Dadaism, Situationism, “happenings,” the Merry Pranksters, and the Yippees, among other predecessors, the group’s activities included ironically modifying commercial billboards, scaling both the Golden Gate and Bay Bridges, infiltrating events sponsored by the Rev. Sun Myung Moon, and exploring subterranean sewers and passages. Members of the Suicide Club “agreed to get all worldly affairs in order, to enter into the world of Chaos, cacophony & dark saturnalia, to live each day as if it were the last.” (“San Francisco Suicide Club” n.d.; see also Evans, Galbraith and Law 2013) The Suicide Club disbanded by 1982, and Warne died from a heart attack in 1983. In 1986, former Suicide Club members, including a man named John Law, formed the Cacophony Society in a similar spirit. This new group declared itself to be: “a randomly gathered network of individuals united in the pursuit of experiences beyond the pale of mainstream society through subversion, pranks, art, fringe explorations and meaningless madness. You may already be a member!” (Evans, Galbraith and Law 2013; see also “You May Already Be a Member” n.d.).

Also in 1986 (and initially unrelated to either the Cacophony Society or the Suicide Club), a man named Larry Harvey and his friend Jerry James cobbled together an eight-foot high wooden effigy and burned it on Baker Beach in San Francisco on Summer Solstice eve. Harvey was born in a rural community outside of Portland, Oregon in 1948, and moved to the San Francisco Bay Area in the late 1970s. Intelligent, self-educated, and talkative, Harvey has described himself as a lifelong misfit (Brown 2005). In his young adulthood, he held a succession of odd jobs and was working as a landscape designer in the mid-1980s when he and a fellow tradesman, James, decided to construct and burn the figure that eventually evolved into the “Burning Man” (although neither of them used this term at the time, nor foresaw the elaborate desert festival that their unpremeditated event would become). Harvey later acknowledged that he had been inspired, in part, by art happenings held by an artist named Mary Graubarger at Baker Beach in the late 1970s and early 1980s, and which he had previously attended with a now ex-girlfriend (Doherty 2004:26-28). However, Harvey has repeatedly stated that neither he nor James had any preconceived meaning in mind when they first erected and burned “the Man.” Approximately twenty people attended this first “burn,” although as Harvey would tell the story in later years, their numbers swelled as the structure caught fire and curious onlookers rushed over. Someone brought a guitar, another a drum, and others began to dance with the burning effigy. Harvey would later describe this spontaneously gathered group as a “temporary community.”

Harvey and James decided to repeat the event the following year, and in 1988 they joined forces with the Cacophony Society, which began to help publicize and organize the event. The effigy had grown to 30-feet high and was now officially dubbed the Burning Man. (Image at right) The burn drew somewhere around 150-200 people. By 1990, the Man was now 40-feet, the gathered crowd had swelled to an estimated 800 participants, and the local park police determined that they could no longer burn the figure at that location. At this point, John Law and others suggested the Black Rock Desert in northwestern Nevada as an alternative location, and he, Harvey, and other core organizers determined to take the Man there to be burned a few months later over the Labor Day weekend.

Located approximately 340 miles from San Francisco, and 120 miles north of Reno, the dominant feature of the Black Rock Desert is a 400-square mile prehistoric lakebed called the playa (a vast, starkly flat, utterly empty, and intensely arid plane of cracked hardpan alkali clay). The weather there can be extreme, as temperatures in late summer typically range from below forty overnight to well over one hundred degrees Fahrenheit at midday. Fierce dust storms and white-outs can rage, with winds sometimes exceeding seventy-five miles per hour (Goin and Starrs 2005). For many Burners, the unique location itself is a central attraction and significantly shapes their experiences at the event. Graham St John argues that three natural qualities of the Black Rock Desert playa contribute to Burning Man’s aesthetic: otherworldliness, ephemerality, and limitlessness. As St John explains, the Black Rock Desert playa is both an absolutely remote place and a place that lies “in-between space and time,” creating a “quintessential ‘realm of pure possibility’” (St John 2019:292). These characteristics of the Black Rock Desert contribute to participants’ transformational spiritual experiences at the event (St John 2020).

Somewhere between eighty and one hundred intrepid adventurers made the first trek to the playa in September 1990. A prominent Cacophony Society member named Michael Mikel scratched a line across the surface of the playa and invited the gathered attendees to step across the threshold, thus symbolically initiating these first participants into the “Zone.” (The Cacophony Society had held a few other events they called “Zone Trips,” in which they took road trips into strange and exotic territories. See Beale 2007). The event proceeded to grow exponentially over the following years. In 1992, Mikel took on the moniker “Danger Ranger” and organized a group he called the “Black Rock Rangers” in order to assist participants who became lost or stuck in the vast, empty playa. The Rangers continue as a vital peacekeeping and safety resource that interfaces with the various federal, state, and local law enforcement agencies that now patrol the event.

By 1993, there were approximately 1,000 attendees, and some of the event’s distinctive artistic and performative elements began to emerge. For example, Cacophonist Peter Doty staged “Christmas Camp” by putting a plastic Christmas tree in front of his tent, dressing up as Santa Claus, and handing out gifts to other participants while singing Christmas carols, thus instigating what would become the “theme camp” tradition. Other participants began to bring other artistic and ritualistic elements to the event over time, including a contingent of creatively modified automobiles called “art cars.” The encampment eventually came to be called “Black Rock City” and grew more and more elaborate, with a roughly circular layout, designated roadways, a central café, medical services, a post office, and other civic features.

By 1996, the event had swelled to an estimated 8,000 participants, which began to strain the relatively loose infrastructure the event had developed up to that point. The first accidental death took place a few days before the event had “officially” begun, when participant Michael Fury died while riding his motorcycle (apparently drunk and without headlights) in route back to his encampment on the playa from the nearby town of Gerlach. A few days later, during the main event, two other participants were critically wounded, and one never fully recovered, after their tent was run over by another exceedingly intoxicated participant. In the aftermath of these crises, John Law wanted to stop holding future Burning Man events altogether and departed from the organizing team. He did not return to the event, although he remained a prominent figure in the Bay Area arts and alternative culture communities (Law 2013; see also Evans, Galbraith and Law 2013). Harvey and other friends, however, wanted to continue doing Burning Man and so began to develop a more tightly organized infrastructure. The event perimeter and gate became much more carefully controlled, and driving within the event site was banned, with the exception of art cars. Even these would be limited to five miles per hour and would also eventually be carefully regulated and permitted. In 1997, with a few trusted friends, Harvey formed the Black Rock City LLC as a business structure for the event.

From 1997-2007, the event grew from 10,000 to nearly 50,000 participants, and also developed many of the artistic, ritualistic, and other cultural elements that have come to characterize the event. (These features will be discussed below under Doctrines/Beliefs and Rituals.) The late 1990s were an exciting but challenging time for Burning Man, as organizers learned to manage tremendous growth and create a fiscally stable organization, while also coming to agreeable terms with local and federal governmental agencies, as well as local landowners and residents in the nearby community of Gerlach, Nevada. By the 2000s, the process of building the annual infrastructure for Black Rock City began to achieve some stability, allowing organizers to turn some of their energies outward. For example, a noteworthy moment in the event’s history occurred in 2005, when Burning Man organizers helped to support and build a volunteer response to the Hurricane Katrina Crisis on the Gulf Coast. This group, which came to be called Burners Without Borders, helped to rebuild a Vietnamese Buddhist Temple in Biloxi, Mississippi, demolished scores of damaged homes at no cost to owners, and also rebuilt a private home in Pearlington, Mississippi. This spin-off organization has continued to help organize grassroots disaster response efforts and other initiatives, including in New Jersey following Hurricane Sandy in 2012 (see “Burners Without Borders” n.d.).

Beginning in 2007 when its first annual Global Leadership Conference was held in San Francisco, Burning Man formalized the expansion of its network of events, which were spreading internationally and continued to spread through the first two decades of the twenty-first century. A project called “Burning Progeny,” based at the University of Fribourg and led by Francois Gauthier and Graham St John, brought together researchers to explore the spread of Burning Man events in Europe (Vitos et al 2022). Researchers published work on Burning Man-related events in China (Rowen 2023) and Israel (St John and Vitos 2023), among others.

In another community-building effort, extending the boundaries of Burning Man, in 2016 the Burning Man Project bought Fly Ranch, a 3,800-acre property adjacent to the event site in Nevada, in order to create a more permanent presence in the desert and a “year-round opportunity to explore the potential of the Burning Man community,” according to the Burning Man Project’s Fly Ranch website (Fly Ranch website 2024).

In 2020, Burning Man’s virtual “Multiverse” took place online after the real-life event was canceled due to COVID-19. Burning Man 2020 took place across eight virtual “Universes” on different platforms, including the virtual reality platform, Second Life, as well as through many other events organized by participants in their neighborhoods and local communities. Going against pandemic protocol, there were also unofficial “renegade burns” in the Black Rock Desert. Included in the Multiverse was a virtual version of the typical Man sculpture, that burned on Saturday night, and a Temple that burned on Sunday night, as usual. The virtual 2020 Ethereal Empyrean Temple was conceptualized by Sylvia Lisse and Renzo Verbeck and created by Jeremy Roush. Many Burners were afraid that the emotionally engaging large-scale burns of the Man and the Temple would be video game versions of these powerful events in the Black Rock Desert. However, as Caveat Magister put it in an essay for the online Burning Man Journal, “The Temple is a digital structure made of photons and imagination that we can all visit, place offerings within, and gather around together for the ceremonial burn. The building won’t be real, but the gatherings and messages and loss will be” (Magister 2020). According to the Burning Man Project and many Burners, the virtual events were successful and hundreds of thousands of people entered some part of the Multiverse (Pike 2022). According to the Temple Guardians Discord channel, the virtual Temple contained 3,141 offerings that people had put there, with a file size of 16.6 GB and the offerings were viewed 40,498 times (Pike 2022).

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

The topic of Burning Man’s doctrines and beliefs is complex. Neither participants nor organizers characterize Burning Man as a “religion,” nor do they profess any shared narratives concerning an unseen or ultimate realm. At the same time, event organizers state a desire to “produce positive spiritual change in the world,” through the experience of Burning Man (“Mission Statement” n.d.). Organizers have also developed a core ideology, encapsulated by “Ten Principles” which organizers and participants alike strive to live out through the event and its surrounding subcultures. These principles are: “radical inclusion, gifting, decommodification, radical self-reliance, radical self-expression, communal effort, civic responsibility, leaving no trace, participation, and immediacy” (Gilmore 2010:38; see also “Ten Principles” n.d.). Participants (often collectively called “Burners”) bring a wide range of distinct concepts and belief structures concerning the meaning of the event and spirituality in general. Religious studies scholar Lee Gilmore’s 2004 survey of Burning Man participants found that roughly half described their personal outlooks as “spiritual” or “spiritual but not religious,” while over a quarter described their outlooks as atheist, agnostic, or simply ambivalent (Gilmore 2010: 48-49). Despite the significant differences between these various points of view, it is likely that most of these individuals would register as “nones” in surveys such as the Pew Forum’s 2014 U.S. Religious Landscape Survey (“Pew Forum” 2014). Relatively few Burning Man participants affiliate with a specific religious tradition. In Gilmore’s survey, those who did name recognizable traditions claimed a wide range of affiliations, including both progressive and conservative forms of Christianity, secular and reconstructionist Judaisms, various strands of Buddhism and Hinduism, as well as varieties of contemporary Paganism.

To experience the event as a spiritual destination, Burners adopt a number of strategies, such as using the language of pilgrimage to describe their travel to the Black Rock Desert. They consciously construct the event as an inversion of the “default” world outside its boundaries and a sacred space away from ordinary life (Pike 2010). It also becomes a site of intensive interpretation because of its ephemerality, as Graham St John persuasively argues in “Ephemeropolis: Burning Man, Transformation, and Heterotopia” (2020). In St John’s view, Burning Man’s transitory nature is part of what makes it a powerful and transformative experience for Burners. Burners even describe the event as their “church,” “tribe,” “real home,” or “religion” (Pike 2010).

In general, Burners display a wide disparity of views as to the nature and meaning of the event itself. In Lee Gilmore’s survey, over half stated quite clearly that they viewed or experienced the event as in some way “spiritual” or “spiritual, but not religious.” What they meant by that varied a great deal, and their views were not necessarily mutually exclusive. Many described a desire for both individual and collective connections with a nebulous “something more,” and many (nearly forty percent) also acknowledged the clear yet complicated parallels between Burning Man and “religion.” But they often saw these connections as problematic, stemming in part from their own general discomfort with “religion.” Another large share (roughly fifteen percent) disavowed either “religion” or “spirituality” as legitimate frameworks for of the event and insisted that any such resemblances between Burning Man and religion were either illusory, offensive, or both. In the end, many (over forty percent) were most comfortable simply acknowledging that the event could “be whatever you want it to be,” and this outlook is indicative of the event’s malleability, as well as the extent to which it reflects deeply embedded patterns of Protestant American individualism (Gilmore 2010:57-62).

Although Burning Man is sometimes called a “pagan” event, it has never been organizationally nor theologically connected with contemporary Paganism, Wicca, or other modern “earth-based” religions. Lee Gilmore’s 2004 survey turned up fewer self-professed Pagans than she had anticipated (Gilmore 2010:49-52). However, she argued that Burning Man be understood as a “lower-case” pagan event, in that its ritualizing and artwork draws on a range of symbolic resources, often including Indigenous and polytheistic imagery. Furthermore, given the shared experience and physical intensity of camping on the Black Rock playa, combined with the event’s ritual rhythms, Burning Man affects many participants on a visceral, embodied level that is often associated with “pagan” religions. In these regards, Burning Man resonates with what Michael York has called the “root religious” aspect of Pagan religions (York 2005).

The internal diversity of opinion about Burning Man is among the driving engines of the event. As participants both debate and perform the event’s values, ideals, and rituals, its nature, meanings, and contexts continue to evolve. Rather than constituting a discrete NRM, Burning Man is instead a venue for acting out, and otherwise ritualizing, a variety of spiritual impulses often described as alternative, esoteric, new age, or “spiritual, but not religious.” In this regard, Burning Man troubles the boundaries around what can be readily designated or defined as “religion,” according to normative Western standards.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

Beginning with the semi-spontaneous inaugural events on Baker Beach in 1986, the burning of a humanoid figure has served as the event’s central, definitive rite. By 1989, the sculpture had assumed what became its characteristic appearance (with occasional minor variations) in the following years: a wooden lattice-work figure, reminiscent of a garden trellis or electrical tower, although the rite of the Burn has changed in several ways over time. In the early years, nearly all attendees participated in raising the Man to a standing position using a winch and pulley. However, since 2001 the Man has stood atop an elaborate platform (which reflects a particular annual theme) and is put in place by a crane days before most participants arrive. There is no particular liturgy or prescribed manner with which to participate in the Burn, but almost all the thousands in attendance at the event converge around the Man for this climactic event. They arrive at the burn in their most elaborate costumes, draped with flashing LED lights to make themselves visible by vehicles driving towards the Man. They ride colorfully decorated bicycles or dance atop elaborate art cars, (Image at right) playing music as they process to the Burn. The burning of the Man is preceded by an extensive fire dance performance, but most participants are too far back in the crowd to observe these activities, though costumed participants art cars festooned with lights give a sense of being part of a huge spectacle.

Other ritualistic events were held at the event from its earliest days. The “theme camp” tradition that began with Peter Doty’s 1993 Christmas Camp, contains performative and ritualistic elements that pull from a global range of cultural, artistic, and symbolic elements that inspire idiosyncratic themes (For examples, see “Theme Camps & Villages” n.d.). In 1994, artist Pepe Ozan began to sculpt ten to twenty foot-high hollow towers made of wire mesh and playa-mud that he called “lingams,” which would be stoked with wood and set on fire. Beginning in 1996, these sculptures evolved into the stages for elaborate “operas.” Scripted and rehearsed, these performances each drew on religious and spiritual themes including Dante’s Inferno, Ishtar’s Marriage and Descent, Vedic Hinduism, Vodou, and the Atlantis mythos (“Burning Man Opera” n.d.). These operas ceased to be prominent aspects of Burning Man after 2000, but the community of artists and performers that had produced them would continue to engage in a variety of collaborative endeavors, including an opera about Burning Man (called How to Survive the Apocalypse ) that was staged in San Francisco in 2009, Los Angeles in 2011, and Las Vegas in 2012 (“How to Survive the Apocalypse” n.d.).

Since 2001, a second central ritual around what became known as “The Temple” emerged. (Image at right) These Temples are ornate and large temporary structures in which participants are invited to leave inscriptions and small objects for their beloved dead, as well as other messages concerning burdens from which participants wish to free themselves. Each year, the Temple is burned on Sunday night, the night following the burning of the Man. The Temple tradition was founded by an artist named David Best, who transformed a structure he built for the event in 2000 (constructed out of leftover dinosaur puzzle pieces and called the “Temple of the Mind”) into a temporary memorial for a recently deceased friend. He then decided to repeat the event the following year, with a much larger structure called the “Temple of Tears.” Organized by various artists, including Best, every year since, the Temples have become an integral and much beloved feature of the event. In a stark contrast to the atmosphere on the night that the Man burns, the Temple burns tend to be observed with silence and solemnity. (Pike 2001, 2005, 2010, 2011)

In addition to these large-scale examples, numerous smaller rituals and ritual-like activities take place at Burning Man. In any given year, a perusal through the list of activities and events submitted by participants include yoga classes, Kabbalah classes, Reiki attunement, Vipassana, Zen and other mediation sessions, contemporary Pagan and ceremonial magick rites, Balinese kechack, and sundown Shabbat services (among numerous more clearly “secular” types of events). Lee Gilmore met conservative evangelical Christians distributing bottles of water as a “gesture of prophetic witness” from a theme camp designed to represent the biblical Ein Gedi oasis. She also once sought out the leader of the “Black Rock City JCC” theme camp, who would not let her tape-record their Saturday morning interview in observance of Sabbath requirements. Burning Man has also hosted numerous performances by New York performance artist and social justice activist Reverend Billy and his Church of Stop Shopping (also sometimes known as the Church of Life After Shopping, and the Church of Earth-a-lujuah) (Talen and D. 2010; see “Church of Stop Shopping” n.d.).

Finally, to a limited extent, Burning Man is shaped by a series of annual themes, such as Beyond Belief (2002), The Green Man (2007), Rites of Passage (2011), and Cargo Cult (2013), Radical Ritual (2017), and Metamorphoses (2019) to name just a few. These provide a degree of thematic coherence for the artworks, performances, theme camps, and rituals developed for the event by participants. Finally, there is also a sense in which the entire event can be viewed as a ritual of pilgrimage, as mentioned earlier, with attendant preparations and austerities, travel to a remote and marginal site, threshold crossing, communal activities, culminating rites, and transformative reintegration back into normative, day-to-day society (Gilmore 2010; Pike 2010).

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

In the early 1990s, Burning Man was owned via a legal partnership between Larry Harvey, John Law, and Michael Mikel that was informally called “the Temple of the Three Guys,” and the event itself was organized primarily by those three, with varying degrees of assistance from and collaboration with a variety of other friends and volunteers. Starting in 1996, Larry Harvey formed a Limited Liability Corporation through which to own and manage the event with a group of trusted friends. The first iteration was called the Burning Man LLC, though this entity would be supplanted by the Black Rock City LLC in 1997. The immense growth of the event necessitated transforming a small, loosely structured collective into a more structured organization with a Board of Directors, paid staff, and vast army of volunteers without losing the creative and participatory community the event was known for (Chen 2009).

In 2010, Harvey announced that Burning Man would begin transitioning from an LLC to a 501c(3) non-profit called The Burning Man Project (Curley 2010). In 2011, a seventeen-member board of directors for this new organization was formed, which included the six long-time members of the LLC along with a dozen other individuals from San Francisco and the West Coast’s arts and business communities. By Larry Harvey’s death in 2018, Marian Goodell had emerged as the main spokesperson for the Burning Man Project, and as of this writing serves as its CEO. Goodell has overseen the ongoing move to make Burning Man a worldwide community of artists and innovators, ongoing and extended from Black Rock City.

As outlined briefly in the timeline above, the peak population of Black Rock City increased from under 100 participants in 1990 to nearly 80,000 in 2019. It is difficult to measure the size of the global community of Burners (that is, individuals who have at some point since the early 1990s attended the event at least once), although the number is likely in the hundreds of thousands.

Geographically, the Burning Man community is centered in the San Francisco Bay Area, although there are significant presences in numerous other U.S. cities, especially Reno, Los Angeles, and Portland, among others. In addition to these being the urban centers closest to the event location, these cities are also home to large artistic and “alternative” subcultures. Organizers have sought to foster a regional network of Burning Man participants in these and other cities, several of which organize and host Burning Man-esque events in their own area. These regional events are as far flung as Canada, the U.K., Ireland, Australia, and South Africa (“Regional Network” n.d). It is not unheard of for some participants to attend only their own regional events, but never the main event in Nevada, and still consider themselves to fully be a Burner.

According to researchers Graham St John and Botond Vitos, the nearly 80,000 participants at the Nevada Burning Man event in 2019 included 10,000 volunteers. That year the Burning Man Project itself included about 125 year-round employees and 800 seasonal employees. The Project also supported a global cultural network that included 232 volunteer regional contacts in 114 regions in 34 countries. St John and Vitos noted that “As of 2019, there were reported to be more than one hundred events holding standing as authorized affiliates of this network, the official status of which is established via a demonstrated accord with the criteria for regional events and an observance of the 10 Principles” (St John and Vitos 2023: 45). They quoted Larry Harvey’s view that “We are no longer staging an event,” stated Harvey after a decade in the desert, “we’re coordinating a global community” (St John and Vitos 2023: 45).

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

The primary issues and challenges faced by Burning Man stem from the event’s rapid growth, related issues concerning financing and commercialization, and broader community disputes about the meaning and nature of the event. Burning Man organizers have long espoused decommodification as one of their Ten Principles, saying: “our community seeks to create social environments that are unmediated by commercial sponsorships, transactions, or advertising. We stand ready to protect our culture from such exploitation. We resist the substitution of consumption for participatory experience” (“Ten Principles” n.d.). Accusations of Burning Man’s having “sold out” have been an issue since at least the mid-1990s, when the first annual theme (The Inferno in 1996) proposed an imagined and satirical take-over of Burning Man by a satanic multinational conglomeration called “HelCo.” In response to accusations of commodification, Harvey gave a speech at the event in 1998 in which he postulated a distinction between “commerce” and “commodification” (Harvey 1998). The organization would eventually state on their website: “We have drawn a dividing line around our desert event in order to separate direct, immediate experience from the commercial world of manufactured desire. It’s not that we are against commerce, but we are against commerce without community, consumption without purpose and profit without value.” (“Marketplace” n.d.; also see Gilmore 2010). Based on this ideal, they attempt to control the commercial use of the Burning Man name, image, and logo, in order to keep others from cashing in on the Burning Man brand (Pippi 2012).

Another example of how these commitments are practiced is the fact that Burning Man has never accepted corporate sponsorship, instead relying almost exclusively on ticket sales to cover the event’s considerable production costs. These costs include the annual construction and clean-up of Black Rock City’s infrastructure, a hefty per person/per day fee charged by the BLM, insurance, payroll, emergency health and other public safety services during the event, grants for select sponsored art projects, as well as numerous other miscellaneous and administrative costs. Participants have continuously complained about the event’s expensive ticket prices, which have risen from $35 in 1995 to $575 in 2024 and an additional $150 for a vehicle pass in 2024. In an attempt to address the cost and make the event more accessible to people with lower incomes, the organization continues to make a limited number of low-income tickets available every year, by application, and tickets are often compensated for some volunteers.

Despite these efforts to stabilize the ticket sale process, and despite the fact that the organization has for many years made some tickets available to select low-income applicants at a discounted price, some participants complain that costs are exorbitantly high. The situation reflects long-simmering external and internal social class pressures within the event and its surrounding communities. On one hand, Burning Man’s cultural roots are squarely in artistic, bohemian communities. Yet since the mid-2000s, the event has increasingly attracted a wealthy, glamorous, international partying set, who can easily afford the high-ticket costs, and who travel in extravagance and luxury. There has also been a growing phenomenon of so-called “plug-and-play” camps that plan, cook, and otherwise organize camps for those willing and able to pay a high premium. And the event has long drawn numerous wealthy participants from the San Francisco Bay Area’s Silicon Valley tech sector (Turner 2009). Rank and file participants, in the meantime, have been vociferous in their dislike of these trends, as reflected in online dialogues and forums about Burning Man (for example, see “Burners.Me” 2012). Beginning in 2014 and ongoing through this writing in 2024, Burning Man organizers have responded to this issue by eliminating “convenience camping” (also called “plug-and-play” or “turnkey camping”). The Burning Man Project website lists their efforts to do so, as part of the organization’s commitment to the principle of decommodification (Burning Man Project 2024).

Burning Man has faced various other challenges and criticism concerning artistic and cultural authenticity over the years. For example, in 2004 and 2005 a group of artists who were long-time contributors to Burning Man (led by Jim Mason) formed an alliance they called “Borg2” that challenged the Burning Man organizers to increase funding for art at the event, and to democratize the way art grants were selected. Although no significant changes in Burning Man’s art grant process or policy resulted from the ensuing controversy, Borg2 demonstrated the extent to which participants are often critical of the increasingly bureaucratic entity that the Burning Man organization has become.

Although “Radical Inclusion” is one of its 10 Principles, Burning Man has been criticized for its lack of diversity and for cultural appropriation (Lucia 2020). According to the 2023 Burning Man Census (Burning Man Census website 2023) people of color still only made up 14.5 percent of attendees. In response to criticism of the event’s inaccessibility and lack of diversity for people of color, in the 2020s the Burning Man Project developed a number of initiatives, including establishing the Radical Inclusion, Diversity, and Equity Stewardship Group (R.I.D.E.), which includes staff and community members from across the Burning Man community (Burning Man Project website 2024. The Burning Man Project started regularly scheduled staff discussions and worked to elevate the voices of people of color in all its communications channels. A village and numerous theme camps focused on BIPOC communities and their allies have become more visible and prominent in the 2020s.

Relations with Indigenous people have also sometimes been tense and the organization works to address local tribes’ concerns. The event takes places on Northern Paiute ancestral lands and most Burners drive through the Pyramid Lake Paiute Tribe’s reservation on their way to the event. Traffic through the tribe’s small communities has long been an issue, as has trash, and not paying fees to visit Pyramid Lake. Tribal Chairman Phoenix noted in a 2023 interview that the organizers have tried to address the tribe’s concerns and that communication has improved over the years. Some tribal members do attend the event and Phoenix was planning to attend for the first time in 2023 (Moyer 2023). In addition to traffic and trash, a different kind of example of event organizers working with the tribe is honoring the tribe’s request that Burning Man participants refrain from placing cremated human remains in the Temple. According to an article on the Temple Guardian site, Dean Barlese, spiritual leader of the tribe, explained that they do not allow ashes to be spread at Pyramid Lake either: “We speak for Peah Deep, Mother Earth, in this matter, and she is crying tears of blood at this time. So we stand up and do our best to protect her.” The Black Rock Desert is, in Dean’s words, “within our aboriginal territory. We have a very strong cultural/spiritual tie to the area” (Temple Guardians n.d.)

Although in some ways the festival itself is not the most earth-friendly event, since participants consume a large number of resources for a short and somewhat wasteful week, organizers and participants make a concerted effort to “leave no trace” by effectively and scrupulously cleaning up the event site following each annual event. They also began purchasing carbon offsets in 2006. Burners have created a number of other sustainable practices to minimize the event’s environmental footprint, especially through Earth Guardians, a community within the larger event that promotes recycling and other initiatives to facilitate leaving no trace, such as training people how to make grey water evaporators to keep wastewater off the desert floor. In response to critiques of the event’s environmental problems from within and outside the community, in 2019 the Burning Man Project released a 2030 Environmental Sustainability Roadmap, stating its goal to turn Black Rock City into a carbon-negative and ecologically regenerative event by 2030. The plan listed three goals: “No Matter Out of Place. Handle Waste Ecologically,” such as buying less in the first place and on-site clean-up practices; “Be Regenerative. Create a net positive ecological and environmental impact”; and “Be carbon negative” (Burning Man Project 2019; Pike 2023).

All of these issues indicate the extent to which participants and observers hold conflicting views about Burning Man. For some, it is spiritual event and an opportunity to re-create themselves through ritual and community; for others, it is simply an extravagant and expensive party. Yet for many, the spiritual and hedonistic aspects of Burning Man are not necessarily mutually exclusive. Participants have found various ways to critique the organizers whenever they appear to fail to live up to Burning Man’s ideals and 10 Principles, whether concerning costs, commercialization, environmental issues, inclusivity, or artistic authenticity. In doing so, they contribute to the larger dialogue surrounding the event, and thereby shape it by refining and expanding its possibilities.

Given changes in infrastructure, the eventual retirement of key players, and Larry Harvey’s death in 2018, it remains to be seen how the event will change in the future and what further challenges might be faced. Many core participants from the 1990s have stopped attending Burning Man, in part because of the event’s growth and changes, but also because they have simply outgrown the festival or otherwise moved on in their lives. The next generation is bringing its own unique aesthetic and concerns to Burning Man, and, as of this writing, there appears to be no shortage of new participants ready to give considerable time and energy to bring this event to life every year.

IMAGES

Image #1: Burning Man. Credit: Sarah Pike.
Image #2: The playa. Credit: Sarah Pike.
Image #3: An art car and sculpture. Credit: Sarah Pike.
Image #4: The Temple. Credit: Sarah Pike.

REFERENCES

“Afterburn Reports.” n.d. Accessed from http://afterburn.burningman.com on 30 January 2014.

Beale, Scott. 2007. “Bad Day at Black Rock (Cacophony Society Zone Trip #4).” Laughing Squid Blog, January 18. Accessed from: http://laughingsquid.com/bad-day-at-black-rock-cacophony-society-zone-trip-4/ on 30 January 2014.

Bey, Hakim. 1991. T.A.Z.: The Temporary Autonomous Zone, Ontological Anarchy, Poetic Terrorism. Brooklyn, NY: Autonomedia.

“Black Rock City 2013 Population.” 2013. Burning Man Blog, September 13, 2013. Accessed from https://blog.burningman.com/2013/09/news/black-rock-city-2013-population/ on 30 January 2014.

Black Rock City Census. 2023. “Black Rock City Census 2023 Population Report.” Accessed from https://blackrockcitycensus.org/sociodemo on 25 September 2024.

Bowditch, Rachel. 2010. On the Edge of Utopia: Performance and Ritual at Burning Man. London: Seagull Books.

Bowditch, Rachel. 2007. “Temple of Tears: Revitalizing and Inventing Ritual in the Burning Man Community in Black Rock Desert, Nevada.” The Journal of Religion and Theatre 6:140-54.

Brown, Damon. 2005. Burning Man: Beyond Black Rock (Film).

Burners.Me. 2012. “Look Dahhling, A Sparkle Pony! Burning Man in Town and Country.” Burners.Me Burning Man Commentary Blog , May 3, 2012. Accessed from http://burners.me/2012/05/03/look-daaahling-a-sparkle-pony-burning-man-in-town-and-country/ on 30 January 2014.

“Burners Without Borders.” n.d. Accessed from http://www.burnerswithoutborders.org on 30 January 2014.

“Burning Man 2014 Ticket Information.” 2014. Accessed from http://tickets.burningman.com on 30 January 2014.

“Burning Man Opera.” n.d. Accessed from http://www.burningmanopera.org/ on 30 January 2014.

“Burning Man Timeline.” 2024. Accessed from http://www.burningman.com/whatisburningman/about_burningman/bm_timeline.html on 24 September 2024.

Burning Man Project. 2024. “Eliminating Convenience Camping in Black Rock City.” Accessed from https://burningman.org/event/participate/camps/cultural-direction-se.tting-decommodification/convenience-camping/ on 25 September 2024.

Burning Man Project. 2024. “Radical Inclusion, Diversity, and Equity.” Accessed from https://burningman.org/about/about-us/diversity-radical-inclusion/ on 25 September 2024.

Burning Man Project. 2019. “2030 Environmental Sustainability Roadmap.” Accessed from https://burningman.org/wp-content/uploads/BMW_Burning-Man-Project_-2030-Environmental-Sustainability-Roadmap.pdf on 12 September 2024.

Chase, Will. 2013. “Burning Man 2013 Ticket Sales.” Burning Man Blog, January 4. Accessed from https://blog.burningman.com/2013/01/news/burning-man-2013-ticket-sales/ on 30 January 2014.

Chen, Katherine. 2009. Engaging Creative Chaos: The Organization Behind the Burning Man Event. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

“Church of Stop Shopping.” n.d. Accessed from http://www.revbilly.com on 30 January 2014.

Curley, John. 2010. “The State of the Man.” Burning Man Blog , September 1, 2010. Accessed from http://blog.burningman.com/2010/09/eventshappenings/the-state-of-the-man/ on 30 January 2014.

Doherty, Brian. 2004. This is Burning Man: The Rise of a New American Underground. New York: Little, Brown and Co.

Evans, Kevin, Carrie Galbraith and John Law, eds. 2013. Tales of the San Francisco Cacophony Society. San Francisco: Last Gasp Publishing.

Fly Ranch website. 2018. Fly Ranch, Accessed from https://flyranch.burningman.org/ on 24 September 2024.

Gilmore, Lee. 2010. Theater in a Crowded Fire: Ritual and Spirituality at Burning Man. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Gilmore, Lee and Mark Van Proyen, eds. 2005. AfterBurn: Reflections on Burning Man. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press.

Goin, Peter and Paul F. Starrs. 2005. Black Rock. Reno: University of Nevada Press.

Harvey, Larry. 1991. Burning Man 1991 (Film).

Harvey, Larry. 1998. “Larry Harvey’s 1998 Speech.” Burning Man Website, September 8. Accessed from http://www.burningman.com/whatisburningman/1998/98_speech_1.html on 30 January 2014.

“How to Survive the Apocalypse.” n.d. Accessed from http://www.burningopera.com/home/ on 30 January 2014.

Jones, Steven T. 2011. The Tribes of Burning Man: How an Experimental City in the Desert is Shaping the New American Counterculture. San Francisco: Consortium of Collective Consciousness.

