Benny Hinn Ministries

BENNY HINN MINISTRIES TIMELINE

1952 (December 3):  Toufik Benedictus (Benny) Hinn was born in Jaffa, Israel.

1968:  Following the Arab-Israeli War, Hinn’s family emigrated to Toronto, Canada.

1972 (February):  Hinn had a conversion experience whereby he became a born-again Christian.

1973 (December):  Hinn attended a healing service conducted by Kathryn Kuhlman in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.

1979:  Hinn moved to Orlando, Florida, where he met and married Suzanne Harthern, the daughter of a local pastor, on August 4 of the same year.

1983:  Hinn founded the Orlando Christian Center

1989:  Hinn held his first nationally televised faith healing service in Flint, Michigan.

1990:  Hinn’s television program, “This Is Your Day,” began airing daily on the Trinity Broadcasting Network.

1993 (March 2):  Hinn’s ministry underwent its first investigation, conducted by Inside Edition, exploring the legitimacy of Hinn’s healing powers as well as allegations regarding the misappropriation of funds.

1993:  Ole Anthony traveled to Orlando to conduct an interview with Hinn, during which he vowed to medically verify and authenticate all miracles prior to airing them on television.

1994 (June 10):  Hinn “healed” professional and former World Heavyweight Champion boxer Evander Holyfield of a heart condition.

1999:  Hinn handed over his church, since renamed the World Outreach Center, to Clint Brown and moved to Grapevine, Texas.

2001 (April):  HBO aired an investigation of Hinn entitled A Question of Miracles .

2004 (November):  The Fifth Estate aired a documentary titled “Do You Believe in Miracles,” revealing an ostensible misappropriation of funds as well as dubious healing practices within Hinn’s ministry.

2007 (February 13-15):  Hinn held the largest recorded faith healing service in history, the “Festival of Blessings,” in Mumbai, India.

2007 (November 6):  U.S. Senator Chuck Grassley announced an investigation of six televangelists, including Benny Hinn, by the United States Senate Committee on Finance.

2010 (February 1):  Benny Hinn and wife Suzanne filed divorce papers, citing “irreconcilable differences.”

2013 (March 3):  Benny and Suzanne remarried at the Holy Land Experience Church in Orlando, Florida.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Toufik Benedictus Hinn was born on December 3, 1952 in Jaffa, Israel, a coastal city located in modern-day Tel Aviv, to a Greekfather and an Armenian mother. According to personal accounts, being raised in the Greek Orthodox tradition, he answered to “Benny” from a young age due to discomfort with having an Arabic first name. While little is known of his early years, he has written that despite being afflicted with an acute speech impediment during childhood, which isolated him socially, he was able to thrive academically at the College de Frere elementary school in Jaffa . At the age of fourteen, shortly following the Arab-Israeli War of 1967 (also known as the Six-Day War) he, his parents, and seven siblings emigrated to Canada, settling in Toronto. While attending the Georges Vanier High school just north of the city, Benny became involved in a religious group that planted the seeds of his evangelical career. Attending prayer meetings regularly, where he occasionally taught the Gospel. Hinn “surrendered his heart and life to Jesus Christ,” becoming a born-again Christian in February of 1972. His parents feared he was becoming a “fanatic,” particularly after he dropped out of high school the same year (“About” n.d.). Shortly thereafter, Hinn underwent two more transformative experiences; the first occurred when he claimed to have received a divine appeal to minister the Gospel. The second occurred in December of 1973 during a trip to Pittsburgh , Pennsylvania where he attended a healing service conducted by Kathryn Kuhlman. Hinn claims that while on the pilgrimage, he was assigned to assist an elderly woman crippled by arthritis who, before his eyes, lost “all pain in her legs and ‘untwist[ed]’, as he put it (Bloom 2003:3). Recalling this experience, Hinn acknowledges Kuhlman’s influence in driving him towardfaith healing. He would eventually author a book titled Kathryn Kuhlman: Her Spiritual Legacy and Its Impact on my Life, displaying an inspiration also apparent in his adoption of techniques used in her services, such as “her practice of ‘slaying in the Spirit’ and her use of ‘word of knowledge,’ both of which Hinn uses extensively.” Hinn has stated that Kuhlman has “appeared to him from beyond the grave to give him encouragement and ministerial direction,” although he never met her in person, and those familiar with the services of the two healers have noted a similarity in their manners of speaking, stage presence, and even choice of wardrobe (Peters 2009:1). Upon returning to Toronto with a crystallized mission, Hinn began preaching evangelical services on a local television program. The program’s success led him to expand his teaching to Orlando, Florida (“Do You Believe in Miracles” 2004).

Hinn moved to Orlando 1979, where he met Suzanne Harthern, the daughter of a local pastor, and the two were married on August 4 of that same year. He founded the Orlando Christian Center in 1983; he developed and refined the structure of his self-proclaimed “faith healing” services, propelling him to international recognition. Throughout the decade, Hinn’s ministry grew steadily. He began conducting services in venues across the globe, eventually undertaking scheduled tours that he referred to as “miracle crusades” (Bloom 2003:4). His first nationally televised healing service aired in 1989 from Flint , Michigan , the success of which landed him a television show, “This Is Your Day,” which typically features, in addition to the reading of and responding to viewers’ letters, highlights from Hinn’s miracle crusades (Peters 2009). By the time he passed leadership of the Orlando Christian Center (since renamed the World Outreach Center) to Clint Brown in 1999, the success of “This Is Your Day,” along with that of his book, Good Morning, Holy Spirit (1990), had projected Hinn to levels of recognition unprecedented in his career. On his increasingly frequent crusades, he would fill stadiums and auditoriums capable of holding thousands of believers and skeptics alike, sometimes multiple times a day.

Hinn had also begun to attract the attention and support of celebrities. One of these was former World Heavyweight Champion boxer Evander Holyfield, who attended one of Hinn’s services in Philadelphia, Florida, seeking a cure for a recently-diagnosed heart condition that had endangered his career. At the service, held on June 10, 1994, Holyfield was invited on stage. After Holyfield described the nature of his disorder, Hinn reportedly laid his hands on him and, “in full view of the thousands of people in the audience, shook his head and told Evander that there was nothing wrong with his heart” (“You are healed…” 2011). Shortly thereafter, Holyfield underwent an extensive series of tests at the Mayo Clinic, which determined that rather than having been born with a heart condition, the complications had arisen from improper medication following his last fight, but that it was nonetheless a miracle that he had survived and healed so quickly. Holyfield subsequently reimbursed Benny Hinn Ministries with a check for $265,000, and he has spoken out in support of Hinn on multiple occasions.

Following Hinn’s resignation as leader of the World Outreach Center in 1999, he and his family relocated to Grapevine, Texas. On February 1, 2010, Hinn and his wife, Suzanne, filed for divorce, citing “irreconcilable differences.” However, when brought together at a family reunion in 2011, the couple began to settle their disagreements, and the two were remarried at the Holy Land Experience Church in Orlando, Florida on March 3, 2013. They settled in Southern California, “strategically near the ministry-owned television studio and church in Aliso Viejo” (“Benny Hinn Author Profile” n.d.).

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

The doctrines that Benny Hinn professes in his ministry are eclectic and unsystematic as they are a drawn from various individuals and variants of Christianity. Hunt (2000a:74) characterizes Hinn’s ministries as constituting “almost a `movement within a movement’ and have their own style and ethos, beliefs and practices that are exemplified by the `health and wealth’ gospel which, in many respects, is congruent with contemporary cultural values.” The ministry has also been described as Evangelical “on the fringe of Pentecostalism” (Bloom 2003:2). In developing his distinctive theology, Hinn has often made claims that he asserts stem from Divine Revelation. Some of these revelations, such as “that women were originally designed to give birth out of their sides and that there are nine members of the Godhead” distance him considerably from conventional Christian teachings (Peters 2009:2; Stewart n.d.). In recent years, Hinn has increased the prominence of Gospel teaching in his services despite lacking formal education or ministerial training. He has also issued a number of prophetic statements, such as predicting an imminent endtime and the destruction of homosexuals, which subsequently were not confirmed. At the same time, however, Hinn does not claim to personally possess any prophetic or healing capabilities, but rather he asserts that God speaks to and acts through him (Fisher and Goedelman 1996).

Healing services are at the heart of Hinn’s ministry, and they rely heavily on the Prosperity Gospel and Word of Faith doctrines, which have now spread worldwide (Hunt 2000a, 2000b). In North America, this tradition is represented by figures such as Kenneth Hagin (widely regarded as the “father” of Word of Faith movement), Kenneth and Gloria Copeland, Rodney Howard Brown, and Paula White.

Word of Faith doctrine teaches that spiritual knowledge is ultimate truth and is superior to empirical or sense knowledge. In some strands of the tradition, upon which Hinn draws, God established certain rights for all humans at the time of creation, and God honors those rights. The rights, which were lost at the Fall of humankind, may be regained and activated in the present day through prayer and the force of faith. God will grant believers personal health (physical, emotional, or relational) and prosperity if they express committed faith through “positive confession.” As Hunt (2000a:74) summarizes the doctrine, “the teachings insist that God provides for their physical and material needs, along with their spiritual needs, if His commandments are heeded and there is sufficient faith.” Examples of common positive confessions related to prosperity include “I’ll never be broke another day in my life,” I am expecting supernatural increase this week,” and “I am expecting supernatural debt cancellation this week” (Harrison 2005:4).

A basic belief is that “spoken words are containers of the substance of faith,” and that those with faith can actually talk actions, objects, or circumstances into reality (Peters 2009:2). The spoken word, “rhema,” refers to “the direct revelation of God’s intents, purposes, promises, power, and very character through scripture…” (Harrison 2005:7). Believers express their needs and promises to God as acts of faith and agreements with God, and these may be confessed before they become material realities. As Benny Hinn has asserted, “faith works as a mighty power or force,” and health, healing, and prosperity can be obtained through, and only through, faith (“Benny Hinn” 1997). If positive confessions are not realized, believers typically conclude that results have been impeded by a lack of faith, a failure to follow God’s word, or a “negative confession.”

RITUALS/PRACTICES

The pivotal ritual events organized by Benny Hinn Ministries are faith healing services. Hinn began shaping his preaching technique after founding the Orlando Christian Center in 1983. Prior to conducting healings, Hinn would dramatically recite scripture in a manner sources have compared to “tent revival meetings of the 19th century,” often also speaking in tongues. He later abandoned glossolalia when his services began to be televised (Bloom 2003:5).

A typical contemporary Benny Hinn Ministries healing service begins in a dimly lit sanctuary with a soft musical backdrop and a repeated vocalization of:

“He touched me, oh, He touched me,
And, oh, the joy that filled my soul!
Something happened and now I know
He touched me, and made me whole…”

Hinn then enters the stage to the strains of the spiritual song “How Great Thou Art.” An animated Hinn moves around the stage announcing the presence of God and the healing potential in the building. He also typically speaks of the current and future state of a sinful world, often noting or predicting natural disasters and disease that are signs of God’s displeasure with human sinfulness. Hinn offers protection to those with faith in the power of the Lord (Bloom 2003:5; Nickell 2002). At some services Hinn has gone into a trance-like state during which he has proclaimed that God is speaking to him, that angels are present in the room, or that demons are flying out of the building.

During the healing portion of services Hinn will typically heal members of the audience “en masse” from the stage. He may announce a specific ailment, such as cancer, the “demon of suicide,” or even witchcraft that is being expelled from the arena. Alternatively he may refer to an area of the body or a section of the audience that is being healed. Hinn also has proclaimed that “he need not name every disease or body part, that God’s power was affecting a multitude of cures all over the arena” (Nickell 2002; Hunt 2000). Consistent with the Word of Faith tradition, healing extends beyond physical conditions to financial circumstances. As Hunt (2000:82) notes, “ There may be an attempt to deal with bank overdrafts or financial insecurity. Bank balances may be commanded to `come in line’ with the `power of Jesus’. Being `in the red’ may be dismissed as `a lie of the devil’. Hands might be lain on members of the congregation for the ‘multiplying of finances’, to cast away `a spirit of unbelief’, to combat `harassing circumstances’ in peoples’ lives by `coming against’ the evil spirits responsible.”

Hinn invites individual members of the audience on stage for personal healings as well. The persons to be healed will provide a quick synopsis of the condition for which they seek cure. Hinn responds with a prayer or short sermon-like comment. One of Hinn’s “catchers” then stands behind the person as Hinn touches the person’s forehead or holds his or her face between his thumb and forefinger. The person being healed usually falls to the stage floor, sometimes lying motionless and sometimes trembling. The person being healed may then get up and demonstrate some sign of their healing, such as jumping or running around the stage. Hinn conducts several dozen personal healings during each service. It is commonplace for members of the congregation to be slain in the spirit during the service.

In addition to healing services, Benny Hinn Ministries offers internet prayer services. These services, often termed “ePrayers,” have been made available to anyone and can be used with any electronic device with internet access, including computers, tablets, and cellular smartphones (Cooper 2014). The Benny Hinn Ministries’ “Prayer Request” form can be accessed from the homepage of the organization’s website. It requires the user to fill out basic information, such as his or her name, country, and email address before focusing on the prayer itself. The user must identify for whom the prayer is being submitted and, from a dropdown box, choose the general nature of the prayer request. The box includes an alphabetized list of “needs” from alcohol and drug abuse, to various illnesses, to “the current world situation” (“Prayer Request” 2014). Located below is a box labeled “Prayer Details” where, using a maximum of 1,000 characters, the person submitting the prayer is able to elaborate upon the request. Upon submitting the prayer, the request is documented on a separate webpage, where it can be seen by any given member of a group of Benny Hinn Ministries’ affiliates titled the Mighty Warriors Prayer Army (MWPA).

The MWPA consists of a group of volunteers whose specific and sole responsibility is to fulfill online prayer requests. MWPA members are volunteers who agree to several terms and conditions outlined on Ministries’ webpage. These include a vow to pray at least fifteen minutes per day for those who seek prayer assistance through Benny Hinn Ministries; for Benny Hinn, his family, and the Ministries; for the nation and government; and for fellow “prayer warriors” (Hinn 2014). Hinn claims that with thousands of MWPA members worldwide, prayer requests are fulfilled twenty-four hours per day. However, Hinn has also addressed a larger goal than simply creating a platform for easily-accessible prayer services. He has called for the creation of a prayer community so vast and effective that it will precipitate divine intervention, predicting that “millions will be swept into the kingdom of God and His power will be unleashed for the miraculous as never before” (Hinn 2014).

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Benny Hinn began preaching in Toronto , hosting prayer services and eventually a local television show. His success led him to Orlando, Florida, where he founded the Orlando Christian Center in 1983 and began to build his ministry (“Biography: Benny Hinn” n.d.). The church grew rapidly almost immediately and soon required multiple Sunday services to accommodate the growing number of worshipers. Hinn began undertaking Miracle Crusades in the latter half of the decade, holding healing services in large venues across the United States, and later internationally, attracting tens of millions annually (“Benny Hinn Author Profile” n.d.). Benny Hinn’s celebrity status expanded even further following the success of his television show, “This Is Your Day,” which began airing in 1990 on the Trinity Broadcasting Network. At its peak, Hinn’s Center in Florida attracted audiences of over 10,000. However, as his tours gained momentum, Hinn spent more and longer stretches of time traveling (Okello-Kampala 2007).

In 1999, Hinn handed over the church to Clint Brown, “while retaining legal ownership of the ‘World Outreach Center Benny HinnMinistries.” He moved his headquarters to Grapevine, Texas where he claimed God had told him to construct a World Healing Center in Irving. However, the center was never built, and Hinn and his wife subsequently moved to Southern California. There Hinn began hosting his television show “This Is Your Day” from the Ministries’ owned and operated studio, the World Media Center, in Aliso Viejo. Hinn’s thirty-minute program is broadcast on a number of different television networks, including Trinity Broadcasting Network, the Daystar Television Network, Grace TV, and The God Channel. It airs daily in two hundred countries. He reaches millions of followers each year through his television program, Miracle Crusades, online sources, numerous literary works, and the sale of recorded sermons and healing sessions. Hinn claims to have communicated God’s message to over a billion people during his thirty-year career.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Benny Hinn Ministries has faced opposition from three primary sources: governmental and private agencies that are chiefly concerned with religious group financial practices, Christian organizations that have called into question Hinn’s claims of miraculous healing and the validity of his interpretation of the Gospel, and media outlets that have frequently challenged both.

Because Word Faith groups are non-denominational, there is no denominational scrutiny of their organizational practices. Throughout his career, Hinn has been under the scrutiny of the Trinity Foundation, a Dallas , Texas based organization that investigates the financial practice of televangelists. In 2005, the organization contacted the IRS concerning Benny Hinn Ministries’ status as a tax-exempt religious organization, claiming that it did not meet exemption guidelines because it is not an actual church. Headed by Ole Anthony, the Foundation posited not only that the Ministries failed to hold regular services, but also that it did not have a stable foundation of directors and therefore lacked legitimacy as a legal religious organization. Further, the Trinity Foundation questioned the appropriation of the Ministries’ supposed $100 million annual income, alleging that Hinn has appropriated money donated to the organization for personal use. At roughly the same time, another “watchdog group,” the Wall Watchers, contacted the IRS with similar allegations regarding Benny Hinn Ministries. According to the Ministries, the IRS responded by sending them a letter that included a series of questions regarding the leadership of the organization, but never conducted a formal audit. Neither the Ministries nor the IRS released Hinn’s response to the letter, but it was reported that the organization cooperated fully and was able to retain its exemption status (Wrolstad 2005; Martin 2005). Benny Hinn Ministries was subject to several such investigations in the following years, perhaps most notably in 2007 when he and five other televangelists were investigated by United States Senate Committee on Finance. On November 6, Senator Chuck Grassley announced the investigation on the grounds that those under scrutiny had abused their tax exemptions for personal gain. The six churches, among them Benny Hinn Ministries, Paula White Ministries, and Creflo Dollar’s World Changers Church, received letters from the Senate committee, posing questions regarding the allocation of church donations and requesting transparency of financial documents. While Hinn initially resisted the inquiry, he eventually agreed to “ fully cooperate…with the investigation and even implemented financial reforms,” and the three-year investigation was closed in January of 2011 (Garcia 2011).

Hinn has also faced opposition from a number of individuals and groups, both within and beyond the Christian community, for a reported refusal to join the Evangelical Council for Financial Accountability. The ECFA, with over 1,1000 members, including Billy Graham and Pat Robertson, requires a degree of financial transparency, aiming to “earn the public’s trust through adherence to seven standards of accountability” (“Do You Believe in Miracles” 2004). Paul Nelson, the CFO of the organization, has reported that Benny Hinn’s extravagant lifestyle and secrecy regarding financial documents and funds appropriation in spite of repeated inquiries have “invited IRS scrutiny” (Wrolstad 2005).

Hinn has rejected allegations of financial impropriety. For example, The Fifth Estate investigatory team obtained financial records from individuals within the Ministries who stated that they “want the public to know how Benny Hinn spends the money entrusted to him” (“Do You Believe In Miracles” 2004). The records the journalists obtained showed what were deemed extravagant travel expenses as well funds given to Benny Hinn, with no reasons specified. Hinn addressed these accusations by stating that the documentary’s portrayal of his traveling expenses was misleading as it failed to take into account expenditures that were deeply discounted and services that were provided to the Ministries free of charge.

Concerns over financial practices have continued. Despite the estimated $100-200 million the Ministries receives annually in donations, in April of 2013, Benny Hinn called upon his supporters to donate $2.5 million, which Hinn claimed would be matched by an undisclosed donor, to lift the organization out of debt (Zaimov 2013a). Earlier in the month, Hinn reportedly asked the attendees, who numbered in the thousands, of a service in Trinidad and Tobago to each donate $100 to the Ministries in order to fund the crusade.

Benny Hinn has also been vulnerable to criticism because he never received formal biblical training or education, rather claiming his knowledge to come from the Holy Spirit itself. Conservative Christian critics assert that his teaching of the Gospel is flawed, particularly his acceptance of Word Faith doctrines. They contend that Word Faith adherents, such as Benny Hinn, do not preach the Gospel, but rather, they shape the teachings of the Bible to fit their specific purpose, selecting scripture “out of context and apply[ing] it to a personal interpretation which is claimed to have been given by direct revelation from God” (“Benny Hinn” n.d.). One of the most disputed teachings of Hinn and the Word Faith Movement involves the belief that that Jesus Christ died a spiritual as well as physical death in atonement for the sins of humanity and “descended to Hell where He was tortured” before becoming reborn (Peters 2009:2). Critics have rejected this claim, deeming it heretical and asserting that because God cannot simply cease to be, the spiritual death of Christ would prove that he is not God. Another such teaching is the Little gods Doctrine. Taken from Bible passages such as II Peter 1:4 and John 10:31-39, the “Little gods Doctrine” asserts that since God created humans in his exact likeness, believers are actually “little gods,” who, with faith, are incapable of suffering from illness or poverty (Gilley 1999). This Word Faith interpretation contradicts more traditional interpretations of numerous Bible passages, such as Psalms 50:1 and Romans 16:27. These passages state that there is only one God and humans being created in God’s image “means we as humans have the capacity through a saving relationship with Jesus Christ to know God,” the traditional interpretation of the verse. Further, the Little gods Doctrine is rejected because “not everyone who loved and served the Lord walked in perfect health” and that God does not intend his followers to “be physically healed in this life” (Peters 2009:3).

Benny Hinn Ministries has been the target of several media investigations. The first occurred in 1993. Conducted by Inside Edition , hosted by Bill O’Reilly, the investigation called into question the legitimacy of Hinn’s healings, following up with individuals who had supposedly been healed at one of Pastor Benny’s services. The report stated, for example, that a man who apparently had been miraculously cured of brain cancer on stage found that the tumor was still present after an examination by his doctor; a woman who believed she had been cured of lung cancer refused medical treatment and died two months after she attended a Benny Hinn healing service in Houston; and the doctor of a woman “cured” of deafness reported that she had never actually been deaf at all. Following the airing of this investigation on March 2, 1993, Hinn made a number of media appearances, including an interview on the 700 Club with Pat Robertson. In that interview he vowed to make changes in his ministry, acknowledging the mistakes he had made. In the same year, Ole Anthony of the Trinity Foundation traveled to Florida to interview Hinn. Hinn asserted that he would begin medically verifying all miracles prior to airing them on his program and that he would return to teaching the Gospel. However, shortly after the dust had settled, according to Ole Anthony, Hinn was “back to his old tricks” (Bloom 2003:8). A number of similar investigations were conducted by media programs, including a 2001 documentary aired on HBO titled “A Question of Miracles,” in which reporters followed up on 76 putative healings that occurred during a service in Portland, Oregon. Despite having claimed to possess medical verification for the healings, Hinn withheld the documentation. Several months later, Hinn produced only a list of five names. Upon conducting follow-up interviews with the crusade attendees and their medical examiners, the reporters found results similar to those of the Inside Edition investigation. Another such investigation was conducted by Dateline at a Las Vegas healing and again, the crew tried to contact the five individuals, whose names were provided by Hinn, who reportedly had been healed. Four refused to share their medical records and the fifth, a woman who had purportedly been healed of Lou Gehrig’s Disease at a Hinn crusade, had been misdiagnosed. Possibly the largest news media investigation of Benny Hinn Ministries was conducted in 2004 by the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation’s The Fifth Estate. The documentary, “Do You Believe in Miracles,” used hidden cameras and interviews with former Benny Hinn Ministries’ employees and crusade audience members to assess Hinn’s healing claims, as well as to probe his financial practices. The documentary revealed, for example, a screening process by which audience members were carefully selected for appearance on stage. Those who were visibly handicapped physically, for example, were consistently turned away, presumably to avoid disconfirmation. Hinn has responded to allegations regarding his healing practices, stating that it is not he, but God, who heals the individuals; his crusades simply provide a channel through which those who are ill may become recipients of the Lord’s gift. Successful healing requires complete faith in God’s power and not on Hinn’s personal power.

Despite the substantial controversy surrounding Benny Hinn Ministries, millions of believers from across the globe flock to his crusades and tune into his daily television show in hopes of experiencing a miracle. “This Is Your Day” is now broadcast in 200 countries, and Hinn undertakes regular Miracle Crusades across the globe. In 2007, Hinn held the largest recorded healing service in history in Mumbai, India, with estimates ranging from five to seven million attendees over the course of the three day “Festival of Blessings” (“Benny Hinn: India Healing Crusade” n.d.). The Ministries receives an estimated $100-200 million in donations annually and contributes heavily to various crisis relief efforts, mission organizations, and schools and orphanages, claiming to “support…over 40,000 children each day” (“How Much Money Does Benny Hinn Make?” (“Salary & Net Worth” n.d.). Hinn also recouped some stature within the Evangelical community when he remarried his former wife in front of an audience of over 1,000 (Zaimov 2013b).

REFERENCES

“Benny Hinn” n.d. Biblical Discernment Ministries. Accessed from http://www.rapidnet.com/~jbeard/bdm/exposes/hinn/general.htm     on  25 May 2013.

“Benny Hinn Author Profile.” n.d . New Release Tuesday. Accessed from http://www.newreleasetuesday.com/authordetail.php?aut_id=496 on 25 May, 2013.

“Benny Hinn: India Healing Crusade.” n.d. 700 Club. Accessed from http://www.cbn.com/700club/Guests/Bios/Benny_Hinn_110404.aspx on 25 May 2013.

“Benny Hinn Ministries” n.d. Apologetics Index. Accessed from http://www.apologeticsindex.org/h01.html on 25 May 2013.

“Benny Hinn Ministries – World Media Center.” n.d. Patch. Accessed from http://alisoviejo.patch.com/listings/benny-hinn-ministries-world-media-center on 25 May 2013.

“BIOGRAPHY: Benny Hinn.” n.d. The Fifth Estate. Accessed from http://www.cbc.ca/fifth/amazinggrace/hinn.html 25 May 2013.

Bloom, John. 2003. “The Heretic.” The Trinity Foundation. Accessed from http://www.trinityfi.org/press/heretic.html on 26 May 2013.

Cooper, Travis. 2014. “ePrayer and Online Prayer Rituals.” In The Materiality of Prayer, edited by Anderson Blanton. The Social Science Research Council. Accessed from http://forums.ssrc.org/ndsp/2014/01/13/eprayer-and-online-prayer-rituals/ on 22 January 2014.

“DO YOU BELIEVE IN MIRACLES?” n.d. The Fifth Estate. Accessed from http://www.cbc.ca/fifth/main_miracles.html on 25 May 2013.

Garcia, Elena. 2011. “Benny Hinn Sued by Publisher Over Alleged Relationship with Paula White.” The Christian Post, February 18. Accessed from http://www.christianpost.com/news/benny-hinn-sued-by-publisher-over-alleged-relationship-with-paula-white-49060/ on 26 May 2013.

Harrison, Milmon. 2005. Righteous Riches: The Word of Faith Movement in Contemporary African American Religion. New York: Oxford University Press.

Hinn, Benny. 2014. “Mighty Warriors Prayer Army.” Benny Hinn Ministries . Accessed from http://www.bennyhinn.org/mwia/ on 22 January, 2014.

Hunt, Stephen. 2000a. “Dramatising the ‘Health and Wealth Gospel’: Belief and Practice of a Neo-Pentecostal ‘Faith’ Ministry.” Journal of Beliefs & Values 21:73-86.

