David G. Bromley

Nine O’Clock Service (NOS) (1986-2025)

 NOS TIMELINE

1840:  St Thomas’s Anglican Church in the Sheffield suburb of Crooke opened with a mission of serving “destitute” populations.

1958:  Christopher (Chris) Brain was born.

1980:  Brain, his wife, Lynne (“Winnie”), and their daughter moved to Sheffield.

1986:  The Nine O’Clock Service (NOS) began at St. Thomas’ Church in Crookes, Sheffield.

1988:  The popularity of the service led the Anglican Bishop of Sheffield to approve the relocation of the service to the Ponds Forge Rotunda in Sheffield.

1991:  Brain was ordained as a deacon in the Anglican Church.

1992 (August):  Brain was accepted for ordination as a priest in the Anglican Church and celebrated his first communion. He wore the cassock worn by Robert de Niro in the 1986 film The Mission.

1992:  The Planetary Mass was performed at an annual Christian festival near Northampton, Greenbelt.

1994:  Brain began exploring potential expansion of NOS to the United States.

1994:  The BBC released a documentary reporting that Brain was moving away from traditional Christian doctrine and introducing his own innovations.

1995 (Summer):  Allegations of sexual abuse by Brain led to his resignation as a priest.

1995:  NOS services were halted following allegations that Brain had engaged in sexual and emotional abuse.

1995 (August):  NOS ceased to exist as a formal entity.

2019:  South Yorkshire Police opened an investigation into allegations of sexual abuse by Brain; he was formally charged for criminal offenses in 2024.

2024 (March 18): Brain appeared at Sheffield Magistrates’ Court to face thirty-four criminal charges of sexual offenses. He offered a not guilty plea on all charges.

2025 (June 30): Brain’s criminal trial began.

2025 (August 2025):  The jury delivered guilty verdicts on seventeen counts of indecent assault against nine women.

2025 (September):  The Crown Prosecution Service  announced that it was planning for retrial on the remaining charges in September.

FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY

Graham St. John nicely describes the Rave scene as it emerged in England in the 1980s (2004:2):

Emerging in London in 1988, and subsequently exported around the world, rave has proliferated and mutated alongside associated music and body technologies. Its primary theatre of action was and remains the dance floor, a kinaesthetic maelstrom inflected by diverse sonic currents and technological developments influencing that which has been generically dubbed ‘house’, ‘electronica’ and ‘techno’. Throughout the 1990s rave grew prevalent in the experience of urban youth as vast numbers attached primary significance to raving. With the combined stimulus of electronic musics, psychotropic lighting, chemical alterants and all-night dancing, young novices and experienced habitues transcended the mundane in converted warehouses, wilderness areas, beaches, deserts and streets. Decked out in esoteric accessories, ultra violet (UV)- reactive clothing, personalized icons and an array of assimilated ‘religious’ glossolalia, their ecstatic experiences moved multitudes to draw on a plenitude of traditional interpretative religious frameworks – Hindu, Buddhist, Christian, pagan, Australian Aboriginal, mystical, etc.

The Nine O’Clock Service was one of the most visible of these groups, despite its relatively brief history (Robinson and Warne (2021) document the proliferation of rave groups across England).

There were a number of social and cultural influences that shaped the environment in which raves appeared in England in the 1980s. For example, John Wimber, who led the Vineyard churches visited in 1985 as did a leader of the Sojourners that same year. Winnie Brain had earlier met with prophets associated with the Toronto Blessing (Robinson and Warne 2021). More directly, Winnie enrolled in the music program at Sheffield University and Brain was a member of a Christian rock band, Present Tense.

The NOS emerged initially in St. Thomas’ Church as simply an alternative service under the leadership of Chris Brain (Till 2006). It immediately attracted the interest of primarily younger adult who were religiously unaffiliated. Anglican Church leaders were attracted by the prospect of new, young members as the church was (and has continued) experiencing steep membership decline. The service began with around a dozen participants but over time ultimately grew to about 600. In its rebellion against traditional religious structure, NOS began meeting as “worship in the round” at a local Shffield club, “Fruit.” It was not long before NOS received permission from the local Bishop to create a separate venue at the Ponds Forge leisure center. Winne Brain served as NOS’s designated DJ at the Fruit club-nights. (Robinson and Warne 2021). Chris Brain began training for the priesthood with enthusiastic support from Anglican clergy.