Kreuter, Holly, ed. 2002. Drama in the Desert: The Sights and Sounds of Burning Man. San Francisco: Raised Barn Press.

Law, John. “Who is John Law.” John Law Website. Accessed from http://johnwlaw.com/about/ on 30 January 2014.

Lucia, Amanda. 2020. White Utopias: The Religious Exoticism of Transformational Festivals. Oakland: University of California Press.

Magister, Caveat. 2020. “A Virtual Temple Made of Photons and Imagination.” Burning Man Journal. Accessed from https://journal.burningman.org/2020/07/burning-man-arts/brc-art/a-virtual-temple-made-of-photons-and-imagination/ on 2 September 2024.

“Marketplace.” n.d. Accessed from http://marketplace.burningman.com/ on 21 September 2013.

Moyer Leslie. 2023. “A Message from the Pyramid Lake Paiute Tribe to All BRC Citizens.” Accessed from https://journal.burningman.org/2023/07/black-rock-city/leaving-no-trace/pyramid-lake-paiute-tribe-message/on 25 September 2024.

“Mission Statement.” n.d. Burning Man. Accessed from http://www.burningman.com/whatisburningman/about_burningman/mission.html on 30 January 2014.

Pippi, Evil. 2012. “How Not to Burn: Commodifying Burning Man.” Burning Man Blog, May 16, 2012. Accessed from http://blog.burningman.com/2012/05/tenprinciples/how-not-to-burn-commodifying-burning-man/ on 30 January 2014.

“Pew Research Center Religious Landscape Study.” 2008. The U.S. Religious Landscape Study. Accessed from https://www.pewresearch.org/religious-landscape-study/database/ on 10 September 2024.

Pike, Sarah M. 2023. “Leaving Traces: Transformative Events and the Porosity of Humans and Environment.” Journal of Festive Studies 5:91-109.

Pike, Sarah M. 2022. “Do Avatars Weep? Ritual and Sacred Space at Virtual Burning Man.” Religion 52: 199–213.

Pike, Sarah M. 2011. “Burning Down the Temple: Religion and Irony in Black Rock City: A Report from Burning Man 2011.” Religion Dispatches, September 11. Accessed from http://www.religiondispatches.org/archive/culture/5082/burning_down_the_temple__religion_and_irony_in_black_rock_city/ on 30 January 2014.

Pike, Sarah M.  2010. “Desert Goddesses and Apocalyptic Art: Making Sacred Space at the Burning Man Festival.” Pp. 154–73 in God in the Details: American Religion in Popular Culture, Second Edition, edited by Eric Michael Mazur and Kate McCarthy. London: Routledge.

Pike, Sarah M. 2010. “Performing Grief in Formal and Informal Rituals at the Burning Man Festival,” Pp. 525-40 in Body, Performance, Agency and Experience, edited by Axel Michaels, Volume II in Ritual Dynamics and the Science of Ritual, edited by J. Weinhold and G. Samuel. Wiesbaden, Germany: Harrassowitz.

Pike, Sarah M. 2005. “No Novenas for the Dead: Ritual Action and Communal Memory at the Temple of Tears.” Pp. 195-213 in Afterburn: Reflections on Burning Man, edited by L. Gilmore and M. Van Proyen. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press.

“Regional Network.” n.d. Accessed from http://regionals.burningman.com on 30 January 2014.

Rowen, Ian. 2023. “The Capitalist Surrealism of Chinese Burning Man.” Journal of Festive Studies 5:68-90.

St John, Graham. 2020. “Ephemeropolis: Burning Man, Transformation and Heterotopia.” Journal of Festive Studies 2:289-322.

St John, Graham. 2019. “At Home in the Big Empty: Burning Man and the Playa Sublime.” Journal of the Society for the Study of Religion, Nature, and Culture 13:286–313.

St John, Graham. 2009. Technomad: Global Post-Rave Counterculture. London: Equinox Publishing.

St John, Graham and Vitos, Botond. 2023. “Burnerverse: The Borderland, Midburn, and the Global Event Culture of Burning Man.” Journal of Festive Studies 5: 41-67.

“San Francisco Suicide Club.” n.d. Accessed from http://www.suicideclub.com on 30 January 2014.

Talen, Bill and Savitri D. 2010. The Reverend Billy Project: From Rehearsal Hall to Super Mall with the Church of Life After Shopping. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.

Temple Guardians. n.d. “Paiute Tribe Asks Burning Man Participants to Respect Their Guidance on Human Remains in Temple.” Accessed from https://templeguardians.burningman.org/paiute-tribe-asks-burning-man-participants-to-respect-their-guidance-on-human-remains-in-temple/ on 25 September 2024.

“Ten Principles.” n.d. Accessed from http://www.burningman.com/whatisburningman/about_burningman/principles.html on 30 January 2014.

“Theme Camps and Villages.” n.d. Accessed from: http://www.burningman.com/themecamps/themecamps.html on 30 January 2014.

Turner, Fred. 2009. “Burning Man at Google: A Cultural Infrastructure for New Media Production.” New Media Society 11:73-94.

Vitos, Botond, St John, Graham, and Gauthier, François. 2022. “Burning Man in Europe: Burns, Culture and Transformation. Pp. 87-114 in Festival Cultures: Mapping New Fields in the Arts and Social Sciences, edited by Maria Nita and Jeremy Kidwell. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.

York, Michael. 2005. Pagan Theology: Paganism as a World Religion . New York: New York University Press.

“You may already be a member!” n.d. Accessed from http://www.cacophony.org/sample-page/ 30 January 2014.

Publication Date:
25 September 2024

 

 

 

 

 

 

Share

Creation Evidence Museum

CREATION EVIDENCE MUSEUM TIMELINE

1936 (October 21):  Carl Edward Baugh was born in Kennedy, Texas.

1955:  Baugh graduated from Abilene, Texas High School.

1959:  Baugh graduated from Baptist Bible College.

1968:  Baugh founded Calvary Heights Baptist Church in East St. Louis, Illinois.

1984:  Baugh founded the Creation Evidence Museum in Glen Rose, Texas.

1996 (February):  Baugh’s creationist views were broadcast in a one-hour NBC television special, “The Mysterious Origins of Man.”

2009:  The Creation Evidence Museum moved into a new building in its current location.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

The longstanding tensions between the scientific and biblical narratives have flared historically whenever advances in various scientific disciplines have raised questions about the empirical validity of biblical accounts of creation. For example, around the beginning of the nineteenth century, the development of Geology as a discipline, with its findings that the Earth was far more ancient than suggested by the account in Genesis, led to increased support for Gap Theory and Day-Age Theory as alternative theories for the discrepancy between geological and biblical accounts. Gap Theory posits that there was a long time-gap between the first two days of creation as chronicled in Genesis while Day-Age Theory proposes that the days of creation listed in Genesis were themselves long periods of time (thousands or even millions of years). Most recently, evolutionary creationism, which postulates that God created life and humankind while evolution constitutes an explanation for how life developed (Saletan 2014).

Beginning in the 1960s, conservative Christian groups of various kinds have mounted active opposition to evolutionary theory with creationism, in part due to the struggles over a variety of issues (e.g., science education, sex education, prayer in schools) in the public school system. One outgrowth of these struggles has been the formation of a variety of museums, research institutes, and foundations defending the biblical creation narrative (Numbers 2006; Duncan 2009). Creationist museums are found primarily in the United States, but there is a sprinkling of such museums around the world ( Simitopoulou and Xirotitis 2010). One of the more significant creationist museums in the U.S. is the Creationist Evidence Museum.

Carl Baugh, the founder of the Creation Evidence Museum, was born in Kennedy, Texas in 1936. He graduated from high school in Abilene, Texas in 1955 and then attended Baptist Bible College in Springfield, Missouri where he earned a three year Graduate of Theology degree. Following graduation, Baugh was ordained as a minister in the conservative Baptist Bible Fellowship denomination. In 1968, he founded Calvary Heights Baptist Church in East St. Louis, Illinois and then during the 1970s founded International Baptist College there (Henry 1996).

Baugh recalls having a longstanding interest in the origins of life: “”I have always been interested in answering the questions…of life origins,” Baugh says “I wanted to know who I really was. And after a period of decades of looking into this, I found that I specifically needed to know what was in the fossil record, so I came to Glen Rose” (Henry 1996). Baugh acted on this interest in 1982 when he moved to Glen Rose Texas, which is about fifty miles from Ft. Worth and near the Dinosaur Valley State Park. The park has become a tourist attraction that features dinosaur tracks in the stream bed of the Paluxy River estimated to be 113 million years old (Beets 2005). Footprints from the Paluxy site have been featured in books written from a creationist since at least the 1960s (Morris and Whitcomb 1961; Wilder-Smith 1965; Moore 2009). Baugh began his explorations around the Paluxy River in March, 1982 and within a few days reported findings of “unparalleled historic significance.” He went on to found the Creation Evidence Museum there in Glen Rose in 1984.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Contemporary creationists can be divided into “old earthers” and “young earthers.” The former postulate that science-based dating of the evolutionary process is correct but that the process itself was initiated by a Creator. The latter, the strong creationists, attempt to validate biblical dating and the biblical creation narrative. By his own account, Baugh has come to his strong creationist position gradually. He initially held both biblical and “atheistic” (evolutionist) views simultaneously. He initially was a “theistic evolutionist.” He believed that there was a God of creation who Himself created the lowest life forms and then put in place the process of evolution: “It means that there is a God superintending all the universe, but he developed man through the lower life systems in a progressive, evolutionary epoch” (Henry 1996). It was his experience excavating limestone formations along the Paluxy River that converted him into a strong creationist. In the course of his excavations, he discovered in the context of what was an ancient limestone formation (in situ) containing what he believed to be a perfect human footprint. He recalled that “It blew my mind. My explanation for my origins had been blown. If man and dinosaur had existed contemporaneously in the fossil record, that meant that the whole fossil record had to be recent in origin,” he says. “I had to examine my own philosophical posture. That was traumatic. It was exhilarating, but traumatic” (Henry 1996). Baugh subsequently authored a book, Dinosaur: Scientific Evidence that Dinosaurs and Men Walked Together in which he presented the evidence produced from his excavations (Baugh 1987).

The Creation Evidence Museum also takes on other problematic biblical accounts, such as the claim that biblical figures lived for hundreds of years and acts of divine origin (Duncan 2009:25-31). Baugh argues that before the Great Flood, Earth had a smaller and denser atmosphere, which had higher concentrations or oxygen and carbon dioxide. The electromagnetic field surrounding Earth was stronger, operating as a filter to eliminate impurities. The atmosphere was a magenta-colored protective canopy. Together these features prolonged lifespan and permitted the development of larger life-forms, both animal and human. Baugh also offers an explanation for biblical passages referring to God causing the Earth to tremble. By his account, God created “gravity waves” that stretched the “space fabric” to such an extent that distant stars exploded, sending shock waves back to Earth (Beets 2005). This same stretching of the space fabric also is used to reconcile scientific and biblical universe origin narratives in a way that resembles Gap Theory and Day-Age Theory. In this account, what occurred in deep space through space fabric stretching could have occurred over millions of years and had little to do with events on Earth.

LEADERSHIP/ORGANIZATION

The Creation Evidence Museum reflects the vision and personal mission of its founder, Carl Baugh. The museum itself has evolved over time. It originated in a small, one hundred year-old log cabin (in 1984) and then moved to a double-wide trailer (in 1993) and, most recently, to its own building (1993). The museum space remains too limited to adequately display range of artifacts necessary to support its basic premise. Baugh claims to have located and excavated 475 dinosaur footprints along with 86 human footprints. The museum features exhibits such as a painting of a baby playing alongside, a painting of Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden, a videotaped lecture titled “Creation in Symphony,” the fossil collection gathered from the Glen Rose area, and, somewhat inexplicably, a statue of legendary Dallas football coach Tom Landry.

Outside of the museum, Baugh is erecting a “hyperbaric biosphere” that is intended to replicate the pre-Flood atmosphere of Earth (strong electromagnetic field, oxygen-rich and carbon dioxide-rich atmosphere, and protective canopy) that Baugh claims permitted the growth of large life-forms within the creationist timeframe (Duncan 2009:31-35). Baugh claims to have already extended the lifespans of fruit flies three-fold and detoxified copperheads in the biosphere. The museum also sponsors research trips to Papua New Guinea in search of living pterodactyls. Baugh reports that five colleagues have spotted the flying dinosaurs, “but all the sightings were made after dark, and we were not able to capture the creatures” (Powers 2005; Moore 2009).

The nonprofit museum has struggled with financial support issues through its history. Baugh has at times drawn on family members to staff the operation, and admission rates have remained modest (Henry 1996). The museum has received support from the conservative Christian Father House Foundation, and Baugh has generated funds through speaking engagements (Father House Foundation n.d.).

In addition to the museum, Baugh has pursued his mission through personal appearances. For a time he hosted a creationism program, Creation in the 21st Century on the Trinity Broadcasting Network. During the 1990s, he also appeared on televangelist Kenneth Copeland’s television program in a series, Evidences of Creation, which featured some of Baugh’s most extreme claims and explanations ( Scaramanga 2012). In 1996, NBC broadcasted a one-hour special program, hosted by actor Charlton Heston ,”The Mysterious Origins of Man,” that featured Baugh’s claims. The NBC program drew intense opposition from mainstream scientists and skeptics. One review concluded that “Rather than being an objective documentary on human origins, or legitimate scientific debate about the subject, the show promoted many unfounded and pseudoscientific claims, presented a very misleading picture of the way science works, and largely ignored what mainstream scientists have to say on these subjects (Kuban 1996; see also Thomas 1996).

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

The Creationist Evidence Museum, like counterparts, such as The Creationist Museum in Kentucky, has generated considerable controversy. Some major sources of controversy in the Creationist Evidence Museum case have been Baugh’s educational claims and credentials and the validity of the artifacts presented to support the creationist case.

Carl Baugh’s educational credentials have been repeatedly questioned as the degrees that he claims and the institutions from which they were obtained ( California Graduate School of Theology in Los Angeles, Pacific College of Graduate Studies , College of Advanced Education) are defunct or of dubious legitimacy in the academic community. For example, the College of Advanced Education is a unit within the International Baptist College; Baugh is president of International Baptist College (Duncan 2009:44-45; Vickers 2002; Henry 1996).

Baugh has promoted his Paluxy findings as a direct challenge to evolutionist claims: “Leading evolutionary scholars have admitted that if we could prove that man and dinosaur existed contemporaneously, that would destroy the entire theory of evolution,” Baugh explains. “I have that evidence” (Henry 1996). However, the evidence presented has been contested, not only by mainstream scientists and skeptics but also by other creationists. There are a number of artifacts offered in support of creationism at the Creationist Evidence Museum, but independent investigations have rejected all of the creationist interpretations (Hastings 1988; Neyman 2014). There is a hammer of recent origin that was discovered in a limestone formation (“London Artifact”); it appears that limestone simply formed around the contemporary hammer, There is a footprint (“Burdick Print”) that appears to have been carved into the artifact. What is presented as a fossilized finger is simply an “interestingly shaped rock.”

Baugh’s most direct challenge to evolutionary theory is contemporaneous dinosaur and human footprints. In a thorough assessment of the mantracks debate, Hastings asserted: “ To conclude that there are no mantracks in Cretaceous limestone along the Paluxy River in Texas is to take no necessary ideological stand; it merely is stating matter-of-factly the results of an evidence-based scientific position. From a variety of viewpoints among the careful and probing mantrack investigators came our common scientific conclusions. That variety includes both conservative and liberal Christianity, atheistic humanism, and agnostic skepticism. Though we differed on some details of interpretation, we have come to the same or very similar overall conclusions concerning creationist mantrack claims along the Paluxy. The absence of mantracks is not necessarily a pro-evolutionary statement, although none of the research in pursuit of them does harm to modern evolutionary conclusions. Nor is it anti-creationist for the myriad of philosophical and theological positions embodying the concept of a Creator. It is, however, a devastating indictment against scientifically irresponsible claims fueled by an anti-evolutionary zeal notable among many fundamentalist Christian believers – a zeal sufficient to obscure or diminish sensitivity to the scientific irresponsibility of the claims” (Hastings 1988; see also Kuban 2010). It is also worth noting that the expansive Dinosaur Valley State Park, which is just a short distance from the Creationist Evidence Museum, has yielded thousands of dinosaur tracks along the Paluxy, but no contemporaneous human footprints ( Henry 1996; Moore 2009). It does not help Baugh’s case that there have been some admissions of deliberate fabrication of artifacts (Kennedy 2008).

Just as significantly, stiff challenges to Creation Evidence Museum claims have been mounted by other creationists. Henry (1996) summarizes their position as follows: “Baugh has misinterpreted his evidence, they say–and is, in fact, a myth himself. They say he’s fabricated his own credentials, horribly botched a major dinosaur dig, and claimed credit for archaeological discoveries he did not make. He has stretched the “evidence” to perpetuate his own version of the truth, much to the chagrin of fellow creationists.” Greg Neyman, founder of Old Earth Ministries (formerly, Answers in Creation), harshly assessed Creation Evidence Museum displays: “Creation Evidence Museum is a collection of fabricated, faked items. Items which cannot be verified, such as the iron pot, leave us with no choice but to assume these also are faked.  When presenting evidence, it is the burden of the creation science advocate to provide evidence to corroborate the authenticity of the item.  Baugh and CEM provide none whatsoever.  When considering any evidence from young earth creationist Carl Baugh, one should immediately suspect deception and deceit” (Neyman 2014).

For his part, Baugh, now at an advanced age, continues his mission and vision, undeterred by critiques and disconfirmations from a variety of sources. His mission continues to be to attempt to provide scientific legitimation for the biblical account of creation. As Duncan (2009:27) has summarized the matter, Baugh’s model “was very clearly developed from the pages of the Bible. Uniquely, however, this model is not an attempt to make the biblical account of creation “fit” with more broadly accepted scientific thought about the universe; it is, rather, an attempt to take the biblical account of creationism and adorn it with scientific-sounding rhetoric.”

REFERENCES

Baugh, Carl. 1987. Dinosaur: Scientific Evidence that Dinosaurs and Men Walked Together. Columbia, TN: Promise Publishing.

Beets, Greg. 2005. “Creationism Alive and Kicking in Glen Rose.” Austin Chronicle , August 5. Accessed from http://www.austinchronicle.com/news/2005-08-05/283058/ on 24 December 2014.

“Creation Evidence Museum.” RoadsideAmerica.com. Accessed from http://www.roadsideamerica.com/story/8196 on 24 December 2014 .

Duncan, Julie A. 2009. Faith Displayed as Science: The Role of the Creation Museum in the Modern Creationist Movement. Honors Thesis, Department of the History of Science. Cambridge: Harvard University.

Father House Foundation. n.d. Accessed from
http://fathershousefoundation.com/pages/creation-evidence-museum.php#sthash.Gh6Oi0TS.dpuf on 28 December 2014.

Hastings, Ronnie. 1988. “ The Rise and Fall of the Paluxy Mantracks.” Accessed from
http://www.asa3.org/ASA/PSCF/1988/PSCF9-88Hastings.html on 24 December 2014 .

Henry, Kaylois. 1996. “Footprints of Fantasy.” Dallas Observer, December 12. Accessed from
http://www.dallasobserver.com/1996-12-12/news/footprints-of-fantasy/full/ .

Kennedy, Bud. 2008. “Human Footprints along with Dinosaur Tracks?” Fort Worth Star-Telegram, August 10.

Kuban, Glen. 2010. “ Man Tracks? A Summary of the Paluxy “Man Track” Controversy.” Accessed from http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/paluxy/mantrack.html on 24 December 2014.

Kuban, Glen. 1996. “ A Review of NBC’s “The Mysterious Origins of Man” Accessed from http://paleo.cc/paluxy/nbc.htm on 28 December 2014.

Moore, Randy. 2009. “Reports of the National Center for Science Education: Creation Evidence Museum.” 29:34–35. Accessed from http://ncse.com/rncse/29/5/creation-evidence-museum on 27 December 2014.

Neyman, Greg. 2014. “Creation Science Rebuttals: Creation Evidence Museum Lacks Evidence!” Old Earth Ministries . Accessed from http://www.oldearth.org/rebuttal/cem/cem.htm on 24 December 2014.

Numbers, Ronald. 2006. The Creationists: From Scientific Creationism to Intelligent Design. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Powers, Ashley. 2005. “Adam, Eve and T. Rex.” Los Angeles Times, August 27. Accessed from http://articles.latimes.com/2005/aug/27/local/me-dinosaurs27 on 24 December 2014.

Saletan, William. 2014. “Creativity for Creationists.” Accessed from http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/human_nature/2014/12/evolutionary_creationism_jeff_hardin_reconciles_evangelical_christianity.html on 28 December 2014.

Scaramanga, Jonny. 2012. “Five Most Epic Creationist Fails.” Accessed from http://www.patheos.com/blogs/leavingfundamentalism/2012/07/25/five-most-epic-creationist-fails/#ixzz3NCPb3MMM on 28 December 2014.

Simitopoulou, Kally and Nikolaos Xirotitis. 2010. “ The Revival of Creationism in Cntemporary Societies: A Short Survey.” Bulletin der Schweizerischen Gesellschaft für Anthropologie 16:79–86.

Thomas, Dave. 1996. “ NBC’s Origins Show.” Skeptical Inquirer. Accessed from
http://www.csicop.org/sb/show/nbcs_origins_show/ on 28 December 2014.

Vickers, Brett. 2002. Some Questionable Creationist Credentials.” The TalkOrigins Archive. Accessed from http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/credentials.html on 24 December 2014 .

Whitcomb, John C., Jr., and Henry M. Morris. 1961. The Genesis Flood. Philadelphia: Presbyterian and Reformed.

Wilder-Smith, Arthur Ernest. 1965. Man’s Origin/Man’s Destiny: A Critical Survey of the Principles of Evolution and Christianity. Chicago: Harold Shaw.

Post Date:
30 December 2014

CREATION EVIDENCE MUSEUM VIDEO CONNECTIONS

Share

Catholic Worker Movement

CATHOLIC WORKER MOVEMENT TIMELINE

1877:  Peter Maurin was born in Oultet, France.

1897:  Dorothy Day was born in Brooklyn, New York.

1926:  Dorothy Day’s daughter, Tamar Teresa, was born.

1927:  Dorothy Day converted to Catholicism.

1932:  Dorothy Day met Peter Maurin in New York City.

1933 (May 1):  Dorothy Day and Peter Maurin began publishing The Catholic Worker newspaper in New York City.

1933:  Day and Maurin started the first “house of hospitality” in New York City, which later became known St. Joseph House (later joined by Maryhouse).

1939-1945:  The Catholic Worker ‘s circulation dropped due to the pacifist stance of Day and the other editors during World War II.

1949:  Peter Maurin’s Easy Essays were published.

1949:  Peter Maurin died at the Catholic Worker farm near Newburgh, New York.

1952:  Dorothy Day’s autobiography, The Long Loneliness, was published.

1980:  Dorothy Day died at Maryhouse Catholic Worker in New York City.

1983:  A proposal for Day’s canonization was put forth by the Claretian Missionaries.

2000:  Pope John Paul II granted Day “Servant of God” status, the first step toward canonization.

2012:  The United States Conference of Catholic Bishops formally endorsed Day’s cause for sainthood.

2014:  Over 225 Catholic Worker communities existed around the world.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

The Catholic Worker was co-founded by Dorothy Day and Peter Maurin. While Day is the better known of the two, Maurin was the elder. He was born with the name Aristide Pierre Maurin in Oultet, France in 1877, the son of French peasant farmers and one of 24 children. Born into a Catholic family, as a young man he considered religious life, joining the Christian Brothers. A creative yet quiet person inspired by French personalist philosophy, especially the work of Emmanuel Mounier, Maurin sought to live a simple and dignified life of manual labor. In 1909, he migrated to Canada and later to the U.S., working in a variety of jobs as a manual laborer, which eventually brought him to New York City.

Twenty years after Maurin’s birth in France, Dorothy Day was born in Brooklyn, New York. Her father was a journalist, and the family moved to San Francisco and Chicago as he followed the work. Raised nominally Episcopalian, Day later reported having a strong attraction to faith and God as a child despite her parents’ lack of regular religious engagement. As an adult, Day became a journalist herself, writing for socialist and anarchist newspapers in New York City. A strong supporter of workers’ rights and feminist causes, Day rubbed shoulders with radical thinkers, politicians, philosophers, and artists in the bohemian culture of NewYork City in the 1920s, counting playwright Eugene O’Neill as a close friend. During her twenties, she became pregnant and had an abortion. Later, she fell in love with a biologist named Forster Batterham, who became her common-law husband. She spent four happy years with him, during which time she became pregnant. Out of joy and gratitude for her child, she began attending mass at a Catholic church near their home in Staten Island, New York. When she voiced her desire to convert to Catholicism and to have their baby baptized, Forster, an atheist who wanted little to do with religion, urged her not to go through with it. The two ended up separating, an experience that Day later described as one of the most painful decisions of her life: choosing the Church over her love for Forster.

Following her conversion to Catholicism, Day sought a way to bring together her belief in God and her long-standing commitment to social justice. She found a marriage of these two in Catholic social teaching and in the person of Peter Maurin, who she met in New York City in 1932. Together, Maurin and Day decided, in part because of her background in journalism, to start a newspaper focused on issues of workers’ rights from a Catholic perspective. The birth of The Catholic Worker newspaper happened in the midst of the Great Depression in the United States. In addition to publishing pieces relevant to the struggles of workers, Day and Maurin also sought a way to aid poor and unemployed people in material ways, performing what is known in Catholic tradition as the “Works of Mercy:” feeding the sick, giving drink to the thirsty, housing the homeless, welcoming the stranger, visiting the prisoner, clothing the naked, and burying the dead. Their response: the house of hospitality.

Day and Maurin began inviting people in to stay at their apartments in the Lower East Side of New York City, sharing their food and offering a bed (or even a floor) to people in need. Both believed that one of the problems with bureaucratic social service agencies was their impersonalism. In contrast, Maurin was strongly influenced by French personalist philosophers, who saw the key to a “society in which it was easier to be good” as directly tied to people reaching out to each other through personal relationships and helping their brother or sister at a
personal sacrifice. Over time, their efforts grew into a group of volunteers who lived in a Lower East Side building (eventually called “St. Joseph House”) with people seeking shelter from the streets, running a daily soup line that often stretched down the block and publishing pieces in The Catholic Worker newspaper critiquing the social, spiritual, and personal crises underlying problems, such as poverty and racism. Over time, the newspaper (and the Catholic Worker community) became focused on issues of violence and militarism as well, with the group’s pacifist stance and nonviolent civil disobedience becoming more central to its existence during the Spanish Civil War, World War II, the Vietnam War, and into present time.

As the newspaper’s circulation grew and word of the house of hospitality’s work spread, the Catholic Worker community gave birth to what has become known as the Catholic Worker movement. Houses of hospitality, often with their own accompanying newspapers describing their work, began to spring up around the United States. By 1940, over thirty Catholic Worker communities were formed by local groups around the country interested in the kind of work that Day and Maurin described in their newspaper. The movement’s growth was, and has continued to be, decentralized and unorganized. No one’s permission is needed to start a Catholic Worker community, nor do incarnations of Catholic Worker vision and practice need to follow a particular set of rules or models. Indeed, Day’s anarchist past nurtured her commitment to a movement that was informed by those directly involved, which left room for spontaneity and creativity rather than authority and leadership dictating the boundaries for communities. While the de facto leaders of different communities were sometimes familiar with each other, connections between different Catholic Worker communities rarely extended beyond informal friendships.

As of 2014, over 225 Catholic Worker houses and farms exist in the United States and around the world. Some observers thought the movement would disappear following Day’s death in 1980 given her centrality as a symbolic figure for the movement as a whole. And while the movement has evolved over time, including after Day’s death, it continues to thrive in many ways. Catholic Workers in the U.S., Ireland, Germany, Mexico, and other countries serve food to the hungry and house the homeless, publish newspapers critiquing social policy and reflecting on spiritual issues, and are arrested for protesting war and militarism worldwide.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Because it is a decentralized movement, beliefs vary from Catholic Worker community to community and within communities as well. Still, many groups throughout the movement do share similar principles, the most common of which are stated in “The Aims and Means of the Catholic Worker,” published annually in The Catholic Worker newspaper. These aims and means focus on creating a society, as founder Peter Maurin said, “where it is easier for people to be good” centered in the “justice and charity of Jesus Christ.” They advocate for personalism (a focus on taking personal responsibility for changing conditions rather than reliance on the state for “impersonal charity”) as well as decentralization of societal institutions and a “green revolution” that cultivates agricultural and craft skills for self-sufficiency and meaningful labor. While these principles underlie the culture of many Catholic Worker communities, their actions tend to focus on the four practices listed in the Aims and Means: nonviolence, the works of mercy, manual labor, and voluntary poverty.

The Catholic Worker’s commitment to nonviolence has grown over the years. Dorothy Day’s pacifism took root before World War II, but it was strengthened during that period, when many people left the Worker or cancelled their subscriptions to the newspaper because of Day’s outspoken opposition to the war. These beliefs were rooted in an understanding of Jesus’ teachingand behavior in the gospels as being nonviolent (e.g., turn the other cheek) while also disrupting the status quo (e.g., when Jesus overturned the tables of the temple money lenders). During the Vietnam War, Catholic priests Philip and Daniel Berrigan (friends of the Catholic Worker) staged draft card burnings inspired by their Catholic faith. The Worker’s support of the Berrigans and similar anti-war activists solidified its reputation as a major force of nonviolent activism, opposition to war, and Catholic peace activism during a period when many young people had become disillusioned by war and violence. Increasingly, Catholic Worker communities around the country began to attract war resisters looking for communities where their views would be supported, especially if they were Catholics, since the Catholic Church’s official teachings were much more open to war and violence in certain circumstances.

The Works of Mercy (held by most in Catholic Worker tradition to be feeding the hungry, giving drink to the thirsty, clothing the naked, sheltering the homeless, caring for the sick, visiting those in prison, and burying the dead) are in some ways more central to the Catholic Worker’s beliefs, since the first house of hospitality was started in order to allow for their practice. In Christian tradition, especially Catholic tradition, the works of mercy are seen as central to the Christian life. In the twenty-fifth chapter of the gospel of Matthew, Jesus is reported as telling his followers that in order to enter the kingdom of heaven, they had to do these things for their brothers and sisters in need just as they would have done them for Jesus himself. Catholic Worker communities not only perform works of mercy, but also in encourage others to engage in similar practices. Also, these central Catholic Worker beliefs about what it means to be Christian are proclaimed in various works of art, which are often displayed in the houses as reminders of the importance of the works of mercy to Catholic Worker life.

Many Catholic Workers also believe in the importance of manual labor and voluntary poverty, though these beliefs are less central in that not all community members share these commitments. Still, most Catholic Worker communities place a premium on simplicity, living in small rooms with simple beds, eating donated food out of donated dishes, wearing donated clothes, and doing much of the work of the houses (washing dishes, mopping floors, repairing walls) themselves, regardless of whether full-time volunteers have college degrees or come from wealthy backgrounds. Most houses of hospitality are set up as places where people can work with their hands and where often well-educated, middle-class volunteers live in the same conditions as people from the street who have been invited to live in the house as guests. Belief in the importance of manual labor is rooted in the conviction that many of contemporary society’s ills are due to an alienation from the products of one’s labor as well as the belief that manual labor is good for both the body and the mind. Voluntary poverty is seen as important because it separates one from the rampant consumerism in modern capitalist societies as well as helping one to live in solidarity with the poor.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

Catholic Worker rituals are centered in the works of mercy and nonviolent protest against militarism, homelessness, and other issues facing many contemporary societies. Many communities also participate in traditional Catholic rituals, such as the mass and praying the liturgy of the hours (typically, vespers). Rituals also include intellectual endeavors such as reporting and writing as part of communities’ publication of newspapers and newsletters. Many of these rituals involve, whether intentionally or not, the act of distancing the Catholic Worker from other groups, such as the Roman Catholic Church and social service agencies (Yukich 2010).

Though each community is different, most Catholic Worker communities engage regularly in the works of mercy. Many have soup kitchens, food pantries, and/or clothing closets. Several books and articles have been written chronicling the work of the original Catholic Worker community in New York City. Many of these include details on the daily rituals of the community, which provide a sense of what Catholic Worker ritual entails. At St. Joseph House in New York City, there is a soupline Monday through Friday. Each morning, there is a volunteer assigned to make the huge pot of soup. Other volunteers show up later to butter bread and to brew pitchers of hot tea. Before the soupline begins, the volunteers all join hands and pray for God’s blessing on the community and all who will eat there that day. Then people began to file in the front door, sitting down at tables where they are served a bowl of soup by one of the volunteers. Volunteers also bring around tea and bread, serving the guests as one might be served at a restaurant. Often volunteers take a moment to sit and talk with one of the guests, especially if they see someone they know.

After the soupline ends, many of the volunteers head to their homes and jobs. Live-in volunteers then make lunch for all of the people who live in the house. The afternoon is typically a quieter time. Some volunteers accompany residents to doctor’s appointments, while someone else makes dinner for the community, which always begins at 5 PM. Someone from Maryhouse, the other New York City house of hospitality located two blocks away, comes with a grocery cart to pick up their portion of the dinner. After everyone is finished eating, the dishes must be done, tables cleaned, and floors mopped. On Tuesday nights, these rituals are followed by a Catholic mass: a priest comes to the house each week just for the occasion. On Friday nights, they are followed by open-to-the-public “Friday night meetings” on topics varying from the spirituality of St. Teresa of Avila to the prison at Guantanamo Bay.

In addition to the everyday rituals of the community, in which the works of mercy are central, many Catholic Workers are also regularly involved in acts of civil disobedience protesting war and other forms of violence. One of the most common locations for these protests is the armed forces recruiting center in Times Square. In a typical protest, activists from the Catholic Worker and similarly-minded groups take signs to the recruiting center, stand outside with the signs, and block the entrance to prohibit anyone from entering. After a certain period of time, police officers come and arrest those blocking the entrance. Usually a few activists stay behind to collect the posters and take them back to the house. After spending a short time in jail, the protestors are typically released, though they later have to appear in court. Most use the court appearances as an opportunity to share their views about the immorality and illegality of war and violence.