Hunt, Stephen. 2000b. “’Winning Ways’: Globalization and the Impact of the Health and Wealth Gospel.” Journal of Contemporary Religion 16:88-105.

Martin, Allie. 2005. “Benny Hinn the Subject of IRS Inquiry.” AgapePress. Accessed from http://www.ministrywatch.com/pdf/article_071205_hinninvestigated.pdf on 25 May 2013.

Nickell, Joe. 2002. “Benny Hinn: Healer or Hypnotist?” Skeptical Inquirer. Accessed from http://www.csicop.org/si/show/benny_hinn_healer_or_hypnotist/ on 25 May 2013.

Okello-Kempala, Raphael. 2007. “ Uganda : Benny Hinn Has a Gift for Country.” Accessed from http://watchmanafrica.blogspot.com/2007/05/pastor-joseph-serwadda-says-benny-hinn.html on 25 May 2015 .

Peters, Justin. 2009. “Benny Hinn.” Watchman Fellowship. Accessed from http://www.watchman.org/profiles/benny-hinn/ on 26 May 2013.

“Prayer Request.” 2014. Benny Hinn Ministries. Accessed from http://www.bennyhinn.org/prayer/prayer-request on 22 January 2014.

Stewart, David J., n.d. “Benny Hinn’s Hidden Heresies.” Accessed from http://www.jesus-is-savior.com/Wolves/benny_hinn-hidden.htm on 25 May 2013 .

Wrolstad, Mark. 2005. “IRS questions Hinn’s Tax-Exempt Status.” The Dallas Morning News, July 6. Accessed from http://trinityfi.org/press/hinn07.html on 25 May 2013.

Zaimov , Stoyan. 2013a. “Benny Hinn Asks Followers for $2.5 Million to Get Out of Debt.” The Christian Post, April 26. Accessed from
http://www.christianpost.com/news/benny-hinn-asks-followers-for-2-5-million-to-get-out-of-debt-94822/ on 26 May 2013.

Zaimov, Stoyan. 2013b. “Benny Hinn Remarries in Front of 1,000 People.” The Christian Post, March 4. Accessed from http://www.christianpost.com/news/benny-hinn-remarries-in-front-of-1000-people-91218/ 25 May 2013.

Publication Date:
26 December 2013

Share

The Amish

AMISH TIMELINE

1517:  Martin Luther nailed his ninety-five theses to the door of Wittenburg Church, setting off the Protestant Reformation.

1525:  Conrad Grebel (ca.1498-1526), the son of a prominent Zurich family; Felix Manz (ca.

1498– 1527 (January 5):  Another well-educated Zurich native; and Georg Blaurock (ca. 1492-September 6, 1529), a former priest, met secretly with some of their followers at the Zurich home of Felix Manz on January 21, 1525, where they rebaptized each other, launching the Anabaptist movement.

1527:  Michael Sättler (ca. 1495- May 21, 1527), a former priest from Freiburg, led a secret Anabaptist conference in the town of Schleitheim, north of Zurich. Here they formulated the Schleitheim Confession , which put in writing for the first time Anabaptist beliefs about how the church would function as a community within worldly society, but separate from it.

1632:  The Dordrecht Confession of Faith was adopted by Mennonites meeting in conference in Dordrecht, Holland.

1660:  Thieleman J. van Braght published The Bloody Theater; or Martyrs Mirror of the Defenseless Christians , popularly known as The Martrys Mirror. The second edition of the book, published in 1685, contained 104 engraved illustrations by the Dutch Mennonite artist Jan Luyken.

1693:  Alsation minister Jakob Ammann excommunicated Mennonite preachers and congregations that rejected his call for greater separation from the world. Twenty of the twenty-three Alsatian ministers, one minister in the Palatinate region, and five in Germany support Ammann. These congregations became known as “Amish Mennonites.”

ca. 1717-1750:  The first wave of Amish immigration to North America took place.

ca. 1815-1861:  The second wave of Amish immigration to North America took place.

1862-1878:  The Diener Versammlungen, a series of ministers’ meetings, were held to confirm Amish unity, but the result was a division between traditionalists who wished to keep the “Old Order” and those desiring changes. After 1865, there was a distinct “Old Order” Amish movement.

1890:  The Budget (Sugarcreek, Ohio) began publication. Presenting correspondence from “scribes” in Old Order communities across North America, it linked Amish communities.

1910:  A schism in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, resulted in the formation of the Peachey church, which soon adopted such mainstream Protestant practices as Sunday School.

1913-1918:  The ultra-conservative Swartzentruber Amish group formed in Ohio, separating itself from the Old Order churches.

1925:  The first private Amish school, the Apple Grove School, was founded in Dover, Delaware.

1927:  A church division occurred in Somerset County, Pennsylvania, resulting in the formation of the Beachy Amish (after their leader, Bishop Moses Beachy). The group maintained plain dress but soon adopted the automobile and electricity. Other affiliations, both conservative and progressive, evolved over the next century.

1937:  Writing to “our Men of Authority” in the Pennsylvania state government, a group of Old Order church members from Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, present a petition (signed by over 3,000 Amish and Mennonites) to state officials, protesting a new law that would extend the school year from eight months to nine and raise the age at which children could leave school from fourteen to fifteen years old.

1937:  The Ixheim Amish congregation, the last remaining in Europe, merged with the nearby Ernstweiler Mennonite congregation.

1939:  Frustrated by school struggles, a group of Amish, led by Stephen F. Stoltzfus, left Pennsylvania to establish a new community in Maryland.

1940 – present:  Following World War II, social and economic changes in mainstream society began to challenge Amish communities. In some Amish communities, factory work offered a means of dealing with population growth, less (and more expensive) farmland, and increased competition from non-Amish farmers, who were increasingly relying on technological innovation. Other communities turned to entrepreneurship. Still others began to start new settlements where there was more available farmland.

1948:  The Old Order Book Society of Pennsylvania was formed to discuss, among other topics, the standardization of books to be used by the Old Order schools of in Pennsylvania.

1950s:  Increasingly, the Amish were starting their own schools in reaction to school consolidation and curricular change in public schools. While the Old Order Book Society was influencing the standardization of Old Order schools in Pennsylvania, a group of Old Order Amish teachers in Ontario, Ohio, and Indiana began a circle letter to help each other with classroom issues and provide support to new teachers.

1957:  The teachers’ circle letter became The Blackboard Bulletin , a monthly teachers’ journal devoted to developing Old Order schools.

1963:  Uria R. Byler wrote Our Better Country , an eighth grade history text specifically designed for Amish schools. An Amish letter to The Budget calls it “the first book ever written by an Amishman as a textbook for Amish children.”

1964:  The Pathway Publishing Company was incorporated by the Amish as a non-profit organization.

1965:  Self-employed Amish were exempted from Social Security. (Amish workers employed by other Amish were exempted in 1988.)

1967:  The Old Order Amish Steering Committee formed to serve as liaison between the Amish and the federal government, initially to address the military draft but later for other issues.

1967:  Lutheran pastor, the Reverend William Lindholm, organized the National Committee for Amish Religious Freedom to provide legal assistance to Amish communities that were challenging local laws governing school attendance.

1968:  The first of the Pathway Readers appeared, a series of textbooks designed specifically for Old Order schools.

1972:  In the case of Wisconsin v. Yoder, et al , the United States Supreme Court exempted the Amish from laws requiring them to send their children to high school.

1975:  Die Botschaft (Millersburg, Pennsylvania), a newspaper featuring letters only from “scribes” in Old Order communities, began publication.

1985:  The film Witness (from Paramount Pictures and starring Harrison Ford and Kelly McGillis) helped spur popular interest in the Amish.

2006:  A shooting at the Nickel Mines Amish School resulted in the death of five young Amish girls and attracted worldwide media attention.

2011:  Members of the Bergholz Amish community attack relatives and others who had opposed Bergholz leader Sam Mullet, cutting men’s beards and women’s hair. In 2012, sixteen members of the Bergholz community were convicted of hate crimes in federal court. The case sparked discussion of what it meant to be Amish.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Today’s Amish are descended from the Anabaptists, a radical faction of the reform movement that began at the end of October 1517, when Martin Luther (1483-1546) challenged Pope Leo X in Rome by nailing ninety-five theses to the door of the Wittenberg Church.

In 1518, the city-state of Zurich elected Ulrich Zwingli (1484-1531) [See painting at right], a former Catholic priest, to be its headpastor. Zwingli was popular, and many hoped that he would move quickly to do away with all rituals for which there was not a clear scriptural basis. Nevertheless, Zwingli felt that secular authority should guide reform, and he refused to proceed without the consent of the Zurich City Council, which had taken charge of the church. Zwingli’s decision seemed to privilege secular authority over scriptural and angered several of his young students, most particularly Conrad Grebel (ca.1498-1526), the son of a prominent Zurich family; Felix Manz (ca. 1498–January 5, 1527), another well-educated Zurich native; and Georg Blaurock (ca. 1492-September 6, 1529), a former priest. The conflict between students and teacher ultimately came to a head over the issue of infant baptism, a practice that not only had religious significance but also helped to ensure that children were entered into state records. In other words, it served a secular purpose as well as a religious one, creating both church members and citizens of the state. Grebel, Manz, Blaurock and their followers argued that, because infant baptism was not mentioned in scripture, it had no place in the church. They asserted baptism should be undertaken as a sign of one’s commitment to the church. Further, they argued, the church should be a believers’ church, a position that many in authority feared would bring anarchy. In January, 1525, the Zurich City Council enacted laws requiring that infants be baptized and forbidding the rebaptism of those who had been baptized as infants. In response, Grebel, Manz and Blaurock, rebaptized each other and launched the Anabaptist movement (Hostetler 1993; Hurst & McConnell 2010); Johnson-Weiner 2010; Kraybill et al 2013; Loewen and Nolt 1996; Nolt 2016).

Official persecution of Anabaptists did not stop the spread of the movement. Only ten years after it began, Michael Sättler (ca. 1495- May 21, 1527), a former priest from Freiburg, led a secret Anabaptist conference in February, 1527, in the town of Schleitheim, north of Zurich. From this conference came the Schleitheim Confession, the first written statement of Anabaptist belief. The Confession defined the church as a community of believers, separate from worldly society. One joined this church by voluntarily by choosing to be baptized, which ruled out infant baptism. The Confession also rejected violence, and argued that, within the church, those who sinned were to be simply banned from fellowship. Finally, the Confession proposed a ministry chosen from among the church membership (Loewen and Nolt 1996).

By the end of the sixteenth century, the Anabaptists were widely known as “Mennonites” after Menno Simons (1496-1561), a Dutch priest turned Anabaptist preacher whose teachings helped to shape Anabaptist views of baptism, nonconformity, and pacifism. Simons reaffirmed the Anabaptist view of the church as pacifist, non-resistant, and separate from the worldly social order. He also helped to reinforce the notion of the church as a fellowship of believers, who, through their commitment to following Christ’s example, would maintain the purity of the church. For Simons, excommunication and shunning were the only means church members had to guard the purity of the church (Loewen and Nolt 1996; Nolt 2016).

Shunning, the social avoidance or Meidung, of those excommunicated from church fellowship, was later upheld in the Dordrecht Confession of 1632, issued by the leaders of a number of Mennonite factions who came together in the city of Dordrecht in Holland in an attempt to iron out disagreements over church practice. As affirmed in the Confession, social avoidance meant that one could not eat, drink, do business with, or interact socially with any church member who had been put out of the fellowship. The Dordrecht Confession remains the statement of faith for today’s Amish groups (Dordrecht Confession; Loewen and Nolt 1996; Nolt 2016).

In 1693, Alsatian preacher, Jakob Ammann (1644-1730) [See drawing of Jakob Ammann at right] argued that the Mennonites were becoming worldly. He lamented the apparent willingness of Mennonite church members to conform to fashions in dress and tointeract with and even marry non-Mennonites, and he chastised congregations for their apparent failure to shun expelled members. Most of the Mennonite preachers and congregations in Switzerland and the Palatinate region rejected Amman’s call for greater separation from the world, and so, in 1693, Amman excommunicated them. Twenty of the twenty-three Alsatian ministers, along with one in the Palatinate and five in Germany, supported Amman. They and their congregations became known as Amish Mennonites, or, simply, Amish (Nolt 2016).

In response to continued persecution in Europe, many Amish immigrated to the new world. there were two waves of immigration to North America, the first lasting from approximately 1717 to 1750 and the second from 1817 to about 1861. The first wave of immigrants came primarily from the Palatinate and Switzerland and settled primarily in Pennsylvania. The second wave also brought immigrants from Alsace and Lorraine, and they tended to settled further west in Ohio, Illinois, Iowa, and Ontario (Crowley 1978; Hostetler 1993; Nolt 2016). By the end of the nineteenth century, most of the remaining Amish congregations in Europe had rejoined the Mennonites. The Ixheim Amish Church, the last remaining Amish congregation in Europe, merged with the Ernstweiler Mennonite Church in 1937. There are no Amish left in Europe today (Hostetler 1993; Nolt 2016).

By the mid-nineteenth century, there were a number of small, isolated Amish church-communities. Spread out geographically and encountering different hardships, they began to evolve in different ways. A number of regional ministers’ meetings were held in an attempt to resolve differences between the groups, but the divide between more conservative and more progressive congregations grew. Between 1862 and 1878, church leaders met annually, but ultimately the different factions were unable to reconcile. Pledging to remain faithful to the Alte Ordnung or “Old Order” of their forebears, the conservative congregations withdrew. Then and today, these church-communities are marked by a desire to continue with as little change as possible the practices of daily life and religious observance (Hostetler 1993; Johnson-Weiner 2010; Kraybill et al 2013; Nolt 2016).

The majority of more progressive Amish congregations formed regional conferences, each of which eventually merged with the Mennonite Church. A number of more traditionally-minded congregations remained unaffiliated with either the Old Order group or with the regional conferences. In 1910, these came together to form the Conservative Amish Mennonite Conference (Hostetler 1993; Kraybill, Johnson-Weiner and Nolt 2013; Nolt 2016).

As the lifestyle of the Old Order Amish became increasingly different from that of their non-Amish neighbors, and church-communities struggled to define their place in a changing world, schisms occurred. Increasingly, church members debated what to do about members who left the Old Order church in which they had been baptized to join more progressive Amish Mennonite congregations. Many argued that those who did so violated the vow they had taken at baptism to uphold the teachings of the church and so should be excommunicated and socially shunned in accordance with the Dordrecht Confession, a position called streng Meidung. Others disagreed. In Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, for example, Amish opposed to streng Meidung withdrew from the Old Order in 1910 to establish an independent church. This group, which became known as the Peachey Amish, soon accepted more mainstream Protestant practices, such as Sunday school.

Others protested when streng Meidung was not observed. In 1913, arguing for streng Meidung, Sam Yoder, a bishop in the Holmes County, Ohio, Amish settlement, asserted that one must remain in the church one had joined or be subject to excommunication and social avoidance. A number of ministers’ meetings were held in an attempt to reach a compromise that would hold the different congregations together, but, by 1917, Yoder’s faction, which would come to be known as the Swartzentruber Amish, was no longer fellowshipping with the Old Order congregations in the region (Hurst and McConnell 2010; Johnson-Weiner 2010).

In 1927, yet another schism occurred, this time in Somerset County, Pennsylvania, when Bishop Moses Beachy rejected streng Meidung. Within a year, members of the Beachy Amish had adopted both automobiles and electricity. Also embracing technology but to a more limited degree than the Beachy Amish, the New Order formed in 1966 when different Amish congregations began to emphasize spiritual values and to articulate a more individualistic belief in the assurance of salvation. Perhaps more properly a subgroup of the Old Order, the New Order Amish have offered a middle way between Old Order and Beachy churches, allowing tractors in the field but forbidding automobile ownership (Kraybill et al 2013; Nolt 2016).

Schisms have continued to separate congregations, providing evidence of the on-going struggle by Amish church-communities to apply Anabaptist principals in the face of pressure, both from the dominant, non-Amish society and from forces within the group. The Amish do not have any central organizing structure that would unite all congregations, so each Amish is a distinct and self-defined group, separate not only from the non-Amish community that surrounds it but also from most other Amish ones as well. A congregation may dien or “fellowship” with others whose Ordnungs, or church rules, are similar, meaning that ministers from one group are able to preach in church services held by the others and that a member of one church-community might marry a member of one of the others. But, although a church-community may consult with those with which it fellowships, it must ultimately find its own path (Hostetler 1993; Hurst and McConnell 2010; Johnson-Weiner 2010; Kraybill et al 2013; Nolt 2016; Nolt and Meyers 2007).

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Today, the church remains the one pervasive force in Amish existence. The standard German word for church is kirche, which, like its English equivalent, refers to the building in which services are held or to the services themselves. However, the word for church in Pennsylvania Dutch, the language spoken within Amish communities, is Gmay, from the German Gemeinde, meaning community. For the Amish, the church is not the building in which one meets, or even the religious services themselves, but rather a community formed of those dedicated to putting the teachings of Christ into practice (Hostetler 1993; Hurst and McConnell 2010; Johnson-Weiner 2010; Kraybill et al 2013; Nolt 2016; Nolt and Meyers 2007).

The Old Order Amish continue to believe that God’s people must be a faithful minority, “strangers and pilgrims” (1 Peter 2:11), in the world but not of it. The Amish belief, asserted in the Schleitheim and Dordrecht Confessions and reinforced by centuries of persecution, is that the Christian way will not be chosen by the majority of society, and, thus, they remain “a peculiar people” (Titus 2:14), separate from the world and prepared to suffer at its hands. They interpret the command to be separate from the world literally and, in refusing to assimilate to “English” or non-Old Order society, put strict barriers between themselves and the outside world. Distinct and self-defined, separate not only from the “English” or non-Amish but from other Old Order groups as well, each Old Order group is a redemptive community formed of those dedicated to putting the teachings of Christ into practice.

The Amish are Christian and their religious life is based on discipleship and obedience. Discipleship means the attempt to follow Christ’s example in their daily lives, and to do so they must be obedient to Christ’s teaching and to the church. Thus, the Amish link personal faith to their commitment to the church-community.

Discipleship and obedience result from “giving up,” surrendering to God’s will and trusting in God so completely that one accepts whatever happens with the certainty that it is part of God’s plan. The Amish don’t believe they are saved, for this is something only God can know. But if one can yield oneself completely to God, then, perhaps, one can live a life that will be worthy of salvation. One shows this yielding by how one lives (Kraybill et al 2013).

Life within each church-community is guided by its Ordnung or church discipline, which specifies what is sinful and worldly and, therefore, not to be tolerated. Those elements in the Ordnung that can’t be scripturally supported are justified by the feeling that to do otherwise would be detrimental to the community. The Amish believe that the individual human being is weak, and that only in fellowship with others also committed to God’s service can one gain the strength to live the life that will be pleasing to God.

Such a belief necessarily calls for the subordination of individual desire to group will. This is what baptism is all about. In making one’s baptismal vow before the church, one commits oneself to the Ordnung. Baptism is a vow of obedience, a promise to God to follow Christ’s example as revealed in scripture and interpreted by the Ordnung (Hostetler 1993; Kraybill et al 2013; Nolt 2016).

Ordnungs may change as the group responds to changing circumstances. Some changes may contribute to the economic viability of a community, while others may be reactions to legislation and social changes in the dominant society. Because no two communities have faced the same set of circumstances, no two Amish communities have exactly the same Ordnung. Even when there is general agreement, the outcome might be quite diverse. For example, all Old Order Amish forbid automobile ownership, but buggy styles vary from group to group, as do the rules governing when one can accept rides from a non-Amish neighbor (Hostetler 1993; Hurst and McConnell 2010; Johnson-Weiner 2010; Kraybill et al 2013; Nolt 2016; Nolt and Meyers 2007).

The Dordrecht Confession remains the statement of faith for these modern-day Anabaptists, and young people preparing for baptism study it. Among its key tenets are baptism upon confession of faith (Article 7), pacifism and non-resistance (Article 14), and excommunication and shunning (Articles 16 and 17).

RITUALS/PRACTICES

 Every other week, the church-community meets in the home of a family in the church. This is approximately twenty-six church meetings, so each family can expect to host the service once a year. Families know when their turn is coming up, though circumstances (the birth of a child, illness or death in the family) may result in one family taking another’s turn. Those with large homes may host church for a family whose house is too small (Kraybill et al 2013).

In preparing to host church, families clean their homes and farms. Generally others in the community, especially married daughters or sisters, will lend a hand as the hosting family scrubs down walls, cleans out cupboards, washes floors, and prepares the communal meal that will be served after the service (Johnson-Weiner 2010; Kraybill et al 2013).

Finally, the evening before the service, all of the furniture is moved aside, and the benches [See photograph of church benches at right] are brought in. In some communities,the Ausbunds (hymnbooks) are put out on the benches as well.

Church services begin between eight or nine in the morning, and they last three to four hours. All attend, and there are no nurseries or special services for children. Men and women sit separately. While the congregation sings, the ministry meets in a separate room to decide who will give the opening sermon and the main sermon. There will be silent kneeling prayer after the opening sermon and affirmations (Zeugnis) by ministers or elderly men after the main sermon. Then church members kneel again in prayer before they stand for the final benediction. If a meeting of church members is needed to discuss some important issue, then children and anyone not baptized is excused. Finally, all gather for a fellowship meal, which follows a menu that varies from community to community. While the Swartzentruber Amish always serve bean soup, other Amish groups serve sandwiches with a special “church” spread (Hostetler 1993; Kraybill et al 2013).

The Amish celebrate Good Friday, Easter, Easter Monday, Pentecost, Whitmonday, Ascension Day, Christmas, and, in some groups, “Old Christmas” or Epiphany.

Communion, held in the spring and in the fall, is the most important celebration of church life. Communion Church ( Gros Gmay ) is preceded by Council Church (Ordnungs Gmay). Council Church, attended only by baptized church members, is a time for reviewing the Ordnung and for individuals to recommit to it. This is also the time to purge any ill feelings, confess sins, and forgive others, for, if there is not unity and harmony in the church-community, communion cannot be held two weeks later (Hostetler 1993; Kraybill et al 2013).

Communion is a day-long service that peaks with the retelling of Christ’s suffering and the sharing of bread and wine. It closes with members washing each other’s feet, giving the holy kiss, and providing offerings. It is the only time an offering is collected. Finally, if a church-community needs a new minister (or deacon or bishop), then this generally happens at the close of the communion service (Hostetler 1993; Kraybill et al 2013).

Baptism is the most important rite in any Amish person’s life, for it signals the individual’s confession of Christian faith and devotion to the church. It has important consequences, for, if the individual acts in such a way that he or she violates the Ordnung, then there will be public confession, and possibly excommunication and shunning. Prior to baptism, candidates meet with the ministers and bishop to study the eighteen articles of the Dordrecht Confession. The baptismal service itself takes place after the second of the sermons at a Sunday service. The deacon pours a small amount of water into the bishop’s hands, who, in baptizing the individual, releases the water over the candidate’s head. If the candidate is male, the bishop then shakes his hand and gives him the kiss of peace. If the candidate is female, then the bishop’s wife makes these gestures(Hostetler 1993; Kraybill et al 2013).

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

The church district, or congregation, is the central unit of Amish authority. Limited in size by geography and the number of families that can reasonably meet in an Amish home, the church district is governed by athree-part ministry whose officials are chosen by a combination of democracy and faith. There is a deacon (called in German Armen-Diener or “minister to the poor”), whose responsibilities include assisting in marriage arrangements and seeing to it that the material needs of all in the community are met. Two to three preachers (Diener zum Buch or “minister of the book”) are responsible for preaching and counseling. Finally, there is a bishop (Voelliger-Diener or “minister with full powers”), who performs marriages, baptisms, excommunications, and funerals. When a new clergyman is needed, all members of the church, male and female, are consulted. Each is asked to nominate someone (a baptized male, married and settled enough to be a stable leader). Those receiving a sufficient number of nominations (depending on the size of the congregation) take part in a lottery. While the candidates withdraw into another room, church members set out on a church bench as many Ausbunds, the Amish hymnbook, as there are candidates, placing in one of the hymnals a piece of paper on which is written a Bible verse. When the candidates come out, each chooses a hymnal, and the one choosing the hymnal containing the Bible verse rises to church office. Each Amish person, thus, has a say in the spiritual stability of the church and, by extension, in the stability of the community as a whole. But God has the final word (Hostetler 1993:106; Kraybill et al 2013).

Having been chosen by God, the ministry has considerable authority, and appointments, while unpaid, are generally for life. Nevertheless, an ordained deacon, preacher, or bishop may be silenced if the members of the church feel that he has transgressed or violated the Ordnung. Ultimately, decision-making within the community is subject to der Rat der Gemein or a vote of all church members. All those baptized in the church-community have a say in determining, for example, whether a member is to be excommunicated or reinstated or what actions the church-community should take on particular matters (Hostetler 1993; Kraybill et al 2013).

The church and the Ordnung allow Amish families to live as a community within a community, surrounded by non-Amish society and yet separate from it. The physical boundaries of the community are reinforced by the Ordnung’s limitations on use of the telephone, electricity, the automobile, and all other technological innovations that could disrupt the daily face-to-face that reinforces personal ties.

Ordnungs govern language, strengthening the community by clearly marking the boundaries between those who belong and those who do not. Pennsylvania Dutch or Deitsch, also called Pennsylvania German, is used for oral communication within the group. English is used for writing and to talk to outsiders. Young children, who often do not begin to learn English until they enter school, may be bashful in front of outsiders who communicate in a strange tongue (Johnson-Weiner 2010; Kraybill et al 2013; Louden 2016).

Plain dress further distinguishes members of the church-community from outsiders, identifying the group and giving the wearer a sense of belonging. After Jakob Ammann broke with the other Mennonite congregations, his followers were soon distinguishable by dress. Ammann argued that men should not trim their beards and that church members should wear plain clothing. Locally, his followers became known as Häftler (“hook-and-eye people”) because they often chose to use this simple means of fastening their clothing rather than buttons, which were considered more worldly. The Mennonites were called Knőpfler (“button people”) (Hostetler 1993; Kraybill et al 2013; Nolt 2016).

The Amish don’t think of plain dress as Christian clothing, but rather as Amish clothing, essential not to salvation but to carrying out the full will of God. Thus, in getting dressed in the morning, each Amish person follows the Ordnung. In not ever cutting her hair and in keeping it hidden under her cap, the woman acts in accordance with Paul’s advice to the Corinthians (11:1-14). In cutting his hair according to the Ordnung and shaving off his mustache, the Amish man signals church membership. Whether boys’ shirts have collars, whether women’s capes are the same color as their dresses, whether the capes are crossed or straight, whether the caps are pleated or plain all indicate one’s membership in a particular church-community.

Homes [See photo at right] and their interiors are also shaped by the Ordnung. In fact, the church-community’s Ordnung
regulates much of daily life. While church members will acknowledge that not everything in the Ordnung is scripturally based, what cannot be supported by reference to the Bible is justified by the feeling that to do otherwise would be worldly and disruptive to the community.

For example, all Old Order Amish groups forbid automobile ownership and regulate when members can hire drivers. The Amish know that with fast, easy transportation readily available, family members are apt to be away from home more often than not, and the church community is likely to become very scattered.