The visibility and popularity of NOS attracted attention in the United States. British real estate magnate, Dame Anita Lucia Roddick pledged substantial funding for a transplantation. In  2024, Episcopal priest Matthew Fox, a former priest in the Catholic Dominican Order, who was expelled in 1993 over theological disputes, subsequently joined the Episcopalian priesthood. Brain was invited to San Francisco by Fox and Bishop William Swing and performed his Planetary Mass in the Episcopal Grace Cathedral in October 2024. Fox continued Brain’s innovations in a variation he referred to as the Cosmic Mass. The Cosmic Mass shares in common with Brain’s vision the sacredness of earth, building community, joint creativity, rave dancing) but also incorporates a range of historic religious and spiritual traditions (Christian, Buddhist, Hindu, Muslim, Jewish, and Pagan).

According to the Cosmic Mass website (2025), its defining characteristics include:

So the Cosmic Mass replaces pews with a dance floor and replaces reading with dancing and meditation triggered by powerful imagery and music with DJ and VJ enhancement.  While a brief “teaching” is usually included,  the printed texts of modern worship are replaced in the Cosmic Mass by the context of experience.

While the Cosmic Mass was inspired by rave celebrations, its roots go deeper: to the ancient world traditions of ecstatic sacred dance. By enlivening the forms of modern worship with elements of rave and sacred dance, three things happen:

  • First, new life and inspiration flow, freed by ecstatic dance.

  • Second, ravers learn they can get high on worship itself, without the need for drugs.

  • Third, no single minister carries the responsibilities of leadership; everyone participates in midwifing the grace of the event (no vicarious prayer!). Because everyone dances, everyone is contributing their priestly offering.

The Planetory Mass was performed in San Francisco’s Episcopalian Grace Cathedral in October 2024 (Le Blanc 2024).

DOCTRINES/BELIEFS

NOS was created as an alternative to established religious doctrine and organization. Founder Chris Brain was granted permission to create an experimental form of religious service by Anglican leaders at a time that the denomination was losing members and failing to attract young adherents. At the heart of the experiment was a ritual, the Planetary Mass, that drew upon contemporary rave culture to connect young, religiously unaffiliated youth to the church. Bain’s innovation replicated the secular rave form in a spiritual setting. The Nine O’Clock Service’s ritual featured rave-style electric dance music coordinated by a DJ, sound and light projection, a club-like atmosphere, ecstatic dancing, and a celebrative and participatory style.

While Brain retained some elements of traditional Christian doctrine, he also redefined what it meant to be Christian. NOS advocated for a simple lifestyle that emphasized respect for the planet and concern about environmental abuse. Brain also advocated for a postmodern sexuality that abandoned traditional sexual constraints and allowed more free and open sexual activity. It was sexual activity, of course, that became the central issue in NOS’ ultimate downfall (See, Issues/Challenges).

ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP

Chris Brain’s ascendancy to leadership was rapid. Given that both he and Winnie had musical interests, their leadership in creating the Nine O’Clock Service was not surprising. His rapid rise to an independent status for NOS was also fueled by the Anglican hierarchy’s sense that he might help turn around a floundering denomination. And so his formal status was fast tracked. He was ordained as a deacon in the Anglican Church in 1991 and just a year later was accepted for ordination as a priest in the Anglican Church and celebrated his first communion. The media coverage of NOS also was relatively positive given its innovative and colorful quality. Brain received much of the attention.

Because NOS gatherings were organized as raves, each Planetary Mass required many dozens of individuals to assure a smooth performance. At the heart of each performance were teams of members to organize financial matters, music, prayer, venue, etc (O’Neill and Bradley 2025). These dedicated teams created energy and commitment, but also a certain amount of insularity as the goals of NOS became paramount (O’Neill and Bradley 2025).. There also was a special headquarters team of members who were dedicated to serving the Brain family and household. It was this insider team that was to become the primary source of controversy that engulfed NOS.

The group funded its operation largely through a ten percent tithe, but there also inheritance donations, and the Brain family was given use of a large farmhouse, Green Gates.

ISSUES/CHALLENGES

The situation in which NOS found itself shifted dramatically in a very short time. The movement was attracting young adults, receiving support from denominational leaders and favorable media coverage, and moving toward expansion into the U.S. in the early 1990s. By 1995, NOS was being disbanded and Chris Brain was facing criminal charges.