While these are some of the rituals common in the New York City community, since each Catholic Worker community is different, each community’s rituals differ as well. Some do not hold regular masses at their houses of hospitality. Some are not regularly involved in civil disobedience. However, most have some form of a meal shared with the homeless and other impoverished populations: if there is any ritual common to most communities, it would be this type of activity. The rituals of shared meals, shared time in jail, shared celebration of mass, and others not only enable Catholic Workers to live out their beliefs but also serve to bind them together, creating close-knit communities.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

As of 2014, there are over 225 Catholic Worker houses and farms around the world. Most of these are located in the United States, particularly in the Northeast, Midwest, and West, where a higher percentage of the general population is Catholic than in the South. Approximately twenty five communities are located in other countries, most in Western Europe though a few are in places like Central America, New Zealand, and Africa. Communities vary in size, and because of the decentralized and informal character of the movement, there is no membership list. As an example, in the New York City community, around fifteen people are full-time volunteers living in or near the houses of hospitality. Another thirty people live in the houses as guests, some long-term and some short-term, staying there until they get back on their feet. The larger local community of “friends of the house” (around fifty people at any one time) includes regular volunteers as well as people who attend Friday Night Meetings, house masses, or other community activities. In terms of wider interest and support, the community’s newspaper, The Catholic Worker, has over 20,000 subscribers around the country. The community is financed entirely through private donations from individual supporters, who might loosely be considered part of the movement due to their support of its ongoing work.

In smaller Catholic Worker communities, often a couple will start a house of hospitality, running it in their home with one or two other full-time volunteers and inviting three or four guests to stay with them. In terms of size, most communities lie somewhere in the range between the New York City community and the small, family-run community, with communities in urban areas often larger in size than those in more rural areas, where most of the Catholic Worker farms are located. Catholic Worker farms often provide rest for volunteers from urban areas as well as a place to engage in manual labor, to connect with the land, and to grow food that can be served in urban soup kitchens.

The Catholic Worker is better characterized as a movement than an organization. Catholic Workers seek to differentiate themselves from mainstream society; they also seek to challenge it through providing what they see as a better way to live. The movement is decentralized and relatively unorganized and has no official leader. While Dorothy Day was long considered the unofficial leader of the movement, since her death no single figure has arisen to fill that role. However, certain communities are often seen as particularly important or as role models for other communities. As the original community, the New York City community is often looked to as the standard-bearer by communities elsewhere. Still, some other communities consider it to be too influenced by Day’s legacy and too slow to adapt to current times, demonstrating the diversity of views regarding the Catholic Worker vision within the movement. Authority rests primarily within the local community, and each of these communities organizes that authority differently. In the New York City community, theoretically a designated person “on the house” is in charge for a fixed amount of time, after which someone else is in charge. But in practice, much authority rests on the full-time volunteers who take the majority of those house shifts, particularly volunteers who have lived in the community for a long period of time. In other communities, particularly nonprofit organizations, there is a board of directors or full-time staff members who are in charge of the community.

The Catholic Church is authoritative in the Catholic Worker movement only insofar as most of the communities see themselves as Catholic and wish to engage with the church rather than to ignore it. However, many communities openly disagree with certain Church teachings and practices, claiming that the teaching of the “primacy of conscience” gives them the right (even the duty) to dissent from teachings they believe are against the will of God. Some communities do not identify as Catholic at all, such as Haley House in Boston. Though certain communities adhere more closely to Church teachings and practices than others, the variation in the degree of adherence at times creates conflict within the movement, with some wishing to impose greater uniformity and conformity on communities in the movement.

Most Catholic Worker communities refuse 501(c)3 status and government funding because they do not want to cooperate with what they see as a corrupt, violent system. Instead, their work is supported entirely by private donations. These include cash donations from supporters as well as donations of food and clothing from local businesses and community members. As a result, communities are in theory beholden to the donors who support them. While the degree to which this is actually the case certainly varies by community, in many communities the donors in fact have little impact on decision-making. Because Catholic Workers are attracted to the community based on a commitment to shared principles, they are unlikely to shift those principles simply to makedonors happy. There is a history of this refusal to compromise within the movement. As mentioned earlier, during World War II, Dorothy Day wrote in The Catholic Worker newspaper about her unwillingness to compromise her pacifist stance on the war. Her views were very unpopular, and the paper lost thousands of subscribers (and donors) as a result. Still, Day was convinced that she was right and that God would provide for the community in other ways, and the community survived that period and other rough periods in its history.

Catholic Workers see donations as gifts from God and affirmations of their work rather than as justification for donors to influence the movement. Indeed, most people who donate to the Worker do so precisely because they want to support an anti-authoritarian group that is not beholden to any particular set of interests. In line with their personalist philosophy, community members seek to maintain good relationships with their donors, caring about them as people and showing gratitude to them for their gifts. These relationships form the basis for continuing donations, not just adherence to the same ideas and principles.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

The Catholic Worker movement has faced several challenges over time, some common to the movement as a whole and some specific to particular communities. On a broad scale, Dorothy Day’s death in 1980 left the movement a bit rudderless. Her charismatic personality and leadership had been central not only for the New York City communities but also for the Catholic Worker vision in general. Still, the movement’s decentralized and unorganized character allowed it to adjust, survive, and thrive even after the death of its co-founder and central figure. No individual has arisen to take Day’s place as an overarching inspiration for the movement as a whole, though it is not clear that this is necessarily a challenge for the movement and its future other than making it less prominent in the mainstream media.

This may become more of a problem as the Catholic Church moves forward in efforts to make Dorothy Day a saint. Because of her strong association with the Catholic Worker movement, she remains the public face of the movement and all it stands for. But as the Church moves Day toward sainthood, it has systematically downplayed certain aspect’s of Day’s life and thought while emphasizing others that were far less central to her daily work but are more in line with the Church hierarchy’s teachings. For instance, while Church discussions of Day’s life often gloss over her anarchism and pacifism, they often emphasize her regret for her abortion and her orthodox beliefs about sexuality.

Catholic Workers disagree about many things. Some believe all Catholic Worker communities should be Catholic (and, further, some think they should agree with all of the Church’s teachings), while others do not believe in these restrictions. Some maintain strict rules about the use of technology, following Day’s and Maurin’s positions on the ways in which technology was harmful in general and in particular to the poor, while others have slick websites and/or Facebook pages. Some communities refuse to apply for nonprofit (501(c)3) status, arguing that communities should practice noncooperation with the state and should avoid bureaucratization, while others see nonprofit status as a way to perform the works of mercy more effectively. These disagreements are important, but because the movement is decentralized, they rarely threaten the movement’s existence because groups are independent and often have little concrete interaction with each other, freeing each to operate as it wishes.

The movement’s largest challenges emerge not from conflicts between communities but from demographic changes within them. Many local communities were started by a single family or even one couple. While they typically grow to include larger numbers of people, those people are often more transient, with the founders remaining the glue holding the community together. As those founders age, sometimes it is difficult to know who, if anyone, will be able to run the community in the future.

The question of who will keep local communities running is important in larger and more established houses as well. As long-time community members and leaders age, they sometimes worry that not enough new people are becoming involved in the Catholic Worker to keep the houses, and the movement itself, going. In the New York City community, for instance, there are still people in the house who knew Dorothy Day when she was alive, but most of them are in their sixties or seventies or have passed away in recent years. It is possible that the Catholic Worker remained strong after Day’s death because some of her contemporaries were alive to keep her vision going. The real test may be whether these communities will survive once that era is decisively over.

The lack of young people in particular is a pressing concern in some Catholic Worker communities. In many communities, people in their twenties and thirties volunteer once or twice a week or even for several months at a time. However, some communities have difficulty finding young people committed to joining the movement for the long haul. This makes it difficult to predict what the trajectory of communities will be and whether they will have stable leadership in the future. The Catholic Worker’s strong critiques of consumerism and technology are especially challenging for young people in an age in which both are integral parts of daily life. Demographic shifts in the Catholic Church may also present a challenge to continued longevity: increasingly, committed young American Catholics come from more “traditional” Catholic families, with children of more “liberal” Catholics (and most young Catholics in general) increasingly just leaving the Church altogether (Smith et al. 2014). The pool of likely Catholic Workers may be shrinking, at least in the U.S.

In spite of these challenges, new Catholic Worker communities continue to emerge. Recently, the first Catholic Worker community in Africa started in Uganda. Perhaps more established communities will eventually close, while communities in other places, including outside of the U.S., will grow. While they may find it sad to imagine the decline of their own communities, many Catholic Workers would also acknowledge that the ebb and flow of communities is in line with the Catholic Worker vision. Dorothy Day liked to say that the Catholic Worker was like a school where students came to learn and then went away to incorporate the works of mercy into other endeavors (Riegle 2014). She believed that the movement would continue to exist as long as there was a need for it. Today, poverty, militarism, consumerism, and excesses of technology remain central issues in American society. The question is whether they are still seen as problems and whether a specifically Catholic approach to these issues still has resonance on a broad scale. As long as the answer to both of these questions is yes, the Catholic Worker movement is likely to stay vibrant, offering its simple yet prophetic response to the world’s suffering: “the only solution is love” (Day 1952:285).

REFERENCES

Aronica, Michele Teresa. 1987. Beyond Charismatic Leadership: The New York Catholic Worker Movement. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Books.

Cornell, Tom. 2014. “A Brief Introduction to the Catholic Worker Movement.” The Catholic Worker website. Accessed from http://www.catholicworker.org/historytext.cfm?Number=4 on 4 November 2014.

Coy, Patrick G. 2001. “An Experiment in Personalist Politics: The Catholic Worker Movement and Nonviolent Action.” Peace & Change 26:78–94.

Day, Dorothy. 1952. The Long Loneliness. San Francisco, CA: Harper & Row.

Forest, Jim. 2014. “Peter Maurin: Co-Founder of the Catholic Worker movement.” The Catholic Worker website. Accessed from http://www.catholicworker.org/roundtable/pmbiography.cfm on 4 November 2014.

McKanan, Dan. 2008. The Catholic Worker after Dorothy: Practicing the Works of Mercy in a New Generation. Collegeville, MN: Liturgical Press.

Murray, Harry. 1990. Do Not Neglect Hospitality: The Catholic Worker and the Homeless. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.

Riegle, Rosalie G. 2014. “The Catholic Worker Movement in 2014: An Appreciation.” The Montré al Review, August 2014. Accessed from http://www.themontrealreview.com/2009/The-Catholic-Worker-Movement.php on 4 November 2014.

Smith, Christian, Kyle Longest, Jonathan Hill, and Kari Christoffersen. 2014. Young Catholic America: Emerging Adults In, Out of, and Gone from the Church. New York: Oxford University Press.

Spickard, James V. 2005. “Ritual, Symbol, and Experience: Understanding Catholic Worker House Masses.” Sociology of Religion 66:337-57.

Thorn, William J., Phillip M. Runkel, and Susan Mountin, eds. 2001. Dorothy Day and the Catholic Worker: Centenary Essays. Milwaukee, WI: Marquette University Press.

Yukich, Grace. 2010. “Boundary Work in Inclusive Religious Communities: Constructing Identity at the New York Catholic Worker.” Sociology of Religion 71:172-96.

Zwick, Mark, and Louise Zwick. 2005. The Catholic Worker Movement: Intellectual and Spiritual Origins. Mahwah, NJ: Paulist Press.

Post Date:
9 November 2014

CATHOLIC WORKER MOVEMENT VIDEO CONNECTIONS

Share

Cult of the Dead (Naples)

CULT OF THE DEAD TIMELINE

1274:  Purgatory was formally accepted as Catholic doctrine and defined by the Church as “the place of purification through which souls pass on their way to paradise” at the second Council of Lyons.

1438-1443:  The Council of Florence added that “the suffrages of the faithful still living were efficacious in bringing [souls in purgatory] relief from such punishment…”

1563:  An additional decree concerning purgatory was passed at the Council of Trent, delineating Church-sanctioned ideas about purgatory from “those things that tend to a certain kind of curiosity or superstition, or that savor of filthy lucre”.

1476:  Pope Sixtus IV confirmed that indulgences might be earned by the living for souls in purgatory, thus shortening individual souls’ time there.

1616:  A group of Neapolitan noblemen founded the Congrega di Purgatorio ad Arco, a group dedicated to burying the poor and praying for their souls in purgatory.

1620s:  St. Robert Bellarmine taught that souls in purgatory could help the living because they are closer to God than people on Earth; however souls in purgatory cannot hear specific prayer requests.

1638:  The church of Santa Maria delle Anime del Purgatorio ad Arco was completed and consecrated. Below the church was a hypogeum which is used by the Congrega di Purgatorio ad Arco for burying the city’s poor.

1656-1658:  The Black Death, or Bubonic plague (Yersinia pestis), devastated Naples, killing roughly half of the city’s inhabitants. Of the estimated 150,000 dead, many were hastily buried in pits or existing tufa caves without markers.

1780s:  Neapolitan priest, St. Alphonsus Maria de’ Liguori of Naples, built on St. Robert Bellarmine’s teaching on purgatory. Liguori taught that God makes the prayers of the living known to souls in purgatory, which made it possible for the dead to help the living with specific matters on Earth.

1837:  Victims of a cholera epidemic in Naples were buried in the mass graves around the city, including the Fontanelle cemetery.

1872:  Father Gaetano Barbati sorted and catalogued the bones in the Fontanelle Cemetery with volunteers from the city, who prayed for the dead while they completed the work.

1940-1944:  A number of the tufa caves used as burial grounds served as bomb shelters during World War II, giving new reason for the living to pray to the souls in purgatory, who were represented by the bones buried there.

1969:  Archbishop of Naples, Corrado Ursi decreed that “expressions of cult addressed to human remains” were“ arbitrary, superstitious, and therefore inadmissible.”

1969:  The Fontanelle cemetery was closed, and the Cult of the Dead was suppressed.

1980:  The Irpinia earthquake struck Naples, closing the church of Santa Maria delle Anime del Purgatorio ad Arco, effectively suppressing remaining activities of the Cult of the Dead.

1980s (Late):  I Care Fontanelle was formed to give tours and counteract “degradation” to the Fontanelle cemetery, both the structure of the cave itself and the lingering activities of the Cult of the Dead.

1992:  The church of Santa Maria delle Anime del Purgatorio ad Arco was reopened after restoration work was completed.

2000-2004:  More restoration work at Fontanelle Cemetery took place.

2006:  The Fontenelle Cemetery was reopened on a limited basis.

2010:  The Fontenelle Cemetery was reopened full time.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

To its adherents, the Neapolitan Cult of the Dead exists as a part of the Catholic faith. In fact, adherents often do not identify their religious beliefs as anything other than Catholic or use the designation “Cult of the Dead.” However to the Catholic Church, the cult is heretical and exists outside of the faith. The core beliefs of the cult can best be understood as a mixture of Catholic doctrine concerning purgatory and pre-existing folk-religion within the former Kingdom of Naples (now Southern Italy). In this regional folk-religion, the living attempt to build personal relationships with the souls of the dead. They view these relationships as a practical way to obtain miracles and improve everyday life.

To understand how the Cult of the Dead departs from Catholic interactions with the souls of the dead, one must first understand the concept and origin of purgatory.

As Jaques Le Goff outlined in his seminal book, The Birth of Purgatory, in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, the concept of theafterlife became increasingly specific due to a number of cultural shifts. One particularly important shift was the evolution of the concept of justice; punishments for crimes began to be tailored to individual circumstances. This concept eventually extended into the afterlife and a person’s fate after death reflected the magnitude of his or her sins. This was accomplished through the conception of a third place, other than heaven and hell. It was a temporary place for punishment and atonement thought to be adjacent to hell. All souls marred by sin were believed to go there for a time that corresponded to the number and severity of an individual’s sins before being admitted into heaven. The place was called “purgatory” [Image at right is Fresco of souls in purgatory], and the concept was formally accepted as doctrine in 1274 at the second Council of Lyons.

By the fifteenth century, Catholic doctrine allowed the living to earn indulgences for the suffering souls in purgatory as they had previously earned indulgences for themselves. (An indulgence is a remission or reduction of temporal punishment for sin, earned through spiritual exercises and acts of charity.) This effectively extended the power of the pope (who granted these indulgences) from the earthly realm into the afterlife for the first time. For this reason, the concept of indulgences for the dead was quickly embraced by elite clergy members eager to expand papal power. However the laity embraced this new form of charity for the dead for entirely different reasons.

Throughout the Kingdom of Naples, popular Catholicism already operated in an unorthodox way, through a tit-for-tat system of prayers said in exchange for divine favors granted. This folk Catholicism appeared orthodox to the clergy but was heterodox inpractice. It was an individualistic, results-based style of worship that coexisted with belief in folk-magic and witchcraft, especially among the lower classes. Specific icons of the Madonna, as well as the relics of saints appeared to be venerated by the laity in the orthodox way (by praying with the icon or relic, not to it) but these prayers were, in practice, said to the icon or saint. In turn these images and objects were expected to use their supernatural powers to aid the venerator. When prayers were answered, the person who made the request would bring a token of gratitude, called an ex voto, to the shrine where the request was made [Image at right]. In orthodox Catholicism, ex votos are offered freely in thanksgiving; however, in Neapolitan folk Catholicism, these gifts establish a unique, reciprocal relationship between the individual and the tangible sacred object (the icon or relic). From this moment of reciprocity on, the relationship was expected to be mutually beneficial and could be reversed at any time should the sacred object fail to perform or the venerator fail to express appropriate gratitude.

When the Catholic Church eventually permitted prayers to be said on behalf of souls in purgatory, these reciprocal relationships, formerly limited to saints and the Virgin Mary, expanded to include the dead even though the Church remained adamant that souls in purgatory had no supernatural powers. This dissenting belief, that the souls of ordinary dead people had the power to help the living, formed the basis of the Cult of the Dead in the Kingdom of Naples. Prominent Catholic theologians and clergy such as St. Robert Bellarmine and St. Alphonsus Maria de’ Liguori attempted to expand the orthodox relationship with souls in purgatory to include addressing prayers directly to them. The hope was to include the heretical Neapolitans instead of ostracizing the faithful in a region that had historically been a stronghold for the papacy. However these measures failed to fully bring the Neapolitan concept of purgatory into orthodoxy since the logic of purgatory with its approved system of indulgences neatly meshed with the existing logic of folk Catholicism.

The impact of the Cult of the Dead on Catholicism in Italy has waxed and waned but its presence has often been most noticeable during times of strife: specifically among women affected by disease, natural disaster, or war who lack access to power and resources within the Catholic Church. Though the Cult of the Dead is present throughout the former Kingdom of Naples which encompasses much of Southern Italy today, it took a strong hold in the city of Naples due to its unique history of large-scale disasters. This is primarily where the presence of the cult can still be felt today.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

While praying for souls in purgatory exists within the Catholic Church, there are two main differences that separate the beliefs of the Cult of the Dead from those of the Church. The first is the reciprocal relationship between the dead and the living. Catholic doctrine does not allow the souls in purgatory the power to bestow favors on the living, nor does it believe they ought to be venerated as one would venerate saints or the Virgin Mary. For orthodox Catholics, the relationship between the living and souls in purgatory is strictly one-sided and charitable: prayers said by the living are intended to shorten the dead’s time in purgatory without the expectation of reward. In contrast, members of the Cult of the Dead expect the souls in purgatory to hear their prayers and affect change quickly in their lives. This added benefit explains the unique preoccupation with purgatory in Naples, from the unusually high number of confraternities devoted to caring and praying for the dead, such as the Arciconfraternita dei Bianchi and the Congrega di Purgatorio ad Arco, to the Neapolitan practice of building shrines to souls in purgatory in niches on the street, [Image at right] often complete with terra cotta figurines of people standing in flames and photos of deceased family members.

The second difference is in the distinction that the Cult of the Dead makes between the known and unknown dead. In the Catholic Church, prayers said for souls in purgatory can be specific for a person or for the souls in purgatory in general. Either is considered a charitable way to shorten time in purgatory for the intended. However the Cult of the Dead divides souls into two categories: the known dead and the unknown dead. These two groups are venerated differently and are believed to have two very different fates.

The known souls are addressed in prayer by name. Prayers said to them are thought to shorten their time in purgatory, but when it comes to the reciprocal relationship, these souls are thought to be less powerful and less likely to grant miracles to their living benefactor.

The unknown souls are more important to the Cult of the Dead, and here the cult departs dramatically from Catholic doctrine. Thecult believes that souls whose names remain unknown, typically people who died in plagues, wars, or natural disasters, are doomed to an eternity in purgatory. These souls are represented by the anonymous bones in Naples’ numerous mass graves and burial caves which have been entombed without markers. [Image at right]. Within the Cult of the Dead, these souls are collectively venerated and are thought to be extremely powerful when it comes to bestowing miracles on the living. For this reason, the dead are often commemorated collectively, through the stacking and cataloguing of their bones (as in the case of the Fontanelle Cemetery), building churches above the places they were buried (as in the cases of Santa Maria del Pianto and Santa Croce e Purgatorio al Mercato which replaced the original plague column memorial), or in the preservation of anonymous bodies within the church (as are on display at the Chiesa del Santissimo Crocifisso detta la Sciabica).

Within the cult, the relationship between living and anonymous dead must still remain reciprocal. But without the possibility of releasing a soul from purgatory, the living pray for refrisco for the unknown souls. Refrisco is thought to be a temporary relief from the fires of purgatory, like a cool drink on a hot day. This concept was illustrated in the image of the Madonna of Graces, a popular image of the Virgin Mary expelling breast milk into purgatory. Though some examples still exist, this image was successfully diminished by the Church during the Counter-Reformation due to its sensuality and association with popular but heretical views on purgatory.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

As in its beliefs, in its practices, the Cult of the Dead shares some overlap with Catholicism. These co-practices include having masses said for the dead and earning indulgences for the souls in purgatory through prayers and penance (although the concept of earning refrisco for unknown souls is strictly part of the folk view of purgatory that the Cult of the Dead embraces, rather than official Catholic doctrine).

The primary ritual associated with the Cult of the Dead that does not exist in within the Catholic Church is the adoption andveneration of anonymous human remains. This can take several forms. In the broadest sense, an entire town may adopt a mass grave site such as a prisoner’s cemetery, plague pit or potter’s field and erect a monument where people can come to pray to the souls and leave ex votos. In other instances, specific anonymous remains are adopted by a community and elevated to folk-saint status, as in the case of a mummy nicknamed “Uncle Vincent” [Image at right] in the town of Bonito.

However, this practice of adoption and veneration is most closely associated with the city of Naples and its burial caves and hypogea. This is where members of the Cult of the Dead come to adopt skulls called “pezzentelle,” which means “poor little ones” in Neapolitan dialect. Though considered heretical by the Church, this practice of petitioning a found skull can be understood as a logical outgrowth of the Catholic practice of veneration of saints’ relics.

Indeed, the more famous skulls in Naples such as “Lucia the Virgin Bride” (who rests in the hypogeum at Santa Maria delPurgatorio ad Arco), “Donna Concetta,” [Image at right] and the “The Captain” (both at the Fontanelle Cemetery) are treated like the relics of saints, in that they are considered community property and cannot be adopted by an individual. They receive prayers and thanks from many people and collect ex votos, for prayers answered, just as saints do at the shrines where their relics rest.

While these famous skulls attract the attention of devotees and tourists alike, private skull veneration is more typical within the Cult of the Dead in Naples. While not unheard of in orthodox Catholicism, private relic veneration has been frequently discouraged, fearing it would lead to idolatry or fetishism, and nearly always occurred in the context of a wealthy individual keeping the relic of a saint at home. In contrast, private relic veneration within the Cult of the Dead still happens in public, usually at an ossuary like the Fontanelle cemetery or one of the small hypogea that are still scattered around Naples, such as the one at Santa Maria delle Anime al Purgatorio ad Arco.

The process begins with the adoption. In some cases the skull is chosen by the faithful who dedicates prayers to it, lights candles,or may place a coin on it [Image at right] . In other cases, the person is adopted by a particular skull who comes to the living in a dream to ask for veneration. Communications between the living and the dead typically occur through dreams and the unnamed soul will often reveal its name to the living in this way.

In successful adoptions, the skull and its corresponding soul in purgatory enter into a reciprocal relationship with the living venerator. The living provides prayers and refrisco for the soul in purgatory, and the soul responds by seeing that the person’s prayers are answered. Adopted skulls are often said to cure infertility or other health problems, provide winning lottery numbers, or solve domestic problems. When the living receive answers to their prayers, they reward the skull with ex votos such as rosaries, flowers, or little shelters typically made of marble, glass, Plexiglas, or wood. [Image at right] These are meant not only protect the skull, but also to send the message to other favor-seekers that this skull isnot available for adoption. Skulls that do not answer prayers can be stripped of their gifts and sometimes re-abandoned in favor of a skull with a more generous soul. (Though this vengeful behavior isn’t limited to the Cult of the Dead in Naples, the bust of the city’s most famous patron saint, San Gennaro, was thrown into the sea in 1799 for traitorously granting the wishes of an occupying French general.)

Neapolitan followers of the Cult of the Dead are often thought to come with gifts for their skulls on Mondays, particularly at the Fontanelle cemetery. While this may have been true in the past when the cult was more active, contemporary evidence of the Cult of the Dead appears to show up sporadically.

LEADERSHIP/ORGANIZATION

While there are Church officials who have certainly advanced the orthodox concept of purgatory particularly in Naples, such as St. Alphonsus Maria de’ Liguori (who first theorized that God could make the specific prayer requests of the living known to the dead) and Fr. Gaetano Barbati, there is no leadership or organization specifically for the Cult of the Dead. The traditions are passed down and often turned to during times of particular strife and hardship.

Though high-ranking members of the Catholic Church have engaged with and addressed the Neapolitan Cult of the Dead, the cult itself has never had a formal structure, head, or even representative. It is simply a group of laity who often view the existing institutional structure of the Church as their own, although their practices pertaining to the cult remain at odds.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Today the Cult of the Dead is only slightly active and particularly within Naples, evidence of it is often downplayed or blamed ontourists by locals with more orthodox views. While several of the mass grave sites and confraternity burial grounds have been closed to the public entirely, sites such as the catacombs of San Gennaro and church of Santa Maria delle Anime del Purgatorio ad Arco are now primarily cultural institutions controlled by the Council of Naples. Visitors must pay an entrance fee and are restricted to guided tours to discourage participation in the cult. While this has virtually eliminated unwanted ex votos and bone theft from the catacombs and hypogea, one can still find persistent traces of the cult in the form of ex votos, letters and candles left near these sites, or in the case of Santa Maria delle Anime del Purgatorio ad Arco, near the grated window to the hypogeum on the street. [Image at right].

The main focus of cult activities today centers around the Fontanelle cemetery where there is no entry fee and tour guides are not currently mandatory. The community group, I Care Fontanelle, formed in the 1980s in an attempt to eliminate the theft and relocation of bones, as well as to discourage people from erecting new shrinesand leaving devotional items that could damage the site. Over the years, the group has also addressed ongoing structural issues with the tufa cave (most recently a cave-in that closed the cemetery for several months in 2011 and water leaks that persist today). While I Care Fontanelle’s leadership has successfully addressed these pressing issues, the ongoing lack of funds has left the lighting and video surveillance systems in disrepair. Without these safeguards, the Cult of the Dead still operates. Its adherents leave rosaries, prayer cards, candles, lottery tickets, coins, and even plastic dolls and religious figurines for specific skulls; and new housings for skulls still occasionally show up.

IMAGES

Image #1: A fresco of souls in purgatory inside the Catacombe di Dan Gaudioso Naples, Italy. Photograph taken by and used with the permission of Elizabeth Harper.
Image #2:An offering of a plant and a note outside the Church of Santa Maria delle Anime del Purgatorio ad Arco. Naples, Italy. Photograph taken by and used with the permission of Elizabeth Harper.
Image #3: A typical street shrine made to souls in purgatory. Naples, Italy. Photograph taken by and used with the permission of Elizabeth Harper.
Image #4: An alley dedicated to the “fig tree of purgatory.” Naples, Italy. Photograph taken by and used with the permission of Elizabeth Harper.
Image #5: The anonymous mummy, nicknamed “Uncle Vincent” or “Vincenzo Camuso.” He is said to be a “soul in purgatory” and was adopted by the town of Bonito, Italy. Photograph taken by and used with the permission of Elizabeth Harper.
Image #6: One of the famous, un-adoptable skulls at the Fontanelle Cemetery, donna Concetta. Naples, Italy. Photograph taken by and used with the permission of Elizabeth Harper.
Image #7: Coins placed on skulls to initiate possible adoption, along with a lottery ticket. Naples, Italy. Photograph taken by and used with the permission of Elizabeth Harper.
Image #8: A humble cardboard shelter for an adopted skull with ex votos at the Fontanelle Cemetery. Naples, Italy. Photograph taken by and used with the permission of Elizabeth Harper.
Image #9: The grated window to the hypogeum at the Church of Santa Maria delle Anime del Purgatorio ad Arco. Naples, Italy. Photograph taken by and used with the permission of Elizabeth Harper.
Image #10: A selection of recent ex votos left at the entrance of the Fontanelle Cemetery. Naples, Italy. Photograph taken by and used with the permission of Elizabeth Harper.

REFERENCES

Ariès, Philippe. 1981. The Hour of Our Death: The Classic History of Western Attitudes Toward Death Over the Last One Thousand Years. New York: Knopf.

Carroll, Michael P. 1996. Veiled Threats: The Logic of Popular Catholicism in Italy. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.

Cenzi, Ivan, and Carlo Vannini. 2015. Il Cimitero Delle Fontanelle Di Napoli: De Profundis. Translated by Sally McCorry. Modena: Logos Edizioni.

Ehlert, Rebecca Lisabeth. 2007. “S. Maria Del Pianto: Loss, Remembrance and Legacy in Seventeenth Century Naples.” Thesis. Queen’s University, Kingston, Ontario, Canada. Accessed from //Users/elizabethharper/Downloads/Ehlert_Rebecca_L_2000710_MA%20(1).pdf.

Goff, Jacques Le. 1984. The Birth of Purgatory. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Koudounaris, Paul. 2011.  THE EMPIRE OF DEATH: A Cultural History of Ossuaries and Charnel Houses. New York: Thames & Hudson.

Leeden, Michael A. 2009. “Death in Naples.”  First Things, August. Accessed from http://www.firstthings.com/article/2009/08/death-in-naples on 26 March 2016.

Maria, Lombardi Satriani Luigi, and Mariano Meligrana. 1982.  Il Ponte Di San Giacomo. Milano: Rizzoli.

Stratton, Margaret. 2010.  The Living and the Dead: The Neapolitan Cult of the Skull. Chicago: Center for American Places at Columbia College Chicago.

“Discovering the Mysteries of Naples.” 2001.  City of Naples, May 17. Edited by Giuseppe Contino. City of Naples. Accessed from http://www.comune.napoli.it/flex/cm/pages/ServeBLOB.php/L/EN/IDPagina/5645 2001 on 26 Mar. 2016.

“I Care-fontanelle.” 2015. I Care Fontanelle. N.p., n.d. Accessed from http://www.icare-fontanelle.it on 26 March 2016.

“Purgatorio Ad Arco.” N.d. Purgatorio Ad Arco. Santa Maria Delle Anime Del Purgatorio Ad Arco. Accessed from http://www.purgatorioadarco.it/ on 26 March 2016.

Post Date:
31 March 2016

 

Share

Chen Tao

CHEN TAO TIMELINE

1955 Hon-ming Chen was born in Pei-pu, Hsin-chu County, Taiwan.

1993 Chen Tao was founded in Taiwan (under the name The Soul Light Resurgence Association).

1995 Chen and about 25 of his followers emigrated from Taiwan to San Dimas, California.

1996 Chen wrote and privately published The Practical Evidence and Study of the World of God and Buddha.

1997 (March) Chen Tao headquarters moved from San Dimas, CA to Garland, Texas.

1997 Chen wrote and privately published God’s Descending in Clouds (Flying Saucers) on Earth to Save People.

1998 (March 25) Chen predicted God would be seen on Channel 18 across North America.

1998 (March 31) Chen predicted God will descend in human form at the Garland, TX headquarters.

1998 (April) Chen and a few followers travel to Lockport, NY before settling in Olcott, New York.

1999 Chen wrote and privately published The Appearing of God and Descending of the Kingdom of God –Saving Human Beings by Means of God’s Space Aircrafts.

1999 Chen Tao opened a second branch in Brooklyn, New York City.

2002 Schism occurred leading to the exile of Chen and the rebirth of Chen Tao into the Great True Way.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Born in Pei-pu, Hsin-Chu County, Taiwan on April 22, 1955, Hon-Ming Chen lost both his mother and father at an early age. Despite the loss of his parents, Chen completed grade school and went on to receive his Bachelor’s in Political Science and his Master’s in Social Science. By the age of 28, Chen worked as an associate professor for Chai-Nan Junior College of Pharmacy teaching social science from 1983 until 1993.

In 1992, Chen received a revelation from God urging him to pursue the religious life although he had considered himself to be an atheist previously (Covert 1997). After studying the Sutras, the Bible, and the Tao-Te Ching, Chen turned to the new age movement. He joined a UFO religious group in 1992 only to leave with a few other members who agreed with Chen’s claims of corrupt leadership and his disappointment with the large fees associated with the group. Chen and fellow student Tao-hung Ma then formed the Soul Light Resurgence Association (SLRA) in Taiwan (Prather 1999).

Chen wrote and privately published his first book, The Practical Evidence and Study of the World of God and Buddha in 1996. In this text Chen spoke of the “Jesus of the West” whom he claimed lived in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. Chen envisioned the “Jesus of the West’ would be six feet tall, between 27 and 30 years old, and resemble Abraham Lincoln. In an attempt to find the Canadian Christ, the group placed a personal ad in Vancouver Sun and The Province (Rogers 1998).

Believing that North America was the “Pureland of God,” Chen and 25 members of SLRA moved to San Dimas, near Las Angeles, CA in early 1997. While in San Dimas, Chen and his followers established God’s Salvation Church (Prather 1999). In March, 1997, Chen announced that the headquarters for God’s Salvation Church would relocate from San Dimas to Garland (near Houston), Texas. Chosen because Garland sounded like “Godland” (Baker 1998), a home was purchased at 3513 Ridgedale Drive. After becoming the new center for the church, followers living in San Dimas and Taiwan moved to Texas between March, 1997 and December, 1997.