Other machinery is similarly evaluated. [See photo of Amish buggy at right] Just because a piece of machinery or a household
appliance saves the owner time does not necessarily recommend it, nor does it being “modern” condemn it. The question is simply how it will affect the church-community. Most Amish communities use some battery-powered devices, notably flashlights, as well as diesel motors. Some Amish communities have even permitted solar power. Nevertheless, all have determined that connecting the Amish home to power lines “could lead to many temptations and the deterioration of church and family life” (Hostetler 1993; Hurst and McConnell 2010; Johnson-Weiner 2010; Kraybill 2001; Kraybill et al 2013; Nolt 2016; Nolt and Meyers 2007).

Daily life, shaped by the Ordnung, is bound by scripture. The father reads the scripture in the morning when the family rises and again before they retire for the night. Every meal begins and ends with silent prayer. Every day practice reinforces the scripture lesson. The father sits at the head of the table, and children in order of age, boys on one side and girls on the other. Each child knows his or her place in the family, and, thus, in the community.

The family is the church in microcosm, its formal structure reflecting the formal structure of the church community, which is the larger family of those in the body of Christ. In the Old Order community, one is, in a sense, always in church, in the world but not of it.

The importance of this is even clearer when one realizes that few life cycle functions leave the home (Kraybill et al 2013; Scott 1998):

● The Old Order use modern medicines, but they are often more comfortable with chiropractors or even home remedies.

● Birth, marriage, retirement, illness, and death all ideally occur at home and are often intensely private. Burial is in cemeteries on land owned by the community.

● The family is responsible for its own expenses, but others in the community help through the donation of funds or labor (e.g. barn raisings).

Amish children start school at about age six and attend through the eighth grade. Although many Amish children still attend localpublic schools, most attend small one or two-room schoolhouses in their own communities, where they are taught by teachers of their own faith [See photograph of Amish school at right]. While teachers’ meetings in many communities provide teachers with some training and support, in the most conservative Amish settlements, teachers are likely to be young, unmarried, girls from the community with little or no formal training. In their eight years of formal education, Amish children learn English, arithmetic, German, and maybe geography and health. The important lessons (how to manage the farm and the household, how to raise the children, how to be responsible and work hard) are learned at home, where children participate in work, play, and ceremony to the extent of their abilities (Dewalt 2006; Johnson-Weiner 2007).

At age sixteen or seventeen, depending on the practices of their church-community, Amish teens join the Young Folk or Youngie. This is Rumspringa or the “running around period,” when young people have a social life with each other distinct from family activities. In very conservative groups, the young folk gather in the evenings on a church Sunday to have supper together and sing hymns. In more progressive Amish communities, young folks may dress in non-Amish clothes and buy forbidden objects such as cameras, radios, or even cars and store them at the homes of English neighbors (Stevick 2014).

During Rumspringa , a young Amish person must make the most important choice of all, whether to be baptized or not. Baptism is vowing to God to follow the teachings of the Bible as taught in the Amish church and interpreted in the Ordnung. As did the first Anabaptists, the Old Order Amish see the church as a fellowship of believers; an Amish young person does not become truly Amish until he or she is baptized and joins the church. If a young person does not join the church, he or she will not be encouraged to stay in the community, but he or she will certainly not be thrown out. If a young person does become baptized and then violates the baptismal vows, falls into sin, violates the Ordnung, or refuses to heed the counsel and concern of the fellowship, then he or she must be excommunicated and shunned (Kraybill et al 2013; Stevick 2014).

Young folk gatherings are also the context for dating. Amish marriages can only unite church members from fellowshipping communities. Rumspringa ends with marriage.

Visiting is frequent and important in Amish society, further affirming and reinforcing familial and church ties. The ill and infirm receive many visits as do the elderly and those who are grieving a death. Sometimes the young folk or young married couples sing favorite songs for the elderly or those confined to their home. During childbirth, a funeral, fire, or accident, people assist by making meals, doing chores, running errands, doing childcare and other tasks. Adult children may set up a weekly rotation to assist an elderly parent who needs constant care. Circle letters are a common way of connecting with others who have experienced a similar illness (heart surgery, breast cancer) or accident, such as parents of children who suffered a sudden death, or died by drowning. Periodic country-wide or regional gatherings for people with a certain disability or disease are also an important source of support that stretches beyond the family circle. Finally, family, church and friends typically provide financial support when bills, especially high medical bills, threaten to overwhelm a single family (Kraybill et al 2013).

The Amish world is diverse, but the different church-communities share important similarities. For all Amish congregations,scripture is the final authority. Amish church services are conducted in German, and all Amish sing from the Ausbund [See scan of pages from Ausbund at right], a hymnbook first printed in 1564 that contains songs written by early Anabaptists. The Lobelied, a hymn of praise, is always the second song in the service, but more conservative congregations sing it far more slowly than more progressive ones. The Ausbund does not contain melodies for the songs, and tunes are passed down from one generation to the next, further uniting the community (Hostetler 1993; Kraybill et al 2013).

Also uniting church-communities are two weekly newspapers, The Budget (Sugarcreek, Ohio) and Die Botschaft (Millersburg, Pennsylvania), which publish letters from “scribes” within each community, detailing the weather, who had church, what visitors were there, and who might be ill, as well as births, deaths, travels, and everyday events. A monthly newsletter, The Diary , gives further information including summaries of those who have moved and community events (Kraybill et al 2013).

In addition, church-community newsletters are read far beyond the geographic borders of the settlements in which they’re published, and Old Order Amish magazines focus on a variety of topics, from home-making to clock-making and bird-watching. The Pathway Publishing Corporation, an Amish-owned publishing company in Aylmer, Ontario, publishes three widely read monthly magazines, Family Life, Young Companion, and The Blackboard Bulletin, this last a publication aimed at Old Order teachers (Johnson-Weiner 2007; Kraybill et al 2013).

Finally, uniting the diverse Amish communities are regular gatherings of ministers and others who meet to discuss issues of concern in the Amish world. Although the Amish remain congregationally based, many church-communities send representatives to the meetings of the Old Order Amish Steering Committee, which formed in 1966 to negotiate a response to the military draft. At other times, Amish communities have worked together on educational issues, and, in a number of states, a state-wide committee regulates Old Order schools (Hostetler 1993; Kraybill et al 2013; Nolt 2016).

Nevertheless, the church-community remains the center of Amish authority. Because something is done in a particular way in one district is no guarantee that it will be done that way in any other. This doesn’t make one Old Order community any more authentic or another any less. All are Old Order Amish, and, as they are likely to say, “That’s just our way.”

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

There are always those who are raised in Amish communities but choose not to join the Amish church. A survey of the world’s largest Amish settlement, the diverse community in the Holmes County area of Ohio, found that nearly forty percent of New Order Amish left the church community, while only 2.6 percent left the far more conservative Andy Weaver affiliation. Nationally, roughly ten to fifteen percent of Amish young people choose not to be baptized in the Amish church. The percentage of baptized church members who leave (and thus are subject to excommunication and shunning) is much smaller. In general, the more conservative the community, the higher the retention rate (Kraybill et al 2013).

Although they do accept converts, the Amish do not proselytize, and the number of outsiders who join Amish church-communities is small.

Maintaining the health of the church ultimately depends on keeping young folk from leaving the community. To do so, churches must successfully reconcile faith, tradition, and history with current community and individual needs and with the requirements of the surrounding, non-Amish society. This has become increasingly difficult. In some Amish communities, factory work has offered a means of dealing with population growth, less (and more expensive) farmland, and increased competition from non-Amish farmers, who are increasingly relying on technological innovation. Other communities have turned to entrepreneurship. Still others have started new settlements where there is more available farmland. Each of these paths has had implications for the different church-communities, and today the Amish world is more diverse than ever.

Perhaps the most important challenges facing today’s Amish are changes in mainstream society. New laws requiring photo IDs to accomplish such everyday tasks as opening a bank account pose formidable barriers to more conservative Amish groups whose Ordnungs forbid photographs. Requirements that tax documents be filed on line also stymy the individual Amish farmer, who likely lacks not only a computer but a phone and phone line. Other developments, such as changes to building codes or new regulations regarding child labor and insurance, have also resulted in charges against members of Amish churches.

REFERENCES

“Amish Population Profile 2015.” Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Elizabethtown College. Accessed from http://groups.etown.edu/amishstudies/statistics/amish-population-profile-2015 on 7 March 2016.

Crowley, William K. 1978. “Old Order Amish Settlement: Diffusion and Growth. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 68: 249-64.

Dewalt, Mark. 2006. Amish Education in the United States and Canada. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.

Dordrecht Confession of Faith. Accessed from http://gameo.org/index.php?title=Dordrecht_Confession_of_Faith_(Mennonite,_1632) on 7 March 2016.

Hostetler, John A. 1993. Amish Society. Fourth Edition. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.

Hostetler, John A. and Thomas J. Meyers. January 2012. “Old Order Amish.” Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia Online. Accessed from http://gameo.org/index.php?title=Old_Order_Amish&oldid=133422 on 3 March 2016.

Hurst, Charles E. and David L. McConnell. 2010. An Amish Paradox: Diversity and Change in the World’s Largest Amish Community . Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press.

Johnson-Weiner, Karen M. 2010. New York Amish: Life in the Plain Communities of the Empire State. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

Johnson-Weiner, Karen M. 2007. Train Up a Child: Old Order Amish and Mennonite Schools. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.

Kraybill, Donald B. 2001. The Riddle of Amish Culture . (rev. ed.) Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.

Kraybill, Donald B., Karen M. Johnson-Weiner, Steven M. Nolt. 2013. The Amish. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.

Loewen, Harry and Steven Nolt. 1996. Through Fire and Water. An Overview of Mennonite History. Scottdale, PA: Herald Press.

Louden, Mark. 2016. Pennsylvania Dutch. The Story of an American Language. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press.

Nolt, Steven. M. 2015. A History of the Amish, Third Edition. New York: Good Books.

Nolt, Steven M. and Thomas. J. Meyers. 2007. Plain Diversity. Amish Cultures & Identities. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press.

Scott, Stephen. 1988. The Amish Wedding and Other Special Occasions of the Old Order Communities. Intercourse, PA: Good Books.

Stevick, Richard A. 2014. Growing Up Amish. The Rumspringa Years, Second Edition. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press.

SUPPLEMENTARY RESOURCES

 Huntington, Gertrude E. 2001. Amish in Michigan. East Lansing, MI: Michigan State University Press.

Kaiser, Grace H. 1986. Dr. Frau: A Woman Doctor Among the Amish. Intercourse, PA: Good Books.

Kraybill, Donald B. 2014. Renegade Amish. Beard Cutting, Hate Crimes, and the Trial of the Bergholz Barbers. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press.

Kraybill, Donald B. and Carl F. Bowman. 2001. On the Backroad to Heaven: Old Order Hutterites, Mennonites, Amish, and Brethren. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.

Kraybill, Donald B., Steven M. Nolt, and David L. Weaver-Zercher. 2010. Amish Grace: How Forgiveness Transcended Tragedy. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, Inc.

Kraybill, Donald B., Steven M. Nolt, and David L. Weaver-Zercher. 2010. The Amish Way: Patient Faith in a Perilous World. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, Inc.

Mackall, Joseph. 2008. Plain Secrets: An Outsider among the Amish. Boston: Beacon Press.

Stoltzfus, Louise. 1994. Amish Women: Lives and Stories. Intercourse, PA: Good Books.

Weaver-Zercher, Valerie. 2013. Thrill of the Chaste. The Lure of Amish Romance Novels. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press.

Wesner, Erik. 2010. Success Made Simple: An Inside Look at Why Amish Businesses Thrive. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, Inc.

IMAGES
Image #1: This image is a painting of Ulrich Zwingli, the elected mayor of city-state of Zurich whose support of secular authority led to the launching of the Anabaptist movement.
Image #2: This image is a drawing of Jakob Ammann, who led the breakaway from the Mennonites to form the Amish Mennonites.
Image 3: This image is a photograph of church benches outside of an Amish home. Photograph taken by and used with the permission of Karen Johnson-Weiner.
Image #4: This image is a photograph of a Swartzentruber Amish home. Ordnungs dictate architecture. Photograph taken by and used with the permission of Karen Johnson-Weiner.
Image #5: This image is a photograph of Nebraska Amish buggies in Pennsylvania’s Big Valley region. Photograph taken by and used with the permission of Karen Johnson-Weiner.
Image #6: This image is a photograph of an Amish School in Ashland, Ohio. Photograph taken by and used with the permission of Karen Johnson-Weiner.
Image #7: This image is a document fragment from a document by an anabaptist songwriter (scan from book) [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons.

Post Date:
12 March 2016

Share

Bethel Bible College

BETHEL BIBLE COLLEGE TIMELINE

1873 (June 4):  Charles Fox Parham was born in Muscatine, Iowa.

1888:  Parham began teaching Sunday school and holding revival meetings.

1890:  Parham entered a Methodist school, Southwestern College, in Winfield, Kansas.

1893:  Parham began actively preaching as a supply pastor for the Methodist Churches in Eudora,
Kansas and in Linwood, Kansas.

1895:  Parham surrendered his local preacher’s license and walked away from the Methodist Church.

1898 (Autumn):  Parham opened Bethel Healing Home at the corner of Fourth and Jackson Streets in Topeka, Kansas.

1899 (March 22):  Charles Parham and James Staples published the first issue of a weekly paper entitled The Apostolic Faith .

1900 (summer):  Parham took a six-week sabbatical to attend “Shiloh,” a Bible and Ministry training school in Durham, Maine.

1900 (October 15):  Parham opened the College of Bethel (which later became Bethel Bible College).

1901 (January 1):  Agnes Ozman was the first of many at Bethel Bible College to receive a powerful outpouring of the Holy Spirit and to speak in tongues.

1901 (July 20):  Bethel Bible College lost the lease on its building after it was sold to a new owner who opened it as a roadhouse.

1901 (December 6):  Former building of Bethel Bible College was destroyed by fire.

1902 (January):  Parham wrote his first book which had a Hebrew title, Kol Kare Bomidbar, meaning “A Voice Crying in the Wilderness.”

1905:  Parham opened a ten-week Bible School at the corner of Rusk and Brazos Streets in Houston, Texas and allowed a young black man, William Joseph Seymour, to become a student of the Bible School.

1906 (February):  William J. Seymour left Houston to accept a position as a holiness minister in Los Angeles, California.

1906 (April 14):  William J. Seymour opened the Azusa Street Mission (Apostolic Faith Mission) in Los Angeles, California.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Charles Fox Parham was born on June 4, 1873 to William M. and Ann Maria Eckel Parham in Muscatine, Iowa. By the time William and Ann’s third son, Charles, was born, William was a horse collar maker and painter by trade. Five years later the family moved from Muscatine County, Iowa to Sedgwick County, Kansas, enabling William to join in the agricultural wheat boom of the area.

The people who lived in rural America experienced years of economic and social depression followed by years of prosperity, which created an atmosphere of uncertainty. Religion offered both hope for a better future and a path to cope with the unstable conditions. Churches were few and far between, but in some areas there were traveling preachers who would visit different areas, though infrequently due to the distances involved. The Parham family brought very few books with them when they relocated to Kansas . Among them were a couple of history books, a few old school books, a dictionary and a Bible.

Within the first decade of his life, Parham suffered many childhood illnesses, including encephalitis, stomach problems, colds and/or flu, possible migraines and a very painful bout of rheumatic fever. By the age of ten Parham was “so emaciated that he could count the bones in his hand by holding it up to the light” (Goff 1988:23). Unable to participate in normal chores expected of a child on the farm, he spent a lot of time with his mother. Parham had felt a call to the ministry from the age of nine, and the Bible became his closest companion. There were times that he would go out into the fields and gather cows around him and give them passionate sermons on the realities of the future (Parham 1902:8).

When his mother, Ann Parham, died during childbirth, he was only twelve years-old, yet he made a promise that he would see her again in heaven. One year later, in 1886, he began attending evening scripture meetings, which he thoroughly enjoyed though he still had not made the decision to become a Christian. The meetings were led by a Brother Lippard of the Congregational Church House. One night Brother Lippard threatened to cancel the meetings unless someone else volunteered to start the meeting. Parham stood at the beginning of the next meeting to volunteer, but he was counted as having converted. He did not correct the misunderstanding. Later on the road home, he felt a deep conviction about not being authentic about converting. He found it difficult to pray, and instead a Gospel hymn came to his mind, “I am Coming to the Cross.” With his face turned skyward he began the third verse and was instantly overcome as: “there flashed from the Heaven, a light above the brightness of the sun; like a stroke of lightning it penetrated, thrilling every tissue and fiber of my being; knowing by experimental knowledge what Peter knew of old, that He was the Christ, the Son of the living God” (Parham 1902:11).

By the age of fifteen, Parham had begun teaching Sunday school and holding revival meetings. His messages were drawn from the many religious figures and events that had influenced him. These included Dwight L. Moody, who emphasized personal conversion and premillennialism, and the Keswick, England camp meetings. The camp meetings emphasized a special anointing through the Baptism of the Holy Spirit that would enrich their commitment to serve God in whatever ways He led them in Christian service. Parham also accepted the divine healing views of A.J. Gordon and A.B. Simpson (both believed in divine healing through the atoning death of Jesus Christ). However, it was Benjamin Hardin Irwin, a Wesleyan from Lincoln, Nebraska, who most influenced Parham with “Baptism with the Holy Ghost and fire” (Goff 1988:54). Believers who had this experience were often physically overcome with exuberant joy.

In 1890, Parham entered a Methodist school, Southwestern College in Winfield, Kansas, with the intention of pursuing an education for ministry. He struggled to stay focused on his college studies as he was more inclined to pursue religious work. He soon saw the consequences of his distraction, and, as his grades slipped, he began to question his life in ministry. This was also about the time the Panic of 1893 started. Railroads had been overbuilt and their tenuous finances created a widespread panic that caused many investors to sell their stocks as banks called railroad loans early and many banks failed. Parham began to worry about his financial future in ministry and thus began thinking about a more lucrative profession in medicine. He began to seek a medical degree, turning his back on the ministry.

Parham experienced another round of the rheumatic fever in the spring of 1891, and he suffered for many months despite strong drugs until one day he heard his physician predict that he would not recover this time. He was certain that God had brought back the rheumatic fever as a reminder to him of his promise to dedicate his life to ministry. Remembering the lessons about the healings in the New Testament, he prayed for healing. He recovered from the rheumatism (with the intervention of God, he was convinced) but his ankles were so damaged and weak that he ended up flopping his feet to the side as he walked painfully for months. Finally, in December, 1891, Parham recalled that he had promised God that he would dedicate his life to the ministry. He rededicated his life to ministry and promised God that he would quit college if God would heal his ankles. Strength instantly returned to his ankles, and they appeared to be completely healed. Parham left Southwestern College after three years with a renewed vigor to pursue a life in ministry.

Parham received a call from and was licensed by the Methodist Episcopal Church, North, in March, 1893. He began actively preaching in June of 1893, at the age of twenty, as a supply pastor for the Eudora Methodist Church. A supply pastor is a lay member who is called to perform all the duties of a minister but does not administer the sacraments. The church’s pastor, Werter Renick Davis, who had previously been the first president of Baker University , died suddenly in June of 1893. Parham was asked to continue serving as pastor for the Church for the rest of the year. In addition to his pastoral duties at the Eudora Church , he traveled to the Congregational Church in Linwood where he held revivals. On Sunday mornings he led services in Eudora and in the afternoon he led services in Linwood.

Parham was influenced by the Wesleyan Holiness movement, which taught that current believers could receive a second blessing of sanctification to remove the sin-nature that tempted them to commit sins. This sanctification was in addition to the first act of faith, accepting Jesus Christ as one’s Savior.

Parham gave up his local preacher’s license in March of 1895 and walked away from the Methodist Church after hearing that the new Conference members were not allowed to “preach by direct inspiration” (Goff 1988:36). Some of the subjects that Parham was preaching about were beginning to cause problems for the Methodist Church leaders. He advised people that church membership had nothing to do with salvation and so they should not be too concerned about whether or not to join a church. He believed in conversion and in the second blessing that removed sin-nature. He believed that water baptism was only a ritual but that the Baptism of the Holy Spirit was essential.

Charles Parham married Sarah Thistlethwaite on December 31, 1896. Sarah was the daughter of a Quaker family he met in Tonganoxie , Kansas during his first year in the ministry. Her father was influential in teaching Parham about an evangelical view of hell that depicts the total annihilation of the wicked rather than the traditional doctrine of hell of being eternally separated from God.

In September of 1897 Parham developed heart disease, and his young son, Claude, became ill. Doctors prescribed medicines for the child, but nothing was effective. The scripture “Physician, heal thyself” came to mind; Parham prayed for a healing for himself and believed he was healed. He prayed for his son’s healing and discarded his son’s medicine. His son was also healed. Parham believed that his son’s healing was a result of his faith in and dependence on God. He was now convinced that diseases were of a spiritual nature and were caused by a lack of faith in God. Reliance on medical measures simply reinforced that lack of faith. About two months later, the death of a close friend left Parham feeling partly responsible as he had failed to pray for his healing. It was at this point that he dedicated his ministry to working for salvation from sin and sickness. This led him to begin a new ministry of divine healing in Ottawa, Kansas . It was not long before he received requests to come pray for people as far away as Topeka, a city of about thirty thousand. Parham saw the potential for growth of his ministry and moved his family to Topeka during the summer of 1898. He located a building to rent at the corner of Fourth and Jackson Streets, and a few months later Parham opened Bethel Healing Home.

Bethel Healing Home was a combination home and Bible School where the only textbook was the Bible. Parham led the classes in healing, prophecy and various other topics mainly focused on teaching those who were previously involved in religious work. The Healing Home also offered a temporary orphanage that helped to find Christian homes for the orphan children. An ad hoc employment bureau focused on connecting Christian employees with Christian employers. There were fourteen rooms on the second floor that served as living quarters for the Parham family and for the ill and disabled residents. Resident fees ranged from four to seven dollars per week depending on ability to pay; however, there were other options if a person or family was too poor to pay the fees.

In an attempt to help cover some of the costs of the Healing Home that were not covered by resident fees, Charles Parham and James A. Staples, a local publisher, began publishing a weekly paper entitled The Apostolic Faith . The first issue of the paper was released on March 22, 1899; it contained articles on the holiness movement and healing testimonies as well as religious advertisements. Two months later, Staples suggested changing the frequency to monthly publication, but Parham refused and Staples relinquished his share of the publication. Parham continued as editor and publisher, but by August he had reduced the subscription fee and began publishing the paper semimonthly. Many free issues were distributed, and it was noted that people as far away as New Orleans had subscribed to the publication. The Apostolic Faith became known as the first Pentecostal journal and was published between March 22, 1899 and April 15, 1900.

During the summer of 1900 Parham and about eight others from the Topeka mission attended a six-week session at “Shiloh,” a Bible and Missionary training school founded by Frank W. Sandford’s “Holy Ghost and Us” society in Durham, Maine. When the group returned to the Bethel Healing Home, they were denied access by the people that Parham had left in charge during his absence. Many people encouraged Parham to seek revenge on his former colleagues, but he refused and instead he prayed and looked for God’s provision to keep the ministry going.

A few months later someone affiliated with the American Bible Society of Philadelphia, who knew of Parham’s healing ministry,offered him the opportunity to rent an unfinished mansion in Topeka, often referred to as “Stone’s Folly,” which they had purchased from its previous owner, Erastus R. Stone. Parham agreed to rent the mansion from the Society. On October 15, 1900, he opened Bethel Bible College “with about three dozen persons, including “students” and their children in attendance. Most all of them were ministers or religious workers from Methodist, Baptist, Quaker and independent Holiness Churches and Missions and all were seeking a new experience of the Spirit for evangelistic work” (Anderson 1979:51).

Bethel Bible College held prayer meetings in the tower rooms, twenty-four hours a day, with students participating in three-hour shifts. The students canvassed houses during the day and then held worship services in the evenings in a downtown mission. Several of the rooms were set aside for healing and prayer, and fasting was encouraged. All material possessions and money were shared; everyone ate at a common table, performed chores, worked in the mission and studied with the goal of totally obeying the commandments of Jesus.

Prior to leaving for a three-day revival in Kansas City in late December, 1900, Parham instructed each member of the Bethel group to read the book of Acts and to study the subject of baptism looking for outward evidence of the true baptism. When he returned, he asked what the students had discovered. All of them reported that they believed that speaking in tongues was the evidence of the true baptism of the Holy Spirit. The group believed the outpouring of the Holy Spirit would prepare them with the languages needed for missionary work in all parts of the world.

Watch night services began on New Year’s Eve with prayer, fasting and welcoming of the expected imminent coming of the Holy Spirit. On the next day around 11:00 P.M., Agnes Ozman, at student at the college, had an intense desire to receive the Holy Spirit, and so she asked for prayer and the laying of hands upon her. She soon began glorifying God as she spoke in tongues which she believed sounded like various Chinese dialects. Those present believed that this phenomenon was the outpouring of the Holy Spirit and was causing people to speak in other tongues in preparation for ministry in foreign lands.

Two days later, Parham held a meeting at the Free Methodist Church in Topeka, Kansas. He told the congregation about the recent events at Bethel Bible College and that he anticipated all of the students would be speaking in tongues as they were baptized with the Holy Spirit. When he returned from the meeting, he saw a white light glowing in the second floor room of the college as twelve ministers filled with the Holy Spirit were calmly speaking in other tongues. Parham knelt and prayed for the same blessing. He began to speak first in what he believed sounded like a version of the Swedish language and then later in other languages.

DOCTRINES/RITUALS

Parham’s March 22, 1899, issue of “the Apostolic Faith listed the Hliness beliefs of the Bethel Healing Home as “salvation by faith; healing by faith; laying on of hands, and prayer; sanctification by faith; coming (pre-millennium)[sic] of Christ; the baptism of the Holy Ghost and Fire, which seals the Bride and bestows the gifts” (Goff 1988:55). At Bethel Bible College, students followed the “teaching by the Holy Spirit directly through “prophecy,” and through “messages” in tongues and interpretation” (Anderson 1979:60).

Prayer meetings were held in the tower rooms, twenty-four hours a day, with the students participating in three hour shifts. They believed that speaking in tongues was the evidence of true baptism of the Holy Spirit. They desired and anticipated being recipients of an outpouring of the Holy Spirit as had happened at Pentecost and had been written about in the book of Acts in the Bible. The students canvassed houses during the day and then held worship services in the evenings in a downtown mission. Several of the rooms were set aside for healing. Prayer and fasting were encouraged. All material possessions and money were shared; everyone ate at a common table, performed chores, and studied in the mission with the goal of totally obeying the commandments of Jesus. Late in Parham’s ministry of healing there was such a high demand for his prayers of healing that he prayed over handkerchiefs and sent them to the people who requested prayers of healing.

For weeks afterward, many newspaper reporters came to Topeka to report on the new Pentecost. Parham decided to travel the country spreading the message. He and seven workers traveled to Kansas City and received considerable publicity from the newspapers. Soon afterward, he led a group of twenty people to Lawrence to pray and talk with people and encourage them to attend the evening meetings, which were being held in an old theater. During the meetings, “some were saved, the sick were healed, and a number received the Holy Ghost and spoke in tongues” (Martin 1997:88).

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Bethel Healing Home began as a combination home and Bible school. The textbook was the Bible and classes in healing, prophecy and other topics were taught by Parham to students who had previously been involved in religious work. A temporary orphanage helped to find Christian homes for orphan children. An ad hoc employment bureau focused on connecting Christian employees with Christian employers. There were fourteen rooms on the second floor which served as living quarters for the Parham family and for the ill and disabled residents.

