DIVINE ORDER TIMELINE
1881 (August 2): Matilda May Otis was born in Storm Lake, Iowa.
1896: Otis married Alfred Weiland. The couple had one daughter, Ruth.
1898: Ruth Wieland was born in Union, South Dakota.
1919: Ruth married Edgar J. Richenbaugh in Los Angeles, the first of several husbands.
1918: May Otis married her second husband.
1922: Otis and her daughter Ruth began proclaiming themselves as the two witnesses referred to in the Book of Revelation and gathering followers.
1922-1925: May and Ruth reported receiving messages from the Archangel Gabriel that later became the content of a book, The Great Sixth Seal.
1924 (January): May Otis married her step-brother, Ward Blackburn.
1924 (June): Ruth Wieland Rickenbaugh married Samuel Rizzio.
1924 (October): May Otis Blackburn and Ruth Wieland Rickenbaugh Rizzio reported being visited by the angels Gabriel and Michael.
1929: Leaders of the Divine Order were indicted for grand theft.
1930 (March 2): Blackburn was convicted of eight counts of grand theft.
1931 (March): Upon review, the appeals court and then the state supreme court overturned the trial court convictions. The prosecution declined to pursue a second trial.
1936: May Blackburn published The Origin of God containing elements of her past proclamations.
1951 (June 17): May Blackburn died in Los Angeles.
1978: Ruth Wieland Rickenbaugh Rizzio died.
FOUNDER/GROUP HISTORY
May Otis was born in 1881 in Storm Lake, Iowa. There is little known about her early life. In 1896 she married Alfred Weiland, and the couple had one daughter, Ruth. By 1910, May and Ruth appear to have separated from Wiland and had moved to Portland, Oregon. Otis worked in real estate and later as a film director and producer with her daughter in Los Angeles.
Beginning around 1922 May and Ruth began claiming that they were the two witnesses referred to in the biblical Book of Revelation and began gathering followers. May and Ruth were successful at gathering around 100 followers, organizing first in Los Angeles and subsequently on a farm outside the city. Clifford Dabney, nephew of oil magnate Joseph Dabney, made a substantial financial gift to the group along with a large farm that became the organizational center of the group. However, the group became involved in a litigious relationship with Dabney that led to civil and criminal cases and, ultimately, to the demise of the Divine Order.
DOCTRINES/BELIEFS
The biblical passage on which May and Ruth based their divine claims was drawn from the Book of Revelation (11:3): “And I will grant my two witnesses power to prophesy for one thousand two hundred and sixty days.” May and Ruth self-identified as those two witnesses.
They reported that two angels, Archangel Gabriel and Archangel Michael (archangels are believed to have been granted the power to transmit God’s will to humans) were living with them and had provided them with information that subsequently became The Great Sixth Seal.
On October 6, 1924, May told a journalist that she had been selected as a queen by Archangel Michael (“Angel Gabriel Girls Quizzed.”):
… the Angel Gabriel used to come into the room where May and I were … and he dictated a while on the “Seventh Seal, and the “Seventh Trumpet and now we were to gain eternal life and a mine full of nuggets and jewels near Bakersfield…
In addition, Archangel Michael showed May and Ruth a secret place where they could recover a treasure trove of valuable metals and gems after the publication of The Great Sixth Seal. The publication of this book was indeed to be an event of cosmic significance as the Seventh Seal (the final seal of the Seven Seals of God described in Revelation) would be broken and apocalyptic events would occur.
After May and Ruth were chosen as queens, they in turn would choose nine queens who in turn would be given a matching set of “kings” by Archangel Gabriel. These would constitute the “Great Eleven” who would govern the world as humans gained eternal life. Based on her apocalyptic pronouncements, May subsequently created The Divine Order of the Royal Arms of the Great Eleven. The eleven queens would rule the world from mansions on Olive Hill, in Hollywood, California.
ORGANIZATION/LEADERSHIP
The Divine Order, led by May and Ruth, occupied several locations in Los Angeles before moving to a rural location outside the city. At one point May had planned to build a complex of marble temples on Olive Hill, in East Hollywood. However, the group acquired a plot of land and moved to a 164-acre ranch in the Santa Susana Mountains. They constructed a series of cabins along with a temple. Perhaps the most striking structure at the site was the temple’s “massive gilded wood throne weighing 800 pounds, sitting upon four hand-carved paws and adorned with a lion’s head. The temple was sealed off, waiting for Christ’s return (Rasmussen 1999).
The group supported itself by getting jobs at a nearby tomato packing plant. All wages generated by member employment was deposited in the a common purse.
ISSUES/CHALLENGES
The Divine Order’s history actually was rather belief, beginning with May and Ruth’s claims in 1922 to be the two witnesses referred to in the Book of Revelation and essentially ending with May’s criminal conviction in 1930.