While in Garland, Chen wrote and privately published God’s Descending on Clouds (Flying Saucers) to Save People. In this text, Chen prophesied God would announce his descent into the physical world by appearing on television airwaves of Channel 18 across North America at 12:01 a.m. on March 25, 1998. Furthermore, Chen prophesied that six days later, March 31, 1998, at 10:00 a.m. God would descend in human form at the Garland headquarters (Chen 1997: 74-78). This human incarnation of God would have all the physical features of Chen, but would be able to speak all languages, walk through walls, and replicate himself as many times as necessary to greet everyone (Verhoveck 1998). God’sDescending on Clouds (Flying Saucers) to Save People prophesied other significant world events to occur in both 1998 and 1999. The additional prophesies became components of the group’s belief system.

On April 1, 1998 Chen announced that he and his followers would travel to the Great Lakes area to prepare for the coming tribulation in 1999 and that by May 10 all of his followers would be gone from Garland. On the following day Chen and nine of his followers flew to Buffalo, NY and rented a minivan before travelling to Lockport, NY. Chen had had a prophetic vision in which he had seen the numbers 17 and 78. From Lockport the group travelled to Olcott, a small town on the shores of Lake Ontario (Stephens 1998), which is located at the junction of highways 17 and 78.

In May, 1998 the majority of members did leave Garland, TX on schedule. Around half of the members had visa problems and returned to Taiwan; the remaining members moved to upstate New York. While in Olcott, Chen wrote and privately published another book entitled The Appearing of God and Descending of the Kingdom of God –Saving Human Beings by Means of God’s Space Aircrafts in 1999.

A second branch of the group was opened in Brooklyn, New York City in 1999 which served as a counseling center for the surrounding community. Gathering in Central Park, Chen and his followers offered salvation to people with AIDS and cancer, having deemed the source of the diseases to be spiritual rather than physical (Wojcik 2004). By this time membership of the group had dropped to approximately thirty members.

A schism occurred within the group in 2002, and Chen was exiled from the group due to conflict between Chen and other “high-ranking members.” The schism led to a rebirth and restructuring of the group as the “ Grand True Way” (Cook 2005). According to Cook, the Grand True Way is still located in Lockport, NY and has shifted its religious ideology toward a more “ conventional Chinese Buddhist organization” (personal communication, October 10, 2011). After this time the fate of the Brooklyn office and Chen personally were unknown to those studying the group (Cook, personal communication, October 10, 2011).

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

The Chen Tao belief structure is informed by Buddhism, Taoism, UFOlogy, and Taiwanese folk religions (Baker 1998). Borrowing from Christian theology, Chen Tao also included an apocalyptic world view. According to Chen Tao, God is one in the same with the “magnetic field of Void (heaven)” and divides his spiritual light energy into separate beings, creating the origins of all life (Chen 1997:4). Transmigration, or reincarnation, gives each living being the chance to evolve into a higher life form, depending on the purity of his or her “main soul light”.

Chen Tao teaches that each living being has three souls, with the “main light soul” operating as the primary soul in conjunction with “temporal conscious soul” and the “physical soul.” The main soul light, which is the record keeper for a being’s life, is measured by its “spiritual light energy” (Chen 1997:11, 17, 19). Void is listed as having a spiritual light energy of twelve million degrees (Chen 1997:27), while divine beings (ex. Bodhisattvas and angels) have a spiritual light energy of nine million degrees. According to Chen, religious figures such as Jesus Christ and Ju-lai Buddha have a spiritual light energy commensurate with Void. Purity of the “main light soul” is obtained by following the basic principles of transmigration.

The three souls of living beings separate at death. A being with a pure main soul light, registering at nine million degrees and above, will unite its spiritual energy with the Void and consequently with God (Chen 1997:8, 18, 54). If the main soul light is not pure, the other two souls will follow the reincarnated being until the being has atoned for the sins that have accrued through previous lifetimes. This process is described as “causal retribution” and will continue indefinitely until karma is erased, leaving a pure “main soul light” (Chen 1997:62-64).

Besides the accumulation of karma, two other types of entities, “outside souls” and “devils,” impede the spiritual evolution or reincarnation of beings. Outside souls are described as malevolent, temporal, conscious and physical souls who became lost upon death of the being to which they were attached. Outside souls sustain themselves by feeding off the spiritual light energy of human beings, in addition to feeding on the spiritual air of mountains and rivers (Chen 1997:35-39).

“Devils” seek to possess beings so that they may increase the amount of unrest, evil, and violence in the world. “Heavenly devil kings” or “King Satans” are fallen angels who are described as greedy and corrupt (Chen 1997:62-64, 68). According to Chen, 47 percent of the population in Africa and Asia are possessed by King Satans (1997:70). King Satans also have been responsible for all the past great tribulations that have occurred in humankind’s existence (Chen 1997:68).

In Chen Tao doctrine, existence history has witnessed over 888,800,000 tribulations and five great tribulations. According to Chen, the first great tribulation occurred “at a place called Armageddon in the Hebrew tongue” ten million years ago. This first great tribulation was waged by dinosaurs; the remaining great tribulations resulted in battles in the area of modern day Israel. During each tribulation, beings living in the Americas were rescued by God in a flying saucer (Chen 1997:132-33).

The God of Chen Tao “includes all beings; He has the inexhaustible, endless energy, and His energy is the original source of all existence and permeates everything . . . He is omnipresent, He is both in form and non-form” (Chen 1997:3). Chen Tao’s prophet and leader Chen is viewed as one of the original divine creatures fractured from God’s spiritual light energy into the being Ju-lai Buddha. Ju-lai Buddha and several other Bodhisattvas came from Void to populate the earth (Chen 1997:8-9).

In God’s Descending in Clouds (Flying Saucers) on Earth to Save People Chen made numerous predictions of events during the 1990s. For example, Chen predicted that China would attack Taiwan either during February, 1999 or on April 22, 1999 (Chen 1997: 87,115). The February attack included a vision of simultaneous “war of unification” between North and South Korea. The April 22 attack would include a “thousand million of human-devils” who would initiate a mass slaughter in Chen Tao’s “Holy Land” of Pei-pu, Taiwan (Chen 1997:80). A second prediction was that a “Noah’s Ark” flood of 40 days would devastate Eastern Asia in June and July, 1999, resulting in food shortage that would lead Asians to commit cannibalism (Chen 1997:132-33, 87). Following the flood and fueled by widespread destruction throughout East Asia, China and Japan would join forces to invade Australia and New Zealand, eventually conquering Southeast Asia (Chen 1997:115-119). European and African nations would join the war through territorial alliances, and all the nations would finally destroy each other at Armageddon (Chen 1997:115-119), leaving only 20 percent of the world’s population alive after this final tribulation (Baker 1998).

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Chen Tao began in Taiwan as the Soul Light Resurgence Association but has used various other names through its history. Other names used by the group have included God Saves the Earth Flying Saucer Foundation, was used to describe Chen Tao prior to the failure of the two publicized prophecies, and within its own literature, the God and Buddha Salvation Foundation and The Chinese Association of Light of Soul. Once the central group moved to North America, it became the God’s Salvation Church, while still connected to followers in Taiwan.

The Soul Light Resurgence was founded under the co-leadership of Chen and Tao-hung Ma. Chen and Ma parted ways prior to Chen and his group’s emigration to the United States. Chen remained the central leader of the movement from the inception of the God’s Salvation Church until the schism within Chen Tao in 2002. Movement governance also included “high ranking” members and Richard Liu, Chen’s former chief translator, who at one point became a co-leader for the movement. After the schism in 2002, Richard Liu became the new central leader of the Grand True Way.

In both Chen Tao and the Great True way, the group organized itself geographically with members occupying multiple homes within a neighborhood or multiple apartments within the same building. Under Chen Tao, the leader’s (Chen) home served as the group’s church and religious center. Through its history Chen Tao’s membership ranged between 30 and 150. The current membership of the Grand True Way is unknown but believed to be small.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Most of the controversy surrounding Chen Tao involved sensationalized media coverage in response to the 1998 prophecies. The media, police, and public officials were immediately concerned with Chen’s March 25, 1998 and March 31, 1998 prophesies. Those prophecies were announced in the aftermath of the Heaven’s Gate mass suicide, which had occurred on March 28, 1997. Observers speculated the possibility of a mass suicide in the Chen Tao community should Chen’s prophecies go unfilled. A flurry of media activity followed the story (Bromley 1999).

In response to the media attention Chen and Richard Liu held a press conference on March 12, 1999. Issues addressed included any connections between Chen Tao and Heaven’s Gate (including possible suicide), details of Chen’s prophecies, and allegations of questionable behavior within the group (Bromley 1999). Chen denied any connection to Heaven’s Gate and any intention of mass suicide; he also allowed reporters to inspect the religious shrines and iconography inside the church (Chen’s home) in Garland (Glines and Punzet 1999).

Despite the press conference, extensive media coverage continued, and city officials in Garland planned for extensive crowd control. On Tuesday, March 24, group members prepared for God’s arrival by baptism-like rituals that included some of the male members shaving their heads (Prather 1999). However, at 12:00am on March 25 th, channel 18 showed nothing more than static (Wright and Greil 2011). Chen emerged from his home in Garland at 12:25am to reassure onlookers and media personnel who still believed in the possibility of a mass suicide. Addressing the reporters, Chen announced his intent to still lead his church. One reporter addressed the issue of the false prophecy; Chen replied that he had “never referred to…[himself] as a prophet” (Prather 1999). Additionally, Chen stated “I would highly recommend anybody not believe what I said anymore” (Bachman 1998).

Media attention continued in anticipation of the March 31 st prophecy. In an attempt to prove the transformation of himself into God, Chen stared at the sun directly for a few moments, later explaining to reporters that a mortal would have been blinded by the activity. Media officials noted that Chen appeared to be adversely affected by the demonstration as he blinked copiously afterwards. At this point Chen blamed the media coverage for disrupting the group and incorrectly conveying his religious messages. Chen then said that he would allow anyone to crucify or stone him to death for the next ten minutes in an attempt to reclaim his religious credibility (Glines and Punzet 1990). According to Prather, Chen made similar statements on other occasions, offering to accept the death penalty in the event of a failed prophecy (1999). Media coverage of Chen Tao dropped dramatically after the second failed prophecy.

REFERENCES

Bachman, Justin. 1988. “Predicted TV Showing by God Draws a Crowd.” Fort Worth Star Telegraph, March 25, A3.

Baker, Jason. 1998. “God’s Salvation Church.” Accessed from http://www.watchman.org/cults/godsalvationchurch.htm on February 3, 2005.

Bromley, G. David. 1999. “News on Chen Tao.” Accessed from http:// www.people.vcu.edu/~dbromley/god’ssalvationchurchLink.htm on February 3, 2005.

Chen. 1997. God’s Descending in Clouds (Flying Saucers) on Earth to Save People. Garland, TX: Privately published.

Chen. 1996. The Practical Evidence and Study of the World of God and Buddha. Garland, TX: Privately published.

Cook, J. Ryan. 2005. “Chen Tao.” December 2010. Accessed from http://www.anthroufo.info/un-chen.html on September 28, 2011.

Cook, J. Ryan. 2003. “Chen Tao.” Pp. 161-62 in The Encyclopedia of Cults, Sects, and New Religions, edited by James R. Lewis. Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books.

Cook, J. Ryan. 2002. “Chen Tao.” Pp. 68-70 in UFO’s and Popular Culture: An Encyclopedia of Contemporary Myth, edited by James R. Lewis. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO.

Covert, James. 1997. “Group believes God to appear here, save the world March 31.” Garland News, December 25.

Cowan, E. Douglas. 2003. “Confronting the Failed Failure: Y2K and Evangelical Eschatology in Light of the Passed Millennium.” Nova Religio: The Journal of New and Emergent Religions 7(2): 71-85.

Geier, Thomas. 1998. “Is there life after death for Heaven’s Gate? a year after mass suicides, the cult carries on.” US. News & World Report, March 30, 32.

Glines, Lina and Bernard Punzet. 1999. “Chen Tao”; Accessed from http://myweb.lmu.edu/fjust/Students/ChenTao/main.html on February 2, 2005.

Hylton, Hilary and Stephanie Low. 1998. “Lone Star Loonies. (Taiwanese UFO cult in Texas).” Time International, March 30, 41.

Perkins, Rodney and Forrest Jackson. 1998. “Spirit in the Sky: The Transmigration of Dr. Chen.” Fortean Times, April, 109.

Prather, Houston Charles. 1999. “God’s Salvation Church: Past, Present and Future.” Marburg Journal of Religion 4 (1). Accessed from http://www.unimarburg.de/religionswissenschaft/journal/mjr/prather.html on February 5, 2005.

Rogers . D. David. 1998. “TrueWay/God’s Salvation Church Defined.” Trancenet.org News, March 26. Accessed from http:// www.trancenet.org/groups/gsc/index.shtml on February 1, 2005.

Ross, Rick. 1998. “Chen Tao/God’s Salvation Church.” Accessed from http://www.rickross.com/groups/chen-tao.html on February 1, 2005.

Shaeffer, Robert. 1998. “Apocalypse foiled again; UFOlogists shoot for the moon. (Chen Tao cult’s prediction; Citizens against UFP Secrecy).” Skeptical Inquirer, September-October, 51.

Stephens, Paul. 1998. “Is God Coming to Olcott?” Lockport Journal, April 2

Verhovek, Howe Sam. 1998. “UFO cult waits for God in Texas town.” New York Times, March 5.

“Waiting for God. Oh. (Members of Taiwanese church move to Garland, Texas to witness the appearance of God).” 1998. The Economist (US), April 4, p. 29.

Wojcik, Daniel. 2004. “Chen Tao (God’s Salvation Church).” Pp. 408, 415 in New Religions: A Guide, edited by Christopher Partridge. New York: Oxford University Press.

Wright, Stuart A. and Arthur L. Greil. 2011. “Failed Prophecy and Group Demise: The Case of Chen Tao.” Pp. 153-72 in How Prophecy Lives, edited by Diana Tumminia and William Swatos. London: Brill.

Post Date:
22 October 2011

CHEN TAO VIDEO CONNECTIONS

Share

Discordianism

DISCORDIANISM TIMELINE

1932  Robert Anton Wilson was born.

1938  Kerry Wendell Thornley was born.

1941  Gregory Hill was born.

1957  Thornley and Hill had a revelation of Eris, Greek Goddess of Chaos (Latin Discordia), in a bowling alley in East Whittier, California.

1959  Thornley joined the U.S. Marines and met Lee Harvey Oswald at El Toro Marine Base near Santa Ana, California.

1963  Assassination of President John F. Kennedy in Dallas Texas, and murder of Lee Harvey Oswald by Jack Ruby two days later.

1965  Hill produced the first edition of Principia Discordia. Kerry Thornley published a novel, Oswald, and married Cara Leach.

1967  Thornley and Hill met Robert Anton (‘Bob’) Wilson.

1969  Hill founded the Joshua Norton Cabal.

1975  The Illuminatus Trilogy by Robert Shea and Robert Anton Wilson was published. Discordianism became part of Western popular culture.

1995  Discordianism established a prominent Internet presence via the World Wide Web.

1998  Kerry Thornley died.

2000  Greg Hill died.

2007  Robert Anton Wilson died.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Kerry Thornley and Greg Hill met at high school in East Whittier, California in 1956. They, and their friends Bob Newport and Bill Stephens, were enthusiastic fans of Mad magazine, science fiction, radical politics, and philosophy. In 1957, the friends were drinking in a twenty-four hour bowling alley where they allegedly had a vision of a chimpanzee that showed them the Sacred Chao, a symbol similar to the yin-yang, with pentagon in one half, and an apple captioned Kallisti (“most beautiful”) in the other half. The Sacred Chao is a symbol of Eris, the Goddess of Chaos (Discordia in Latin). Five nights later Eris herself appeared to Thornley and Hill. She told them:

I have come to tell you that you are free. Many ages ago, My consciousness left man, that he might develop himself. I return to find this development approaching completion, but hindered by fear and by misunderstanding. You have built for yourselves psychic suits of armor and clad in them, your vision is restricted, your movements are clumsy and painful, your skin is bruised, and your spirit is broiled in the sun. I am chaos. I am the substance from which your artists and scientists build rhythms. I am the spirit with which your children and clowns laugh in happy anarchy. I am chaos. I am alive and I tell you that you are free (Malaclypse the Younger 1994:2-3).

It is clear from later writings and interviews with Thornley, Hill and others that at this initial stage, Discordianism was intended as a joke, a parody of religion that exposed the deficiencies of mainstream Christianity, and the materialist and conformist culture of post-war America.

The origin and teachings of Discordianism were recorded in Principia Discordia, the first edition of which was written by Greg Hill and published (as five xeroxed copies) in 1965. Principia Discordia (also known as ‘The Magnum Opiate of Malaclypse the Younger’, subtitled How I Found Goddess and What I Did to Her When I Found Her) was an anarchic ’zine, which contained hand-drawn pictures, a jumble of typefaces, selected reproductions of “found’ documents, and instances of absurdist humor. Despite the fact that it lacked a coherent narrative or formal doctrines, the philosophy expounded in Principia Discordia was broadly consistent: Chaos is the only reality, and apparent order (the Aneristic Principle) and apparent disorder (the Eristic Principle) are merely mental constructs, created by humans to assist them to cope with reality. Humanity’s miserable existence, oppressed by convention, wage-slavery, sexual repression and a myriad other ills, results from the Curse of Greyface, discussed in the next section. Principia Discordia became a subcultural classic: it is freely available to all under what Hill and Thornley called “Kopyleft,” it is original, sharply clever, and funny (Cusack 2010:28-30).

Thornley joined the Marines in 1959, and met Lee Harvey Oswald while stationed at El Toro Marine Base near Santa Ana, California. The two men were acquainted for three months and shared many interests; Oswald influenced Thornley briefly to adopt left-wing politics (this was short-lived, and he later embraced Ayn Rand’s philosophy, Objectivism, before becoming an anarchist). When President John F. Kennedy was assassinated in Dallas, Texas in 1963, Lee Harvey Oswald was arrested for the crime, but was killed by Jack Ruby shortly after. Thornley testified about his acquaintance with Oswald to the Warren Commission in 1964, and returned to California with his girlfriend Cara Leach to edit a libertarian publication, The Innovator. Thornley and Leach married in 1965, the year his book Oswald and the first edition of Principia Discordia both appeared (Gorightly 2003:64-69).

In the 1960s, Hill and Thornley developed their religious personae, Malaclypse the Younger (Mal-2) and Omar Khayyam Ravenhurst (Lord Omar). Bob Newport was Dr. Hypocrates Magoun and Robert Anton (“Bob”) Wilson, whom Hill and Thornley met in 1967, became Mordecai the Foul. This fortuitous meeting happened a decade after the founding of Discordianism. Both Mal-2 and Omar had changed radically during that time, in part due Omar’s experience of being pursued by District Attorney Jim Garrison as a suspect in the Kennedy assassination (Gorightly 2003:57-62). In 1969, Mal-2 founded the Joshua Norton Cabal, named for homeless San Franciscan who had declared himself Emperor of the United States. This group inspired the formation of other Discordian cabals. Discordianism, already a religion of the goddess, moved in the direction of modern Paganism in 1966 when Thornley joined Kerista, a sexually experimental commune founded in the early 1960s by John “Brother Jud” Presmont. Margot Adler claimed the first use of “pagan” to describe modern nature religions was by Thornley in 1966, when he wrote, “Kerista is a religion and the mood of Kerista is one of holiness, Do not, however, look for a profusion of rituals, dogmas, doctrines and scriptures. Kerista is too sacred for that. It is more akin to the religions of the East and, also, the so-called pagan religions of the pre-Christian West. Its fount of being is the religious experience …” (Adler 1986:294).

The important Discordian theme of the conspiracy was also intensified in the late 1960s. Thornley changed his view that Oswald alone had assassinated Kennedy after meeting David Lifton, an outspoken critic of the Warren Commission. The Kennedy assassination cast a long shadow over Thornley, as Jim Garrison pursued him in an attempt to prove he was involved in Oswald’s plotting. On February 8, 1968, Thornley made a statement regarding these matters at the New Orleans District Attorney’s Office. He wrote to Hill on February 17, “I’m up to my ass in a cheap spy novel. And right now that means I am over my head” (Gorightly 2003:97). His growing paranoia manifested in Discordian activities such as “Operation Mindfuck” which he and Bob Wilson initiated in 1968. This was a “Marx Brothers version of Zen,” designed to mess with mainstream views of reality, and involved civil disobedience, culture jamming, vandalism and performance art, and other strategies (Gorightly 2003:137). The goal was the realization of guerrilla enlightenment.

Robert Anton Wilson intensified the tendency of Discordianism toward Paganisation. Wilson, a lifelong agnostic and skeptic, was nevertheless profoundly attracted to all sorts of “strange” phenomena. He was a friend of Timothy Leary, the controversial advocate of psychedelic drugs, and had interviewed the popularist Zen author Alan Watts, for The Realist, a freethought magazine. In 1975, he and speculative fiction author Robert Shea, published the vast, sprawling, epic novel, Illuminatus! Trilogy, which ushered in the next phase of the Discordian penetration of popular culture. The first twenty years had been dominated by founders Thornley and Hill, and the religion had spread primarily by word of mouth, personal contact, and ’zines, the circulation of which was limited. By 1988, Illuminatus! was the highest selling science fiction paperback in the United States; it had been made into a rock opera and won awards (LiBrizzi 2003:339). The novel has a complicated, conspiratorial plot that will be discussed below. Most importantly, Shea and Wilson reproduced much of the text of Principia Discordia throughout it, winning a huge, mainstream audience for the subcultural scripture. Knowledge of Discordianism thus ceased to be truly esoteric and rare, and entered Western popular culture.

In the late 1970s, Hill withdrew from the religion, becoming a bank employee after a painful divorce. Thornley, in collaboration with Vietnam veteran Camden Benares (born John Overton), developed Zenarchy, which he deemed “the social order arising from meditation” (Thornley 1991). He took the name Ho Chi Zen during this period. 1989 marked the commencement of the third phase of the history of Discordianism. While the Internet had existed since the late 1950s, particularly within the military, in 1989 the World Wide Web was established. Due to crossover between anarchists, gamers, musicians, artists, computer “nerds” and occultists, Discordianism made a seamless transition to the Web (Cusack 2010:44-45). In the twenty-first century the religion boasts online cabals, websites dedicated to Thornley, Hill, Wilson and other prominent Discordians, and a multitude of other related sites and information. During the fifth decade of Discordianism, from 1997 to 2007, Kerry Thornley died in 1998, Greg Hill died in 2000, and Robert Anton Wilson died in 2007.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

In the Discordian universe, Eris and her twin sister Aneris are the daughters of Void. Eris is fertile and creative, whereas Aneris is sterile and destructive. Eris ordained order, which caused the emergence of disorder (which till then escaped notice as all was chaos). Void also generated a son, Spirituality, and mandated that if Aneris tried to destroy Spirituality he would be reabsorbed into Void. This became the Discordian doctrine concerning the fate of humans; “so it shall be that non-existence shall take us back from existence and that nameless spirituality shall return to Void, like a tired child home from a very wild circus” (Malaclypse the Younger 194:58). Discordian understandings of reality are monistic, a view that is usually understood to be Eastern in origin. Discordianism asserts that binary oppositions are illusory (male/female, order/disorder, serious/humorous) and affirms the oneness of all. Discordians follow Mal-2’s position, dismissing the “truth question” and stating that everything is true, including false things. He is asked how that works, and replied, “I don’t know, man. I didn’t do it” ( Malaclypse the Younger and Omar Khayyam Ravenhurst 2006:34).

Thus it is irrelevant to Discordians whether they believe in the religion, or adopt a Discordian identity as a joke. For Discordians to be is to participate in the eternal, undifferentiated Chaos that is Eris (Cusack 2011:142).

Two other important myths are explained in Principia Discordia. First is the “Original Snub,” which focuses on Eris’ golden apple of discord, a gift to the “most beautiful.” In this myth, Eris arrived at the wedding of the sea-nymph Thetis and the hero Peleus furious as the couple had not invited her. She threw the apple and the guests rioted, as the goddesses argued over who should possess it. The apple was awarded by the Trojan prince Paris to Aphrodite the goddess of love, which was resented by her rivals Athena and Hera (Littlewood 1968:149-51). She promised Paris the most beautiful woman in the world, Helen of Sparta, which led to the Trojan War when her husband Menelaus and Agamemnon of Mycenae invaded Troy. The Discordian version of the myth has Eris “joyously partake of a hot dog” after she departs, and concludes “and so we suffer because of the Original Snub. And so a Discordian is to partake of No Hot Dog Buns. Do you believe that?” (Malaclypse the Younger 1994:17-18). The second myth is the “Curse of Greyface,” which explains humanity’s predicament, which is due a “malcontented hunchbrain,” Greyface, who in 1166 BCE taught that humor and play violated Serious Order, the true state of reality. Greyface and his followers “were known even to destroy other living beings whose ways of life differed from their own,” which resulted in humanity “suffering from a psychological and spiritual imbalance” called the Curse of Greyface (Malaclypse the Younger 1994:42). These myths teach that humanity needs liberation.

The creed of Discordianism is the Law of Fives, which states that “all things happen in fives, or are divisible by or are multiples of five … [and] the Law of Fives is never wrong” (Malaclypse the Younger 1994:16). The pentagon in the Sacred Chao is a five-sided figure, and the Law of Fives results in 23 being a number of significance for Discordians, as 2 + 3 = 5. The Pentabarf, the Discordian profession of faith (“catma,” which is flexible and provisional, as opposed to “dogma,” which is rigid and unchanging), has five principles (Malaclypse the Younger 1994:4):

I – There is no Goddess but Goddess and She is Your Goddess. There is no Erisian Movement but The Erisian Movement and it is The Erisian Movement. And every Golden Apple Corps is the beloved home of a Golden Worm.

II – A Discordian Shall Always use the Official Discordian Document Numbering System.

III – A Discordian is required to, the first Friday after his illumination, Go Off Alone & Partake Joyously of a Hot Dog; this Devotive Ceremony to Remonstrate against the popular Paganisms of the Day: of Roman Catholic Christendom (no meat on Friday), of Judaism (no meat of Pork), of Hindic Peoples (no meat of Beef), of Buddhists (no meat of animal), and of Discordians (no Hot Dog Buns).

IV – A Discordian shall Partake of No Hot Dog Buns, for Such was the Solace of Our Goddess when She was Confronted with The Original Snub.

V – A Discordian is Prohibited of Believing What he reads.

This statement of faith is playful: the first point recalls the Islamic profession of faith (shahada); the third point mocks dietary restriction; and the fifth point mandates skepticism in place of blind faith. In the case of instinct, Discordians are told to consult the pineal gland as a more reliable source of knowledge than either the brain or the heart.

One other major teaching that requires discussion is the conspiracist nature of the Discordian worldview. Principia Discordia contained references to the Illuminati, and this theme took a much greater prominence after the publication of Shea and Wilson’s Illuminatus! Trilogy (1975). The historical Bavarian Illuminati was an order founded by the scholar Adam Weishaupt (1748-1830). He, with four others, initiated the order in 1776, and numbers grew after Baron Adolf Franz Friederich Knigge, a Freemason, joined in 1780. The order was suppressed in 1784, but lives on in conspiracist circles to the present (Cusack 2010:34-35). The Illuminatus! Trilogy is described as follows by David Robertson: “[i]ts central motif is to treat all conspiracy theories as though true, and it mixes Discordianism with the John F. Kennedy assassination, the occult interests of Nazism, rock and roll music and H. P. Lovecraft’s Cthulhu mythos, into an eight hundred-page psychedelic gumbo” (Robertson 2012:429). The Illuminati, who intend to bring about the end of the world at Woodstock Europa, a rock festival to be held at Ingolstadt, are at war with the Justified Ancients of Mummu (JAMS), led by the enigmatic Hagbard Celine, head of the Legion of Dynamic Discord. The “everyman” characters, journalists George Dorn and Joe Malik, and investigators Saul Goodman and Barney Muldoon, all become part of the conflict between the Illuminati and the JAMS. At the novel’s close, Hagbard Celine is revealed to be one of the five heads of the Illuminati (along with Wolfgang, Winifred, Werner and Wilhelm Saure, members of a rock band called the American Medical Association). These four die at Woodstock Europa, when Eris appears and foils the Illuminati plot to awaken undead Nazi troops hidden in Lake Totenkopf (Shea and Wilson 1998[1975]). Celine reveals that true members of the Illuminati seek only to liberate all.

The conspiracy is crucial to Discordianism, both in due to the importance of the Illuminati and other shadowy fraternities, such as
the Assassins, but also as part of Kerry Thornley’s life in the wake of the Kennedy assassination. In the late 1970s, he descended into paranoia, believing his friends had been replaced by look-alikes and that he was living in the reality of Operation Mindfuck. A key Discordian term, fnord, which is disinformation spread by a worldwide conspiracy appears in Principia, but is amplified in meaning by Shea and Wilson, for whom the ability to “see the fnords” is a quality of the enlightened characters (Wagner 2004:68-69). Thornley’s later years were chronicled in interviews with the journalist Sondra London. These are available on YouTube, and the full text of the interviews, titled The Dreadlock Recollections, was released in 2000 (Thornley 2007). Thornley by then regarded Discordianism as essentially Zen Buddhist in nature, and it is true that its worldview is non-dualist, a monistic view of reality in which all is underscored by chaos. This view fits with many Eastern religions that are pantheist and mystical in orientation; as Principia Discordia stated, “all affirmations are true in some sense, false in some sense, meaningless in some sense, true and false in some sense, true and meaningless in some sense, false and meaningless in some sense, and true and false and meaningless in some sense” (Malaclypse the Younger 1994:39-40).

RITUALS/PRACTICES

With regard to ritual, there are only hints in Principia Discordia. To counteract the Curse of Greyface, Discordians are told to perform the ritual Turkey Curse, which summons eristic power to interrupt the Curse of Greyface, which is aneristic (anti-life). Doing the Turkey Curse involves waving your arms and chanting “GOBBLE, GOBBLE, GOBBLE, GOBBLE, GOBBLE, GOBBLE. The results will be instantly apparent” (Malaclypse the Younger and Omar Khayyam Ravenhurst 2006:175). It seems probable that dancing while making turkey noises would raise the spirits of any person who is overly serious or otherwise alienated from play (Cusack 2010:30). Other rituals in Principia Discordia include the “POEE Baptismal Rite,” which involves nudity, dancing and wine, and the “Sacred Erisian High Mass of the Krispy Kreme Kabal,” which involves doughnuts (Cusack 2011:134).

There is also one possible example of Discordian magical thinking; the “Tests by Doctors Prove it Possible to Shrink” entry, subtitled “On Occultism.” This argues that Western magicians have been too concerned with binary opposites (good/evil and male/female), while ignoring the most important polarities, order/disorder and serious/humorous, the specific area of the goddess Eris. It is then claimed:

… when magicians learn to approach philosophy as a malleable art instead of an immutable truth, and learn to appreciate the absurdity of man’s endeavours, then they will be able to persue [sic] their art with a lighter heart, and perhaps gain a clearer understanding of it, and therefore gain more effective magic. CHAOS IS ENERGY. This is an essential challenge [sic] to all basic concepts of western occult thought, and POEE is humbly pleased to offer the first major breakthrough in occultism since Solomon (Malaclypse the Younger 1994:61).

The statement that Chaos is energy relates Discordianism closely to the position of Chaos magick, an unpredictable occult paradigm developed in opposition to Western ceremonial magic by Peter Carroll, Ray Sherwin, and others in the late 1970s (Sutcliffe 1996: 127-128).

As noted above, Kerry Thornley came to the view that Discordianism was “an American form of Zen Buddhism” ( Wilson 2003:11). Therefore, Discordian humour and absurdism are ways to realize satori, the momentary enlightenment of Zen (“seeing the fnords”). Arguably, Operation Mindfuck’s handing out of cards with “There is no Friend Anywhere” and “There is no Enemy Anywhere” on either side may be interpreted as a ritual designed to bring about enlightenment, as it has similarities to the koan riddle system of monastic training found in the Rinzai school of Zen (Cusack 2010:50). As Discordianism is broadly located within Paganism, and Pagans worship deities that are personally meaningful to them, eclectic Discordian rituals are commonplace. It is worth mentioning that the Illuminatus! Trilogy draws other fiction-based religions into the mix, as Shea and Wilson employ the Cthulhu Mythos (invented by H. P. Lovecraft and expanded, through the introduction of the lloigor, by Colin Wilson), which features such “dark gods” as Yog-Sosoth, Azathoth, and Nyarlathotep (Hanegraaff 2007:85-109).

In a study of Finnish Discordians, Essi Mäkelä and Johanna Petsche record instances of new Discordian rituals, which include “worshipp[ing] a cabbage,” making “a pilgrimage to a rubbery gorilla statue in Helsinki,” and meditating “around a plastic golden apple” to receive illumination regarding Discordian power animals, a concept familiar from shamanism (Mäkelä and Petsche forthcoming). This contemporary field research suggests that Discordians engage in an ongoing process of innovation and development in terms of their ritual life.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Principia Discordia ordained a chaotic organizational structure for Discordianism. Members began by joining the Discordian Society, of which Principia stated, “the Discordian Society has no definition.” (Malaclypse the Younger and Omar Khayyam Ravenhurst 2006:93). Discordianism was divided into two sects; the Paratheo-Anametamystikhood of Eris Esoteric (POEE), which was founded by Mal-2, and the Erisian Liberation Front (ELF), which was founded by Omar. This oppositional structure reflected the popular motto “We Discordians Shall Stick Apart” (Adler 1986:332). Members are encouraged to become an Episkopos (Greek “overseer,” cognate with the English word “bishop”) by founding their own splinter sects. Later, all menbers were given the status of pope, and to become a member of the Discordian society was a simple process of self-identification.