Bethel Bible College operated on faith. Students had previously been active in different religious denominations, though most were from the Holiness movement. They shared a common bond of a desire for a meaningful experience of the Holy Spirit and looked forward to carrying that passion into their evangelistic work.

It is interesting to note that the building that housed the Bethel Healing Home was purchased in 2013 by Topeka Storm Ministries.That congregation began the process of having the building listed on the National Historic Register. Members have restored the chapel and regular worship services are being held on Sundays and Wednesdays under the name of Tree of Life Fellowship. There are plans to continue restoring the rest of the building to its original design. Healing rooms and a memorabilia room are expected to open as part of the continuing restoration.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Bethel Bible College lost the lease to the building when it expired on July 20, 1901 as the owners had sold the property to Harry Croft. The new owner converted the building into a roadhouse where liquor was unlawfully sold; the establishment was often raided by police. On December 6, 1901, the building was mysteriously destroyed by fire, leaving only the foundation and a few pieces of wood and trim. The property where Bethel Bible College was located later became the site for The Most Pure Heart of Mary Catholic Parish.

Parham, his wife, and her sister traveled to Kansas City to open another Bible school, which was located in a building at the corner of Eleventh and Oak Streets in downtown Kansas City. However, the family closed the school after only four months and moved to Lawrence, Kansas, where they lived for the next one and a half years. It was during this time that Parham wrote his first book, Kol Kare Bomidbar, Hebrew for “A Voice Crying in the Wilderness,” which he published in January, 1902. And so, “The physical structure most closely identified with the new Pentecostal movement had been destroyed. In its place a more enduring monument had been erected; Parham’s book marked the first published example of Pentecostal theology in history” (Goff 1988:86).

In the Autumn of 1902, he shifted his emphasis back to healing and held revivals in various parts of the local area until 1903 when they moved to the mining region of the tri-state district, located at the intersection of Kansas, Missouri and Oklahoma. Parham held revival meetings twice a day in huge warehouses that accommodated up to 2,000 people. There were news articles reporting many people being converted, healed, baptized and speaking in tongues (Anderson 1979:59). Numerous Apostolic Faith missions were established as converts and workers spread the message in various parts of the tri-state district.

Encouraged by the successful revivals in the tri-state district, in July, 1905, Parham and about two dozen others traveled to Houston, which at the time was the largest city in Texas. In December, 1905, he opened a ten-week Bible school in a large house on the corner of Rusk and Brazos Streets.

A black holiness minister, William Joseph Seymour, learned about the Bible school and requested admission. The local Jim Crow statutes (not allowing black people to be in the same rooms as white people) caused Parham to be cautious with Seymour ‘s request. Over the years, Parham had developed a paternal concern for the races that he felt were inferior and allowed Seymour to attend the school with the condition that he had to sit in the hallway. Eventually Parham and Seymour preached together to various groups of African Americans at several locations in Houston.

After about five weeks of training at the school, Seymour was offered a position as a holiness minister in Los Angeles, California. Parham tried to discourage Seymour from taking the position as he felt that Seymour was needed in Houston , but Seymour felt he was being led by the Holy Spirit. Soon, Parham gave him his blessing and additionally helped with some of his travel expenses. Seymour left Houston in February of 1906 without having personally received the blessing of speaking in tongues. He traveled to California, thoroughly believing that “a third religious work evidenced by tongue-speaking would revolutionize the world through spiritual power and missionary zeal” (Goff 1988:111).

Seymour arrived in Los Angeles with an invitation by Julia Hutchins to preach at the small mission she had founded on Santa Fe
Street. Seymour not only preached Parham’s apostolic faith message that speaking in tongues (glossolalia) was evidence of receiving the Holy Spirit but someone with Seymour began to speak in tongues, which made Hutchins and the Church elders quite uncomfortable. They reported him to the Holiness Association because they felt the message he preached was contrary to the Holiness doctrine that sanctification and baptism of the Holy Spirit were the same thing. When he returned the next week to preach, he was barred from entry to the mission.

Neely Terry, a member of the Santa Fe Street mission, asked Seymour to lead prayer meetings at the Bonnie Brae Street home of her cousins, Richard and Ruth Asberry. Many who attended the prayer meetings were moved to speak in tongues, and as the news spread about the prayer meetings more people began attending than the space could accommodate. Searching for other options available in the area, Seymour found an abandoned church building, located at 312 Azusa Street. He and his small prayer group prayed for a spiritual sign and on April 12, 1906, Seymour and others received the answer to their prayers and “prayed their way through to Pentecost” (Goff 1988:112). On April 14, 1906, Seymour opened the Azusa Street Mission (Apostolic Faith Mission) where he was able to continue preaching the apostolic faith message. Attendance was scattered at the beginning, but just four months later in August, there were around 1,200 people attending the evening services at the mission. The Azusa Street Mission in Los Angeles soon became the largest center of Pentecostal expansion. Holiness leaders from all over the country came to listen, learn, and carry the message throughout the United States and eventually around the world as well.

REFERENCES

Anderson, Robert Mapes 1979. Vision of the Disinherited. New York : Oxford University Press.

Bearman, Alan F. and Mills, Jennifer L. 2009. “Charles M. Sheldon and Charles F. Parham Adapting Christianity to the Challenges of the American West.” Kansas History: A Journal of the Central Plains 32:106-23 . Accessed from www.kshs.org/publicat/history/2009summer_bearman.pdf on 10 November 2013.

Goff, James R., Jr. 1988. Fields White Unto Harvest. Fayetteville: University of Arkansas Press.

Kansas Historical Society. 2013. “Apostolic Faith 03/22/1899 – 04/15/1900.” Accessed from http://www.kshs.org/newspaper/newspaper_reels/search/city:/title:Apostolic%20Faith/county:/state:KS/begyr:1899/endyr:1900/arrange:title/submit:SEARCH on 28 October 2013.
Kansas Historical Society. 2007-2013. “Stone’s Folly, Topeka, Kansas.” Accessed from www.kansasmemory.org/item/216406 on 28 October 2013.

Martin, Larry E. 1997. The Topeka Outpouring of 1901. Joplin: Christian Life Books.

Parham, Charles F. 1911. The Everlasting Gospel. Lexington: Pentecostalbooks.

Parham, Charles Fox 1902. A Voice Crying in the Wilderness. Lexington: Pentecostalbooks.

Topeka Storm Ministries. n.d. “Restoration Project: Charles Parham’s – Bethel Healing Home.” Accessed from http://www.topekastorm.org/restoration/index.cfm?page=restoration on 21 October 2013.

Authors:
Jan Downing Tyner
Timothy Miller

Post Date:
29 March 2014

BETHEL BIBLE COLLEGE VIDEO CONNECTIONS

 

Share

Ammachi

AMMACHI TIMELINE

1953 (September 27) Ammachi was born Sudhamani Idamannel in Kerala, India.

1975 Ammachi experienced an identification with Sri Krishna ( Krishnabhava) and with Devi (Devi bhava).

1981 An ashram, Amritapuri, was established in India.

1987 Ammachi visited the U.S. and became very popular with Western religious seekers.

1989 An ashram was established in San Ramon, California.

1993 Ammachi delivered a speech at the World Parliament of Religions in Chicago.

2002 Ammachi received the Gandhi-King Award for Non-Violence.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Sri Mata Amritanandamayi Devi, also known as Amma or Ammachi, was born Sudhamani (“Pure Jewel”) Idamannel on September 27, 1953, as the fourth child to a poor fishing family in Kerala, India. Sudhamani suspended her formal education during the fourth grade at the age of nine to raise her younger siblings and assist with domestic tasks in her family’s household after her mother became ill. She never married. Beyond these few basic facts, information on Sudhamani’s early life is almost exclusively drawn from hagiographic accounts, with Amritaswarupanada (1994) being the primary source.

In the hagiographic accounts, Sudhamani is depicted as spiritual from birth, having chosen a self-sacrificial way of life, and
possessing extraordinary powers. According to these accounts, the signs of Sudhamani’s future spirituality began prior to her birth. During pregnancy her mother “began having strange visions. Sometimes she had wonderful dreams of Lord Krishna. At others she beheld the divine play of Lord Shiva and Devi, the Divine Mother” (Amritaswarupanada 1994:13). When Sudhamani was born she had a dark blue complexion and would lay in the lotus position of hatha yoga (chinmudra). By the time that she was six months old “she began speaking in her native tongue, and at the age of two began singing devotional songs to Sri Krishna…[E]even at an early age Sudhamani exhibited certain mystical and suprahuman traits, including compassion for the destitute. In her late teens, she developed an intense devotion to and longing for Krishna…sometimes she danced in spiritual ecstasy, and at other times she wept bitterly at the separation from her beloved Krishna” (Raj 2004:206). Sudhanami reportedly was so absorbed with Lord Krishna that “If she suddenly realized she had taken several steps without remembering Krishna, she would run back and walk those steps again, repeating the Lord’s name” (Johnsen 1994:95).

Sudhamani’s childhood is described as very difficult. According to Johnsen (1994:95) she was “the victim of years of physical and psychological abuse.” Her duties in taking care of her mother reduced her to a virtual “house slave” who was “beaten and treated as a servant” (Associated Press 2009). Sudhamani demonstrated great compassion for the suffering and poverty that she encountered in her hometown, and she began comforting and hugging the impoverished and ill, even those deemed untouchable by society. As a result, she was regarded by her family as mentally ill, and her brother is said to have attacked her with a knife for the embarrassment she was causing the family. Sudhamani’s parents attempted to arrange a marriage for her, but Sudhamani had decided not to marry and vigorously rejected their initiative (Raj 2004:206). As a result of these various difficulties, Sudhamani ran away from home on occasion and even considered drowning herself.

The transformational moments during which Sudhamani moved toward her spiritual identity as Ammachi began in September, 1975. As she was returning home after tending cattle, she reported having had a “spiritual rapture” and became aware of her identification and oneness with Krishna (Raj 2004:206). For the next two years Ammachi was said to be in the mood of Krishna ( Krishnabhava). Just six months after her initial rapture she had a second rapture in which she experienced oneness with Devi, the divine mother (Devi bhava). It is this latter identity as the Divine Mother that she has continued to express. By the late 1970s Ammachi was gathering a coterie of disciples. In 1978, a young man named Balu became one of Ammachi’s first disciples, followed in 1979 by two Westerners, an American, now Swami Amritswarupananda, and an Australian, now Armritswarupananda. The movement created its first formal ashram, Amritapuri, in 1981. Ammachi first visited the U.S. in 1987; she was enthusiastically received and gathered a devoted following of religious seekers who consider her a personal guru. Every year Ammachi makes an annual tour to nations around the world. There are now santangs in over thirty countries.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Ammachi’s followers consider her both a manifestation of the Divine Mother goddess and a guru. According to Kremer (2009:5), “Devotees look to Ammachi, not to scriptures, ideas, philosophy, or traditional theology. Ammachi is their foundation, their ideal to strive for, their lens to view other religious ideas and texts through, and their example for moral action. Ammachi is the ultimate authority, and as a living symbol and mother goddess incarnated, she is the base for divine knowledge.” Despite her lack of formal training, Ammachi is believed by her followers to be a true spiritual master (satguru).

Ammachi’s primary teaching to her followers is to seek liberation by serving God and surrendering ego and desire. It is devotion to God that leads to a loss of ego. Devotees seek this goal through meditation, recitation, and community service. As an incarnation of the Divine on earth ( avatar), Ammachi is believed to have completely eliminated her ego, a separate sense of selfhood (Edelstein 2000). As Ammachi has put it: “Reasoning is necessary, but we should not let it swallow the faith in us. We should not allow the intellect to eat up our heart. Too much knowledge means nothing but a big ego. The ego is a burden, and a big ego is a big burden” (Johnsen 1994:99). She teaches that “The love of awakened motherhood is a love and compassion felt not only towards one’s own children, but towards all people … to all of nature,” she says. “This motherhood is Divine Love – and that is God” (Lampman 2006). The ideal of “universal awakened motherhood” is one of Ammachi’s central tenets. She exalts motherhood, love and compassion, and exhorts her followers to be true mothers, regardless of their gender, by exhibiting these maternal qualities to all of creation.

Gender equality plays a major role in Ammachi’s doctrines. She seeks to empower women through her spiritual practices and teachings. In her scripture Awaken, Children!, Ammachi proclaims that “spiritual realization is easier for a woman to attain than for a man, provided she has the proper discrimination and determination” and that “women are the repositories of infinite power. In spiritual matters they can surpass what many men attempt to do; therefore, do not think that women are lower than men” (Kremer 2009:10). Ammachi “teaches men to see their wives as the Divine Mother and women to see their husbands as the Lord of the World, and also to serve their families, the community, and the world. Humility and service are her constant themes” (Johnsen 1994:101).

RITUALS/PRACTICES

Ammachi’s central ritual is the Devi bhava darshan, which allows a devotee to experience a mystical connection with a deity by seeing and being seen by the deity. Ammachi’s darshan features hugging, which is atypical since physical contact is generally eschewed by Hindu gurus. This has led to Ammachi’s sobriquet, “the hugging saint.” Ammachi reportedly developed and then ritualized this practice in the course of soothing those who came to her for advice and consolation.

Ammachi’s Devi bhava is elaborate and highly ritualized. She is seated on a floor mat, often decorated with flowers, and attendedby a female disciple who performs the ritual foot worship (pada puja) by sprinkling water on Ammachi’s feet, then placing sandal paste and flowers on them. Two monks recite from the Sanskritic slokas, followed by the ceremonial waving of a lamp. Another devotee decorates Ammachi with a garland. There is a lecture on Ammachi’s message and spirituality. Finally, Ammachi and an Indian band lead the devotional singing (bhajan). After a period of meditation, Ammachi’s devotees are invited to approach her individually for her trademark embrace.

Each devotee receives a hug from Ammachi, as well as words of comfort (Ammachi speaks her native language, Malayalam, and has limited fluency in English). She then presents each follower with a small token piece of chocolate, rose petals and sacred ash. Each hug is treated as “a hug from the mother goddess herself” as Ammachi is understood to be “a vessel for the goddess to communicate through her” and “a passive recipient of a transcendent deity” (Kremer 2009:3). Ammachi has reportedly administered over thirty million hugs in sessions that can last up to twenty hours. Vasudha Narayanan, director of the Center for the Study of Hindu Traditions at the University of Florida, described Ammachi’s hugs as “a sermon,” and the “experience so moves some that they give up their lives to follow the guru” (Associated Press 2009). Johnsen points out that “Many teachers emphasize the importance of love, but Ammachi’s words have particularly potent impact on so many who have met her because they see that she walks her talk” (Johnsen 1994:100). Ammachi herself has described the hugs as having great spiritual significance: “Amma’s hugs and kisses should not be considered ordinary. When Amma embraces or kisses someone, it is a process of purification and inner healing. Amma is transmitting a part of Her pure vital energy into Her children. It also allows them to experience unconditional love. When Amma holds someone it can help to awaken the dormant spiritual energy within them, which will eventually take them to the ultimate goal of Self-realization” (Raj 2005:136-7). One of Ammachi’s devotees communicates the power of this encounter as follows: “Ammachi gives all the time, twenty four hours a day…She lavishes her love freely on everyone who comes to her. She may be firm with them, but she always radiates unconditional love. That’s why people are so shaken after they meet her. She’s a living example of what she teaches, of what all the scriptures teach” (Johnsen 1994:100).

During the early years Ammachi would give hugs to as many as one thousand visitors each day, with double that number receiving hugs on Devi Bhava nights. In India the hugs sometime lasted for ten minutes. As the ritual has become institutionalized and the size of audiences has increased dramatically, each individual has received less personal time with Ammachi, now only a few seconds to a few minutes. Devotees receive a personal initiation and mantra from Ammachi. Consistent with “one Truth” message, Ammachi’s devotees are allowed to select a Hindu, Devi, Christian, Buddhist mantra, or even one in which the deity is not specified.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Amachi has never been initiated as a guru but is treated as a perfect spiritual master (sat guru) by her devotees, one who is capable of achieving god realization. Her devotees credit her with extraordinary powers. Reportedly she eats very little and often sleeps only a few hours a night. Her spokesman, Rob Sidon, remarks that ”We can’t keep up with her. I have to go to bed. She keeps going. You wake up and she’s still at it. After 15 hours she’s radiant” (Reuters 2001). Her powers are said to include levitation, clairvoyance, being in two locations simultaneously (bilocation), healing of both physical and emotional disorders; creating children for childless couples and absorbing or inhaling devotees’ negative karma” (Raj 2004:207). Some of Ammachi’s most famous miracles include turning water to milk, healing a leper, and permitting “a poisonous cobra to flick its tongue against her own” (Associated Press 2009). Ammachi’s first Western disciple, Neal Rosner, related the story of Ammachi healing a leper by “lick[ing] the pus out of his sores’” until the leprosy disappeared except for one sore (Johnsen 1994:106). Ammachi herself refers to such power: “If you were to really see Amma as She is, it would overwhelm you – you couldn’t possible bear it. Because of this, Amma always covers herself with a thick layer of Maya (illusion)” (Raj 2005:127). In addition to spiritual leadership, Ammachi oversees the movement’s extensive charitable activities.

In the late 1970s Ammachi and her small group of devotees established her first ashram, a simple thatched hut near her home. Two years later Amritapuri, her first formal ashram, was constructed. The ashram has continued to grow and now includes a temple a large dormitory. There are several hundred permanent residents and several hundred more visitors along with a small coterie of initiated, renunciate sannyasis and sannyasinis. The permanent residents at Ammachi’s ashrams, brahmacharins, follow a strict program of discipline (tapas), which “stipulates eight hours of meditation daily in addition to constant social service activities.

Ammachi first visited the U.S. in 1987, and an ashram that became her headquarters in the U.S. was established in San Ramon, California in 1989 on land donated by a devotee. This ashram houses a group of celibate devotees who practice meditation, recitation, and community service. Local chapters have been established in a number of large cities around the U.S. that are administered primarily by volunteers. American devotees are predominantly Caucasian and female, and women occupy the majority of local leadership positions. According to Raj (2005:130), “Western disciples seem more attracted to the asceticism of Ammachi’s spirituality….Indians seem more drawn to the devotional tradition Ammachi embodies.” The highest levels of movement leadership continue to be held by male renunciant devotees. Converts from Siddha Yoga and Transcendental Meditation are commonplace (Raj 2004:210).

Ammachi also operates a number of charitable organizations, including “four hospitals, 33 schools, 12 temples, 25,000 houses for the poor, an orphanage, pensions for 50,000 destitute women, a home for senior citizens, a battered women’s shelter and various technical education projects” (Reuters 2001). The Mata Amritanandamayi (M.A.) Center in the U.S. donated one million dollars to the Bush-Clinton Katrina Fund. And Ammachi committed $23 million for rebuilding after the South Asian tsunami (Lampman 2006). Visitors are not charged for darshan or for receiving mantras; instead the movement supports its charitable activity through donations and sale of a variety of souvenir items.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Ammachi has generated only a modest amount of controversy (Falk 2009). Predictably, there have been Christian critiques of her teachings (Jones 2009). Other critics have taken issue with her directives to separate couples as part of their spiritual practice (sadhana) in order to “put pressure on their egos,” to maintain celibacy, and to engage in long periods of meditation with limited hours of sleep (Edelstein 2000). They dismiss Ammachi’s following as a personality cult and “they question the finances of her organization or even claim it is linked to radical groups” (Associated Press 2009). The legitimacy of Ammachi’s miracles also has been challenged, particularly in India where the tensions between traditionalist Hindus and secular rationalists remain high (Pattahanam 1985). Her followers claim that opponents have made several attempts on her life (Kremer 2009:7).

Some members of the traditional Hindu community resist Ammachi’s egalitarian teachings and practices as they violate traditional Hindu purity/pollution and gender norms. She allows menstruating women, who are considered impure, to participate in her darshan. She has elevated the status of women by allowing them to be priests within her movement. Ammachi also rarely holds gatherings in Hindu temples, preferring secular venues that are accessible to and comfortable for Western devotees. At the same time she requires modest dress for women and uses women as models of selfless service. It is the combination of her empowerment of women together with her commitment to the Hindu tradition and a divine mother model for women that is the source of her enormous appeal to women caught between traditional and modern worlds.

These various criticisms of Ammachi have been far outweighed by the adulation she continues to receive from disciples, the honors that she has received, the support of influentials around the world, and the popularity she enjoys on her annual world tours. She was invited to speak at the World Parliament of Religions in Chicago in 1993. She was invited to speak at the UN’s 50th anniversary in 1995 and at the Millennium World Peace Summit in 2000. In 2002, Ammachi won the Gandhi-King Award for her promotion of nonviolence. In the same year she delivered the keynote address at The Global Peace Initiative of Women Religious and Spiritual Leaders. In 2006, Ammachi received an interfaith award that previously had been given to only the Dalai Lama and Bishop Desmond Tutu. She has been compared to Mother Teresa and heralded a mystic and a saint, and she is now “one of the most recognizable and popular Hindu female gurus in India” (Kremer 2009:8).

REFERENCES

Amritaswarupananda, Swami. 1994. Ammachi: A Biography of Mata Amritanandamayi. San Ramon, CA: Mata Amritanandamayi Center.

Associated Press, 2009. “Millions Flock to India’s Hugging Guru.” AP. 8 March 2009. Accessed from http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2009/3/8/apworld/20090308082927&sec=apworld on February 5, 2012.

Edelstein, Amy. 2000. “Ammachi the ‘Mother of Immortal Bliss’.” EnlightenNext Magazine (Spring-Summer). Accessed at http://www.throughyourbody.com/fantastic-interview-with-mata-amritanandamayi-the-mother-of-immortal-bliss/ on 13 February 2012.

Falk, Geoffrey. 2009. Stripping the Gurus. Toronto: Million Monkeys Press.

Johnsen, Linda. 1994. “Ammachi: In the Lap of the Mother.” In Daughters of the Goddess: The Women Saints of India., 95-110. St. Paul, MN: Yes International Publishers.

Jones, Jovan. 2009. Chasing the Avatar. Shippensburg, PA: Destiny Image.

Kremer, Michael. 2009. Is The Guru a Feminist? Charismatic Female Leaders and Gender Roles in India. M.A. Thesis. Columbia: University of Missouri.

Lampman, Jane. 2006. “Hugging Saint is Compassion in Action.” Christian Science Monitor, July 27. Accessed from http://www.csmonitor.com/2006/0727/p14s01-lire.html on 10 February 2012.

Pattahanam, Sreeni. 1985. Matha Amritanandamayi: Sacred Stories and Realities . Kollam, Kerala, India: Mass Publicationas.

Raj, Selva J. 2005. “Passage to America: Ammachi on American Soil.” In Gurus in America, edited by Thomas Forsthoefel and Cynthia Ann Humes, 123-46. Albany: State University of New York Press.

Raj, Selva J. 2004. “Ammachi, the Mother of Compassion.” In The Graceful Guru: Hindu Female Gurus in India and the United States, edited by Karen Pechilis, 203-17. New York: Oxford University Press.

Tippit, Sarah. 2001. “Indian Guru Seeks to Love the World Personally.” Reuters. 27 June 2001. Accessed from http://wwrn.org/articles/13398/?&place=united-states&section=hinduism on 5 February 2012.

Authors:
David G. Bromley
Stephanie Edelman

Post Date:
15 March 2012

 

 

Share

Bikram Yoga

BIKRAM YOGA TIMELINE

1944 or 1946 (February 10):  Bikram Choudhury was born in Kolcata (Calcutta), India.

1970 (February):  Choudhury opened schools in Japan and created his twenty-six pose sequence.

Early 1970s:  Choudhury immigrated to the United States.

1974:  Choudhury opened the Yoga College of India in Beverly Hills.

1977 (January 1):  Choudhury’s first book, Bikram’s Beginning Yoga Class, was published.

1979 (January 1):  Choudhury submitted a copyright for the entire text of Bikram’s Beginning Yoga Class.

1984:  Bikram and Rajashree Chakrabarti were married.

1994:  Choudhury offered an accelerated course of teacher training.

1998:  Celebrity Madonna appeared on the Oprah television program and promoted yoga practice.

2002 (October 24):  Choudhury filed a supplementary copyright for his twenty-six poses in sequence.

2012 (June):  The U.S. Copyright Office ruled that the sequence of poses was ineligible for copyright.

2013-2015:  Six sexual harassment lawsuits were filed against Choudhury.

2016:  Bikram and Rajashree Choudhury divorced after thirty-two years of marriage.

2019:  Netflix released a damning true crime documentary: Bikram: Yogi, Guru, Predator.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Yoga has become extremely popular in the United States. A 2017 Yoga Journal sponsored survey estimated that the number of yogis and yoginis has topped 20,000,000, up 4,000,000 since an earlier 2012 study. (YJ Editors 2017). [Image at right] According to this source, over eighty percent of practitioners are women; over sixty percent are between eighteen and forty-four. One third of practitioners have been practicing for three years or less. Yoga’s connection to the current exercise and fitness movement is reflected in the finding that health, conditioning, fitness, and stress relief were all mentioned as motivations by more than half of practitioners surveyed.

Hot Yoga, (which generically refers to yoga practiced in a heated space), is the creation of Bikram Choudhury.  He began experimenting with what became Hot Yoga while teaching in Japan around 1970, gradually increasing the heat in the yoga studios to its present level of forty degrees Celsius (104 degrees Fahrenheit) and developing his specific combination of twenty-six asanas in the Hatha Yoga tradition. There are, of course, numerous examples of using heated environments for personal healing and transformation, from Turkish baths to Native American sweat lodges. Choudhury’s innovation was to connect yoga and heated environments, along with his specific combination of twenty-six asanas in the Hatha Yoga tradition (Hall 2019).

Very little actually is known about Bikram Choudhury, founder of Bikram Yoga. He was born on February 10, 1944 or 1946 in Kolkata (Calcutta), India. Much of the limited information available has come from Choudhury himself. According to this autobiographical and hagiographic account, he was first introduced to Hatha Yoga poses when he was three years old. At the age of five, he began studying seriously under Bishnu Ghosh, the brother of Paramahansa Yogananda. Yogananda had moved from India to the U.S. in 1920 and founded the Self-Realization Fellowship in 1925. He reports that he taught meditation practices and Kriya Yoga to a large western audience and authored the influential book, Autobiography of a Yogi (1998). Choudhury’s training included four to six hours of daily, rigorous study and practice of different Hatha poses, or Asanas. Under Bishnu Ghosh, Choudhury claims, he began competing in the National India Yoga Championship and won first place for three consecutive years beginning in 1959. After his third victory, he claims that he retired as the undisputed “All-India National Yoga Champion” and went on to travel with Ghosh, giving weight lifting demonstrations. However, he was forced to discontinue his travels when, at age seventeen, he suffered an extreme knee injury due to a weight-lifting accident. Choudhury sought out the best doctors in Europe; he reports that they informed him that he would be unable to even walk again, let alone continue weight-lifting. Choudhury refused to accept this diagnosis; instead, he sought out the help of his teacher, Bishnu Ghosh. After six months at Ghosh’s school, Choudhury’s knee had fully healed. Soon after, Ghosh encouraged Choudhury to start his own schools in India, and later Japan, teaching the ways of Hatha Yoga. Choudhury asserts that his American supporters convinced him to immigrate to America and open a school. Much of this hagiographic account has now been contested and discredited (See, Issues/Challenges).