Prior to the group’s involvement in civil and criminal legal proceedings there were a series of mysterious, disquieting events that in themselves never had legal implications. There was an unsolved disappearance of Samuel Rizzio, who was believed to have been murdered but who was never found. Sixteen year-old Willa Rhoades died under suspicious circumstances; her remains were preserved on ice for over a year in an what apparently an anticipated resurrection. Her body was then buried under her parent’s home along with the remains of seven dogs. Thirty year-old Frances Turner, who suffered from what was termed a “blood malady” was placed in a heated, crudely constructed brick oven for two days to cure her condition. She died within a few days. Rather, it was financial issues that resulted in civil and criminal litigation.
The case that began the series of events that eventually led to the demise of The Divine Order was a civil suit. Clifford Dabney, nephew of oil magnate Joseph Dabney, had made financial and property donations to the Divine Order, at least partly on the basis of a hidden treasure that could be recovered after publication of The Great Sixth Seal. When book publication was not forthcoming, Dabney filed a civil suit against May and the Divine Order for defrauding him of $40,000. The civil suit subsequently triggered an investigation by the District Attorney that led to criminal charges for defrauding Divine Order members of $200,000 over a seven-year period between 1922 and 1929. On March 2, 1930, May Blackburn and several other group leaders were convicted in a jury trial, in which both May and Ruth offered testimony, of eight counts of grand theft. Each count carried a potential sentence of between one and ten years. With the defendants still in custody, the convictions were appealed, however, and a year later the state appellate court ruled that testimony at trial concerning the deaths and disappearances in which the Divine Order was involved was irrelevant to the offenses for which they were convicted and therefore had been inadmissible. At the end of 1931 the Supreme Court of California upheld the appellate court ruling (California Supreme Court 1931):
We have set forth but briefly disclosures of the record before us, and in our investigation we have been unable to see what relevancy the gruesome story of the preservation of the body of Willa Rhoads, in the promise of resurrection, could have borne to the issue of whether or not the defendant applied the moneys which she received from the complaining witness to the purposes for which they were procured.
The same lack of relevancy exists in the admission of evidence directed to the alleged attempt of the defendant to administer poison to one Sammy Rizzio. We feel, as did the District Court of Appeal, that the evidence as to both of the events above adverted to, must have prejudiced the defendant in the minds of the jury to the extent that the testimony offered in her defense could not have received the deliberate consideration that the law accords to all persons charged with crime.
All other matters of importance have been properly disposed of in the decision of said District Court of Appeal.
The judgment and order are reversed.
In its ruling the Supreme Court also stipulated that ““This is a free country, where there is freedom of religious worship, and it is not actionable to the court if the defendant made certain representations as to being divine” (Eddy 2015). Following the Supreme Court ruling, the defendants were released from custody. The prosecution declined to retry the case, ending legal proceedings.
May Blackburn and the other defendants were freed and there was insufficient evidence to charge her with any additional crimes. However, her organization was in decline as a consequence of the turmoil and negative publicity surrounding her investigation and trial. Blackburn published “The Origin of God”] in 1936, a book that contains elements of her former proclamations. The small group thereafter simply disappeared from public view. May Blackburn died in Los Angeles in 1951.
REFERENCES
“Angel Gabriel Girls Quizzed.” 1925. Los Angeles Times, February 7. Accessed from https://homesteadmuseum.blog/2020/10/07/take-it-on-faith-a-press-photo-of-members-of-the-divine-order-of-the-royal-arms-of-the-great-eleven-los-angeles-7-october-1929/ on 3 November 2024.
California Supreme Court. 1931. People v. Blackburn, November 30. Accessed from https://casetext.com/case/people-v-blackburn-7 on 3 November 2024.
Eddy, Cheryl. 2015. “Angels Made Them Do It: A Brief History of The Blackburn Cult.” Gizmodo, June 15. Accessed from https://gizmodo.com/angels-made-them-do-it-a-brief-history-of-the-blackbur-1711445327 on 3 November 2024.
“The Blackburn Cult.” n.d. Los Angeles Times. Accessed from https://www.laalmanac.com/religion/re720.php on 25 October 2024.
Rasmussen, Cecilia. 1999. “Divine Order’s Tale Smacks of Cult Fiction.” Los Angeles Times, May 23. Accessed from https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1999-may-23-me-40217-story.html on 3 November 2024
Spitzzeri, Paul R. 2020. “Take It On Faith: A Press Photo of Members of the Divine Order of the Royal Arms of the Great Eleven, Los Angeles Times, October 7, 1929.”
Publication Date:
6 November 2024