However, even without self-identification Discordians assert that every human being is a member and a pope, which means that
Discordianism is “the fastest growing religion in all creation (Discordians grow at the exact same rate as the population)” (Chidester 2005: 199). Despite POEE being deemed a “non-prophet irreligious disorganization” and Discordianism “an anarchist’s paradise” (Adler 1986:332), as noted above members do get together to practice the religion. Discordian groups are called “cabals” (from kabbalah, the Jewish mystical system). Discordians do not have to join a cabal, but members often do. In the early twenty-first century many cabals are online (Narizny 2009).

There is evidence that Hill and Thornley came to accept the reality of Eris. Margot Adler interviewed Hill in Drawing Down the Moon (1979), where he admitted that he identified as an atheist in the 1950s and Discordianism began as a parody of religion. By the1970s, his worldview had shifted, and he admitted that:

Eris is an authentic goddess … In the beginning I saw myself as a cosmic clown. I characterized myself as Malaclypse the Younger. But if you do this type of thing well enough, it starts to work. In due time the polarities between atheism and theism become absurd. The engagement was transcendent. And when you transcend one, you transcend the other. I started out with the idea that all gods are an illusion. By the end I had learned that it’s up to you to decide whether gods exist, and if you take a goddess of confusion seriously, it will send you through as profound and valid a metaphysical trip as taking a god like Yahweh seriously. The trip will be different, but they will both be transcendental (Adler 1986:335).

Adler was unable to interview Thornley, who was increasingly paranoid and reclusive by the mid-1970s, but Hill assured her that a similar transformation of Discordianism had also happened for Omar. In what is now possibly his most famous observation, Thornley had told Hill, “You know, if I had realized that all of this was going to come true, I would have chosen Venus” (Adler 1986:336).

Although Malaclypse the Younger occupied the position of Polyfather of the religion until the mid-1970s, contemporary Discordianism is a religion in which leadership and formal organizational structures are largely irrelevant. There are many Discordian groups, a plethora of websites, and individuals give their religion as ‘Discordianism’ in those countries where the Census data collection involves a question about religion. Yet, in practice and despite the assertions of the very real power of Eris made by Hill and Thornley cited above, contemporary Discordians (like those who self-identify as Pagans, as Discordianism has found a niche as a form of revived Paganism) do not have to believe in the ontological reality of Eris as the goddess, and may regard the religion’s theology as a myth, a metaphor, or a joke (or all three simultaneously). Discordians regularly combine their religion with elements of other spiritual paths, or even atheism or agnosticism (Cusack 2010:47).

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Cultural commentators and the academy alike have derided Discordianiam as a “fake religion,” and to date study of it as a new religion has been minimal (Cusack 2010:27-52). The reasons for lack of serious research on Discordianism, and for suspicion of its bona fides, are threefold. First, religion is serious, thus Discordian parody and jokes are inappropriate. Second, its founders admitted that it was a fiction (and their later professions of faith are not to be trusted or believed). Finally, members tend to congregate online and do not have church buildings, schools and hospitals like “real” religions. However, it may be that the scholarly lack of interest will soon dissipate, as although Discordianism looked very unorthodox in the late 1950s, it has become less “odd” over time, as a vast array of new religions have emerged since the 1960s. If the model of Zen Buddhism that Kerry Thornley developed with Camden Benares is used as a prism through which to examine the religion, it is found to be appropriate. For the Beats in the 1950s, Zen represented the rejection of wage-slavery and convention, and the pursuit of the spiritual path of a hobo, uncomfortable in this world and seeking enlightenment (Prothero 1991).

Discordians concur that the sacred is secular, and the secular is sacred. Greg Hill asserted to Margot Adler that, “in due time the polarities between atheism and theism become absurd. The engagement was transcendent. And when you transcend one, you transcend the other” (Adler 1986:335). Adam Gorightly’s portrayal of Thornley’s last years shows him living on the margins, selling libertarian newsletters and practicing what he termed “Zen and the art of dishwashing” (Gorightly 2003:233-34). The spiritual journey of both founders are powerful and real narratives of transformation; scholars presently have no way of estimating the impact of Hill and Thornley’s lives on their followers, but it is not improbable that that impact is considerable. Robert Anton Wilson and Robert Shea’s literary output has reached millions and continues to attract new readers; spiritual seekers and jokers alike find Discordian websites every day. Discordianism as a religion is attracting a higher degree of serious academic interest in the twenty-first century, and although it will probably never be numerically significant, it is broadly recognized by those interested in fiction-based religions, the invention of modern Pagan religions, and a range of esoteric topics, as the earliest and most important of the small family of invented religions (Cusack 2010).

REFERENCES

Adler, Margot. 1986. Drawing Down the Moon: Witches, Druids, Goddess-Worshippers, and Other Pagans in America Today, second edition. Boston: Beacon Press.

Chidester, David. 2005. Authentic Fakes: Religion and American Popular Culture. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Cusack, Carole M. 2011. “Discordian Magic: Paganism, the Chaos Paradigm and the Power of Parody.” International Journal for the Study of New Religions 2:125-45.

Cusack, Carole M. 2010. Invented Religions: Imagination, Fiction and Faith. Farnham and Burlington, VT: Ashgate.

Gorightly, Adam. 2003. The Prankster and the Conspiracy: The Story of Kerry Thornley and How he Met Oswald and Inspired the Counterculture. New York: ParaView Press.

Hanegraaff, Wouter J. 2007. “Fiction in the Desert of the Real: Lovecraft’s Cthulhu Mythos.” Aries 7: 85-109.

LiBrizzi, Marcus. 2003. “The Illuminatus! Trilogy.” Pp. 339-41 in Conspiracy Theories in American History: An Encyclopedia, edited by Peter Knight. Santa Barbara: ABC:CLIO.

Mäkelä, Essi and Johanna Petsche. 2013. “Serious Parody: Discordianism as Liquid Religion.” Culture and Religion: An Interdisciplinary Journal 14:411-23.

Malaclypse the Younger. 1994. Principia Discordia: How I Found Goddess and What I Did to Her When I Found Her. Austin TX: Steve Jackson Games.

Malaclypse the Younger and Omar Khayyam Ravenhurst. 2006. Discordia: Hail Eris, Goddess of Chaos and Confusion. Berkeley: Ronin Books.

Narizny, Laurel. 2009. “Ha Ha Only Serious: A Preliminary Study of Joke Religions.” Bachelor of Arts (Honours) dissertation, Department of Religious Studies, University of Oregon, Eugene, Oregon. Accessed from https://scholarsbank.uoregon.edu/xmlui/bitstream/handle/1794/9336/Thesis%20Laurel%20Narizny.pdf?sequence=1 on 19 August 2009.

Prothero, Stephen. 1991. “On the Holy Road: The Beat Movement as Spiritual Protest.” Harvard Theological Review 84: 205-22.

Robertson, David G. 2012. “Making the Donkey Visible: Discordianism in the Works of Robert Anton Wilson.” Pp. 421-41 in Handbook of New Religions and Cultural Production, edited by Carole M. Cusack and Alex Norman. Leiden: Brill.

Shea, Robert and Robert Anton Wilson. 1998 [1975]. The Illuminatus! Trilogy. London: Raven Books.

Sutcliffe, Richard. 1996. “Left-Hand Path Ritual Magick: An Historical and Philosophical View.” Pp. 109-37 in Paganism Today, edited by Carlotte Hardman and Graham Harvey. London: Thorsons.

Thornley, Kerry Wendell. 1991. Zenarchy. lllumiNet Press. Accessed from http://www.mindcontrolforums.com/hambone/zenarchy.html on 19 August 2009.

Thornley, Kerry Wendell. 2007. The Dreadlock Recollections. Portland: Self-Published. Accessed from www.ibiblio.org/ovo127/media/OVO017.pdf on 19 August 2009.

Wagner, Eric. 2004. An Insider’s Guide to Robert Anton Wilson. Tempe, AZ: New Falcon Publications.

Wilson, Robert Anton. 2003. “The Monster in the Labyrinth.” Pp. 8-16 in The Prankster and the Conspiracy: The Story of Kerry Thornley and How he Met Oswald and Inspired the Counterculture, by Adam Gorightly. New York: ParaView Press.

Post Date:
May 20, 2013

DISCORDIANISM VIDEO CONNECTIONS

Share

Ahmadiyya

AHMADIYYA TIMELINE

Circa 1835:  Mirza Ghulam Ahmad was born in Qadian, India.

1889:  The Ahmadiyya Muslim community (Jama‘at-i Ahmadiyya) was founded.

1908:  Mirza Ghulam Ahmad died in Lahore and was brought back to Qadian to be buried.

1914:  A group of Ahmadi dissenters left Qadian for Lahore and subsequently came to be known as Lahoris, following the Lahori-Qadiani split.

1947:  India was partitioned into the independent countries of India and Pakistan, which was later subdivided into Pakistan and Bangladesh.

1953:  The Punjab Disturbances occurred in which widespread rioting in the Punjab region took place as a result of tensions stemming from the Ahmad controversy, which led to the implementation of martial law.

1974:  Pakistan amended its constitution to change the classification of Ahmadis from being Muslim to being part of its non-Muslim minority.

1984:  A religious ordinance was passed in Pakistan making many aspects of Ahmadi religious life in Pakistan illegal.

1984:  Shortly after the passing of the anti-Ahmadi ordinance, the fourth successor and grandson of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, Mirza Tahir Ahmad, fled Pakistan in exile for London as a refugee.

2003:  The current head of the Ahmadiyya movement, Mirza Masroor Ahmad, was selected by an electoral college following his arrival in London from Pakistan upon receiving news of the death of his predecessor.

2010:  A mass shooting at an Ahmadi mosque in Lahore took place, which resulted in the death of under 100 people and the injury of many more.

2012:  The current Ahmadi khalīfa , Mirza Masroor Ahmad, addressed members of Congress in Washington DC in an attempt to raise awareness about Ahmadi persecution.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

The Ahmadiyya Muslim community (or Jama‘at-i Ahmadiyya) is a Muslim reform movement that was founded in 1889 by Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (c. 1835–1908). He descended from a prominent Muslim family that had originally helped the Mughal emperor Babar settle part of rural India’s Punjab region in the early sixteenth century. By the mid-nineteenth century, much of the Muslim aristocracy in the Punjab had steadily ceded power to the Sikhs and then ultimately the British, which contributed to an overall sense of Muslim decline (Friedmann 1989). During this period, Christian missionaries had been gaining leverage in the subcontinent under British rule, which added another dimension to religious debates taking place and to ongoing religious rivalries. This led to a number of different responses from Muslim thinkers, including from Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, who began his carrier by writing tracts that argued in favor of Islam’s superiority as a religion (Khan 2015).

As Mirza Ghulam Ahmad continued engaging in religious rivalries with Hindus, Sikhs, and Christians, he dedicated increasing time to his own religious devotions. This led to spiritual experiences that changed the course of his religious career (Lavan 1974). In the early 1880s, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad began describing his experiences with the terminology used in the Islamic tradition to characterize revelation from God, which was considered unusual by mainstream Muslims beyond a tight circle of elite mystics. This drew unusual attention to Mirza Ghulam Ahmad’s mission and provoked a sense of caution from Muslims who might otherwise have appreciated his defense of Islam and his argumentation against non-Muslim rivals.

In 1891, two years after Jama‘at-i Ahmadiyya was founded, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad published a trilogy of books, which disclosed his true spiritual station and asserted his divinely appointed status to the world (Khan 2015). Ghulam Ahmad explained that he was a muhaddath , which meant that God was speaking to him. He also declared that he held a joint status as the mahdī (guided one), a figure who was predicted to appear in the latter days, and as the promised messiah (masīh ) in the spirit of Jesus (Khan 2015; Friedmann 1989). This claim of being the promised messiah in particular led to the most controversial aspects Ahmadi theology for Muslims and Christians alike, which will be discussed further in the section on doctrine and beliefs.

In claiming to be the promised messiah, Ghulam Ahmad was claiming to be the second coming of Jesus. By claiming to be Jesus in spirit, Ghulam Ahmad was implying that his spiritual status incorporated a strand of prophethood, which was considered highly dubious to most mainstream Muslims who thought this bordered on heresy. It effectively meant that Ghulam Ahmad was claiming to be another prophet after the Prophet Muhammad, who has generally been regarded as the last prophet in Islam (Friedmann 1989). Mirza Ghulam Ahmad spent the remaining years of his life engaged in a bitter controversy with other Muslims who rejected his claims. Ghulam Ahmad insisted that by following his interpretation of Islam, Muslims would be able to return to their former glory before the impending Day of Judgement. This messianic motif is responsible for providing Jama‘at-i Ahmadiyya with its apocalyptic orientation in the broader Islamic tradition (Friedmann 1989).

Some of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad’s contemporaries declared that his views were blasphemous and deemed his disciples to be beyond the pale of Islam (Khan 2015). The debate about Ahmadis intensified in the decades after Ghulam Ahmad’s death in 1908 and eventually became politicized in the years leading up to India’s independence from Britain following partition in 1947 (Lavan 1974). The outcome of partition eventually resulted in a political divide based on religious orientation, which meant that Muslim majority areas in the East and West would form the country of Pakistan, whereas the majority of the subcontinent would remain as a secular state, resulting in the modern-day nation-state of India. This allowed the Ahmadi controversy, which was centered on the question of determining whether Ahmadis were in fact Muslim, to erupt into a national religious debate, since the grounds for partition had been based on religious affiliation. The fact that religious identity played a role in grounding national identity in Pakistan helped politicize the Ahmadi controversy in the subcontinent, since conversely the notion of being un-Islamic was linked directly to political consequences (Khan 2015). This led to the exacerbation of the Ahmadi controversy after partition in 1947 when questions of religious authenticity plagued the newly formed Islamic state by enabling mainstream political leaders to determine which interpretations were truly representative of Islam (Gualtieri 1989; Gualtieri 2004).

The Ahmadi community came to be associated with Muslim politics, elitism, and exclusivity, which was brought on to some extent by its political involvement in the Kashmir Crisis of the 1930s and the broader independence movement before India’s partition in 1947 (Lavan 1974). In fact, a prominent Ahmadi named Muhammad Zafrulla Khan (1893–1985) served as the first foreign minister of Pakistan before going on to become president of the United Nations General Assembly and president of the International Court of Justice.

Fear of Ahmadi exploitation in Pakistan and general distrust of Ahmadi religious views, led to an overwhelmingly negative perception of the community, which fueled a series of riots, known as the Punjab disturbances of 1953 (Qasmi 2014). The disturbances represented the first time that martial law was declared in Pakistan’s history. This only heightened the level of controversy surrounding Ahmadis in subsequent years. By the 1970s, the Ahmadi controversy had once again garnered national attention when opposition party members of Pakistan’s National Assembly staged a walkout and demanded that the president, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto (1928–1979), revisit the Ahmadi question. As a result, Ahmadis were declared non-Muslim in 1974 by the government of Pakistan whose constitution was amended to reflect the community’s new religious designation (Gualtieri 1989) . This facilitated maltreatment of Ahmadis across the country and led to increased hostility toward the community. In 1984, the military general, Zia-ul-Haq (1924–1988), who had taken over the government by coup, initiated a number of religious ordinances intended to Islamize the legal system. This included an ordinance that famously made most aspects of everyday life for Ahmadis in Pakistan illegal. Since then, Ahmadis have increasingly been known throughout the world as a persecuted Muslim minority in South Asia (Gualtieri 2004) .

Since the mid-1980s, members of the Ahmadi community have increasingly taken root in Western Europe and North America, especially since 1984 when the movement’s organizational headquarters was moved to London. There are now Ahmadi mosques in most urban centers throughout Britain, France, and Germany, as well as in Canada and the United States (Haddad 1993; Khan 2015).

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

At its heart, the Ahmadiyya Muslim community shares most beliefs and doctrines with mainstream Sunni Islam. The differences between Ahmadis and mainstream Muslims stem from the way in which most Ahmadis have understood Mirza Ghulam Ahmad’s claims of prophethood (Friedmann 1989). The debate surrounding these interpretations led to a schism in the movement in 1914 between most Ahmadis whose organization was based in Qadian and a minority group who chose to relocate to Lahore and hence came to be known as Lahoris. The Lahoris interpreted Ghulam Ahmad’s claims of prophethood in a more metaphorical sense and pointed to aspects of Ghulam Ahmad’s texts where he appeared to limit or qualify notions of his prophetic status, whereas the Qadiani branch understood Mirza Ghulam Ahmad’s prophethood more literally (Lavan 1974).

The belief that Mirza Ghulam Ahmad was a prophet of God is the primary distinguishing feature between Ahmadis and mainstream Muslims, and it is arguably the basis of the Ahmadi controversy today. The reason why this belief is considered to be so problematic by mainstream Muslims is because it appears to be a direct contradiction of the Qur’anic verse declaring Muhammad to be the “seal of the prophets ( khātam al-nabiyyīn )”, which has been understood by mainstream Muslims to indicate Muhammad’s status as the last prophet (Qur’an 33:40). Ahmadis, instead, have suggested that the verse should be understood to mean that Muhammad was the best of all previous prophets and that any subsequent prophet who might follow Muhammad would not establish new laws that contravened Islamic law in a way that would abrogate Islam and lead to the formation of a new religion (Friedmann 1989; Khan 2015). Ahmadis compare prophecy in Islam to the age of prophecy in ancient Judaism when numerous prophets were known to have appeared within the same religious tradition as a means of strengthening and revitalizing the tradition in anticipation of the Day of Judgment (Friedmann 1989).

The subtleties of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad’s claims are difficult to explain, since they involve a number of assumptions about Islam and the prophetic tradition. Mirza Ghulam Ahmad was convinced that Jesus could not possibly return to the world in the flesh, since human beings cannot survive indefinitely for thousands of years (Valentine 2008). Ghulam Ahmad’s prophetic status was thereby connected in part to his claim of being the promised messiah or the second coming of Jesus, since the original Jesus was a bona fide prophet (Khan 2015). In order for Mirza Ghulam Ahmad to advance this claim and demonstrate to mainstream Muslims and Christians that Jesus was not alive in heaven and would not return to the world in the latter days, Ghulam Ahmad proposed an alternative account of the crucifixion story (Ahmad 1994; Fisher 1963). According to Ahmadis, Jesus survived the crucifixion and travelled east to escape further persecution and ultimately set out to unite the lost tribes of Israel, which is based on their readings of the Biblical verses (John 10:16, Matthew 15:24). This enabled Jesus to continue his mission and ultimately die a natural death, which likewise made it impossible for him to be physically alive in heaven waiting to return. Mirza Ghulam Ahmad identified the final resting place of Jesus as a burial tomb in Srinagar, Kashmir that was attributed to an ancient saint (Ahmad 2003). This discovery enabled him to demonstrate that Jesus had died and to claim that he was the second coming of Jesus in spirit and hence the promised messiah.

One interesting outcome of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad’s claim of being the messiah was his interpretation of jihad, considering the apocalyptic expectations of the messiah to defeat evil in the world. Whereas the notion of jihad has always been used in Islam to signify various notions of inner and outer struggles, Ghulam Ahmad insisted that his mission would succeed through non-violent means (Hanson 2007). This concept of jihad, as representing an inner spiritual struggle, is certainly not unique to Jama‘at-i Ahmadiyya, but the way in which it has been emphasized by Ahmadis, especially during the early years of the movement under British colonial rule, has developed into one of the hallmarks of Ahmadi Islam. Aside from the colonial context when Ahmadis refused to take up arms against the British, the notion of non-violent jihad has been particularly useful in marketing Ahmadi Islam to western audiences in a post 9/11 era (Khan 2015).

RITUAL/PRACTICES

In theory, the basic rituals and practices of Ahmadi Muslims are identical to those found in mainstream Islam, but there are subtle distinctions that have gradually developed over time. For example, despite the Ahmadi observance of the five daily prayers in accordance with mainstream Islam, Ahmadis refuse to offer prayers behind non-Ahmadi imams. This has resulted in the creation of separate mosques and prayer facilities around the world and is somewhat unique in the Islamic tradition, where at least historically Muslims have largely avoided forming separate prayer congregations. There are of course some exceptions to this rule, especially in modernist South Asian Islam. Nonetheless, in the case of Jama‘at-i Ahmadiyya, the separation in prayer is undeniable. This practice stems from the generalized assumption of Ahmadi congregants that a non-Ahmadi imam leading the prayer would likely consider Mirza Ghulam Ahmad an infidel, and so Ahmadis choose to perform the same prayer ritual behind an Ahmadi imam. To illustrate the subtlety of this distinction, one might find non-Ahmadi Muslims who reject Mirza Ghulam Ahmad’s claims performing the prayer behind an Ahmadi imam, especially in western countries where Muslim communities are diverse and prayer spaces are limited.

This type of self-imposed separation has also led to marriage restrictions for most Ahmadis. Most Ahmadis are expected to marry other Ahmadis, with officially sanctioned exceptions to this practice that are addressed on a case by case basis. For this reason, Ahmadi marriage practices are somewhat more restrictive than those in mainstream Islam.

The annual pilgrimage to Mecca or hajj has been difficult to carry out for Ahmadis as Ahmadis due to the repercussions of persecution, especially when travelling from countries like Pakistan which stamps passports with one’s religious designation (Gualtieri 2004). Over time, a separate Ahmadi ritual has steadily gained prominence, not necessarily as a replacement for the hajj, but as an important gathering nonetheless. This annual gathering (jalsa sālāna) takes place in most countries with significant Ahmadi populations (Lavan 1974). One of the largest gatherings at the moment takes place outside London, since London is where the current head of the movement resides. Ahmadis travel from all over the world to attend the annual gathering if possible and partake in religious events including, sermonizing, poetry readings, and socializing with others (Khan 2015).

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Jama‘at-i Ahmadiyya is an institutionalized religious movement with a clearly defined religious hierarchy. The head of the movement is Mirza Ghulam Ahmad’s successor or the khalīfat al-masīh (lit. successor of the messiah). The caliph (khalīfa ) manages the auxiliary organizations of the movement around the world and represents the centralization of both religious and political authority. He has the power to define or redefine both Ahmadi orthodoxy and Ahmadi orthopraxy (Khan 2015). The institution of Ahmadi khilāfat currently represents a stateless caliphate with branches of the movement in various countries throughout the world that make up the strata of the organizational hierarchy. Each nation with a local Ahmadi community (jama‘at) has a national representative known as an amīr (leader). The national amīr manages local branches, which are headed by a president. There are also subsidiary organizations for men and women that are subdivided by age group that fall within the jurisdiction of the president at the local level, or the amīr at the national level, as part of the hierarchical structure (Khan 2015). Ahmadi missionaries are responsible for spreading Ghulam Ahmad’s mission and will lead the prayer services at the local level while working with the president on local initiatives. Ahmadi missionaries often undergo basic religious training at various Ahmadi seminaries around the world before dedicating their lives to the movement.

The Ahmadi caliphate (khilāfat-i ahmadiyya) is financed by a complex system of member donations known as chanda. Ahmadis must pay certain portions of their income to support the institutional hierarchy and various other causes. This serves as the primary means of remaining within good standing in the community, barring exceptional circumstances where members are unable to contribute financially to the movement for legitimate reasons, which are dealt with on a case by case basis. Any member who remains within good standing in the community is granted voting rights and may be eligible to participate in the various electoral processes at the local level, which usually determine who holds the relevant positions of authority in local Ahmadi communities. Once again, all of this is directed by the khalīfat al-masīh , who remains the sole person with power to intervene in any process atop the institutional hierarchy.

As mentioned above, a dispute broke out in 1914 between two camps of the movement following the election of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad’s second khalīfat al-masīh. This dispute, commonly referred to the Lahori-Qadiani split, arose in part because of a disagreement about the nature of the institutional hierarchy. The Lahori branch rejected the notion of a centralized supreme khalīfa and favored the formation of an administrative board known as the Ahmadiyya Anjuman Isha‘at Islam Lahore (Lahore Ahmadiyya Committee for the Propagation of Islam), which is headed by an amīr (Lavan 1974; Friedmann 1989). The amīr in the Lahori branch does not carry the same authoritative connotations as the khalīfat al-masīh in the larger Qadiani branch, even though he holds considerable authority in terms of guiding the administrative affairs of the branch nonetheless.

ISSUE/CHALLENGES

The primary issue facing the Ahmadiyya movement today revolves around questions of identity. Are Ahmadis really Muslims or do they represent a new religious movement? As the movement has evolved since its formation in 1889, it has become increasingly politicized in a globalized context, which has changed the nature of this debate. Nonetheless, it is certainly conceivable that Ahmadis themselves may one day choose to take a definitive stance against the Islamic tradition and no longer identify as Muslims, but rather as Ahmadis. This could represent a similar path taken by members of the Baha’i Faith, who no longer choose to identify with Islam. Similarly, it is certainly possible for Ahmadis to attempt to reconcile their differences with mainstream Islam and regain acceptance as a legitimate expression of South Asian Islam, especially at a time far removed from the politicization of the Ahmadi controversy. In the meantime, however, Jama‘at-i Ahmadiyya remains immersed in a highly politicized controversy about its status as a Muslim minority movement, where certain key issues have yet to have been formalized into anything beyond a rudimentary precursor of official dogma. Examples of these issues include the role of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad’s spiritual status in comparison to the status of the Prophet Muhammad, the formal relation of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad’s writings and teachings in relation to the foundational textual sources of the mainstream tradition, and the Ahmadi community’s attitude toward mainstream Muslims who refuse to pass judgment on its members or renounce ties to those who endorse continuing to pursue acts of hostility and persecution of Ahmadis. These are serious yet unresolved issues that represent major theological challenges for Jama‘at-i Ahmadiyya.

Another challenge facing the movement is the future of its leadership. Jama‘at-i Ahmadiyya will need to reconcile aspects of the role of the khalīfat al-masīh in contemporary times in order to avoid allowing the position to be reduced to a mere figurehead role. This might mean developing, or at least bolstering, institutions for internal religious and political discourse. It may also mean further elaborating the doctrine of charisma and its relationship to the lineage of the movement’s founder, since four out of five successors of the messiah have thus far been direct descendants of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad. Expounding notions of charisma in relation to heredity, while accommodating other aspects of religious or political leadership and development, will need to be developed over time.

One of the most immediate challenges facing the movement is its persecution and mistreatment in various parts of the world (Nijhawan 2010). The community’s expansion to parts of Western Europe and North America has certainly helped many Ahmadis avoid the dangers that exist in countries like Pakistan or Indonesia where there are legal sanctions against Ahmadi Muslims. However, changing attitudes in the Muslim World may help or hurt the community’s relationship with mainstream Muslims throughout the world, especially as conceptions of Jama‘at-i Ahmadiyya’s own self-identity continue to emerge.

REFERENCES

Ahmad, Mirza Ghulam. 2003. Jesus in India. Tilford, UK: Islam International Publications.

Ahmad, Mirza Tahir. 1994. Christianity: A Journey from Facts to Fiction . Tilford, UK: Islam International Publications.

Fisher, Humphrey. 1963. Ahmadiyyah: A Study in Contemporary Islam on the West African Coast. London: Oxford University Press.

Friedmann, Yohanan. 1989. Prophecy Continuous: Aspects of Ahmadi Religious Thought and Its Medieval Background. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Gualtieri, Antonio. 2004. The Ahmadis: Community, Gender, and Politics in a Muslim Society. London: McGill–Queen’s University Press.

Gualtieri, Antonio. 1989. Conscience and Coercion: Ahmadi Muslims and Orthodoxy in Pakistan. Montreal: Guernica Editions.

Haddad, Yvonne Yazbeck, and Jane Idleman Smith. 1993. Mission to America: Five Islamic Sectarian Communities in North America. Gainesville: University Press of Florida.

Hanson, John H. 2007. “Jihad and the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community: Nonviolent Efforts to Promote Islam in the Contemporary World.” Nova Religio 11:77–93.

Khan, Adil Hussain. 2015. From Sufism to Ahmadiyya: A Muslim Minority Movement in South Asia. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.

Lavan, Spencer. 1974. The Ahmadiyah Movement: A History and Perspective. Delhi: Manohar Book Service.

Nijhawan, Michael. 2010. “‘Today, We Are All Ahmadi’: Configurations of Heretic Otherness between Lahore and Berlin.” British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies 37:429–47.

Qasmi, Ali Usman. 2014. The Ahmadis and the Politics of Religious Exclusion in Pakistan. London: Anthem Press.

Valentine, Simon Ross. 2008. Islam and the Ahmadiyya Jama‘at: History, Belief, Practice. New York: Columbia University Press.

Post Date:
5 May 2015

AHMADIYYA VIDEO CONNECTIONS

Share

Aum Shinrikyō

AUM SHINRIKYŌ TIMELINE

1955:  Matsumoto Chizuo (birth name of Asahara Shōkō) was born with a serious sight disability, in Kumamoto, Japan, the sixth son of poor family.

1977:  Matsumoto moved to Tokyo.

1978:  Matsumoto married Matsumoto Tomoko and started an herbal business.

1981:  Matsumoto joined Agonshū and began practicing yoga and meditation.

1984:  Matsumoto quit Agonshū and established his own yoga and meditation group (initially called Aum Shinsen no Kai) with fifteen followers in Tokyo. The group changed its name to Asahara Shōkō and started performing ritual initiations for devotees.

1985:  Asahara appeared in Twilight Zone (a magazine focused on alternative religious views) claiming he could levitate.

1985:  Asahara claimed spiritual encounters with deities, including the Hindu deity Shiva, who informed him that he was destined to carry out sacred missions of world salvation. Shiva became a figure of veneration in Aum.

1986:  Aum established a publishing company and Asahara published his first book, Chōnōryoku no kaihatsuhō, suggesting a way to develop new supernatural spiritual powers.

1987:  Aum Shinsen no Kai was renamed as Aum Shinrikyō and emphasized world renunciation. The first Aum disciples became renunciates (shukkesha), monastic practitioners who have left their families.

1987:  Asahara began talking of possible end of world due to growing environmental and spiritual crisis and because of bad karma enveloping the world. He prophesied that Aum could avert this catastrophe and bring about world salvation by getting 3,0000 people enlightened.

1988 (August):  Aum opened a commune at Kamikuishiki, Yamanashi prefecture (to be the model for future ideal communities). Asahara expressed an optimistic belief that Aum could save the world.

1988 (c. September):  Asahara became frustrated at lack of progress by some disciples. He began beatings reluctant members (including his wife). He developed the doctrine of poa (the notion that an advanced practitioner/teacher could perform rituals to enable the spirit of a dead person to advance to higher realms in the next life).

1988 (September or October):  Majima Terayuki (or Teruyuki) died suddenly during ascetic practices ordered by Asahara; the death was covered up.

1989 (February?):  Taguchi Shūji (a participant in the cover-up of Majima Terayuki’s death) decided to leave movement and denounce Aum. Asahara ordered Taguchi’s murder; the killing was declared as poa (see below, under Doctrines/Beliefs).

1989:  Metsubō no hi books (prophesying apocalyptic destruction and citing the Book of Revelation) were published, and Aum teachings became focused on apocalypse and the impossibility of universal salvation.

1989:  Aum’s application to gain registration as a legally affiliated religious organization was turned down but later reinstated after an appeal to higher courts.

1989 (October):  Hostile media articles about Aum denounced Asahara and alleged malpractice in Aum. The association of Aum victims (Aum Higaisha no Kai) was established. It engaged the lawyer Sakamoto Tsutsumi to represent them in meetings with Aum. Sakamoto claimed to have found evidence of Aum malpractice.

1989 (early November):  Sakamoto and his family disappeared from their home in Yokohama. Aum denied any involvement. Later, in the summer of 1995, Aum devotees confessed to having killed the family on Asahara’s orders, and the bodies of Sakamoto, his wife and infant son were recovered.

1989 (later months):  Aum formed a political party, the Truth Party (the Shinritō), to raise its profile by taking part in the spring, 1990 parliamentary elections. Aum used the campaign to warn of impending millennial catastrophe unless Japan embraced Aum’s teachings.

1990 (February):  Aum’s election campaign was derided in the mass media, and Aum candidates all failed miserably. Asahara claimed a conspiracy against Aum wrecked the campaign and (March 1990) that there was a world conspiracy working against Aum.

1990 (April):  The Ishigaki Seminar was held on an island in Okinawa. Asahara declared that Aum was now on the Vajrayāna path of Buddhism. It henceforth regarded salvation as selective rather than universal and asserted that mass destruction was needed to purify the world and punish wrongdoers.

1990 (March-April):  Aum established laboratories for making biological weapons. Devotees released botulism in Tokyo to punish electors for rejecting Aum, but the attack failed.

1991:  Asahara’s teachings became increasingly pessimistic, and he talked of the inevitability of Armageddon as necessary to purify the world. His teachings focused increasingly on poa and on severing links with society at large. Increasing conflicts arose between Aum and its neighbours, and with other religions especially in Tokyo, such as Kōfuku no Kagaku.

1991: (onwards):  Aum became increasingly involved in building secret laboratories and trying to get or make biological and chemical weapons, including in October, 1992, a vist by Aum members to Congo seeking to acquire the Ebola virus.

1993:  Aum devotees (Tsuchiya Masami and Endō Seiichi) made sarin secretly; Asahara mentioned sarin in sermons and Aum developed songs valorizing it as a sacred object.

1993 (June):  The accidental death of Ochi Naoki during austerities was covered up by Aum leaders).

1993:  Throughout the year there were further attempts to release botulism spores in Tokyo (all fail) to punish Japanese society for failing to acknowledge Aum’s truth and sacred mission.

1994:  Asahara claimed that Aum was being attacked by conspirators (Japanese and U.S. governments and others) and that sarin has been sprayed on the Kamikuishiki commune. Killings of Aum dissidents and kidnappings of members who tried to flee the movement continued.

1994 (June 27):  Sarin gas was released in Matsumoto, central Japan, killing seven people and injuring over 500. At the same time Aum announces the formation of its own government, with Asahara as its “sacred ruler” (shinsei hōō).

1994-1995:  Japanese newspapers reported that sarin has been released/found at or near Aum’s commune in Kamikuishiki and linked Aum to the Matsumoto attack. Aum issued denials

1995 (February 28):  Aum devotees abducted estate agent Kariya Kiyoshi, whose sister was in Aum, to extract money from him to help Aum finances. Later investigations indicated that Kariya was killed shortly after the abduction.

1995 (March):  The police and media became aware of Aum involvement in the Kariya abduction and Aum involvement with chemical weapons. Police prepared raids on Aum premises.