It is established that Choudhury [Image at right] arrived in the U.S. in 1973 and established the Yoga College of India in Beverly Hills the following year. In the early years, Choudhury appears to have been interested primarily in teaching Yoga (MacGregor 2002):

“In those years he was trying to be a pure yogi,” recalls Emmy Cleaves, who was Bikram’s 15th student in Los Angeles and is now a senior teacher. “He slept on the floor there. That’s the kind of sacrifice he was willing to make. He has invested a lot in this, because his guru told him to go out and teach yoga. From an Indian perspective, he was doing the right thing.”

In those days Choudhury was celibate. He didn’t drink, nor does he now. Some recall that the young Choudhury was so shy he would barely meet people’s eyes when he spoke. He ran his yoga school as if it were in Calcutta, rather than Beverly Hills. “Do you know, every yoga school in India is free?” Bikram asked. “My school was free. We don’t think to charge money. For us, a yoga school is like a temple. I had a little box, and people could put money in it. Like a church.”

Using this location in Beverly Hills as his base of operations, Choudhury began expanding what became his empire and published his first book, Bikram’s Beginning Yoga Class, in 1977. Shortly thereafter, Choudhury found his classes increasing in size and popularity. His classes could accommodate a hundred people at a time, many more than traditional yoga classes. As the demand for classes increased, so did the demand for schools and teachers. The names of many celebrities (Martin Sheen, Candice Bergen, Raquel Welch, Quincy Jones, Shirley MacLaine, Madonna, Michael Jackson, George Clooney, Tiger Woods), have been linked to Bikram Yoga (Larsen 2018).  Choudhury has also claimed that President Richard Nixon invited him to the White House for advice on how to deal with his phlebitis problem.

Choudhury ‘s personal life changed in 1984 when Bishnu Ghosh’s son helped to arrange his marriage to then nineteen year-old Rajashree Chakrabarti. (Image at right)  Chakrabarti had won the National India Yoga Championship. The couple had a daughter, Laju, and a son, Anurag. Rajashree Choudhury is a yoga therapist and founded the U.S. Yoga Federation and the International Yoga Sports Federation. One of her goals has been to gain acceptance of Yoga as an Olympic event.

In 1994, Choudhury made the decision to offer an accelerated course of teacher training. This would allow dedicated students to study ten hours a day for nine weeks with Choudhury, his wife, and some senior instructors. At the end of the nine week training, those students who passed Choudhury’s personal review received their teaching certification and were able to teach in one of his studios or open one of their own. In 1998, Madonna, who became a practitioner of Bikram Yoga for a time, appeared on the Oprah television show and promoted yoga practice, which brought even greater attention to Choudhurh. According to Choudhury, he has certified more than 11,000 teachers. As of 2011, there were over 500 Bikram yoga studios worldwide, and that number has continued to increase steadily.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

There are eight elements of yoga: absorption (samadhi), breathing (pranayama), concentration (dharana), meditation (dhyani), observances (niyamas), postures (asana), restraints (yamas), and withdrawal of senses (pratyahara). The ultimate goal is to reach liberation or enlightenment. Yoga programs featuring asana are the most popular among yoga practitioners in the West. Hatha Yoga, from which Bikram Yoga is derived, emphasizes unifying opposites (such as masculine and feminine, hot and cold, positive and negative), and creating balance. The asanas are intended to balance flexibility and strength, purify the body, and open the body’s channels so that energy may flow freely.

Bikram Yoga is one form of what has come to be known as “Hot Yoga” or “Powerful Flow Yoga.” As already noted, Hot Yoga may be used to describe any yoga practice carried out in a heated environment. [Image at right] Proponents of Hot Yoga assert that the heat and resulting sweating are cleansing and loosen tight muscles. Proponents see the high energy/high exertion style of Hot Yoga as quintessentially American. As one yoga instructor put it: “On some level, we’ve Americanized yoga. People are living very frenetic lives, and our nervous systems are used to that…. it’s only logical that a nation of multitaskers would want to do a number of things at once: working out, sweating, balancing and stretching (Theiss 2013).

Bikram Yoga is a very stylized form of Hot Yoga. Choudhury has abandoned individual and small group instruction characteristic of classical yoga instruction for large classes in spacious studios. This format has earned his teaching style the nickname McYoga.  Each studio must be carpeted, sessions run ninety minutes, no music is allowed during the sessions, studios are heated to 90-105 degrees, and, most importantly, there are twenty-six poses that are always performed in a specified sequence. Choudhury has often been questioned about the unique nature of his sequence. He is asked how it can be unique if others who teach Hatha Yoga employ the same poses. Bikram acknowledges that the poses themselves are not unique. Instead, he asserts, it is the specific order of poses and breathing techniques that make his system the most effective.

Bikram Choudhury strongly professes a belief in the healing power of Hatha Yoga based on his personal experience. He claims that, when his knee was injured and doctors told him it was beyond repair, yoga is what returned him to full health. He states that it was this experience that inspired him to begin teaching and to create a powerful sequence of asanas and pranayamas that he has dubbed Bikram Yoga. This sequence is so powerful, Choudhury says, that it can produce miracles. Many yogis and yoginis who faced apparently insurmountable physical ailments, from crippling car accidents to severe physical impairments, report making full and astounding recoveries. They credit their recoveries to the practice of Bikram Yoga.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

Every session of Bikram Yoga features two breathing methods (pranayama) and twenty six poses (asanas) that are derived from eighty four classical yoga poses and are always performed in the same order. [Image at right] When students walks into the studio with their towels and wash cloths in hand, they are immediately struck by a heat wave, as the studios are kept at temperatures ranging from 90 to 105 degrees Fahrenheit. Choudhury believes that this allows the muscles to heat up more quickly, which, in turn, will assist his students in their poses.

Choudhury and all of his instructors teach their classes   the same way, from the front of the room with a microphone, instead of on the floor demonstrating the poses. Choudhury believes that if a student if really listening, then he or she should be able to correctly do the pose as instructed. If the student is not doing the pose correctly, the instructor will tell them what to change and how, but only rarely will the instructor physically correct the pose.

Class begins with the first of two breathing exercises, called Pranayama. In this first Pranayama, the students will stand while moving their arms in time with their breathing to completely fill and empty the lungs. This is followed by twelve standing poses that are common in most Hatha disciplines of yoga. It begins with Half Moon Pose, which involves standing with arms stretched overhead and palms pressed together while bending in all directions. This stretches the abdomen and the back while increasing flexibility. This stretch and Standing bow are the only ones in this set with back bends; all of the others are either forward bends or balancing poses. The balancing poses, such as Eagle Pose, are extremely physically demanding, and most beginners find themselves teetering within seconds. However, Bikram asserts that these poses can be invaluable, as they build focus and concentration.

After the standing poses are completed, the students move into Corpse Pose, or Savasana, which is a brief, but necessary, respite for the students tense muscles. Next comes a quick straight-legged sit-up and a forward bend before moving into the next pose. This sequence of Savasana, sit-up and forward bend is inserted between each of the next several poses. First comes a series of backbends, Cobra Pose, Half Locust, Full Locust and Bow Pose. Next is a forward bend, Half Tortoise pose, backbend, Camel Pose and finally a kneeling Pranayama. This pranayama marks the end of the series, as the body empties and fills with clean, healthy air.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Bikram Yoga was first conceptualized in Japan, after Bikram Choudhury began his Hatha Yoga School there in 1970. [Image at right] When he first began teaching in the winter in Japan, he claimed that his studio was so cold that his muscles did not work correctly. However, when he heated the small room up, he found that his muscles were able to move more freely. Later, when he was teaching in Hawaii, much warmer outside than Tokyo, he found a similar result. The studio had been so air conditioned that his muscles simply did not move the way he wanted them to. So, in the middle of hot and sunny Hawaii, Bikram turned off the AC and turned on the heat. Further, “As an added benefit, the saunalike temperatures heightened their sense of euphoria and purification after workouts” (Martin 2011). This simple temperature change was a major part of the founding of Bikram Yoga.

The other major element in the development of Bikram’s Beginner Yoga classes was the sequence he developed for the Asana and Pranayama. When he was injured, Bikram set about finding the perfect poses that would allow him to heal. It then occurred to him that there may be a set of poses that address the most common ailments of the public. So, in Japan he set about creating and shifting a list of poses that, when done in a particular order, provided the maximum amount of stretching and strengthening possible. Once this sequence was completed, he was encouraged by some famous students of his to bring this technique to America. In America, this fast and efficient teaching method was quickly picked up by many of Hollywood’s notables in an attempt to be healthy as well as trendy.

A boom in the popularity of “Hot Yoga” meant a high demand for more teachers. [Image at right]  Bikram took this opportunity to expand his empire by allowing students to quickly become certified as teachers. After they completed a rigorous and expensive training course, these teachers could work for him in his schools or open their own franchises that would pay him rights. Bikram has received most of his income, not from the franchises themselves, but instead from the teacher certification course.

In 1973, there were three Bikram Yoga locations in the U.S. (Honolulu, San Francisco, and Beverly Hills). The first studio in BeverlyHills was located in the basement of a former bank building. By 2002, there were 500 Bikram Yoga studios. [Image at right] It is not entirely clear what produced the surge in the number of Bikram Yoga studios. Bikram himself has commented that “It was like this for years,” Choudhury says, drawing a flat line through the air. “Then in the last years it shot up, like this! Like a rocket!”Some factors. The American fascination with Asian spiritual teachers, the physical fitness fascination that swept America, the location in avant garde California, and the celebrities that Bikram attracted all may have contributed.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Choudhury and his Bikram Yoga have faced controversy and opposition on a number of fronts: his putative commercialization of yoga, competitors in the “hot yoga” market, allegations of sexual impropriety, and a related erosion of yoga studios maintaining any visible relationship with the Bikram name.

Choudhury faced increasing personal scrutiny as controversy increased around his practice. While little had been, and remains, known about his early life, the hagiographic account that he created and that remains in place on many Bikram-sponsored websites has been substantially undermined (Armstrong 2018).

There is strong opposition to the commercialization of yoga among a number of traditional practitioners and groups for whom Bikram Yoga essentially constitutes selling a spiritual practice when one of the principles of Yoga discourages greed. As one observer stated: “Yoga is huge and infinite. What’s being branded are the physical aspects of the practice. You can’t brand the spiritual aspects. Yoga is not hamburgers.” Dr. Aseem Shulkla, co-founder of the Hindu American Foundation was even more pointed: “Call it exercise. Call it a good workout. Call it what you like,”….”But don’t call it yoga. It’s a cynical appropriation of Hinduism” (Martin 2011). There have been similar responses to Choudhury’s establishment of franchises (MacGregor 2002):

“We have never heard of this,” said Deborah Willoughby, founding editor of Yoga International, a Pennsylvania-based magazine that focuses on the spiritual dimensions of yoga. “A lot of places have branch centers, like Shivananda, or the Himalayan Institute, where students will open a center and work under the guidance of a spiritual director. But it is not like it is owned, or licensed. It is just a desire to spread the spiritual teachings.

This branding is particularly characteristic of American innovations on traditional yoga. As observer Paul Keegan put the matter, “America is changing yoga….It’s turning from a spiritual discipline to a fitness routine and a marketable commodity.” Beyond the Americanization of yoga, the higher level of athleticism and physical exertion required can have deleterious consequences. Theis (2013) reports that “The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, which monitors yoga injuries, has found there were about a dozen reported nationwide in 2000, and 7,369 in 2010, the most recent year studied. These include tendon, hamstring, disk, and back strain injuries. And, there is controversy whether this yoga-fitness regimen actually burns more calories than conventional yoga practice (Askell 2013). The debate over the health costs and benefits of Bikram’s training have continued (Notarantonio 2025; Paris 2025)

Bikram Yoga has also faced an increasing number of competitors who adopt certain aspects of Bikram practice. One successful competitor is Modo Yoga, founded by a former Bikram practitioner, has revised a number of Bikram precepts and practices (Rubin 2013):

There would be 40 postures and classes of varying length and format taught with no script, with the temperature set at just below 100 degrees rather than Bikram’s “torture chamber” (Mr. Choudhury’s description). Students are encouraged to drink water; Bikram suggests holding off as much as possible. And studios are to be of green construction from top to bottom. The selected name is Moksha, which is Sanskrit for freedom or liberation.

The group claims over sixty studios, with additional studios planned. Another competitor that also uses heated rooms, Core Power Yoga, is reported to be growing rapidly in the U.S. Choudhury has responded to competitors by labeling others offering Hatha Yoga as “circus clowns” and filing lawsuits where he felt there was infringement of his unique style of yoga (MacGregor 2002; Wright, Newman, and Effron 2009; Fish 2006). Choudhury has been successful in trademarking his form of yoga practice and the variety of products associated with it but not in copyrighting the sequence of postures that are at the center of Bikram Yoga as it is the expression of facts and ideas not facts and ideas themselves that are legally protected (Bennett 2013). Partly in response to Bikram Yoga’s attempt to copyright its practices, the government of India initiated a program to head off such initiatives (Gowan 2014): “For more than a decade, they’ve been building a vast compendium of age-old medicines and practices, the Traditional Knowledge Digital Library, which is now available to patent offices worldwide. They are documenting 1,500 yoga poses, some by videotape, which will be added online next year to help prevent the ‘misappropriation’ of yoga by commercial enterprises, said Archana Sharma, the project’s leader.”

Certainly the most damaging issue  Choudhury has faced is accusations of sexual harassment and assault. In 2013, he began facing six lawsuits involving sexual harassment or rape charges, five initiated in 2013 and one in 2015 (Koul 2013; Sanchez 2013; Ford 2015). The women all provided very similar accounts. They were initially approached by Bikram when attending his classes. He told them that he felt a special, cosmic connection to them. The women tried a variety of evasive tactics, but none of them was prepared for the escalation of attention they received. As time went on, all women reported that Choudhury became more demanding of their time and attention, singling them out for meetings alone or for massages from them. He then pressured them to have sex with him. All of the women report having rejected his advances, which allegedly resulted in physical restraint and in some cases rape. All of the women also reported occupational consequences as well. Those with independent studios found that their names were removed from his website; those who taught at Bikram Yoga schools were denied teaching opportunities; alternative employment proved difficult as Choudhury made an effort to blacklist them.

For his part, Choudhury did not deny that he has had sexual relationships with his students but rather accused his accusers of blackmailing him (Martin 2011): “Only when they give me no choice! If they say to me, ‘Boss, you must fuck me or I will kill myself,’ then I do it! Think if I don’t! The karma!” He is also unrepentant in the face of such charges. He has been quoted as saying that “I’m beyond Superman… I have balls like atom bombs, two of them, 100 megatons each. Nobody fucks with me” (Sussman 2005). There is some evidence that Bikram Yoga insiders suspected sexual violations were occurring but chose to remain silent (Horton 2019).

The Los Angeles District Attorney’s office ultimately declined to pursue criminal charges, citing insufficient evidence. However, Choudhury’s former attorney, Micki Jaffa-Bodden, filed a civil discrimination and harassment lawsuit against him that resulted in a $7,000,000 judgment in Jaffa-Bodden’s favor in 2016. In the wake of this decision, Bikram fled the U.S. and returned to India. Choudhury’s reputation was further damaged with the release of a hard-hitting Netflix true crime documentary, Bikram: Yogi, Guru, Predator in 2019 that was immediately condemned by Choudhury’s attorney (Hurst 2019).

The outcomes of the sexual violation allegations have been mixed and complex. Choudhury himself remains a fugitive from justice in the U.S. At the same time he continues to teach in India and other nations (Mexico, Canada), and his devotees operate licensed studios in the U.S. Bikram Yoga remains both popular and controversial. Numerous studios in the U.S. have chosen to sever their ties with the Bikram name and have “rebranded” (Healy 2015). Practitioner have divided, with some expressing a sense of betrayal and others seeking to draw a distinction between the individual and his work. It appears that Choudhury will be able to continue to operate Bikram Yoga outside the U.S. but with a compromised founder and organizational image.

IMAGES
Image #1: Front cover of Yoga Journal.
Image #2: Bikram Choudhury.
Image #3: Rajashree Choudhury.
Image #4: A “Love Your Sweat” Bikram Yoga poster.
Image #5 : The twenty-six poses (asanas) in Bikram Yoga that are derived from eighty four classical yoga poses.
Image #6 : Bikram Choudhury leading a yoga practice session.
Image #7 : “I Love Hot Yoga” bumper sticker.
Image #8: U.S. map of Bikram Yoga studios.

REFERENCES

Arkell, Harriet, 2013. “Sorry Gwyneth! ‘Hot Yoga’ Popular with Celebrities Does NOT Burn More Calories, Study Claims.” Daily Mail, August 6. Accessed from http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2385254/Sorry-Gwyneth-Hot-yoga-popular-celebrities-does-NOT-burn-calories-study-claims.html#ixzz2rcBM6r1r on 1 March 2015.

Armstrong, Jerome. 2018. Calcutta Yoga: ​Buddha Bose and the Yoga Family of Bishnu Ghosh and Yogananda. NewAndroid.

Bennett, Tamera. 2013.“Bikram Yoga Protected by Trademark NOT Copyright – It’s Hot!” January 12. Accessed from http://ipandentertainmentlaw.wordpress.com/2013/01/04/bikram-yoga-protected-by-trademark-not-copyright-its-hot/ on 1 March 2015.

Choudhury, Bikram and Bonnie Jones Reynolds. 1977. Bikram’s Beginning Yoga Class. New York: Tarcher.

Despres, Loraine. 2007. “Yoga’s Bad Boy: Bikram Choudhury.” Yoga Journal, August 28. Accessed from http://www.yogajournal.com/article/lifestyle/yoga-s-bad-boy-bikram-choudhury/ on 1 March 2015.

Fish, Allison. 2006. “The Commodification and Exchange of Knowledge in the Case of Transnational Commercial Yoga. International Journal of Cultural Property 13:189-206.

Ford, Dana. 2015. “Yoga Guru Bikram Choudhury Accused of Sex Assault, Rape.” CNN, February 26. Accessed from http://www.cnn.com/2015/02/25/us/bikram-yoga-sex-assault-lawsuits/ on 28 February 2015.

Hall, Colin. 2019. “Hot and Bothered: The Hype, History, and Science of Hot Yoga.” Yoga International. Accessed from https://yogainternational.com/article/view/hot-and-bothered-the-hype-history-and-science-of-hot-yoga on 11/25/2019.

Healy, Jack. 2015. “Schism Emerges in Bikram Yoga Empire Amid Rape Claims.” New York Times, February 23. Accessed from http://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/24/us/cracks-show-in-bikram-yoga-empire-amid-claims-of-rape-and-assault.html?_r=2 on 1 March 2015.

Horton, Adrian. 2019. “He got away with it’: how the founder of Bikram yoga built an empire on abuse.” The Guardian, November 20. Accessed from https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/nov/20/bikram-choudhury-yoga-founder-abuse-netflix-documentary on 10 December 2025.

Hurst, Allison. 2019. “Vancouver hot yoga studio feels blowback from scathing Bikram Netflix documentary,” November 26. Accessed from https://bc.ctvnews.ca/vancouver-hot-yoga-studio-feels-blowback-from-scathing-bikram-netflix-documentary-1.4703923 on 27 November 2019.

Koul, Dvssvhi. 2013. “Inside the Bikram Yoga Scandals: Bikram Choudhury’s Accuser Speaks.” Hazlitt, August 13. Accessed from http://www.randomhouse.ca/hazlitt/feature/inside-bikram-yoga-scandals-bikram-choudhury%E2%80%99s-accuser-speaks

Larson, Sarah. 2018. “Bikram” and the Fraught, Telling Tale of a Yoga Phenomenon.”
New Yorker, June 27. Accessed from https://www.newyorker.com/culture/podcast-dept/bikram-and-the-fraught-telling-tale-of-a-yoga-phenomenon on 11/25/2019.

MacGregor, Hilary. 2002. “Had Your McYoga Today? A Stretch of Success.” Los Angeles Times, July 7. Accessed from http://articles.latimes.com/2002/jul/07/news/lv-bikram7 on 1 March 2015.

Martin, Clancy. 2011. “The Overheated, Oversexed Cult of Bikram Choudhury.” details.com. Accessed from
http://www.details.com/culture-trends/critical-eye/201102/yoga-guru-bikram-choudhury on 1 March 2015.

Muller, Judy. n.d. “Hot Yoga: New Form is Revolutionizing the Spiritual Exercise.” Accessed from http://www.bikramyoga.com/press/press8.htm on 31 January 2014.

Murphy, Rosalie. 2014. “ Why Your Yoga Class Is So White.” The Atlantic, July 8. Accessed from http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2014/07/why-your-yoga-class-is-so-white/374002/ on 1 March 2015.

Notarantonio, Lucy 2025. “Experts Warn Against Hugely Popular Yoga Trend.” Newsweek, October 5. Accessed from https://www.newsweek.com/experts-warn-against-hot-yoga-trend-2039919 on 8 December 2025.

Paramahansa Yogananda. 1998. Autobiography of a Yogi. Los Angeles: Self-Realization Fellowship.

Paris, Calin Van. 2025. “Yoga’s Bad Boy: Bikram Choudhury.” Yoga Journal, January 25. Accessed from https://www.yogajournal.com/lifestyle/yoga-s-bad-boy-bikram-choudhury/  on 8 December 2025.

Rubin, Courtney. 2013. “Modo, a New Version of Bikram Hot Yoga, Is Growing Popular.” New York Times, December 6. Accessed from http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/08/fashion/Moksha-Modo-a-New-Version-of-Bikram-Hot-Yoga-Is-Growing-Popular.html on 28 February 2015.

Schettler, Renee. 2023. “He Faced Allegations of Sexual Assault and Rape from Students for Years.” Yoga Jorunal, February 23. Accessed from  https://www.yogajournal.com/lifestyle/bikram-choudhury-teachingyoga/#:~:text=He%20Faced%20Allegations%20of%20Sexual%20Assault%20and,Bikram%20Choudhury%20is%20%22Back%22%20Teaching%20in%20Canada.

Singleton, Mark. 2010. Yoga Body: The Origins of Modern Posture Practice. New York: Oxford University Press.

Theiss, Evelyn. 2013. “’Hot Yoga’ is Gaining Popularity, and Injuries are Increasing Too.” The Plain Dealer, May 6. Accessed from http://connect.cleveland.com/staff/etheiss/posts.html on 1 March 2015 .

Wright, David, Ben Newman and Lauren Effron. 2012. “Bikram Yoga Guru Reaches Settlement in Copyright Suit.” ABC News, December 3. Accessed from http://abcnews.go.com/Business/bikram-yoga-guru-reaches-settlement-copyright-suit/story?id=17869598#.UL1gaOQ0chQ on 1 March 2015.

Sanchez, Raf. 2013. “ Yoga guru Bikram Choudhury ‘raped students in cult-like training’.” The Telegraph, December 5. Accessed from http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/10498946/Yoga-guru-Bikram-Choudhury-raped-students-in-cult-like-training-camps.html on 1 March 2015.

YJ Editors. “Yoga Journal Releases 2012 Yoga in America Market Study.” Yoga Journal. Accessed from https://www.yogajournal.com/press-releases/yoga-journal-releases-2012-yoga-in-america-market-study on 28 November 2019.

Publication Date:
2 March 2015
Update:
12 December 2025

 

Share

Amway

Name: The Amway Corporation

Founders:   Jay Van Andel and Richard M. Devos

Year Founded: 1959

Headquarters:   Ada, Michigan

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Andel and DeVoss first realized the marketing potential of independent distributors when they worked selling Nutrilite.  In 1959, they organized their own system of marketing through independent distributors selling L.O.C.® Multi-Purpose Cleaner.  Quickly the business took off and, according to Amway, did a half million dollars in business their first full year.  Since its beginning, Amway has grown to do 7 billion dollars in sales and has reached 14,000 employees worldwide.  Their plant in Ada, Michigan stretches a mile and covers 390 acres. 1

“The System”:  The key to Amway’s success is not the products they sell, rather the system in which they sell.  Amway does not have a traditional sales force.  In fact, Amway technically does not employ sales people, rather they sell their products through independent contractors.  It is a business made up of small businesses.  Only a small aspect of the system is the products you sell.  What truly makes a successful Amway distributor is a person who sponsors many other distributors.  Each distributor has an “upline” which consists of the person who sponsored them, the person who sponsored the sponsorer, and on up.  A successful distributor will also have an extensive “down line” which consists of people who they sponsored, anyone that person may sponsor, and on down.  A distributor not only gets money for what they sell, but they also get a bonus based on how much their “down line” may sell.  Therefore a person with a very large down line may never have to sell a product themselves, yet still make a lot of money.

Much to the Amway Corporation’s dismay, Amway has often been compared to religious groups or even “cults.”  Although Amway is a non-religious entity (ultimately it’s a business!), it shares many features with religion.  It seems Amway would fall into the category of the “para-religious.”  According to Arthur Greil, the para-religious are “phenomena that clearly fall outside the American folk category of religion but which nonetheless seem to be “like” religion in certain notable ways.” 2

Amway and the Entrepreneurial Model of Religious Formation:  As a possible explanation for religious formation, Rodney Stark and William Bainbridge have presented the entrepreneurial model to show how certain religions may have formed and grow.  Although Amway does not fit the traditional definition of a religion, Amway seems to have formed in a similar way.  The entrepreneurial model notes that religious founders may consciously develop new compensator-systems in order to exchange them for great rewards. The entrepreneur is often stimulated by prior involvement in a religious movement, is open to experimentation and restructuring of their products, and is motivated by a desire for profit.  Motivation to enter the movement is stimulated by the perception that such business can be profitable. 2

It may seem that any entrepreneur may follow a similar pattern.  But Amway is unique because the business has always been run by De Voss, Andel and their children and has never been a business corporation in the traditional sense.  De Voss and Andel were inspired to create their own distribution system after a successful experience in the Nutrilite business.  They carefully constructed their business around a great vision which would hopefully attract as many potential distributors as possible: the American Dream.  It is of no coincidence that Amway’s name (although it cannot be used for legal purposes) stands for “the American Way.”  The key to gaining distributors is promoting the vision of free-enterprise, financial success, and the feeling of operating your own business.   Amway is specifically structured so that everybody has the same potential for success.  In Amway, the truck driver who has a large “down line” is looked up to more than the doctor who just started.  Each meeting of Amway distributors begins with a “dream session” where members speak of things they would like to have: cars, travel, and charity. Amway also encourages a strong family bond by requiring husbands and wives to share businesses and providing families with free time to spend together.  Amway is carefully constructed with a grand reward system, “the American Way,” which promotes free-enterprise, independence, the family, America, and most importantly financial success. 4

Because of this carefully structured process, Stark and Bainbridge propose that  many people (specifically journalists) “hold that these innovators are outright frauds who have no faith in their own product and sell it through trickery to fools and desperate persons.”  5 Many similar views have been given to Amway.  The duty of this page is to remain objective and restrain from judgment on this issue.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

The Sacred and Profane:  Durkheim introduced the ideas of sacred and profane beliefs in explaining what holds religions together.  The sacred is anything supremely important that you must approach seriously and with due preparation.  Profane things, on the other hand, are ordinary things which can be handled “matter-of-factly.” 6

Sacred beliefs are very important to Amway’s organization.  One only has to go to the Amway World Headquarters in Ada to understand this.  The core of Amway’s Center for Free Enterprise is the “Freedom Shrine,” a collection of twenty-eight reproductions of historical manuscripts promoting freedom for every American.  Included are the Constitution, the Gettysburg address, the Emancipation Proclamation, and the Declaration of Independence. 7  Each embodies freedom; a belief very sacred to Amway.