While there were other issues, the pivotal issue in the downfall of Chris Brain and NOS was the sexual violation allegations against Brain. As part of the organizational development, Brain had created the Homebase Team that attended to the needs of the Brain household and family. This insider group was small and insular within NOS (O’Neil 2025; Baynes and Evans. 2025). Brain developed a small coterie of women, often referred to as the “Lycra Lovelies.” Comprised of attractive young women whose attire consisted of black lingerie or tight Lycra outfits, these women not only performed household maintenance tasks and childrearing assistance but also provided sexual services when they “put Chris to bed” at night. One of the organizers of this system, Lori Camm, selected members of the Homebase Team and had an ongoing intimate relationship with Bain (O’Neill 2025; O’Neill and Bradley 2025).

While the crisis within NOS began in the 1990s and Brain resigned his priesthood in 1995, the legal case against him did not take shape until 2019. This created a difficult path for prosecutors as considerable time had elapsed since the events at issue and jurors needed to be convinced that the repeated sexual encounters could not have been consensual due to psychological coercion. The flood of media coverage created a highly charged atmosphere surrounding the legal proceedings.

Brain first appeared at Inner London Crown Court on April 30, 2024. and pleaded not guilty to one charge of rape and thirty-three charges of indecent assault against eleven female NOS members. The alleged assaults occurred between 1981 and 1995. His jury trial began on June 30, 2025.  On August 20, 2025 the jury delivered guilty verdicts on seventeen counts of indecent assault against nine women. He was found not guilty of another fifteen charges of indecent assault. On five cases the jury was unable to reach a verdict. The Crown Prosecution Service subsequently announced that it was planning for retrial on the remaining charges in September 2025 (Baynes 2025).

REFERENCES

Baynes, Chris. 2025. “Former priest faces retrial on sex assault charges.” BBC, September 4. Accessed from https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cq5jdy67p47o&ved=2ahUKEwid5aDfiPyPAxXBLlkFHb3vFAYQFnoECBwQAQ&usg=AOvVaw1CUOvZ83j9yCdXZSy4Uex8 on 1 October 2025.

Baynes, Chris and Alice Evans. 2025. “’Slave-like’ assistants and late-night massages: How a radical priest abused his congregation. BBC, August 21. Accessed from https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cr4ezy3  on 29 September 2025.

Cosmic Mass website. 2025. Accessed from https://www.thecosmicmass.com/ on 28 September 2025.

Hutson, Scott. 2000. “The Rave: Spiritual Healing in Modern Western Subcultures.” Anthropological Quarterly 73:35-49.

Hutson, Scott. 1999. “Technoshamanism: Spiritual Healing in the Rave Subculture.” Popular Music and Society 23:53-77.

Le Blanc, Douglas. 2024. “Ex-Priest Christopher Brain Faces Sex Charges.” Accessed from https://livingchurch.org/news/news-anglican-communion/ex-priest-christopher-brain-faces-sex-charges/ on 28 October 2025.

O’Neill, Sean. 2025. “Ex-priest and ‘rave church’ leader guilty of 17 indecent assaults.” The Times, August 20. Accessed from https://www.thetimes.com/uk/crime/article/priest-guilty-indecent-assaults-rave-church-5jrwqkdb9 on 1 October 2025.

O’Neill, Sean. 2021. “The rise and fall of Chris Brain and the Nine O’Clock Service.” The Times, July 15. Accessed from https://www.thetimes.com/uk/religion/article/the-rise-and-fall-of-chris-brain-and-the-nine-oclock-service-ggknfzpvl on 29 September 2025.

O’Neill, Sean and Sian Bradley. 2025. “Chris Brain: ‘charismatic priest’ behind the Nine O’Clock Service.” The Times, August 21. Accessed from
https://www.thetimes.com/uk/crime/article/chris-brain-nine-o-clock-service-cult-abuse-5kk2pdmcl on 29 September 2025.

Robinson, Lucy and Christopher Warne. 2021. ‘Embracing the divine chaos’: transcending the sacred-secular divide in the 1990s British rave church movement.” Accessed from https://sussex.figshare.com/articles/chapter/_Embracing_the_divine_chaos_transcending_the_sacred-secular_divide_in_the_1990s_British_rave_church_movement/23473865 on 10/2/2025.

St. John, Graham. 2004. “Introduction.” Pp. 1-15 in Rave Culture and Religion, edited by Graham St. John. London: Routledge.

Till, Rupert. 2006. ‘The Nine O’clock Service: Mixing Club Culture and Postmodern Christianity.” Culture and  Religion 7:93-110.

Publication Date:
5 October 2025

Share