1995 (March 18):  Asahara became aware of the likely raid and ordered devotees to prepare sarin for an attack on Tokyo (probably to cause chaos and avert a raid).

1995 (March 20):  Aum conducted a sarin attack on Kasumigaseki station/trains at rush hour (striking the area around government ministries including the National Police Agency), killing thirteen people and injuring thousands.

1995 (March 22):  Police raids were conducted on Aum buildings and communes, with hundreds of arrests and confiscation of equipment and materials.

1995 (March-May):  The police discovered evidence of numerous crimes and continued to arrest senior figures, including Asahara, on May 16.

1995 (April 23):  Murai Hideo (one of Aum’s leaders, central to its weapons program) was stabbed to death in public in Tokyo.

1995 (May and after):  Senior Aum figures (notably Hayashi Ikuo, one of the subway attackers) began confessing to participation in Aum crimes. There was a mass exodus of Aum members, between eighty and ninety percent.

1995 (October-December):  Aum’s status as religious organization was revoked and subsequently the revocation was upheld by the Tokyo High Court.

1996 (April 24):  Asahara’s trial began. He claimed that disciples committed the crimes and that he was therefore not responsible.

1996 (and later):  Trials began to be held of various Aum figures who were accused of murders, making illegal weapons, and involvement in various lethal conspiracies. Over 100 devotees were convicted and sentenced. Thirteen (including Asahara) were sentenced to death for murder.

1996 (and later):  There were debates in Japan about proscribing Aum under the Anti-Subversive Activities Law, and about how to deal with those who wished to remain in Aum. There were also debates about the formation of various support groups for ex-members and cases for financial retribution to compensate Aum’s victims. Aum properties were liquidated to this end.

1996 (and later):  Remaining Aum devotees sought to keep the movement going and to draw a line with the past by distancing themselves from Asahara and by renouncing violence and doctrines such as poa.

1997 (January 31):  The government announced that Aum would not be formally proscribed but discussed introducing new laws to monitor the movement.

1999 (September):  Aum announced that it was ceasing all religious activities.

1999 (December):  Aum made an official apology for its crimes in a televised press conference and on its website.

2000 (January-February):  Aum changed name to Aleph and made plans to transfer its remaining properties to a fund to compensate Aum victims.

2000 (and later):  Aleph continued on with a small number of devotees and was heavily monitored by the state and subject to various legal restraints. Aleph members (including members of Asahara’s family) faced continued discrimination in Japanese society.

2004:  Asahara was sentenced to death for murder and conspiracy to murder.

2007:  Aleph split into factions, including Hikari no Wa (see separate entry).

2018 (July):  Thirteen members of Aum, including Asahara, executed for conspiracy to commit murder and for other Aum crimes;  Asaahra and six others on July 6 and the remaining six on July 26.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Asahara Shōkō, was born in 1955 as Matsumoto Chizuo to an impoverished family in Kumamoto, southern Japan. The sixth of seven children, he was partially sighted, a disability coupled with family poverty that led to him being sent away to a boarding school for the blind. This caused him to become alienated from his family and to later reject his birth name and take on a new name when he began his religious career. Interested in medicine and healing, he sought entry to universities to study medicine but was turned down (in one case because of his disability). In 1977, he moved to Tokyo, set up a business as a practitioner of acupuncture and vendor of herbal remedies and married Matsumoto Tomoko (who also held a high position in Aum), with whom he had six children. Their third daughter became a highly revered religious practitioner in Aum.

In 1982, Asahara was fined for selling herbal remedies without a license, an incident that caused him great mental distress. He also became a member of the new religion Agonshū, but, dissatisfied with its lack of ascetic practice, he left to set up a yoga and meditation centre in Tokyo, where he gathered disciples attracted by his reputation as an insightful teacher. The group, which began in 1984, included many who were at the center of Aum’s later nefarious activities. It initially called itself “Aum Hermit’s Society” (Aum Shinsen no Kai); the word Aum was drawn from the Hindu and Buddhist term meaning creation, destruction and preservation. Initially, Asahara was seen as a teacher (sensei) but soon came to be referred to as Aum’s “guru” and as an absolute spiritual master and epitome of the truth, to whom disciples owed total obedience. According to disciples, he was highly compassionate and kind, and strove to help them, but they also noted that he was very strict and was harsh on anyone who failed to perform the austerities he deemed necessary for their salvation (Reader 2000:39-44; Takahashi 1996:154-56).

He drew attention to the movement through public talks and various publicity activities, including a claimed ability to levitate, which was
publicized in a 1995 edition of Twilight Zone, a spiritually-oriented Tokyo magazine. In 1986, he visited India, performed ascetic practices there and claimed to have reached enlightenment. He had a succession of religious experiences and claimed that various spirits (including the Indian deity Shiva) had spoken to him and entrusted him with a mission of world salvation and renewal. These reinforced his conviction that he had a special mission to save the world, and that his devotees formed a cadre of sacred warriors who would help him in this task. In 1986, the group followed a common pattern among Japanese new religions by establishing its own publishing firm to allow it to more easily distribute its teachings.

The movement attracted a very small but ardent group of young, well-educated followers, particularly in the Tokyo area. Many were attracted by the promise of attaining enlightenment and personal salvation and by being part of a movement that would bring about world salvation and transformation (Shimazono 1995a, 1995b). Asahara changed the group’s name to Aum Shinrikyō in 1987. Around this time, while continuing to stress the importance of personal spiritual practice and asceticism in the search for enlightenment, he began to express millennial teachings, warning of a crisis engulfing the world that could only be overcome by a rejection of materialism and a turn to spiritual practices. To do this required a growing spiritual army of devotees who would renounce the world and become enlightened (Reader 2000:88-93). This message of world transformation to avert a crisis (caused by factors such as materialism, environmental disasters and the manipulations, according to Asahara, of a conspiratorial group of power-hungry interests including the U.S. government) gradually changed as Aum became beset by difficulties in spreading its message, and as crises gripped the movement.

Asahara was clearly charismatic, and many of those who followed him have testified that it was his charisma, his ability to explain and articulate teachings that presented solutions to their worries, and his compassionate nature that drew them to him and his movement. Devotees sought to align themselves with his charismatic powers by undergoing initiations at his hands, in which he took on their negative karma and thus, according to Aum beliefs, freed them to heighten their spiritual status (Asahara 1992; Reader 2000:12-16).

Asahara was a skilled practitioner of asceticism, and his teachings reflected this. Devotees were expected to fast and perform harsh austerities to purify their bodies and attain higher spiritual states. They renounced the world to live in rural communes, where harsh physical disciplines, including the beating of members to make them engage in more ascetic practices, cultivated a culture of violence within the group. This culture of violence emerged in autumn, 1988 as Asahara became frustrated that his “salvation mission” was running into difficulties because it was not producing enough enlightened beings to bring about the spiritual transformation necessary to avert cosmic catastrophe. As a result, Aum became more hostile towards the world beyond its borders, while Asahara pressed his disciples harder to make them undergo austerities that would bring about their salvation (Reader 2000).

However, the death of a devotee (Majima Terayuki) during such ascetic training in autumn of 1988 caused a fatal blow. Aum’s leaders covered the death up to avoid public scandal and damage to the movement, but this meant breaking the law. One disciple, Taguchi Shūji, lost faith in Asahara as a result and decided to go public on this death, provoking a new crisis. In February, 1989, Taguchi was killed by a group of devotees to stop him bringing the movement into disrepute and to protect “the truth.” Asahara argued that by killing Taguchi, he was saving him from committing the heinous crime of undermining the spiritual truth of Aum (Reader 2000:144-45). In so doing, Asahara began to formulate the doctrine of poa, which became central to Aum teaching and to its escalating violence (see below, under doctrines and teachings).

In this same period, Aum began to become embroiled in disputes with its neighbors where it built its communes, and with the families of devotees who had joined Aum’s communes and severed all familial ties. Hostile stories began to spread in the mass media about Aum, and the Society of Aum Victims (Aum Higaisha no Kai, consisting of ex-members and the families of devotees, was formed. Throughout 1989 Aum thus became enveloped in violence and conflicts, culminating in the murder by devotees of a lawyer, Sakamoto Tsutsumi and his family, in November, 1989. Sakamoto represented the Aum Higaisha no Kai and began investigating the movement, subsequently claiming to have uncovered evidence of fraud (Hardacre 2007:186). As with the killing of Taguchi (above), the reason given for killing Sakamoto was to stop him destroying Aum’s mission, with Asahara using the concept of poa to justify giving the order to kill the lawyer. Evidence of how Aum’s senior devotees agreed with this teaching and with the belief that they had a special mission that should be protected at all costs (even including the killing of others) is shown by the words of Nakagawa Tomomasa, a qualified doctor and Aum devotee. He was asked to carry out the killing and, rather than being shocked at being asked to breach his Hippocratic oath, he said he felt elated to have been chosen for this “salvation mission.” (Pye 1996:265). He felt Asahara had thereby recognized his spiritual prowess and that he had therefore attained a state where he had gone beyond the world of normative morality and acquired a spiritual status that entitled him and other Aum devotees to kill in the service of their guru (Reader 2000:150-51).

Although Aum developed a doctrinal structure that made its senior figures convinced of the righteousness of their violent deeds against “enemies of the truth,” this criminality, combined with external conflicts with hostile family groups and local communities, plus negative media attention, created an aura of paranoia within the movement. This was compounded by Aum’s failure to attract enough practitioners to enable it to achieve the number of spiritually advanced beings Asahara believed were necessary to bring about a peaceful world transformation before the catastrophic events he foresaw at the end twentieth century would otherwise occur. This failure was due in part to Aum’s harsh austerities and requirements that devotees abandon their families and swear absolute devotion to the guru. While this appealed to a small zealous minority it proved unattractive to most young Japanese. The growing controversial reputation of Aum also was a barrier to recruitment (Reader 2000:126-61).

Thus, Aum became beleaguered, and Asahara, shaken by the criminality his mission had produced, became increasingly paranoid, claiming that his salvation mission was being threatened by hostile conspiratorial forces. These views were compounded when, trying to make the Japanese public more aware of Aum’s millennial messages, he established a political party, the Party of Truth (Shinritō) to participate in the February, 1990 elections. The total failure of this party (all Aum candidates including Asahara lost badly) was compounded by public ridicule in the media for Aum’s campaign, and it served to further widen the growing gulf between Aum and Japanese society (Young 1995).

Aum acquired land and built communes in rural Japan, initially at Kamikuishiki in Yamanashi prefecture, not far from Tokyo, and later at Namino in Kyushu. These were perceived as blueprints for its utopian visions of the future (Shimazono 1995). Soon, however, its communes became areas of conflict with local communities and civic authorities as Aum refused to obey local planning laws and faced hostility from rural neighbors suspicious of Aum’s motives (Kumamoto Nichinichi Shinbun 1995; Takeuchi 1995). In late 1990, Aum abandoned the Namino commune (after the local authorities there paid it reparations to get the movement to leave) and made Kamikuishiki its main center. Such conflicts intensified the feelings inside Aum that the movement was being threatened by hostile forces out to stop it from bringing about world transformation. This produced a progressive shift in Aum’s millennialism. Between 1989 and 1991, Asahara turned away from an initial optimism that Aum could save the world, to an increasingly pessimistic view that universal salvation was impossible and that cosmic war, in which the “truth of Aum would confront the evils of the world, was inevitable and necessary. Aum’s growing apocalypticism was reinforced by external teachings encountered by Asahara and his devotees, such as the apocalyptic imagery of the biblical Book of Revelation. Its prophetic messages of a final war between good and evil resonated with Asahara so forcefully that he began to use the term harumageddon (the Japanese phonetic rendition of Armageddon) in his talks and prophecies (Reader 2000:126-95; Shimazono 1997).

In March, 1990, after its electoral humiliation of February 1990, the movement held a seminar on the island of Ishigaki in the Okinawan archipelago. There Asahara announced that a global apocalypse was now inevitable in which only very few (those who followed his teachings) would survive and that humanity had lost any chance of universal salvation. The world had rejected Aum, and Aum was in effect turning its back on the world and saying that in the future it was only interested in saving its own devotees while fighting against anyone who rejected its teachings and who therefore deserved to be punished. Henceforth, Aum had to prepare for a real cosmic confrontation between good and evil when it would fight its enemies, whose purpose was to destroy Aum and subjugate the world. Thus Aum was placed on a war footing, and devoted its energies to acquiring the means to fight. This was a process aided by its activities in Russia, where it briefly established centers and, through contacts there, was able to acquire various forms of weaponry. From the spring of 1990 onwards, a group of Aum devotees who had some scientific training began to make biological and chemical weapons in clandestine laboratories at its Kamikuishiki commune, and a number of unsuccessful attempts were made to use these on the general public. Asahara, from 1993 onwards, began to publicly talk of making sarin in order to protect Aum and fight its enemies (Asahara n.d.:231; Reader 2007:68-69).

Convinced that evil forces were out to destroy his movement, Asahara spoke of the inevitability of a final war, whose date he progressively brought closer to hand. He initially said that it would be in 1999 but later moved the date to 1997 and then to 1995, while emphasizing the spiritual legitimacy of killing anyone who opposed Aum or who refused to acknowledge its supreme spiritual nature (Reader 2000:179-80). The movement thus became increasingly geared towards violence and progressively more hostile to anyone who expressed any dissent towards it. In the years leading up to March, 1995, dissidents within the movement and opponents outside it were attacked (Reader 2000:198-206). The tensions inside the movement led to various defections and to attempts by Aum’s senior figures to recapture those who left. They did this in the belief that the world beyond its borders was consumed by evil and that simply living in that world meant acquiring negative karma that would lead to numerous aeons spent in the Buddhist hells after death. The only way to avoid such post-death horrors was to remain in Aum and perform its austerities under the guidance of Asahara so as to accumulate good karma that would enable one to achieve a better rebirth. As a result, members who tried to leave were often forcibly stopped from so doing or were kidnapped and brought back to Kamikuishiki in order to “save” them (Reader 2000:10-16).

This growing culture of violence was also reflected in Asahara’s apocalyptic visions, which became increasingly stark as the expected date of the end-times came closer. Aum publications became suffused with graphic images of a final war, while members chanted songs in praise of sarin, and the movement moved onto a war footing while devoting increasing resources to its attempts at weapons’ acquisition. In June, 1994, Aum declared its secession from the Japan state and announced the formation of a “sacred government” headed by Asahara as its sacred leader. At the same time, it carried out a sarin gas attack in Matsumoto, central Japan, to strike at a group of judges administering a court case involving Aum (Reader 2000:200, 208-11; Hardacre 2007:191). The attack killed seven people, although Aum’s involvement in the attack was not recognized at the time. However, evidence began to accumulate and be reported in the press connecting Aum with the attack. Other criminal acts by members of the movement, such as the kidnapping of the brother of a devotee (in order, it is believed, to acquire funds to help finance Aum’s costly weapons-making activities), threw further suspicion on the movement. During this period, too, Asahara’s pronouncements were suffused with paranoid images, to the extent that he may well have been undergoing some form of mental collapse. In March, 1995, it became clear that the police were about to take action. On March 20, 1995, Aum devotees, under Asahara’s direction, carried out a sarin attack at Kasumigaseki station, the subway station at the heart of the government district in Tokyo, killing thirteen people and injuring thousands. It was considered to be either the first act in the cosmic war mentioned above or, more likely, an attempt to disrupt the police, whose headquarters were adjacent to the subway station attacked (Reader 2000:211-26).

Two days after the attack, on March 22 1995, the police mounted mass raids on Aum’s main commune at Kamikuishiki and on its centers throughout Japan. Over the months that followed, hundreds of members were arrested, including the movement’s entire hierarchy. On May 16, 1995, Asahara was arrested. By that time, some senior figures, such as Hayashi Ikuo, who had been one of the subway attackers, had made full confessions and had alerted the police to earlier crimes committed by the movement, such as the killing of the lawyer Sakamoto and his family. A succession of trials ensued, in which Asahara (who largely refused to cooperate with the court and with his lawyers, and who appears to have undergone a general mental collapse) and twelve other key figures who had been involved in Aum’s killings and in the manufacture of its sarin were sentenced to death. During July 2018 Asahara and twelve senior figures in Aum, having been convicted of murder and conspiracy to murder, were executed. Over one hundred others received prison sentences, and some remain incarcerated (Ramzy 2018).

After the events of 1995, most of Aum’s members left the movement, and it was later stripped of its legal status as a religious organization. Initially, too, the government discussed whether to proscribe it completely, but this step was not taken due to concerns about the civil liberties of members who, under Japanese constitutional law, are guaranteed freedom of religious worship. A small group of devotees, including members of Asahara’s family and some devotees who were released from prison after serving their sentences, have maintained the faith, while renouncing Aum’s teachings that legitimated violence and distancing themselves from Asahara himself. They changed the
movement’s name to Aleph in 2000 as a way of further breaking from their past, while liquidating all Aum’s remaining assets to provide compensation for its victims. Subsequently Aleph has itself undergone further changes, including secessions. On outcomes of these secessions was the formation of Hikari no Wa in 2007 by Jōyū Fumihiro, perhaps the most senior figure in Aum who had not been directly involved in Aum’s violence (although he was incarcerated for a while on charges of perjury).

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

The above narrative of Aum’s leader and the group’s history indicates many of the key doctrinal issues surrounding the movement, and they cannot be separated from the visions of its leader or the ways in which the movement developed over its brief period of activity. Aum’s teachings were a product of its leader’s visions, but they drew also on aspects of Buddhist teaching, coupled with millennial thinking, concepts about the existence of hells and of negative karma that could threaten humanity, and beliefs in the importance of performing ascetic practices to purify the body and mind and guard against bad karma. Critically, too, the teachings increasingly focused on the notion that Aum alone was true, that it possessed absolute truth, and that its guru’s position was as a supreme spiritual master, which gave him and his devotees the right to punish those who opposed them.

Over the period between 1984 and 1995, Aum’s teachings were outlined by Asahara in numerous sermons and books, which, taken as a set of historical documents, also serve as an indicator of how experiences in Aum impacted on the movement and influenced its doctrinal development. In particular, the increasing pessimism of its teachings and the turn to violent confrontation with the world at large were underpinned by doctrinal changes that were themselves in part responses to the problems the movement faced. The key document in this context is the Vajrayana kōsu. Kyōgaku shisutemu kyōhon, a photocopied document consisting of fifty-seven lectures given by Asahara between the late 1980s and 1994 (Asahara, n.d.). Never published officially as a single entity, it contained sections from many of his published works over the period and was used as a training manual for senior disciples. The text contains the basis of Asahara’s teachings, including his millennial visions, beliefs in an imminent cosmic war of good against evil, and the belief that Aum could justifiably kill enemies because they stood in the way of truth. The text also outlined Asahara’s interpretations of Vajrayāna Buddhism (the form of Buddhism Aum claimed to adhere to) in which he argued that his teachings took Aum out of the realms of normative morality and into a higher spiritual realm where anything is permitted as a means of advancing the truth and bringing spiritual salvation (Shimazono 1997; Reader 2000). A critical aspect of Aum’s doctrinal structure was that it, and its leader Asahara (who was referred to in Aum as a sacred master sonshi and as guru (with Aum using this Indian term as a Japanese loanword), possessed absolute truth and that all other religions (and, indeed, anyone who rejected Aum’s and Asahara’s teachings) were false.

Aum was millennial in nature and had a polarized view of the world, which was divided into the forces of good and evil, and it saw itself as fighting a spiritual war against evil. It taught that the world was mired in materialism and dominated by corrupt influences (amongst which it included the U.S. and Japanese governments and many groups that are often included in millennialist conspiracy theories, such as the Freemasons, Illuminati and Jews). Aum, like many other Japanese new religions at the time, considered that the world was enveloped in a crisis that might lead to cataclysm and apocalypse by the end of the twentieth century, due to global war, environmental destruction and natural disasters (Reader 2000:47-52). The roots of this destruction were grounded in humanity’s nature; the world had become too materialistic, people had lost sight of their true spiritual nature and the bad karma that had been created was leading to disaster. The materialism of the world was such that it tainted all who lived in it, and only by following a path of truth and righteousness (in essence by becoming an Aum devotee and following the on true guru) and by engaging in strict ascetic practices to purify the body and eradicate bad karma, could one be saved and avoid falling into the lower realms at death. The concept of hells was important, and Asahara’s sermons in the Vajrayāna kōsu. Kyōgaku shisutemu kyōhon make repeated references to their horrors and to the fates of those who fail to perform spiritual austerities. This fear of the hells was a factor in the emphasis Aum placed on austerities, which were seen as necessary to continually purify the body and save it from the negative karma that surrounded everyone living in the everyday world. The material world in which everyone (apart from Aum in its communes) lived, was seen as a “den of evil” (akugō no sōkotsu), and it was only through leaving this world and following the guidance of a true guru that one could achieve enlightenment, purify the body and be saved from such negative karma. Anyone who failed to do this was an enemy of truth, unworthy of salvation and, ultimately, worthy of punishment (Asahara, nd, passim; Reader 2000:10-16).

The most critical doctrine in Aum, in terms of its violent activities, was that of poa. This term, derived initially from a Tibetan term, refers to the notion that the spirits of the deceased can advance towards salvation and better rebirths in the next life with the guidance of advanced spiritual practitioners who will perform rituals for them to this end. This reflects a standard East Asian Buddhist activity in which ritual services are performed by Buddhist priests when someone dies in order to purify the deceased of their bad karma in this world and help them attain a better rebirth. In Aum, Asahara performed poa rituals for members who died, and he did them at the behest of members, for their relatives as well. Taguchi’s planned revelation of Majima’s accidental death, which would have jeopardized the viability of the movement, caused a drastic modification of the concept. If Taguchi had gone public and undermined the “truth” and upset Aum’s mission of world salvation, he would, Asahara believed, acquire terrible negative karma and would thus have to spend aeons in various hells after death. To stop this (and to protect Aum’s mission), Taguchi was killed, thereby “saving” him from acquiring endless bad karma and allowing him a favorable rebirth. The term used to describe the killing was poa  It had become modified from being a ritual performance aimed at improving the karmic merit of someone who had died, to a process of “saving” someone by intervening in their lives (i.e. killing them) to stop them committing grave karmic sins. Being killed, which Aum referred to as carrying out an act of poa on someone (poa suru), was to be blessed with the karmic intervention of a spiritually superior being, who would thus bestow merit on the person killed and enable that person to achieve a better rebirth (Asaahara nd, passim, but especially p. 286). Since Aum regarded all who did not support its message as “enemies of the truth” (shinri no teki) and saw everyone who lived in the material world as being subject to negative karma that would necessarily take them into the hells at death, this interpretation meant that anyone who lived in the material world and did not belong to Aum, was liable to incur grave karmic consequences. Killing them was, in Aum’s eyes, a beneficial act that would bring them merit in the hereafter. This doctrine was one of the foundations on which Aum’s acts, real and attempted, of mass murder was founded, along with its millennial views that a final and real war between good and evil was inevitable and necessary, and that anything was permitted to Aum in its mission of bringing about world transformation (Shimazono 1997; Reader 2000:18-19, 145-46).

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Aum was never a major mass movement. At its peak it may have had 10,000 members in Japan, but its core centered on a smaller number of people who renounced the world and lived as monastics in Aum’s communes (shukkesha). There were around 1,100 of these by 1995. Overseas, it only gained some success in Russia, although attempts were made to develop centers in Germany, the U.S. and Sri Lanka as well. The failure to acquire a significant membership was a factor in Aum’s turn against the world and in convincing Asahara that most people were not capable or ready to accept the truth. Yet, while its membership was relatively small by the standards of Japanese new religions, it was highly motivated, articulate and educated, with many of its senior figures graduates of elite universities and/or with professional qualifications. They included qualified doctors, such as Nakagawa Tomomasa and Hayashi Ikuo, the latter of whom was a senior heart surgeon; lawyers, such as Aoyama Yoshinobu; and science graduates, such as Endō Seiichi and Tsuchiya Masami (who were at the heart of its chemical weapons’ program). All were all involved in Aum’s criminal activities.

Aum was centered on Asahara’s charismatic leadership and teachings, and asserted that he was the epitome of truth (Reader 2000:32-33). It was both communal (in that members who renounced the world, lived together in Aum centers and communes) and hierarchical in nature, with different levels of shukkesha. Ascent through the hierarchy was linked to devotion to Asahara and readiness to engage in Aum’s initiation practices and to perform extreme ascetic practices (Reader 2000:84-88). While this emphasis on extreme austerities and devotion proved a barrier to mass recruitment, and thus contributed to Aum’s gradual estrangement from society at large, it facilitated the emergence of a very loyal and zealous core of disciples. They were driven by an absolute dedication to Asahara and a belief in their own spiritual powers and in their special mission to bring about world salvation. They shared a disdain for and an indifference to those who did not follow their path. They readily acquiesced in the hierarchic structures of Aum, which gave them a degree of power and authority and confirmed, in their eyes, their spiritual prowess (Reader 2000:101-25).

Such hierarchic structures also isolated Asahara from the rank and file. A cohort of senior figures, such as Murai Hideo and Hayakawa Yoshihide (both of whom oversaw aspects of Aum’s weapons acquisition programmes), along with Asahara’s wife and others, gathered around the leader and became conduits for his orders. The hierarchic structure that developed also shielded the activities of different parts of the organisation from each other; many people, even in the upper echelons of the movement, appear to have been unaware of the extent of Aum’s secretive weapons’ making program at Kamikuishiki. There was also rivalry between senior disciples, which made them more zealous and ready to commit atrocities or to suggest potential targets for poa activities so as to curry favor with Asahara.

In June, 1994, Aum revised its organizational structures in a way that mimicked the structures of the Japanese government. Aum declared it had established an alternative government so as to prepare for Armageddon. This “government” consisted of twenty-two ministries; each was headed by a senior devotee who thus had major control of different areas of Aum activity, under the ultimate supervision of Asahara, who was declared the “ sacred ruler” (shinsei hōō) (Hardacre 2007:191; Reader 2000:200). The title implied being a theocratic ruler incorporating the (former) spiritual/mystical role of the Japanese Emperor, along with the temporal one of Japan’s former military leaders (shogun). This organizational structure remained in existence until the subway attack and the subsequent police raids on Aum. The leaders in charge of the various “ministries” were prominent among those arrested and charged with Aum’s crimes.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Aum’s turn to criminality, outlined above, has had massive repercussions in Japan and beyond. It provides a clear example of a new religious movement that, driven by extreme religious beliefs coupled with a series of internal disasters, became violent externally and internally primarily due to endogenous issues that arose within the movement. While Aum had numerous conflicts with those outside the movement, and had problems with the law in Japan well before March, 1995, these conflicts were greatly spurred by its own intransigence, while its initial violence (the beatings of members, from around 1998, and the unforeseen death of a member as a result of enforced austerities) occurred prior to any serious external pressure (Reader 1999). Aum also provides a salient example of how a millennial movement can become increasingly catastrophic in its orientations, how a charismatic leader can become increasingly paranoid, and how a movement can develop doctrines that it believes are essential for saving people, but that in reality justify killing them. It thus raises major questions about how religious beliefs and practices can lead to, or be associated with, violence and mass murder.

In legal and political terms, too, the “Aum Affair” (Oumu jiken) raises many challenging issues. In Japan, the affair has raised major questions about definitions of “religion” in the public sphere. The Japanese Constitution guarantees freedom of religious association and worship, while other laws grant tax concessions to religious groups, based in the notion that their activities are a force for the public good. Aum’s use of tax-exempt resources to finance its weapons program has led to calls for major reforms to these laws, while there have been continuing debates about whether there should be state-imposed limits on religious freedom. There have been proposals about redefining religion to differentiate between “orthodox” religions (i.e. those that adhere to and are associated with long-established traditions) and “cults” (i.e. new movements that deviate from Japanese norms). While such changes have not occurred legally, this notion of a differentiation between “religions” and “cults” has become quite prevalent in the media and in public perceptions. The laws governing religious organisations in general have, however, been modified in the wake of the affair, and they have made it harder for any religious group to acquire registered religious status and the protections and tax concessions that go with it (Mullins 2001; Baffelli and Reader 2012).

Questions were raised about proscribing Aum completely and about whether that would thereby infringe the constitutionally guaranteed religious freedoms of members who wished, even after March, 1995, to remain faithful to the movement. Eventually it was decided that Aum could not be formally proscribed as such, but its status as a registered religious organization and its tax-exemptions were withdrawn. New laws enabling the authorities to closely monitor it, and the groups that emerged from it, have been instituted. A number of people (estimated to be around 1,000) remain linked to Aum’s offshoots and retain aspects of their faith. They have renounced violence, and two groups have emerged out of the ashes of Aum: Aleph and Hikari no Wa (Baffelli 2012).

There has also been increased public hostility to religious organizations in general in the aftermath of the affair. Surveys indicate that many Japanese now consider “religion” to be dangerous and fear that joining a religious organization will leave them open to manipulation and to becoming involved in illegal activities. There is also considerable public support for increased surveillance of religions and for proscribing public religious proselytization, even as many religious organizations, notably new religions, have experienced declining memberships. There is a general notion that Aum might not have been unique but simply an example of the wider dangers of religion, and for many years the media engaged in searches for the “next Aum,” with numerous groups (none of which exhibited any violent tendencies) being labeled in such ways and subjected to public opprobrium. While in recent years this aspect of Aum’s aftermath has died down, the media continues to affix the label “cult” (karuto), which in Japanese has highly pejorative implications, to various religious groups that appear to not conform with mainstream social views (Reader 2004).

Outside of Japan, too, Aum has had a major impact both strategically and politically. It was the first case of the lethal use of chemical weapons by a non-government agency, and this has led to intensive study of Aum by various civil and law enforcement agencies worldwide, as well as having an influence on the policies of such agencies and governments. In the period prior to September, 2001 in particular, some in law enforcement circles considered that threats from small millennial groups armed with such weapons, would be the future of terrorism, and considerable resources were devoted to the issue and to gathering data on Aum and other groups that were feared to have similar millennial orientations (Feakes 2007; Reader 2012). It was focused on in various reports by intelligence agencies in the run-up to the year 2000, which looked at whether millennial movements might pose threats to public order at that time (Kaplan 2000). A number of public exercises designed to test public service responses to terror attacks on mass transport systems have been carried out on subway systems in cities such as London, invariably based in the assumption that such attacks will use sarin. The Aum case has also been used for political ends by governments in other parts of the world as an example of the “dangers” of religious freedom. The Chinese government has cited the case of Aum in this context when seeking to legitimate its crackdown on Falun Gong, for example. The Russian government has also cited Aum in this context when developing new laws aimed at overseeing religious movements in its country.

REFERENCES

Asahara Shōkō. 1992. Haiesuto danma (Oumu Shuppan).

Asahara Shōkō. (n.d. but probably 1994). Vajrayana kōsu. Kyōgaku shisutemu kyōhon.

Baffelli, Erica. 2012. “Hikari no Wa: A New Religion Recovering from Disaster.” Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 39:29-50.

Baffelli, Erica and Ian Reader. 2012. “ Impact and Ramifications: The Aftermath of the Aum Affair in the Japanese Religious Context.” Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 39:1-28.

Feakes, Duncan. 2007. “The Chemical Weapons Convention and the Biological Weapons Convention: Confronting the Threat of International Terrorism.” Pp. 116-57 in Terrorism and Weapons of Mass Destruction: Responding to the Challenge, edited by Ian Bellany. London: Routledge.

Hardacre, Helen. 2007. “Aum Shinrikyō and the Japanese Media: The Pied Piper Meets the Lamb of God.” History of Religions 47:171-204.

Kaplan, Jeffrey, ed. 2002. Millennial Violence: Past, Present and Future. London: Frank Cass.

Kumamoto Nichinichi Shinbun. 1995. Oumu Shinrikyō to mura no ronri. Fukuoka, Japan: Ashi Shobō.

Mullins, Mark R. 2001. “The Legal and Political Fallout of the “Aum Affair.” Pp. 71-86 in Religion and Social Crisis in Japan Understanding Japanese Society Through the Aum Affair, edited by Robert Kisala and Mark R. Mullins. Basingstoke, U.K.: Palgrave.

Pye, Michael. 1996. “Aum Shinrikyō: Can Religious Studies Cope?” Religion 26:261-70.

Ramzy, Austin. 2018. “Japan Executes Cult Leader Behind 1995 Sarin Gas Subway Attack.” New York Times, July 5. Accessed from https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/05/world/asia/japan-cult-execute-sarin.html on 5 July 2018.

Reader, Ian. 2012. “Globally Aum: The Aum Affair, Counterterrorism and Religion.” Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 39:177-96.

Reader, Ian. 2007. “Manufacturing the Means of Apocalypse: Aum Shinrikyo and the Acquisition of Weapons of Mass Destruction.” Pp. 53-80 in Terrorism and Weapons of Mass Destruction: Responding to the Challenge, edited by Ian Bellany. New York: Routledge.

Reader, Ian. 2004. “Consensus Shattered: Japanese Paradigm Shifts and Moral Panic in the Post-Aum Era.” Pp. 191-201 in New Religious Movements in the 21st Century: Legal, Political and Social Challenges in Global Perspective, edited by Philip Charles Lucas and Thomas Robbins. New York: Routledge.

Reader, Ian. 2000. Religious Violence in Contemporary Japan: The Case of Aum Shinrikyō. Richmond, U.K.: Curzon Press.

Reader, Ian. 1999. “Imagined Persecution: Aum Shinrikyō, Millennialism and the Legitimation of Violence.” Pp. 138-52 in Millennialism, Persecution and Violence: Historical Cases, edited by Catherine Wessinger. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press.

Shimazono Susumu. 1997. Gendai shūkyō no kanōsei: Oumu Shinrikyō to bōryoku. Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten.

Shimazono Susumu. 1995a. Aum Shinrikyō no kiseki. Tokyo: Iwanami Booklets, No. 379.

Shimazono Susumu. 1995b. “In the Wake of Aum: The Formation and Transformation of a Universe of Belief.” Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 22:343-80.

Takahashi Hidetoshi. 1996. Oumu kara no kikan. Tokyo: Sōshisha.

Takeuchi Seiichi. 1995. Fujisan fumoto no tatakai: Oumu 2000 nichi sensō. Tokyo: KK Besuto Serazu.

Young, Richard Fox. 1995. “Lethal Achievement: Fragments of a Response to the Aum Shinrikyō Affair.” Japanese Religions 20:230-45.