Near the “Freedom Shrine” is the “Hall of Achievement” where the names of all the direct distributors and higher are placed.  This symbolizes the sacred belief in moving up in the Amway system. The hierarchy of the Amway system is shown with special pins.  Pins are given for sales consistency, number of sponsorships, and so forth. The greatest milestone of a distributor is becoming a “direct distributor.”  When a person reaches this point, they begin buying directly from the company.  The occasion is marked by a special ceremony in Ada and recognition in the “Hall of Achievement.”  Beyond this a person can work towards Ruby, Pearl, Emerald, Diamond, Double Diamond, Triple Diamond, Crown and finally Crown Ambassador.  Each level is recognized with some special ritual and the higher your pin, the more you are looked up to. 8

In order to keep its members under control, there is a set of guidelines in Amway’s Career Manual which must be followed to keep Amway’s reputation.  This is held sacred because if a distributor breaks a guideline, they can no longer participate in the organization.

Beyond these things, Amway holds things previously mentioned “sacred.”  The ideas of the family, independence, and financial success are also sacred beliefs to Amway distributors.

RITUALS/PRACTICES

Durkheim further emphasizes the importance of rituals to bond people together and remind them of their sacred beliefs.  Rituals are probably the single most important factor to Amway’s success. 9

The pin system is one important ritual in Amway.  At each pin level, a ritual is performed to recognize the achievement.  When a person reaches the direct distributor level, they are flown into Ada, Michigan where they stay in Amway’s own Grand Plaza Hotel in luxury.  Here they hear addresses by company leaders and have their pictures taken for the monthly newsletter.  Similar methods of recognition are used at each level.  At the Diamond level, a person becomes a member of the “Diamond Club” which meets periodically at exotic locations.  At the Double Diamond level, a person gets their own special day where they are flown by the company jet to Ada and treated as royalty.  The factory is draped with banners in their honor and employees wear buttons with their names. 10

Every time a distributor picks up products at their direct distributor’s house, some type of ritual is performed.  Here you are likely to watch a film, listen to a presentation, or go into detail how to better show your plan.

Group rallies are always a set ritual.  They usually begin with the Pledge of Allegiance and end with “God Bless America.”  Music groups often perform and crowd chants are done.  A “dream session” is held to review what sorts of things people desire to achieve.  Finally at every meeting, people put all their names in a L.O.C.® Multi-Purpose Cleaner bottle (Amway’s first product).  The announcer draws names from a bottle and that person has to go up and say what excites them the most.  This excites the crowd and gives the individual confidence. 11

These rituals are vital to Amway’s success and reinforce what is sacred to the distributors.  This type of process is very similar to religion.

REFERENCES

Books

Ammerman, Nancy Sue. 1983. `Because People Buy Soap’: Amway and the Priests of Capitalism. Master’s thesis: University of Virginia.

Biggart, Nicole Woolsey. 1989. Charismatic Capitalism: Direct Selling Organizations. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Butterfield, Stephen. 1985. Amway, the Cult of Free Enterprise.  Boston: South End Press.

Collins, Randall. 1992. Sociological Insight: An Introduction to Non-Obvious Sociology. New York: Oxford Univeristy Press.

Conn , Charles Paul. 1978. The Possible Dream: A Candid Look at Amway. Geensburg; Penn.: Manna Christian Outreach.

Greil, Arthu L. and Thomas Robbins, eds. 1994. Between Sacred and Secular: Research and Theory on Quasi-Religion.

Roberts, Richard. 1995. Religion and the Transformations of Capitalism. New York: Routledge.

Smith, Rodney K. 1984. Multilevel Marketing: A Lawyer Looks at Amway, Shaklee, and Other Direct Sales Organizations. Grand Rapids: Baker House Books.

Articles

Bromley, David G. 1995. “Quasi-Religious Corporations: A New Integration of Religion and Capitalism?” in Richard H. Roberts, ed. Religion and the Transformations of Capitalism. New York: Routledge. pp. 135-160.

Bromley, David G. 1998. “Transformative Movements and Quasi-Religious Corporations: The Case of Amway,” in Demerath, N.J. et al, eds. Sacred Companies: Organizational Aspects of Religion and Religious Aspects of Organizations. New York: Oxford University Press. pp.349-363.

Greil, Arthur L. 1993. “Explorations Along the Sacred Frontier: Notes on Para-religious, Quasi-religions, and Other Boundary Phenomena,” in The Handbook on Cults and Sects in America. Part B. David G. Bromley and Jeffrey K. Hadden, eds. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press, Inc. pp. 153-172.

Greil, Arthur, L., and Thomas Robbins. 1994. “Exploring the Boundaries of the Sacred.” in Greil and Robbins. op cit. pp. 1-23.

Endnotes

1. Information from Amway’s Homepage. www.amway.com
2. Greil article (see bibliography).
3. Stark and Bainbridge. (see bibliography)
4. Ammerman 5.
5. Stark and Bainbridge.
6. Collins 34.
7. Ammerman 41.
8. Ibid.
9. Collins.
10. Ammerman 25.
11. Ammerman 27-30.

Created by  Christopher Smith.
For Soc 257, Spring 1998.
Last modified: 04/16/01

Share

Ananda Marga Yoga Society

Ananda Marga Yoga Society

Founder : He is known to his followers as Marga Guru Shrii Shrii Anandamurti (which means “He who attracts others as the embodiment of bliss”), but is also known as Prabhat Rainjan Sarkar (his birth name), or Ba’Ba (which means father). 1

Date of Birth : May 21, 1921-October 21, 1990. 2

Birth Place : The small town of Jamalpur in Bihar, India. 3

Year Founded : 1955 in Jamalpur, Bihar, India. 4

Sacred or Revered Texts : Although there aren’t any sacred texts in Ananda Marga, there are works by the founder of Ananda Marga and other writers that are used as a philosophical skeleton to help guide the members. The founder used the name Shrii Shrii Anandamurti when he wrote books on spiritual topics and the name Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar when he authored books on other areas. The first book was Ananda Marga- Elementary Philosophy that was written by Shrii Shrii Anandamurti, and outlines the philosophy of Ananda Marga. Besides this book, there are many more books that outline the philosophy of Ananda Marga and other important doctrines written by Anandamurti and others. These books can be found on the Ananda Marga Homepage. 5

Size of Group : The largest concentrations of Ananda Marga are located in India and in the Phillipines, but members are found throughout the world and can be found in most countries. “Though it has been suggested that this ‘revolutionist’ movement has several million adherents, the actual membership is undoubtedly very much smaller” 6 . Worldwide, there are spiritual and social activity centers in over 160 countries. 7

History

Prabhat Rainjan Sarkar was born on May 21, 1921 on Vaesha’Khii Pu’rn’ima’, or Buddha Pu’rn’ima’ (the day of the full moon of the lunar month). He was the fourth child in a family of eight. 8

He was a bright student who eventually went to Vidyasagar College in Calcutta, and it was here that his spiritual powers manifested. The story of his first disciple is said to have taken place when he was a freshman in college in 1939. One night Sarkar took his usual walk along the banks of the Ganges and sat down to rest and there went into a state of meditation. A man by the name of Kalicharan came up to him and tried to rob him. Sarkar acted very calmly and began to talk to Kalicharan and finally asked him if he was interested in changing his life. As Sarkar continued to talk, Kalicharan became captivated and ended up bathing in the river and becoming the first sadhaka (spiritual aspirant) initiated to the spiritual path by Sarkar. Kalicharan then changed his name to Kalikananda. This event occurred on a full moon in August, Shra’van’ii Pu’rn’ima’, and every year this date is celebrated. 9

In 1941 Sarkar passed the intermediate science exam and went to work on the railway where his father had worked. During this time before the establishment of the Ananda Marga Yoga Society, Sarkar built up a following. He was evidently able to look over his followers with his “omniscient power” and the ability to see whether they correctly observed yama and hiyama (the ten cardinal principles of morality). 10

In 1954 Sarkar told his senior sadhakas that he would be establishing a new organization and preparations went under way for the inauguration (by-laws and articles of association were drawn up), which would take place on January 1, 1955. On this date, Sarkar and his followers met at house 339 at the Rampur Rail Colony where he was instated as the organization’s founder-president. The organization took the name of Ananda Marga Pracaraka Samgha, “The Society for the Propagation of Ananda Marga Ideology,” which would be better known as the Ananda Marga Yoga Society. 11

The name “Ananda Marga” came from a relationship with saint Brghu. Saint Brghu had attained Brahma (infinite consciousness) after a long period of penance. From this infinite bliss, the universe and its entities were created. In this bliss (Ananda) everything flourishes and in the end everything also returns to Ananda and merges with it. Because of this, Ananda is the same as Brahma. 12

After the founding of Ananda Marga, Sarkar started to train missionaries to spread his teaching of “self-realization and service to humanity” (which became the motto of Ananda Marga) into India and the rest of the world, and in 1962 initiated the first monk (called Dada, meaning elder brother) of Ananda Marga. He followed this with the creation of an order of nuns (called Didis, meaning elder sister) in 1966. 13 In 1963, Sarkar established the Education Relief and Welfare Section (ERAWS) of Ananda Marga. ERAWS has created schools, colleges, homes for children, hospitals all over the world. 14 Sarkar also created the theory of PROUT (Progressive Utilization Theory) in 1959 which is a theory of how to end social and economic injustice in society and the world. 15

In December 1971 Sarkar was arrested and charged with murder which was later reduced to the charge of “abetment to murder” and had no trial for four years. When he finally had a trial he was found guilty and sentenced to life in prison. After Indira Gandhi fell from power in 1978 he was granted a new trial and found innocent. Sarkar and Ananda Marga have sparked much controversy due to its political activism. In the early and mid- 1970s, the Indian government considered the organization a terrorist organization that taught its members ritual murder. He continued to work to expand his philosophy and also Ananda Marga to the rest of the world until his death in 1990. 16

Because Sakar’s philosophy of “service to humanity” covers such a broad base of ideas, his organization is made up of numerous branches dedicated to different aspects that Ananda Marga focuses on, such as environmental awareness and disaster relief. Under environmental awareness, he used the term “Neo-Humanism” to define his belief that one should extend humanism to love for animals and plants as well as people. 17 With this belief, he established a global plant exchange program to save plant species around the world and also established animal sanctuaries around the world. Under disaster relief, Ananda Marga has created two organizations to help with disaster relief efforts. AMURT (Ananda Marga Universal Relief Team) and AMURTEL (Ananda Marga Universal Relief Team Ladies) were created in 1965 and 1977 respectively.

AMURT was first founded to help victims of the numerous floods in India but has eventually expanded globally to 80 countries. Each sector is independent (choice of projects and obtaining funds) but can obtain technical help from other sectors. In each country that AMURT exists, it not only helps with disaster relief but also works with helping to develop the country. They follow the method called “co-operative development” which is when workers of AMURT work with the people to help improve their situation through construction, agriculture, and water preservation. It also participates in social programs such as owning and running schools, renovating schools, training teachers, running children’s homes, and providing medical aid. 18

AMURTEL is the sister organization of AMURT and is geared toward the specific needs of women and their families and is also run by women. AMURTEL provides medical care for pregnant and nursing mothers, helps educate women in home industry such as tailoring, handicraft, and commercial food production, and also promotes effective birth control. AMURTEL also sets up relief and refugee camps, distributes food, medicine and clothing, provides cheap kitchens and nutrition classes, and aids underprivileged children by running low tuition schools. It also sponsors homes and halfway houses for children, the elderly, the handicapped, battered women, and also run cheap hostels for underprivileged students. 19

Today, Ananda Marga is a worldwide organization with centers in over 160 countries, including the United States. 20
Beliefs

The ideology of the group is universal and it stresses the unity of human society. Criticizing religions and other spiritual paths is strongly discouraged and the group has a strong commitment to bring progress to the whole of human society (and other creatures) by doing service to the suffering in all kinds of ways. To this effect, Sakar created organizations such as AMURT, AMURTEL, and the philosophy of PROUT to carry out the activities to achieve this progress.

His philosophy of PROUT called for economic democracy, which is maintaining human rights, and giving control of the economy to the local level rather than “a handful of leaders [who] misappropriate the political and economic power of the state.” He also called for the election of competent, educated, and moral people into public office rather than candidates who rely on money to win an election, a balanced economy by controlling industry on the local level, redistributing cultivatable land, and putting money into productive ventures such as railroads. Sakar said that science and technology should be guided by Neo- humanistic principles. He wanted the establishment of a welfare system and fair taxation, social and economic justice, women’s rights, and the creation of a world government with a global bill of rights, global constitution, and global justice system. 21

The group’s dislike of narrow-mindedness is very apparent in the philosophy of Neo- Humanism, which is the belief that one should extend humanism to love for animals and plants as well as people. This philosophy of Neo-Humanism is carried over into education through Ananda Marga schools, which are located throughout the world, including the United States. 22

Ananda Marga practices Tantra Yoga, and since it is considered a practical science (intuitional science of the mind). Yoga is an important practice in following Ananda Marga. Tantra yoga was founded by Lord Sadashiva who was also the interpretor of the Tantra which is a mystical tradition of Eastern India. Tantra means “liberation through expansion” and so the practice of Tantra yoga is to free one’s mind. Tantra yoga the universe is a part of Brahma which is the Supreme Conscious Being. It is said that Brahma is split up into two parts, the Eternal Consciousness (Shiva) and creative power (Shakti). All living things apparently identify with material and mental goods made by Shakti and are not fully connected with Shiva. When one becomes human they can increase their identification with Shiva, the Eternal Consciousness through meditation. By reestablishing equilibrium between Shakti and Shiva, a person can return to a state of Eternal Bliss or the state of Brahma. Brahma can be experienced through Tantra Yoga by exploring and mastering the mind to the point where it realizes its connection with Brahma. Tantra Yoga uses two ways to connect with Brahma. One way is by releasing a person from addictive activities and the other is to practice yoga. Yoga helps a person overcome their addictions and also deepen a person’s feeling of connection with Brahma. The end product is the experience of the Eternal Bliss. The correct ways of meditating are taught by Acharyas who give initiation and lessons on yoga as representatives of the Guru (God). 23

Ananda Marga uses the Sixteen Points 24 , created by P.R. Sarkar, which is an important system of spiritual practices, to help guide its followers to maximize their own personal growth. Although few people can actually follow the Sixteen Points perfectly, these practices can help balance the physical, mental, and spiritual parts of human life. Members of Ananda Marga are encouraged to try and follow these points as strictly as possible. Below is a basic outline of the Sixteen Points, provided by “Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Practices” edited by Tarak, but it is suggested that they should be learned from a person who has experienced them. The Sixteen Points are split up into two sections and are as follows:

Jaeva Dharma (Maintenance of Existence)

Use of Water
Water should be poured over the genital area after passing urine. Pouring cool water over this area counteracts this heat build-up and causes the muscles to contract, thereby entirely emptying the urinary bladder. The reason for this practice is because any residual urine in the bladder can cause a glandular imbalance and result in disease, excessive sexual stimulation, and general wastage of physical and mental energy. 25

Skin
If possible, males should be circumcised. This prevents many diseases and maintains all-round cleanliness. If not circumcised, males should clean and pull back the foreskin regularly, so as to prevent the accumulation of urine sediments. 26

Joint Hair
Hair under the arms, on the legs and in the pubic area should not be shaved. It grows naturally to provide a balance in body heat and is important for good health. Joint hair (armpits and genitals) should be cleaned with soap daily and oiled with coconut oil. 27

Underwear
Males should wear a laungota to protect the genital area, prevent excessive sexual stimulation and divert the seminal flow. Women should wear bra and underwear to protect the genital area, prevent excessive sexual stimulation and prevent infections. 28

Vya’Paka Shaoca (Half Bath)
This practice is done before meditation, meals, and sleep. To take a half-bath one systematically cleans certain areas of the body with cool water, the genital area, knees, calves, feet, elbows, lower arms, mouth, eyes, nose, back of the mouth, throat, tongue, ears, and back of neck. This is done to prevent build-up of body heat; it also helps relax the body creating an ideal calm state for meditation. 29

Bath
A full bath should be taken at least once a day. Cool water (all water used should be no higher than body temperature) should be used unless one has a cold. If one does have a cold, lukewarm water should be used in a closed area. Baths should be taken four times a day at very specific times, the morning, noon, evening, and midnight. The wet skin should be dried either by sunlight or light from a white light bulb. 30

Food
“It is preferable to eat sentient food rather than mutative food, while static food should be avoided.” The reason for this is that mutative foods contain stimulants and static foods requires one to kill an animal and is unhealthy for the body. Meals should be eaten at regular times throughout the day and no more than four meals should be eaten. Other meal etiquette should be followed such as not eating when one is not hungry, drinking plenty of water throughout the day, and eating with others rather than alone. 31

Bha’Gavad Dharma (The Path to Salvation)

Upavasa
Members of Ananda Marga should fast the eleventh day after the full or new moon (Ekadshii), and should not eat food or drink water during this time. A person that is pregnant or suffers from medical ailments does not need to fast. “Fasting generates willpower” and “generates empathy with the sufferings of the poor and also of animals and plants.” 32

Sa’Dhana’
This word defines the conscious effort that a person takes to achieve the goal of enlightenment. “An aspirant enters the realm of Sadhana by receiving initiation into the process of meditation.” This initiation is important to the life of a spiritual seeker as he/she learns about meditation, which is made up of a system of six lessons. Meditation is taught by an Acarya, or teacher and it should be done twice a day. As well as meditation, Sadhana is also made up of other spiritual practices. 33

Madhuvidya (also called Guru mautra) – It is the second lesson in Ananda Marga’s system of meditation. It should be performed before sleeping, eating, meditating, and bathing. 34

Sarva’tmaka Shaoca – Meaning “all round cleanliness.” A person’s body, clothes, and environment should be kept clean. A person should keep their mind clear. 35

Tapah – Meaning service. Sarkar outlines four services and one should try and perform all four types of service every day. 36

Bhuta Yajina – “Service to the created world.” One should be kind to animals, plants, and inanimate objects. 37

Pitr Yajina – “Service to ancestors.” 38

Nr Yajina – “Service to humanity.” There are four different ways to perform this: physical labor, giving financial support, physical strength and courage, and using one’s intellectual strength. Paincaseva (five services) should be done daily and can be accomplished by distributing free food, selling cheap vegetarian food, distributing clothing, medical supplies, or books and educational supplies. 39

Adhya’tma Yajina – “Spiritual Service.” An internal form of service throughout the day and during meditation. 40

Sva’dhya’ya – To understand spiritual materials fully. By reading Sarkar’s books, one is able to clearly understand what the goal to reach for is. By reading, one is also able to understand one’s own spiritual experiences. 41

Asanas (or Innercises) – These yoga postures should be done in the presence of an Acarya and done twice a day (morning and evening). 42

Pashas and Ripus – Individuals acquire eight pa’shas (bondages) as they interact with the world around them. These bondages are shame, fear, doubt, hatred, pride of decent, pride of culture, egoistic feeling, and hypocrisy. There are also six internal bondages, which are physical desire, anger, greed, attachment, pride, and envy. To control the internal bondages, Sadhana is used and Yama and Niyama are used to control the societal bondages. 43

Kiirtan – A spiritual dance that should be done before Sadhana. This dance loosens the body to help the ease of movement and also helps create a calm state of mind. 44

Pa’incajanya – Every morning at 5 a.m. one should follow the yoga routine of kiirtan and sadhana. This is the time when spiritual elevation can be optimized. 45

Guru Saka’sha – This means to be near the Guru. At dawn, when one rises, one should think of Guru and do internal service to him. 46

Is’ta – This term defines “the chosen ideal.” It is the goal of the Absolute, which is personalized for us. “No negative remarks against the Guru should be tolerated and duties given by the Guru should be followed.” 47

A’darsha – The term means ideology. “The path by which [a person] move[s] towards [their] chosen goal. [A person] should not compromise [their] ideology nor allow others to ridicule it without making an effort to explain [their] position properly and logically. One should read Baba’s books and become competent in the spiritual and social philosophy of Ananda Marga.” 48

Conduct Rules – One should strictly follow the Conduct Rules. These rules help during Sadhana by helping keep one’s ideation. Understanding and following of Yama, Hiyama, the 15 Shiilas (Social Conduct rules), the Supreme Command, the One Point Local (one should not compromise the sanctity of Is’ta, A’darsha, the Conduct Rules, and Supreme Command) and the 40 Social Norms will help one maintain mental equilibrium. 49

Supreme Command – This is the “fundamental guidepost for all Margiis to follow.” One should follow the Supreme Command strictly. 50

Dharmacakra – This is the weekly collective meditation sessions. In these sessions, one can be in the company of the Absolute Entity, or the Lord. “If one misses Dharmacakra, one should go to the jagriti (house of spiritual awakening) and perform sadhana that day.” If jagriti is also missed, a meal should be missed and given to a needy person. 51

Oaths – Every morning one should think about the oaths that they have taken and make the conscious effort to put them into practice. 52

C.S.D.K – Each letter stands for a practice that will help increase one’s knowledge of Ananda Marga as well as reinforces their spirituality.

C. Conduct Rules: One should know and follow these rules.

S. Seminar: “One should try to attend all seminars and retreats which are available.”

D. Duty: Any duty that is given by one’s acarya or another superior should be done happily.

K. Kiirtan, Tandava, and Kaoshikii: Kiirtan should be danced every day. Tandava should also be danced by men twice a day and Kaoshikii by women. Tandava should not be done by a woman. 53

Sarkar also called himself the “Leader of the New Renaissance.” In 1958 he established Renaissance Universal (RU). It was created to help raise social awareness of humankind and strives for universal peace. It is believed that art and science should be used for service and self-realization rather than negative uses (i.e. money and creating weapons), that the gap between the rich and the poor should shrink by improving the condition of the lower class, improving education, and promoting unity and cultural diversity. RU accomplishes this by participating in service projects around the world. RU is a global organization and has sectors in about 150 countries around the world. 54

The practices of Ananda Marga are not uncommon to other religions. One such group is the Self-Realization Fellowship. This group is older than Ananda Marga (founded in 1920), but the similarities are apparent. Ananda Marga and the Self-Realization Fellowship both share the philosophy of Self-Realization (that fufillment can be achieved from within) and both also practice yoga and consider it an important practice in their spiritual lives. 55
Bibliography

Ananda Marga. 1981. The Spiritual Philosophy of Shrii Shrii Anandamurti. Denver, CO: Ananda Marga Publications.

Ananda Marga. 1993. Shrii P.R. Sakar and His Mission. Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications.

Anandamitra, Didi. The Philosophy of Shrii Shrii Anandamurti, A Commentary on Ananda Sutram. Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications.

Anandamurti, Shrii Shrii. 1973. Baba’s Grace; Discourses of Shrii Shrii Anandamurti. Los Altos Hills, California: Ananda Marga Publications.

Anandamurti, Shrii Shrii. 1973. The Great Universe: Discourses on Society. Los Altos Hills, California: Ananda Marga Publications.

Anandamurti, Shrii Shrii. 1993. Discourses on Tanrta. Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications.

Avadhuta, Ácárya Vijayánanda. 1994. The Life and Teachings of Shrii Shrii Ánandamúrti. Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications.

Avadhuta, Shraddhananda. 1991. My Spiritual Life with Baba. Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications.

Avt., Tadbhavananda. 1990. Shraddhainjali. New Delhi: PROUT Research Center.

Bowler, John. 1997. Oxford Dictionary of World Religions. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Devadatta and Nandita. 1971. Paths of Bliss, Ananda Marga Yoga. Wichita, KS: Ananda Marga Publications.

Dhruvananda. 1991. The Supreme Friend: My Days with Baba. Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications.

Kamaleshvahananda, Dada Acarya. 1999. Yogic Treatment and Natural Remedies. Chiang Mai, Thailand: (transcript of his presentation at the 33rd World Vegetarian Congress).

Melton, J. Gordon. 1978 .The Encyclopedia of American Religions. Wilmington, N.C.: Mcgrath Publishing Co.

Sarkar, P.R [translated by Vijayananda Avadhuta and Jayanta Kumar]. 1990. Yoga Psychology. Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications.

Tarak, ed. 1990. Anada Marga, Social and Spiritual Practices. Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications.
References

1. Vijayananda, Acarya. The Life and Teachings of Shrii Shrii Anandamurti . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p78.

2. Vijayananda, Acarya. The Life and Teachings of Shrii Shrii Anandamurti . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p7.

3. Vijayananda, Acarya. The Life and Teachings of Shrii Shrii Anandamurti . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p7.

4. Vijayananda, Acarya. The Life and Teachings of Shrii Shrii Anandamurti . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p77.

5. http://www.anandamarga.org/books/index.html

6. Bowler, John. Oxford Dictionary of World Religions . Oxford, Oxford University Press, p.62.

7. http://www.anandamarga.org/- click on “BRIEF STORY” paragraph five.

8. Vijayananda, Acarya. The Life and Teachings of Shrii Shrii Anandamurti . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p6&10.

9. Vijayananda, Acarya. The Life and Teachings of Shrii Shrii Anandamurti . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p31&35-36.

10. Vijayananda, Acarya. The Life and Teachings of Shrii Shrii Anandamurti . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p40.

11. Vijayananda, Acarya. The Life and Teachings of Shrii Shrii Anandamurti . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p77.

12. Vijayananda, Acarya. The Life and Teachings of Shrii Shrii Anandamurti . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p81-83.

13. http://www.anandamarga.org/- click on “BRIEF STORY” paragraph two.

14. Ananda Marga Shrii P.R. Sarkar and His Mission. Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p2.

15. Ananda Marga Shrii P.R. Sarkar and His Mission. Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p4-5.

16. Bowler, John. Oxford Dictionary of World Religions . Oxford, Oxford University Press, p.62 and Melton, J. Gordon. The Encyclopedia of American Religions . Wilmington, N.C.: McGrath Publishing Co., p381.

17. Ananda Marga Shrii P.R. Sarkar and His Mission. Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p7.

18. Ananda Marga Shrii P.R. Sarkar and His Mission. Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p3 and http://www.amurt.org/About.html, http://www.amurt.org/development.html, and http://www.amurt.org/disaster.html.

19. http://www.amurt.org/Women.html, http://home1.pacific.net.sg/~rucira/amurtel/relief.html, http://home1.pacific.net.sg/~rucira/amurtel/children.html, and http://home1.pacific.net.sg/~rucira/amurtel/women.html.

20. http://www.anandamarga.org/- click on “BRIEF STORY”

21. Ananda Marga Shrii P.R. Sarkar and His Mission. Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p4-5 and http://www.prout.org/Summary.html.

22. Ananda Marga Shrii P.R. Sarkar and His Mission. Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p7.

23. http://www.abhidhyan.org/Teachings/Tantra_Yoga_Tradition.htm.

24. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p3-4.

25. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p5.

26. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p5.

27. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p5.

28. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p6.

29. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p6-7.

30. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p7-8.

31. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p8-9.

32. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p10-11.

33. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p11-12.

34. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p12-13.

35. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p13.

36. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p13.

37. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p13.

38. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p13.

39. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p13-14.

40. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p14.

41. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p14.

42. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p14.

43. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p15.

44. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p15.

45. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p15.

46. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p.15-16.

47. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p16.

48. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p17.

49. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga

Publications., p17-18.

50. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p18.

51. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p18-19.

52. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p19.

53. Edited by Tarak. Ananda Marga: Social and Spiritual Pracices . Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p19-20.

