SATANISM SCARE TIMELINE
1966 (April) – Church of Satan was founded by Anton Szandor LaVey and began to gain media attention
1972: Mike Warnke publishes ‘The Satan Seller’ in which he claims to have previously been a ‘Satanic high priest’ in the mid 1960s, before turning to Christ (a backstory that was eventually debunked in a 1992 exposé). He positions himself as an expert during the livestock mutilation panic, and in the late 80s on the Geraldo TV special.
1973 – Early reports of lifestock mutilations began, sparking conspiracy theories
1974 (January) – Nixon signs the Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act (CAPTA) into law, prompting investigations into determining the extent of the problem of child abuse in the US.
1974 – Ted Patrick founds the Citizens Freedom Foundation (CFF)
1975 – Investigative and media reports began to speculate whether lifestock mutilations were being carried out by Satanic cults
1978 – The Jonestown Massacre occurs, prompting a new wave of cult fear in the US
1979 – Rev Jerry Falwell establishes the Moral Majority
1980 – Lawrence Pazder and his patient Michelle Smith publish the co-authored ‘Michelle Remembers’, which documented Smith’s alleged childhood experiences as a victim of ‘Satanic Ritual Abuse’ (SRA). Pazder claimed that these memories had previously been supressed, but that he had been able to uncover them.
1983 – Patricia Pulling creates Bothered About Dungeons and Dragons (BADD), and began publishing information alleging that D&D encouraged devil worship and suicide.
1983 – Judy Johnson, a parent of a child at McMartin preschool, reports to the police that her son had been sexually abused by preschool employee Ray Buckey. Buckey is arrested.
1984 – News of a mass child abuse scandal at McMartin is reported, alleging up to 360 victims. Ray Buckey, along with 6 others, are indicted on 115 counts of child sexual abuse. Among the many allegations were claims that the children were ritualistically abused and made to watch animals be slaughtered.
1985 – The CFF officially changes its name to the Cult Awareness Network (CAN)
1985 – Mike Warnke publishes ‘Schemes of Satan’, building on the D&D panic. In this book he fabricated claims relating to Dallas Egbert’s suicide.
1986 – Charges are dropped against 5 of the 7 McMartin defendants
1987/88 (est) – Jacquie Balodis starts ‘Overcomers Victorious’, a support group for self-proclaimed SRA survivors. She later features on Geraldo’s TV special (see below).
1988 – Geraldo Rivera broadcasts his TV special ‘Devil Worship: Exposing Satan’s Underground’ in which he claimed a hidden interconnected network of Satanic cults were sacrificing children across the US, and recruiting young people through materials such as D&D and heavy metal music.
1989: Judith Spencer publishes ‘Suffer the child’ – an account of “Jenny” and her recovered memories of being abused by a satanic cult, many of which were almost identical to Michelle’s.
1989 – Lawrence Pazder and Michelle Smith (now Michelle Pazder as they had married in 1986) appear together on The Oprah Winfrey Show to promote Michelle Remembers
1990 – Peggy Buckey is acquitted on all counts, charges are dismissed (following two hung verdicts favouring acquittal) against Ray Buckey
1993 – Teenagers Damien Echols, Jesse Miskelley Jr, and Jason Baldwin are arrested and charged with the murder of three children. Police suspicions of Echols being a Satanist prompted them initially questioning him.
1994 – Misskelley is sentenced to 40 years, Baldwin to life, and Echols to death.
2007: DNA evidence found at the crime scene is found not to match Echols, Misskelley or Baldwin
2011: The West Memphis 3 (Echols, Misskelley, and Baldwin) are released using an Alford plea
The foundations of the Satanism scare
Note early foundations and various existing concerns and panics it built on:
Church of Satan?
Mutilations
Missing children panic
Homophobia / concerns around women in workforce
ACM
Note here on the different social roles that then banded together to make the panic more plausible & span religious and secular.
The allegations of the panic
Satanic ‘brainwashing’
Discuss BADDD and heavy metal concerns. Fears of corrupted youth being indoctrinated into Satanism.
Satanic Ritual Abuse
Discuss Pazder and McMartin. Note McMartin was far from the only case.
((End note on these not being mutually exclusive. Tabloid media branded these together – such as infamous Geraldo TV special. Note that SRA cases generally died down after McMartin, but effects went on into the 1990s – note WM3 case and San Antonio 4. Both cases exonerated far later. However, still not the end. Last noted exoneration was documented in 2023 (check!). Impact of the 80s panic still ongoing, while we may already be witnessing a new revival.))