SUPPLEMENTARY RESOURCES

The above references include accounts of Aum’s interactions with local communities, written from the perspective of those communities (Kumamoto Nichinichi Shinbun 1995 and Takeuchi 1995) plus an account by a former believer (Takahashi 1996) of life inside Aum. For further accounts of life inside Aum, the following two books by senior Aum disciples convicted of involvement in murder and other of Aum’s crimes are:

Hayakawa Kiyohide. 2005. Watashi ni totte Oumu to wa nan datta noka Popurasha.

Hayashi Ikuo. 1998. Oumu to watashi. Tokyo, Bungeishunjū.

For Asahara’s teaching, the main source is the above-cited Asahara Shōkō (n.d. but probably 1994) Vajrayana kōsu. Kyōgaku shisutemu kyōhon. An extensive extensive bibliography of Asahara’s and Aum’s publications is provided in Reader 2000:283-86 (cited above). While Aum books have, since the sarin attack, become difficult to find, the following two volumes published just before and around the time of the subway attack, illustrative of Asahara’s increasingly pessimistic apocalyptic visions:

Asahara Shōkō. 1995. Hiizuru kuni wazawaichikashi. Tokyo: Oumu Shuppan.

Asahara Shōkō 1995 Bōkoku Nihon no kanashimi. Tokyo: Oumu Shuppan. The former was published in an English version as
Asahara Shōkō. 1995. Disaster Approaches the Land of the Rising Sun. Tokyo: Aum Publishing.

For further discussions of the Aum Affair and Aum’s activities and teachings, see:

Lifton Robert Jay. 1999. Destroying the World to Save It: Aum Shinrikyo, Apocalyptic Violence, and the New Global Terrorism. (New York: Holt. This book takes a largely psychological approach to the affair.

Reader, Ian. 1996. A Poisonous Cocktail? Aum Shinrikyō’s Path to Violence. Copenhagen: NIAS Books). This is the first academic book on the affair, which is based largely on media reports and analyses.

Reader, Ian 2002. “Spectres and Shadows: Aum Shinrikyo and the Road to Megiddo.” Terrorism and Political Violence 14:147-86. This article examines Aum in the context of various security agency reports on the dangers of millennial movements.

Serizawa Shunsuke. 1997. Oumu genshō no kaidoku. Tokyo: Byakujunsha. This is one of many Japanese volumes produced in the immediate aftermath of the sarin attack, looking at Aum’s history, teachings and activities.

Shimada Hiromi. 2000. Oumu: naze shūkyō ga terorisumu o unda noka 2001. Tokyo: Transview. This book is written by a scholar whose earlier positive writings about Aum caused controversy and led to his dismissal from a Japanese university after the sarin attack (an issue covered in Reader 2004, cited above) and who in this volume sought to answer why a movement he had earlier examined as an idealistic Buddhist organization, turned to terrorism.

On the issues and challenges produced by Aum and its aftermath, the following two volumes are valuable:

Kisala, Robert J. and Mark R. Mullins, eds. 2001 Religion and Social Crisis in Japan: Understanding Japanese Society through the Aum Affair. Basingstoke, U.K.: Palgrave. This book draws on early academic analyses of the affair and looks at its legal, political and security ramifications.

Japanese Journal of Religious Studies, 2012, Vol. 39/2, “Aftermath: Impact and Ramifications of the Aum Affair” is guest edited by Erica Baffelli and Ian Reader, and covers the ways in which the Aum Affair has affected Japan and had impacts beyond its shores. It covers general public and media responses and hostility to religion, the formation of post-Aum offshoots of Aum, the impact on other new religions, politics, nationalist movements and popular culture, and Aum’s impact on global terrorist policies. The articles in it are as follows:

Baffelli, Erica and Ian Reader. “Introduction: Impact and Ramifications: The Aftermath of the Aum Affair in the Japanese Religious Context.” Pp. 1-28.

Baffelli, Erica. “Hikari no Wa: A New Religion Recovering from Disaster.” Pp. 29-50.

McLaughlin, Levi. “Did Aum Change Everything? What Soka Gakkai Before, During, and After the Aum Shinrikyo Affair Tells Us About the Persistent “Otherness” of New Religions in Japan.” Pp. 51-76.

Klein, Axel. “Twice Bitten, Once Shy: Religious Organizations and Politics after the Aum Attack.” Pp. 77-98.

Mullins, Mark R., “The Neo-Nationalist Response to the Aum Crisis: A Return of Civil Religion and Coercion in the Public Sphere?” Pp. 99-126.

Thomas, Jolyon Baraka. “Horrific “Cults” and Comic Religion Manga after Aum.” Pp. 127-52.

Dorman, Benjamin. “Scholarly Reactions to the Aum and Waco Incidents.” Pp. 153-78.

Reader, Ian. “ Globally Aum: The Aum Affair, Counterterrorism, and Religion.” Pp. 179-98.

Post Date:
24 December 2013

AUM SHINRIKYO VIDEO CONNECTIONS

Share

Alcoholics Anonymous

Alcoholics Anonymous

Founders: William Griffith Wilson (Bill W.); Dr. Robert Holbrook Smith (Dr. Bob)

Dates of Life: November 26, 1895 – January 24, 1971; August 8, 1879 – November 16, 1950

Birth Place: East Dorset, Vermont; Johnsbury, Vermont

Year Founded: 1935

Sacred or Revered Texts: In 1939, the fledgling organization published its basic textbook, Alcoholics Anonymous. This volume, known affectionately as The Big Book, continues to be the primary text of the group today.

Size of Group: As of the writing of this page, AA reports 2,000,000 recovered alcoholics worldwide. For updated figures and geographical breakdown see Membership.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

William Griffith Wilson, later known simply as “Bill W.” to thousands, was born in a small room behind a bar on a chilly Vermont November day in 1895. His parent’s marriage was far from happy, and in 1905, Gilman Wilson deserted his family. Over the early years of his life Wilson attained a secondary school education, lived through the tragic death of his first love, survived a brief stint in France during WWI, and married Lois Burnham.

After the war, Wilson settled down to an uneventful career on Wall Street. After the infamous crash of 1929, he began his own downward spiral. Wilson’s drunkenness intensified with the passage of time. Over the course of 1933-1934 he was hospitalized four times in New York’s Charles B. Towns Hospital (Kurtz: 14). There Wilson was often treated by Dr. William D. Silkworth, who helped Wilson to understand alcoholism as a disease and not just a malady of the mind, a concept that would later figure heavily into AA doctrine. Throughout this period of five years, Lois continued to support him.

Around his birthday in 1934, Wilson was visited by his friend and fellow alcoholic Ebby Thatcher. Thatcher told him about the Oxford Group and the principles of the organization. Wilson accompanied Ebby to a meeting of the Oxford Group led by Reverend Sam Shoemaker (Pittman: 155).

The Oxford Group of the 1920s and 1930s, founded by Dr. Frank N.D. Buchman, was a loosely organized group who recognized no board of officers. The groups operated instead on “God-control” instead of hierarchies of men, and were committed to realizing a world governed by people who were governed by God (Melton: 957).

Despite participation in the fellowship, on December 11, 1934 Wilson was admitted at 2:30 p.m. to Towns Hospital once again (Pittman: 152). On his second or third evening in the facility, Wilson experienced an intensely spiritual realization of God that he would thereafter call his “Hot Flash” (Pittman: 153). After this realization of a higher power, Wilson was able to fully embrace the Oxford Group’s fellowship and attain sobriety.

After drying out Wilson, supported by Lois ever since 1929, began to seek work in 1935. His job search led him to Akron, Ohio in early May (Kurtz: 26). Sitting alone in the hotel lobby on Mother’s Day and panicking at the need to get drunk, Wilson called the local Episcopalian minister, asking to be put in touch with any Akron Oxford Group members. Reverend Tunks gave him the number of Henrietta Seiberling, a long-term Oxford member. Wilson called her and learned of her personal project for the past two years: sobering up her best friend’s husband, Dr. Robert Holbrook Smith (Kurtz: 27). Bill W. and Dr. Bob met for the first time later that day at Seiberling’s house. The two native Vermonters bonded instantly, swapping stories and experiences.

Dr. Smith was born in August 1879 to rigidly religious parents. At age nine he found a jug of alcohol under a bush and took his first drink (Kurtz: 30). Smith left home to attend Dartmouth, and was freed from his parent’s totalitarian control. He resolved never to attend church and began to drink. After deciding that he wanted to be a doctor he transferred to Michigan State’s pre-med program. At Ann Arbor his drinking began to interfere with his life, eventually causing him to drop out of school to dry out (Kurtz: 30). He eventually earned his M.D. from Rush Medical College in Chicago, and found himself in a prestigious internship at the City Hospital in Akron. For the first two years in Akron, Dr. Smith was so busy he stayed dry (Kurtz: 30). Eventually he began drinking again and admitted himself into at least a dozen sanatoria. Even the passage of the Eighteenth Amendment was not able to stop Dr. Smith, as he had access to liquor for medical reasons. For seventeen years, he lived a drunken nightmare dragging his wife Anne and two children along in his wake. Anne’s friend Henrietta suggested she bring Bob to the Oxford Group meetings. Dr. Smith initially agreed, but balked at the group’s spiritual nature. He continued to attend meetings, and also continued to drink (Kurtz: 32). Upon meeting Bill W., Dr. Smith understood the Oxford Group’s principle of fellowship with sudden clarity through Bill W.’s understanding of him. He then began three intensive weeks with the Oxford Group (Kurtz: 32).

Bill W. and Dr. Bob joined forces to understand alcoholism as a disease. They drew on the principles and practices of the Oxford Group, Dr. Silkworth’s influence from New York’s Towns Hospital, as well as the work of Jung to begin their own fellowship and write Alcoholics Anonymous. From Jung they adapted the idea of the necessity of conversion to counteract the hopelessness of alcoholism (Kurtz: 34). The conversion of AA lies in the transition from drunkenness to a sobriety as more than a state of not drinking. The conversion must move the alcoholic into a different life that has no need for alcohol. Bill W. and Dr. Bob went to work in The Akron City Hospital and converted another drunk to sobriety. These three men formed the first fellowship based on the principles which would become AA. Bill W. remained in Akron long enough to finish his business and participate in the expanding group. Upon returning to New York, he founded his own group at home. In 1939, four years after the meeting of Bill W. and Dr. Bob, three groups existed in Akron, Cleveland, and New York. Over the course of those four years, the three groups produced 100 sober alcoholics 1 .

Although living apart, Dr. Bob and Bill W. remained in close contact and began writing Alcoholics Anonymous, the so-called “Big Book.” Bill W. began writing the book, and sent the chapters to Dr. Bob for editing and ideas (Pittman: 180). He also consulted his New York members and sent chapters to the Cleveland organization for contributions. At its April 1939 publication, the Big Book was 400 pages in length, outlining the Twelve Steps of recovery and continuing case histories of recovered members (Pittman: 181). The book and growing groups attracted favorable media attention across the nation, including a particularly influential series of articles by the Cleveland Plain Dealer 1 . In 1941, the Saturday Evening Post also ran an excellent article on AA, evoking an enormous positive response. 1 AA grew increasingly rapidly after nationwide press and the extensive distribution of Alcoholics Anonymous by the new Alcoholic Foundation created by Bill W. and Dr. Bob with the financial assistance of the Friends of John D. Rockefeller. 1 Between 1940 and 1950, AA made a hectic transition from isolated local groups to a nationwide organization. Bill W. focused on developing a successful formula for AA structure and functioning that eventually congealed into the Twelve Traditions, a blueprint for non-coercive management for the growing organization (Ellis 73). Meanwhile Dr. Bob concentrated his efforts on the clinical application of AA treatment. Through their combined efforts, Alcoholics Anonymous began to make the attainment of sobriety into a mass-produced system. By 1950, 100,000 recovered alcoholics affiliated with AA could be found worldwide. 1

In 1950, the movement underwent a transition that resulted in the foundation of the organization we know today. Shortly after speaking emphatically for continued organization to hold the fellowship together and focused at the first AA convention in Cleveland, Dr. Bob died. As a result of his words in 1951, the AA General Service Board of Alcoholics Anonymous was created with delegates from all states and Canadian provinces 1 . The remote branches of AA were thus made accountable and networked into the larger organization, thereby assuring for the future AA’s function as a massive international yet non-hierarchical organization with a single goal: sobriety. In 1951, another landmark development of the organization occurred, the now global AA Grapevine magazine was put into publication, placing AA literature and thought into a periodical media. Since then, AA has become impressively global. AA’s way of life has today transcended most barriers of race, creed and language 1 . A World Service Meeting, started in 1969, has been held biennially since 1972 1 .

The smashing success of Alcoholics Anonymous started a cascade of spin-off groups known collectively as the recovery group movement. One of the first groups sprouting from AA, and an excellent example, is the genesis of Narcotics Anonymous in 1947 3 . The core of the Narcotics Anonymous recovery program is a series of personal activities known as the Twelve Steps, closely adapted from Alcoholics Anonymous 3 . These steps include admitting there is a problem, seeking help, self-appraisal, confidential Self-disclosure, making amends where harm has been done, and working with other drug addicts who want to recover 3 . Central to the program is an emphasis on what is referred to as a “spiritual awakening,” borrowing the Jungian idea of conversion, and its practical value in addiction recovery 3 . Like other spin-off groups, NA also incorporates AA’s Twelve Traditions into its concept of governance on the levels of individual group leadership and interaction with a non-hierarchical international organizing body 3 . Another, less successful schism from AA, the group movement Synanon did not copy AA’s non-hierarchical structure and opted instead for the charismatic leadership of Charles Dederich (Bufe: 102). In the early seventies Synanon declared itself a church and began a series of practices including mass vasectomies, beatings of would-be runaways, and even the attempted murder of critics (Bufe: 102). The adoption of the Twelve Traditions prevents AA or any similar groups from one individual’s abuse of power, as happened in Synanon. In addition to groups closely and successfully modeled on AA such as Workaholics Anonymous founded in 1983, Gamblers Anonymous started in 1957, and Overeaters Anonymous from 1960, other AA inspired organizations are less recovery oriented and instead capitalize on the fellowship and sharing principles of AA. These groups include Parents Anonymous founded in 1970, Humor Anonymous and even Knappers Anonymous since 1996.

Today Alcoholics Anonymous is administered via two operating bodies:

The first organization, A.A. World Services Inc. centered in the General Service Office in New York City, employs 84 workers to keep in touch with local groups, with AA groups in treatment and correctional facilities, with members and groups overseas, and with the thousands of “outsiders” who turn to AA each year for information on the recovery program. AA Conference-approved literature is prepared, published, and distributed through this office 2 .

The second group, The A.A. Grapevine, Inc., publishes the AA Grapevine, the Fellowship’s monthly international journal that has a circulation of about 125,000 in the U.S., Canada, and other countries. The Grapevine also produces a selection of specialty items, principally cassette tapes and anthologies of magazine articles 2 . The two operating corporations are responsible to a board of trustees (General Service Board of AA created in 1951), of whom seven are nonalcoholic friends of the Fellowship, and 14 are AA members 2 .

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

The famous Twelve Steps are the core of the AA experience. The twelve steps are drawn directly from the Oxford Group that Bill W. and Dr. Bob participated in before branching out to create AA (Bufe: 62). In the Oxford Group these steps were used as a cure for sin; Bill W. and Dr. Bob later adapted them to serve as a cure for alcoholism (Bufe: 62). The power of the AA Twelve Steps has snowballed since their codification in the early forties. Today the past success of the Twelve Steps serves as a powerful motivational factor for an individual starting on the road to sobriety (Bufe: 64). Knowledge of massive success in the past helps the individual believe that he can accomplish a life-transforming move to sobriety as well. The reputation of organization gives hope for the new member setting out on his own road. This highly successful organization in its simplest form operates when a recovered alcoholic passes along the story of his or her own problem drinking, describes the sobriety he or she has found in AA, and invites a newcomer to join the informal Fellowship 4 . In accordance with the Stark and Bainbridge definition of Client Cult, no effort is made to weld the membership into a social movement 6 . In fact the Anonymity aspect of the program prevents AA from ever becoming more organized into a cult movement lifestyle. Many members of AA continue to practice religion in an organized church while interacting with AA for the specific compensator of sobriety. AA’s membership participation in a church or organized religion, and also the specific compensator of leaving drinking behind, are also both aspects of the organization that fit Stark and Bainbridge’s definition of Client Cult 6 . Instead of building and expanding power, the heart of AA is contained in the application of the Twelve Steps describing the experience of the earliest members of the Society 4 :

We admitted we were powerless over alcohol — that our lives had become unmanageable.

Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity.

Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him.

Made a searching and fearless moral inventory of ourselves.

Admitted to God, to ourselves and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.

Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.

Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.

Made a list of all persons we had harmed, and became willing to make amends to them all.

Made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do so would injure them or others.

Continued to take personal inventory and when we were wrong promptly admitted it.

Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us and the power to carry that out.

Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these steps, we tried to carry this message to alcoholics and to practice these principles in all our affairs 4 .

Half of the Twelve Steps explicitly mention “God,” “A power greater than ourselves,” or “Him,” giving the organization a distinctly religious overtone (Bufe: 63). The Twelve Traditions also have a decidedly religious tone, referring to “a loving God,” “He,” and “Himself.” 4 The references to God, the concept of the individual powerless against alcohol in the first step, the confession seen in the fifth step, and the idea of “Continuance” in the tenth and twelfth steps come directly from the Oxford Group, which was an evangelical Christian movement (Bufe: 62). The Oxford Group, a “First Century Fellowship,” attempted to duplicate the fellowship of the Apostles 10 . AA finds its direct roots in evangelical Christianity, and is clearly a religious organization (Bufe: 82). In spite of AA’s straightforwardly religious origins, beliefs, and practices, it presents itself as a non-religious organization and not “allied with any religious organization.” 5 AA further says that in its belief structure

The majority of A.A. members believe that we have found the solution to our drinking problem not through individual willpower, but through a power greater than ourselves. However, everyone defines this power as he or she wishes. Many people call it God, others think it is the A.A. group, still others don’t believe in it at all. There is room in A.A. for people of all shades of belief and nonbelief. 5

AA does not require or force any aspect of the Twelve steps on any of the membership to allow each individual to create his own AA experience. Newcomers are not asked to accept or follow these Twelve Steps in their entirety if they feel unwilling or unable to do so 4 . They will usually be asked to keep an open mind, to attend meetings at which recovered alcoholics describe their personal experiences in achieving sobriety, and to read A.A. literature describing and interpreting the AA program 4 . Senior AA members will also point out all available medical testimony indicating that alcoholism is a progressive illness, that it cannot be cured in the ordinary sense of the term, but that it can be arrested through total abstinence from alcohol in any form 4 .

AA offers explanations on both religious and scientific fronts, resulting from the natures and conversions of the founders Bill W. and Dr. Bob. Bill W. attained sobriety mainly through a religious experience while a scientific explanation of alcoholism as a disease proved more effective for Dr. Bob. Thus AA as a global organization provides a number of belief structures and interpretations that the membership can use to their best advantage, but on the local level, AA can take on a more homogeneous approach.

Part of the strength of AA is the importance of the autonomy of the individual groups laid out in step four of the Twelve Traditions. The autonomy of various groups often results in highly Christian AA groups in some areas and more agnostic groups in other areas, depending on the backgrounds of each group’s membership. The official beliefs of AA as expressed in AA literature and on the official Alcoholics Anonymous web site are non-religious in nature and open to free interpretation of the terms “God” and “Higher power” et cetera, while AA in practice can become highly religious in nature.

ISSUES/CONTROVERSIES
For 40 years since its inception in 1935, AA and the Twelve Steps were the only national self-help organization for alcoholics. The religious aspect of the program was a matter of concern for some agnostic, atheist, and religious minority alcoholics who needed help but didn`t want to betray their spiritual beliefs. In 1975 sociologist Jean Kirkpatrick, after trying AA twice and feeling it was too male-dominated, founded Women For Sobriety, a program designed to address the self-esteem issues in female alcoholics. Kirkpatrick solidified her program into the Thirteen Statements of Acceptance, aimed at creating positive self-esteem rather than re-building it. There is not a trace of religiosity in the statements, proving WFS the first significant dissatisfaction and subsequent departure from AA (Bufe: 124). In 1988, WFS expanded to help men in a separate program, Men For Sobriety.

Another large national secular alternative to AA, Save Our Selves (also known as Secular Organizations for Sobriety), arose in 1985. Founded by Jim Christopher, SOS has no structured recovery program of steps or acceptances and is non- religious in nature. Both organizations meet in homes and non-religious places whenever possible, and have grown into national organizations through books, pamphlets, positive press, and web-sites. WFS, MFS, and SOS are all alternatives to AA, and are made up of non-religious refugees from AA (Bufe: 126).

Until Jack Trimpey founded Rational Recovery Center in 1986, organizations existed as alternatives to AA and, its religious nature, but not in war against it. Trimpey, a licensed clinical social worker and recovered alcoholic, began Rational Recovery, which remained very small until it’s affiliation with the American Humanist Association in 1989 (Bufe: 126). AHA helped Trimpey publish his book Rational Recovery from Alcoholism: The Small Book and publish his newsletter The Journal of Rational Recovery (Bufe: 126). RR strives to enable alcoholics to remain sober independently of any organization, and has launched the cancellation of the recovery group movement. RR insists on professional involvement in an alcoholic’s recovery, and unleashes an assault on AA and other groups that perpetuate membership and thus dependency. Trimpey fuels the anti-AA movement by publishing such articles as Alcoholics Anonymous: The Embodiment of the Beast. Alcoholics Anonymous: The Embodiment of the Beast includes a discussion of the unreliable nature of AA’s “Higher power” as well as Trimpey’s thoughts on Bill W. and Dr. Bob’s relationship to alcohol and each other, suggesting that AA transfers dependence from alcohol to the group and allows the individual to give up responsibility for his disease 7 . Trimpey suggests instead his program of AVRT, best described by Trimpey himself instructing the reader to:

Observe your thoughts and feelings, positive and negative, about drinking or using. Thoughts and feelings which support continued use are called the Addictive Voice (AV); those which support abstinence are you. When you recognize and understand your AV, it becomes not-you, but ‘it’, an easily-defeated enemy that has been causing you to drink. All it wants is pleasure. ‘I want a drink,’ becomes, ‘It wants a drink.’ Think to yourself, ‘I will never drink again,’ and listen for its reaction. Your negative thoughts and feelings are your AV talking back to you. Now, think, ‘I will drink/use whenever I please.’ Your pleasant feelings are also the AV, which is in control. Recovery is not a process; it is an event. The magic word is ‘Never,’ as in, ‘I will never drink/use again.’ Recognition defeats short-term desire and abstinence soon becomes effortless. Complete separation of ‘you’ from ‘it’ leads to complete recovery and hope for a better life. The only time you can drink is now, and the only time you can quit for good is right now. ‘I will never drink/use again,’ becomes, ‘I never drink now.’ It’s not hard; anyone can do it. 8 .

AVRT stands for Addictive Voice Recognition Technique. Trimpey’s copy written program is at the core of RR and the cancellation of the rational recovery movement. RR’s most successful members leave the group quickly, no longer dependent on alcohol or the program 8 . RR has itself spawned another organization. SMART Recovery was founded in 1994 as a non-profit splinter from Jack Trimpey’s for-profit Rational Recovery. SMART stands for Self-Management and Recovery Training, and the program inherited RR’s principles of the individual healing himself and relinquishing dependence even on the recovery organization 9 . Trimpey mainly focuses on providing alternatives to the Recovery Group Movement that he hopes will replace the need for 12 step groups such as AA.

At least one other group wages war on AA in a completely different vein. The founder of the AA Deprogramming site, who himself remains anonymous, takes a more brutal attack on AA using words such as “brainwashing” to describe AA’s program and challenges the reader to “reclaim your brain” 18 . Unlike Trimpey who seeks to provide a different plan for recovery, this unnamed individual has gathered a series of articles attacking AA on the grounds that AA is “your new abusive family” and “the escape plan” without promoting an alternative program 18 .

The religious nature of AA has sparked controversy beyond the caustic prose of Jack Trimpey. AA’s long history of cooperation with law enforcement officials and servicing the court is coming into conflict with the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause (Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion) and Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 10 . AA members work with officials to bring AA’s message into jails and prisons in order to reach those who are suffering. Offenders who have been found guilty of driving under the influence, and those who accept some form of negotiated plea, are nearly always subject to formally defined programs of rehabilitation 10 . When deemed appropriate, AA is frequently one of the utilized programs.

For example, in New Jersey Superior Court Judge James N. Citta ordered Harlan E. Keown on December 20, 1998, to attend weekly AA meetings for the duration of his probation springing from charges of aggravated assault, possession of a firearm, and possession of a weapon for unlawful purpose 12 . More domestic crimes also result in AA mandated meetings, as seen in Riverside California Superior Court when Judge Sharon Waters ordered Tracy Watson on December 1, 1998, to include AA meetings as part of her probation package necessitated from child endangerment charges 13 . Violation of mandated AA meetings is usually severe, as exemplified in early January 1999 at 48th District Court in Detroit. Judge Kimberly Small sentenced Richard Gnida to 90 days in jail after violating the stipulation of his probation to attend AA 11 .

In recent years, offenders have increasingly protested mandatory attendance at AA meetings on the basis that the references to God and a “Higher Power” offend their religious beliefs and violate their First Amendment rights 10 . While attending an AA meeting the offender would not be required to participate in any ritual or prayer, but would invariably be exposed to prayers and religious forms of expression from other members 10 .

State mandated attendance of AA meetings, therefore, calls into question the relationship between the government and AA as a possible violation of the Establishment Clause in the form of an improper government endorsement of religion. A ruling in the summer of 1997 in the New York Court of Appeals held that in the case of Griffin v. Coughlin mandated AA meetings as part of prison treatment are a violation of the Establishment Clause of The First Amendment 10 . Petitioner David Griffin, an inmate at Shawangunk Correctional Facility in New York and an atheist, was approved for participation in the Family Reunion Program allowing for extended visitation 10 . As a caveat of the program the inmate must participate in the Alcohol and Substance Abuse Treatment (ASAT) program, patterned after AA’s Twelve Steps 10 . Griffin complained of the religious nature of the program, taking his case to the Supreme Court of New York and asking that he be excused from participating in ASAT as part of the Family Reunion Program 10 . On appeal the New York Court of Appeals reversed the Appellate Division and ruled that the Twelve Steps of AA amount to a religious exercise “as a matter of law” and that “adherence to the AA fellowship entails engagement in religious activity and religious proselytization” 14 . These findings were based on the court’s interpretation of Alcoholics Anonymous,Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions, and other AA literature 10 .

As a result of the ruling, correctional facilities nationwide have begun to see the need for alternative forms of substance abuse therapy. One of the groups utilized is Save Our Selves, a secular approach to addiction therapy 15 .

In a case currently before a federal court in Chicago two commercial airline pilots are suing their employer for being forced to participate in a program for alcohol abuse based on the AA Twelve Step Program 17 . They contend that the airline’s policy discriminates against them on the basis of religion as one pilot is an atheist and the other a secular humanist. The pilots are suing on the grounds that AA’s Twelve Steps refer to a monotheistic god and thus their forced participation is a violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which states that employers and unions must not discriminate against employees because of their religious beliefs. Second, they must reasonably accommodate an employee’s religious beliefs, unless the accommodation would create an undue hardship for the employer or the union. 16

AA’s religious nature has spawned alternative secular addiction-recovery groups, as well as groups seeking to destroy the recovery group movement as a whole. The prominent use of “God,” “Him,” and “Higher Power” in AA’s literature has led to conflicts in the courts over court or employer mandated participation in AA or groups patterned after AA. The New York Federal Appeals Court recently ruled that participation in AA forced by the government violates the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. A Chicago court is currently deciding if membership required by an employer violates Title VII of The Civil Rights Act of 1964. The legal controversy over AA and AA patterned programs has provided a more favorable economy for alternative groups such as Save Our Selves, Rational Recovery, and SMART Recovery.

It is too early to foresee the legal outcome of the controversies regarding the separation of church and state, and related cases claiming discrimination of the grounds of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, but most certainly the legal wheels are turning. The issue is of such enormous importance that it seems likely that the matter will be before the highest court in the land.

REFERENCES

B, Dick. 1998. The Oxford Group & Alcoholics Anonymous. Paradise Research Publications.

Bufe, Charles. 1991. Alcoholics Anonymous: Cult or Cure? San Francisco: See Sharp Press.

Kurtz, Ernest. 1979. Not-God: A History Of Alcoholics Anonymous. Center City, Minn: Hazelden Educational Services.

Melton, Gordon. 1996. Encyclopedia of American Religions. 5th edition, New York: Gale.

Morreim, Dennis. 1990. The Road to Recovery: Bridges Between the Bible and the Twelve Steps . Minneapolis: Augsburg.

Pittman, Bill. 1988. AA, the Way It Began. Seattle, WA: Glen Abbey Books.

Thomsen, Robert. 1975. Bill W. New York: Harper & Row.

Articles

Conlon , Leon S. 1997. ” Griffin v. Coughlin: Mandated AA Meetings and the Establishment Clause.” Journal of Church and State. 39 n3 p427-454.

Court Report. 1998. Ashbury Park Press. December 20, 1998. sec: AA p2.

Kataoka, Mike. 1998. “Ex-Deputy Gets Probation for Child Endangerment.” The Press-Enterprise ( Riverside CA). December 1, sec: local pB01.

Nichols, Darren A. 1999. “Wings Driver Jailed For 90 Days: Gnida Violated Probation Given for 1997 accident.” The Detroit News. January 6, sec: Metro, pD1.

Skoning, Gerald D. 1999. “10 Wackiest Employment Cases of ’98.” The National Law Journal. March 15, p A23.

Stark, Rodney and Bainbridge, William Sims. 1979. “Of Churches, Sects, and Cults: Preliminary Concepts for a Theory of Religious Movements.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion , 8 (2):117-133.

Extended Bibliography

Dick B’s Historical Collections is probably the most extensive bibliographic resource of print materials available on the internet. Available as a PDF file.

Appendix

The Twelve Traditions

Our common welfare should come first; personal recovery depends on AA unity.

For our group purpose there is but one ultimate authority, a loving God as He may express himself in our group conscience. Our leaders are but trusted servants; they do not govern.

The only requirement for AA membership is a desire to stop drinking.

Each group should be autonomous except in matters affecting other groups or AA as a whole.

Each group has but one primary purpose, to carry out its message to the alcoholic who still suffers.

An AA group ought never endorse, finance, or lend the AA name to any related facility or outside enterprise, lest any problems of money, property, and prestige divert us from our primary purpose.

Every AA group ought to be fully self-supporting, declining outside contributions.

Alcoholics Anonymous should remain forever non-professional, but our service centers may employ special workers.

AA, as such, ought never be organized; but we may create service boards or committees directly responsible to those they serve.

AA has no opinion on outside issues; hence the AA name ought never be drawn into public controversy.

Our public relations policy is based on attraction rather than promotion; we need always maintain personal anonymity at the level of press, radio, and films.

Anonymity is the spiritual foundation of all our Traditions, ever reminding us to place principles before personalities.
(Bufe, 74-81)

Footnotes

1 Alcoholics Anonymous Historical Data http://www.alcoholics- anonymous.org/em24dc14.html

2 Alcoholics Anonymous Structure of General Services http://www.alcoholics- anonymous.org/em24doc5.html

3 Narcotics Anonymous http://www.na.org/berlbull.htm

4 AA Twelve Steps http://www.alcoholics- anonymous.org/em24doc6.html

5 Alcoholics Anonymous: A Newcomer Asks http://www.alcoholics- anonymous.org/ep24doc1.html

6 Stark and Bainbridge. Of Churches, Sects, and Cults: Preliminary Concepts for a Theory of Religious Movements

7 Trimpey, Jack Alcoholics Anonymous: The Embodiment of The Beast as cited at http://www.rational.org/reco very/Embodiment.Beast.html

8 Internet Crash Course on AVRT http://www.rational.org/recovery/Crash. html

9 SMART Recovery FAQ http://www.smartrecovery.org/faqsmart.htm

10 Conlon, Leon. Griffin v. Coughlin: Mandated AA Meetings and the Establishment Clause

11 Nichols, Darren. Wings Driver Jailed for 90 Days: Gnida Violated Probation for 1997 accident

12 Court Report

13 Kataoka, Mike. Ex-Deputy gets Probation for Child Endangerment

14 Griffin v. Coughlin, 88 N.Y. 2d 674 at 683

15 Supreme Court Ruling Makes Room for SOS in Prisons http://www.secularhumanism .org/library/shb/sos_13_2.html

16 Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 http://www.nrtw.org/ro1.htm

17 Skoning, Gerald. 10 Wackiest Employment Cases of ’98

18 AA Deprogramming http://www.aadeprogramming.com

Created by Sara Hull
For Soc 257: New Religious Movements
Spring Term, 1999

Last modified: 07/17/01

ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS VIDEO CONNECTIONS

 

 

Share

Integral Yoga (Sri Aurobindo)

INTEGRAL YOGA TIMELINE

1872 (August 15):  Aurobindo Ghose was born in Calcutta, India.

1878 (February 21):  Mirra Alfassa was born in Paris.

1879:  Aurobindo was taken to England along with his brothers; he lived in Manchester with an English family for five years.

1884:  Aurobindo was enrolled in St. Paul’s School, London.

1889 (December):  Aurobindo won a Classics scholarship to attend Kings College, Cambridge; in June 1890 he passed the Indian Civil Service (ICS) entrance examination; he attended Cambridge as an ICS probationer until 1892.

1892:  Aurobindo passed his final Classics and ICS examinations but was rejected from the ICS because he failed to attend the riding examination.

1893-1906:  Aurobindo worked in the Indian princely state of Baroda as administrative trainee, professor at Baroda College, secretary to the Maharaja of Baroda, and vice-principal of the college.

1902-1910:  Aurobindo was active in the Indian freedom movement; he was charged twice with sedition and once with waging war against the government, but was acquitted in all three cases.

1903-1905:  Mirra Alfassa (then Mirra Morisset) exhibited paintings at salons in Paris.