54. Ananda Marga Shrii P.R. Sarkar and His Mission. Calcutta: Ananda Marga Publications., p2 and http://www.ru.org/ru.html under “Principles of Renaissance Universal.”

55. http://religiousmovements.lib.virginia.edu/nrms/SelfReal.html under “Beliefs.”
Created by Angela An
For Soc 257, New Religious Movements
University of Virginia
Spring Term, 2000
Last modified: 07/17/01

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Share

Answers in Genesis

ANSWERS IN GENESIS TIMELINE

1951:  Ken Ham was born in Cairns, Australia.

1980:  After teaching public school, Ham and his wife, Mally, decided to minister full time and founded the Creation Science Foundation (CSF).

1980:  Dr. Carl Wieland handed over his magazine, Creation, to CSF. Ham merged Wieland’s Creation Science Association into the Creation Science Foundation.

1987:  Ham and his wife moved to the United States and located in the Institute for Creation Research (ICR) in San Diego to help the Creation Science Foundation gain more international influence.

1993:  Ken and Mally Ham believed that it was time to begin a new U.S. ministry and resigned from ICR (Mark Looy and Mike Zovath followed, helping to found “Creation Science Ministries.”

1994:  Answers in Genesis (AIG) was founded in Florence, Kentucky.

1994:  AIG’s first major conference held in Denver, Colorado, with around 6,000 attendees. The first ministry newsletter was mailed

1996:  The Boon County Fiscal Court denied AIG’s proposal to build a Creation Museum to serve as headquarters for the AIG ministry.

2000:  AIG purchased fifty acres along Interstate 275 in Petersburg, Kentucky for the museum.

2001:  Construction on the Creation Museum began.

2005:  AIG-U.S. and AIG-Australia separated due to leadership issues.

2007 (May 28):  The Creation Museum opened.

2010 (December 1):  AIG announced the construction of the Ark Encounter LLC.

2016:  The Ark Encounter Project is scheduled to be completed.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

The longstanding tensions between the scientific and biblical narratives have flared historically whenever advances in various scientific disciplines have raised questions about the empirical validity of biblical accounts of creation. For example, around the beginning of the nineteenth century, the development of Geology as a discipline, with its findings that the Earth was far more ancient than suggested by the account in Genesis, led to increased support for Gap Theory and Day-Age Theory as alternative theories for the discrepancy between geological and biblical accounts. Gap Theory posits that there was a long time-gap between the first two days of creation as chronicled in Genesis while Day-Age Theory proposes that the days of creation listed in Genesis were themselves long periods of time (thousands or even millions of years). Most recently, evolutionary creationism, which postulates that God created life and humankind while evolution constitutes an explanation for how life developed (Saletan 2014).

Beginning in the 1960s, conservative Christian groups of various kinds have mounted active opposition to evolutionary theory with creationism, in part due to the struggles over a variety of issues (e.g., science education, sex education, prayer in schools) in the public school system. One outgrowth of these struggles has been the formation of a variety of museums, research institutes, and foundations defending the biblical creation narrative (Numbers 2006; Duncan 2009). Creationist museums are found primarily in the United States, but there is a sprinkling of such museums around the world (Simitopoulou and Xirotitis 2010). The most prominent creationist museums in the U.S. was established by Answers in Genesis.

Ken Ham, the founder of Answers in Genesis (AIG), received his bachelor’s degree in applied science from Queensland University of Technology in Brisbane, Australia and a degree in education from the University of Queensland. He went on to become a public high school science teacher. Ham expanded his educational credentials with an honorary Doctorate of Divinity in 1997 from Temple Baptist College in Cincinnati, Ohio and another in Literature in 2004 from Liberty University in Lynchburg, Virginia (Answers in Genesis n.d.). In 1979, Ham left teaching to become a full-time minister with his wife, Mally Ham. Initially, they established Creation Science Supplies, a book ministry, and Creation Science Educational Media Services, a teaching ministry. Later, these two initiatives were combined to form the Creation Science Foundation (CSF), co-founded with John Mackay. Even at this point, Ham had dreams of building a museum that taught history as it is recorded in the Bible.

In 1986, Ken Ham reported feeling that he was called by God to travel to the United States and continue his ministry there. The CSF board in Australia sent Ham to work with Dr. Henry Morris’s Institute for Creation Research (ICR) in 1987 as a speaker; he remained the Director of the Australian CSF ministry until 2004. Ham went on to lecture not only in the U.S. but also in the U.K.

After working with ICR for seven years, Mally Ham approached her husband about separating from the research group to form their own more “layperson-oriented” creation organization. Ham then resigned from ICR, along with colleagues Mark Looy and Mike Zovath, and together they formed Creation Science Ministries (CSM). Supported by donations, CSM was able to become an independent organization, while still maintaining a sister-relationship with CSF-Australia. CSM began its first year of ministry in 1994 and changed its name to Answers in Genesis. The name change was intended to reflect the importance and authority of all scripture, not just the portion pertaining to creation. Soon after, CSF-Australia changed its name to Answers in Genesis as well. In the same year, the three original founders relocated their families to Florence, Kentucky to establish a headquarters for the organization. Two-thirds of the United States’ population lives within 650 miles of Cincinnati, Ohio, which is only fourteen miles from Florence, giving considerable accessibility to a substantial portion of the American population.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Contemporary creationists can be divided into “old earthers” and “young earthers.” The former postulate that science-based dating of the evolutionary process is correct but that the process itself was initiated by a Creator. The latter, the strong creationists, attempt to validate biblical dating and the biblical creation narrative. Answers in Genesis (AIG) can be categorized as Young-Earth Creationists (YECs). AIG asserts that the Bible is the word of God and the absolute authority on all matters. The Board of AIG explains that any evidence in any area of knowlege must be confirmed by the Bible to be valid. As AIG puts the matter, “no apparent, perceived or claimed evidence in any field, including history and chronology, can be valid if it contradicts the scriptural record” (Answers in Genesis 2012). Therefore, AIG accepts the Bible as the accurate historical account of Earth’s creation recorded in Genesis 3:14-19 (Ross, 2005). From its perspective, the organization of the natural world is “irreducibly complex” and could only have been originally designed (Petto & Godfrey, 2007).

On February 4, 2014, AIG leader, Ken Ham debated renowned scientist, Bill Nye on the question “Is Creation a Viable Model of Origins?” and provided an explanation of AIG’s view on science. AIG makes a distinction between observational science and historical science. During his presentation, Ham commented that “People by and large have not been taught to look at what you believe about the past as different compared to what you observe in the present. You don’t observe the past directly. Even when you think about the creation account, we can’t observe God creating.” Ham and his followers therefore hold that mainstream science is not viable because there was no one in the past to observe any events that transpired. AIG accepts the natural laws of mainstream science, but believes they have divine origin, which allows for their belief in a six-day creation (Foreman, Ham, and Nye 2014).

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP/

With its increasing speaking ministry, radio program, and web outreach, AIG searched for a building site in northern Kentucky fortheir creation museum. Two efforts to rezone land for the project met strong opposition from evolution proponents and other secular groups. Despite this resistance, hundreds of radio stations began featuring AIG’s Answers program. By 2006, AIG’s website, AnswersInGenesis.org, was chosen out of 1,300 ministries to receive the “Website of the Year” award from the National Religious Broadcasters. The website has gone on to host about 25,000 visitors a day. The AIG magazine, Creation, which was originally published in Australia, is also distributed in the United States. In 2006, however, AIG-US discovered that over half their subscribers did not renew their subscriptions after one year. The organization recognized the need for a new magazine, Answers , which would feature biblical and scientific articles about the origins controversy and emphasize the biblical worldview with practical applications. Further differences between the American and Australian branches caused AIG-US to stop distributing Creation and focus solely on Answers. After only five years in operation, Answers received the “Award of Excellence” from the Evangelical Press Association (Ham n.d.).

By 2004, AIG was able to obtain the site for its Creation Museum, fifty acres near Interstate 275. The museum opened on May 28,2007. Ham created the Creation Museum to spread “Biblically correct science” to the public and to try and bring Creationism into the mainstream. He preferred a museum to a church because museums are accepted as places of public education and for the display of scientific research findings. Further, a museum is a more engaging environment in which to encourage learning among children. Finally, a museum could connect directly with visitors and AIG’s message would not be filtered through mainstream scientists or the government (Duncan 2009). According to Ham, AIG simply wants the Creation Museum to tell people that “the Bible is true and the Bible is God’s word, that’s what it’s all about” (Jacoby, 1998). The museum features a planetarium, the Johnson Observatory, SFX Theater, a petting zoo, an insectarium, a zip-line course, dinosaur fossils, and animatronic exhibits. The Creation Museum was very successful in its first year, attracting 404,000 visitors but suffered declining visitation, with only 280,000 visitors in 2012.

AIG announced plans in 2010 for a project to build a full-scale version of Noah’s Ark and biblical village. The Ark Encounter, is to belocated on 800 acres near Interstate 75 in Grant County, Kentucky and is scheduled to open in the summer of 2016 (Ham, n.d.). The Ark Encounter is described as “a 160-acre park with a life-size replica of Noah’s Ark built to stand 500 feet long and 80 feet high” (Goodwin 2012). Initial construction plans were delayed until 2014 due to a weak economy and a decline in visitation to the Creation Museum (Goodwin 2012). Based on outside consulting term estimates, AIG has anticipated 1,600,000 visitors in its first year, as well as improved visitation. The initial financial projections were also optimistic as a result of tax breaks pledged by the State of Kentucky; these were withdrawn after considerable controversy concerning church-state separation (Alford 2010; “Kentucky” 2015). AIG subsequently announced plans to sue Kentucky over the withdrawal (Linshi 2015).

ISSUES/CONTROVERSIES

AIG has met some opposition within the conservative Christian community. For example, in March, 2011, the Board of GreatHomeschool Conventions, Inc. (GHC) voted to disinvite Ken Ham and AIG from “all future conventions [as Ham made] unnecessary, ungodly, and mean-spirited statements that are divisive at best and defamatory at worst” (Blackford 2011) about another speaker at the convention. The board stated that “Ken’s public criticism of the convention itself and other speakers at [the] convention require him to surrender spiritual privilege of addressing a homeschool audience” (Blackford 2011). Ham, in his blog, explained that Peter Enns of the BioLogos Foundation teaches misleading information about Genesis that compromises Genesis with evolution and is an “outright liberal theology that totally undermines the authority of the Word of God” (Answers in Genesis Board of Directors 2011). After the allegations against Ham being un-Christian and sinful were made, AIG launched an internal investigation of GHC, but has yet to find any resolution (Answers in Genesis Board of Directors 2011).

Predictably, AIG has received heavy criticism from scientists representing a variety of disciplines who regard the Creation Museum as a “monument to scientific illiteracy” (Kennerly 2009). According to Jerry Lipps, professor of geology, paleontology, and evolution at University of California, Berkeley, even most mainstream Christians do not agree with AIG’s interpretation of Earth’s history. Lisa Park, a professor of paleontology and a firm follower of Christianity views Creationism as focusing “on fear… [and] a malicious manipulation of the public” (Kennerly 2009). Daryl Domning, professor of anatomy at Howard University claims it imbibes visitors to the museum to believe in “a major distortion and misrepresentation of Christianity as it is of science” (Kennerly 2009).

It is not surprising, therefore, that Ham’s initial plan to locate the museum next to Big Bone Lick State Park, which is the birthplaceof vertebrate paleontology in North America, drew vigorous opposition from scientists (Goodwin 2012). From the scientists’ perspective, this location implied that the local government was giving support to a sectarian religious group. Ham’s proposal was subsequently denied after several zoning disputes and legal proceedings, and he then decided to move his museum strategically closer to the Cincinnati International Airport.

The most direct confrontation between Ham and an opposing scientist took place on February 4, 2014 in a public debate between Bill Nye and Ken Ham at the Creation Museum. Nye argued in a YouTube post that “Creationism is Not Appropriate for Children.” He stated that “If we raise a generation of students who don’t believe in the process of science, who think everything that we’ve come to know about nature and the universe can be dismissed by a few sentences translated into English from some ancient text, you’re not going to continue to innovate” (Lovan 2012). For his part, Ham attempted to substantiate the YEC model of the universe’s origins. He reasserted that Earth was created by God approximately 6,000 years ago and dinosaurs and humans once coexisted, as it is specifically stated in the Genesis. Nye sought to refute Ham’s claims by citing widely supported observations by scientists that the Earth is approximately 4.5 billion years old. Ham responded that “I believe science has been hijacked by secularists…and that there is a difference between historical science and observational science” (“Bill Nye Debates Ken Ham” 2014). Nye pointed out that a variety of methodologies (radiometric dating, ice core data, and the light from distant stars) supports the position that the Earth is much older than 6,000 years (Lovan 2012). When Ham referred to the Genesis flood narrative and Noah’s Ark, Nye pointed out that the Ark as described in the Book of Genesis would not float. Nye also pointed out that, using Nye’s calculations, an ark containing 7,000 kinds of animals would require that approximately eleven new species would have to come into existence every day for the Earth to contain all presently known species (O’Neil 2014). While Ham does not have appeared to have won over a majority of the audience, he seemed unconcerned. From his perspective, the publicity generated by the debate was a source of fundraising for AIG’s construction of the Ark Encounter theme park (Chowdhury 2014).

REFERENCES

Alford, Roger. 2010). “Full-scale Replica of Noah’s Ark Planned in Kentucky.” USA Today, December 3. Accesed fromhttp://usatoday30.usatoday.com/travel/destinations/2010-12-05-noahs-ark-kentucky-creation-museum_N.htm on 27 February 2015.

Answers in Genesis Board of Directors. 2011. “Kicked Out of Two Homeschool Conferences.” answersingenesis.org, June 10. Accessed from https://answersingenesis.org/ministry-news/core-ministry/kicked-out-of-two-homeschool-conferences/ on 31 January 2015.

Answers in Genesis. 2012. “Statement of Faith.” Accessed from https://answersingenesis.org/about/faith/ on 6 January 2015.

Answers in Genesis. n.d. “Ken Ham.” Accessed from http://creation.com/ken-ham on 7 January 2015.

Blackford, Linda B. 2011. “Founder of Creation Museum Banned from Convention.” kentucky.com, March 24. Accessed fromhttp://www.kentucky.com/2011/03/24/1682122_founder-of-creation-museum-banned.html?rh=1 on 31 January 2015.

Chowdhury, Sudeshna. 2014. “Bill Nye versus Ken Ham: Who Won?” The Christian Science Monitor, February 5. Accessed fromhttp://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-357806905.html on 26 January 2015.

Duncan, Julie A. 2009. Faith Displayed as Science: The Role of the Creation Museum in the Modern Creationist Movement . Honors Thesis, Department of the History of Science. Cambridge: Harvard University.

Goodwin, Liz. 2012. “The Creation Museum Evolves: Hoping to Add a Life-Size Ark Project, The Museum Hits Fundraising Trouble.news.yahoo.com, July 5. Accessed from http://news.yahoo.com/blogs/lookout/creation-museum-evolves-hoping-add-life-size-ark-170347907.html on 31 January 2015.

Ham, Ken. 2009. “If You Don’t Matter to God, You Don’t Matter to Anyone.” Answersingenesis.org , April 20. Accessed fromhttps://answersingenesis.org/sanctity-of-life/mass-shootings/if-you-dont-matter-to-god-you-dont-matter-to-anyone/ on 29 January 2015.

Ham, Ken. n.d. “The History of Answers in Genesis through December 2014.” Accessed fromhttps://answersingenesis.org/about/history/ on 7 January 2015.

Jacoby, Steve. 1998. “Culture Clash.” Cincinnati Best & Worst 33: 80-86. Accessed from http://books.google.com/books?id=7u0CAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA80#v=onepage&q=50%2C000&f=false on 29 December 2014.

Kennerly, Britt. 2009. “Paleontologists Brought to Tears, Laughter by Creation Museum.” Phys.org, June 30. Accessed fromhttp://phys.org/news165555744.html on 29 January 2015.

“Kentucky: No Tax Break for Site of a New Noah’s Ark.” Associated Press, December 11. Accessed fromhttp://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/11/us/politics/kentucky-no-tax-break-for-site-of-a-new-noahs-ark.html on 27 February 2015.

Linshi, Jack. 2015. Noah’s Ark Theme Park Group Sues Kentucky Over Withdrawn Tax Breaks.” TIME, February 3. Accessed fromhttp://time.com/3694802/ken-ham-genesis-kentucky-lawsuit/ on 27 February 2015.

Lippard, Jim. 2006. “Trouble in Paradise: Answers in Genesis Splinters.” Reports of the National Center for Science Education, 26(6) .Accessed from http://ncse.com/rncse/26/6/trouble-paradise 14 January 2015.

Lovan, Dylan. 2012. “Bill Nye Warns: Creation Views Threaten US Science.” AP Online, September 24. Accessed fromhttp://www.highbeam.com/doc/1A1-07009c71ef51419a98865a691635f294.html on 26 January 2015.

Numbers, Ronald. 2006. The Creationists: From Scientific Creationism to Intelligent Design . Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

O’Neil, Tyler. 2014. “Science vs. Bible? 5 Arguments for and Against Creationism From the Ken Ham, Bill Nye Debate.” The Christian Post, February 5. Accessed from http://www.christianpost.com/news/science-vs-bible-the-5-best-arguments-for-and-against-creationism-from-the-ken-ham-bill-nye-debate-114005/pageall.html on 26 January 2015.

“Richard Dawkins Interview.” 2010. AIGbusted.blogspot.com, December 26. Accessed fromhttp://AIGbusted.blogspot.com/2010/12/richard-dawkins-interview.html on 29 January 2015.

Ross, Marcus R. 2005. “Who Believes What? Clearing up Confusion about Intelligent Design and Young-Earth Creationism.” Liberty University. Accessed from http://digitalcommons.liberty.edu/bio_chem_fac_pubs/79 on 5 January 2015.

Saletan, William. 2014. “Creativity for Creationists.” Accessed from http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/human_nature/2014/12/evolutionary_creationism_jeff_hardin_reconciles_
evangelical_christianity.html
on 28 December 2014.

Simitopoulou, Kally and Nikolaos Xirotitis. 2010. “The Revival of Creationism in Contemporary Societies: A Short Survey.” Bulletin der Schweizerischen Gesellschaft für Anthropologie 16:79–86.

Wieland, Carl. 2005. “Rushing in—Where Wiser Heads Might Not.” answersingenesis.org, April 12. Accessed fromhttp://web.archive.org/web/20080307123315/http://www.answersingenesis.org/docs2005/0412zimmer.asp on 14 January 2015.

Authors:
David G. Bromley
Merin Duke
Simren Bhatt

Post Date:
27 February 2015

ANSWERS IN GENESIS VIDEO CONNECTIONS

 

Share

Anusara Yoga

ANUSARA TIMELINE

1959 John Friend, founder of Anusara yoga, was born.

1987 Friend left the profession of financial consulting to become a fulltime yoga instructor.

1989 Friend received shaktipat (spiritual awakening) from Gurumayi while traveling in India.

1997 Anusara, Inc. was established.

2010 Property was leased and plans began for “The Center,” a yoga and performing arts complex, in Encinitas, California.

2012 (February) A scandal erupted concerning personal and business choices made by John Friend.

2012 Anusara, Inc. restructured after the scandal and mass exodus of Anusara teachers.

2012 (October) Friend resumed teaching as an independent Hatha Yoga instructor.

2012 (November) The Anusara School of Hatha Yoga, a global teacher-led school, incorporated.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Anusara® yoga developed under the inspiration and leadership of John Friend. In the early stages of developing the brand, Friend asked his guru, Gurumayi, about a name (Williamson 2012). She referred him to Douglas Brooks, a scholar of Tantra who teaches at Rochester University. Brooks was, at that time, translating the Kularnava Tantra while residing at Shree Muktananda Ashram, a major center for Siddha Yoga – a type of meditation-based yoga brought to the United States in the 1970s by Muktananda and now led by Gurumayi. Friend consulted with Brooks just as he was translating a sentence from the scripture as, “By stepping into the current of grace, the student becomes capable of holding what is of value from the guru.” The word anusara comes from saras, which means flowing. The literature of Anusara yoga translates anusara as “flowing with grace,” drawing on the larger context of the sentence. Friend continued to consult scholars of Tantra whom he had befriended during his stays at this ashram as he developed Anusara yoga, but Friend is the ultimate architect.

As Friend trained teachers in Anusara yoga, some rose to the top as stars, beloved by many students. However, John Friend was undeniably the virtuoso of Anusara, with his classes attracting thousands of devoted followers. In fact, he was adulated to such a degree that some considered him a guru. Friend, however, denies any status of enlightenment beyond the divine nature he believes everyone possesses (Author interview of Friend, 2010). In spite of this, a power differential developed over time between Friend and others – even those who worked closely with him in the organization. Some Anusara yoga teachers and leaders would later accuse Friend of abusing his power.

The road to Friend’s ascent as a hatha yoga guru began at a young age. His mother introduced him to stories of yogis, and he determined that he would someday acquire the powers these yogis had. He began the study of Hatha Yoga at the age of thirteen in his hometown of Youngstown, Ohio. His yoga teacher, a woman he simply refers to as Margaret, together with his mother, exposed Friend to an eclectic group of Eastern and Western esoteric teachings. Through his teen and young adult years, Friend studied the philosophies and practices of the Theosophical Society, Wicca, Sufism, New Thought, and Buddhism. His inspiration to deeply pursue the practice of yoga and meditation came, in large part, from reading the autobiography of Paramahansa Yogananda (1893-1952) in the late 1970s. For a period, he pursued the meditation techniques taught by Self-Realization Fellowship, the organization founded by Yogananda. From his teen years to the present day, Friend has been interested in the connection between physical movement and spiritual ecstasy. This was witnessed in his practice of Sufi dancing, but even more so in his embrace of physical yoga. T.K.V. Desikachar (Viniyoga style), Patabbhi Jois (Ashtanga Yoga style), and Indra Devi are among the yoga teachers under whom Friend studied. Of these, he worked most consistently with B. K. S. Iyengar, eventually becoming an instructor of Iyenagar Yoga and serving on the board of directors for the Iyengar organization.

Friend attended Texas A&M University, where he received degrees in Finance and Accounting, and upon graduating, he worked as a financial consultant. In 1987, he left this profession to teach yoga fulltime. While a student of Iyengar, he traveled throughout India in 1989. In Ganeshpuri, near Mumbai, he met Gurumayi, the head of a guru lineage known as Siddha Yoga. He received shaktipat (spiritual awakening) from her and shortly thereafter began teaching yoga courses for her devotees, primarily at an ashram in South Fallsburg, New York. There, Friend was exposed to different Hindu philosophies, including the philosophy of Tantra, which was to play a large part in his formulation of Anusara yoga.

In creating his own brand of postural yoga, Friend developed a positive teaching vocabulary. Phrases such as “lead from the heart” became emblematic of Anusara yoga classes and inspired students to view their yoga practice as a melding of the physical and psycho-spiritual realms. Friend encouraged students to perform their postures from an internal space of joy and peace. In training teachers, he instructed them to, “Communicate to the students on a personal or heart level, not to their outer bodies on an impersonal level” (Friend 1998:101). He also integrated the physical and pycho-spiritual by developing a theoretical framework that connects the muscles and bones of the body to circular energy systems, or “loops and spirals.” By developing a set of principles which “bring the body into alignment with the Optimal Blueprint” (Friend 1998:39), his approach stands in contrast to that of Iyengar, who worked more from the purely physical level. Friend fine-tuned and formalized Anusara yoga as he trained instructors and wrote a manual for the extensive teacher training process.

Friend organized large gatherings of Anusara yoga practitioners from 2008 to 2012 and also participated in the Yoga Journal conferences where his classes drew such a crowd that his image needed to be projected onto screens throughout the room. Anusara yoga’s presence also became well known at music festivals, such as Wanderlust. At workshops, conferences, and festivals, Friend tightened the association of Anusara yoga with Tantra by arranging for some former swamis of Siddha Yoga (Sally Kempton and Carlos Pomeda) and scholars of Hinduism and Tantra (Douglas Brooks, Paul Muller-Ortega, and William Mahony) to speak and offer classes. Later a younger scholar, also formerly associated with Siddha Yoga, Christopher “Hareesh” Wallis, joined the group and became a popular teacher among Anusara yoga practitioners. Those seeking Anusara yoga teacher certification have been strongly encouraged to study with any one or all of these teachers. Friend also began to incorporate Hindu chants into workshops, and several kirtana (chanting) groups regularly traveled with Friend, including Krishna Das, Benjy and Heather Wertheimer (known as Shantala), and MC Yogi. Friend included performing arts in these various gatherings through talent shows that featured music, dance, and drama. Some of the performances enacted hula hooping and light or fire twirling, which were prevalent at large festivals such as Burning Man.

Anusara, Inc. grew by leaps and bounds throughout the first fifteen years of its existence. At its apex, Anusara had approximately 1,500 instructors and 500,000 practitioners in seventy countries. All of this came to a grinding halt in 2012 – just at the start of Friend’s “Igniting the Center 2012 World Tour” that was to add yantras (sacred geometry) and pyramid power to the mixture of practices. In February, a website posted incriminating evidence against Friend, which is detailed in the Issues/Challenges section below. Currently, after a brief hiatus for self-reflection and therapy, Friend is back on a touring schedule, acting outside of the Anusara yoga organization as an independent hatha yoga instructor – albeit “one of the most knowledgeable and experienced hatha yoga teachers in the world,” according to Friend’s website (“About John Friend” n.d.).

As Anusara yoga restructured, new faces have come to the fore. However, with the lesson of the corrupting influence of power still fresh, no one person is viewed as having authority. Decisions are made through committees. Three licensed Anusara yoga teachers are now the owners and managers of the newly formed Anusara School of Hatha Yoga (ASHY) ®: BJ Galvan, William Savage, and Jane Norton.

Galvan has traveled extensively in the United States, Australia, South America, and Europe, apprenticing under Friend and assisting him with classes. She has been teaching globally since 2007 and played an integral part in introducing Anusara yoga in South America. Currently, Galvan leads bi-lingual Anusara yoga events and trainings around the world. Passionate about her yoga practice, she is also a Reiki Master, Hypnobirthing® practitioner, former commercial real estate developer, volunteer for local civic organizations, and a mother and grandmother.

William “Doc” Savage specializes in one-on-one yoga therapy sessions. He has been teaching yoga for five years after studying under many teachers, including John Friend, Adam Ballenger, BJ Galvan, and Martin and Jordan Kirk. Savage also traveled to India with Douglas Brooks in order to deepen his understanding of Tantra. Prior to teaching yoga, he spent twenty-two years in the U.S. Air Force. He and his wife, Donna, teach yoga in the Black Hills of South Dakota as well as regionally under the moniker Dakota Yogi.

Jane Norton, the third manager of ASHY, became hooked on Anusara yoga when a nagging wrist pain was cleared up after attending her first class in 2003. Like Savage, Norton specializes in using Anusara yoga’s alighment principles to help people recover from injury and chronic pain conditions. From 2005-2007,she toured the United States as Anusara yoga’s boutique manager. Norton lives on the island of Martha’s Vineyard and enjoys cooking, beachcombing, and gardening.

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

Anusara yoga, as a form of physical yoga – also known as asana, hatha yoga, and postural yoga – is similar to other contemporary, global brands of physical yoga, but also has characteristics that set it apart. The practice centers around postures that are held with focused attention, accompanied by breath control. Types of physical yoga might be dotted along a line stretching from secular at one end to spiritual at the other. Anusara yoga’s placement falls toward the spiritual end because of its emphasis on developing “heart” qualities and, for Anusara yoga teachers, upon studying sacred texts from the yoga tradition of India. Required reading includes the Bhagavad-Gita, Yoga Sutras, Shiva Sutras, and Hatha Yoga Pradipika.

The philosophy section of the organization’s website states: “It is through the revelatory power of Grace that we awaken to the truth that this Divine flow is our essential nature. This higher knowledge naturally fuels our deepest desire to lovingly serve the creative flow of life through each breath and posture in our yoga practice. On our yoga mat we artistically offer our individual light and our unique music with the heartfelt prayer of adding more beauty, love, and goodness to the world” (“Philosophy” n.d.).

Friend developed his own philosophy of yoga when he realized that his views did not align with those of his teacher, B.K.S. Iyengar, who embraced the philosophy of samkhya found in the Yoga Sutras (Author interview of Friend, 2010). Samkhya is a dualistic system that divides the world into purusha and prakriti: the unchanging yet conscious spirit and the changing yet non-conscious matter. Because samkhya privileges purusha and thus tends to devalue the physical world, Friend favors the non-dual Tantric approach.

Tantra is multi-faceted system of philosophy and practice that developed in India during the Middle Ages. André Padoux provides a simple definition when he writes of Tantra as “an attempt to place kama, desire, in every sense of the word, in the service of liberation . . . not to sacrifice this world for liberation’s sake, but to reinstate it, in varying ways, within the perspective of salvation” (2004:15). The ultimate goal behind the philosophy of Anusara yoga is to leave behind ego-driven desire and align oneself instead with divine desire, or divine will, known as iccha. The specific form of Tantra that Friend learned during his time with Siddha Yoga is Kashmir Shaivism. Scholars from the Siddha Yoga tradition who have been associated with Anusara yoga align themselves with different sects of Tantra. Douglas Brooks proffers Shrividya Tantra, which focuses on Shakti, or feminine creative energy, and which Brooks teaches under the auspices of his newly coined Rajanaka Yoga. Paul Muller-Ortega aligns with Trika Tantra, which focuses on Shiva, considered to be an all-pervasive supreme reality inseparable from the creative power of Shakti. Muller-Ortega teaches his system under the moniker, Blue Throat Yoga.

Some confusion ensued for those Anusara yoga students who studied with both of these scholars. Thus, Friend coined the term Shiva-Shakti Tantra as a way to incorporate aspects of both sects, as well as his own larger worldview. Tantric scholar Christopher Wallis (2012) stated in an article for Bay Shakti that the terminology is “too broad and too vague.” The philosophy is indeed broad as it brings together Buddhist and Hindu Tantra, philosophies of China and Japan, Celtic and Wicca philosophies, and even aboriginal Australian views. The bottom line in all of these, for Friend, is that reality is orderly and good, and that all levels of life and the cosmos are interconnected (Coy interview of Friend, Bay Shakti 2010). Douglas Brooks and those Anusara yoga practitioners who followed his teachings objected to the newly articulated philosophy, eventually forming one faction that left Anusara yoga following the scandal disclosure. However, Shiva-Shakti suits the eclectic and loosely-defined Tantra that Anusara yoga represents. Former Anusara teacher Christina Sell expressed this potpourri when she stated in her blog: “Rajanaka Tantra lives within the world of Shiva-Shakti Tantra with no conflict although it has its own worldview, operating paradigm and points of difference. As do the profound teachings of Kashmir Shaivism that Paul [Muller Ortega] is bringing to life in his courses. As do the heart-ful teachings of Jesus, Budhha, Wicca and anything else that brings us closer to the direct experience of our intrinsic beauty, delight, and creative expansion” (2011).

Another aspect of Anusara yoga’s philosophy has to do with linking the physical body to the foundational principles of attitude, alignment, and action. Attitude comes into place before any movement begins as an Anusara practitioner “opens to Grace.” Grace is understood to be the revelatory power of spirit that animates the postures; it is a life force that opens one’s body, mind, and spirit. The second foundational principle, alignment, requires integrating the different parts of one’s being. The third principle, action, applies to “the natural flow of energy in the body” (Friend 1998:25). The concept of “shri” (beauty and abundance) also plays a large role in Anusara yoga’s philosophy and is said to unite spiritual and worldly aspirations.

It is the philosophy of Anusara yoga that unites its followers according to the organization’s website: “Anusara yoga is held together by everyone’s implicit alliance to the spiritual principles of Anusara yoga philosophy, such as celebrating beauty in all its diversity, truthfulness, and honoring the creative freedom of the Divine in all beings. Everyone is aligned with the truth that Grace plays the key role in the successful flow of their practice, classes, and the community itself” (“Philosophy” n.d.).

RITUALS/PRACTICES

Anusara yoga is built on rituals of the body that create a sense of community and connect practitioners to a larger cosmic reality. Words are used to link the body to the heart and to instill virtue. The body becomes the axis mundi toward which all levels of reality coalesce and which elevates the physical toward the spiritual. Each Anusara yoga class begins with an invocation that Friend had learned from his mother at an early age and which he encountered again during his time with Siddha Yoga. He asked Krishna Das to write a melody for the verses, which serve to unite Anusara yoga students from around the world. The Sanskrit words are rendered on the back of Anusara yoga invocation cards as, “I honor the essence of Being, the Auspicious One, the luminous teacher within and without, who assumes the forms of Truth, Consciousness, and Bliss, is never absent, full of peace. Who is ultimately free and sparkles with a divine luster.” (This is more of an interpretation than direct translation; the first words, for example, namah shivaya gurave translate more directly as, “I bow to the Guru, who is Shiva.”) If the class is being taught in a more secular setting such as a gym, the opening mantra may be omitted or replaced with a simple chant of om three times.

Following chanting and bowing to each others’ and one’s own deepest self with the word, namaste, the instructor relates a spiritual story or theme she or he has contemplated. This theme sets the tone for the class and is referred to throughout the session so that students perform the postures as much from inner inspiration as from outer willpower. The organization’s website states under Methodology, “Each theme gives a direction for the attitudinal energy that infuses every action and breath in the poses. Effectively, all the poses in Anusara yoga are expressed from the ‘inside out.’” The Teacher Training Manual offers suggestions to teachers as they create an intention for each class. Among these are: “Experiencing our innate goodness, joy, love, worthiness, or divine power through the poses,” and “Doing the poses as artistic expressions of celebrations of one’s spirit” (Friend 1998:93). Classes end with the corpse pose, or “final relaxation,” followed by a final namaste.

The class ritual is the face of Anusara yoga that has inspired people around the world. While mostly focused on the physical body,“opening the heart” is an integral part of the class experience. Following class, community is built in some Anusara yoga studios through chatting over tea. Some Anusara yoga kulas (communities) organize social outings and support each other in times of need by preparing food or offering transportation. Some groups also hold benefits to provide donations to non-profit service organizations.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

The purpose of Anusara yoga’s organization – formerly Anusara, Inc. and currently Anusara School of Hatha Yoga – is to offer instruction and to certify teachers. In addition, the organization has profited from selling clothing, yoga props, and print and electronic media. Some of the books, CDs, and videos they sell were produced by their own publishing company. Two scholars have recently had their work published by Anusara Press: Christopher Wallis, who wrote Tantra Illuminated (2011) and William Mahony, who wrote Exquisite Love: Heart-Centered Reflections on the Narada Bhakti Sutra (2011). But primarily, the organization sells Anusara yoga itself. Andrea Jain calls Friend a “a second-generation yoga entrepreneur,” who “selected from Iyengar Yoga and Siddha Yoga and subsequently introduced, elaborated, and fortified the Anusara yoga brand” (2012:13-14).

Under Friend’s leadership, the organization reached its financial apex in 2010 when it took in $2.8 million, according to a memorandum prepared for investors in 2011 (Roig-Franzia 2012). At that time, Anusara, Inc. was attempting to equip an educational and performing arts center in Encinitas, California, which was to focus on practices and precepts of the yoga and Tantra traditions. Friend envisioned a community growing up around The Center in Encinitas (Author interview of Friend, 2010). According to The Coast News, Anusara, Inc. had signed a 73-year lease for the 8,269-square-foot building for $1.86 million in October 2010 (Cagala 2012). The scandal, in part, involves allegations surrounding the funding for this project, but an investigation did not reveal intentional illegal activity. The plans and the lease were dissolved in 2012.

At the time the scandal erupted, there were 1,200 “Anusara-Inspired” yoga teachers (having completed at least 200 hours of training) and over 300 fully certified teachers (having completed at least 500 hours of training, among other rigorous requirements) for a total of over 1,500 teachers. The number of practitioners was about 500,000. According to Wendy Willtrout, operations manager for Anusara Inc., this number was estimated based on the number of students John taught in a year, plus all of the licensed teachers’ students. Currently, Willtrout states, there are 177 certified Anusara yoga teachers and 656 Anusara-Inspired licensed teachers. Thus, the number of instructors was reduced in the months following February, 2012, by about 700. Some of these, including John Friend, have gone on to become independent hatha yoga instructors. A good number have joined a break-off non-profit organization called Kula Evolution. The rest are currently re-organizing to continue under the trademarked name of Anusara yoga.

All Anusara application paperwork, videos, and trademarks have been passed on to the newly formed school called Anusara School of Hatha Yoga (ASHY), a for-profit teacher-owned school, which will license teachers in Anusara yoga in the future. The school is run by licensed Anusara yoga teachers representing five regions: the United States, Canada, Central and South America, Europe and the Middle East, and Asia and the Pacific. ASHY’s European and Middle East region encompasses all of the countries in the European Union, Israel, and Turkey. Its Asia/Pacific region is comprised of Australia, New Zealand, China, Singapore, Japan, Taiwan, Korea, Malaysia, and Thailand. The Anusara School of Hatha Yoga will be the sole licensee of the Anusara yoga trademarks and will be the central global body to administrate curriculum and certification in these five regions.

Kula Evolution is the other main entity that has replaced Anusara, Inc. According to their website, they are not associated with Anusara yoga in any way. In their words, “By forming Kula Evolution we are pursuing a new path with a new organization that has grown from our experiences in this past time period. Phase One of our organization includes a simple network that any current or former Anusara teachers and supporting students are free to join. In Phase Two, we will be re-writing curriculum and teacher training materials” (Kula Evolution n.d.).

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

Criticism of Anusara yoga began long before the scandal of 2012. Some complained that its practitioners maintain a myopic focus on the positive that obscures a balanced view of the human condition. Tantric scholar Christopher Wallis, for example, referred to Anusara yoga philosophy as “Pollyanna” rather than Tantra (Author interview of Wallis, 2010). In an article for the New York Times, Mimi Swartz compared John Friend to Christian evangelist Joel Osteen (2010).

Anusara yoga has also been criticized for its consumer orientation, an assessment common to the yoga phenomenon more generally. Jeremy Carrette and Richard King, authors of Selling Spirituality: The Silent Takeover of Religion, argue that contemporary groups, including those promoting eastern practices, exploit people’s desire for spiritual experience for capitalistic gain. Furthermore, the authors indict “private spirituality” for its disregard of issues of social justice. Mimi Swartz stated that Anusara, Inc. was bringing in revenue of two million dollars a year, and that Friend paid himself a salary of just under $100,000 a year. This is not viewed as problematic by Friend who stated, “There’s no differentiation between yoga philosophy and business philosophy. We honor spirit, based on our vision that life is good” (Swartz 2010). In 2010, Anusara teamed up with a well-established vendor of yoga accessories to the benefit of each. A statement of endorsement appears on John Friend’s Blog: “With Manduka, I was able to ask, ‘What is important to me in a yoga mat?’ Wider. Light, to fold and fit easily into a day bag or suitcase. Produced in greater harmony with the earth.’ – John Friend” (November 8, 2011). Just as Friend has been accused of using his savvy business sense to form partnerships that might help him sell his products, he also has been criticized for teaming up with scholars and swamis for his own advantage in order to sell Anusara yoga.

The emergence of incriminating evidence against John Friend with the publication of a website, www.jfexposed.com, which appeared for a day and a half in February of 2012, was the final straw needed for some who had been questioning the direction of Anusara yoga to make a clean break. For others who were distant from the inner workings of the organization and who had little contact with Friend, the news came as a heart-breaking revelation. The allegations included Friend’s involvement in questionable financial practices, in sexual relations with several female employees, some of whom were married, in a Wiccan coven that used sexual rituals, and in using marijuana and placing employees in legal jeopardy by having them accept packages of marijuana on his behalf. More recently, Friend stated that, “Someone sent a box with marijuana to the office without my knowledge and it was opened unknowingly by an employee” (Personal correspondence with author, December 11, 2012). He also stated that “the coven never used sex acts as rituals!” (December 11, 2012). However, earlier he had a written a letter to one of the coven members with the statement, “As part of our rituals you and I both agreed that we would use sexual/sensual energy in a positive and sacred way to help build the efficacy of our practices, which is a common element of most Wiccan circles, as you know” (YogaDork 2012).

In February of 2012, the yoga conglomerate began to crumble. A group of senior Anusara yoga teachers attempted to meet the crisis by demanding Friend step down as CEO of Anusara, Inc. and immediately cease teaching. Friend was due to teach at a conference in Miami, and he continued with the plan, garnering yet more criticism from increasingly disenfranchised followers. On March 20, 2012, Friend wrote a letter of apology to the community of Anusara yoga practitioners in which he stated that he took full responsibility for “being out of integrity” by engaging in intimate relationships with married women. The allegation regarding financial indiscretion was dismissed as untrue, and the allegations regarding marijuana were not addressed.

Roig-Franzia stated in an article for the Washington Post that several teachers had reported that Friend had changed the ethical guidelines for the organization in 2009, essentially allowing sexual relationships between Anusara teachers and their students. Friend had formed a small Wiccan coven around that time with some of his students called the Blazing Solar Flames in which he was the only male. The “high priestess” of this former coven revealed in an interview for The Daily Beast that the rituals involving Friend and several women were sexual in nature. When she told Friend that she wanted to leave the coven, he implored her to stay, saying that the coven was the “battery” for Anusara yoga (Crocker 2012). It may be that Friend considered sexual energy the foundation of his charisma, an idea found in “left-handed” Tantra.

Amy Ippoliti, a former Anusara yoga teacher stated for The Daily Beast, “The model of working for a monarch can’t function in 2012. If there’s one good thing emerging from all of this, it’s people feel like they can teach without being connected to a brand. They know now that the collective is stronger than any one person’s view” (2012). John Friend still owns Anusara, Inc., which now functions as a holding company for ownership of the trademarks, all of which have been licensed to the Anusara School of Hatha Yoga. So the brand, Anusara yoga, continues even without its founder’s direction. BJ Galvan stated, “I believe on a global level, people are still practicing Anusara because the scandal was almost entirely an American phenomenon” (Personal correspondence with author, December 7, 2012). Andrea Jain attributes the brand’s popularity to its principles, stating, “What made Friend’s yoga brand stand out most was that it signified the idea that goodness is present in everyone in a life-affirming way” (2012:12). Whatever might be said of John Friend’s personal behavior, aspects of the spiritual practices and teaching style he developed continue to spread – both through those teachers who have left the specific Anusara brand and through those who continue to promote it through the Anusara School of Hatha Yoga.

REFERENCES

“About John Friend.” n.d. Accessed from http://www.johnfriend.com/about-john-friend/ on 10 December 2012.

Anusara Homepage. n. d. “Philosophy” and “Methodology.” Accessed from http://www.anusara.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=frontpage&Itemid=73 on 8 December 2012.

Cagala, Tony, 2012. “The ‘Center’ for Anusara Yoga no longer holds lease.” The Coast News, April 26. Accessed from http://thecoastnews.com/2012/04/the-center-for-anusara-yoga-no-longer-holds-lease/ on 6 December 2012.

Carette, Jeremy R. and Richard King. 2005. Selling Spirituality: The Silent Takeover of Religion. New York, NY: Routledge.

Crocker, Lizzie. 2012. “John Friend Anusara Scandal: Inside the Wiccan ‘Sex’ Coven.” The Daily Beast, April 15. Accessed from http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2012/04/15/john-friend-anusara-scandal-inside-the-wiccan-sex-coven.html on 3 December 2012.

Friend, John. 2011. “Part 2: Interview with John Friend-Dancing with the Divine, 2011 World Tour.” Bay Shakti, March 1. Accessed from http://bayshakti.com/part-2-interview-with-john-friend-dancing-with-the-divine-2011-world-tour on 8 December 2012.

Friend, John. 2011. John Friend’s Blog. November 8. Accessed at http://www.anusara.com/index.php?option=com_wpmu&blog_id=2&Itemid=250 on 11 December 2012.

Friend, John. 1998. Teacher Training Manual, 12 th ed. The Woodlands, TX: Anusara Press, 2009.

Jain, Andrea R. 2012. “Branding Yoga: The Cases of Iyengar Yoga, Siddha Yoga, and Anusara yoga.” Approaching Religion 2:3-17.

John Friend Homepage. n.d. “About John Friend.” Accessed from http://www.johnfriend.com/about-john-friend/ on 8 December 2012.

KulaEvolution. n.d. Accessed at http://kulaevolution.wordpress.com/ on 11 December 2012.

Padoux, Andre. 2004. “Tantrism.” Encyclopedia of Religions, ed. M. Eliade, Macmillan, 14: 273; cited in D. G. White. 2006. Kiss of the Yogini: “Tantric Sex” in its South Asian Contexts. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

Roig-Franzia, Manuel. 2012. “Scandal contorts future of John Friend, Anusara yoga.” The Washington Post, March 2. Accessed from http://articles.washingtonpost.com/2012-03-28/lifestyle/35450478_1_anusara-yoga-mats-web-site on 2 December 2012.

Sell, Christina. 2011. Blog, April 20. http://christinasell.blogspot.com/2011/04/few-reflections-on-shiiva-shakti-tantra.html accessed on 3 December 2012.

Schwartz, Mimi. July 21, 2010. “Yoga Mogul.” New York Times. Accessed from http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/25/magazine/25Yoga-t.html?pagewanted=all on 7 April 2012.

Wallis, Christopher (Hareesh). Feb. 28, 2012. “What is Shiva-Shakti Tantra? Did John Friend make it up?” Bay Shakti. Accessed from http://bayshakti.com/what-is-shiva-shakti-tantra-did-john-friend-make-it-up on 2 December 2012.

Williamson, Lola. 2013 (forthcoming). “Stretching toward the Sacred: John Friend and Anusara yoga.” In Gurus of Modern Yoga, edited by Ellen Goldberg and Mark Singleton. New York: Oxford University Press.

Williamson, Lola. 2012. “Methodological Issues.” Anusara is considered a “brand” rather than a system of yoga because of its trademarked status. Due the fact that over a thousand people worldwide have put in many hours of training as well as significant financial outlay toward becoming an Anusara yoga instructor, and many of them have recently left to teach on their own or to join a break off group, the registered trademark symbol signifies that it is the system that John Friend developed and that continues today under the Anusara School of Hatha Yoga, also a registered trademark.

YogaDork. 2012. “John Friend, Head of Anusara: The Accusations.” Feb. 3. Accessed from http://yogadork.com/news/john-friend-head-of-anusara-wiccan-leader-sexual-deviant-pension-withholding-homewrecker-the-accusations/ on 16 December 2012.

Post Date:
3 January 2013

 

 

 

 

 

Share

Universal Church Triumphant of the Apathetic Agnostic

APATHETIC AGNOSTIC (UCTAA) TIMELINE

1965:  While attending the Royal Military College of Canada, John Tyrrell first used the phrases “I don’t know and I don’t care” and ‘Apathetic Agnosticism’ to describe his religious beliefs.

1996:  John Tyrrell founded The Universal Church Triumphant of the Apathetic Agnostic (UCTAA) with the creation of a single, sparse page on his personal site. At the time, the webpage included only the three Articles of Faith and a disclaimer.

1996:  Later this year, the page expanded to include a Meditations section and a commentary on the Articles of Faith. The page was also placed on its own website.

1997:  A church membership option was made available.

1998:  A clerical hierarchy was established, with degrees and ordination being offered from the International University of Nescience.

2000:  There was an increase in interest in the Apathetic Agnosticism movement, with members wishing to become more active. This led to a number of new initiatives, including a Clergy Resource site, private message boards for members, and an outcropping of regional sites. Tyrrell purchased the domain names uctaa.org and ApatheticAgnostic.com.

2003 (January):  The Church was legally incorporated in the United States. The incorporation subsequently lapsed.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Little is known about the life of John Tyrrell, the founder of the Apathetic Agnosticism movement. He was raised in an Anglican family in Ontario. He matriculated at The Royal Military College of Canada where he received his BA in Economics and Politics and later obtained his MBA from Queen’s College. From 1963-1994, Tyrrell served as a Logistics Officer in the Canadian Armed Forces (Tyrell 2012).

It took Tyrrell several years to arrive at the concept of apathetic agnosticism. After thoroughly considering several religions, he came to the realization that none of them successfully addressed the issue of any god’s existence. He felt strongly that “without being able to address that issue realistically, the whole belief structure collapses – regardless of which religion” (“History” n.d.).

When John Tyrrell first created the UCTAA page, it was simply a humorous exposition of his personal beliefs
and he had no  aspirations of it taking off. Today, it is estimated that UCTAA has over 10,000 members in over 40 countries, but no accurate membership records exist (“History” n.d.). Tyrrell is responsible for the bulk of the website’s maintenance. He personally responds to questions from the public, which he then posts on the site in a section called “Ask the Patriarch.”

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

The term Apatheism (a portmanteau of Apathy and Theism or Apathy and Atheism) was coined by American author and activist, Jonathon Rauch. He defines it is “a disinclination to care all that much about one’s own religion and an even stronger disinclination to care about other people’s” (Rauch 2003). Rauch sees the rise in apatheism in America as a major civilizational advance and applauds the relaxed attitude that many Americans have adopted towards religion. In contrast with Apathetic Agnosticism, many apatheists do in fact believe in a god and do attend religious services. Although most agnostics are apatheists, not all apatheists are necessarily agnostic (Rauch 2003).

The key difference between agnosticism and apathetic agnosticism is that while both claim to not know if a god exists, agnostics may find the question to be quite important. Apathetic agnosticism stresses that agnosticism is an adequate end point in the search for religious belief. By understanding that the ultimate truth is inexplicable, “we can free ourselves from a fruitless search and indeed, no longer care about answering the question” (Tyrrell n.d.).

The Universal Church Triumphant of the Apathetic Agnostic (UCTAA) holds three fundamental “Articles of Faith:”

1. The existence of a Supreme Being is unknown and unknowable.
2. If there is a Supreme Being, then that being appears to act as if apathetic to events in our universe.
3. We are apathetic to the existence or nonexistence of a Supreme Being (“Faith” 2006).

The organization’s website states that “If you understand and accept these Articles of Faith… then you are an Apathetic Agnostic, whether or not you can be bothered to actually join the Church” (“Faith” 2006).

Agreement with the Articles of Faith is the only requirement for affiliation with the Church, and even that is a
loose rule. There is commentary on the website, but disciples are encouraged to interpret the articles as they see fit. According to the founder, the first article is based on the belief that faith is not the same as empirical knowledge, and thus there is no evidence for or against the existence of a Supreme Being. The only certain position on the matter is that we do not know. The second article proposes that if there is a Supreme Being, it is indifferent to our existence. This is contingent on the understanding that all events in our Universe are explainable regardless of the existence or nonexistence of a Supreme Being. The final article maintains that, based on the first two, there is no reason to trouble oneself with pondering the existence of a Supreme Being.

The aims of the church are as follows:

1. “We could be bigger than Scientology… if only we weren’t so darned apathetic.”
2. “To disseminate the concept of Apathetic Agnosticism as widely as possible. Being apathetic on the question of a Supreme Being’s existence does not imply being apathetic about the concept.”

These aims reflect that the church, while maintaining tangible beliefs and goals, does not take itself too seriously (“Aim” n.d.).

RITUALS/PRACTICES

There is very little ritual associated with the UCTAA. The Apathetic Agnostic Tabernacle Choir practices on Thursdays in showers across the world. Otherwise, the main action associated with the church is the dissemination of knowledge relating to apathetic agnosticism.

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Preceding the creation of the website in 1996, John Tyrrell was the single member of the Universal Church Triumphant of the Apathetic Agnostic. In 1997, a membership option was made available, and in 1998 a clerical hierarchy was established. This is a very informal hierarchy as it is not mandatory that lower clergy take command from their superiors (“Organization” n.d.).

Presently, the Patriarch of the Church is John Tyrrell, the founder. There are several membership options offered, including:

  • Basic affiliation: simply accepting the Articles of Faith, whether or not you apply to be a member of the congregation.
  • Choir membership: an application is offered to join the Apathetic Agnostic Tabernacle Choir which takes place every Thursday evening in the shower.
  • Congregation membership: provides a Bachelor’s Degree from the International University of Nescience and access to the website’s message boards. Degrees can be obtained in several disciplines including Apathy, Ignorance, Nescience, Agnostic Studies, and Spiritual Re-Engineering.
  • Ordination: receive a Masters Degree and ordination as Minister, Pastor, Rabbi, Priest, or Priestess.

The role of the ordained clergy is to “help make information about the church and its teachings available to interested individuals” (“Ordination” n.d.). This can range from including a link to the UCTAA site on one’s personal webpage, creating a mirror website, or conducting an outreach program. Ministers are able to ordain clergy and conduct appropriate ceremonies, including legal marriage ceremonies in areas where their ordination is recognized by law. Ordained clergy are also allowed access to the Church’s Clergy Resource Site (Ordination n.d.).

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

As the Church is unincorporated, there have been concerns about legal liability. The potential for liability falls solely on John Tyrrell, the founder. While the organization strongly discourages monetary donations, the website does accept pro bono advice and representation from willing lawyers. This advice is accepted primarily in order to secure official recognition as a religion so that ordained clergy are able to perform legally binding marriages.

The UCTAA does not solicit or accept donations as a general rule. The founder of the website maintains the organization primarily out of pocket. This structure, along with the apathy of the adherents, has allowed the Church to remain predominately non-controversial (“Needs” n.d.)

REFERENCES

“Aim.” n.d. The Church of the Apathetic Agnostic. Accessed from http://uctaa.net/ourchurch/aims.html on 12 April 2013.

“Faith.” 1996. The Church of the Apathetic Agnostic. Accessed from http://uctaa.net/ourchurch/faith.html on 9 April 2013.

“History.” n.d. The Church of the Apathetic Agnostic. Accessed from http://uctaa.net/ourchurch/history.html on 12 April 2013.

“Needs.” n.d. The Church of the Apathetic Agnostic. Accessed from http://uctaa.net/ourchurch/needs.html on 12 April 2013.

“Ordination” n.d. The Church of the Apathetic Agnostic. Accessed from http://uctaa.net/join/ordain.html on 14 April 2013

“Organization.” n.d. The Church of the Apathetic Agnostic. Accessed from http://uctaa.net/ourchurch/organization.html on 14 April 2013.

Rauch, Jonathon. 2003. “Let it Be: Three Cheers for Apatheism.” The Atlantic. Accessed from http://www.jonathanrauch.com/jrauch_articles/apatheism_beyond_religion/ on 13 April 2013.

Tyrrell, John. 2012. “2012 Edition of the John Tyrrell Web Site.” Accessed from http://www.johntyrrell.com/about.html on 13 April 2013.

Post Date:
15 April 2013

 

 

 

Share