1903-1908:  Mirra Alfassa was active in the Mouvement Cosmique, a neo-Kabbalah group based in Tlemcen, Algeria, and Paris; during this period she contributed articles to the Revue Cosmique.

1910 (April):  Aurobindo sailed to Pondicherry (then part of the French Settlements in India), where he remained for the rest of his life; between 1910 and 1926 an informal group of disciples gathered around him.

1912-1913:  Mirra Alfassa (then Mirra Richard) met Sufi leader Hazrat Inayat Khan and Baha’i leader ‘Abdu’l-Baha in Paris.

1914 (March 29):  Mirra Alfassa met Aurobindo in Pondicherry; they, along with Mirra’s then husband Paul Richard, launched a monthly journal, Arya, in August.

1915 (February):  Mirra and Paul Richard returned to France; Aurobindo brought out the Arya singlehandedly between 1915 and 1921, publishing in it all his major prose works.

1916-1920:  Mirra and Paul Richard lived in Japan; in April 1920 they came to Pondicherry; Paul later returned to France.

1916-1950:  Aurobindo worked on Savitri , an epic poem in English based on a legend in the Mahabharata.

1926 (November 24):  After a major spiritual experience, Aurobindo retired to his rooms, leaving the community of disciples in Mirra’s hands. Viewed retrospectively, this is regarded as the founding date of Sri Aurobindo Ashram.

1927-1938:  The ashram grew under the guidance of Mirra (now known as the Mother); Aurobindo (now known as Sri Aurobindo) stayed in touch with his disciples by means of letters.

1938 (November 24):  Sri Aurobindo broke his leg while walking in his room; from this point on a group of disciples looked after him.

1942 (December 2):  The Mother opened a school for children of disciples.

1947 (August 15):  India attained independence on Sri Aurobindo’s seventy-fifth birthday.

1950 (December 5):  Sri Aurobindo died.

1950-1958:  The Mother gave regular talks to children and members of the ashram, which later were published as Entretiens (Conversations).

1952 (January 6):  The Mother inaugurated the Sri Aurobindo University Centre, later renamed Sri Aurobindo International Centre of Education.

1955:  Sri Aurobindo Ashram organized legally as Sri Aurobindo Ashram Trust.

1956 (February 29):  The Mother announced that the “supermind” (see below) had manifested in the “earth atmosphere.”

1957-1973:  The Mother had regular conversations with a disciple concerning her practice of yoga; these talks later were published as L’Agenda de Mère (Mother’s Agenda).

1962 (August 16):  Pondicherry became part of the Republic of India.

1968 (February 28):  The Mother inaugurated Auroville, an international township situated outside Pondicherry.

1973 (November 17):  The Mother died.

1980 (December):  The Indian Parliament passed the Auroville (Emergency Provisions) Act, 1980.

1988 (September):  The Indian Parliament passed the Auroville Foundation Act, 1988.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Aurobindo [Image at right] worked in Baroda from 1893 to 1906. During this period he studied classical and modern Indian literature, wrote a great deal of poetic and prose literature in English, and began to organize physical-culture clubs that he hoped would become the basis of an anti-British revolutionary movement. He took no interest in the Indian National Congress, then a powerless advocacy group, until 1905, when there was a wave of agitation against the government’s proposed partition of the province of Bengal. Going to Calcutta in 1906, he became a leader of the extremist faction of the Indian National Congress and the inspiration of a revolutionary group led by his brother Barindrakumar, which took part in some unsuccessful attempts to assassinate British officials. Arrested in 1908 along with Barindrakumar and other members of the revolutionary group, Aurobindo was charged with conspiring to wage war against the government. After a year-long trial he was acquitted for lack of evidence in May 1909.

Aurobindo had begun to practice yoga in 1905, initially to get power to help him in his revolutionary work. Before his arrest and during his imprisonment, he had several transformative spiritual experiences. After a brief return to political action following his release from jail, he withdrew from politics to devote himself fulltime to yoga. Sailing under an assumed name to avoid detainment by the British, he reached Pondicherry, a port in southern India that was then under French control, in April 1910. During the next four years he remained out of sight, absorbed in the practice of yoga, in study, and in writing (Aurobindo 2006; Heehs 2008).

Mirra Alfassa’s parents were non-practicing Sephardic Jews who emigrated to Paris from Alexandria, Egypt, in 1877, a year before Mirra was born. Privately educated, she studied art at the Académie Julian and married a painter, Henri Morisset, in 1897. The couple moved in creative circles, getting to know Auguste Rodin, Anatole France, and other artists and writers. They also frequented groups connected with the French occult revival, particularly the Mouvement Cosmique, which was founded by Max Théon (born apparently Eliezer Mordechai Bimstein in Poland around 1850), and his wife (born Mary Ware in England in 1839) in Tlemcen, Algeria, around 1900 (Huss 2015; Heehs 2011). In contrast with the Theosophical Society and other groups that looked for inspiration to a romanticized East, the Mouvement Cosmique held up “the standard of the occidental Tradition.” The basis of its teachings was Lurianic Kabbalah, augmented by the inspirations and occult experiences of Madame Théon. The Mouvement Cosmique had a branch in Paris, and Mirra took part in its activities between 1903 and 1908. During the same period she twice visited Théon and his wife in Tlemcen. In Paris she hosted her own discussion group, called Idéa. At one of its meetings she met the lawyer and writer Paul Richard, who later became her second husband. In 1910, Paul Richard went to Pondicherry to contest the French Indian seat in the Chamber of Deputies. He lost the election, but before returning to Paris met Aurobindo Ghose, with whom he remained in contact. Between 1910 and 1913 he and Mirra met Eastern spiritual teachers, such as Sufi leader Hazrat Inayat Khan and Baha’i leader ‘Abdu’l-Baha, in Paris (Heehs 2008).

In 1914, Paul Richard went to Pondicherry again, this time accompanied by Mirra. After failing in his second bid to be elected to the Chamber, Paul proposed that he and Aurobindo publish a philosophical journal in English and French. Aurobindo accepted, and the journal, Arya, was launched in August 1914, the month that World War I broke out. Five months later Paul was mobilized, and he and Mirra returned to France. Paul managed to obtain a post in Japan, and he and Mirra [Image at right] spent the war years there. In the meantime, Aurobindo brought out Arya on his own. In April 1920, Paul and Mirra returned to India. Paul left for France soon afterward; Mirra remained in Pondicherry as a disciple of Aurobindo.

There were at this time around a dozen men and women living in Pondicherry as Aurobindo’s disciples. He met them in the evening and spoke with them about various topics, most of them not overtly spiritual. If they showed an interest in spiritual philosophy, he suggested that they read his writings in the Arya. If they said they wanted to practice yoga, he encouraged them to meditate but imposed no fixed routine. Mirra emerged as his foremost disciple, and some of the others began to go to her for guidance. Aurobindo eventually announced that she was his spiritual equal, and when he retired after an important spiritual experience on November 24, 1926, Mirra took over as the active leader of the community, which soon became known as Sri Aurobindo Ashram. (Aurobindo had no love for formal institutions and accepted the name ashram “for want of a better” (Aurobindo 2006)). Around this time Mirra became known as the Mother, while Aurobindo became known as Sri Aurobindo.

Between 1927 and 1938 Sri Aurobindo wrote thousands of letters to his disciples, which eventually filled seven large volumes. Mirra meanwhile was overseeing the development of the ashram into a multifaceted spiritual community. Members were expected to work several hours a day in one of ashram’s services (kitchen, laundry, construction and maintenance, etc.). Apart from this there were no mandatory activities. Most disciples practiced meditation and studied the writings and talks of Sri Aurobindo and the Mother. Many also took part in cultural activities, such as writing, painting, and singing. The gurus encouraged each individual to find his or her own path and to establish a personal relationship with the Divine. Most of the disciples’ devotion was directed toward Sri Aurobindo and the Mother themselves. The two gave darshan or public viewing three (later four) times a year, and the Mother presided over collective meditations and other group activities. The ashram grew from around twenty-five members in 1926 to around 150 in 1933. After 1934, people who applied for membership were encouraged to practice where they lived. Some of them formed communities on the model of the ashram, but Sri Aurobindo and the Mother did not assume responsibility for such groups and they made no effort to expand their activities outside Pondicherry. They viewed the ashram as a “laboratory” for the development of a new sort of humanity and felt that mere quantitative growth would not facilitate this process (Aurobindo 2011).

After the outbreak of World War II, Sri Aurobindo and the Mother allowed a number of outside disciples who felt threatened by the approach of the Japanese army to settle in Pondicherry. Some of them brought their children. The Mother opened a school in 1942 and established an innovative program of mental and physical education. She and Sri Aurobindo had never encouraged their disciples to practice hathayoga (postures and breathing exercises). She felt that modern Indians had more need of active forms of exercise, such as athletics, sports and swimming, and she arranged for the construction of a track, tennis courts, basketball courts, and so forth. Soon adult members, and the Mother as well, were taking part in the ashram’s [Image at right] physical education program.

Sri Aurobindo had long been in the habit of walking in his room, sometimes for hours at a time. In 1938, he tripped and broke his leg and was confined to his bed for several weeks. At this time a group of disciples was chosen to look after him. For a couple of years he had daily conversations with them: this was the first direct contact he had had with any of his followers since 1926. Around this time, he began to revise and republish the works he had written for the Arya between 1914 and 1921. He also gave attention to Savitri , an epic poem in English that he had begun in 1916. It was published in two volumes in 1950 and 1951.

Sri Aurobindo passed away on December 5, 1950 as a result of a kidney infection brought on by enlargement of the prostate. He refused any invasive medical treatment. After his death, the Mother remained in charge of the ashram. In January 1952 she inaugurated the Sri Aurobindo University Centre, later renamed the Sri Aurobindo International Centre of Education, which currently offers classes from kindergarten to college levels. During the 1950s the Mother gave regular talks to students and members of the ashram, sometimes speaking of her own spiritual realizations, which she saw as a continuation of Sri Aurobindo’s efforts to open the way for an evolutionary transformation of life on earth. In the years that followed, she reported progress in her own practice of the yoga of transformation in conversations with a disciple, which later were published as Mother’s Agenda (Mother 1979-1982). In 1968, the Mother inaugurated Auroville, an international community meant to “realize human unity” (Mother 2004).

The Mother died on November 17, 1973, at the age of 95. She appointed no successor. A trust that had been set up in 1955 took over the administration of the ashram, which has continued to grow and expand. As of 2016 it consists of around 1,500 fulltime members. Thousands of “devotees” live in the surrounding community and in other Indian and foreign cities. Many frequently visit the ashram and take part in its activities. Devotees and others have organized independent study circles and other Sri Aurobindo- and Mother-related groups in India and abroad. These have no direct relationship with the ashram, which has no branches or any national or international organization. The community of Auroville, which has no legal or administrative relationship with the ashram, was taken over by the Government of India in 1988 to guarantee proper management. (For details see below under Leadership/Organization). The community has continued to develop under the inspiration of Sri Aurobindo and the Mother. At present it has around 2,500 fulltime members, representing more than forty countries (Census – Auroville Population 2016).

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Broadly speaking, the philosophy of Sri Aurobindo is a combination of the ancient Indian philosophical system of Vedanta with certain ideas usually associated with Western modernity, such as evolution, progress and individuality. Classical Vedanta, one of the six orthodox systems of Indian philosophy, is based on the teachings of the Upanishads, the Bhagavad Gita, and other Sanskrit texts. Among the central ideas of Vedanta are (1) that the universe is an expression of a single Reality, called brahman ; (2) that each individual being is fundamentally atman or self; and (3) that atman is identical with brahman, which means that each individual being can achieve a state of union with the ultimate Reality, sometimes conceived of as ishwara or the Lord of the Universe. (The Indian term ishwara is roughly equivalent to the Western “God.” Sri Aurobindo and the Mother often used the term “the Divine” when referring to God or the Lord.)

The Sanskrit word for union is yoga. In philosophy, yoga came to mean a set of teachings and practices found in Patanjali’s Yoga Sutra. More broadly, yoga refers to all practices by which an individual can achieve union with brahman or move in that direction. Conventionally, the methods of yoga are placed in three categories: (1) those that rely on work conceived of as selfless service to the Divine ( karma-yoga or the yoga of action), (2) those that rely on mental exercises such as meditation (jnana-yoga or the yoga of knowledge), (3) those that rely on devotion to ishwara conceived of as a personal god (bhakti-yoga or the yoga of devotion). Some authorities also recognize a fourth category of practices relying on occult forces to bring about personal transformation. In the system known as raja-yoga , this transformation is associated with extraordinary powers or siddhis, as described in the Yoga Sutra. In Sri Aurobindo’s yoga, the transformation comes about through the action of the divine force or shakti, as described in the Tantras.

Sri Aurobindo called his system Integral Yoga because it synthesized or integrated the methods of the four traditional paths of yoga, which he called the yoga of divine works, the yoga of integral knowledge, the yoga of divine love, and the yoga of self-perfection. He first used the term “Integral Yoga” in The Synthesis of Yoga in September 1914. (In 1913 he used the Sanskrit equivalent, purna yoga, in an essay.) (Aurobindo 1999; Aurobindo 1997a). In The Synthesis of Yoga he explained that the fundamental principle of yoga was “the turning of one or of all powers of our human consciousness into a means of reaching divine Being.” In the three traditional paths, “one main power of being or one group of its powers is made the means,” while in a synthetic or integral yoga “all powers will be combined and included in the transmuting instrumentation.” The yoga of works, with its main power of will; the yoga of knowledge, with its main power of intellect; and the yoga of devotion, with its main power of love, will be elevated from “the mental into the full spiritual and supramental nature,” paving the way for a “spiritual and gnostic self-perfection” (Aurobindo 1999).

Supermind and the supramental are terms that Sri Aurobindo introduced to describe levels of consciousness above the ordinary mind. In his cosmology the “lower hemisphere” is made up of matter, life and mind, while the “higher hemisphere” is made up of being, consciousness and bliss (which are known to Vedanta as sat-chit-ananda ). Between the two hemispheres is supermind, referred to in certain Upanishads as vijnana. Supermind is the dynamic link between the spiritual levels of being-consciousness-bliss and the lower levels of matter-life-mind. Sri Aurobindo viewed the manifestation of the cosmos as a dual process of involution and evolution. Life and mind, which are “involved” in matter, evolve out of it through the intermediary of plant, animal and human life. The supermind, also involved but still latent in matter, is destined to evolve through the intermediary of supramental or gnostic beings. The full emergence of supermind will bring about a transformation of matter, life and mind and inaugurate a divine life in which “gnostic individuals” will interact harmoniously with one another “in a gnostic community or communities.” (Aurobindo 2005). In a yoga diary that he kept between 1912 and 1920 and again in 1927 Sri Aurobindo wrote that he was ascending into various intermediary levels of consciousness between ordinary mind and supermind (Aurobindo 2001). Years later he wrote that the highest of these levels, which he called overmind, had descended into his body in 1926. Thereafter he applied himself to ascending into supermind and to bringing it down into matter. After his death in 1950, the Mother continued this supramental yoga. In 1956, she announced that the supermind had descended into the earth’s atmosphere (Mother 2004). Later she told her disciples that the supermind force was at work in her body to transform it.

Sri Aurobindo and the Mother did not encourage their followers to speculate about the descent of the supermind, the physical transformation, and so forth. It was important for them to know that the ultimate goal of yoga was the transformation of individual and collective life and not, as in traditional Vedanta, an escape from samsara , the karma -driven round of birth-and-death. But before individuals could think about rising to the supermind or bringing down its power into their bodies, they had to go through a long and difficult preparation. First comes a preliminary physical and mental purification such as is recommended by virtually all religious and spiritual traditions. There follows the practice of yoga properly speaking, beginning with the triple path of works, knowledge and devotion. In practical terms, the path of works means performing all actions without desire, as described by the Bhagavad Gita. The path of knowledge entails gaining control of the activities of the mind by means of concentration or meditation, while the way of devotion depends on establishing a personal relationship with the Divine or the guru. Many followers of Sri Aurobindo and the Mother look on them as avatars or divine incarnations and direct their devotion to them. While not insisting that they embrace belief in avatarhood, Sri Aurobindo asked his disciples surrender themselves to the Mother and to allow her to guide them from within.

Sri Aurobindo took one important term of his philosophy not from the Indian tradition but from the Western esoteric tradition that the Mother had studied before she came to India. This term was the être psychique or “psychic being,” which corresponds roughly to the “divine spark” of the school of Kabbalah developed by Isaac Luria in sixteenth-century Palestine. (The idea of the divine spark also occurs in other spiritual traditions. It is similar to the caitya purusha of medieval Hinduism.) (Heehs 2011). According to Sri Aurobindo, the psychic being preserves the impressions of each individual’s experiences as it passes from one life to another. The embodied human being comprises inner or subtle and outer or gross components. The psychic being is the inmost being, and it is in direct contact with the Divine. An important constituent of the practice of Sri Aurobindo’s yoga is for the individual to establish contact with the psychic being and respond to its inner promptings.

In his letters to disciples, Sri Aurobindo specified a number of inner states and attitudes that those who wished to follow his yoga should cultivate. These are the foundations of his sadhana or practice of yoga. Most important is inner peace (shanti) along with a state of freedom from disturbance ( samata ) leading to a positive state of inner cheerfulness (sukham). The sadhaka or practitioner must learn to have faith in the Divine. This is not mental belief, but what is called in Sanskrit shraddha, the soul’s “dynamic entire belief and acceptance” of “the Divine’s existence, wisdom, power, love and grace.” Sadhakas must learn to surrender themselves to the will and guidance of the Divine without insisting on their own preferences and ideas. They should aspire for the Divine’s grace and support, rejecting movements that lead away from the path, such as egoism, desire and anger. Finally, they should be patient, not expecting major results in a few days or even a few decades (Aurobindo 2013).

According to Sri Aurobindo and the Mother, the practice of yoga is an individual affair. Each sadhaka ‘s progress is of interest only to him or her, the guru and the Divine. They did not encourage congregational activities, but they did ask sadhakas to work together in harmony, learning how to keep their egos under control. This was the main reason, apart from the maintenance of the ashram’s outward life, that the Mother and assigned work to everyone. On a wider scale, she and Sri Aurobindo looked forward to the establishment of spiritual and, eventually, supramental communities that would be expressions of the Divine in life. They hoped that the ashram would serve as a model for such communities and they viewed the disharmonies of community life as indications of problems that had to be worked out before spiritual and supramental communities could be founded. When the Mother established Auroville in 1968 she intended it to become “a site of material and spiritual researches for a living embodiment of an actual human unity” (Mother 2004).

RITUALS/PRACTICES

Sri Aurobindo and the Mother did not belong to any religion and therefore did not encourage religious rituals, such as the pujas of popular Hinduism. On the other hand, they accepted that many individuals had a need to give outward expression to their religious or spiritual feelings. Most of their disciples were from Hindu backgrounds, and they allowed them to express their devotion in the traditional Hindu way, for example through pranam or prostration and by attending darshans or public viewings. After Sri Aurobindo’s retirement, the three (later four) yearly darshans were the only occasions when his disciples, and a few selected outsiders, could see him. They passed quietly before him and the Mother, taking a few seconds to make pranam before them. For many years the Mother gave darshan [Image at right] every morning; later only on special occasions. The observance of darshan continued even after the passing of Sri Aurobindo and the Mother. On four special days [the Mother’s birthday (February 21), the day of her final return to Pondicherry (April 24), Sri Aurobindo’s birthday (August 15) and the day of the descent of the overmind in 1926 (November 24)] disciples and visitors pass through the rooms of one or both of them. There is a special darshan every four years to mark the descent of the supermind, which took place on February 29, 1956. During the early years of the ashram, the Mother presided over ceremonial activities that were meant to help the disciples consecrate their lives to the Divine. For a while she used to distribute soup over which she had concentrated in a solemn ceremony. She also led group meditations and presided over group pranam ceremonies. Sri Aurobindo distinguished between such homegrown activities, which had “a living value,” from “old forms which persist although they have no longer any value,” such as the Hindu ceremony of sraddh (offerings to the dead). In a similar way, Christians or Muslims who practiced his yoga might find the forms of prayer they grew up with “either falling off or else [becoming] an obstacle to the free development of their sadhana” (Aurobindo 2011).

Sri Aurobindo’s books on yoga, such as The Synthesis of Yoga and Letters on Yoga, are filled with practices that he recommended to followers of his yoga; but he never prescribed a particular technique or set of techniques that everyone must follow. In the Synthesis and in letters he laid down the principles of his path and sketched general lines of practice that each individual could adapt to the circumstances of his or her sadhana under the direction of the outer or inner guru. He accepted, as a basis, the principles of Vedanta (among them brahman, atman, and ishwara) and the practices of the three traditional paths of yoga (karma-yoga, jnana-yoga and bhakti-yoga). To these he added some of the principles and practices of Tantric philosophy and yoga, in particular shakti or the power of the Divine, which is regarded as a creative energy active in the cosmos and the individual. The Integral Yoga, he wrote, “starts from the method of Vedanta to arrive at the aim of the Tantra.” The divine shakti is “the key to the finding of spirit,” and therefore the “initial stress is upon the action of the awakened Shakti in the nervous system of the body and its centres.” This process required a surrender to the Divine and the divine Shakti, whom members of the ashram conceived of in the form of Sri Aurobindo and the Mother. By means of this surrender, “the Divine himself … shall by the light of his presence and guidance perfect the human being in all the forces of the Nature for a divine living.” (1999).

Sri Aurobindo in his letters and the Mother in letters and conversations suggested practices that might be helpful to a particular individual: this one should concentrate more on work, that one should do more meditation, and so forth. But the actual course of each individual’s sadhana was left to the direction of the Divine and the Shakti. Through aspiration to them and by contact with the psychic being, the individual would develop the ability to make the right choices in yoga and in life.

Since the deaths of Sri Aurobindo and the Mother, members of the ashram and outside disciples have continued to practice yoga along the lines that the two established during their lifetimes. There is a general belief that Sri Aurobindo and the Mother are present to those who aspire to them and that their guidance is available to all who open themselves to it. In addition, their books are available for all who care to read them. In recent years many people in the ashram and Auroville have turned to Sri Aurobindo’s poetic epic Savitri as a source of inspiration and guidance (Aurobindo 1997b). A group based in Auroville disseminates the Mother’s Agenda, which they regard as the key to the yoga of physical transformation. Neither in Auroville nor the ashram are there any mandatory practices or ceremonies, but many ashram members and visitors attend twice-weekly meditations in the ashram playground (where the Mother herself used to give readings and talks) as well as meditations in the ashram’s main building on other days. The four yearly darshans attract thousands of visitors. In Auroville the main focus of yoga is the Matrimandir (literally, temple of the Mother), an innovative meditation hall that was designed according to the Mother’s directions. [Image at right] Special days such as Auroville’s foundation day (February 28) are marked by public observances.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

During the lifetime of Sri Aurobindo and the Mother, the two of them were accepted by the members of the ashram as spiritual guides and also as directors of the outward life of the community. Asked to write about the legal status of the ashram in 1934, Sri Aurobindo replied that an ashram was simply “the house or houses of a Teacher or Master of spiritual philosophy in which he receives and lodges those who come to him for the teaching and practice.” His ashram could not be considered “a religious association” because its members came “from all religions and some are of no religion.” There was “no creed or set of dogmas, no governing religious body.” The guiding principles were his and the Mother’s teachings, which included “certain psychological practices of concentration and meditation, etc., for the enlarging of the consciousness” (Aurobindo 2006). He regarded the Mother as his spiritual equal and asked members of the ashram to approach him through her. Thus, when disciples wrote letters to Sri Aurobindo they addressed them to the Mother. Unlike Sri Aurobindo, who remained out of sight in his rooms, the Mother interacted with each disciple (particularly when the ashram was relatively small) and oversaw every detail of the ashram’s outward life. She delegated responsibility to heads of departments (gardens, kitchen, construction service, library, printing press, embroidery unit, etc.), who reported directly to her.

Apart from publishing books and journals, Sri Aurobindo and the Mother made no effort to publicize the ashram, did not engage in any sort of proselytism, and turned down the majority of those who wrote asking if they could become members. Neither of them thought that numerical expansion was important. “Nothing depends on the numbers,” Sri Aurobindo wrote in 1934 to a disciple who thought that the numbers attracted to Sri Aurobindo’s yoga would never rival those of the world religions. “The numbers of Buddhism and Christianity were so great because the majority professed it as a creed without its making the least difference to their external life. If the new consciousness were satisfied with that, it could also and much more easily command homage and acceptance by the whole earth. It is because it is a greater consciousness, the Truth-consciousness, that it will insist on a real change” (Aurobindo 2011). They did not establish branch ashrams or assume responsibility over groups that devotees outside the ashram started on their own initiative.

When Sri Aurobindo died in 1950, the spiritual and material leadership of the ashram passed seamlessly to the Mother. She continued to run it on established lines, but she did inaugurate a few new organizations, such as the Sri Aurobindo University Centre (later renamed Sri Aurobindo International Centre of Education). In 1955, she reorganized the ashram as a trust in order to guarantee its legal continuity. The first board of Sri Aurobindo Ashram Trust consisted of her and four disciples of her choice. Since her death, replacement members of the board have been chosen by sitting members. As a public charitable trust, the ashram enjoys tax-exempt status in accordance with the terms of Indian law. Most of its funds come through voluntary donations by devotees. The trust oversees several productive departments (cottage industries, publications section, and so forth) that allocate their profits to the ashram.

When the Mother conceived of the community that would became Auroville, she entrusted its development to the Sri Aurobindo Society (SAS), a fundraising group founded in Calcutta in 1960, while retaining overall control. A few years after her death, the residents of Auroville came into conflict with the management of the SAS. In 1988, after a period of unrest during which the residents asked the Government of India to intervene, the Indian Parliament passed the Auroville Foundation Act, under which the Government of India assumed administrative control over Auroville (Auroville Foundation Act 1988). Four years later the government vested the assets of Auroville in the Auroville Foundation, which consists of an International Advisory Council, a Governing Board and a Resident’s Assembly. A government-appointed secretary oversees the functioning of the community. The residents are represented by a Working Committee (Auroville Foundation n.d.). Foreign friends of Auroville have organized themselves into Auroville International, a worldwide network that helps fund the community’s projects (Auroville International n.d.). These include a vast reforestation program, attempts to solve the region’s water problems, and joint initiatives with neighboring villages.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

During the early years of the community that became the ashram, it faced financial and other challenges that stemmed from Sri Aurobindo’s coming to French India as a political refugee. Between 1910 and 1936 British police spied upon him and his companions as a result of his former activities as a revolutionary politician. This unfriendly attention made it difficult for them to move around freely or to receive financial support from friends. The French government tolerated their presence but put limits on the number of houses they could acquire. Pondicherry became part of the Republic of India in 1962. This did not immediately ease the ashram’s financial problems, but by the 1990s it had acquired sufficient resources to provide adequate housing for all its members. Auroville experienced a lean period from 1975 to 1988, when the community was engaged in conflict with the SAS. Since then it has been able to support its members and fund its projects thanks to donations from friends and limited financial assistance from the Government of India.

Despite a widespread belief among members of the ashram and Auroville that they and the communities benefit from the spiritual guidance of Sri Aurobindo and the Mother, the lack of explicit directions from embodied gurus has left both communities open to various sorts of disturbance. After the Mother’s death in 1973 the life of the ashram continued in accordance with her and Sri Aurobindo’s teachings and the established customs of the community. Individuals looked within themselves for guidance. Senior sadhakas provided inspiration and advice. Department heads reported to the trustees, who also were obliged to adjudicate conflicts between individuals and to deal with cases of indiscipline. They did their best to make their decisions according to the teachings and the example of Sri Aurobindo and the Mother but did not claim to be acting under their direct guidance. From the mid-1990s, disgruntled ashram members who refused to accept the trustee’s decisions began to form pressure groups and to institute legal cases against the trustees and other members. Many of the cases had to do with practical matters, such as allocation of resources, disciplinary matters, and so forth. Others had to do with questions of belief or sentiment. One cause of dissension was a new edition of Sri Aurobindo’s poem Savitri . Based on a thorough examination of the manuscripts, the new edition (1997) eliminated errors that had crept into the text during the long process of writing, transcription and publication. Some sadhakas were concerned that these corrections constituted changes of an inviolable text, and began to agitate against the editors and the trustees and eventually to institute legal proceedings against them. The case ultimately went before the Supreme Court of India, which decided in favor of the trustees. Another case involved a biography of Sri Aurobindo written by a member of the ashram and published by an American university press. This book was deemed sacrilegious by certain people inside and outside the ashram, who lodged several cases against the book, its author, and the trustees, who were accused of harboring an “unbeliever.” The case against the trustees was dismissed by the Supreme Court in 2016 after five and a half years of hearings. During this period, dissident members formed informal groups to advance their interests, while individuals loyal to the trustees founded groups to support them. The situation led to an unprecedented polarization of the ashram’s community life (Heehs 2015). Though higher courts have always ruled in favor of the ashram, the leaders of dissident groups found that it was relatively easy to institute legal cases, thus undercutting the authority of the trust.

Auroville also had to pass through the crucible of legal disputes. In 1975, a group of Auroville residents, troubled by apparent mismanagement by the SAS, registered a new body called the Auroville Residents Association. The SAS filed for a permanent injunction against this group. After several years of inconclusive legal maneuvering, the Government of India intervened. In December 1980 the Indian Parliament passed the Auroville (Emergency Provisions) Act, which authorized a temporary takeover of Auroville by the government. The SAS challenged the act in the courts, saying that Auroville was a religious body and therefore the government had no right to interfere. Two years later the Supreme Court ruled on the matter, saying that Sri Aurobindo and the Mother explicitly denied that their work was religious, and therefore the Auroville Act could stand (Minor 1999; Heehs 2013). Since the passage of the Auroville Foundation Act of 1988, the government has been in direct control of Auroville. This has prevented the sort of legal challenges that have troubled the ashram after 1997, but has led to fears that the government might treat Auroville as an ordinary government project rather than a spiritual experiment. In fact, government officials have shown a remarkable willingness to let the community develop in its own way.

Despite its success in surviving its first forty-eight years relatively unscathed and launching many projects that have enriched the community and the surrounding villages and ecosystem, Auroville has come nowhere near the projected population of 50,000 that the Mother spoke of during the 1960s. It proved impossible for the community to acquire all the land the Mother envisaged as forming the city area and surrounding greenbelt, and speculators have driven land prices up to dizzy levels. The villages around the township have become glitzy tourist traps that stand in sharp contrast to the well-designed, ecologically sound Auroville settlements [Image at right]. Nevertheless both Auroville and the ashram remain dynamic communities that attract visitors from around the world.

IMAGES

Image #1: Photograph of Aurobindo Ghose (sitting center) with his parents and siblings in London, 1879.
Image #2: Photograph of Aurobindo Ghose as editor of Bande Mataram, a influential nationalist newspaper published in English from Calcutta, 1907.
Image #3: Photograph of the Mother in Japan, circa 1916.
Image #4: Current photograph of the main building of Sri Aurobindo Ashram.
Image #5: Photograph of Sri Aurobindo and the Mother giving darshan, April 1950.
Image #6: Photograph of the Matrimandir, a meditation hall that the Mother called “the soul of Auroville.”
Image #7: Photograph of a house in Auroville.

REFERENCES

Aurobindo, Sri. 2013. Letters on Yoga II. Pondicherry, India: Sri Aurobindo Ashram Publication Department. Auroville Foundation Act. 1988. Accessed from http://www.auroville.org/contents/540 on 20 May 2015

Aurobindo, Sri. 2011. Letters on Himself and the Ashram. Pondicherry, India: Sri Aurobindo Ashram Publication Department.

Aurobindo, Sri. 2006. Autobiographical Notes and Other Writings of Historical Interest. Pondicherry, India: Sri Aurobindo Ashram Publication Department.

Aurobindo, Sri. 2005. The Life Divine. Pondicherry, India: Sri Aurobindo Ashram Publication Department.

Aurobindo, Sri. 2001. Record of Yoga . Pondicherry, India: Sri Aurobindo Ashram Publication Department.

Aurobindo, Sri. 1999. The Synthesis of Yoga. Pondicherry, India: Sri Aurobindo Ashram Publication Department.

Aurobindo, Sri. 1997a. Essays Divine and Human: Writings from Manuscripts 1910-1950. Pondicherry, India: Sri Aurobindo Ashram Publication Department.

Aurobindo, Sri. 1997. Savitri: A Legend and a Symbol. Pondicherry, India: Sri Aurobindo Ashram Publication Department.

Auroville Foundation n.d. Accessed from http://www.auroville.org/contents/572 on 20 May 2016.

Auroville International n.d. Accessed from http://www.auroville-international.org/ on 20 May 2016.

Census – Auroville Population, January 2016. Accessed from http://www.auroville.org/contents/3329 on 20 May 2016.

Heehs, Peter. 2015. The Sri Aurobindo Ashram 1910-2010: An Unfinished History. Nova Religio 19:65-86.

Heehs, Peter. 2013. “Not a Question of Theology”? Religions, Religious Institutions and the Courts in India. Comparative Legal History 1:243-61.

Heehs, Peter. 2011. “The Kabbalah, the Philosophie Cosmique, and the Integral Yoga: A Study in Cross-Cultural Influence.” Aries 11:219-47.

Heehs, Peter. 2008. The Lives of Sri Aurobindo. New York: Columbia University Press.

Huss, Boaz. 2015. “Madame Théon, Alta Una, Mother Superior: The Life and Personas of Mary Ware (1839-1908).” Aries 15:210-46.

Minor, Robert N. 1999. The Religious, the Spiritual and the Secular: Auroville and Secular India. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.

Mother, the (Mirra Alfassa). 2004. Words of the Mother – I. Pondicherry, India: Sri Aurobindo Ashram Publication Department.

Mother, the (Mirra Alfassa). 1979-1982. Mother’s Agenda. Thirteen volumes. New York: Institute for Evolutionary Research.

SUPPLEMENTARY RESOURCES

Johnson, W.J, trans. 1994. The Bhagavad Gita, Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

Miller, Barbara Stoller, trans. 1998. Yoga: Discipline of Freedom: The Yoga Sutra Attributed to Patanjali. New York: Bantam Books.

Roebuck, Valerie J., trans. 2003. The Upanishads. London: Penguin Books.

Post Date:
25 May 2016

 

Share